Professional Documents
Culture Documents
April 2009
232, Avenue Napolon Bonaparte P.O. BOX 213 92502 Rueil-Malmaison France Phone: +33 1 47 08 80 00 Fax: +33 1 47 08 41 85 info@beicip.fr
@Beicip-Franlab
Background, methodologies and tools to account for the presence of fractures in oil & gas reservoirs
Part 1: What is a fractured reservoir? What is the impact of fractures on field behavior? When do we consider a reservoir is fractured? Part 2: How to characterize a fractured reservoir? How to detect fractures? How to model their distribution as well as their geological and flow properties?
Part 3: Which parameters control the fluid flow in fractures ? How to upscale these parameters into a flow simulator ?
Part 4: How to identify the appropriate recovery mechanism?
@Beicip-Franlab
232, Avenue Napolon Bonaparte P.O. BOX 213 92502 Rueil-Malmaison France Phone: +33 1 47 08 80 00 Fax: +33 1 47 08 41 85 info@beicip.fr
@Beicip-Franlab
fm Km
fm Km
Fractures
@Beicip-Franlab
North
50 m
A fracture set is characterized by its avg. strike and dip, length distribution, and density
@Beicip-Franlab
Local connection
@Beicip-Franlab
If fractures are open, this connected fracture network will have an impact on fluid flow
P1
~ P1
X
P2
10
@Beicip-Franlab
The connected fracture network will induce flow anisotropy in the reservoir: Px < Py
The block size is determined by length of matrix blocks surrounded by connected fractures
@Beicip-Franlab
11
Length of homogenisation
12
@Beicip-Franlab
The length of homogenization (REV) is a value of grid size not impacting the fracture properties
Summary
What is a fracture, a fracture set, a fracture network? A fracture is a surface of discontinuity of mechanical origin. The fracture is the failure of a rock (= deformation) resulting from applied forces (= stress)
a fracture is characterised by its attributes (dip, strike, length, aperture, morphology and origin) A fracture set (or fracture family) is a set of fractures with similar attributes The fracture network involves the description of the fracture attributes and investigates the relationship between the different fracture sets the fracture network is characterised by the spatial properties of fractures, such as the number of fracture sets, their relative fracture density, the fracture connectivity, the length of homogenization
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
13
@Beicip-Franlab
14
Fracture mode nomenclature is purely descriptive, not genetic. For example, a mode I fracture can be formed by one or more mechanisms such as hydraulic fracturing, thermal contraction, etc.
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
15
@Beicip-Franlab
Stress is defined as the force per unit area acting on a given plane. Any stress state at a point in a solid body can be described completely by the orientations and magnitudes of three stresses called principal stresses and oriented perpendicular to each other. The principal stresses are defined: s1> s2> s 3
@Beicip-Franlab
16
Increased confining Stress and/or Temperature Joints (mode I) in green Shear fractures/faults (mode II) in red Stylolites in blue
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
17
@Beicip-Franlab
1. Tectonic fractures
Small-scale fractures (diffuse/sistematic fractures) Joints, fold-related fractures
Large-scale fractures
Fracture swarms, fault-related fractures
2. Diagenetic fractures
Bed-parallel stylolites, stylolite-related fractures, diagenetic cracks, etc.
@Beicip-Franlab
18
Tectonic fractures
19
@Beicip-Franlab
Diffuse fractures
@Beicip-Franlab
Fracture swarms
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
20
21
@Beicip-Franlab
22
Homogeneous density
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
23
@Beicip-Franlab
A
Homogeneous fracture density with constant fracture orientation
@Beicip-Franlab
Figure 1 Outcrop patternPart of 1an orthogonal fracture set on a gentle fold limb. What is a naturally fractured reservoir
24
25
@Beicip-Franlab
h1> h2 > h3
26
@Beicip-Franlab
Relation between lithology and fracture density Joints are controlled by lithology
27
@Beicip-Franlab
28
@Beicip-Franlab
MFS FS
Fracture
density
1 : Shalyness
29
30
@Beicip-Franlab
Definition of fold
Folds result from a compressive ductile deformation, in which the maximum stress axis (s1) is sub-horizontal
Anticline
Youngest
Oldest
Youngest
Syncline
Oldest Youngest Oldest
31
@Beicip-Franlab
Fold geometry
Study-case in Northern Mexico: the Menchaca Anticline
The Menchaca anticline is a kink-style box fold, cored by evaporites (Olvido Fm, Middle Jurassic)
Courtesy of PEMEX
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
32
@Beicip-Franlab
33
@Beicip-Franlab
1 and 2 form during the early phases of folding (e.g. layer parallel shortening) 3 and 4 form in the latest phases of folding.
