Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
TODAYS TOPICS FOR PRESENTATIONS
3
MAIN COMPONENTS OF ELECTRICAL POWER SYSTEM
4
POWER SYSTEM STRUCTURAL CONSIDERATIONS
5
MAIN COMPONENTS OF ELECTRICAL POWER SYSTEM
6
A power system is not only capable to meet the present load but also has
the flexibility to meet the future demands.
And to cause the prompt removal from service of any element of a power
system when it suffers a short circuit or it starts to operate in any
abnormal manner that might cause damage or otherwise interfere with
the effective operation of the rest of the system.
8
FUNCTION OF POWER SYSTEM PROTECTIONS
9
A protection system shall continuously monitors the power system to
ensure maximum continuity of electrical supply with minimum damage to
life, equipment and property.
1. Abnormally large currents are caused to flow in parts of the system with
the associated overheating of components.
2. System voltages will be off from their normal acceptable levels, resulting
in possible equipment damage.
10
BASIC DESIGN PRINCIPLES OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTION SCHEME OR PROTECTIVE RELAYING:
The correct application of protective relays requires not only, the knowledge
of the relay design parameters, but also a good understanding of the
behavior of the power system in which the relay is to be applied.
The nature of the power system condition, which is being guarded against
must be thoroughly understood in order to make an adequate protection
design.
11
BASIC DESIGN PRINCIPLE OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTION SCHEME OR PROTECTIVE RELAYING;
12
BASIC DESIGN PRINCIPLE OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTION SCHEME OR PROTECTIVE RELAYING;
13
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
I. Phasors or Vectors
II. Polarity.
14
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
The phasor diagram shows only the magnitude and relative phase
angle of the currents and voltages.
While the circuit diagram shows only the location, direction and
polarity of the currents and voltages.
15
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
16
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
17
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
18
PHASORS OR VECTORS
19
PHASORS OR VECTORS
20
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
POLARITY is always associated with directional type protection
relay units such as those indicating the direction of power flow.
The terminals of the CT are marked by P1 (H1) and P2 (H2) on the primary
S1(X1) and S2 (X2) on the secondary side of the CT.
22
23
24
25
26
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
27
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
28
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
29
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
30
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
31
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
32
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
33
SYMMETRICAL COMPONENTS
34
SYMMETRICAL COMPONENTS
35
SYMMETRICAL COMPONENTS
36
SYMMETRICAL COMPONENTS
37
SYMMETRICAL COMPONENTS
38
SYMMETRICAL COMPONENTS
39
TOOLS NEEDED IN PROTECTION RELAYING STUDY
System configuration.
* Existing power plant or substations system protections.
Existing operating procedures and practices.
Degree of protection requirements.
Fault study and analysis.
Maximum load, current transformer ratios, rating etc.
Voltage transformer locations, connections, rating and ratios etc.
Impedance of the lines (OH & UG) and transformers
* Length of the lines.
40
DEFINITIONS AND PROTECTION TERMINOLOGY
41
DEFINITIONS AND PROTECTION TERMINOLOGY
RELAYS are compact analog, digital and numerical devices that are
connected throughout the power system to detect intolerable or
unwanted conditions within an assigned area.
42
DEFINITIONS AND PROTECTION TERMINOLOGY
43
DEFINITIONS AND PROTECTION TERMINOLOGY
44
DEFINITIONS AND PROTECTION TERMINOLOGY
Operating time means that with a relay de-energized and in its initial
condition, the time which elapses between the application of a
characteristic quantity and the instant when the relay operates.
45
DEFINITIONS AND PROTECTION TERMINOLOGY
46
DEFINITIONS AND PROTECTION TERMINOLOGY
47
DEFINITIONS AND PROTECTION TERMINOLOGY
48
DEFINITIONS AND PROTECTION TERMINOLOGY
Drop Out a relay drops out when it moves from the energized position
to the un-energized position.
Power Factor (pf) is the term cosine angle theta where theta is the
angle between the voltage and current wave shapes or the ratio of the
circuit real power (KW) to the circuit apparent power (KVA).
