Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This training material was prepared based on seminar delivered by Prof. Thomas Perez, Ph.D. of Harvard University.
What is an interview?
Interview is commonly used assessment technique. Used to give information to employees to demonstrate concern for the person being interviewed. More importantly to gain information in making decision. Included in the company Policy & Procedure that must be used by all company executives for effective and efficient recruitment process.
1. Data collection
Most interviewers do not employ a systematic technique which standardizes the process for each person interviewed. This leads to faulty conclusions during data analysis due to either the lack of comparable data or insufficient data.
2. Data recording
Data recorded in writing by the interviewer is often incomplete and superficial (shallow). It focuses on impressions rather that facts. The information given by the interviewee is not recorded with enough accuracy or in enough detail to be used for critical review and analysis.
3. Hypothetical data
Hypothetical questions are asked in typical interview. For example, a person is asked, What would you do in a situation?, rather than, What did you do in a situation?. When people are asked to state what they usually do in a situation, they give a response which does not reflect what they actually do in that situation. Instead the interviewee tends to describe what he or she thinks the interviewer want to hear, or what is consistent with their self-image.
8
4. Leading questions
Questions which suggest what the interviewer values will lead to based responses by the interviewee. The interviewee learns to respond to the value being espoused (take up) by the interviewer.
5. First impressions
The first impression an interviewee makes on the interviewer influences how the data is collected and how the interviewee is appraised during the interview.
10
6. Personal preferences
The resources of personal biases interfere with accurate and thorough data-collection. First, more weight is given to feelings than facts. Second, interviewers tend to like people who are similar to them. This leads to assumptions about the interviewee which are not confirmed by data. Third, prior experiences or training of the interviewee establishes biases in terms of what the interviewee seeks and value.
11
7. Assigning causes
In the absence of data, an interviewer attributes motives to the interviewee. In other words, if the interviewee does not provide factual or logical reasons for either hypothetical or actual behaviors, the interviewer assigns a reason to explain the behavior. One of the errors which occurs when motive are attributed to the interviewee is stereotyping. Based on a small amount of data, the interviewer infers reasons to explain a persons behavior and makes predictions based upon this biased assumption, rather than on facts.
12
8. Hallo
Another type of error occurs when the interviewer assumes that if a person is strong in one characteristics; or if weak in one a area, is weak in all areas. After forming a particular impression, the interviewer perpetuate (bring about) the bias by interpreting subsequent information as being favorable or unfavorable.
13
9. Comparison
A comparison error occurs when the interviewer uses another person as a norm for comparison with the interviewee, rather than using facts and preestablished external norms to appraise him or her. If the impression the interviewer had of one person was very, very good. The second person suffers in comparison suffers in comparison, regardless of the data.
14
15
16
Course objectives
1. 2. 3. To master in interviewing method that allows the candidate the opportunity to demonstrate specific job competencies. To validate the competencies to be used as assessment criteria in this organization. To accurately recognize the job competencies used as selection criteria. To practice the assessment skills necessary to identify the strengths and limitations of a job candidate; to assess a candidates job-to-person fit.
4.
17
2.
3.
19
Job-to-person fit
CANDIDATE Competencies Possessed
FIT
20
Interviewers job
Major goals 1. 2. 3. Major tasks 1. 2. 3. Basic skills 1. 2. 3. Advance skills 1. 2. 3.
4.
4.
4.
4.
21
22
OVERVIEW
Data from interview is evaluated
Qualified applicants for job are assessed by structured interview and field observation
DECISION
25
26
Make a Decision
Select the best candidate for the job. Identify skill and knowledge areas for the selected candidates to develop on the job. Identify feedback (especially for internal candidates) to be available for candidates not selected.
27
Job task
Job competencies
Key selection criteria : Education Experience Technical skill Competencies Interview questions Interview for competencies
DECISION
28
29
30
Un-acceptable
Acceptable
Acceptable Un-acceptable
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Un-acceptable
Un-acceptable Un-acceptable Un-acceptable Acceptable Acceptable
31
Un-acceptable Acceptable
Acceptable Un-acceptable
32
21
Answers
Questions
1 2 3 Rationale : Age discrimination : One can ask an applicants age if it is an occupational qualification (BFOQ). Rationale : This question appears on most current job application. Assuming we do everything we can to adapt the job to your situation, so you have any impairments, physical, mental or medical, which would interfere with your ability to perform the job for which you applied? Rationale : the current job application has a certification statement which applicants sign agreeing to undergo a physical examination and if requested, a chest X-ray and laboratory test. If such report show that they do not meet the required medical standards or if they do not meet all other standards of the corporation, they agree that their employment may be terminated immediately.
