The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering
Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1)
by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 1 Coverage Revisit pin and rigid connections Look at support conditions Review equilibrium Introduce static determinacy External Internal Analysis of pin jointed trusses Method of joints Method of sections (Tension coefficient method) (Graphical method) Example problems Static determinacy Analysis of pin jointed trusses
Lecture 2 Pin jointed structures The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 2 uz = 0 A x = Ay = 0 Pin connections Simple representation of above pin joint x y z Mathematical description of degrees of freedom The end of the beam, where it is attached to the column can rotate, but it is fixed in position it cant move upwards, downwards or sideways The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 3 Rigid connections Simple representation of above rigid joint x y z A x = Ay = 0 uz = 0 Mathematical description of degrees of freedom The end of the beam, where it is attached to the column cant rotate, and it cant move upwards, downwards or sideways. The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 4 Support conditions for a beam Pinned supports transfer forces, but not moments Load Pin Pin The simplest support condition for a beam is to have a pinned support at each end. In order to avoid extra forces due to changes in length, we can to make one support a roller bearing. this is called a simply supported beam. Load Pin Pin + roller Plan view The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 5 Support conditions for a beam Rigid (or encastr) supports transmit forces and moments Load Encastr A beam with an encastr support at each end is known as a fixed end beam. A beam supported at one end only (this must be an encastr support) is known as a cantilever. Plan view Fixed end beam Cantilever Note that Encastr The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 6 Equilibrium Free body diagram P P P P Externally applied axial force Free body Free body Internal forces in equilibrium with external force P But note that a long, thin (slender) member in compression may buckle. The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 7 Equilibrium In structures, we normally study bodies at rest statics
Consider a particle subject to two forces F 1 F 2 F 1 F 2 R
The two forces are equivalent to a single force R. If the same particle is subject to a third force R 1 that is equal and opposite to R then it is in equilibrium at rest. F 1 F 2 R 1 The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 8 Equilibrium In a 3-dimensional world there are 6 equations of equilibrium x y z F y F x F z M z M y M x Resolve forces in the directions of the three Cartesian axes Resolve moments about the three Cartesian axes M
M
Rather than more usual to draw The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 9 Equilibrium x y F y F x In a 2-dimensional, or plane system, world there are 3 equations of equilibrium. z M z EF x = 0 EF y = 0 EM z = 0
Load Pin Pin + roller R A,Horiz R A,Vert R B,Vert If there are 3 unknown reactions, we have enough equations to calculate them using equilibrium. A B The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 10 Static determinacy for reactions If the number of unknown reactions is less than, or equal to, the number of equilibrium equations we have available, the problem is said to be externally statically determinate. We can use equilibrium to calculate the reactions.
If the number of unknown reactions is more than the number of equilibrium equations we have available, the problem is said to be externally statically indeterminate or externally hyperstatic. We cant use equilibrium alone to calculate the reactions.
3 unknown reactions Externally statically determinate 3 unknown reactions Externally statically determinate The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 11 Static determinacy for reactions 4 unknown reactions Externally statically indeterminate 3 unknown reactions Externally statically determinate 5 unknown reactions Externally statically indeterminate 3 unknown reactions Externally statically determinate 25 kN The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 12 Static determinacy for reactions 4 unknown reactions Externally statically indeterminate 3 unknown reactions Externally statically indeterminate because there are only 2 useful equations of equilibrium The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 13 Static determinacy for reactions 3 unknown reactions Externally statically determinate 3 unknown reactions Externally statically determinate 3 unknown reactions Externally statically determinate The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 14 Pin jointed trusses Made from members connected together with pin joints. Based on triangles. If forces are applied at the joints (nodes) the members are under axial forces only (if they are straight). Examples:
A Warren truss
A Howe truss
A Pratt truss
The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 15 Pin jointed trusses How many unknowns? 4 reaction forces 3 member forces Externally statically indeterminate but if we knew the reactions we could calculate the member forces from equilibrium at the nodes. The structure is internally statically determinate. The triangular shape allows pin jointed trusses to take the load. This structure would fall over under the applied force. Such a structure is known as a mechanism. The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 16 Internal static determinacy In a 2D truss with M members, there are M unknown member forces. If there are J connections, we can resolve forces horizontally and vertically at each (no moments) giving 2J equations. However, 3 equations are required to satisfy the conditions of global equilibrium. EF x = 0 EF y = 0 EM z = 0
So if M = 2J - 3 we can find the member forces using equilibrium the structure is internally statically determinate.
