Professional Documents
Culture Documents
– Understand the process and know how to develop and review MTSSs.
– Understand well the definitions of the different tiers of the planning
process.
– Understand the links between MTSSs and Performance Reviews and
Reporting.
– Understand the inter-relationship between the:
State Development Plan : MTSSs : Annual Budgets.
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Section 1: Overview of the MTSS
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Key definitions
The following items are crucial in the context of development
planning and require defining:
– Policy
– Strategy
– State Development Plan
– MTSS
– Medium-Term Expenditure Framework
– Sector
– MDAs
– Programme Budgeting
– M&E and the Annual Performance Review and Report
– Results Chain.
These will be defined over the next few slides and shall be referred to
throughout the course of the training.
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Definitions
Item Definitions
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Definitions contd
Item Definitions
www.sparc-nigeria.com
The Results Chain
Medium-Term Longer-Term
Objectives Goals
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Results Chain levels
Medium Term Long Term
Sector Strategy Strategic Plan
Medium-Term Longer-Term
Objectives Goals
POLICY PUBLIC
RESEARCH
DIRECTIVES CONSULTATIONS
&
FROM
STATISTICS
POLITICIANS
Service
Improvement
Planning
REVIEW(s)
ANNUAL
PERSONAL STAFF OBJECTIVES
Annual
Service PUBLIC SERVICES
Reviews
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Why is an MTSS necessary
The Medium Term Approach is about how to turn ambitions into
results.
We need to link the two – our dreams, ambitions and hopes with
our current capacity to deliver results, so that we start to deliver
better results.
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Flaws within the current planning system
www.sparc-nigeria.com
MTSS in the Broader Process
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Linkages between different
planning documents
Long and Medium Term Policy Documents – Outlines overall State Policy Outcomes Loosely
20:2020 and State Development Plan costed if possible to demonstrate general realism
Sector Development Plan – 5 to 10 years Links policy to strategy, generally costed but may
include funding gaps
MTSS – 3 years – No funding gaps Consistent with the Sector Plan, all activities
costed within projected ceilings
Annual Budget Based on the first year of the most recent rolling
MTSS
Annual Operational & Depart’l Work Plans Defines responsibilities for implementation in
relation to the budget
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Multi-layered approach to Planning
Sector Plan
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Key features of an MTSS/MTEF framework
An MTSS/MTEF framework should contain:
A Fiscal Framework statement which outlines sources and
types of projected revenue for the government
Resource ceilings (as a % of the state’s total projected
revenue) for sectors in accordance with the government’s
predetermined priorities
Goals for the sector that are derived from a high level
Development Plan
Sector priorities and expected outcomes
Sector programmes, projects and activities
Sector targets and Key Performance Indicators
Resource allocations to sector programmes and projects
A robust performance monitoring framework www.sparc-nigeria.com
MTSS and the Medium-Term
Expenditure Cycle
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Who is responsible for developing the
MTSS
The following stakeholders are responsibility for various aspects of the
development of the MTSS:
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Processes
Input Literally, what you put in so that you get out an output. Technically, it is
the financial, human and material resources used in your project. For
example, if you are building a road, it will be labour, engineers, planners,
plans, money, tarmac, vehicles, etc.
Activity Activities are the ways in which you use the inputs to produce the
outputs. Technically, it is actions taken or work performed through which
inputs, such as funds, technical assistance and other types of resources
are mobilized to produce specific outputs. For example, road building
would include activities like ground clearing or tarring.
Results
Output Outputs are very often things and they result from the project.
Technically, outputs are the products, capital goods and services which
result from a project. In the road-building example, the chief output is
the actual road but it may also include some bridges.
Outcome An outcome, in policy terms, is a statement of how life is better than it
was before in some way, for some people. Technically, an outcome is the
likely or achieved short-term and medium-term effects of a project’s
outputs. In the road example, there may be many outcomes for many
people, arising from their new ability to have access to health services,
markets and other communities.
Impact The impact is the cumulative effect of the outcomes and is largely about
scale or time. Technically, impacts are positive and negative, primary and
secondary long-term effects produced by a project, directly or indirectly,
intended or unintended. The impact of the new road may be the
economic and agricultural regeneration of that region.
Goal A goal is the most ambitious statement of overall impact that is hoped
for. Technically, it is the higher-order objective to which a project is
intended to contribute.
