Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Large fires
and
As presented to the Northern California-Nevada Chapter of the Society of Fire Protection Engineers On April 21, 2006 in Walnut Creek, California. by Edward Munyak, P.E. esmunyak@earthlink.net
Historical catastrophic fires in high rise buildings from 1986 to 2005 Actual fire tests in steel frame buildings in the UK Thermodynamic simulations
Fire Resistance
Unprotected steel that resists high winds and seismic forces has considerable fire resistance. Adding dead weight at a cost of 20% ?
Structures need to be designed to resist higher wind, seismic loads and increased fire resistance will automatically follow.
ASTM E-119 is the standard test for full size structural components. Oven temperature(not structure) versus time. One side of the structure is exposed to heat. If temperature on unexposed side is excessive or if deflection is above a certain limit after the test duration, the component fails. Structure is always within the elastic range
1000
800
600
200
WTC 7
WTC 7 was one city block away from Towers No damage to fire proofing Small fires were observed Global collapse was initiated on the lowest level Different structure
Madrid,Spain12/2/2005
Edificio Windsor
Elements of Strength of Materials by Timoshenko & Young 4th edition page, p. 246-263
Theorem of Castigliano
Strain energy that must be overcome before limit collapse is complete is proportional to all forces squared and inversely proportional to high strength modulus of elasticity.
Integration of area under the stress-strain curve represents a massive amount of strain energy that must be overcome before collapse is complete in the case WTC 1, 2 & 7. The only available source of energy of that magnitude is the potential energy of at least 10 floors and it had to be released in
Potential energy (2 towers) =6.8 e=11 metric joules (controlled demolition can release this in less than one second)
Recommendation
Reimbursement of any loss must be contingent upon access to and analysis of fire damaged structure: The wreckage of WTC 1, 2 & 7 was worth hundreds of millions of dollars in terms of research and practical knowledge. There was evidence of sulfadation on beams from explosive material The severed ends of beams were observed to be partially molten for days after cleanup. This is characteristic of thermite.
http://www.implosionworld.com/ci nema.htm
What is incredible in the fire effects continua is routine in the world of controlled demolition. Even with explosives, achieving such results requires a great deal of preplanning and expertise The explosive demolition hypothesis better satisfies tests of repeatability and parsimony states Professor Steven Jones
http://www.physics.byu.edu/research/energy /htm7.html
To be continued
For additional information contact Edward Munyak, P.E. esmunyak@ earthlink.net (650)948-8035
References
NFPA Journal, March/April 2005 Fire Unchecked page 47 Caracas, Venezuela Fire Culver, Charles, Characteristics of fire loads in office buildings Fire Technology 1978, Vol 14, No.1 pages 51-60 NFPA investigation of High Rise office Building Fire, Montreal, Canada, October 26, 1986 NFPA investigations of May 4, 1988 First Bank Building Bank Fire, Los Angeles, Ca WWW. Implosionworld.com http://911reserach.wtc7.net Building Regulatory Systems in a post-September 11 World by Richard Bukowski, P.E. NIST Building and Fire Research Laboratory http://www.mace.manchester.ac.uk/project/research/structures/casestudy/historic fires/building fires/default.htm http://www.physics.byu.edu/research/energy/htm7.html Fire Protection of Structural Steel in High Rise Buildings, NIST GCR 04-872 Moscatelli, Frank, WETC energy calculations 9/11 Commission Report, Omissions and Distortions. David Ray Griffin 9/11 Synthetic Terror-Made in the USA, Webster Griffin Tarpley