In a 3D truss (a space truss), there are 3 equations per joint and 6 equations for global equilibrium. So if M= 3J - 6 the structure is internally statically determinate
The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 17 Internal static determinacy M = 3, J = 3 3 = 6 3 Internally statically determinate M = 3, J = 3 3 = 6 3 Internally statically determinate Externally statically indeterminate M = 15, J = 9 15 = 18 - 3 M = 27, J = 14 27 > 28 - 3 Internally statically indeterminate Internally statically determinate The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 18 Analysis of pin jointed trusses Calculation of reactions at supports using equilibrium as for beams shown previously. 4 main methods for finding member forces using equilibrium: Method of joints (Megson 4.6) Resolving horizontal and vertical forces at each node Finds all member forces one by one Method of sections (Megson 4.7) Cutting the structure and resolving horizontally, vertically and for moments Useful for finding a member force in the middle of a structure without having to calculate lots of other member forces Tension coefficient method (Megson 4.8) Alternative form of method of joints useful for 3D trusses Graphical method (Megson 4.9) Pen and paper vector method for those without a calculator This lecture will explain the method of joints and the method of sections. Assumptions: Deflections are small no changes to geometry Members are able to resist the forces The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 19 R 2 R 1 Method of joints F 1 F 2 F 3 R 2 R 1 R 3 F 3 F m1 m1 m2 m3 m4 F m2 F m1 F m3 F m4 Step 1: Resolve globally to find reactions (R 1 , R 2 & R 3 ). EF x = 0 EF y = 0 EM z = 0 Step 2: Pick a support node * and resolve locally to find member forces at node (F m1 & F m2 ). EF x = 0 EF y = 0 Step 3: Pick an adjacent node and resolve locally to find remaining member forces at node (F m3 & F m4 ). Repeat step 3. EF x = 0 EF y = 0 * Or any node where 2 unknown forces meet The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 20 Method of joints example 100kN
R 2 R 1 R 3 Find the force in members m4, m5 and m6
Step 1: Resolve globally to find reactions (R 1 , R 2 & R 3 ). EF x = 0 R 2 = -20kN (ie 20kN to the left) EF y = 0 R 1 + R 3 100 = 0kN EM z = 0 (about roller support) R 1 6 + 20 1 + R 2 0 100 3 = 0 kNm 6R 1 + 20 = 300 kNm R 1 = 46.7 kN and R 3 = 53.3 kN
1m 45 o 20kN
m1 m2 m3 m4 m5 m6 The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 21 Method of joints example 20kN
F m1 F m2 46.7kN
Step 2: Pick a support node and resolve locally to find member forces at node. EF x = 0 F m2 + F m1 cos45 20 = 0 kN 45 o -66.0 kN
F m3 F m4 20 kN
45 o EF y = 0 F m1 sin45 + 46.7 = 0 kN F m1 = -66.0 kN i.e. compression F m2 = 66.7 kN i.e. tension Step 3: Pick an adjacent node and resolve locally to find remaining member forces at node. EF x = 0 F m4 + 20 = -66 sin45 F m4 = -66.7 kN (comp) EF y = 0 F m3 66 cos45 = 0 F m3 = 46.7 kN (tens) The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 22 Method of joints example Warning: It is easy to mix up + and signs. The forces shown above are those acting on the node Advisable to have a system. e.g. Begin by assuming all member forces are tensile (a -ve number for a member force would then indicate compression. Also, when you get to the other support check that the final node is in equilibrium to verify your analysis.