49
DEFINITIONS AND PROTECTION TERMINOLOGY
Short Time Rating is a rating for low voltage power circuit breakers
and the medium voltage power circuit breakers that describe the
breakers ability to withstand a fault current for a period of time.
For low voltage CB 0.5 seconds (30 cycles)
For medium voltage CB 3 seconds
50
CRITERIA FOR GOOD DESIGN OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTION
51
CRITERIA FOR GOOD DESIGN OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTION
When applied to a relay, high speed indicates that the operating time
should not exceed 50 ms (three cycles on 60 HZ base).
52
CRITERIA FOR GOOD DESIGN OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTION
53
CRITERIA FOR GOOD DESIGN OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTION
54
CRITERIA FOR GOOD DESIGN OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTION
When a fault occurs, the protection is required to select and trip only
the nearest circuit breakers. This property of selective tripping is also
called Discrimination and is achieved by two general methods;
55
CRITERIA FOR GOOD DESIGN OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTION
When a fault occurs, the protection is required to select and trip only
the nearest circuit breakers. This property of selective tripping is also
called Discrimination and is achieved by two general methods;
56
CRITERIA FOR GOOD DESIGN OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTION
57
CRITERIA FOR GOOD DESIGN OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTION
58
PRINCIPLE OF TIME AND CURRENT GRADING
a. Discrimination by time.
b. Discrimination by current.
c. Combination of both time and current.
59
PRINCIPLE OF TIME AND CURRENT GRADING
Discrimination by current this method relies on the fact that the fault
current varies with the position of the fault, because of the difference in
impedance values between the source and the fault.
Hence typically, the relays controlling the various circuit breakers are
set to operate at suitably tapered values such that only the relay
nearest to the fault, trips its circuit breaker.
60
PRINCIPLE OF TIME AND CURRENT GRADING
61
AN ILLUSTRATI0N OF TIME GRADING
E F
CB
0
CB TF TF
CB CB
S
S F
A F
A
C
A BB C DD
1.45s 1.05s 0.65s 0.25s
62
ILLUSTRATION OF CURRENT GRADING
CB CB TF CB
A B C F4
F1 F2 F3
63
POWER SYSTEM PROTECTIONS OR PROTECTIVE RELAYING
The protection of the primary equipment must involve not only the faulty
parts but also the other equipment in the network.
64
POWER SYSTEM PROTECTION BASIC COMPONENTS
Relay inputs are usually electric but maybe mechanical, thermal and
other physical quantities. 65
POWER SYSTEM PROTECTION BASIC COMPONENTS
66
POWER SYSTEM PROTECTION BASIC COMPONENTS
Fuse links are usually made of tin, lead or silver in various alloys or
combinations to achieve a desired time-current characteristic.
67
CURRENT TRANSFORMERS BASIC COMPONENTS OF
POWER SYSTEM PROTECTIONS
68
POWER SYSTEM PROTECTION BASIC COMPONENTS
There are two types of Voltage Transformer (VT) which are commonly used
for protective relaying;
The capacitance potential devices are used for protective relaying only
when they are sufficiently less expensive that potential transformer and
when the circuit voltage is higher than 69 kv especially if carrier current
is involved. Because potential device coupling capacitor can be used for
coupling the carrier current equipment to the circuit.
69
70
71
POWER SYSTEM PROTECTION BASIC COMPONENTS
Current Transformers (CTs) are classified into two main groups according
to their application;
a. The metering CT
b. The protection CTs.
72
POWER SYSTEM PROTECTION BASIC COMPONENTS
Metering CTS are usually connected in series in the primary circuit for
low current as this method is more accurate.
However, for high current applications the RING type CT or Bar type are
used as no current then passes directly through the CT.