Acceptable / Unacceptable
Un-acceptable Acceptable
Acceptable
Rationale : child care problems discrimination When asked of woman, this is considered discriminatory unless it is also asked of men. Also, it is not job related.
Rationale : Religion discrimination No inquiries concerning applicants religious denomination, religious affiliations, church, parish, pastor or religious holidays observed are acceptable. Rationale : Marital Status Discrimination Not permissible unless asked of both men and women. It is permissible to ask, How do you wish to be addressed? where giving a first name is an alternative.
Un-acceptable
Un-acceptable
Un-acceptable
33
Answers
Questions
7 Rationale : National Origin Discrimination Any attempt to determine applicants nationality, lineage, ancestry, national origin, descent or parentage is illegal. Rationale : it is legal to ask an applicant whether he or she worked for a company competitor under a different name, and if so, what name. companies have a legitimate need to know if a person has been employed before because they would want to check any performance during the prior employment as well as apply former length of service to determine fringe benefits if applicable. The current job application has ever gone to school or worked under any other name, where and when. Rationale : It is unlawful to give a copy of a birth certificate, naturalization or baptismal record prior to employment. You can ask for the birth certificate after you have hired the person. Rationale : It Is legal to ask the names of applicants relatives already employed by this company if it is asked to avoid placing relatives where one supervises the other. Rationale : Sex Discrimination All questions as to pregnancy or medical history concerning pregnancy and related matters is rarely asked of men. Also, it is not job related.. Rationale : It may be necessary for an employer to have this information Acceptable / Unacceptable
Un-acceptable
Un-acceptable
Acceptable Acceptable
Un-acceptable
10
11
12
Acceptable
34
Answers
Questions
13 Rationale : Sex Discrimination. This is usually sex discrimination because it is rarely asked of men. It is not job related. Rationale : Children care problems. Specific inquiries concerning spouse, spouses employment or salary, child care arrangement, or dependents are considered unfair pre-employment inquiries. An employer may believe that married woman with young children are more prone to absenteeism or turnover, but actual studies show that in total employment, there is little difference in absentee rates of men and women. Rationale : Under federal law asking whether an applicant is a US citizen is permissible. On the current job application the applicant acknowledges his or her individual responsibility as an employee for compliance with security regulations and that they will be governed by provisions of Federal Espionage and Sabotage Laws. (Falsely claiming US citizenship is subject to prosecution). The applicant also signs that they understand that if hired, they will be required to submit proof citizenship or alien status. Rationale : Questions about military experience or training are permissible, but not questions about the applicants general military service. The current job application provides for information from the applicant relative to military service. Acceptable / Unacceptable
Un-acceptable
14
Un-acceptable
15
Acceptable
16
Acceptable
35
Answers
Questions
17 Rationale : Child care problems discrimination. An employer can ask this question of both sexes or neither. Rationale : Sex Discrimination. Any question not routinely asked of male applicants is discriminatory in nature, i.e. What does your husband think of you working?. Acceptable / Un-acceptable
Un-acceptable
18
Un-acceptable
19
Rationale : It is legal to ask this question. However, a better way of phrasing it might be How did you happen to apply for a position here? With the second question the applicant would not have to give any information about individuals should they not want to do so. Rationale : You are stating facts of the job and merely asking if this work schedule would cause conflicts. Rationale : National Origin Discrimination. Inquiries about the name which would show the applicants lineage, ancestry, national origin or descent are unlawful.
Acceptable
20
Acceptable
21
Un-acceptable
36
Assessing Competencies
37
Threshold
Inferior
Average
Superior
39
The more complex the job the more important the competencies
Job Competency
40
41
KNOWLEDGE
SKILL
SELFCON CEPT
TRAIT
MOTIVE
44
45
Reliability in selection
Selecting for competencies should be integrated with other selection criteria. A reliable selection procedure should provide data on the following key factors about a job candidate. 1. The level of technical proficiency demonstrated by a candidate. 2. The candidates history or track record of past performance. 3. The candidates motivation to perform. 4. The candidates potential to execute in the job given his or her technical skill.
