Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A BRIEF HISTORY
OF GEOSCIENCES
Pre- Geology Concepts on
the Theory of the Earth
PERIODS of THOUGHTS
Pre-Classic Period
Classic Period (Greeks)
Arabic (Islamic) Period
Pre-Renaissance Period
Renaissance Period
Modern Period
PRE-CLASSIC PERIOD
Generally related to primitive and religious
DEMOCRITUS VS ARISTOTLE
Atomist vs Aristotelians
Democritus
LINGERING ARISTOTELIANS VS
ATOMISTS CONTROVERSIES
ARISTOTELES NATURAL
PHILOSOPHY
1.
Fire
Earth
Water
Wind
2.
3.
4.
The Four
Elements
of the
Earth
(Museum
Geologi
Bandung)
THEOPHRASTUS BOOK OF
STONES
Arabic/Islamic Period
PRE-RENNAISSANCE PERIOD
GEOLOGIC PRINCIPLES
ESTABLISHED PRE-RENNAISSANCE
Superposition
Lateral Continuity
Original Horizontality
Strata
Original Horizontality of Strata
Collorary: Vertical Accumulation of
Strata
1
LAW OF SUPERPOSITION
(STENO, 1669)
Modified statement:
Law of Superposition:
The youngest strata are at top in an
undisturbed sequence (Anthony,
1955, p. 83
2
HORIZONTAL LATERAL
CONTINUITY
(Steno, 1669)
Modified statement:
Law of Original Continuity:
The original continuity of water-laid sedimentary
strata is terminated only by pinching out against
the basin of deposition, at the time of their
deposition.
(Anthony, loc.op.cit, p.83)
3
ORIGINAL HORIZONTALITY
(STENO, 1669)
Statement of Principle: Dipping beds were once
horizontal (Woodford, 1935, p.3)
Modified Statement: Law of horizontality:
Sedimentary strata are laid down nearly
horizontally and essentially parallel to the
surface upon which they accumulate. (Anthony,
loc op cit., p.83)
RENNAISSANCE PERIOD
Rationalism:
Bouffons Theory of Cosmogeny
Werners Geognosy: Doctrine of Geological
Succession
Empiricism: (Francis Bacon, Newton)
Huttons
Theory
of
the
Earth:
Uniformintarianism
Descartes Minerals Map
Strachey and W.Smith: Fossil Identification of
Strata
Soulavie: Principle of Faunal Succession
evolution
EMPIRICISM VS RATIONALISM
Rationalism:
based
intuition
or
rationalization of previous theories , using
deduction to explain a natural phenomenon
Empiricism:
based
entirely
on
observations of natural phenomena or
laboratory experiments and an explanation
is induced solely from observation
Scientists vs Scholars
BUFFONS COSMOGENY
Werners Geognosy:
Doctrine of Geological Succession
Earth
UNIFORMITARIANISM (HUTTON,
1785)
Statement of principle: Amid all the revolutions of
the globe, the economy of nature has been
uniform ... and her laws are the only things that
have resisted the general movement. The rivers and
the rocks, the seas and the continents have been
changed in all their parts; but the laws which direct
these changes, and the rules to which they are
subject, have remained invariably the same.
(Playfair, Illustrations of Huttonian Theory of the
Earth, 1802, p.421, quoted by Woodford, op.cit.,
p.6).
Modified Statement:
to the past.
GEOLOGICAL
GEOLOGICAL CYCLES
CYCLES VS
VS
GEOLOGICAL
GEOLOGICAL SUCCESSION
SUCCESSION
James
James Hutton
Hutton proposed
proposed cyclic
cyclic geological
geological
processes,
processes, based
based on
on unconformities
unconformities
present
present day
day processes
processes were
were repeated
repeated in
in
the
the past
past
Werner:
Werner: Geologic
Geologic history
history consists
consists aa
succession
succession of
of geological
geological processes,
processes,
based
based on
on mineralogy
mineralogy
UNIFORMITARIANISM VS CATASTROPHISM
James Hutton (Scotland): vs Cuvier,
Lyell (1797-1875) Gradualism vs Actualism
EVOLUTION VS CATASTROPHISM
Lamarck (1744-1829) Evolution by Adaptation
Cuvier (1769-1832): Catastrophism: New Creation after Extinction
Darwin: Evolution by Mutation and Natural Selection
PLUTONISM VS NEPTUNISM
The Granite Problem