Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Theory Index
Theory Index....................................................................................................................................1 Dispo Bad.........................................................................................................................................2 Dispo Good......................................................................................................................................3 Condo Bad.......................................................................................................................................4 Condo Good.....................................................................................................................................5 PICs Bad..........................................................................................................................................6 PICs Good........................................................................................................................................7 Floating PICs Bad............................................................................................................................8 Floating PICs Good..........................................................................................................................9 50 State Fiat Bad............................................................................................................................10 50 State Fiat Good.........................................................................................................................11 Multi Actor Fiat Bad......................................................................................................................12 Multi Actor Fiat Good...................................................................................................................13 Agent CPs Bad..............................................................................................................................14 Agent CPs Good...........................................................................................................................15 Consult CPs Bad...........................................................................................................................16 Consult CPs Good........................................................................................................................17 2NC CPs Bad................................................................................................................................18 2NC CPs Good.............................................................................................................................19 Utopian Fiat Bad............................................................................................................................20 Utopian Fiat Good..........................................................................................................................21 Vagueness Bad...............................................................................................................................22 Vagueness Good............................................................................................................................23 No Solvency Advocate Bad...........................................................................................................24 No Solvency Advocate Good.........................................................................................................25 No Alt Text Bad.............................................................................................................................26 No Alt Text Good..........................................................................................................................27 Textual Competition Good............................................................................................................28 Functional Competition Good........................................................................................................29 Lopez CP Bad................................................................................................................................30 Lopez CP Good..............................................................................................................................31 Multiple Perms Bad.......................................................................................................................32 Multiple Perms Good.....................................................................................................................33 Severance Perms Bad.....................................................................................................................34 Severance Perms Good..................................................................................................................35 Intrinsic Perms Bad........................................................................................................................36 Intrinsic Perms Good.....................................................................................................................37 Intrinsic DA Perms Bad.................................................................................................................38 Intrinsic DA Perms Good...............................................................................................................39 Perf Con Bad..................................................................................................................................40 Perf Con Good...............................................................................................................................41 Advocating Perms Bad..................................................................................................................42 Advocating Perms Good................................................................................................................43
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Dispo Bad
1. Kills Education a. Conditionality in disguise the neg knows it puts us at a strategic disadvantage to straight turn the cp/k so they can just kick them later. b. Not real world policy makers have to deal with the consequences of proposing an action. They cant just pretend they didnt read it if someone questions them about it. 2. Ground a. Strategy and time skew the neg can just read a bunch of dipso counterplans and moot 2AC answers by kicking almost all of them in the block because the aff cant fairly turn all the different counterplans. b. Race to the bottom Forcing the aff win offense on the counterplan by straight turning vs. the negs net benefits leads to a race to the bottom. c. Perms key to aff ground checks back non-competitive and artificially competitive counterplans 3. Straight turns dont check its suicide not to perm in most instances, it puts the neg into a strategic advantage. 4. Reciprocity the aff is forced to stick with one advocacy, so should the neg. 5. Err aff on theory debate has changed, statistically neg wins more rounds. When was the last time you wanted to be aff in an outround? 6. Voter for fairness, ground and education
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Dispo Good
1. Education a. Best policy option real policy makers are never confined to just one solution to a problem or forced to pass it no matter the consequences. b. Forces strategic 2AC answers promotes critical, in-round thinking from the affirmative. 2. Ground -a. Neg flex Our only burden is to disprove the plan. Arguing from multiple levels is vital to negative strategy which outweighs because its key to checking aff bias and we have a right to make strategic 2NR decisions. 3. Non-unique -- All other negative arguments are dispo. 4. Time skew is inevitable for the aff with 13 minutes in the block. 5. Aff choice -- the aff literally decides whether or not the neg can kick the cp. 6. Err neg on theory aff gets first and last speeches and unlimited prep. 7. Not a voter -- Reject the argument not the team.
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Condo Bad
1. Education - Depth over Breadth Theres an incentive for the neg to read 11 conditonal counterplans and net benefits for us to undercover one and then kick out of everything else in the block. 2. Not reciprocal the aff cant just kick its advantages whenever it wants. Conditionality kills fairness because the neg can just kick out of the cp/k even if we kick it. 3. Time skew- Any arguments read against the cp or k can instantly go away if the neg doesnt want to go for it. 4. Strat skew- weve already done our 2ac, there is in round abuse. We cant change what weve already gone for. 5. Potential and in round abuse are voting issues for fairness and education.