73
POWER SYSTEM PROTECTION BASIC COMPONENTS
74
VOLTAGE TRANSFORMER BASIC COMPONENTS OF
POWER SYSTEM PROTECTION
75
PROTECTIVE RELAYS BASIC COMPONENTS OF POWER
SYSTEM PROTECTIONS
76
CIRCUIT BREAKERS BASIC COMPONENTS OF POWER
SYSTEM PROTECTIONS
77
13.8 kv Switchgear with Circuit breaker- BASIC
COMPONENTS OF POWER SYSTEM PROTECTIONS
78
HV CIRCUIT BREAKERS BASIC COMPONENTS OF POWER
SYSTEM PROTECTIONS
79
FUSES BASIC COMPONENTS OF POWER SYSTEM
PROTECTIONS
80
DC POWER WITH BATTERY & CHARGER BASIC
COMPONENTS OF POWER SYSTEM PROTECTIONS
81
GENERAL CLASSIFICATIONS OF PROTECTIVE RELAYS
ACCORDING TO THEIR FUNCTIONS;
82
GENERAL CLASSIFICATIONS OF PROTECTIVE RELAYS
ACCORDING TO THEIR FUNCTIONS;
6. Synchronizing relays are used to check and assure that proper and
correct conditions exist for interconnecting two sections of a power
system.
83
GENERAL CLASSIFICATIONS OF PROTECTIVE RELAYS
ACCORDING TO THEIR FUNCTIONS;
For solid state and static relays, they are further categorized under one of
the following designations.
a. Analog relays are those in which the measured quantities are converted
into lower voltage but similar signals, which are then combined or
compared directly to reference values in level detectors to produce the
desired output.
84
GENERAL CLASSIFICATIONS OF PROTECTIVE RELAYS
ACCORDING TO THEIR FUNCTIONS;
85
GENERAL CLASSIFICATIONS OF PROTECTIVE RELAYS
ACCORDING TO THEIR FUNCTIONS;
Example: Distance relay type RELZ 100, REC 670, RED 670, REL 670,
RET 670 etc. from ABB.
From Alstom such as relay type Micom P122, P139, P443, P543, P546
P663 etc.
86
POWER SYSTEM EARTHING
87
POWER SYSTEM EARTHING
88
PURPOSE OF FAULT CALCULATIONS
89
PURPOSE OF FAULT CALCULATIONS
The currents and voltages at different parts of the network for the different
types of faults, different positions of the faults and different configurations
of the network are calculated.
The fault calculations are one of the most important tools when
considering the following;
90
FACTORS AFFECTING THE FAULT CALCULATIONS
The fault current and fault voltage at the different parts of the network
will be affected by the following;
- - Type of fault.
The OPEN circuited phase faults are due to conductor breakage such as
open isolators or circuit breaker poles, busted fuses and high
resistance connections.
92
ELECTRICAL FAULTS
The SHORT CIRCUITED faults are the most severe and are always the
results of insulation breakdown in electrical machines, transformers
and cables.
Then, there is both one single phase to earth fault and one single phase
open circuited fault in the system
93
ELECTRICAL FAULTS
a. Transmission lines 85 %
b. Bus bars - 12 %
c. Transformer / Generators 3 %
94
PRE REQUISITES OF FAULT CALCULATIONS
95
PRE REQUISITES OF FAULT CALCULATIONS
96
RULES FOR FAULT CALCULATIONS
VPHASE
If = ---------------- or VM = If Zf
ZT
97
BASIC THEORY IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
ZS = VP ISC
where;
ZS = Source Impedance
VP = Phase Voltage
ISC = Short Circuit Current
98
BASIC THEORY IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
3. If the three phase network short circuit capacity is given in MVA instead
of current, the system can be still be represented by a single phase
equivalent.
2
( KV line)
ZBASE = ---------------- where; ZBASE = Base Impedance
MVA KV line = Voltage of the line
MVA = given MVA of the power system
network
4. Transformer impedances are usually represented as a percent ( Z%)
on the MVA rating. To get the OHMIC ( ZTR ) value of the transformer
impedance, the base impedance must be calculated using the voltage
rating and MVA rating. 2
(KV)
ZBASE = -----------------
MVA
99
BASIC THEORY IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
100
BASIC THEORY IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
101
BASIC THEORY IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
Note:
The positive and negative sequence reactance of all transformers
are identical.
The resistance terms for the three sequences (Z1, Z2, Z0) are
usually neglected for overhead lines, except for lower voltage lines
and cables.
