Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Object knowledge trich: state of empirical certainty, skeptical doubt may exist but only in an expansive way. Colour knowledge (Jonston1992, Hellie2005) Higher than empirical certainty. Introspection (cartesian certainty), as she need not that the object actually is the colour it seems to be or even that the object is a fruit or that the fruit exists. Innate representational scheme of colours/quasi analytic Unexperienced colours Even chromatically deprived people were capable of raising up (Hume) Knowledge about colours that one has never encountered must be a priori (Crane & Pinatanida1983) Object appearance knowledge That looks orange. Lack of empirical certainty but there is cartesian certainty. Since one cannot have Cartesian certainty of what objects looks like even after viewing them, the source of ones certainty regarding the colour orange must be different.
Dispositionalism Disposition in things to evoke in normal perceivers a certain type of sensation in normal circumstances. Trichs experience fails to give her empirical certianty about experiences of others. Too great a gap b/w sensation and colour Relationalism (Brian Mclaughlin 2003 & Jonathan Cohen 2004) Intuitive weakness
Light of 600nm : orange. Orange experience is 600nm??? Can trich be certain in virtue of her own experience that the productances are related by these relations of relative similarity?? Red is similar to violet , since both are reddish, than either is to saturated green. Yet as far as wavelengths, green is in between red and violet.
Projective symbols Red projective: using a property of the symbol to refer to the object it denotes. Knowledge of empirical information and the denotational system are required. Projective symbols and colour experience Knowledge of denotative scheme is innate. In any compositional language, there is a possibilty of impossible compounds squarecircle.
PLURALISTIC REALISM
Secondary colour similarities (SCS) (Relationalism, Dispositionalism) Real world realisation (productances), of the organisms similarity relations. Primary colour similarity (PCS) Similarity for conditioning defines colour similarity from an organisms point of view. PLURALISTIC REALISM :PCS & SCS varies across species THIS POSITION ALLOWS THAT COLOUR IS REALISED IN DIFFERENT WAYS IN DIFFERENT ORGANISMS
Offering Semantic relations --------Similarity relations Argument Perceptual relations----innate Similarity relations are dynamic
Semantics relation between signifiers, such as words, phrases, signs and symbols, and what they stand for