Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Consumer Staples
Joshua Bohinc
Kevin Barney
Dan DeFrances
Agenda
Sector Overview
Sector Factors
Economic Factors
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Recommendations
Anheuser-Busch Action
2
Consumer Staples Sector (SP-30)
% of S&P Level
As of 10/31/2008 # of Companies MKTCAP 500 10/31 Daily MTD QTD YTD
S&P 500 500 $ 8,485,552 100.0% 968.8 1.54% -16.94% -16.94% -34.03%
Energy 40 $ 1,115,525 13.1% 401.2 0.60% -18.01% -18.01% -33.47%
Materials 30 $ 266,696 3.1% 156.2 0.87% -22.18% -22.18% -39.90%
Industrials 57 $ 929,732 11.0% 223 1.86% -18.93% -18.93% -37.07%
Consumer Discretionary 80 $ 696,340 8.2% 178.6 2.72% -19.27% -19.27% -31.17%
Consumer Staples 41 $ 1,094,747 12.9% 253.7 0.96% -11.08% -11.08% -15.31%
Health Care 53 $ 1,175,390 13.9% 312.7 1.32% -11.81% -11.81% -23.69%
Financials 84 $ 1,266,175 14.9% 209.1 5.48% -22.74% -22.74% -46.66%
Information Technology 74 $ 1,335,754 15.7% 257.4 0.09% -17.81% -17.81% -37.46%
Telecommunications 9 $ 280,706 3.3% 104 -1.14% -9.53% -9.53% -38.17%
Utilities 32 $ 324,486 3.8% 148.1 -1.63% -11.87% -11.87% -31.49%
3
Industry Makeup of SP-30
Index % of 5 - Year
Value Sector Beta Std Dev.
Consumer Staples 234.17 13.17% 0.6 11.5
Household Products 337.28 23.48% 0.6 14.4
Soft Drinks 195.22 17.25% 0.8 16.6
Tobacco 382.54 14.94% 0.6 17.7
HyperMarkets & Super Centers 95.04 13.60% 0.4 15.8
Packaged Foods & Meats 221.78 12.37% 0.5 12.5
Drug Retail 365.45 6.16% 0.8 19.8
Brewers 416.08 4.62% 0.5 15.5
Food Retail 91.94 3.04% 0.7 17.8
Personal Products 270.94 1.40% 1.1 23.9
Food Distribution 277.65 1.38% 1.0 21.9
Agricultural Products 303.00 1.12% 0.9 33.8
Distillers & Vinters 120.68 0.67% 1.0 21.6
4
Consumer Staples – Household Names
Symbol Company Price Symbol Company Price
MO Altria Group Inc. $ 19.19 KMB Kimberly-Clark $ 61.29
BUD Anheuser-Busch $ 62.03 KFT Kraft Foods Inc-A $ 29.14
ADM Archer-Daniels-Midland $ 20.73 KR Kroger Co. $ 27.46
AVP Avon Products $ 24.83 LO Lorillard Inc. $ 65.86
BF.B Brown-Forman Corp. $ 45.40 MKC McCormick & Co. $ 33.66
CPB Campbell Soup $ 37.95 TAP Molson Coors Brewing $ 37.36
CLX Clorox Co. $ 60.81 PBG Pepsi Bottling Group $ 23.12
KO Coca Cola Co. $ 44.06 PEP PepsiCo Inc. $ 57.01
CCE Coca-Cola Enterprises $ 10.05 PM Philip Morris Intl. $ 43.47
CL Colgate-Palmolive $ 62.76 PG Procter & Gamble $ 64.54
CAG ConAgra Foods Inc. $ 17.42 RAI Reynolds American Inc. $ 48.96
STZ Constellation Brands $ 12.54 SWY Safeway Inc. $ 21.27
COST Costco Co. $ 57.01 SLE Sara Lee Corp. $ 11.18
CVS CVS Caremark Corp. $ 30.65 SVU Supervalu Inc. $ 14.24
DF Dean Foods $ 21.86 SYY Sysco Corp. $ 26.20