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Condo Good
1. Best for education- forcing the aff to make critical decisions maximize the education in debate. 2. Best for fairness- aff gets first and last speech, and 8 minutes in the 1ac. Multiple conditional advocacies are the only way to check. 3. Multiple worlds good forces the aff to think critically on how to answer certain arguments and is key to negative flexibility. 4. Most real world laws that go through Congress can be instantly rejected if they are not good enough. 5. Making the neg a moving target is key to having non-repetitive debates. 6. Err aff on theory -- neg gets the block and can control the outcome of the debate by strategically picking certain arguments. 7. Not a voter - reject the argument not the team.
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
PICs Bad
1. Bad for education a. Unfair: makes the aff debate themselves.
b. Resolutional shift: concentrates the debate on insignificant aspects of the counterplan c. Encourages vague plan writing to avoid PICs.
2. Ground explodes neg ground because there is an infinite amount of things that they can pic out of. 3. Err aff on theory neg gets the block and can control the outcome of the debate by strategically picking certain arguments. 4. Voter for fairness, ground, and education.
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
PICs Good
1. Ground a. Aff should be prepared to defend the entire plan text, PICs prove the plan is a bad idea in at least one instance. b. pics c. 2. Most cps are pics the ability to test the agent is destroyed if we cant run Key to checking extra topical plan planks
Education a. Forces better plan writing the aff will write their plan more strategically
b. Depth over Breadth focuses the debate on specifics of the policy which is better for topical education. 3. Lit checks abuse there is only a few things we can functionally pic out which answers their infinite regression argument. 4. 5. Err neg on theory aff gets first and last speech and infinite prep. Not a voter, reject the argument not the team.
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
b. Key to negative ground everything except for the plan is fair game after the 1AC and key to neg flex. 2. Education a. Most real world We learn about the interaction between the different relevant various policymakers. There is never just a single actor. b. Best policy option if the best policy option is with multiple actors than that is better for education. 3. Multi-actor fiat is default the aff automatically fiats 500 congressman, the president, and the courts alone. 4. No reasonable regress as long as we dont fiat two random obscure actors we should be entitled to more than one. 5. 6. Err neg on theory aff gets first and last speech plus infinite prep No voter - reject the argument and not the team
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Vagueness Bad
1. Vagueness kills ground a. Moving target: Vagueness can make the aff a moving target which kills predictability they can spike out of disads or change plan planks vital to the function of the counterplan. b. Time and strat skew all our arguments are predicated upon the plan text as per the 1AC. Later clarifying actual implementation is completely abusive. 2. It slays education a. Sketchiness -- If the plan is unclear, we cant learn about the specific results of the plan because the details of actual implementation are murky at best and which kills education about real world policies. b. Generics Unclear specification means stuck with running generic arguments to just guarantee a link. 3. Err neg on theory aff gets first and last speech plus unlimited prep. 4. Voter for fairness and education.
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Vagueness Good
1. No link -- The plan is not vague ___________________ 2. Increases education a. Breadth over depth -- it forces a discussion about more of the resolution which is the best way to evaluate the topic because we have a wider grasp of poverty and applicable social services. 3. Increases neg ground A vague plan allows the neg to run more disads or kritiks because we link to more arguments and we wont spike out of their specific links. 4. C-x checks you had three minutes to clarify anything you didnt understand after the 1AC, its not our fault you think were vague. 5. Not a bill it is just a plan text with resolved intent, we dont have to specify ever minute detail. 6. Err neg on theory -- aff gets first and last speech and unlimited prep. 7. Not a voter - Reject the argument not the team.
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Lopez CP Bad
1. Justifies multi-actor fiat the cp uses multi actors which jacks predictability and allows the neg to selectively pick actors to out solve the aff. 2. No literature there is zero evidence on a Supreme Court ruling to devolve power to the states and then have complete uniformity. Lit is crucial for predictability and aff offense. 3. No test case they cant fiat a test case occurring otherwise its object fiat which is an independent voter because it means they can essentially fiat anything. 4. Artificial competition the counterplan is only artificially competitive by banning the plan, which destroys fairness and doesnt test opportunity costs of the plan. 5. Err aff on theory neg gets the block and can control the outcome of the debate by strategically picking certain arguments. 6. Voter for fairness and ground.
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Lopez CP Good
1. Multi-actor fiat is default the aff automatically fiats 500 congressman, the president, and the courts alone. No reason why one more actor is any worse. 2. Increases aff ground they can read a courts disad. 3. Increases education we can learn about how the judicial branch and the constitution interact with federal policy. 4. Err neg on theory - aff gets first and last speech and unlimited prep. 5. Not a voter - Reject the argument not the team.
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell
Power is inflicting pain and humiliation. Power is tearing human minds to pieces. George Orwell