Target A target is way of measuring progress towards the result and is set in a
way that will be capable of being accurately measured. Technically, a
“performance indicator” is a variable that allows the verification of
changes in the project or shows results relative to what was planned. At
one stage in the road example, it may be “one kilometre of tarred road
completed each week”.
Policy planning is about delivering outcomes. Project planning is about delivering outputs.
Outputs + people = outcomes. Sometimes, that equation also needs institutio ns, such as
systems or “rules of the game” for people to apply. For example, a hospital building (output)
needs doctors and nurses but also needs administration and management before it provides
health outcomes to patients.
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Outcomes
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Outcomes vs Outputs
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Outcome / Output / Input
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Input – Output – Outcome(?)
www.sparc-nigeria.com
The Results Chain
Medium Term Long Term
Sector Strategy Strategic Plan
Medium-Term Longer-Term
Objectives Goals
We now add “Impacts” to look at the longer term changes that result
from our outcomes;
And “Activities” are the bit in the middle that turn Inputs to Outputs.
www.sparc-nigeria.com
The Logic Chain Medium Term
Sector Strategy
Long Term
Strategic Plan
Medium-Term Longer-Term
Objectives Goals
Assumptions Assumptions Assumptions
Assumptions
We make assumptions at each stage that a link will occur – the “Logic
Chain” that underpins the Results Chain. The one in red is often the
most unreliable link, often leading to unintended consequences, rather
than the desired policy outcome.
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Medium Term Long Term
Linking Chains Sector Strategy Strategic Plan
Medium-Term Longer-Term
Objectives Goals
Medium-Term Longer-Term
Objectives Goals
When the outputs of one become the inputs of
another, the planning framework takes shape.
www.sparc-nigeria.com
A quick exercise: distinguishing
outcomes, outputs, inputs & activities
Input Activity Output Outcome Impact
12 project staff
Income of small farmers increased
To train NGO members in book keeping
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Planning - The Current Position
Policies
www.sparc-nigeria.com
. . . . or maybe more like this
No Policy Framework,
no direction
? ? ?
?
?
Education
?
Health ?
Water
Agri.
? ?
?
www.sparc-nigeria.com
. . . but it could be this - the SMTDP
Overall Policy Framework
Policy Goal Policy Goal Policy Goal Policy Goal
Environment Services Growth Governance
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Section 2: The MTSS
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Steps in the MTSS development process
STEP TASK
Identify and Review Existing Policy Statements, including sector and general,
1B both state level, Federal and International. Agree sector policy position and
establish draft three year outputs – involve the HC at this stage
1E Describe existing contract and other budget commitments that are payable or
you expect to be paid during the forthcoming years
Make decisions about changes to the levels of activities and projects, and their
2D phasing of input, so that expenditure ceilings are complied with in the spread-
sheet – include public consultation and perhaps a public forum
Use the spread sheet to compile budget submission (following receipt of call
3C budget circular) and use presentation based on MTSS document to defend it
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Suggested Timeline
Task/Step Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jly Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Conduct Annual
Reviews
Collect data and
information
Review national
policy guidance
Refine State Policy
Outcomes
Receive Expend-
iture Envelopes
Develop sector
strategies & cost
Review strategy
within ceilings
Prepare MTSS
Document
Receive Call Budget
Circular
Refine MTSS and
compile budget
Defend Budget using
MTSS
Make Operational
Plan
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Stage 1: Review and Preparation
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Stage 2: The MTSS process
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Figure 9 MTSS Strategy Log Frame – Outline Template Annex 3
Policy Outcome: e.g. By 2020, sixty percent of secondary school aged children in the state are equipped
with the skills that allow them to obtain gainful employment and learn through higher levels of education.
Medium-Term Output : (Must contain a SMART target): e.g. Thirty percent of secondary age children,
regardless of gender, faith, social background and special needs, complete secondary school by 2014, with at
least 33 percent of these obtaining sufficient results to allow them to proceed to tertiary education.
