Professional Documents
Culture Documents
com
Lehman Brothers does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its research reports. As a result, investors should be aware that the firm may have a conflict of interest that could affect the objectivity of this report. Customers of Lehman Brothers in the United States can receive independent, third-party research on the company or companies covered in this report, at no cost to them, where such research is available. Customers can access this independent research at www.lehmanlive.com or can call 1-800-2LEHMAN to request a copy of this research. Investors should consider this report as only a single factor in making their investment decision. PLEASE SEE ANALYST CERTIFICATION AND IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES BEGINNING ON PAGE 28.
2009 Outlook
2009 Bull 300 -850 700 400 100 350 230 55 70 40 70 35 130 52 52 450 60 70 60 40 2 ,924 2,330 2 ,600 800 540 200
2009 Bear 300 -850 300 250 30 200 230 55 70 40 70 35 130 52 52 200 60 70 60 40 1,904 1,310 2,600 800 540 200
1,800
340
Regional Demand
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Europe
Annual Solar Installations (MW)
Germany y/y (%) Italy y/y (%) Spain y/y (%) France y/y (%) Greece y/y (%) Czech Republic y/y (%) Austria y/y (%) Portugal y/y (%) Switzerland y/y (%) The Netherlands y/y (%) Belgium y/y (%) Cyprus y/y (%) Israel y/y (%) Rest of Europe y/y (%) Total y/y (%)
2001
79 NM
0
2002
83 5%
0
2003
170 105%
0
2004
546 221%
0
2005
837 53%
6
2006
960 15%
60
2007
1,328 38%
87
2008E
1,793 35%
131
2009E
2,689 50%
500
2010E
4,034 50%
850
2011E
5,244 30%
1,275
2012E
6,293 20%
1,657
NM
0
NM
5
NM
15
NM
25
NM
35
900%
110
45%
428
50%
1,156
283%
300
70%
360
50%
432
30%
518
NM
3
NM
3
200%
4
67%
5
40%
7
214%
11
289%
16
170%
33
-74%
229
20%
458
20%
916
20%
1,831
NM
0
27%
0
18%
0
26%
1
43%
1
56%
1
50%
12
100%
30
600%
75
100%
188
100%
469
100%
1,172
NM
0
-10%
0
-10%
0
186%
0
-3%
0
20%
0
900%
4
150%
7
150%
70
150%
105
150%
158
150%
236
NM
1
NM
4
NM
7
NM
4
NM
3
NM
2
NM
3
100%
6
900%
25
50%
38
50%
56
50%
84
NM
0
250%
0
55%
0
-35%
1
-29%
0
-47%
0
56%
12
150%
18
300%
54
50%
81
50%
122
50%
182
NM
2
100%
2
0%
2
25%
2
-20%
4
-100%
3
NM
3
50%
6
200%
36
50%
54
50%
81
50%
122
NM
8
-17%
6
-21%
20
40%
4
90%
2
-35%
2
15%
1
100%
2
500%
22
50%
33
50%
50
50%
74
NM
0
-25%
0
238%
0
-82%
0
-53%
0
-12%
0
-33%
2
100%
4
1000%
40
50%
60
50%
90
50%
135
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
1
100%
2
900%
12
50%
18
50%
27
50%
41
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
100%
0
500%
36
50%
55
50%
82
50%
123
NM 20 NM 113 NM
NM 16 -18% 120 6%
Regional Demand
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Asia
Annual Solar Installations (MW)
Japan y/y (%) China y/y (%) S outh Korea y/y (%)
2001
122 NM 0 NM 1 NM 0
2002
16 1 32% 0 NM 1 -25% 0
2003
218 35% 0 NM 1 0% 11
2004
256 17% 5 NM 3 317% 13
2005
292 14% 15 200% 5 100% 16
2006
292 0% 20 33% 21 324% 12
2007
230 -21% 24 20% 42 100% 17
2008E
150 -35% 29 20% 85 100% 31
2009E
299 100% 58 100% 339 300% 132
2010E
508 70% 104 80% 678 100% 250
2011E
661 30% 166 60% 1,255 85% 475
2012E
760 15% 232 40% 1,632 30% 807
India y/y (%) Australia y/y (%) Other y/y (%) Total y/y (%)
NM
4
NM
6
NM
7
18%
7
23%
8
-25%
10
45%
16
80%
20
320%
70
90%
98
90%
126
70%
154
NM 43 NM 170 NM
17% 52 6% 355 6%
Regional Demand
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Americas
Annual Solar Installations (MW)
California y/y (%) New Jersey y/y (%) Nevada y/y (%) Colorado y/y (%) New York y/y (%) Hawaii y/y (%) Connecticut y/y (%) Arizona y/y (%) Massachuesets y/y (%) Oregon y/y (%) Other States y/y (%) US Total y/y (%) Canada y/y (%) Other y/y (%) Total y/y (%)
2001
30 NM 3 NM
0
2002
35 NM 5 NM
0
2003
45 NM
5
2004
48 NM
5
2005
52
2006
70
2007
97
2008E
165
2009E
280
2010E
420
2011E
713
2012E
1,070
NM
6
34%
18
39%
18
70%
21
70%
30
50%
45
70%
68
50%
101
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0.5
224%
3
0%
15
20%
22
40%
44
50%
74
50%
127
50%