102
SAMPLE FAULT CALCULATIONS
103
From the substation single line diagram, we shall simplify it into
an equivalent circuit in terms of impedance values.
ZS
33 kv busbar
ZL
33 kv Bus bar
ZTF
ZT = ZS + ZL + ZTF
F
104
SAMPLE FAULT CALCULATIONS
PROBLEM:
SOLUTIONS:
Given:
1. Maximum Through Fault Currents at 33 kv bus-bars (Source) of
S/S 8053 (132/33kv Substation) = 15KA
2. Under ground cables, two parallel feeders with 850 meters in length
for each circuit; ckts; 7356 8053 (A &B).
3. The Cable size used is 2 x 3c x 240 sq. mm, XLPE, Cu. 33 kv
4. The cable parameters / characteristics are;
Where;
ZT = total impedance
ZT = ZS + Z L + ZTF
106
SAMPLE FAULT CALCULATIONS
107
SAMPLE FAULT CALCULATIONS
Since the length of the two underground cable feeders is only 850
meters, we shall ignore it and Z L shall not be included in our fault
calculations in solving for ZT.
We can also include it, but the impedance value is very small which
have no significant effect and it does not contribute much in the fault
current level calculations.
For underground cable circuit whose length is less than 5 Kms., shall be
ignored in the fault calculations.
108
SAMPLE FAULT CALCULATIONS
1. Given two parallel under ground cable feeders with 850 meters in
length for each circuit;
2. The cable size used is 2 x 3C x 240 sq. mm, XLPE, CU, 33kv
109
SAMPLE FAULT CALCULATIONS
110
FAULT CALCULATIONS - CABLES
C=5
A=+j3
B=4
Rectangular form ( 4 + j3), to convert it polar form, we shall use the formula ;
2 2 2
C = A + B
Polar form ( 5 with an angle 36.87 degrees)
5( cosine 36.87) = 4 (Real Component)
5( sine 36.87) = 3 (Imaginary Component)
3
Polar angle Arc tan = ---------- = 36.87 degrees
4 111
FAULT CALCULATIONS
For 1 x TF = 40/2
= 20%
112
FAULT CALCULATIONS
Therefore for 1 x TF
= 13.21 / 2
= 6.6 KA
113
ILLUSTRATION OF CURRENT GRADING
CB CB TF CB
A B C F4
F1 F2 F3
114
EXAMPLE 2 - FAULT CALCULATIONS
Given:
115
EXAMPLE 2 - FAULT CALCULATIONS
(11)(11)
= ------------------------- = 0.485 ohms
250
6350
Hence ISC = ------------------
0.725
= 8800A
116
EXAMPLE 2 - FAULT CALCULATIONS
In this lower fault level the fault current would not exceed 6800A even
for a cable fault close to A, so a relay set at 8800A would not protect
any of the cable section concerned.
6350
ISC = ----------------------------
ZS + ZL1 + ZL2 + ZTF
11(11)
= 0.07 ( ----------------- )
4
= 2.12 ohms
6350
ISC = ----------------- = 2200A
2.885
118
EXAMPLE 3 - FAULT CALCULATIONS
119
EXAMPLE 3 - FAULT CALCULATIONS
120
EXAMPLE 3 - FAULT CALCULATIONS
121
EXAMPLE 3 - FAULT CALCULATIONS
122
EXAMPLE 3 - FAULT CALCULATIONS
123
EXAMPLE 3 - FAULT CALCULATIONS
124
125
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
126
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
2. Make it sure that the relay farthest from the source has current settings
equal to or less than the relays behind it.
That is, that the primary current required to operate the relay in front is
always equal to or less than the primary current required to operate the
relay behind it.
127
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
4. Calculate the maximum and minimum through fault currents of the power system or
network to be protected.
5. Plot the characteristic curve of the relays on the maximum and minimum fault levels
(which are represented by vertical lines) in a logarithmic graphing paper in order to
obtain the relays time and current grading.
