You are on page 1of 125

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

COMPANY POLICIES
MANAGEMENT PREROGATIVE in writing

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Company policies lay


down the rules in the
workplace.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO
Business Lawyer & Legal Consultant
JDP Consulting Ltd. Co.

Business Law Professor


San Beda Graduate School of Business

Book Author, Legal Aspects of Business


Central Books Publishing

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTING

www.jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What are
company policies?
Company policies are the rules and regulations in the workplace.
It is recognized principle that company policies and regulations are, unless shown
to be grossly oppressive or contrary to law, generally valid and binding on the
parties and must be complied with until finally revised or amended, unilaterally or
preferably through negotiation, by competent authority.

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Tanala v. NLRC, Via Mare Catering Services, G.R. No. 116588, 24 January 1996

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What is the basis for


company policies?
Management prerogative is the basis for company policies.
The principle of management prerogative is that right of the employers to regulate
all aspects of employment.

Jurisprudence recognizes the exercise of management prerogatives. Labor laws


also discourage interference with an employers judgment in the conduct of its
business.

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Endico v. Quantum Foods Distribution Center, G.R. No. 161615, 30 January 2009

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What is the importance of


having good company
policies?
Company policies form part of the employment contracts.
They create rights and obligations between employers and employees.

Whenever there is doubt, all labor laws and employment contracts are construed in
favor of the safety and decent living of the laborer.
Art. 1702, Civil Code of the Philippines

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

What are the usual contents of


company policies?
Contents

Mandatory

1. Company Profile
2. Mission and Vision
3. Working Conditions
4. Monetary Benefits
5. Leaves
6. Violations
7. Disciplinary Actions
8. Miscellaneous
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

A. Sexual Harassment
B. Drug-Free Workplace
C. HIV-AIDS
D. Hepatitis B
E. Tuberculosis

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

What are the usual contents of


company policies?
COMPANY PROFILE

A short introduction of the company


Company values, aspirations and
principles
General background or history of the
company

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

MISSION & VISION

Company objectives, goals, and


targets
Over-all direction and thrust of the
company
Roadmap towards achieving these
objectives

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

What are the usual components of


company policies?
WORKING CONDITIONS
Working days and time of the week
Rest day of the week
Rules on overtime work
1-hour meal period
20-minute short rest
Compensable working hours

MONETARY BENEFITS
Holiday pay
Overtime pay
Premium pay
Night shift differential pay
Service charges
13th month pay
Separation pay
Retirement pay

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

What are the usual components of


company policies?
LEAVES
Service incentive leave or vacation
leave, and sick leave
Maternity leave
Paternity leave
Solo parental leave
VAWC leave
Company-authorized leaves

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

VIOLATIONS
Company violations and offenses
Just causes: serious misconduct,
willful disobedience, gross and
habitual neglect, breach of trust,
commission of a crime against
person, etc.
Absence without leave (AWOL)

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

What are the usual components of


company policies?
DISCIPLINARY ACTION

Penalties and sanctions


Preventive suspension or penalty of
suspension
Termination or dismissal

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

MISCELLANEOUS

Clearance process in case of


termination of employment
Release, Waiver, and Quitclaim

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

What are the required components


of company policies?
SEXUAL HARASSMENT
Complaint process, including
reporting of harassment
Due process to give both sides the
opportunity to be heard
Sanctions and penalties, including
termination
Rules against retaliation

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

DRUG-FREE WORKPLACE

Rules on random drug testing


Process of selection
Date and time to be conducted
Sanctions and penalties, including
termination

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

What are the required components


of company policies?
HIV-AIDS
Non-discrimination and
confidentiality
Advocacy, information, education
and training
Workplace education package on HIV
and AIDS based on curriculum by
Inter-Agency Committee (IAC) on
STD
Work accommodation and
arrangement
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

HEPATITIS B
Non-discrimination and
Confidentiality
Rights-based, incorporating human
rights standards and principles
Advocacy, information, education
and training
Preventive strategies
Work accommodation and
arrangement

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Do company policies need


to have all of these?
Except for those that are required, company policies depend on the
rules and conditions of employment laid down by the
management.

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What if the company


policies do not provide for
these?
Labor laws are written into employment contracts.
Thus, the employees are entitled to statutory monetary claims and benefits even if
they are not provided in the company policies, employment contracts, and CBA.

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What should management do if


it revises the
company policies?
Employees should be given an opportunity to access the revised
company policies. If they ask for a copy, they should be given one.

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What are the consequences for


having poorly written
employment contracts?
Company policies may be the basis for an employees rights.
Poorly written employment contracts may result in creating unintended
rights in favor of the employees which the management will be bound to
observe. Failure to comply with these, a labor complaint may result
exposing the employer to liabilities and costs for litigation.

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

How do you avoid such


liabilities?
Management should observe best legal practices to avoid such
consequences and liabilities.
Best legal practices are best practices with legal compliance. For employment, they
are sourced from labor laws, rules & regulations, jurisprudence, and best practices.

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

What are these best legal practices


for company policies?
Ensure that the company policies are in compliance with
current labor laws, rules, and jurisprudence
Clearly and expressly state the working conditions, monetary
claims, benefits, leaves, violations, disciplinary actions, and so
on
Whenever necessary, provide for their scope and extent of
applicability
Harmonize the company policies with the employment
contracts and company practices
Document and announce revisions to the entire workforce, as
well as allow employees the opportunity to read them
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Have there been cases when


company policies were used in
labor cases?
Yes, there are numerous Supreme Court Decisions or Jurisprudence
wherein company policies were used either for or against the
employer.

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

Jurisprudence or Supreme Court


Decisions
GENERAL

IN FAVOR

Company policies
and regulations are
generally valid and
binding and must be
complied with until
finally revised or
amended by
competent authority.

An employee was
validly dismissed
after refusing to
attend a Values
Transformation
Seminar where
company policies are
primarily discussed.

- Tanala v. NLRC, Via Mare


Catering Services, G.R. No.
116588, 24 January 1996

Canadian Opportunities
Unlimited v. Dalangin, G.R. No.
172223, 06 February 2012

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

AGAINST
An employer was
liable for illegal
dismissal after
dismissing
employees in
violation of its own
company policies
on drug testing.
- Plantation Bay Resort and
Spa v. Dubrico, G.R. No.
182216, 04 December 2009

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Company policies may


help shield the company
from labor complaints.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO

JDP

Business Lawyer & Legal Consultant


JDP Consulting Ltd. Co.