215
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0.2
548%
1
356%
13
50%
39
100%
59
70%
99
70%
169
70%
287
NM 0 NM 0 NM 0 NM 0 NM
0
NM 0 NM 0 NM 0 NM 0 NM
0
NM 0 NM 0 NM 0 NM 0 NM
0
NM 0 NM 0 NM 0 NM 0 NM
0
NM
1
459%
3
1200%
4
200%
5
50%
8
70%
11
70%
15
70%
21
NM NM
0.2
105%
1
34%
3
40%
4
40%
5
40%
7
40%
10
40%
14
NM
1
225%
3
40%
4
40%
10
40%
20
40%
41
40%
81
NM
2
302%
2
257%
2
50%
3
170%
5
100%
10
100%
18
100%
35
NM
1
36%
2
0%
1
55%
2
55%
9
90%
17
90%
30
90%
54
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
NM
0
134%
1
-7%
1
65%
3
300%
5
80%
10
80%
21
80%
42
NM
4
NM
17
NM
16
NM
31
NM
43
42%
40
160%
64
100%
73
100%
84
100%
310
100%
734
100%
1,386
NM 37 NM
2
NM 57 54%
1
NM 66 16%
2
NM 84 27%
2
NM 105 25%
3
NM 40 NM 79 NM
Tier I Firms
Annual S upply (MT) 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008E 2009E 20 10E 2011E 2012E
TIER I - Total
Tier II Firms
Annual S upply (MT) 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008E 2009E 20 10E 2011E 2012E
Tier II Firms
Annual Supply (MT) 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008E 2009E 2010E 2011E 2012E
Germany
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Despite the recent change to the EEG, Germany should remain the worlds largest market Germany recently amended its Renewable Energy Law and has decided to accelerate the decrease of tariffs to 8% in 2009 and 2010 and 9% thereafter. The government has decided to increase/decrease incentives in the following year depending upon the level of installations in the previous year. The change in tariffs would be 1% depending on the following levels: 2009: 1.1GW 1.5GW annual installations 2010: 1.2GW 1.7GW annual installations 2011: 1.3GW 1.9GW annual installations
Solar Project IRR Summary
20 year incentive program; IRR assumes 15% ASP decline in 2009 Annual solar insolation: 1,250 kWh/sq. mtr 7.8% 7.8%
7,500 6,000 4,500 3,000 1,500 -
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
Spain
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
The new draft proposal could limit the growth in the Spanish market The government provides a feed-in tariff of 0.44/kWh for systems smaller than 100kW, 0.418 for system greater than 100kW, fixed for 25 years with 20% decrease thereafter. Current proposal expires in Sept. The current proposal approved by the CNE calls for a cap of 300MW on installations (100MW ground mounted, 200MW roof-top) and a feed-in tariff of 0.33/kWh (roof-top)/ 0.29/kWh (ground mounted). Additionally, government has proposed incentives for up to 200MW of installations that do not meet the September 2008 deadline.
Solar Project IRR Summary
25 year incentive program; IRR assumes 15% ASP decline in 2009 Annual solar insolation: 1,950 kWh/sq. mtr 14.3% 12.0%
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
United States
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
United States could emerge as a large market in 2H09 PV Demand in the US has been driven by the 30% federal tax credit which expires in 2008. Although there is no national feed-in tariff law, a number of state and municipal governments have provided incentives for PV. Seventeen states have committed to fund the installation of more than 10GWp of solar power in the next 15 years, with California, New Jersey, Arizona, Maryland, and Pennsylvania leading the charge.
4000 3000
Retail Electricity
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
10
Japan
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Japan plans to halve the cost of solar generation in 3-5 years through renewed subsidies The government in Japan plans to increase solar installed capacity to 4.8GW by 2010. Growth in the solar industry in Japan has stagnated since 2005 when the subsidies provided by the government lapsed. Despite this, solar electricity costs in Japan are near retail electricity costs. The government plans to reintroduce subsidies for installing solar panels in order to stimulate its industry.