128
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
129
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR C0ORDINATIONS
130
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
131
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
132
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
The Normal Inverse (NI) is used as protection for phase and earth faults.
b. The fault level at the near and far ends of the system
does not vary significantly.
133
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
134
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
135
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
136
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
137
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
138
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
139
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
140
BASIC RULES FOR CORRECT RELAY (O/C, E/F) GRADING,
DISCRIMINATION OR COORDINATIONS
141
SAMPLE FOR RELAY COORDINATION
142
SAMPLE FOR RELAY COORDINATION
Assumed that the relays in our example were all of same type and
no lower and upper restrictions were placed on the grading, it would
be very simple and the time current grading would look like as
shown in the next slide.
143
SAMPLE FOR RELAY COORDINATION
144
SAMPLE FOR RELAY COORDINATION
Relay 4 will trip in 4 seconds, clearing the fault, without any of the up
stream relays tripping.
Should Relay 4 (or the circuit breaker) fail to trip, Relay 3 will
trip in 10 seconds, clearing the fault.
(This is also an example of the principle of back up protection)
145
SAMPLE FOR RELAY COORDINATION
Relay 2 will trip in 5 seconds, clearing the fault. Relay 3 and 4 will
not see the fault, and hence will not trip.
Should Relay 2 (or the circuit breaker) fail to trip, Relay 1 will trip
in 8 seconds, clearing the fault.
147
GRAPH / CURVES FOR RELAY COORDINATION
1000
100
Transformer value
10 Feeder value
time
0.01
1 10 100 1000 10000 1E+05
current
148
THEORY AND SAMPLE OF ADVANCE FAULT CALCULATIONS
149
THEORY AND SAMPLE OF ADVANCE FAULT CALCULATIONS
150
THEORY AND SAMPLE OF ADVANCE FAULT CALCULATIONS
151
THEORY AND COMPLEXITIES IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
152
THEORY AND COMPLEXITIES IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
153
THEORY AND COMPLEXITIES IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
154
THEORY AND COMPLEXITIES IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
155
THEORY AND COMPLEXITIES IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
156
THEORY AND COMPLEXITIES IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
157
THEORY AND COMPLEXITIES IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
158
THEORY AND COMPLEXITIES IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
159
THEORY AND COMPLEXITIES IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
160
THEORY AND COMPLEXITIES IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
161
THEORY AND COMPLEXITIES IN FAULT CALCULATIONS
162
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
163
164
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
3. The 415V and 600V loads at the outgoing circuits are well- distributed
such that their individual maximum load is 800A.
5. The accuracy limit factors of CTS were checked and confirmed adequate
for the respective burdens.
6. The 3.3 kv loads are also well distributed such that the rated primary
CT currents are close to the maximum load envisaged.
The relay operating time for the a fault close to the respective circuit
breaker was previously calculated to be 0.4s
166
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
7. All the over current relays are of the same type with pug setting
adjustable at 50%, 75%, 100%, 125% and 150% and time
multiplier setting is continuously adjustable from 0 to 10.
Problem;
1. Calculate the protection settings for the condition that the two
3.5MVA 11/3.3 kv transformers are in service.
2. Indicate graphically that the relay settings are adequate for the
range of fault currents occurring between peak load and base load.
167
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
168
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
11
For 11 kv base, impedance base = --- = 1.21 ohms.
100
100
Current base =------ kA
3 x 11
= 5.249 kA
169
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
3.3
For 3.3 kv base, impedance base = --- = 0.1089 ohm.
100
100
Current base =------ kA
3 x 3.3
= 17.95 kA
170
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
0.6
For 0.6 kv base, impedance base = --- = 0.006 ohm.
100
100
Current base =------ kA
3 x 0.6
= 96.225 kA
171
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
0.415
For 0.415 kv base, impedance base = --- = 0.00415 ohm.