Business Law Professor


San Beda Graduate School of Business

Book Author, Legal Aspects of Business


Central Books Publishing

CONSULTING

www.jdpconsulting.ph

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

MANAGEMENT
PREROGATIVE
FRAMEWORK OF PHILIPPINE LABOR LAW
FOR EMPLOYERS & MANAGERS

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Labor law can work for


the advantage and
benefit of the employer.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO
Business Lawyer & Legal Consultant
JDP Consulting Ltd. Co.

Business Law Professor


San Beda Graduate School of Business

Book Author, Legal Aspects of Business

For more info:

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

Central Books Publishing

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What constitutes labor law?


Labor law is a body of laws regulating employment.
It primarily consists of: (a) the 1987 Constitution, (b) Labor Code, (c)
Special laws (e.g. 13th Month Pay, SSS Law, Paternity Leave Law, VAWC
Leave, etc.), (d) Jurisprudence (Supreme Court Decisions), (e) Omnibus
Rules Implementing the Labor Code, and (f) DOLE Advisories.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What is the
most important rule
to know in labor law?
Full protection to labor
The 1987 Constitution itself requires the State to afford full protection to
labor.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What is the next


most important rule
to know in labor law?
Doubts in labor law and employment contract = Rule for Employees
Whenever there is doubt, all labor laws and employment contracts are
construed in favor of the safety and decent living of the laborer.
- Article 1702, Civil Code

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What is the basis for labor law?


Social Justice
The aim and the reason [and, as such,] the justification of labor laws is social
justice.
- Cesar Alvero Azucena, Jr., Former Supreme Court Justice
The basic tenet of social justice is that those who have less in life must have more
in law.
The 1987 Philippine Constitution mandates the State to afford full protection to
labor, local and overseas, organized and unorganized, and promote full employment
and equality of employment opportunities to all.
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What is the basis for labor law?


Social Justice
The State is required to guarantee the rights of all workers to self-organization,
collective bargaining and negotiations, and peaceful concerted activities, including the
right to strike in accordance with law.
The workers are entitled to security of tenure, humane conditions of work, and a living
wage. The constitutional right to security of tenure is an act of social justice.
The State is mandated to promote the principle of shared responsibility between
workers and employers and the preferential use of voluntary modes in settling disputes,
including conciliation, and shall enforce their mutual compliance therewith to foster
industrial peace.
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Is labor law unfair to the


employer?
No injustice to employer
While labor law is based on social justice, it does not necessarily mean
that the employer is left to his/her own devices.
The Supreme Court itself has repeatedly mandated that injustice should
not be done to the employer: We cannot simply tolerate injustice to
employers if only to protect the welfare of undeserving employees.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Supreme Court understands the


problems of an employer
Needless to say, so irresponsible an employee like petitioner does not
deserve a place in the workplace, and it is within the managements
prerogative to terminate his employment. Even as the law is
solicitous of the welfare of employees, it must also protect the
rights of an employer to exercise what are clearly management
prerogatives. As long as the companys exercise of those rights and
prerogative is in good faith to advance its interest and not for the purpose
of defeating or circumventing the rights of employees under the laws or
valid agreements, such exercise will be upheld. (Emphasis supplied.)
- Rene P. Valiao v. The Hon. Court of Appeals, G.R. No. 146621, 30 July
2004.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Supreme Court understands the


problems of an employer
Social justice is not one-sided.
The law in protecting the rights of the employees, authorizes
neither oppression nor self-destruction of the employer there
may be cases where the circumstances warrant favoring labor
over the interests of management but never should the scale be
so tilted as to result in an injustice to the employer.
Hence, the Supreme Court has correctly pointed out that social
justice is not one-sided.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

When is there a labor


dispute?
Employment Relationship Labor Dispute
A labor dispute is any controversy or matter concerning terms and
conditions of employment or the association or representation of person in
negotiating, fixing, maintaining, changing or arranging the terms and
conditions of employment, regardless of whether the disputants stand in the
proximate relation of employer and employee. Before any labor case may
proceed, it is required first to establish the employer and employee
relationship between the parties.
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

When is there an employeremployee relationship?


Four-fold Test of Employment
The elements to determine the existence of an employment relationship
are: (a) the selection and engagement of the employee; (b) the payment
of wages; (c) the power of dismissal; and (d) the employers power to
control the employees conduct.
The most important element is the employers control of the employees
conduct, not only as to the result of the work to be done, but also as to the
means and methods to accomplish it.
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What is the extent of


control or power by the
employer?
Management Prerogative
Management Prerogative is the wide freedom of the management to
regulate, according to its own discretion and judgment, all aspects of
employment, including hiring, work assignments, working methods, time,
place and manner of work, processes to be followed, supervision of
workers, working regulations, transfer of employees, work supervision, lay
off of workers and discipline, dismissal and recall of workers.
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Is there a limitation to
management prerogative?
Management Prerogative
The exercise of management prerogative requires that it be done in good
faith and with due regard to the rights of the employee.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Proper use of
management prerogative
addresses labor
concerns.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO

For more information, contact:

JDP CONSULTING LTD. CO.


Call: (+632) 479-5405, Fax: (+632) 479-5401
Mobile: (+63) 917-622-0124
E-mail: info@jdpconsulting.ph
Website: www.jdpconsulting.ph

You may also want to visit:

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

EMPLOYMENT
CONTRACTS AND
EMPLOYEE STATUS
REGULAR, PROBATIONARY, CASUAL, PROJECT, SEASONAL,
FIXED-TERM

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Defective employment
contracts result regular
employment.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO
Business Lawyer & Legal Consultant
JDP Consulting Ltd. Co.