48
49
50
51
(4) The candidates potential to execute in the job given his or her technical skill.
The data produced in this assessment are the competencies the person acquired over the years through job experience, practicing avocations, receiving coaching, or completing a formal education. The possession of a competency is a predictor of the person being able to sue hi or her talent in a job. The predictions increase in reliability if the competencies possessed are directly related to the target job.
52
Primary competencies
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Professional self confidence Independent self image Self control Critical thinking Organizational astuteness Orientation to socialized power Need for achievement Initiative
53
Secondary competencies
9. 10. 11. 12. Systematic problem-solving Calculated risk taking Assessing the team Empowering and motivating others
54
Primary Competencies
1. Professional self confidence : Stating opinions openly
and demonstrating a willingness to confront others.
55
Primary Competencies
4. Critical thinking :
Identifying the critical factors that makeup a problem or event. Understanding how to use informal networks in the organization to get things done. Taking into account how others are likely to react to predetermined plans. Maximizing ones successes at persuasion by anticipating how diverse groups will react to a particular argument. Working to win the support of key people in the organization.
5. Organizational astuteness :
56
Primary Competencies
6. Orientation to socialized power : 7. Need for achievement :
Using ones power and influence to accomplish organizational goals, not personal aggrandizement. A concern for setting and meeting high personal standards of performance, including career mobility as a longterm goal. Finding ways to innovate. the absence of external pressure to do so.
57
Secondary Competencies
9. Systematic problem-solving : Developing outlines or
plans with milestones to evaluate the progress of work. Breaking down problems or processes into their component parts and determining what needs to be done, by whom, and in what order. take initiative based on an assessment of the risk involved; assessing whether given risks are acceptable. strengths an limitations of employees or a work-unit.
10. Calculated risk taking : Taking or allowing others to 11. Assessing the team : Assessing and verifying the
58
Secondary Competencies
12.Empowering and motivating others :
Encouraging others to take initiative. Giving people room to do their jobs. Not micromanaging the work of others, but trusting that employees can perform. Making others feel important and supporting them by words and gestures. Giving credit to others to enhance their motivation or sense of job satisfaction. Focusing on employees strength in order to seek contributions to the organizations goal.
59
60
61
Welcome the candidate Introduce yourself and your role Give an outline or overview of the interview Build rapport by engaging the candidate in small talk conversation Establish an open and friendly tone.
2. Build rapport
Tell candidate that you want to get a clear picture of his or her strengths an capabilities to help decide whether he or she fits the requirements of the position.
62
State the amount of time that you expect to spend in the interview. Anticipate up to one hour. State that in the major part of the interview you will ask detailed questions about work related experiences that he or she has had. i.e. Candidates most recent experience; as well as past experience. Explain that you will take notes as a way to ensure that you remember everything that he or she says. Explain the function of the selection team if others are going to review the candidate.
63
Describe the major job / responsibilities and any changes that have occurred since the posting. i.e : Given my description of the position we are hiring for, what are some of the things you believe qualify you for this position?
Ask any questions to follow up on the resume that will help determine the candidates level of mastery of technical or specialized knowledge.
64
Ask question about candidates present job. I.e. : What are your duties and responsibilities in your present job? Does anyone report to you? If so, what are their responsibilities? What do you like most about your current job? What do you like least? Ask follow up questions for further detail, if desired.
Insert questions about the task skills required. Use a probing strategy to get at past behaviors.
65
Ask the candidate if he or she has any questions Explain about the position your are offering, the job itself, the working environment, facilities and possible career advancement. Tell the candidate when he or she can expect to hear about a decision.
66
67
Opening Statement
Please tell me about a high or low point event (or challenge) for you during the last year in your job or extracurricular activities. A high or low point could consist of a 2-minutes interaction or 6-months project. The key is that the event was important (or stands out) for you. Give me an overview of the situation and the Ill lead you back through it in more detail. I really need to understand your role in depth. Therefore, I will be asking you to describe to me what you thought and felt as well as what you did. Since I need to know your role in the situations you describe, if you use the term we, I will ask what you did. Please try to use I whenever possible. Tell me back to the event
68
69
70
71
72
Do the following
1. Provide an outline of what you require :
a.
b.
c.
