You are on page 1of 7

Waiting Your Turn 2011: Fraser InstituteScribd Upload a Document Search Documents Explore Documents Books - Fiction Books

- Non-fiction Health & Medicine Brochures/Catalogs Government Docs How-To Guides/Manuals Magazines/Newspapers Recipes/Menus School Work + all categories Featured Recent People Authors Students Researchers Publishers Government & Nonprofits Businesses Musicians Artists & Designers Teachers + all categories Most Followed Popular shelleykrussell View Public Profile My Documents My Collections My Shelf Messages Notifications Account Help Log Out

inShare0Embed Doc Copy Link Readcast Collections CommentsGo Back Download Health PolicyStudies inKey ConclusionsSpecialist physicians surveyed across 12 specialties and 10 Canadian prov-inces report a total waiting time of 19.0 weeks between referral from ageneral practitioner and elective treatment in 2011the longest total waittime recorded since the Fraser Institute began measuring wait times in 1993.Patients in Ontario experience the shortest wait (14.3 weeks) followed byBritish Columbia (19.3 weeks), and Quebec (19.9 weeks)Patients wait longest to undergo plastic surgery (41.6 weeks) and waitleast for medical oncology treatment (4.2 weeks)After an appointment with a specialist, Canadians

wait nearly 3 weekslonger than what physicians believe is reasonable for elective treatment. Throughout the provinces, in 2011 people are waiting for an estimated941,321 procedures. Assuming that each person waits for only oneprocedure, 2.8 percent of Canadians are waiting for treatmentOnly 9.4 percent of patients are on waiting lists because they requesteda delay or postponementWaiting Your TurnWait Times for Health Care in Canada2011 report by Bacchus Barua, Mark Rovere, and Brett J. Skinner December 2011 Studies inHealth Care PolicyDecember 2011Waiting Your TurnWait Times for Health Carein Canada2011 Report by Bacchus Barua, Mark Rovereand Brett J. Skinner Fraser Insti tute4www.fraserinstitute.orgPrcisThis edition of Wait ing Your Turnindicates that wait ing times for elective medical treatment have increased since last year. Spe cialist phy sicians sur veyed across 12 spe- cialties and 10 Ca nadian prov inces report a total wait ing time of 19.0 weeks between referral from a gen eral practitioner and receipt of elective treatment. At 104 percent longer than it was in 1993, this is the longest total wait time recorded since the Fra ser Institute began measuring wait times in Canada. Wait times between 2010 and 2011 increased in both the segment between refer-ral by a general practitio ner to consultation with a specialist (rising to 9.5 weeks from 8.9 weeks in 2010), and the seg ment between a consultation with a specialist and receipt of treatment (rising to 9.5 weeks from 9.3 weeks in 2010). In fact, phy sicians themselves believe that Canadi ans wait nearly 3 weeks longer than what they consider is clinically reasonable for elective treatment after an appointment with a spe cialist. There is, how ever, a great deal of variation in the total waiting time faced by patients across the prov inces. While Ontario reports the short est total wait in 2011(14.3 weeks); Prince Edward Island reports the lon gest at 43.9 weeks. The same is trueof variations among specialties. Patients wait longest between a GP referral and plastic surgery (41.6 weeks), while those waiting for medical oncology begin treat ment in 4.2 weeks.It is estimated that, across all 10 prov inces, in 2011 people are waiting for an esti- mated 941,321 procedures. This means that, assuming that each person waits for only one procedure, 2.8 percent of Canadians are waiting for treat ment. Importantly, phy sicians report that only about 9.4 percent of their patients are on a waiting list because they requested a delay or postponement. The results of this years sur vey indicate that despite high lev els of health expen- diture and pro vincial wait time strat egies, it is clear that patients in Canada are waiting too long to receive treatment. ContentsPrcis4iiAcknowledgements45Find ings46Method414Verification of data 416Change in estimation methodology for Alberta and Quebec426Conclusion427Selected graphs428Selected data tables437Appendix A: Links to wait times datapublished by provin cial govern ment agen cies 471Appendix B: National psychiatry waiting list survey 473Appendix C: Waiting Your Turn survey questionnaire 481Ref erences483About the authors485Publishing information487Supporting the Fraser Institute 488Pur pose, fund ing, and inde pendence489About the Fraser Institute489Editorial Advisory Board491Fraser Insti tute4www.fraserinstitute.org AcknowledgmentsThis edi tion of Wait ing Your Turn: Wait Times for Health Care in Can adadraws ex-ten sively on pre vious edi tions. As such, the authors would like to pay spe cial tribute and thanks to:Michael Walker , who is responsible for helping nav igate the beginnings of wait time measurement in Canada, and has authored or co-authored the report for almost two