Business Law Professor


San Beda Graduate School of Business

Book Author, Legal Aspects of Business

For more info:

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

Central Books Publishing

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What is an
employment contract?
An employment contract is an agreement between the employer and the
employee on the terms and conditions of employment.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

What are the parts of an


employment contract

CONSULTIN
G

1. Parties
2. Whereas Clause
3. Terms and Conditions of Employment
4. Miscellaneous Provisions
5. Signature Provisions
6. Notarial Details

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What is the importance of


having a good employment
contract?
Whenever there is doubt, all labor laws and employment contracts are
construed in favor of the safety and decent living of the laborer.
- Art. 1702, Civil Code of the Philippines

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

What are the different employment


arrangements?
REGULAR

PROBATIONARY

Employee who has


been engaged to
perform activities
which are usually
necessary or
desirable in the
usual business or
trade of the
employer

Employee who is
made to undergo a
probationary period
not exceeding 6
months and the
standards/criteria for
qualifying as a
regular employee
was made known
on/before time of
engagement

CONSULTIN
G

CASUAL
Employee who
performs functions
that are incidental,
or those not
necessary or
desirable in the
usual trade or
business of the
employer, and for a
limited duration

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

What are the different employment


arrangements?
PROJECT

SEASONAL

FIXED-TERM

Employee who has


been engaged for a
specific project or
undertaking the
completion of which
has been determined
at the time of the
employees
engagement

Employee who has


been engaged to
perform work or
service which are
seasonable in nature
and the employment
is for the duration of
that season

Employee who has


been engaged for a
particular duration,
which has been
made known to the
employee at the
time of engagement

CONSULTIN
G

Bilateral relationship:
Employer Project Employee

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

What are the different employment


arrangements?

CONSULTIN
G

CONTRACTUAL WORKERS
(UNDER DOLE D.O. No. 18-A, S. 2011)
Employee hired by a contractor/subcontractor to perform or
complete a job, work, or service pursuant to the Service
Agreement with a principal
Trilateral relationship:

Principal Contractor Contractual Workers


Note: Do not confuse w/ project employees.
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What if the requirements for


employment contracts are not
followed?
The employee is deemed a regular employee despite any verbal or written
agreement as a consequence for failing to comply with the legal
requirements.
The next slides will show these instances.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

When employees are deemed


regular by labor laws
1. A casual employee who has rendered at least one year of service,
whether continuous or broken, with respect to the activity in which
he/she is employed and his/her employment continues while such
activity exists;
2. A probationary employee who has been allowed to continue work
despite the last day of the probationary period;
3. A probationary employee who was not informed of the
standards/criteria under which he will qualify as a regular employee
on/before at the time of engagement;

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

When employees are deemed


regular by labor laws
4. A project employee when the following conditions concur: (a) there is a
continuous rehiring of the project employee even after the cessation of a
project; and (b) the tasks performed by the alleged project employee is vital,
necessary, and indispensable to the usual business or trade of the employer;
5. A fixed-term employee whose employment fails to comply with the 2-fold
criteria: (a) a fixed period of employment was agreed upon knowingly and
voluntarily by the parties, without any force, duress or improper pressure
being brought to bear upon the employee and absent any other circumstances
vitiating his/her consent; or (b) where it is satisfactorily appears that the
employer and the employee dealt with each other on more/less equal terms
with no moral dominance whatsoever being exercised by the former over the
latter;

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

When employees are deemed


regular by labor laws
6. A learner whose training is terminated by the employer before
the end of the stipulated period without any fault of the learner
provided he/she has been allowed or suffered to work during the
first two months.

NOTE: In all of these 6 instances, the law itself deems the


employee to be regular despite any verbal or written agreement as
to his/her status whether probationary, casual, project, or fixedterm. No further declaration by the employer is necessary.
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What are the consequences


once the law deems an
employee to be regular?
The employee is entitled all the rights, benefits, and privileges of a regular
employee under labor laws, employment contract, company policies and
practices, and Collective Bargaining Agreements.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

How do you avoid such


liabilities?
Management should observe best legal practices to avoid such
consequences and liabilities.
Best legal practices are best practices with legal compliance. For
employment, they are sourced from labor laws, rules & regulations,
jurisprudence, and best practices.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

What are these best legal practices


for employment contracts?

CONSULTIN
G

In General
Clearly state in employment contracts the status of the employee
upon engagement e.g. probationary, casual, project, etc.
Provide the necessary information related to the functions, roles,
and responsibilities of the employee
Incorporate by reference the company policies, rules, and
practices as integral parts of the employment contract
Ensure that the terms and conditions of the employment has been
properly explained and the employee understood the same
Notarize the employment contract to convert it to a public
document
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

For specific best legal practices


depending on the arrangement
REGULAR
Specifically state the
regular status of the
employee
Provide therein the
necessary preemployment
requirements and
ensure compliance
prior to engagement

PROBATIONARY
Ensure that
probationary period
does not exceed 6
months
Provide the
standards/criteria for
qualifying as a
regular employee
No work beyond
probationary period

CONSULTIN
G

CASUAL
State the functions,
roles, and
responsibilities which
are incidental to the
usual trade or
business of the
employer
Ensure that
employment is for a
limited duration
No casual employment
beyond 1 year
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

For specific best legal practices


depending on the arrangement
PROJECT
Clearly state the
specific project or
undertaking
Ensure that the
completion of these
have been determined
at the time of the
employees
engagement
Avoid continuous
rehiring for similar
project/undertaking

SEASONAL

FIXED-TERM

Specifically state
that the work or
service which are
seasonable in nature

Stipulate that the


employee is engaged
for a particular
duration

Ensure that the


employment is for
the duration of that
season

Ensure that such


fixed-term or period
is stated and made
known to the
employee at the
time of engagement

CONSULTIN
G

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

For specific best legal practices


depending on the arrangement
CONTRACTUAL WORKERS
(UNDER DOLE D.O. No. 18-A, S. 2011)
Ensure that there is a written employment contract that complies
with the Rules, namely: (1) specific job description; (2) place of
work and terms and conditions of employment, including a
statement of the wage rate applicable to the individual
employee; (3) term or duration of employment that must be coextensive with the Service Agreement or with the specific phase
of work for which the employee is engaged.
Avoid prohibited acts e.g. repeated hiring of employee for short
duration Employment Contracts or Service Agreement, Cabo

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Have there been cases when the


law declared employees to be
regular?
Yes, there are numerous Supreme Court Decisions or Jurisprudence
wherein employees were declared to be regular despite having a different
arrangement with the employer.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

Jurisprudence or Supreme Court


Decisions
REGULAR
Employees
(formatters) who
performed necessary
or desirable activities
but under various
fixed-term
employment
contracts were
considered regular
employees.
- Price v. Innodata Phils, Inc.,
G.R. No. 178505, 30
September 2008

PROBATIONARY

CASUAL

An probationary
employee
(management
trainee) who was
made to work 2 days
after the
probationary period
was considered a
regular employee.

An causal employee
(photocopier/sorter)
who performed
necessary or desirable
activities and who has
rendered more than 1
year of service was
considered a regular
employee.