Sub-Output 1.1: e.g. Adequate numbers of qualified teachers needed to achieve the medium term output are
employed to provide education of good quality in public Schools. Programme Code 001
Target 2013: e.g. Number of qualified teachers employed increases by 5 percent each year
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Stage 3: Documentation and
Agreement
This will entail:
• Discussing with and receiving the approval of the relevant Honorable
Commissioners on the outcomes of the strategy session. Approval needs to be
given for the proposed initiatives that the sector will pursue in furtherance of the
achievement of the policy aspirations of the government
• Production and drafting of the MTSS document. This will:
Describe the process followed in the eventual development of the MTSS
Explain the connection between the policy objectives and the activities that are proposed to
deliver them
Place the plan in the context of existing and future resource constraints
Follow a prescribed outline table of contents
Set out the performance monitoring framework to be used in tracking performance
• Using the contents of the MTSS to develop the State’s annual budget
• Consulting stakeholders on the draft MTSS and revising it as appropriate
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Outline table of contents of MTSS
The draft MTSS document should contain five main chapters and accompanying
annexes, including:
• A Forward signed by the appropriate Honorable Commissioner
• Table of Contents
• Acknowledgements
• Abbreviations
• Chapter One - Introduction:
Aims and objectives of the document
Summary of the process used
Summary of conclusions
Outline of the structure of the document
• Chapter Two – The sector and Policy in the state
A brief introduction of the state
The current situation in the sector
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Outline table of contents of MTSS
contd
Key sector policies
• Chapter Three – The development of sector strategy
Outline of major strategic challenges facing the sector
Resource constraints
Contributions from key partners
Programme connections between sector MDAs
Outline of key strategies
Justification
Results Framework
Responsibilities and operational plan
• Chapter Four – Three-year Expenditure Projections
The process used to make expenditure projections
Outline Expenditure Projections
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Outline table of contents of MTSS
contd
• Chapter Five – Monitoring and Evaluation
Identifying sources of data against the Results Framework
Defining how the Annual Sector Reporting and Review will be conducted
Setting out the organisational arrangements for undertaking the performance monitoring
and reporting activity
• Annexes
MTSS Strategy Log Frame
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Section 3 – M&E
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Purpose of the Performance Evaluation
Report and Annual Review
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Some key sections of the Report
template
Key sections of the Performance Evaluation Report include:
• Executive Summary
• Introduction
Background to the sector and key linkages with sector policies/MTSSs
Purpose of the Performance Evaluation Report
• Analysis of Key Performance Indicators
Summary of progress against work plans
Assessment of performance against targets/KPIs
Impact analysis of strategies/programmes on relevant KPIs
Conclusions and recommendations
• Sector Financial Performance
Sector budget appropriation, disbursement and expenditure trends
. www.sparc-nigeria.com
Some key sections of the Report
template (contd)
Key sections of the Performance Evaluation Report include:
• Institutional and Organisational Capacity
Human resources management performance
Physical infrastructure and facilities
• Cross cutting issues
Linkages with other sectors
Reform progress and impact on overall goals of sector
• forward Look: review and adjustment of MTSS
Recommendations for sector policy and strategy revisions
Recommendation for budgetary adjustments
• Annexes
Data sources and methodology
KPIs, Targets, and relevant statistics
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Key stages of the Annual Performance
Review
Key stages of the Annual Performance Review include:
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Experience sharing by Health and
Educations sectors
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Section 4 – The Intangibles
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Civil society role in planning &
performance monitoring
Civil society has a considerable role to play in planning and
service performance monitoring:
• Professional associations/practitioners in specific sectors need to
engage with government to provide technical knowledge and data on
the sector
This is used to establish possible gaps in service provision and inform the
development of appropriate strategies
• Members of the public and service users should complete exit
questionnaires at the point of accessing services
• Members of the public can, if and when invited, participate in
organised public service reviews
• Members of the public should report poor service standards to the
Ombudsman or relevant agency or to their member of state
assembly
www.sparc-nigeria.com
G&SI in MTSS and Planning
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Action Planning for the development of
outstanding MTSSs
www.sparc-nigeria.com
Steps in the MTSS development process
STEP TASK
Identify and Review Existing Policy Statements, including sector and general,
1B both state level, Federal and International. Agree sector policy position and
establish draft three year outputs – involve the HC at this stage
1E Describe existing contract and other budget commitments that are payable or
you expect to be paid during the forthcoming years
Make decisions about changes to the levels of activities and projects, and their
2D phasing of input, so that expenditure ceilings are complied with in the spread-
sheet – include public consultation and perhaps a public forum
Use the spread sheet to compile budget submission (following receipt of call
3C budget circular) and use presentation based on MTSS document to defend it
www.sparc-nigeria.com
THANK YOU!
www.sparc-nigeria.com