Now I would like to talk about key events on your job. Please think of a time in your current job where you were satisfied. It was a high point; a situation the turned out well. It is not necessary to start with a positive event, although this is the usual practice. This could be an event or situation which last only a minute or two, or occurred over months or years. Its critical that it was something important to you.
73
Do the following
d. Please walk me through the situation, and I will need to know the following information and will be asking these types of questions as something important to you :
What led you to the situation? Who was involved? What did you think? What did you feel? What did you say? In fact, recreate the conversation. What were the result? Remember, I need to know what you did. If you use we, I will stop and ask you what you actually do.
74
Do the following
2. If the candidate seems to be having problems identifying an event, offer to turn off the recorder and wait. During this time you may want to restate or clarify your requirements. 3. The first time the candidate gives an event, the detail is almost never sufficient for your purposes. Allow the individual a few minutes to give you an overview of what happened.
75
Do the following
Then say the following :
That is the type of situation I am looking for. However, I need it in much more detail.
At that point, start your probes. In other words, ask such Questions as : o What led up to the conversation? o Who was involved? o What was said and done? o What was the outcome?
76
Do the following
4. Comments and probes that will help you to obtain the required details are as follows :
o
o o o
o
o o o
What did you do then? What happened next? Tell me more about that. Please give me more detail about that. What did you say? What did he or she say? What did you see? What did you thing (were you thinking)? What did you feel (were you feeling)?
77
Do the following
5. To make the transition to the next event say something else :
That is the type of information I need. Now I would like to get information on an event or situation that did not run out to your liking. It was a low point; caused you problems; left you frustrated ; was not satisfying. Please walk me through that situation.
Follow the same procedures here as you did with the first event.
6.
7.
It is preferable to alternate positive and negative events so that the person does not get into a particular set. The purpose for getting both types of events is that it is necessary to see the persons behavior in as broad a job context as possible. It should be noted that a negative event may contain the attributes required to do a superior job. At the beginning of the first or second event, note as many of each type of event (positive or negative) you would like to get. How many events you actually obtain will depend on the following :
78
Do the following
A. B. C. D.
The objective of interview. The amount of time available. The number of events that the interviewee can recall. The length of each events . In some cases one long event may provide you with as much or better data than three or four small events. You must use your own judgment as to whether sufficient information and detail has been obtained.
79
80
81
82
3. If the conversation seems to be drifting or there is a lack of significance, e.g. if the event is too task related.
Ask the person if he is talking about something that is of significance. Push for conversations. Stay away from HOW or WHY questions as they foster generalization and task descriptions rather than personal involvement in an event.
83
84
5. If you want greater detail, ask questions only about behaviors that actually occurred.
Correct : What did you do (think, feel)? What did you do then (next)? Tell me more about what you did (were doing, were thinking, were feeling). Incorrect : What do you do (think, feel)?
85
6. If you are asking leading questions, they are not appropriate except when asking prepared questions.
Correct : What did you feel when that happened? Incorrect : Did you feel that she was doing the right thing at that time?
86
7.
If the candidate seems quiet, allow him or her to formulate a response. Be patient. Silence in effective tool for stimulating a response in the candidate. It also places the burden for providing data on the candidate.
87
8.
If you are fumbling (mishandle) with paper, keep in mind that extensive notes are not required during the interview itself. But, consolidate your observations and conclusions immediately following the interview.
88
89
Depending on the interviewee, the ease of the interview will vary greatly from case to case. Problems arise if the interviewee is anxious about the interview itself. Much of that anxiety can be reduced by good preparation before you arrive. Take time to insure that the arrangements and your purpose are very clear. These actions will go a long way in making the process flow smoothly. Below is a list of problems you may face and their potential solutions.
90
Clarify your objective, how the process will be conducted, and why this person was chosen for the interview. Probe the reasons for the nervousness. Respond appropriately. Give the interviewee some control in the situation, e.g. tell the interviewee that you are happy to take a break at any point that would like to, etc. Reiterate how the data will be handled, i.e. issues about confidentiality.
91
2.
3.
92
4.
5.
Ask the interviewee what sort of job related things he or she talked to others about. What types of things has he or she brought home. Were there any things that the interviewee bragged or complained about to others. At a last resort, give an example of an event. The caution here is that you do not want to give an event that leads the interviewee to believing that specific content of what you said, as opposed to process, is what you are interested in.