Mitsubishi Motors Philippines


Corporation v. Chrysler
Philippines Labor Union, G.R.
No. 148738, 29 June 2004

CONSULTIN
G

- Philippine Long Distance


Telephone Company, Inc. v.
Arceo, G.R. No. 149985, 05
May 2006
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

Jurisprudence or Supreme Court


Decisions
PROJECT

SEASONAL

FIXED-TERM

A project employee
(laborer/carpenter)
who was repeatedly
and continuously rehired for 31 years
and performed vital,
necessary, and
indispensable work
was considered a
regular employee.

Seasonal employees
(hacienda workers)
who were performed
work/services
seasonal in nature
but not hired for
duration of one
season were
considered regular
employees.

Fixed-term employee
(newscaster/anchor)
who was repeatedly
rehired under fixedterm contracts for
fearing of losing the job
resulting in unequal
footing with employer
was considered a
regular employee.

- D.M. Consunji, Inc. v. Jamin,


G.R. No. 192514, 18 April
2012

- Hacienda Bino v. Cuenca,


G.R. No. 150478, 15 April 2005

CONSULTIN
G

- Dumpit-Murillo v. Court of
Appeals, ABC, G.R. No.
164652, 08 June 2007

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H

Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Employment contracts
are construed in favor of
labor in case of doubt.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO
For more information, contact:

JDP CONSULTING LTD. CO.


Call: (+632) 479-5405, Fax: (+632) 479-5401
Mobile: (+63) 917-622-0124
E-mail: info@jdpconsulting.ph
Website: www.jdpconsulting.ph

You may also want to visit:

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

STATUTORY MONETARY
BENEFITS
Minimum wage, holiday pay, premium pay, overtime pay,
maternity/paternity/parental leaves, 13th month pay, etc.

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Statutory monetary
benefits are mandatory.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO
Business Lawyer & Legal Consultant
JDP Consulting Ltd. Co.

Business Law Professor


San Beda Graduate School of Business

Book Author, Legal Aspects of Business


Central Books Publishing

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

For more info:

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What are statutory


monetary benefits?
Statutory monetary benefits are those which the employee is entitled to
receive from the employer and the government as required by law.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Statutory monetary benefits may


either be from
THE EMPLOYER

Minimum wage

Holiday pay

Premium pay

Overtime pay

Night shift pay

Service charge

Service incentive leave

Maternity/Paternity/Parental leave

VAWC leave

Special leave for women

13th month

Separation pay

Retirement pay

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

THE GOVERNMENT

SSS benefits

Philhealth benefits

Pag-IBIG

ECC benefits

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Are all establishments required


to pay these statutory monetary
benefits?
Non-agricultural establishments are required to pay them.
Retail and service establishments employing a certain number of
employees are not required to pay them.
See next slide for the compliance guide.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Compliance Guide:

Managers
are not
entitled.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

Statutory Monetary
Benefits

Retail & Service w/ up to 9


employees

Non-Agriculture

Minimum wage

Holiday pay

N/A

Premium pay

Overtime pay

Night shift pay

(except up to 5 employees)

Service charge

Service incentive leave

N/A

Maternity/Paternity/ Parental leave

VAWC leave

Special leave for women

13th month pay

Separation pay

Retirement pay

N/A

Coverage:

Not all employees are entitled.


Labor Code working
conditions and benefits do not
apply to:

Labor Code working conditions and benefits do not apply to:


1. Government employees

1. Holiday Pay

2. Managerial employees

2. Premium Pay

4. Field personnel

3. Overtime pay

6. Domestic helpers

4. Night Shift Pay


5. Service Charge
6. Service Incentive Leave
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

3. Officers/members of managerial staff

5. Family members of employers dependent on latter for support

7. Persons in the personal service of another


8. Workers paid by results

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

May a covered employer


refuse to pay these?
No, the statutory monetary benefits are mandatory.
Failure to pay these statutory monetary benefits opens the employer to
consequences, ranging from labor, administrative, to criminal liabilities.C

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

JDP

Consequences for failing to pay the


statutory monetary benefits:
LABOR CASE
Labor complaint for
statutory monetary
benefits
For minimum wage,
the employer may
be required to pay
double the unpaid
sum.
10% attorneys fees
on the monetary
award
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

ADMIN CASE

CRIMINAL CASE

DOLE may initiate an


administrative case
against an employer
for non-compliance
with labor laws

Certain statutory
monetary benefits
carry criminal
liabilities for their
non-compliance.

Administrative
penalties and fines
may be imposed
against the employer
for non-compliance.

For minimum wage,


the employer may be
imprisoned despite
payment of unpaid
sum or indemnity.

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

How do you avoid such


liabilities?
Management should observe best legal practices to avoid such
consequences and liabilities.
Best legal practices are best practices with legal compliance. For
employment, they are sourced from labor laws, rules & regulations,
jurisprudence, and best practices.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

JDP

What are the best legal practices for


statutory monetary benefits?
Regularly update on and follow labor laws for legal compliance,
especially on minimum wage and new benefits
Follow social media sites of DOLE and the Government which
regularly provides for statutory monetary computations, particularly
on holiday pay, special holiday pay, overtime pay, etc.
Ensure that the requirements are followed whenever a benefit is
availed e.g. Solo Parental ID, SSS notice, Barangay Complaint, etc.
Harmonize employment contracts, company policies and practices,
and Collective Bargaining Agreement, with statutory monetary
benefits
Keep proofs of payment to serve as evidence in case of a labor
complaint
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

May an employer substitute


statutory monetary benefits with
company benefits?
No, statutory monetary benefits being mandatory have to be paid to the
employees who are entitled thereto as a matter of law.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

May an employer lessen or


add to these statutory
monetary benefits?
Following the rule on non-diminution, the employer may add and improve
on these statutory monetary benefits but it may not lessen them.
Improving these benefits inure to the benefit of the employees.
Conversely, lessening these benefits are prejudicial to the employees.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Statutory Monetary
Benefits
Lets discuss each one.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

1) Minimum Wage
The minimum wage rates are those
prescribed by the Regional Tripartite Wages
and Productivity Board for each and every
region.

Exceptions to Minimum Wage*


1. Handicapped/Learner/Apprentice**
2. Retail/Service w/ up to 9 employees**
3. Barangay Micro Business Enterprises

Payment
Legal tender only, twice a month

4. Household Helpers/Personal Drivers


5. Homeworkers in needlework
6. Registered-cooperatives

Employees death, pay to DOLE

7. Distressed/Calamity-affected/New establishments

Proof of payment

8. NCIDA-registered enterprise
9. Farm tenancy or leasehold arrangements

Non-compliance
1. Double unpaid sum
2. Criminal liability
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

Obtain clearance from DOLE first.


