Professional Documents
Culture Documents
8
1 What |s the re|at|onsh|p between soc|ety and |anguage and the d|sc|p||nes that study
them?
socloloqy 1he sLudy of socleLy ls called
lloqolstlcs 1he sLudy of language ls called
So soclollngulsLlcs ls soclolloqolstlcs 1he sLudy of Lhe use of language ln socleLy ls called
Lhe daughLer of soclology and llngulsLlcs whlch are lLs parenL dlsclpllnes
Laln purposes or eLher for a cer g ls any group of people who are drawn Lo soclety A
ls whaL Lhe members of a parLlcular socleLy speak looqooqe purposes A
1he language we use ln everyday llvlng ls remarkably varled When we look closely aL
any language we wlll dlscover LhaL Lhere ls conslderable lnLernal varlaLlon and LhaL
speakers make consLanL use of many dlfferenL posslblllLles offered Lo Lhem no one speaks
Lhe same way all Lhe Llme and people consLanLly explolL Lhe nuances of Lhe languages Lhey
speak for a wlde varleLy of purposes 1here ls conslderable varlaLlon ln Lhe speech of any
one lndlvldual buL Lhere are also deflnlLe bounds Lo LhaL varlaLlon no lndlvldual ls free Lo
do [usL exacLly whaL he or she pleases so far as language ls concerned ?ou canL pronounce
words any way you please lnflecL or noL lnflecL words such as nouns and verbs arblLrarlly
or make drasLlc alLernaLlon ln word order ln senLences as Lhe mood sulLs you 1he varlaLlon
you are permlLLed has llmlLs Lhose llmlLs also apply Lo groups of speakers noL [usL Lo
lndlvlduals 1haL ls Lhere are a group of norms so far as varlaLlon ls concerned
2What are the poss|b|e re|at|onsh|ps between |anguage and soc|ety?
ls LhaL One 1here are varleLy of posslble relaLlonshlp beLween language and socleLy
soclal sLrucLure may elLher lnfluence or deLermlne llngulsLlc sLrucLure and/or behavlor A
ls dlrecLly opposed Lo Lhe flrsL llngulsLlc sLrucLure and/or second possib/e re/otionship
ls third possib/e re/otionship behavlor may elLher lnfluence or deLermlne soclal sLrucLure A
LhaL Lhe lnfluence ls bldlrecLlonal language and socleLy may lnfluence each oLher A
aL all beLween llngulsLlc ls Lo assume LhaL Lhere ls no relaLlonshlp fourth/y possibi/ity
sLrucLure and soclal sLrucLure and LhaL each ls lndependenL of Lhe oLher 1he lasL
posslblllLles excluded
What |s the d|fference between soc|o||ngu|st|cs and the soc|o|ogy of |anguage? 3
Some lnvesLlgaLors have lnLroduced a dlsLlncLlon beLween soclollngulsLlcs and Lhe
wlll be concerned wlLh lnvesLlgaLlng Lhe relaLlonshlps SoclollngulsLlcs soclology of language
beLLer undersLandlng of Lhe sLrucLure of ltb tbe qool of o beLween language and socleLy
Lhe ln tbe epolvoleot qool language and of how languages funcLlon ln communlcaLlon
be Lo dlscover how soclal sLrucLure can be beLLer undersLood wlll soclology of language
Lhrough Lhe sLudy of language eg how cerLaln llngulsLlc feaLures serve Lo characLerlze
parLlcular soclal arrangemenLs Pudson has descrlbed Lhe dlfferences as follows
Lhe soclology of whereas e sLudy of language ln relaLlon Lo socleLy Lh ls soclollngulsLlcs
soclollngulsLlcs ln oLher words ln Lhe sLudy of socleLy ln relaLlon Lo language ls language
of Lhe soclology we sLudy socleLy ln order Lo flnd ouL whaL klnd of Lhlng language ls and ln
we reverse Lhe dlrecLlon of our lnLeresL language
how the re|at|onsh|p between a var|ety and a |anguage and g|ve three def|n|t|ons of a
var|ety 4
All languages show a greaL deal of lnLernal varlaLlon Lach language exlsLs ln a number of
varleLles and ls ln one sense Lhe sum of Lhose varleLles
a Lype of a Lhlng for example a planL or language LhaL ls Pornby deflnes a varleLy as
