This document discusses different types of non-experimental research designs that can be used in nursing research, including basic or library research, applied or action research, descriptive designs (such as surveys, correlational studies, comparative studies, and case studies), and longitudinal designs. Some key points covered include how basic research involves literature review while applied research seeks to solve practical problems, and how descriptive designs describe characteristics and relationships while longitudinal designs study variables over time.
Original Description:
PHASE 2:DESIGN AND PLANNING PHASE NON-EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH
This document discusses different types of non-experimental research designs that can be used in nursing research, including basic or library research, applied or action research, descriptive designs (such as surveys, correlational studies, comparative studies, and case studies), and longitudinal designs. Some key points covered include how basic research involves literature review while applied research seeks to solve practical problems, and how descriptive designs describe characteristics and relationships while longitudinal designs study variables over time.
This document discusses different types of non-experimental research designs that can be used in nursing research, including basic or library research, applied or action research, descriptive designs (such as surveys, correlational studies, comparative studies, and case studies), and longitudinal designs. Some key points covered include how basic research involves literature review while applied research seeks to solve practical problems, and how descriptive designs describe characteristics and relationships while longitudinal designs study variables over time.
PHASE NON-EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH B. Non-experimental research A. BASIC OR LIBRARY RESEARCH B. APPLIED OR ACTION RESEARCH 1. Basic or Library Research
This is intended to increase knowledge in science for the purpose of knowing and learning the truth. It is also called pure research for purposes of generating new knowledge for knowledge sake.
Basic research includes: 1. Reading books and literatures. 2. Listening to discussions 3. Journal analysis 4. Browsing articles from the internet and website. 5. Teleconferencing
2. Applied research/action research It is a scientific investigation conducted to generate knowledge that will directly influence or improve clinical purposes. This can provide evidence-based data since its findings seeks solutions to immediate problems that have been identified by the clients and the nurse in the actual setting.
Findings of action research can also help in making decisions or predict and control outcomes in real- life practice.
Types of Applied Research A. HISTORICAL DESIGN B. DESCRIPTIVE DESIGN 1. Historical Design A critical investigation and analysis of events, developments and experiences of the past. It describes past events in relation to the present situations and then analyzes and interprets the implications of past events to present trends or practices. Example: The evolution of nursing practice from the time of Florence Nightingale to the present century.
2. Descriptive design A study that describes the nature of the phenomenon under investigation after a survey of current trends, practices and conditions that relate to that phenomenon. Descriptive studies involve analysis of an extremely broad range of phenomena, the result of such analysis are a comprehensive presentation and interpretation of statistical tabulations of data yielded by a survey.
Types of DESCRIPTIVE DESIGN
1. Descriptive Normative 7. Case study surveys 2. Correlational 8. Content analysis 3. Comparative 9. Feasibility study 4. Descriptive Evaluative 10. Cross-sectional Methodological studies study
It is a self-reported data which are collected from samples for purposes of exploring and describing real-life situations. It provides an accurate account of the characteristics of that particular situation, individuals or groups in a population. Surveys are done thru phone, mail, or personal contact with subjects. Data collection is mostly done thru questionnaires and interviews. 2. Correlational studies This examines the extent of relationship between variables by determining how changes in one variable relate to changes in another variable. This is also called Explanatory research this explains why something happened.
Example: How is X related to Y? As X increases, does Y also increase?
Correlation coefficient This data determines the extent and direction of the relationship between 2 variables conducted through + or correlation using a range of 1.00 (perfect negative correlation to 1.00 (perfect positive correlation). A correlation of 0.0 indicates the nonexistence of a relationship between variables.
Positive or direct relationship means that as the value of one variable increase, the value of the other variable also increases. Negative relationship or inverse relationship indicates that as the value of one variable increases, the value of the other variable decreases.
Example: Is there any correlation between anxiety and nurse licensure exams among baccalaureate nursing graduates? Correlation: As anxiety is higher, the scores in the licensure exam is lower (negative relationship). As anxiety gets lower, the scores in the licensure exam is also lower (positive relationship). 3. Comparative studies This examines 2 or more intact groups to find out the difference in their performance between and among them in certain dependent variables of interest. There is no manipulation of independent variables because characteristics of the subjects are inherent such as personality type, educational level and medical condition.