100
100
Current base =------ kA
3 x 0.415
= 139.12 kA
172
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
11
At Peak load = -----
3 x 6
= 1.0585 ohms
1.0585
= ---------
1.21
= 0.8748 pu
173
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
11
At Base load = -----
3 x 4.5
= 1.4113 ohms
1.4113
= ---------
1.21
= 1.1663 pu
174
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
iii. 11 kv Cable;
0.0128 + j 0.073
= ------ -------
1.21 1.21
= 0.01058 + j 0.006033 pu
175
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
0.07
Impedance = ------ x 100 pu
4
= 1.750 pu
176
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
0.055
Impedance = ------ x 100 pu
1.5
= 3.6667 pu
177
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
0.05
Impedance = ------ x 100 pu
1.0
= 5 pu
178
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
179
180
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
1. At 11 kv bus bar;
1
Peak load fault current = ---- pu
contribution from source 0.8748
= 1.1431 pu
1
Bus bar fault current at base load = ------
1.166
= 0.8576 pu
181
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
1.0 x 0.5
Fault current contribution from each circuit peak load = ----------------- pu
0.8748 + 1.756/2
= 0.2853 pu
= 0.5705 pu
182
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
1.0 x 0.5
Fault current contribution from each circuit base load = ----------------- pu
1.166 + 1.756/2
= 0.2446 pu
= 0.4892 pu
183
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
1
Peak load fault current = --------------------- pu
0.5707 + 3.6667
= 0.1845 pu
1
Base load fault current = ------------------ pu
0.4892 + 3.6667
184
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
1
Peak load fault current = --------------------- pu
0.8748 + 5.0
= 0.1702 pu
1
Base load fault current = ------------------ pu
1.166 + 5.0
= 0.1622 pu
185
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
Step D Carry out protection coordination or grading for the relays closest
to the loads.
Outgoing circuits;
Assuming all 600V outgoing circuit are the same and hence the same
maximum load of 800A.
CT ratio = 800/5A
800
Hence, the plug setting = ---------
800/5A x 5
= 100%
186
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
= 0.1845 x 96.225 kA
= 17.75 kA
17,750
Plug-setting multiplier (PSM) =-----------
800/5 x5 x1.0
= 22.2 > 20
187
188
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
0.25 x 1.0
TMS = -------------
2.1
= 0.12
189
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
3 436 0.74
5 727 0.51
10 1,454 0.36
20 2,908 0.26
190
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
Incoming Circuits;
= 1443A
Relay rating = 5A
CT ratio = 1600/5A
1443
Plug setting = ----------------
1600/5 x 5
= 0.902 191
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
17,750
Plug Setting Multiplier ( PSM) = ----------------------
1600/5 x 5 x 1.0
= 11.09
At TMS = 1.0 and PSM = 11.09, relay operating time = 2.90s
0.6 x 1.0
Hence, TMS = ---------
2.90
= 0.22
192
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
3 873 1.4
5 1455 0.94
10 2911 0.66
193
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
Outgoing circuits;
Assuming all 415V outgoing circuit are the same and hence the same
maximum load of 800A.
CT ratio = 800/5A
800
Hence, the plug setting = ---------
800/5A x 5
= 100%
194
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
= 0.1702 x 139.12 kA
= 23.68 kA
23,680
Plug-setting multiplier (PSM) =-----------
800/5 x5 x1.0
= 29.6 > 20
0.25 x 1.0
TMS = -------------
1.9
= 0.13
196
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
3 302 0.81
5 503 0.55
10 1,006 0.39
20 2,012 0.29
197
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
Incoming Circuits;
= 1391A
Relay rating = 5A
CT ratio = 1600/5A
1391
Plug setting = ----------------
1600/5 x 5
= 0.87 198
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
23,680
Plug Setting Multiplier ( PSM) = ----------------------
1600/5 x 5 x 1.0
= 14.8
At TMS = 1.0 and PSM = 14.8 relay operating time = 2.5s
0.65 x 1.0
Hence, TMS = ---------
2.5
= 0.26
199
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
3 604 1.6
5 1,006 1.1
10 2012 0.78
200
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
For the transformer circuits, the relay operating time for a fault at the
600V switchboard must be the same as that for the 2000A circuit breaker
to avoid having too many grading stages.