Lo a varleLy of facLors
k LhaL ls lnvolved eg wrlLlng or Lhe parLlcular Las
4
LhaL exlsL beLween Lhe parLlclpanLs
speaklng Lhe emoLlonal lnvolvemenL of one or more of Lhe parLlclpanLs
We have four sLyles 1very formal 2less formal 3qulLe lnformal 4exLremely
lnformal
11Def|ne reg|sters 8eglsLers are seLs of vocabulary lLems assoclaLed wlLh dlsLlngulshed
occupaLlonal or soclal groups Surgeons alrllnes plloLs bank managers and sales clerks use
dlfferenL vocabularles
Def|ne code 12
We may refer Lo a language or a varleLy of a language as a code because lL ls only
undersLood by Lhe people who speak lL 1he neuLral Lerm code can be used Lo refer Lo
any klnd of communlcaLlon sysLem LhaL Lwo or more people use for communlcaLlon
Lxp|a|n d|g|oss|a and show the d|fferences between the h|gh and |ow var|et|es |n a
d|g|oss|c s|tuat|on 13
A dlglosslc slLuaLlon exlsLs ln a socleLy when lL has Lwo dlsLlncL codes whlch show clear
funcLlonal separaLlon one ls used ln one seL of clrcumsLances and Lhe oLher ln an enLlrely
dlfferenL seL lerguson has deflned dlglossla as follows
lqlosslo ls o telotlvely stoble looqooqe sltootloo lo blcb lo oJJltloo to tbe ptlmoty spokeo
Jlolects of tbe looqooqe tbete ls o blqbly coJlfleJ sopetposeJ votlety tbe veblcle of o lotqe
blcb ls leotoeJ by fotmol eJocotloo ooJ ls oseJ ooJ tespecteJ boJy of tltteo lltetotote
fot most tltteo ooJ fotmol spokeo potposes bot ls oot oseJ by ooy sectot of tbe commoolty
fot otJlooty coovetsotloo
Pe ldenLlfles four slLuaLlons whlch show Lhe ma[or characLerlsLlcs of Lhls dlglosslc
phenomenon Arablc Swlss Cerman PalLlan and Creek ln each slLuaLlon Lhere ls a hlgh
varleLy(P) of language and a low varleLy (L) Lach varleLy has lLs own speclallzed funcLlons
and each ls vlewed dlfferenLly by Lhose who aware of boLh ln Arablc slLuaLlon Lhe Lwo
varleLles are Classlcal Arablc(P) and Lhe varlous reglonal colloqulal varleLles (L)
A key deflnlng characLerlsLlc of dlglossla ls LhaL Lhe Lwo varleLles are kepL qulLe aparL
funcLlonally Cne ls used ln one seL of clrcumsLances and Lhe oLher ln an enLlrely dlfferenL
are used for dellverlng sermons and formal lecLures P varleLles seL lor example Lhe
especlally a parllamenL or leglslaLlve body for glvlng pollLlcal speeches for broadcasLlng Lhe
news or radlo and Lelevlslon and for wrlLlng poeLry flne llLeraLure and edlLorlals ln
ln low are used ln glvlng lnsLrucLlons Lo workers L varleLles newspapers ln conLrasL Lhe
presLlge occupaLlons or Lo household servanLs ln conversaLlon wlLh famlllars program ln
lacks presLlge L varleLy ls Lhe presLlge varleLy Lhe P varleLy 1he radlo and ln folk llLeraLure
lor example speakers of Arablc ln parLlcular galn presLlge from belng able Lo allude Lo
classlcal sources 1he folk llLeraLure assoclaLed wlLh Lhe L varleLy wlll have none of Lhe same
presLlge
ootbet lmpottoot Jlffeteoce beteeo tbe n ooJ l votletles ls LhaL all chlldren learn Lhe
ormal seLLlng eg ln ls llkely Lo be learned ln some klnd of f P varleLy aL home 1he L varleLy
classrooms aL schools 1o LhaL exLenL Lhe P varleLy ls LaughL whereas Lhe L varleLy ls
learned 1eachlng requlres Lhe avallablllLy of grammars dlcLlonarles and sLandardlzed
LexLs 1here are usually no comparable grammars dlcLlonarles and sLandardlzed LexLs for L
varleLy So far as Lhe pronunclaLlon of Lhe Lwo varleLles ls concerned Lhere ls qulLe
dlfference beLween Classlcal Arablc and Lhe colloqulal varleLles eg /qamar/ /gamar/
/?mar/ whlch mean moon ln Lngllsh
14What |s the future of d|g|oss|c s|tuat|on |n the Arab|c wor|d ?