Example: A study between College X and College Y nursing graduates class 2010 and their performance in nursing licensure examination. This study is comparative and correlational as regards to X and Y groups performance on the dependent variable which is board examination rating. COMPARATIVE STUDY IS ALSO APPLICABLE TO: A. Descriptive study Example: Is there any significant difference in readiness to learn about pre-operative teaching between pre-op patients who have high anxiety levels, compared to pre-op patients who have low anxiety levels? B. Experimental Study Example: Is there any significant difference in the pre-op anxiety levels of patients who were exposed to relaxation techniques (experimental group) and those who were not exposed to these techniques ( control group). 4. DESCRIPTIVE EVALUATIVE SURVEYS /METHODOLOGICAL STUDIES These studies are concerned with the development, testing and evaluation of methods, procedures, guidelines and instruments after which an evaluative judgment is done. This is also used to revise, modify existing programs or develop more effective programs, methods and procedures in nursing for more efficient and effective delivery of health care. Example: This study aims to test the viability, quality or effectiveness of a product, program, method or procedure and answer specific questions such as: a. Training programs for new graduate nurses and their Clinical Proficiency. b. Community Health Programs and the incidence of Dengue Fever in Sampaloc, Manila 5. PROBLEM-SOLVING All researches are investigations leading to the solutions of a problem The researchers make assessments of needs and problems and generates alternative solutions to problems. The objective is to improve specific problem situations derived from reliable and accurate data. Example: 1. How much nursing care does a particular patient need? 2. How often is it necessary to take vital signs of a patient in labor? 3. How can a nurse make the patient feel satisfied with nursing care given to him? 6. DECISION-MAKING This study selects the most feasible course of action from given alternatives to solve the problem It is useful in policy making and in improving the image of nursing as a profession. Examples: a. Should salaries paid to nurses be increased? b. Is the 12-hour work shift more effective than the 8- hour shift in solving staffing patterns? 7. CASE STUDY This is an in-depth study of a single case or limited number of typical, interconnected cases intended to interpret their behavior relative to the occurrence of certain events or phenomenon of interest to the nursing disciplines. Example: A case study of a patient with problems of oxygenation (COPD). It is done to analyze the medical, and personal- social history of the patient in relation to the pathophysiology of the disease process and appropriate nursing interventions of the same case. 8. CONTENT ANALYSIS This is the process of synthesizing or dissecting information and messages embodied in documents. Information and messages are clustered to determine the ideals and standards of professional nursing practice. Example: The Practical Implementations of Phil Nursing Law (RA 9173 of 2002) provisions for Nursing Education and Nursing Service. 9. FEASIBILITY STUDY This study is conducted to determine the viability of an undertaking or a business venture and establishing an institution or constructing infrastructure. Example: A. A feasibility study on Nursing Entrepreneurship in the Philippines Setting. B. Credentialing of nurse clinicians and its impact to the nursing profession and the society. 10. CROSS-SECTIONAL DESIGNS This study will assess the subjects at a single time in their lives. It is fast and can be done at one time with a large number of patients at little cost or effort. The researcher does not have to worry about patients dropping out during the course of the study.
CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDIES cont. This study is efficient at identifying association of relationships, but may have trouble in deciding cause and effect. It provides a snapshot of the variables of the study at one particular time. It may reveal these variables are represented in a cross- section of a population. It generally uses survey techniques to gather data. 11. LONGITUDINAL DESIGNS These studies collect data overlong periods of time. Measurements are taken on each variable over 2 or more distinct time periods. This allows the researcher to measure change variables over time. TYPES OF LONGITUDINAL DESIGNS 1. Trend studies investigates samples from a population are studied over time with respect to some phenomenon of interest to the researcher. Example: Studies on maternal compliance to breastfeeding and newborn screening as health care policy. 2. PANEL DESIGNS This study collects repeated measurements from the same people or subjects over time. It reveals changes at the individual level. Example: Repeated measurements and analysis of variations in health services and practices, causes and effects. 3. FOLLOW-UP STUDIES They are usually undertaken to determine the subsequent status of subjects with a specified condition or those who received a specified intervention. Example: Follow-up on post-natal health care activities and complications arising. (contrceptive method of BTL tying method)