DPS Dr Pepper Snapple Group Inc $ 22.90 HSY The Hershey Company $ 37.24
EL Estee Lauder Cos. $ 36.04 TSN Tyson Foods $ 8.74
GIS General Mills $ 67.74 UST UST Inc. $ 67.59
HNZ Heinz (H.J.) $ 43.82 WMT Wal-Mart Stores $ 55.81
K Kellogg Co. $ 50.42 WAG Walgreen Co. $ 25.46
WFMI Whole Foods Market $ 10.72
S&P500 Data provided by Standard and Poor’s web site and is based on market closing information from 10/31/2008. 5
S&P500 vs. SIM Portfolio
Consumer Staples
S&P500: 12.9%
SIM: 14.3%
SIM – currently overweight 140 bp
6
Historical Sector Performance
•Declined in past 11 months, but sustained growth trend over last 4 years
7
Performance Relative to S&P500
8
Agenda
Sector Overview
Sector Factors
Economic Factors
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Recommendations
Anheuser-Busch Action
9
Sector Factors
Stable demand based on consumer needs
Defensive (non-cyclical)
Consistent returns regardless of economic
conditions
Generally lags market during periods of growth
Composed of stable, slow growth
multinational companies
Wal-Mart / Costco
General Mills
Pepsi 10
Note: This slide has been reproduced from the Autumn Quarter 2007 Consumer Staples presentation.
Sector Demand
Steady demand in US
Sector relying on international expansion
to spur growth
Branding important to differentiate an
commoditized product
11
Note: This slide has been reproduced from the Autumn Quarter 2007 Consumer Staples presentation.
Sector Characteristics
High barriers to entry
Dominated by large, well-established companies
High capital requirements to enter sector
Mature industry with strong brand identities
Difficult to create wide distribution network
High buyer power
Undifferentiated product equates to low switching
cost
Note: This slide has been reproduced from the Autumn Quarter 2007 Consumer Staples presentation.
12
Sector Characteristics (Cont.)
Low Supplier Power
Long-term contracting/agreements common
High threat of substitution
Multiple brands competing in same product line
High threat of competition
Consumers are price sensitive (despite brand loyalty) with
undifferentiated products
Note: This slide has been reproduced from the Autumn Quarter 2007 Consumer Staples presentation.
13
Agenda
Sector Overview
Sector Factors
Economic Factors
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Recommendations
Anheuser-Busch Action
14
Economic Analysis
DEMAND:
GDP growth
Unemployment rate
Personal income
Consumer Price Index
15
Note: This slide has been reproduced from the Autumn Quarter 2007 Consumer Staples presentation.
Economic Analysis
SUPPLY:
Energy Prices
Commodity Prices
16
Note: This slide has been reproduced from the Autumn Quarter 2007 Consumer Staples presentation.