** Requires prior approval
*

2) Holiday Pay

Absent w/o pay prior to a holiday

Payment

No holiday pay unless he works on such


holiday

100% - Unworked

(Same rule if prior day is non-working day)

200% - Worked / Unworked Double Holiday


300% - Worked on Double Holiday

Computation
Regular Wage, COLA not included
Special Rules

Absent w/o pay prior to successive holidays


No holiday pays unless he works on 1st
holiday to be paid the 2nd holiday pay
Temporary/periodic/temporary shutdown of
work

Private School Teachers, Paid by Results


Holiday pays required to be paid unless
(ADS), Seasonal, No regular working days

due to business reverses + DOLE


authorized
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

3) Premium Pay
Payment (RW: Regular Wage)
x 130% RW Rest day

Compulsory Rest Day Work

x 150% RW Rest day + Special Day*

1. Actual/Impending Emergencies due to disaster/calamity to prevent loss


of life/property, and imminent danger to public safety

x 260% RW Rest day + Regular Holiday

Rest Day Preference


Management Prerogative
Religious 2 days per month +
serious prejudice or obstruction
to operations
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business*Ninoy
Laws & BestAquino
Legal

(Aug. 21), All Saints Day (Nov. 1), Years

2. Urgent work on machinery, equipment, installation, to avoid serious


loss on employer
3. Abnormal pressure of work due to special circumstances + employer
cannot ordinarily be expected to resort to other measures
4. To prevent loss or damage to perishable goods
5. Nature of work requires continuous operations + work stoppage will
result in irreparable injury/loss
6. Work is necessary to avail of favorable weather or environmental
conditions + performance/quality of work depends thereon
7. Analogous or similar to the foregoing via DOLE regulations

4) Overtime Pay
OT Rate
x 125% RW/8 Ordinary
Compulsory Overtime Work
1. Country at war, or declared national/local emergency by
Day
President/Congress
2. Necessary to prevent loss of life/property, imminent danger to public
safety due to disaster or calamity

Computation

3. Urgent work on machines, installation, equipment, etc. to avoid serious


loss or damage

COLA not included

4. To prevent loss/damage to perishable goods


5. Completion/continuation of work prior to 8th hour necessary to prevent
serious obstruction or prejudice to business/operations
6. Necessary to avail of favorable weather or environmental conditions +
performance/quality of work dependent thereon

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

JDP

STATUTORY MONETARY BENEFITS


(MANAGERS NOT ENTITLED.)
NIGHT SHIFT PAY
10% daily rate / hour
10:00 pm to 6:00 am
following day work
COLA excluded

SERVICE CHARGE
85% covered nonmanagerial
employees, 15%
covered employers
Paid twice a month
If abolished, 12
month average of
each employee
integrated in salary.
Pooled tips covered.

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

SERVICE INCENTIVE
LEAVE
5-day leave w/ pay
Conditions: 1 year of
service (continuous /
broken)
Convertible
Non-cumulative

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

STATUTORY MONETARY BENEFITS


MATERNITY
LEAVE
100% daily salary rate
for 60 days (normal)
or 78 days
(caesarean)
Conditions: SSS
member w/ 3 mo.
contributions,
reasonable notice to
employer and SSS, full
payment advanced by
employer w/n 30 days
from filing, first four
deliveries (or
miscarriages)

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

PATERNITY LEAVE

SOLO PARENTAL
LEAVE

7 calendar days
leave w/ full pay

7 working days leave w/


full pay

Conditions: married
male employee and
cohabiting with
legitimate wife, first
four deliveries,
reasonable notice to
employer

For solo parents or


individual w/ responsibility
of parenthood

Non-convertible

Conditions: 1 year service


(continuous or broken),
reasonable notice to
employer, Solo Parent
Identification Card
Non-convertible, NonCumulative

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

STATUTORY MONETARY BENEFITS


VAWC LEAVE

SPECIAL LEAVE FOR WOMEN

10-day leave w/ full pay, extendible via protection orders

VAWC: Violence against women and their children

Conditions: Certification of Pending Action/Case (either from


Barangay Officers, Prosecutor, or Clerk of Court)

Non-convertible, Non-cumulative

2 mos. leave w/ full pay: gross monthly

Surgery for gynecological disorders (involving female


reproductive organs)

Conditions: 6 mos. service, application w/ employer w/n


reasonable time, underwent above surgery certified by
competent physician

WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

Non-convertible, Non-cumulative

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

STATUTORY MONETARY BENEFITS


13TH MONTH PAY

SEPARATION PAY

Only for Rank & File


Employees who
worked at least 1 mo.

Authorized Causes +
In lieu of
reinstatement

Proportional
Minimum of 1/12 of
total basic salary
earned by employee
in 1 calendar year

For Nos. 1 to 3
authorized causes: 1
mo. pay or 1 mo.
pay / year of service

Basic salary: all


remunerations,
excluding allowances
and monetary
benefits not integral
WWW.LEGALASPECTS.P
H
Business Laws & Best Legal

RETIREMENT PAY
Retirement pay = Labor Code or
Higher (Daily Rate x 22.5 days x
Years of Service); 6 months = 1
year

For Nos. 4 to 6
authorized causes: 1
mo. pay or pay /
year of service

Retirement age: employment


contract, CBA, or company policy;
If none, optional at 60 yrs. old ,
mandatory at 65 yrs. old or 50
yrs. old for underground mining
employees, and minimum 5 years
of service

In both, whichever is
higher

Included: Workers paid by results


and part-time workers

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Statutory monetary
benefits are owing to the
employees.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO
For more information, contact:

JDP CONSULTING LTD. CO.


Call: (+632) 479-5405, Fax: (+632) 479-5401
Mobile: (+63) 917-622-0124
E-mail: info@jdpconsulting.ph
Website: www.jdpconsulting.ph

You may also want to visit:

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

DUE PROCESS
TERMINATION
For disciplining or terminating an employee

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Illegal dismissal is
employee termination
without due process.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO
Business Lawyer & Legal Consultant
JDP Consulting Ltd. Co.

