Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Important Notice
The recipient of this document should note that in no circumstances should this document be used as a sale or disclosure document. This document is a private and confidential communication between Merrill Lynch and the recipient. It is a brief summary of some of the aspects of the abovementioned notes and is not intended, and should not be read, as a substitute for the detailed provisions of the documentation relating thereto. The document is for information purposes only and is not to be distributed, reproduced or published in whole or in part, for any purpose without the expressed permission of Merrill Lynch. IN NO CIRCUMSTANCES SHALL THIS DOCUMENT BE TRANSMITTED OR DISTRIBUTED TO ANY PERSON OTHER THAN THE RECIPIENT OR ITS AFFILIATES. This is not a prospectus, nor is it an offer of any notes or securities, or any invitation to acquire any notes or securities. All opinions and information contained in this document constitute Merrill judgment as of the date of this document and are subject to change without notice. This document has been prepared by Merrill Lynch (Asia Pacific) Ltd ("MLAP") by its Equity Structured Solutions group and is not a product of its Research Department. This document does not have regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation and the particular needs of any specific person who may receive this presentation. Generally all transactions of any nature, whether OTC derivative transactions or otherwise, involve the risk of adverse or unanticipated market developments, risk of illiquidity and other risks. Any investor/counterparty should take all such independent professional advice as it deems necessary before entering into any transaction. Neither the information contained, nor any opinion expressed, herein constitutes any offer, or any solicitation of an offer, to buy or sell any securities or any options, futures or other derivatives related to such securities or any investment advice in respect of any such securities or related securities or any related investment strategies. MLAP, including all of its affiliates and persons connected with it or them, may, directly or indirectly, effect or have effected a transaction for its own account in the investments referred to in the material contained herein before or after the material is published to any customer or may give advice to customers which may differ from or be inconsistent with the information and opinions contained herein. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance. The information herein was obtained from different sources; we do not guarantee its accuracy or completeness. Merrill Lynch makes no representation (express or implied) and shall have no liability in any way arising from the provision of this document to the recipient for any loss or damage, direct or indirect, arising from the use of this document. Provision of this document shall not extend or increase any rights of the recipient or obligations of Merrill Lynch arising with respect to any transaction or securities Neither the information contained, nor any opinion expressed, herein constitutes any offer, or any solicitation of an offer, to buy or sell any securities or any options, futures or other derivatives related to such securities (related securities) or any investment advice in respect of any such securities or related securities or any related investment strategies.
2
Objectives + Outline
Is leveraged
Using sector-specific and leveraged ETFs from around the world as proxies for potential interest in this product space, we examine the following:
Current trends and growth in the ETF market in Asia Asian investors in US-Listed Leveraged ETFs Turnover and Trade Volume of the Asian ETF market Asian Investors in US-Listed Sector-Specific ETFs Negative aspects an argument against Asian listed ETFs
Trends: Asian economy is growing IMF economists have predicted Asian growth for 2010 between 7% to 7% increased Asian wealth will attract Asian investors and increased Asian market growth to attract foreign investors Asian ETFs will grow in demand and value
Past Trends
Asian economies are becoming more sophisticated and investors more wealthy Past trends show that Asian ETFs are growing in line with Asian economies However, there is a low number of Asians investing in US-listed leveraged and sector-specific ETFs Asia-listed leveraged ETFs still do not exist Apparent trend that US and European ETPs are currently experiencing a high-growth period Asian ETFs are still relatively untapped presents an opportunity for BofAML
Asian markets and investors will turn to products like ETFs in the near future
6
Asia-Pacific Trends
In China and Malaysia, global ETF providers need a local partner slowed growth (SS) Japan: Retail investors hold the majority of ETF assets (SS) Hong Kong: Individuals are the primary investors (SS) Asia Pacific investors tend to invest by region (SS) According to T.K. Yap, Executive Director, OCBC, Most ETF trades in Singapore are professional, not retail; ETFs have not yet caught on with retail investors. This is probably due to misconception: liquidity is viewed as being the dealt volumes whereas it really should be defined by the bid and offered volumes. Investor education for retail has been lacking. According to BlackRock, in the more developed markets like Hong Kong and Singapore, it is mainly institutional investors who are using ETFs, but there is real potential for the retail market to develop.