80 deg
20 ft
@Beicip-Franlab
34
80
35
@Beicip-Franlab
Fractures produced by extension are pure extensional and open fractures Fractures produced by compression are closed, stylolithic and/or partially open.
Compression
Extension
@Beicip-Franlab
36
37
@Beicip-Franlab
disconnecting them.
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
38
39
@Beicip-Franlab
2m
40
@Beicip-Franlab
41
@Beicip-Franlab
42
@Beicip-Franlab
15 Fracture density 0
200m
100m
43
@Beicip-Franlab
Limestone
Calvisson quarry (France - Gard)
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
44
@Beicip-Franlab
Limestone
45
@Beicip-Franlab
Minerals + Cristals
46
@Beicip-Franlab
Definition of fault
FAULTS (Large-scale fractures) Faults are defined as structures across which appreciable shear displacement discontinuities occur. Fault blocks predominantly move along the plane or zone of the discontinuity. The term fault zone is used when referring to the zone of complex deformation (fracturing) that is associated with the fault plane.
@Beicip-Franlab
47
Normal Fault
Reverse/Thrust Fault
Hanging wall block
Strike-slip Fault
48
@Beicip-Franlab
49
@Beicip-Franlab
Faults in outcrop
50
@Beicip-Franlab
51
@Beicip-Franlab
E
Background Subvertical Fractures Background Subvertical Fractures
5 cm
5 cm
Lozenge-shaped fractures
Damaged area
Damaged area
Fault core
52
53
@Beicip-Franlab
Porous sandstones
Displacement 1m
Shales Tight sandstones
Displacement 1m
54
@Beicip-Franlab
The absence of a damage zone can also depend from the mechanical behaviour of rocks affected by faults
The widest damage zone for normal faults forms either in the hanging wall near the upper tip of the fault or in the footwall near the lower tip.
The width/location of the damage zone observed at wells may depend on where the well intersects a fault (near either the upper or lower tip)
@Beicip-Franlab
55
56
@Beicip-Franlab
Definition of stylolites
A bed-parallel stylolite is an irregular discontinuity commonly found in limestones and other sedimentary rocks. They result from compaction and pressure solution during diagenesis and may be enlarged by subsequent groundwater flow. Stylolites appear as jagged discontinuities in outcrops and are often filled with insoluble clays, opaques (such as iron oxide), or dark organic matter.
@Beicip-Franlab
57
Bed-parallel stylolites in limestones (Southern France) Bed-parallel stylolites in limestones (Southern France)
58
@Beicip-Franlab
Tectonic fractures
Tension gashes Paleo-minimum stress direction Stylolite peaks Tight zone related to pressuresolution Stylolite
Fracture
overburden
@Beicip-Franlab
59
60
@Beicip-Franlab
Origin of stylolites is overburden plus tectonic stresses They form tight intervals that may be preferentially fractured
Fault
Large-scale fractures
Swarm
Small-scale fractures
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
61
@Beicip-Franlab
62
@Beicip-Franlab
Examples: LA PAZ (Venezuela) WHITE TIGER (Vietnam) MONTE ALPI (Italy) ROSPO MARE (Italy)
ff K f
Matrix
Fracture
f m~ 0
K
m
~0
Hydrocarbon
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
63
@Beicip-Franlab
Examples: QUARTZITE SANDSTONE (Algeria) HUSSUM SCHNEEREN (Germany) OROCUAL (Venezuela) AGHA JARI (Iran) HAFT KEL (Iran) VILLAFORTUNA (Italy)
f f < 1%
Kf
fm
K
m
Matrix
~0
Hydrocarbon
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
64
@Beicip-Franlab
ff K f fm
Km
Matrix
Fracture
Hydrocarbon
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
65
@Beicip-Franlab
Examples: HASSI MESSAOUD (Algeria) GHAWAR (Saudi Arabia) SHAH (Abu Dhabi)
ff K f
fm
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
Matrix
66
@Beicip-Franlab
Km
Fractured reservoirs where both matrix and fractures contribute significantly to production at field scale Ex. : Kirkuk Field (highly-productive fractured limestone)
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
67
High productivity/injectivity Anisotropy of flows Early breakthrough Communication between different reservoirs Specific recovery mechanisms (dual medium) If sealed fractures : compartmentalization into several reservoir units
@Beicip-Franlab
68
Matrix = High fluid capacity / low permeability Fractures = Low fluid capacity / high permeability Ratio of capacity (F/M): 10-3 to 10-2 Ratio of permeability (F/M): 10 to 1000
(Well test interpretation methods are based on this dual-porosity flow behavior)
69
@Beicip-Franlab
Fractures bypass the matrix spontaneous (= non-forced) displacement mechanisms (expansion, capillarity, gravity, diffusion) control oil recovery from matrix blocks
Absolute criteria of fracturation: well testing versus core analysis (K.H) test >> (K.H) matrix (at least 10 times)
Required information: an interpreted pressure build-up matrix permeability from representative core measurements (or f-K laws
and porosity log) - continuous sampling through the reservoir - K measurements under stress (or corrected for stress effects)
(SPE 22915)
Difficulties: Which H has been tested ? Reservoir / Perforated /Producing height ? (KH) calculation from plug measurements? Which average?