Business Law Professor


San Beda Graduate School of Business

Book Author, Legal Aspects of Business


Central Books Publishing

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTING

www.jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What is

?
DUE PROCESS

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

DUE PROCESS
is the legal way to terminate an employee

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Due process
is divided into two:
Substantive Due Process

Procedural Due Process

Refers to the step-by-step process of dismissing an employee

Refers to the valid grounds for dismissing an employee

Ground for termination:


(1) Just causes; or
(2) Authorized Causes

Step-by-step procedure for just causes:

(1) 1st Written Notice


(2) Opportunity to be Heard
(3) 2nd Written Notice
+Dole Establishment Termination Report

Step-by-step procedure for authorized causes:

(1) 30-day notice to concerned employee


(2) DOLE Establishment Termination Report
(3) Separation Pay
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Substantive due process


is further divided into two:
Just Causes

Authorized Causes

Refers to termination grounds attributable to the employee:

(1) Serious misconduct or willful


disobedience by the
employee of the lawful orders of his
employers or
representative in connection with his work;
(2) Gross and habitual neglect by
duties;

the

employee of his

(3) Fraud or willful breach by the


employee of the trust
reposed in him by his employer or duly authorized
representative

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Refers to termination grounds which are not attributable to


the employee:
(1) Installation of labor-saving
(2) Redundancy;
(3) Retrenchment;
(4) Closure of establishment;
(5) Disease of an employee

devices;

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Substantive due process


is further divided into two:
Just Causes

Authorized Causes

Refers to termination grounds attributable to the employee:

Refers to termination grounds which are not attributable to


the employee:

(4) Commission of a crime or offense by the employee


against
the person of his employer or any immediate
member of his family or his duly authorized representatives;
and

(1) Installation of labor-saving

(5) Other causes analogous to


the foregoing (ex. loss
of trust and
confidence, gross inefficiency,
etc.)

(4) Closure of establishment;

(2) Redundancy;
(3) Retrenchment;

(5) Disease of an employee

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

devices;

JDP

Just Causes

Procedural due process

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Note: The above steps comply with the due


process requirements in relation to the
employee. For DOLE compliance, the
employer is required to submit a monthly
Establishment
Termination
Report
for
dismissed employees.

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

[Date]

CONSULTIN
G

Re: 1st Notice to Explain


Dear Mr. Michael S. Cruz;

1st Written
Notice

Sample 1: Written Explanation

Requirements:

An investigation is being conducted for your alleged


commission, participation, or involvement in the following
specific acts with the corresponding detailed narration of facts
and circumstances:
Specific Acts
(Charges)

Ground/s for disciplinary


action or termination
Reasonable opportunity to
be heard/explain, at least 5
calendar days
Detailed narration of facts
and circumstances as basis
for charge/s
Specific violations of
employment contract,
company rules and policies
and/or just causes
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Detailed Narration of
Facts and
Circumstances (Date,
Time, Place, etc.)

Applicable Provisions
Violated in
Employment Contract,
Company Rules &
Policies, Just Causes,
etc.

In the event that you are found responsible, these are


grounds for disciplinary actions, including termination. You are
hereby directed to submit you written explanation within five
(5) calendar days from receipt hereof. Failure to do so
constitutes waiver on your part resulting in the continuation
of the investigation.
For your compliance.

Ms. Anna D. Banal


Human Resource
If sent via registered mail with return card:
Registry Receipt Nos. _______, ________ Post Office
Private Courier O.R./Tracking No. ________________

Received:

Michael S. Cruz
Date: _________

JDP

[Date]

CONSULTIN
G

Re: 1st Notice to Explain with Suspension

1 Written
Notice
st

Sample 2: Written Explanation w/


Suspension
Requirements:

Ground/s for disciplinary


action or termination
Reasonable opportunity to
be heard/explain, at least 5
calendar days
Detailed narration of facts
and circumstances as basis
for charge/s
Specific violations of
employment contract,
company rules and policies
and/or just causes
Max Suspension: 30 days
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Dear Mr. Michael S. Cruz;


An investigation is being conducted for your alleged commission,
participation, or involvement in the following specific acts with
the corresponding detailed narration of facts and circumstances:
Specific Acts
(Charges)

Detailed Narration of
Facts and
Circumstances (Date,
Time, Place, etc.)

Applicable Provisions
Violated in
Employment Contract,
Company Rules &
Policies, Just Causes,
etc.

In the event that you are found responsible, these are grounds for
disciplinary actions, including termination. You are hereby
directed to submit you written explanation within five (5) calendar
days from receipt hereof. Failure to do so constitutes waiver on
your part resulting in the continuation of the investigation.
Meanwhile, you are placed on 30-day preventive
suspension effective immediately. You are directed to
report for work after the lapse of the period without
further notice.
For your compliance.

Ms. Anna D. Banal


Human Resource

Received:

Michael S. Cruz
Date: _________

If sent via registered mail with return card:


Registry Receipt Nos. _______, ________ Post Office
Private Courier O.R./Tracking No. ________________

JDP

[Date]

CONSULTIN
G

Re: 1st Notice to Explain

1st Written
Notice

Sample
3: Administrative Hearing
Requirements:

Ground/s for disciplinary


action or termination
Reasonable opportunity to
be heard/explain, at least 5
calendar days
Detailed narration of facts
and circumstances as basis
for charge/s
Specific violations of
employment contract,
company rules and policies
and/or just causes
Right to counsel in
hearing
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Dear Mr. Michael S. Cruz;


An investigation is being conducted for your alleged
commission, participation, or involvement in the following
specific acts with the corresponding detailed narration of facts
and circumstances:
Specific Acts
(Charges)

Detailed Narration of
Facts and
Circumstances (Date,
Time, Place, etc.)

Applicable Provisions
Violated in
Employment Contract,
Company Rules &
Policies, Just Causes,
etc.

In the event that you are found responsible, these are grounds
for disciplinary actions, including termination. You are
directed to appear for an administrative hearing on
________ at _________ (AM/PM), to be conducted in the
conference room. Failure to participate constitutes your
waiver resulting in the continuation of the investigation.
You may be assisted with counsel.
For your compliance.