17
18
19
20
Agenda
Sector Overview
Sector Factors
Economic Factors
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Recommendations
Anheuser-Busch Action
21
Financial Analysis
Revenue growth is above average and falling
Mean is 7.7%, currently 9%
Net profit margins decreasing the past
two years with a slight correction in mid-2008
Slow increase in dividend yield last five
years, but sharp increase last two months
Falling growth rate estimates
22
23
Income Statement Analysis
Consumer Staples Income Statement Ratios
S&P CONS. STAPLES SECTOR COMP ADJ (SP-30)AsM-Wtd
Reported Financials StockVal ®
FYE Dec Company Filings
Gross Profit Margin (%) 29.14 29.74 29.61 29.76 29.84 29.82 29.65 29.73
Operating Profit Margin EBITDA (%) 11.64 11.50 11.84 11.38 10.94 11.69 12.01 11.93
Operating Profit Margin EBIT (%) 9.39 9.18 9.56 8.98 8.49 9.23 9.10 9.15
Pre-Tax Profit Margin (%) 12.05 12.05 12.45 12.34 11.68 11.80 11.48 10.97
Tax Rate (%) 30.73 30.95 31.90 34.76 35.67 34.87 35.04 35.44
Net Profit Margin Adjusted (%) 5.85 5.86 5.99 5.60 5.73 5.73 5.78 5.79
Return on Avg Common Equity (%) 61.91 29.62 35.74 31.12 47.88 34.58 33.42 40.95
Return on Average Total Equity (%) 21.24 22.07 23.87 23.35 24.82 24.97 25.90 29.26
Return on Average Capital (%) 13.71 14.08 14.79 13.90 13.92 13.69 14.53 16.36
Return on Average Assets (%) 8.33 8.39 8.74 8.46 8.63 8.55 8.85 9.59
Times Interest Earned 8.90 8.64 9.36 9.07 7.79 7.56 6.05 6.48
•Margins constant
•Returns decreasing
24
Income Statement Analysis
S&P 500
Income Statement Ratios
S&P 500 COMPOSITE ADJUSTED (SP5A) M-Wtd As Reported Financials StockVal ®
FYE Dec Company Filings
Gross Profit Margin (%) 33.37 33.53 33.00 32.60 31.96 31.90 31.20 32.39
Operating Profit Margin EBITDA (%) 21.97 22.99 21.01 19.69 18.91 16.91 19.27 24.09
Operating Profit Margin EBIT (%) 17.54 18.73 16.73 14.82 13.50 11.24 12.75 18.34
Pre-Tax Profit Margin (%) 14.97 16.50 17.05 15.43 12.91 6.83 8.82 18.21
Tax Rate (%) 31.06 28.64 29.68 29.63 29.76 27.76 32.51 35.87
Net Profit Margin Adjusted (%) 8.83 9.29 8.85 8.53 7.64 7.22 7.84 8.71
Return on Avg Common Equity (%) 23.57 20.40 25.75 19.57 19.26 18.08 20.42 24.90
Return on Average Total Equity (%) 17.29 17.71 16.88 16.59 15.25 14.01 15.75 20.01
Return on Average Capital (%) 8.87 9.45 8.94 8.58 7.69 7.15 8.26 10.50
Return on Average Assets (%) 3.20 3.38 3.18 3.09 2.78 2.59 2.97 3.63
Times Interest Earned 2.68 3.20 3.69 4.19 3.74 2.62 2.13 2.77
•Margins increasing
•Returns fluctuating
25
Cash Flow Analysis
S&P CONS. STAPLES SECTOR COMP ADJ (SP-30)AsM-Wtd
Reported Financials StockVal ®
FYE Dec Company Filings
27
Valuation Analysis
28
Valuation Analysis
29
Agenda
Sector Overview
Sector Factors
Economic Factors
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Recommendations
Anheuser-Busch Action
30
Economic Outlook
Real GDP growth projected to fall until mid-2009
at the earliest
Growing fears of inflation because of massive
cash infusion by Fed
Consumer spending growth trending downward
Consumer confidence at all-time low
31
32
Recommendations
Decrease SIM portfolio allocation by 140 bp
Bringallocation in line with broader S&P
New target: 12.9% (S&P: 12.9%)
Rationale:
Currently overweighted due to outperformance over
past quarter
Decrease exposure to sector because of underpricing
of other sectors
SP-30 underperformance in upcoming quarters
Recommend next class consider further underweighting if
economic turnaround seems imminent
33
Agenda
Sector Overview
Sector Factors
Economic Factors
Financial Analysis
Valuation
Recommendations
Anheuser-Busch Action
34
Anheuser-Busch Action
Proposed acquisition by InBev for $70/share, all cash
Currently trading at $64.60
BUD shareholders to vote on Nov. 12
Already approved by InBev shareholders
InBev hopes to complete acquisition by year end
Options market
Jan. 2009 $65 call options currently trading at $3.80
Represents in-the-money share price of $68.80
Return of 1.7%, or the cost of capital
In short, options market believes merger will happen
Purchase today represents 7.7% return over two months
35
36