@Beicip-Franlab
70
10000
K.H Test
1000
No evidence of fracture
100
10
K.H Core
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
71
Lagalaye (Total), Grard (Beicip-Franlab) Conductive Fault Modelling and History Match Improvements on a Fractured Carbonate Field - GEO2002 - Bahrein 14-17th of april 2002
72
@Beicip-Franlab
INJ 2
Conductive faults
INJ 1
Well A Well C
Sealing faults
Lagalaye (Total), Grard (Beicip-Franlab) Conductive Fault Modelling and History Match Improvements on a Fractured Carbonate Field - GEO2002 - Bahrein 14-17th of april 2002
73
@Beicip-Franlab
A B C D E
A B C D E
Lagalaye (Total), Grard (Beicip-Franlab) Conductive Fault Modelling and History Match Improvements on a Fractured Carbonate Field - GEO2002 - Bahrein 14-17th of april 2002
74
@Beicip-Franlab
Sweep efficiency
75
@Beicip-Franlab
76
@Beicip-Franlab
- Fractures act as a saturation (or pressure or composition) boundary condition for matrix blocks: they impose on the limits of the blocks a fixed potential different from that of matrix; large exchange surfaces are offered. - Determinant parameters for exchanges: block size and shape (height); matrix properties; wettability, permeability, boundary conditions (rate of fracture invasion), fluid properties.
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
77
@Beicip-Franlab
P1 P2
P2 ~ P1 and Kf >> Km
@Beicip-Franlab
78
Depletion
Gas Injection
A
GOC
WOC
Gravity Drainage
Gas drive
Diffusion Reimbibition
GOC WOC
Imbibition
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
79
@Beicip-Franlab
Water drive
Convection phenomenon
Gas liberated
GOC
Heavier oil
High vertical permeability Gravity segregation Thermal gradients
Lighter oil
80
@Beicip-Franlab
84 bar
GOC, 1900 m
112 bar
In 1998
2000 m
124 bar
1950 m 2255 m 2620 m
3000 m
(initially 150 bar everywhere in 1977)
81
@Beicip-Franlab
Basement Interval
Fault related fractures
82
@Beicip-Franlab
10 years
20 years
55 years
83
@Beicip-Franlab
10 years
20 years
55 years
84
@Beicip-Franlab
Gas Drainage = small effect In the matrix blocks Reason: Block reduced size
10 Years
20 Years
Water Injection Started 40 years after production
55 Years
Injected water
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
85
@Beicip-Franlab
10 Years
20 Years
55 Years
86
@Beicip-Franlab
important Effect of matrix blocks imbibition Due to water injection Reason: blocks wettability
87
@Beicip-Franlab
Conclusion: - Fractures can either enhance recovery (Lacq, Haft Kel) or stop it prematurely (breakthroughs) - Recovery may be very low in fractured reservoirs with poor oil and matrix properties (high o, low K, oil wettability) and/or an unsuited production method (early breakthroughs)
88
@Beicip-Franlab
20 18 16 14
Frequency
12 10 8 6 4 2 0
0 - 10% 10 - 20% 20 - 30% 30 - 40% 40 - 50% 50 - 60% 60 - 70% 70 - 80% 80 - 90% 90 - 100%
Ultimate recovery
89
@Beicip-Franlab
Ref: SPE 84590 Figures obtained from 56 fractured oil reservoirs and 8 fractured gas reservoirs.
Structural information
High structural dips, folding Field located close to regional faults
Core description
Presence of numerous continuous open (or partly open) fractures
90
Well testing:
Kh test >> Kh core dual porosity signature presence of no flow boundaries or constant pressure boundaries dispersion of skin data
Production logs
Low temperature gradient in the oil column (convection in fractures) Flowmeters with sudden changes
91
Conclusion
@Beicip-Franlab
Evidence of fractures and of matrix-fracture flow-property contrast results from the cross-checking of several sources of information.
Part 1- What is a naturally fractured reservoir
92