Ms. Anna D. Banal


Human Resource

Received:

Michael S. Cruz
Date: _________

If sent via registered mail with return card:


Registry Receipt Nos. _______, ________ Post Office
Private Courier O.R./Tracking No. ________________

JDP

[Date]

CONSULTIN
G

Re: 1st Notice to Explain with Suspension

1 Written
Notice
st

Sample 4: Administrative Hearing w/


Requirements:
Suspension

Ground/s for disciplinary


action or termination
Reasonable opportunity to be
heard/explain, at least 5
calendar days
Detailed narration of facts and
circumstances as basis for
charge/s
Specific violations of
employment contract,
company rules and policies
and/or just causes
Right to counsel in hearing
Max Suspension: 30 days

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Dear Mr. Michael S. Cruz;


An investigation is being conducted for your alleged commission,
participation, or involvement in the following specific acts with the
corresponding detailed narration of facts and circumstances:
Specific Acts
(Charges)

Detailed Narration of
Facts and
Circumstances (Date,
Time, Place, etc.)

Applicable Provisions
Violated in
Employment Contract,
Company Rules &
Policies, Just Causes,
etc.

In the event that you are found responsible, these are grounds for
disciplinary actions, including termination. You are directed to
appear for an administrative hearing on ________ at _________
(AM/PM), to be conducted in the conference room. Failure to
participate constitutes your waiver resulting in the continuation of
the investigation. You may be assisted with counsel. Meanwhile,
you are placed on 30-day preventive suspension effective
immediately. You are directed to report for work after the
lapse of the period without further notice.
For your compliance.

Ms. Anna D. Banal


Human Resource

Received:

Michael S. Cruz
Date: _________

If sent via registered mail with return card:


Registry Receipt Nos. _______, ________ Post Office
Private Courier O.R./Tracking No. ________________

JDP

Opportunity to be heard
may either be through
Written Explanation

In case of a written explanation by the employee, the letter


will suffice to comply with rule on opportunity to be heard.

In labor law, the essence of due process lies simply in an


opportunity to be heard, and not that an actual hearing
should always and indispensably be held.

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

Administrative Hearing

If a hearing is scheduled, the employee may be assisted with


counsel.
The employee and his/her counsel should be given the
opportunity to respond to the charge, present their evidence,
or rebut the evidence presented against them.

See: Metropolitan Bank and Trust Company v. Barrientos, G.R. No. 157028, 31 January 2006;
Philippine Pasay Chung Hua Academy v. Edpan, G.R. No. 168876, 10 February 2009.

JDP

[Date]

CONSULTIN
G

Re: 2nd Notice, Management Decision


Dear Mr. Michael S. Cruz;

2 Written
Notice
nd

We hereby inform you that, upon due consideration of all the


circumstances, sufficient grounds have been established to
impose the following disciplinary actions against you:

Sample 1: Management Decision

Requirements:
Ground/s for disciplinary
action or termination
Detailed narration of
findings and evidence/basis
Specific violations of
employment contract,
company rules and policies
and/or just causes
Disciplinary actions for
violations, including
termination
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Specific Acts
(Charges)

Detailed Narration of
Findings and
Evidence/Basis

Disciplinary Actions
for Violations

The disciplinary actions imposed are effective immediately.


You are hereby directed to personally report and coordinate
with the office regarding their implementation, as well as any
process that you may be required to undertake.
For your compliance.

Ms. Anna D. Banal


Human Resource
If sent via registered mail with return card:
Registry Receipt Nos. _______, ________ Post Office
Private Courier O.R./Tracking No. ________________

Received:

Michael S. Cruz
Date: _________

JDP

Authorized Causes

Procedural due process

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

What if

DUE PROCESS
is not followed?

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Failure to observe

DUE PROCESS
results in

ILLEGAL DISMISSAL
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

Illegal dismissal
What are the consequences?
Full backwages

Reinstatement

Damages

Inclusive of
allowances, and
benefits or their
monetary equivalent
computed from time
withheld up to time
of actual
reinstatement

Without loss of
seniority rights and
other privileges

Moral damages

If employer appeals
reinstatement, payroll
reinstatement is
allowed

Nominal damages

If employer appeals
reinstatement,
computation is until
finality of decision

Separation pay in lieu


of reinstatement if
doctrine of strained
relation applies

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Exemplary damages
Attorneys Fees
Joint and solidary
liability of manager
with employer, if
warranted

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

What happens if only one of the due


process is followed?
Illegal Dismissal

Illegal Dismissal

Valid Dismissal

No substantive due
process, no
procedural due
process

No substantive due
process, with
procedural due
process

With substantive
due process, no
procedural due
process

Employer is liable for


full backwages,
reinstatement, and if
applicable, for
damages with
attorneys fees.

Employer is liable for


full backwages,
reinstatement, and if
applicable, for
damages with
attorneys fees.

While dismissal is
valid, employer is
liable for nominal
damages. (Agabon
doctrine)

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Due process termination


protects the employer
from illegal dismissal.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO
Business Lawyer & Legal Consultant
JDP Consulting Ltd. Co.
Business Law Professor
San Beda Graduate School of Business
Book Author, Legal Aspects of Business
Central Books Publishing

You may also want to visit:

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

BEST LEGAL
PRACTICES
For Human Resource in relation to Labor Law

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

BULLET PROOF THE


WORKPLACE AGAINST
LABOR COMPLAINTS.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO
Business Lawyer & Legal Consultant
JDP Consulting Ltd. Co.

Business Law Professor


San Beda Graduate School of Business

Book Author, Legal Aspects of Business


Central Books Publishing

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTING

www.jdpconsulting.ph

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

How?
By observing

Best Legal Practices

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Best Legal Practices


are based on
Labor Laws
1987 Constitution
Labor Code
Omnibus Rules
Implementing the Labor
Code
Special Laws: Minimum
Wage, 13th Month Pay,
Migrant Workers and
Overseas Act of 1995,
Nightwork, Parental Leave,
Leave for Victims of VAWC,
Retirement, etc.
DOLE Advisories, etc.

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Jurisprudence
Totality of infractions
doctrine
Doctrine of strained
relations
Agabon doctrine
Brent doctrine
Globe doctrine
In pari delicto doctrine
Doctrine of necessary
implication
24-hour duty doctrine
Etc.

Best Practices
Industry-wide specific best
practices which comply
with labor laws
International labor
standards prescribed by
the International Labor
Organizations (ILO)

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Why learn best legal practices?


There are two primary reasons why:
To prevent lawsuits

To avoid liabilities

Monetary awards

Labor complaints for illegal dismissal, monetary claims, etc.

Administrative cases with DOLE for non-compliance with


labor law

Moral damages, exemplary damages, nominal damages,


attorneys fees

Criminal complaints for violations of labor laws, such as


paying below minimum wage, unfair labor practices, etc.