= 3.228A
CT ratio = 300/5A
201
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
1500
Transformer full load current = -------------
3 x 3.3
= 262A
262
Plug Setting = ----------
300/5 x 5
= 0.87
Hence, choose plug setting = 100%
3 x 228
Plug Setting Multiplier (PSM) = ------------
300/5 x 5 x 1.0
= 10.8
202
203
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING =
0.65 x 1.0
Hence, TMS = -----------
2.85
= 0.23
204
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
3 897 1.4
5 1,494 0.98
10 2,989 0.69
20 5,978 0.51
205
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
= 0.5707 x 17.495 kA
= 9.981 KA
9,981
At this current, the PSM = ----------
300/5A x 5 x 1.0
= 33.3 > 20
206
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
Since the tripping time of relays to the other 3.3 kv loads is 0.4s, the
longest relay tripping is due to the transformer relays. Hence, they will
used to grade with the upstream relays.
Incoming Circuits;
= 0.2853 pu
= 0.2853 x 17.495 kA
= 4.991 kA
207
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
4000
The transformer full load current = -------------- = 700A
3 x 3.3
700
Plug Setting = -------
800/5 x 5
= 0.875
= 0.81s
Using Figure T1-2,
0.81 x 1.0
The TMS = ------------
3.7
= 0.22
209
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
2 1,600 2.2
3 2,400 1.4
5 4,000 0.94
210
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
= 0.1702 pu
= 0.1702 x 5.249 kA
= 0. 8934 kA
Relay rating = 5A .
CT ratio = 75/5A
211
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
1000A
The transformer full load current = -------------
3 x 11
= 52.49A
52.49
Plug setting = ------------
75/5 x 5
= 0.7
212
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
893.4
PSM = ------------
75/5 x 5 x 0.75
= 15.9
0.65 x 1.0
The TMS = ----------- = 0.27
2.4
213
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
3 562 1.8
5 936 1.1
10 1,873 0.81
20 3,746 0.59
30 5,618 0.51
214
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
II. For a fault at the 11 kv terminals of the transformer, the fault current;
= 1.143 pu
= 1.143 x 5.249 kA
= 6.0 kA
6000
PSM = -------------
75/5 x 5 x 0.75
= 107
At such high currents, the relay operating time is less than 0.3s.
But the overheating problems are expected.
215
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
I . For a fault at the 3.3 kv side, the fault current = 0.2853 x 5.249 kA
= 1.498 kA
Relay rating = 5A, CT ratio = 250/5A;
4000
Transformer full load current = --------
3 x 11
= 210A
210
Plug setting = ---------
250/5 x 5
= 0.84
216
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
1,498
PSM = -----------
250/5 x 5 x 1.0
= 5.99
The relay is to operate with the same time as the 3.3kv relay to reduce
the number of grading stages.
0.81 x 1.0
Hence TMS = --------------
3.8
= 0.21
217
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
3 2,500 1.3
5 4, 168 0.89
10 8, 336 0.63
218
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
II. For a fault at the 11 kv terminal of the transformer, the fault current;
= 1.143 pu
= 1.143 x 5.249 kA
= 6.0 kA
6000
PSM = -----------
250/5 x 5 x 1.0
= 24
219
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
Incoming Circuit;
247
Plug setting = ---------
250/5 x 5
= 0.987
220
TUTORIAL OVERCURRENT PROTECTION GRADING
6000
PSM = ----------
250/5 x 5 x 1.0
= 24 >20
= 0.82s
3 2, 500 2.4
5 4,166 1.7
10 8, 333 1.2
222
Circuit Time
Switchboard Breaker / CT Ratio Pug Setting Multiplier
Relay Setting
224
INTERPOSING CURRENT TRANSFORMER
(IPCT)
225225
HOW IT WORKS AT NORMAL CONDITION
226226
HOW IT WORKS DURING EXTERNAL
FAULTS
227227
HOW IT WORKS DURING INTERNAL
FAULTS
228228
- THE END -
THANK YOU OF YOUR KEEN INTEREST AND USUAL FULL
SUPPORT AND COOPERATION IN ANY IIEE CRCSA
ACTIVITIES
THANK YOU
229