Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Where:
G = mass flux (mass of SS transported/area-
time)
Vi = zone settling velocity (ZSV) at Xi
u = bulk transport velocity due to sludge
withdrawal from bottom of the tank.
u = Qu/As
liter
m -0.4 gX
V = 200 e gm
hr
X = gm / liter
150
120
90
V (m/hr)
60
30
0
0 3 6 9 12 15
X (gm/liter)
Flux due to subsidence can then be calculated:
liter
m -0.4 gX
Gs = X
200 e gm
hr
Be sure to make units consistent.
Typical units = kg/m2-hr
liter
m -0.4 gX
G total = X
200 e gm
+u
X
hr
The limiting flux in for each underflow rate, u, is
found by locating the minimum in the total flux
curve. Note that minimum of interest occurs to the
right of the curve peak for reasons discussed
earlier. This minimum can be found graphically
or by differentiating the flux curve with respect to
X and setting the resulting equation equal to zero
and then solve for XL.
G total -0.4 -0.4
= 200
e X
- 200
X0.4
e X
+u
X
G total
When = 0, X = X L
X
For this particular problem:
u (m/hr) XL (mg/liter)
8 11,020
10 10,338
12 9,655
This means that if we choose to operate a clarifier
with an underflow rate of 8 m/hr (Qu/As) then the
flux limiting concentration will be at 11,020 mg/L.
In other words the subsidence flux will be:
liter gm
gm m -0.4 g(11.02 )
G s = (11.02 )200 e gm L
L hr
-3 kg
= 7.5 10 2
m sec
And the bulk transport flux will be:
m mg
Gb = u
XL = 8 11, 020
hr L
kg
= 0.024 2
m sec
The total capacity of the clarifier to transmit
solids under these conditions is:
G t = Gs + G b
kg
= 0.0075 + 0.024 = 0.032 2
m sec
This same information can be obtained graphically. In
fact once the subsidence flux curve is drawn a
straight line at slope u drawn tangent to the
subsidence curve will give all the required
information. One important point is that the tangent
line must remain below the subsidence curve
otherwise the flux limiting capacity will be exceeded
and the clarifier will fail.
Slope = 8m/hr
(0.032) = Gt
G
(.0075) = Gs (14.41)
11,020
How is this information used to design a clarifier?
The major design parameters for a clarifier-
thickener are the cross-sectional area, As, and the
volumetric underflow rate Qu. These parameters
must be selected so that the solids loading
capacity of the clarifier-thickener is not exceeded
and the solids concentration of the underflow is
adequate. These parameters can be selected by
the following procedure.
Consider mass flow through a clarifier:
Perform a solids mass balance around the
clarifier:
X u = Qf
Qu X f - X e (Qf - Q u )
Start with:
Qf = Lf = X u
Xf Qu
Qu = u
As
Lf = X u
As
u
As = X u
G total As
u
Consider the previous case.
As = Qu/u = 2.355 m2
The way in which the problem was set up the
clarifier is critically loaded. However, clarifiers do
not need to be loaded critically to function.
As = X u
G total As
u
If Xu is held constant u will be half of the previous
value so Gtotal will be halved.
Assuming Lf (Qf * Xf) is constant then lowering Gtotal
by is exactly compensated by doubling A s. This
analysis can be extended to any combination of
changes in Xu, u, Qu, etc. as long as the mass balance
is met and as long as the line connecting Gtotal and Xu
remains below the subsidence flux curve.
In the following graph black lines are acceptable
operating conditions whereas blue lines are
unacceptable conditions.
There are an infinite number of non-critically
loaded conditions a few of which are shown in
the following graph. All variations in X u or u or
Gtotal are allowed as long as mass balances are
satisfied.
Critically loaded design can be accomplished
graphically using the Batch Flux: technique.
(GS = viXi).
Select an Xu . Draw a line tangent to the subsidence
batch curve which originates at G = 0, X = X u. Extend
this line to the ordinate. The ordinate intercept is G total.
The G value at the point of tangency is G s.
The slope of the tangent line is the negative of
the underflow rate u.
Gtotal
Gs
Justification for this procedure can be shown from
geometry or the Kynch analysis.
Then:
Qu
Xu Xf -Xe (Qf -Qu )
Qf
G total = =
As As
Tube Settlers:
One method to increase the efficiency or increase
the capacity of clarifiers is to install "false
bottoms" in the clarifiers. For example in a
rectangular clarifier such a "false bottom" would
look like:
Using Type I settling analysis, the effect of
providing a single false bottom (of equal area of
the original bottom) is to effectively reduce the
critical velocity, Vc , by half if the false bottom is
located at mid-depth.