decades, andNadeem Esmail, who, apart from adding sig nif icantly to the refinement and accuracy of the report, and authoring or co-authoring the report for almost a decade,also pro vided extensive assistance and guid ance in the production of this par ticular edition of Wait ing Your Turn.We are also pleased to acknowledge the impor tant contributions of Ste venGloberman,Maureen Hazel,Joanna Miyake,Cynthia Ramsay ,Greg Wilson, andMartin Zelderin completing earlier versions of the sur vey and in building the base of knowl edge that is incorporated into this publication. Data-entry for this par ticular edi tion of Waiting Your Turn was com pleted with the assistance of Hillson Tse.Fraser Insti tute4www.fraserinstitute.orgWaiting Your Turn: Wait Times for Health Care in Canada, 2011 Report 45 FindingsTotal wait timesThe Fraser Institutes twenty-first annual waiting list sur vey finds that prov ince-wide wait times1for surgical and other therapeutic treatments have increased in 2011. The total wait ing time between re ferral from a general practi tioner and deliv ery of elec tive treatment by a specialist, av eraged across all 12 specialties and 10 prov inces sur veyed, has risen from 18.2 weeks in 2010 to 19.0 weeks in 2011. Compared to 1993, the totalwaiting time in 2011 is 104 percent lon ger.This nation wide dete rioration in access reflects waiting-time increases in six prov inces, while concealing decreases in Alberta, New Bruns wick, Prince Edward Island, and New found land & Labrador. Fraser Insti tute4www.fraserinstitute.org64Waiting Your Turn: Wait Times for Health Care in Canada, 2011 Report Chart 1: Median Wait by Prov ince in 2011Weeks Waited from Refer ral by GP to Treat ment Source: The Fraser Institutes national waiting list sur vey, 2011. Totals may not equal the sum of subtotals due to rounding.1For a further explanation of how Wait ing Your Turnmeasures wait times, see the Method sec tion.9.511.531.613.316.610.77.27.59.910.79.79.511.412.315.710.99.27.117.519.010. 49.619.022.843.929.027.519.914.325.029.021.119.30 10 20 30 40 50CANNLPENSNBQCONMBSK ABBCWeeks waited Wait from specialistto treatmentWait from GP tospecialist Ontario reports the shortest total wait in 2011 (14.3 weeks), followed by British Columbia (19.3 weeks), and Quebec (19.9 weeks). Prince Edward Island has the lon- gest total wait at 43.9 weeks, followed by Nova Sco tia and Saskatch ewan (29.0 weeks each) (see table 2 and chart 1).Wait time by segment Total wait time can be examined in two con secutive segments: 1.The first segment occurs from referral by a general practi tioner to con sultation with a specialist.2.The second segment occurs from the con sultation with a special ist to the point at which the patient receives treatment. The rise in wait ing time between 2010 and 2011 results from an increase in bothsegments.Fraser Insti tute4www.fraserinstitute.orgWaiting Your Turn: Wait Times for Health Care in Canada, 2011 Report 47 Chart 2: Waiting By Province in 2010 and 2011Weeks Waited from Referral by GP to Appointment with Specialist Source: The Fraser Institutes national waiting list sur vey, 2011. 9.511.531.613.316.610.77.27.59.910.79.78.914.722.013.024.68.97.88.66.79.98.20 5 10 15 20 25 30 35CANNLPENSNBQCONMBSK ABBC20102011Weeks waited The wait ing time in the first segment, from referral by a general practitioner to consultation with a spe cialist, has risen from 8.9 weeks in 2010 to 9.5 weeks in 2011. This wait time is now 156 percent longer than in 1993 when it was 3.7 weeks (seegraphs 1 and 2). The waiting time to see a specialist has