93
C. You are doing all the talking. You are asking question after question
1. Insure that you questions are open-ended. Be sure they cannot be answered with a yes or a brief answer. 2. Use silence. Wait out the interviewee. 3. Keep your questions to a very brief number of words. Use phrases such as :
o
o o o
Who did that? What happened next / then? What did you think / feel? What did you see?
94
D. Interviewee is not focused; jumps around a lot; is too vague; provides too little detail.
1. 2. Keep the individual on track. Restate your objectives. Remind the individual that you want a detailed story, a history. You want information from start to finish. Push for dialogue. Ask for specific examples.
3.
95
96
97
2.
98
99
I. You receive generalized highs and lows that do not shoe a real involvement on the interviewees part
1.
You may accept these, but if after probing, the interviewee does not seem to have that much investment in the event, do not probe any further; move on and look for a more significant event.
100
J. The interviewee gives you a lot of hypothetical responses, i.e. how they usually do things, would normally do things
1.
Push for specific examples in the work environment where these types of concepts have been applied. Do not accept these responses without factual examples ; they provide no reliable or useful data.
101
Improvement plan
Check Problem list Suggestions for improvement --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Purpose of key events stage not stated clearly Help problems helping the interviewee identify key events Close questions Leading questions Questions / probed too long Talked too much Probed (search, investigate, look into) too soon Allowed interviewee to drift or be vague. Spent too little time (not enough relevant detail) Spent too much time (too much irrelevant detail)
---------------------------------------------
Did not get entire event (what led up to it, what occurred, the outcome)
Allowed hypothetical / non-factual responses Allowed the use of we Other problems (please list)
102
103
To acquaint the interviewer with the applicants job skills To help the organization make a fair decision To help the applicant understand the organization / position.
104
o o o
Interviewer will ask questions about past jobs and experiences in order to make fair assessment of how well applicants abilities meet job requirements. Greet the applicant by giving your name and position. Applicant will have an opportunity to ask questions. Interviewer will be taking notes.
105
106
Allow silence
It takes time for an applicant to recall examples from the past. Do not interrupt while the applicant is searching his or her memory, you may cause the example to be lost. Use the time to record notes or develop a follow-up question.
108
What were you trying to accomplish? What were you thinking about? Then what did you do? Say? Think?
The way you get at how people approach job tasks, their motivations and problem-solving skills is to use : What were you thinking? probes.
109
110
Take notes
Recording brief comments and important facts as the candidate responds to your questions will be critical in helping you rate the candidate on the basis of facts, rather that gut feeling. The notes will help you avoid confusing the candidates responses. Specially : o Dont rely on your memory. o Note key words and phrases used by the candidate. o Listen for answers directly related to the critical skills and record. o Note direct quotes as much as possible, mark with quotations ( ). o Keep your comments or conclusions separate from what the candidate said.
111
112
113
5 minutes 5 minutes
3 minutes
40 minutes 10 minutes
114
115
i.e. Your answers regarding your experience working with _____ have been very informative. Now lets move on so I can learn about your experience with ________.
116
117
118
Sometimes applicants are unsure of the question and, therefore, respond with a general statement. If you think the applicant has understood, rephrase the question.
As to follow-up question :
Follow up questions can be very effective in helping you obtain specific information. Use a follow-up question to gain more information about a point the applicants made when responding to the original question. Only use followup questions when it will help you obtain additional information about the applicants skills.
119
Show encouragement :
Showing encouragement by nodding or smiling will help a nervous applicant feel more comfortable and communicate facts and information more freely.
This helps the applicant understand that you are looking for a specific examples of past behavior. Once the applicant understands the kind of answer you are looking for, the interview will be much more productive. i.e. Thanks for being so specific. Thats just the kind of information I need.
120
121
In summary, try to ..
ask clarifying questions. reward the interviewee for providing information you need.
In summary not to .
accept generalization. let too much time pass when you are not getting specific information.
allow the interviewee to change the topic until you have a complete event.
test out your ideas about what the job is, or how it should be done. ask leading questions or cross-examine the interviewee. summarize, paraphrase, or leap to conclusions. assume you know what is happening, or who is involved, unless this has been specifically stated by the interviewee. rely on a tape recorder. it could fail.
122
123