Asia-Pacific Trends
In order to promote a vibrant ETF marketplace, we need to create awareness and interest of the product class and its key benefits amongst investors, existing or new, institutional or retail, said Ms Magdalyn Liew, assistant vice-president at SGX. Recent market declines and increased volatility have caused investors to seek safer, beta investments ETF index tracking beta products have benefited from this trend in the US and Europe (DB) Recent increase in ETFs offered, and diversity thereof, providing investors with a larger variety of profiles to invest in, including sectors that are typically difficult to access (DB) Increased coordination among Asia-based regulators, ex: recent coordination between Taiwan and Hong Kong regulators to allow ETFs to be cross listed in both markets. (DB) Fragmentation is one of the major impediments to the growth of the ETF market in Asia (DB) Because market makers in Asia can hedge their exposure more efficiently during Asian market hours, and they can compare ETF prices in real time with the value of the index, Asian ETFs listed in Asia would have better bid-offer spreads than those listed in the US/Europe, which would make them more likely to do well in Asia.
8
Asia-Pacific Trends
Especially out here in Asia, if you look at the percentage of assets managed on a passive basis, its very low. If you look at the US, its probably 30%, the UKs 30%, the continent is probably 5-10 percent. Here, its really single digit. So there is an opportunity for more money to be managed on a passive basis, said Deborah Furh, BlackRocks global head of ETF research and implementation strategy. Asian ETF growth for 2009 high in all sectors except Currency. Volume concentrated in Equity ETFs Institutional investors and professional investors have traditionally played the largest roles in the ETF market, but off late retail investors are entering the market and demand is high According to Mr. Chan Kum Kong, senior vice president for ETF Investments at DBS Asset Management (DBSAM), retail investors are increasingly embracing ETFs as they see the benefits of utilizing them as a tool for investment portfolio asset allocation.
Asia Pacific ETF Growth was incredibly high (27.5%) in 2009 especially in Equity, Fixed Income and Commodities. It is a good time to take advantage of such high growth numbers which may temper off once ETFs become more established. BofAML can issue structured products to gain market share and first-mover status on leveraged and sector-specific funds.
10
December-09
423.24 0.14 2.94 5,214.37 0.00 1,523.90 137.33 3.24 1,974.65
January10 349.16 12.79 0.93 6,298.10 0.05 1,547.34 125.48 4.70 1,894.45
Year-to-Date
349.16 12.79 0.93 6,298.10 0.05 1,547.34 125.48 4.70 1,894.45
Shanghai and Hong Kong lead the Asia Pacific Market for ETF turnover. Shanghai SE and Korea Exchange lead the Asian Pacific Market in terms of Number of ETF Trades.
Asia - Pacific ETF # of Trades Bombay SE Bursa Malaysia Hong Kong Exchanges December10 0.3 0.6 160.6 January-10 14.7 390.0 230.7 Year-toDate 14.7 390.0 230.7
Indonesia SE
Korea Exchange National Stock Exchange India New Zealand Exchange Shanghai SE Shenzhen SE Taiwan SE Corp. The Stock Exchange of Thailand
0.0
448.6 149.8 0.4 991.0 347.0 67.9 8.9
0.1
501.2 110.0 0.4 914.0 267.9 83.0 7.7
0.1
501.2 110.0 0.4 914.0 267.9 83.0 7.7
Shanghai SE
Shenzhen SE Singapore Exchange Taiwan SE Corp. The Stock Exchange of Thailand Tokyo SE
9,247.38
3,297.91 317.19 490.89 9.63 1,819.20
8,105.23
2,294.90 245.73 627.00 9.49 2,036.22
8,105.23
2,294.90 245.73 627.00 9.49 2,036.22
Professional Insight
Insight From Marco Montanari, Deutsche Banks director of ETF business in Hong Kong (June 2010) What we are seeing is that asset managers are looking at moving into the ETF market. This is not just in China, where everyone is looking to list an ETF, but in each individual market. You have the local fund providers trying to set up a master feeder or an independent structure. They can see that in the long run, the fund market will segment and that ETFs will become a key product. The biggest problem is that you cannot get passport funds across Asia, so you can only be a local player. That is where global players like Deutsche Bank have the advantage. Insight From Nick Good, managing director, head of iShares Asia-Pacific at Black Rock (June 2010) Total trading assets of ETFs in the Hong Kong exchange is expected to grow 30 percent this year and next iShares will launch more ETF products to meet market demand with cross-border listing products being considered.