600
300
Retail Electricity
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
11
South Korea
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
South Korea plans to raise solar PV cap from 100MW to 500MW in October 2008 Government has set a PV capacity target of 1.3GW by 2011. From October 2008, the government will provide tariffs for 15 years of 64c/kWh for 30kW-200kW, 61c/kWh for 200kW-1MW, 58c/kWh for 1MW-3MW and 49c/kWh for 3MW and above. The government plans to raise the cap from 100MW to 500MW. The government also provides support to the industry through joint R&D projects coordinated by the Korean Development Organization (KPVDO) since 2004.
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
12
France
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
France could emerge as a major market for BIPV due to its favorable tariff system The government plans to increase installed capacity of PV to 3GW by 2020. The French PV tariff program favors BIPV systems. It provides a basic tariff of 0.30/kWh in the mainland and 0.40/kWh in the overseas territories. A 0.50/kWh is provided for BIPV throughout France. Small private system market receives a 50% income tax credit, which at times represents approximately 50% of the solar module investments.
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
13
Italy
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Attractive IRRs in Italy could make it one of the most promising markets in Europe Italy plans to install 3GW of PV capacity by 2016. The government set up a PV tariff program in 2007 which is aimed to provide tariffs until a cap of 1.2GW is reached. The tariffs range from 0.40/kWh for 1-3kW, 0.38/kWh for 3-20kW and 0.36/kWh for >20kW non-integrated installations. Additional incentives of 0.04 - 0.05/kWh each are provided for partly integrated and fully integrated projects.
12.1%
13.3%
1200
600
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
14
Greece
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
The government will likely have to simplify its procedures in order to meet market expectations The government has set a target of 840MW of solar PV installations by 2020 with 640MW on the mainland and 200Mw on the islands. The current process is complicated due to annual caps by region and by market segment. Tariffs are provided for 20 years for the mainland grid of 0.45/kWh for systems less than 100kW and 0.40/kWh for other systems. A 0.05/kWh additional incentive for the autonomous grid. These are annually adjusted for inflation and retail price increase.
Solar Project IRR Summary
20 year incentive program; IRR assumes 15% ASP decline in 2009 Annual solar insolation: 1,550 kWh/sq. mtr 15.8% 16.8%
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
15
China
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Chinas focus has been more towards increasing solar hot water The government has set a target of 1.8GW of installed solar capacity by 2010. China has also set national goals for solar hot water, with a target of 150 million square miles by 2010 and 300 million square miles by 2020. China provides tariffs at preapproved rates. The rates depend on the region and are calculated on a cost plus reasonable margin basis.
$0.07
100 -
Retail Electricity
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
16
India
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Despite low IRRs, India could emerge as an attractive market due to sheer size India announced a feed-in tariff structure in Jan 2008, of Rs. 12/kWh ($0.30) for solar PV and Rs. 10/kWh ($0.25) for solar thermal power fed to the grid. The government has set a cap of 10MW per state and a cap of 5MW per developer under this initiative. A number of states are also planning to generate solar power such as West Bengal which expects to generate 50MW by 2015 and Punjab which plans to offer 100MW of solar PV power projects.
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
17
Australia
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Several state government feed-in tariff incentives could result in 50MW demand in 2009 State of South Australia provides A$0.44/kWh feed-in tariff for 20 years from July 08 for 10MW cap. Electricity supplier asked to increase solar tariff to $0.52/kWh from $0.07/kWh currently. Solar Cities Program for 3,400 solar panels or 6MW. Cash rebates A$8,000 with 6,000 households cap. Finally some state programs and a national program that integrates all state targets is expected by end of 08. 2008 shipments: 20MW, 2009 shipments: 50MW
Solar Project IRR Summary
20 year incentive program; IRR assumes 15% ASP decline in 2009 Annual solar insolation: 1,500 kWh/sq. mtr 10.0% 9.2%
120 90 60 30 -
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
18
Austria
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Austria can potentially replicate its success in solar thermal power with solar PV power Feed-in tariffs between 0.30 and 0.46 per kWh are to be paid over 10 years in 2008. 75% will be paid in the 11th year and 50% in the 12th year. Funding volume for renewable energy systems is to be increased to 21 million annually with the share of PV to increase to 12%. The government has created an additional 10,000 roofs program from April 2008 which provides a subsidy to private investors of 2.7/W - 2.8/W for rooftop and 3.5/W for faade installations for systems up to 5kW.