Step 3 repeat: Pick an adjacent node and resolve locally to find remaining member forces at node. 45 o 66.7kN
46.7kN
F m5 F m6 EF x = 0 F m5 cos45 + F m6 = 66.7 kN EF y = 0 F m5 sin45 + 46.7 = 0 F m5 = -66.0 kN (comp) F m6 = 113.3 kN (tens) The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 23 Method of sections F 1 F 2 F 3 R 2 R 1 R 3 m1 m2 m3 Step 1: Resolve globally to find reactions (R 1 , R 2 & R 3 ). EF x = 0 EF y = 0 EM z = 0 Step 2: Cut the structure at point of interest and resolve globally to find unknown released member forces (F m1 , F m2 & F m3 ). EF x = 0 EF y = 0 EM z = 0 F 1 F 2 R 3 m1 m2 m3 F m1 F m2 F m3 The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 24 Method of sections example 100kN
R 2 R 1 R 3 Find the force in members m4, m5and m6
Step 1: Resolve globally to find reactions (R 1 , R 2 & R 3 ). EF x = 0 R 2 = -20kN (ie 20kN to the left) EF y = 0 R 1 + R 3 100 = 0kN EM z = 0 (about roller support) R 1 6 + 20 1 + R 2 0 100 3 = 0 kNm 6R 1 + 20 = 300 kNm R 1 = 46.7 kN and R 3 = 53.3 kN
1m 45 o 20kN
m1 m2 m3 m4 m5 m6 The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 25 Method of sections example 20 kN
46.7 kN
45 o 20kN F m4 F m5 F m6 This method is a quick way of finding the forces in members in the middle of a truss with experience you can spot where the highest member forces will be useful. Note 1: Cut the structure so that there are no more than 3 unknown released forces otherwise not enough equilibrium equations. Note 2: You can verify your answer by looking at the other part of the cut frame. Step 2: Cut the structure at point of interest and resolve globally to find unknown released member forces. EF x = 0 F m4 + F m6 + F m5 cos45 20 + 20 = 0 EF y = 0 46.7 + F m5 sin45 = 0 EM z = 0 (abt A) 1 46.7 + 1 20 + 1 F m4 = 0 A
F m4 = -66.7 kN (c) F m5 = -66 kN (c) F m6 = 113.3 kN (t) The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 26 True or false? a) This structure is externally statically indeterminate b) This structure is externally statically indeterminate c) This structure is externally statically indeterminate The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 27 True or false? d) This structure is externally statically determinate e) This structure is a mechanism f) This structure is internally statically indeterminate The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 28 True or false? g) Member A is in compression A h) Member A is in compression i) Member A is in compression A A The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 29 True or false answers a) False. 3 external reactions and 3 equations of equilibrium so structure is externally statically determinate. b) False. 3 external reactions and 3 equations of equilibrium so structure is externally statically determinate. c) True. 4 external reactions and 3 equations of equilibrium so structure is externally statically indeterminate. d) True. 3 external reactions and 3 equations of equilibrium so structure is externally statically determinate. e) True. The roller support does not prevent the beam rotating about the other support. f) False. 9 members and 6 joints. 9 = 2 6 3 so internally statically determinate. Note there are 4 external reactions and 3 equations of equilibrium so structure is externally statically indeterminate. g) True. The beam is bending downwards (sagging) so the top chord will be in compression. h) False. The beam is bending downwards (sagging) so the bottom chord will be in tension. i) False. This member cannot possibly be under load. Consider equilibrium at the left-hand node.
The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 30 Final puzzle How many unknowns? How many reaction forces? How many member forces? Would you be able to find them using equilibrium? Is the structure externally statically determinate? Is the structure internally statically determinate? 1 m 3 m 3 m 2 kN The University of Nottingham, School of Civil Engineering Structures and Materials 1 (H21SM1) by B.S. Choo & D.J.Ridley-Ellis Page No. 31 Final puzzle hint At each pin joint there are, potentially, two reaction forces. These two components represent a single (vector) resultant for which there are two unknown quantities a magnitude and a direction.
When a single member meets a pin joint, equilibrium of the joint dictates that the direction of the support reaction must be in the direction of the member.