12
Professional Insight
Since no single sector, style, or stock consistently outperforms its peers, having a diversified portfolio invested in ETFs tracking various asset classes can help manage risk and minimize overexposure to a single stock or market segment. We see an increasing use of ETFs by all types of institutions asset managers, pension plans, insurance companies, sovereign wealth funds, hedge funds, as well as retail investors Institutional investors can use ETFs to pursue a variety of different investment objectives and strategies including core/satellite models, transition management, portfolio completion, hard-to-reach asset classes, and restricted markets Retail investors can use ETFs to gain quick and easy diversification, gain exposure to restricted markets, and implement asset allocation strategies Since the financial crisis, there is an increasing acceptance of ETFs by the retail market in Asia As more and more investors are discovering the benefits of ETFs, the popularity of ETFs is likely to continue to grow. According to BlackRocks estimation, the global ETF market can grow by 20-30% in 2010.
13
Asian Investors tend to invest larger amounts into leveraged ETFs where they have direct visibility of the market being tracked
High growth forecasts for Asia would attract foreign and local investors to inevitably profitable Asian investments According to Seeking Alpha and Yahoo Finance (July 28, 2010), the U.S. Unit of ETF Securities is set to market a physical gold ETF with the storage vault in Singapore movement of U.S. investors into safe Asian economies Asian investors currently prefer to trade ETFs on the US/European markets because of higher trade volume there More popular ETFs (SPDR Gold Shares, iShares FTSE/Xinhua China Index, iShares MSCI India ETF etc.) have caught on well with retail investors in Asia, but providing direct market access to ETFs through SGX and increasing liquidity would make investors more likely to experiment providing impetus for growth of Asian ETFs
15
There have already been examples of consequences with leveraged ETFs so second generation leveraged ETF investors will be more risk aware They are often considered more similar to gambling than investing High volatility and uncertainty increases risk When leveraged ETFs lose money, they lose two or three times the indexs losses Tracking Error ETFs not delivering results and tracking benchmark results as promised
16
Spreads Risk lower trading liquidity leads to larger spreads and increases costs Tax Risk more complex tax issues and higher percentages to be paid Counterparty risk owning a stake in the funds that make up the index is exposure to the risk of those companies
17
KDB Asset Management (South Korea), tends to invest small numbers of shares into US Index-Linked ETFs About 20 small investments into US Leveraged ETFs Fuh-Hwa Investment Trust (Taiwan) 48,000 shares in ProShares UltraShort QQQ Korea Investment Trust (South Korea) 500 shares in ProShares Ultra Oil & Gas Nomura Holdings (Japan) 100,000 shares in ProShares UltraShort Yen Mirae Asset Global (Hong Kong) 278,618 shares in ProShares UltraShort FTSE/Xinhua China 25 Chinarock Capital (Hong Kong) 160,000 shares in ProShares UltraShort FTSE/Xinhua China 25
TREND: Asian asset managers are using US-listed leveraged ETFs in their funds investment banks, hedge funds, asset management companies
18
Reason for above observed trend (more Asian investors in ProShares Leveraged ETF rather than iShares non-leveraged ETF could be explained by a) Non-Leveraged ETFs are more easily available on Asian markets so investors dont need to seek investments based in the US or b) The leveraged ETF seeks twice the inverse of FTSE/Xinhua whereas the non-leveraged ETF seeks to represent the performance. Singapore ETF turnover grew 56% to S$4.6 billion in 2009, the third straight year in which record turnover was achieved. (SGX 4)
19
The growth in Asian demand for non-leveraged ETFs as well as the increasing sophistication of the Asian markets will inevitably cause significant demand for nontraditional investments such as leveraged ETFs. However, these seem more suited
towards institutional investors rather than retail. Most of the Asian investors in US-listed
leveraged ETFs, though few, are institutional investors with lower sensitivity to losses than retail investors and greater inclinations toward high risk investments, making them the target investor group for the product. Leveraged notes would be suitable to sell on open exchanges in Asia only if all investors were clearly informed of the risk exposure and of the controversial consequences. Those who still invest after such warning will be those who track their investments and are seeking leveraged exposure. The main problem in the US/Europe was that investors were unhappy that their products were not performing as advertised. Preventing false advertisements, and presenting all information will reduce the likelihood of controversy and increase investments.