Solar Project IRR Summary Annual Solar Installations (MW)
12 year incentive program; IRR assumes 15% ASP decline in 2009 Annual solar insolation: 1,150 kWh/sq. mtr 5.9% 4.3%
100 80 60 40 20 -
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
19
Canada
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
With over 1GW of applications, the Canadian market appears set to take off in 2009 Ottawa has a fixed feed-in tariff of C$0.42/kWh for 20 years for all types of PV systems with no cap, although there is a 10MW cap on individual project size. It has also set a target of 100,000 solar roofs and retail sales tax rebate on solar equipment by Jan 1, 2010. The PV industry is seeking an increase in tariffs with graduated levels in order to increase residential installations with tariffs of C$0.82/kWh for systems <10kW, C$0.65/kWh for 1MW 2.5MW and C$0.42/kWh for systems up to 10MW.
Solar Project IRR Summary
20 year incentive program; IRR assumes 15% ASP decline in 2009 Annual solar insolation: 1,230 kWh/sq. mtr 4.6% 3.8%
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
20
Israel
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
The adoption of a new tariff for smaller PV systems may provide fresh impetus Israel provides feed-in tariffs for 20 years of 87.6Agorot/kWh ($0.242) for installations between 100kW - 20MW and 70.25Agorot/kWh ($0.194) for installations over 20MW. These are annually updated. It is expected to adopt a tariff for smaller PV systems in 2008 with the Public Utilities Association considering a tariff structure of ILS2.04/kWh ($0.564) for up to 15kW installations for residential and 50kW for commercial. These would be paid for 20 years and reduced by 4% per annum from 2010 with a cap of 50MW or 7 years.
Solar Project IRR Summary
20 year incentive program; IRR assumes 15% ASP decline in 2009 Annual solar insolation: 2,000 kWh/sq. mtr 16.8% 15.2%
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
21
Portugal
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Portugal plans to install 150MW solar by 2010 Portugal has a 150MW cap for solar PV until 2010. IPPs receive 0.445/kWh for systems below 5kW and 0.315/kWh for systems above 5kW for 15 years or a production of 21GWh/MW (for larger systems). Consumers can also sell 50% of their electricity to utilities which must purchase it at 100% of the tariffs for 10 years. From April 2008, it will provide 0.65 /kWh for up to 3.68kW systems for 5 years with a soft annual cap of 10MW, after which tariffs will be reduced by 5%.
Solar Project IRR Summary Annual Solar Installations (MW)
5 year incentive program; IRR assumes 15% ASP decline in 2009 Annual solar insolation: 1,680 kWh/sq. mtr 8.5% 6.3%
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
22
Switzerland
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Switzerland provides additional incentives for Building Attached and Building Integrated A draft was issued in Nov 2007 for an incentive structure for 25 years, which is expected to become effective from January 1, 2009 but be applicable to all operations after January 1, 2006. Tariffs of 0.39/kWh for the first 10kW, 0.33/kWh for 10kW - 30kW, 0.31/kWh for 30kW 100kW, and 0.30/kWh for systems over 100 kW with additional incentives for Building Attached and Building Integrated PV.
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
23
The Netherlands
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
The Netherlands has the potential to become a large solar market in 2010 The Dutch PV industry peaked in 2003 with installations of 20MW due to favorable support under subsidy schemes such as the Energy Premium Incentive. A feed-in tariff of 0.33/kWh is to be paid for 15 years for systems between 0.6kW and 3kW from April 2008. A net-metering tariff of 0.234/kWh is also provided.
75 60 45
1.9%
1.1%
30 15 -
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
24
Belgium
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Measures taken by several states could result in strong growth in the Belgian market Taxpayers are refunded 40% of investment costs of up to 2,440 in 2008. Net Metering is at the normal retail price of 0.15/kWh. Flanders provides green certificates which place a 0.45/kWh value on solar electricity for 20 years from the date of installation. A net metering compensation is also provided. Wallonie provides subsidies for 20% of the investment up to a limit of 3,500 per system.
8.1% 7.3%
100 75 50 25 0
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
25
Cyprus
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Cyprus has the worlds highest per capita solar thermal power Households are provided a grant of 55% of total system costs of up to 64,927 with the option to sell the electricity to the Electricity Authority of Cyprus at 0.205/kWh or receive a tariff of 0.383/kWh. Companies can sell generated electricity at 0.333/kWh in tariffs but are not eligible for PV grants. Standalone systems receive a grant of 55% of costs.
50 40 30 20 10 -
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
26
Czech Republic
Overview of Major Solar Market Incentives
Attractive IRRS in the Czech Republic could result in it becoming a major market The Czech Republic has set up two incentive options for system operators 0.49/kWh incentive in 2008 which is paid for 15 years and is 2.5% lower than the incentives paid in 2006 and 2007. A green bonus system which provides incentives of 0.48/kWh in 2008 for 15 years. The remuneration is adjusted to electricity prices annually.
250
2008
Source: IEA, Lehman Brothers Research
2009
2007
2008
2009E
2010E
2011E
2012E
27
28
29
30