increased in six prov inces since 2010, but has fallen in Manitoba, Ontario, New Brunswick, and New foundland & Lab- rador (see chart 2). The shortest waits for specialist con sultations are in Ontario (7.2 weeks), Manitoba (7.5 weeks), and British Columbia (9.7 weeks). The longest waits for specialist consultations occur in Prince Edward Island (31.6 weeks), New Brunswick (16.6 weeks), and Nova Scotia (13.3 weeks) (see table 3).The wait ing time in the sec ond seg ment, from con sultation with a specialist to the point at which the patient receives treatment, has risen from 9.3 weeks in 2010 to9.5 weeks in 2011. This portion of waiting is 70 percent lon ger than in 1993 when it was 5.6 weeks (see graphs 3 and 4). Inter estingly, wait ing times from specialist con sul- tation to treatment have decreased in six prov inces, rising only in Manitoba, Ontario, New Brunswick, and Nova Scotia (see table 6 and chart 3). The shortest specialist-to- treatment waits are found in Ontario (7.1 weeks), Quebec (9.2 weeks), and British Fraser Insti tute4www.fraserinstitute.org84Waiting Your Turn: Wait Times for Health Care in Canada, 2011 Report Chart 3: Waiting by Province in 2010 and 2011Weeks Waited from Appointment with Specialist to Treatment, by ProvinceSource: The Fraser Institutes national waiting list sur vey, 2011. 9.511.412.315.710.99.27.117.519.010.49.69.314.422.415.59.09.96.28.919.712.210.60 5 10 15 20 25CANNLPENSNBQCONMBSK ABBC20102011Weeks waited of 91 Leave a Comment Comment must not be empty. SubmitCharacters: 400 Comment must not be empty. SubmitCharacters: ...Waiting Your Turn 2011: Fraser Institute Download or Print 209 ReadsInfo and Rating Category:Uncategorized. Rating: Upload Date:12/12/2011 Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial Tags:This document has no tags. Flag document for inapproriate content This is a private document. Uploaded by winnipegsun DownloadEmbed DocCopy LinkAdd To CollectionCommentsReadcastShare Share on Scribd: Readcast SearchTIP Press Ctrl-F F to quickly search anywhere in the document. SearchSearch History: Searching... Result 00 of 0000 results for result for p. More from This UserRelated Documents More From This User 25 p.Wps Marathon Results1 p.Jets Replay March 31 20121 p.Sentence Statement by

Theo Fleury and Todd Holt Next 1 p.Gas Pain1 p.Gas Pain1 p.0309WS1MS004 Prev Next 1 p.Jets Replay 03051 p.Winnipeg s new dog house1 p.Jets Game Day 0225 Prev Next 1 p.Jets Replay 02231 p.Jets Game Day 02191 p.Jets Replay 0217 Prev Next 1 p.Jets Game Day 02141 p.Jets Replay 02121 p.Jets Game Day 0212 Prev Next 1 p.Jets Game Day 02071 p.Jets Replay 02051 p.Jets Gameday 0205 Prev Next 1 p.121 p.CFIB Business Barometer Manitoba1 p.Do you support or oppose CMHR? Prev Next 1 p.If in Winnipeg, would you visit CMHR?1 p.Would you rather go to the museum or a Jets game?1 p.Jets Game Day Jan 31 2012 Prev Next 2 p.transitfare_longleaflet1 Prev Related Docuements 90 p.Wait Times for Health Care in Canada 2010 Report From edsunonline12 p.ARTICULO METODOS From Carlos Pineda11 p.MH Bulletin No 277 6th December 2010 From Health Library Next 4 p.US Census Bureau Disability Act Info 2009 From alicepaul224 p.Depresion Presentation From ENTELECHEIA3 p.Tennis Basics 101 From Mikayla Pamberton Prev Next 23 p.ten-rules-of-value-investing-1229411231966584-1 From dwphoto20d9 p.HB 1166 - House: Prefiled and ordered printed; offered 01/13/10 101... Controlled substances; unlawfully obtaining or attempting to obtain, report r... From MyGov36520 p.Health Insurance Coverage in New York Keeps Shrinking as Premiums, ... Medical care has become too expensive in New York, leaving 2.6 million state ... From Citizen Action of New York Prev Next 24 p.css documento que presenta informacin sobre la introduccin a CSS. From frankjark39 p.Thematische Impuls Intelligente Sensornetwerken 1 From Kenneth Tts10 p.Heartbeat Silver Brochure From subs007 Prev Next 7 p.null From Pearltrees26 p.Untitled From eurolex1 p.Chicken and Egg Salad With Almond Satay Sauce Re Delicious recipe for chicken and egg salad with almond satay sauce, Suitable... From deep1mpact Prev Next 4 p.Patient Procedures Surgeries From Tracy10 p.Risk of Emergency Admission While Awaiting Elective Cholecystectomy... From mrs aznar21 p.Social Security: v65n2p28 From Social Security Prev Next 2 p.USDA: ok appd2 From USDA Prev