20
Can still generate high percentage gains if investor successfully identifies high-growth sectors
Higher numbers of Asian investors in US-listed sector specific ETFs than in leveraged ETFs because the risk factor is lower and the exposure Reduces stock-specific risk Increased tax efficiency because they trade on an exchange, insulating investors from taxable events generated by other investors The opportunity to invest in a favored sector yet avoiding the potentially negative effects a downturn in the market could have on a few individual stocks
21
22
23
24
LYXOR ETF Commodities CRB Woori Asset Management holds 300,000 shares (South Korea)
25
sectors (i.e. technology, energy, commodities etc.) in which they see growth rather than
choosing specific companies. It allows them flexibility, diversification, and ease because just one stock provides exposure to a larger underlying group of companies. There are not many sector-specific ETFs listed on Asian stock exchanges so there is definite growth potential. Sector-specific ETFs provide less volatility and risk exposure than do leveraged ETFs so would be more successful with retail as well as institutional investors in Asia.
26
27
% Obtained 0.5% 1% 2% 3%
% Obtained 0.5% 1% 2% 3%
Analysis Timing
High and increasing demand for ETFs may indicate a regional trend and interest in more sophisticated investment schemes, which means Asian investors are likely to experiment with leveraged ETFs. However, they should probably be introduced during a
market upswing where confidence is high and risk sensitivity is lower than usual.
Sector-specific products are less risky and should be introduced to the market by BofAML as there is a relatively low but inevitably rising percentage of such products. These can be introduced during a bear market because they allow investors the opportunity to single out sectors which they believe will beat the market even in a downturn.
29
Most of the popular ETFs in Singapore are regionally focused, and SPDR Gold Shares ETFs to avoid
Low number of ETFs in commodities, sector-specific, currencies and bonds Potential Market Regionally focused leverage notes could attract investors with strong views but must be attractive enough to take investors away from currently available (and more predictable) regional non-leveraged ETFs According to Thorsten Michalik, head of ETFs for DB Asia, about 70% of ETF trade in Asia is China-Related Less potential because there are many established opportunities
Not much money managed on a passive basis in Singapore (compared to 30% in the US and Asia) shows future growth of ETFs
30
Management fees of 1% - 2%
Can only be bought and sold at end-ofday prices quoted by sales personnel or banks
31
There is enough precedent of challenges, problems and recommendations for BofAML to learn from and improve upon
The market trends and background info show fast growth of the market Revenue projections (even conservative estimates) show that the business will prove to be profitable Leveraged ETFs and Sector-Specific ETFs cover both the retail and institutional investor markets
32
Main Challenges
Being a first mover in the market, there may be some unprecedented challenges faced in the Asian market which were not experienced in the US and Europe due to regulatory differences in Asia Educating investors is a large but necessary burden to avoid problems
33
Conclusion
A structured listed note which tracks a sector-specific index is a viable business potential in Asian markets (specifically Singapore and Hong Kong) in the near future there are very few in Hong Kong and none in Singapore in ETF form, so seizing this first-mover status opportunity is crucial A structured listed note which is leveraged is a more risky option but still has potential to be successful in Asian markets because they do not yet exist in the market, and more sophisticated and risk-seeking investors will be potential buyers For both of the above propositions, the survey of the current ETF market as a proxy for potential growth has proven that there is market potential for Asian structured products to reach the levels of those in the US and Europe as long as the marketing and structuring of the products is done in a way that Asian investors will be
34