Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Brief Overview: Purpose and Process of Empirical Research Standard Format of Research Articles Evaluating/Critiquing Research
Introduction
Background - the reasons the author(s) conducted the study; theoretical framework Statement of Purpose - the goal of the research (the destination); the problem statement Hypotheses - educated guesses about relationships or differences
Methodology
Participants (sample) - who the subjects are, how obtained/selected Materials (equipment, apparatus, measuring instruments) - what was used, quality of measuring instruments Procedures - how study was conducted; what subjects did or what was done to them
Results
Technical summary of the statistical analyses used: In text In tables In figures
Discussion/Conclusions
Non-technical interpretation of results Linking results to original purposes and hypotheses Why the results turned out the way they did Identifying the studys limitations Suggesting steps for further research
Evaluating Research
Goal: to be able to critique a research article by identifying the strengths and weaknesses of each component of the research
Tools for Evaluating Research Reports
Evaluating Methodology
Sufficient detail of procedures (treatment), design and instruments Full description of population Full description of sampling method Quality of measures used Obvious weaknesses in design
Evaluating Results
Appropriateness of statistical techniques used Clarity of presentation of results Adequacy of presentation of results
Evaluating Discussion/Conclusions
Consistency of conclusions with findings Appropriateness of generalizations Discussion of implications of findings Discussion of limitations of study Alternative explanation for findings Linkage of conclusions with theoretical framework, research questions