Upload a Document Search Documents Follow Us!scribd.com/scribdtwitter.com/scribdfacebook.com/scribdAboutPressBlogPartner sScribd 101Web StuffSupportFAQDevelopers / APIJobsTermsCopyrightPrivacyCopyright 2012 Scribd Inc.Language:EnglishChoose the language in which you want to experience Scribd:EnglishEspaolPortugus Download This Document PDF PDF TXTDocument size: 1008.14 156.077 Document name: 75467591-Waiting-Your-Turn-2011-Fraser-Institute.pdf.txt Download PDF Your download has started. Close this dialog. Having trouble downloading? Try again.The Scribd Archive

This document was uploaded by someone just like you and is now part of The Scribd Archive*. Give back to the community and gain 24 hours of download access by uploading something of your own. Do you understand the Scribd Terms of Service and Copyright Policy, and confirm that your uploading of this material complies with those policies and does not violate anyone s rights? Queued: Uploading: You have uploaded: Upload failed: Document URL: This document is: PrivateThis document is: Public Cancel Upload Make it easier to find your new document! Title: Category: Presentations Choose a Category Art & Design Brochures/Catalogs Business/Law Government Docs How-To Guides/Manuals Recipes/Menus Research School Work Spreadsheets Choose a Category Business/Law How-To Guides/Manuals Research School Work Choose a Category Art & Design Comics Reviews Op-Ed Books - Fiction Books - Non-fiction Brochures/Catalogs Business/Law Creative Writing Government Docs How-To Guides/Manuals Magazines/Newspapers Puzzles/Games Recipes/Menus Research Resumes/CVs School Work Speeches Please select a top level category first Automobiles Crafts Gadgets Scrapbooking Court Filings Press Releases Finance Marketing Real Estate Taxes & Accounting Technology Biography Health & Lifestyle History Philosophy Politics Psychology Religion & Spirituality Self-Help Travel Calendars Crosswords Word Search Essays & Theses Homework Study Guides, Notes, & Quizzes Book Film Music Art Essays Fan Fiction Humor Memoirs Novels Poetry Screenplays & Plays Short Stories Chick Lit Children s Literature Romance Science Fiction & Fantasy Thrillers Young Adult Bills Forms Letters Public Notices Maps Sheet Music Origami Photography Posters Arts & Architecture Business & Economics Genealogy Health & Medicine

History Internet & Technology Law Literature Math & Engineering Science Tags: (separate with commas) Description: Save Subscribe to The Scribd Archive and download as many documents as you d like. Monthly SubscriptionMost Popular$9/mo.1 Day Pass$51 Year Pass$59 Choose payment option Pay with Credit CardPay with PayPal or Credit * The Scribd Archive is a collection of millions of documents, including research reports, best-selling books, news source materials, and more. Read the Scribd Archive FAQ for more information.

PDF PDF TXTDocument size: 1008.14 156.077 Document name: 75467591-Waiting-Your-Turn-2011-Fraser-Institute.pdf.txt Download PDF Your download has started. Close this dialog. Having trouble downloading? Try again.

You might also like