Joint and solidary liability of a manager and the company

DOLE administrative fines

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

Imprisonment

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

Now let us learn these

Best Legal Practices


for
Human Resource in relation to Labor Law

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

1. Require signed rsum or


curriculum vitae
Ensures that the rsum was prepared and/or it came
from the applicant
Protects the employer from any denial later on by the
employee
May be used in evidence in case of misrepresentation

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

2. Complete company form


Provides employer the opportunity to obtain additional
information which may not be in the rsum
Allows employer to get written consent for background check,
and avoid any liability as a result thereof (ex. action for damages
if current employment is compromised)
Gives the employer the opportunity to obtain written consent for
other matters, such as parental consent in case of minors
Protects and safeguards the employer with an attestation clause
signed by the employee who made all the representations and
declarations therein, especially important for job positions
requiring a license, specialized knowledge, certified training, etc.
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

3. Background check
Verifies information provided in the rsum, from educational
background to work experiences
Forewarns any red flag in an applicant (ex. comments from previous
employer/manager on performance and character)
Alerts the employer of any pending or ongoing cases, such as
criminal, civil, labor, or administrative
Do note: Once the employee is hired, the employer is placed on the
defensive when it comes to labor cases. Regardless of whether
employees have any basis/ground, they have the right to file a labor
complaint. Thus, background checking is an important safeguard.
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

4. Regularly re-evaluate
employment contracts
Employment contracts are the 1st line of defense.
Clearly state therein the status of employment (ex. regular, project,
fixed-term, etc.) salaries, benefits, and other terms and conditions
Ensure that employment contracts incorporate by reference the
terms and conditions in the company policies
Keep templates of employment contracts so they are readily
accessible, in particular have samples for each varying employment
status
Explain the terms and conditions of employment to ensure that the
prospective employees understand and consent thereto, especially
on matters concerning Intellectual Property
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

5. Update company policies


Company policies are the 2nd line of defense.
Update company policies to comply with changes in labor
laws, rules and regulations, jurisprudence
Ensure that the employees learn of any changes by posting it
Obtain written acknowledgment and consent, if practicable

Provide employees with opportunity to read the changes


Do note: Company policies should have rules concerning - (a)
drug-free work environment, (b) tuberculosis, (c) hepatitis B,
(d) HIV-AIDS, and (e) sexual harassment.
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

6. Train Human Resource Staff


Avoid losing to labor cases due to lack of knowledge and
skills in labor law by the employer or human resource
manager/staff
Regularly train human resource staff on company
policies and procedures, in particular conduct written
tests and make the results part of their performance
reviews
Observe proper turn over whenever a human resource
manager or staff moves due to promotion, lateral
transfer, or resignation especially if there are ongoing
labor cases
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

JDP

7. Observe proper documentation


and safekeeping of employee files
Burden is on the employer to prove: (a) that dismissal was valid,
(b) that monetary claims were paid, (c) that resignation was
voluntary, and (d) that the employees abandoned their work, etc.
All of these rely on documentary evidence. Without
documentation, the employer stands to lose a labor case.
Make digital copies of 201 files by scanning them or
computerizing the system
Backup files to cloud services (ex. Amazon, Google, Microsoft,
etc.)
Send scanned files to office e-mail for future reference
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

8. Design a flowchart for disciplinary


actions
Lays down the process or procedure to guide both the
employer/manager and the employee
Avoids missing or skipping a process required by law (cf.
procedural due process)
Informs everyone of their rights and obligations, in
particular the employees right to have counsel in
administrative hearings
Easy and accessible reference for human resource staff
in-charge of disciplinary actions
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

9. Keep and use templates for 1st


and 2nd written notices, etc.
Avoids drafting and using legal forms which do not comply
with the requirements prescribed by the law
Prevents staff from deleting important clauses
Supports defense or claims by the employers/managers
Easily and readily accessible whenever necessary

Templates: 1st and 2nd written notices, affidavits of service,


employees written explanation, resignation letter, RWQ
(release, waiver, and quitclaim), etc.
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

10. Document process for


disciplinary actions or termination
Avoid losing to a labor case due to lack of
documentation
Prevent being subjected to a huge monetary award (ex.
full backwages) as a result of improper and poor record
keeping
Protect the company and professional managers from
liability, in particular from solidary and personal liability
of managers with the employers/company

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

11. Observe proper conduct before


SENA Officer and Labor Arbitrator
Avoid being the receiving end of an irked and irritated
Labor Arbiter who is empowered and authorized to
grant monetary awards, moral damages, exemplary
damages, nominal damages, and attorneys fees
With the proper approach, the SENA Officer and Labor
Arbiter may be instrumental in reaching an amicable
settlement.
Be nice.
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

12. Be very careful in making


company notices or press releases
To protect the morale of the workforce, the employer
may find it important to issue a statement through
company notices or press releases of an ongoing labor
case. Be very careful in doing so.
If not warranted, do not issue any statement.
If warranted:
Avoid libelous or slanderous remarks or statements
Do not give the other party a leverage that they may
use
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

13. Consider and evaluate all factors


when making a settlement
Assess both the legal and economic costs of continuing
with a labor complaint (ex. full backwages in case of
illegal dismissal)
Determine whether sufficient documentary evidence is
available
Objectively weigh and evaluate the merits of both sides
If settlement is much lower than costs of litigating, the
employer or concerned manager can learn from it and
adapt new measures to avoid similar situations. As they
say, charge it to experience.
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

14. Execute and have the


compromise agreement notarized
Converts the written agreement to a public document
Adds more evidentiary weight to the compromise agreement in
case it is questioned or denied later on
May be used as a bargaining tool (ex. perjury, falsification, etc.)
In an ongoing case, the compromise agreement may be
subscribed and sworn to before the Labor Arbiter.
It is best to use your own legal form for compromise agreement.
Have supervisors or managers sign as witnesses to the
settlement whenever practicable.
www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal
Practices

CONSULTIN
G

JDP

CONSULTIN
G

PREVENTION IS BETTER
THAN (AN EXPENSIVE)
CURE.
- ATTY. JERICHO B. DEL PUERTO
Business Lawyer & Legal Consultant
JDP Consulting Ltd. Co.
Business Law Professor
San Beda Graduate School of Business
Book Author, Legal Aspects of Business
Central Books Publishing

You may also want to visit:

www.legalaspects.ph
Business Laws & Best Legal Practices

2015, Atty. Jericho B. del Puerto. All rights reserved. For permissions to use this material, send a request to this e-mail address: info@jdpconsulting.ph

You might also like