Resources

Problem • Start the discussion with each member expressing their initial
Dilemma position on the dilemma
Task • The Group needs to select a member to prepare a record of
Step 1 the agreements reached during discussions
Step 2

Step 3

Step 4

Possible
Outcomes
 Resources

Problem
• The following points should emerge during the discussion:
Dilemma
• The Certifier should offer to clarify her concern with the Builder’s proposal (which should
Task result in it not being acceptable)
Step 1 • The Group should identify options that comply with 3.7.1.5 (b)(i)

Step 2 • The Group should consider options that do not comply with 3.7.1.5 but may comply with
Performance Requirement P2.3.1
Step 3
• The Group should agree which option will be addressed under Steps 2,3 and 4
Step 4

Possible
Outcomes
Resources

Problem • As a minimum, the following should be documented as part of the Performance-Based

Dilemma Design Brief:
Task • Which Assessment Method will be used to assess whether the proposal meets the
respective Performance Requirement ? (See 1.0.5 & 1.0.7)
Step 1
• What form of supporting evidence, if any, will be required by the Certifier to facilitate
Step 2
approval of the proposal?
Step 3
• What acceptance criteria will be used as a benchmark to assess whether the proposal
Step 4 complies with the NCC?
Possible
Outcomes
Resources

Problem • Upon completion of STEP 1, the Certifying Authority should not participate in the
Dilemma
rest of the process

Task • A reason for this is that a Certifying Authority should not be involved in the
Step 1
development of a design that it will be required to assess

Step 2 • Involvement is allowed in STEP 1 - but not in STEPS 2, 3 and 4

Step 3

Step 4

Possible
Outcomes