Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OnlineJFS and
Oracle ASM Basics*
Dusan Baljevic
Sydney, Australia
2009
File System
Swap Space
File System
Raw Space
Boot Area
File System
Swap
Swap
Physical
Volume
Physical
Volume
Volume
Group
Logical Volumes
6
Logical Volume
Manager (LVM)
MirrorDiskUX
(MDUX)
Veritas Volume
Manager (VxVM)
Cluster Volume
Manager (CVM)
Included
in VSE,
HA, and
DCOE
Include
Base File System
d in
(VxFS-lite)
Base
OE
Include
MirrorDiskUX
d in
(MDUX)
VSE,
HA,
and
Cluster File
DCOE
System (CFS)
HP-UX 11.23
3.5
4.1
HP-UX 11.31
5.0
4.1
5.0
5.0.1 Sep
2009
Base Products
Base-VxFS
Base-VxVM
Base-VxVM Base-VxVM
Base-VxFS5.0
BaseBaseBase-VxVM
VxVM-50
VxVM-5.0
BaseVxVM-5.0
Standalone Products
Online-JFS
B3929DA
B3929EA
B3929FA
B3929EA
B3929FB
B3929FB
VxVM-FULL
B9116AA
B9116BA
B9116CA
B9116BA
B9116CB
B9116CB
Scalability:
LVM
LVM
HP-UX 11i
v1/v2
Current L1
Limits
Update 3
enhancement
Supported
maximums
HP-UX 11i v3 (L2 Layout Limits)
On Disk L2 Limits
Code L2 Limits
Arch
Impl
Arch
Impl
Tested
Max LV size
(64TB) 16TB
284
284
16EB
264
256TB
Max PV size
241 (2TB)
264
264
264
264
16TB
Max Volume
Groups (VG)
256
N/A
N/A
211
2304*
Max Logical
Volumes
(LV)
255
211-1
2047
Max
Physical
Volumes
(PV)
2047
224-1
232-1
232-1
255
232-1
232 -1
232-1
232-1
Max
number of
mirrors
254
254
Max Nodes
for
mirroring
N/A
N/A
N/A
16
16
Max
number of
Extents/VG
216 (64K)
264
264
264
264
225
HP-UX 11.31
LVM, MD/UX
VxVM 4.1/5.0
Y3
RAID0
RAID1
Y
MD/UX
Y
FULL license4
MD/UX
MD/UX
FULL license
FULL license
16EB (256TB)2
32TB
2048 (511) 2
Unlimited
2304 (768) 2
Unlimited
Y
SLVM
Y
FULL license5 + CVM5
MD/UX
Y(SLVM)
Y
Y
6
Y
ALL
Limited6
Limited
Limited6
Rootability
Online Volume Reconfiguration
Fast Resync
Cluster Aware
Static Path Failover (A/P)
Dynamic Path Load balancing (A/A)
# Mirrors
Dynamic Root Disk (DRD)
HP Storage Device Support
3rd Party Storage Support
Instant Snapshots
Portable Data Containers
Multi-volume File System
support
Dynamic Storage Tiering
support
Dynamic LUN expansion
Extended Campus,
Metrocluster, and
Continental cluster
integration
Disk group configuration
from any node
Number Of Nodes
Storage Distance Support
(standard/Metrocluster)
HP-UX 11.31
LVM, MD/UX
VxVM 4.1/5.0
N
N
FULL license
FULL license1
FULL license
FULL license
Y
Y
Y
Y
16
100 km /
100 km /
300 km
300 km
Rolling Upgrade
Y
Y3
RAID 5
N
FULL License
Cluster lock support
Y (disk, lun)
N
Hot Relocation
N
Y
1 VxVM 5.0 Only
3 As long as no functional or protocol changes (y within 3.x, n between 3.x = 4.x)
Heterogeneous platforms
Same
AIX, Solaris, Linux, Windows
2 AIX and Solaris have similar cluster solution
4 Not supported for all configurations
commands
HP-UX 11i v1
HP-UX 11i v2
HP-UX 11i v3
N/A
16TB
50TB
1024
N/A
N/A
2TB
16TB
32TB
32TB
N/A
N/A
2TB
2TB
2TB
32TB
VxVM volume
32TB
32TB
32 TB
LVM
10.x,11.x,11i 10.x,11.x,11i
Yes
Yes
sam, smh
sam, smh
VxVM
11i
Yes
vea
Similar
Similar
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
No
No
Yes
Yes*
Yes
Yes*
No
No
Yes
Yes*
Yes
Yes*
No
Yes*
Yes*
RAID 5 supported?
No
No
No
No
Yes*
No
Yes*
Active/PassiveActive/Active*
16
Product-use application
Volume Management
Logical Volume Manager (LVM)
If you need:
No-cost solution
Basic Volume
Management-default
Operating Environment
install
Simple operation
SAN boot
Disk-mirroring
capability with
MirrorDisk/UX
17
VxVM
If you need:
Advanced Volume
Management solution
Instant Snapshots
Cross-platform data
sharing
QoSS support
Raid 5
Hot
Relocate/Unrelocate
CFS support
Product-use application
File Systems
VxFS Lite
If you need:
18
Online
defragmentation
Online log and
file system
resizing
Oracle Database
Management
Concurrent I/O
performance*
File change log
Storage
Checkpoints
Functionality for
aclustered
environment
Cluster Volume
Manager
Dynamic Storage
Tiers
Flashsnap
technology
19
9/11/15
21
26
28
29
36
38
39
41
Capability compare
Business Benefit
Product
Vendor
(s)
HP
HP
HP
HP
Oracle
42
OnlineJFS+LVM/
MirrorDisk/UX
(Single
Instance only)
OnlineJFS+VxV
M/ODM Storage
Management
for Oracle
(Single
Instance only)
Cluster file
system(both
RAC & Single
Instance)
No file system
raw volumes
(RAC ONLY)
Automatic
Storage
Management
(RAC & SI)
Oracle
executable
and nondatabase
files
Multipathing
capability
Strong I/O
fencing
Singleinstance
Database
object
storage
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
no
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
no
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
RAC
Near raw
Database
database
object
performanc
storage
e
No
No
Yes
No*
No
Yes
YES it is
raw volume
No
No
(limited)
No
Yes
Yes
Vendor
HP
HP
HP
HP
43
Ease of
Ability to use
managemen
standard
t (e.g.,
UNIX
Proven,
All disaster- backup and
commands time-tested
recovery
database
to move or quality and needs can maintenance
Product(s) copy data reliability
be met
)
OnlineJFS+LVM/M
irrorDisk/UX
(Single Instance
only)
Yes
Yes
Yes
y
OnlineJFS+VxVM/
ODM (Storage
Management for
Oracle)(Single
Instance only)
Yes
Yes
Yes
y
Cluster file
system(both RAC
& Single
Instance)
y
y
No file system
raw volumes
(RAC ONLY)
n
y
y
n
Automatic
Storage
* Currently this is offered through the purchase of a Storage Management Suite bundle