Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Marisa Ruiz
Sociology 251
What Two Aspects of Culture or Society may be Affecting the Discrimination that Edith is
Experiencing?
When one looks at an individual’s experience, it is important to consider all the factors
that shape their lives. In using the “Sociological Imagination” we can better understand an
individual by looking at how their personal experiences interact with the larger structure of
In the movie, If These Walls Could Talk 2: 1961, we look inside the life of a lesbian
couple during the early 1960’s. As racial and ethnic inequality and discrimination was prevalent
during this time, gay and lesbian couples were not immune to the same injustices that the other
groups experienced. Upon the death of Edith’s partner, Edith alone faced many difficulties, thus
forced to undertake painstakingchoices in order to protect her from further adversity. Among the
various issues that plague American society, we can further investigate Edith’s experience with
inequality by looking at two aspects of discrimination: gay and lesbian discrimination and
institutional discrimination.
During the early 1960’s, gay and lesbian couples had to deal and cope with society’s
general intolerance of homosexuality. Trials and tribulations of being a lesbian couple during
this time met social stigma and minimal public acceptance. The general public felt that any
deviation from society’s idea of the “traditional family” was perverted and immoral. In the
earlier half of the movie, this is demonstrated by the teenagers’ reaction towards Edith and her
Ruiz 3
woman friend holding hands as they walked out of the movie theatre. According to society’s
ideology of marriage and the family structure at the time, the only accepted model was based on
the “traditional nuclear” heterosexual couples, Family, itself is a social institution in which
gender related role behaviors learned, is molded fundamentally in part of our larger social
institutions. During the early 60’s, there was no support systems available for homosexual
couples. Same-sex relationships were not an option; when there was emphasis on the American
idea of what a “traditional family,” homosexuality was not a part of the normal conventions and
institutions that govern heterosexual couples and families. Based on American society at that
time, same-sex couples were not widely accepted. Knowing this, Edith was faced to take some
drastic measures that hid her love for her woman friend, which caused her to be further isolated
in her life. In their relationship, they chose to keep their union rather private in order to avoid
clearly observed by the outcomes that affect specific groups of people such as gay and lesbian
groups. There were no public policy concerning the rights, recognition, and protection of same
sex couples when it came to legal issues, such as hospital’s next of kin rules and policy. Legally
there were no open doors. With lack of support, and lack of access to resources that were
established for these groups, there was no way Edith could fight hospital policy. Therefore,
under these conditions it made no sense to disclose the true nature of their relationship. In the
film, one example of institutional discrimination was when Edith went to the hospital. During
the final hours of her partner’s life, Edith could not go into the ICU due to next of kin rules and
hospital policy. She was not even informed of her death; although she made it known that, she
was waiting to hear of any changes in her lover’s condition. Like today, there were no
Ruiz 3
government policies that legally protected the rights and equality of same-sex groups or any
the factors that shape their lives from a micro-macro perspective. In doing this, one must look at
all the components within the person’s framework as well as society’s outlook on such issues like
observe the interrelations between the individual, their family, and larger society. In all fairness,
it is crucial to come to conclusions without bias or judgments from what we have learned from
our own individual experiences. We must use this “sociological Imagination” to further
understand each individual’s beliefs and perceptions in living their life as part as a larger social
network.