Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RESEARCH METHOD
METHODOLOGY COURSE, BM07
PREPARE
PLAN
DESIGN
COLLECT
SHARE
ANALYZE
WHEN TO USE?
How and Why research questions
Researcher has little control over events
Focus is on contemporary phenomenon within
real-life context
CRITICISM
Rigor of case study research
Little basis for scientific generalization
Too long, result in massive, unreadable
documents
Cant directly address causal relationships
DEFINITION
(R.YIN, 2009, Case Study Research, 4th Ed., SAGE. p.18)
NUMBER OF CASES
Single vs. Multiple
Comparative case method (distinctive form of
multiple case study)
DESIGN
PREPARE
PLAN
DESIGN
COLLECT
SHARE
ANALYZE
CONSTRUCT VALIDITY
Problem:
Operational set of measures: objectivity vs. subjectivity
Tactics:
Use multiple sources of evidence
Establish chain of evidence
Have key informants review draft case study report
INTERNAL VALIDITY
Problem:
Mainly a concern for explanatory case studies
Making inferences in a case study
Tactics:
Do pattern matching
Do explanation building
Address rival explanation
Use logic model
EXTERNAL VALIDITY
Problem:
Is this study generalizable? This is a major concern in
case studies!
Tactics:
Use theory in single-case studies
Use replication logic in multiple-case studies
RELIABILITY
Problem:
To minimize errors and biases in a study
Tactics:
Use case study protocol
Develop case study database
PREPARE
PLAN
DESIGN
COLLECT
SHARE
ANALYZE
DESIRED SKILLS
Ask good questions
Be a good listener
Be adaptive and flexible
Have a firm grasp of the issues being studied
Be unbiased by preconceived notions
PROTOCOL OF INVESTIGATION
Major way to increase the reliability of case study
Guides the investigator in the data collection
General content of a case study protocol:
an overview of the project
field procedures
case study questions
a guide for case study report
PREPARE
PLAN
DESIGN
COLLECT
SHARE
ANALYZE
SOURCES OF EVIDENCE
Documentation
Archival records
Interviews
Direct observation
Participant observation
Physical artefacts
DOCUMENTATION
Strengths:
Stable, unobtrusive, exact, broad coverage
Weaknesses:
Retrievability, biased selectivity, reporting bias, and
access
ARCHIVAL RECORDS
Strengths:
Same as for documents
Precise and usually quantitative
Weaknesses:
Same as for documents
Accessibility due to privacy reasons
Often take a form of computer files and records
E.g., organizational records (budget or personnel records)
Usefulness of archival records vary: from essential to passive
relevance
INTERVIEWS
Strengths:
Targeted, insightful
Weaknesses:
Bias due to poorly articulated questions
Response bias
Inaccuracies due to poor recall
Reflexivity
DIRECT OBSERVATIONS
Strengths:
Reality, contextual
Weaknesses:
Time-consuming, selectivity, reflexivity, and cost
PARTICIPANT OBSERVATION
Strengths:
Same as for direct observation
Insightful into interpersonal behavior and motives
Weaknesses:
Same as for direct observation
Bias due to participant-observers manipulation of events
PHYSICAL ARTEFACTS
Strengths:
Insightful into cultural features and technical operations
Weaknesses:
Selectivity and availability
ANALYSIS
PREPARE
PLAN
DESIGN
COLLECT
SHARE
ANALYZE
GENERAL STRATEGIES
Relying on theoretical propositions
Developing a case description
Using both qualitative and quantitative data
Examining rival explanations
1. PATTERN MATCHING
Compare an empirically based pattern with a
predicted one
Can help to strengthen the internal validity
A pattern might be related to the variables of the
study
Example of pattern analysis
2. EXPLANATION BUILDING
Analysis of a case study by building an
explanation about the case
Mainly relevant to explanatory case studies
Explanation building occurs most often in a
narrative form
Reflect theoretically significant propositions
Iterative nature of explanation building
Potential problems with explanation building
3. TIME-SERIES ANALYSIS
The ability to trace changes over time is a
strength of case studies
Single dependent or independent variable
Statistical tests are used
Complex time series analysis
Chronologies
4. LOGIC MODELS
The model stipulates a complex chain of events
over an extended period of time
Repeated cause-effect-cause-effect patterns
Can be considered as a form of pattern matching
Matching empirically observed events to
theoretically predicted events
PREPARE
PLAN
DESIGN
COLLECT
SHARE
ANALYZE
ISSUES IN REPORTING
There is no any stereotypic form
Targeting case study reports
Structures for case study reports:
REFERENCES
R. Yin, 2009, Case Study Research: design and
methods, 4th Ed., SAGE.