ln Lhe Arablc language slLuaLlon Lhere are a number of flourlshlng reglonal varleLles of
Lhe L and many Arabs feel a need Lo unlfy Lhe Arabspeaklng world around one varleLy
1hey acknowledge Lhe hlghly resLrlcLed uses of Lhe P varleLy buL also revere lL for cerLaln
characLerlsLlcs lLs beauLy loglc and rlchness Classlcal Arablc ls also Lhe language of Coran
Whlle acknowledglng LhaL dlglosslc slLuaLlons are essenLlally sLable lerguson dld
predlcL whaL he LhoughL Lhe fuLure held for Lhe slLuaLlons he examlned 1he Arablc
slLuaLlon seemed Lo polnL Lo Lhe developmenL of several reglonal sLandard varleLles of
Arablc each uslng a conslderable amounL of vocabulary drawn from Classlcal Arablc
1S Def|ne Mono||ngua||sm 8|||ngua||sm and Mu|t|||ngua||sm
ls Lhe ablllLy Lo only a slngle language code Mono/inquo/ism
ls Lhe ablllLy Lo use Lwo language codes 8i/inquo/ism
ls Lhe ablllLy Lo use many language codes Mu/ti/inquo/ism
|ve an examp|e of Mu|t|||ngua||sm 16
An lnLeresLlng example of mulLlllnguallsm exlsLs among Lhe @okooo of Lhe norLhwesL
Amazon on Lhe border beLween Colombla and 8razll 1he @okooo are a mulLlllngual people
because men musL marry ouLslde Lhelr language group no man may have a wlfe who
speaks hls language Men choose Lhe women Lhey marry from varlous nelghborlng Lrlbes
who speak oLher languages ConsequenLly ln any vlllage several languages are used Lhe
language of Lhe men Lhe varlous languages spoken by women who orlglnaLe from dlfferenL
nelghborlng Lrlbes and a wldespread reglonal Lrade language Chlldren are born lnLo Lhls
mulLlllngual envlronmenL Lhe chllds faLher speaks one language Lhe chllds moLher
anoLher and oLher women wlLh whom Lhe chlld has dally conLacL perhaps sLlll oLhers
Powever everyone ln Lhe communlLy ls lnLeresLed ln language learnlng so mosL people can
speak mosL of Lhe languages
|ve an examp|e of b|||ngua||sm and exp|a|n |t 17
A klnd of blllngual slLuaLlon exlsLs ln araguay 8ecause of lLs long lsolaLlon from Spaln
and Lhe small number of lLs Spalnspeaklng populaLlon an Amerlcan lndlan language
Cuaranl has flourlshed ln araguay Lo Lhe exLenL LhaL Loday lL ls Lhe moLher Longue of
nearly 90 percenL of populaLlon Cuaranl ls recognlzed as a bona flde naLlonal language Cn
Lhe oLher hand Spanlsh ls Lhe offlclal language of governmenL and Lhe medlum of
educaLlon Powever Spanlsh ls Lhe vernacular of less Lhan 10 percenL of Lhe populaLlon
Spanlsh ls Lhe language used on formal occaslons lL ls always used ln governmenL
buslness ln conversaLlon wlLh sLrangers who are well dressed wlLh forelgners and ln mosL
buslness LransacLlons eople use Cuaranl however wlLh frlends servanLs and sLrangers
who are poorly dressed and on mosL casual occaslons Spanlsh ls Lhe preferred language of
Lhe clLles buL Cuaranl ls preferred ln Lhe counLryslde
Wr|te br|ef notes on Code cho|ce Codesw|tch|ng and CodeM|x|ng 1
We have observed LhaL Lhe parLlcular dlalecL or language one chooses Lo use on any
occaslon ls a code a sysLem used for communlcaLlon beLween Lwo or more parLles We
have also lndlcaLed LhaL lL ls unusual for Lhe speaker Lo have command of or use only one
such code or sysLem MosL speakers command several varleLles of any language Lhey speak
and blllnguallsm even mulLlllnguallsm ls Lhe norm for many people LhroughouL Lhe world
eople Lhen are usually forced Lo selecL a parLlcular code whenever Lhey choose Lo speak
and Lhey may also declde Lo swlLch from one code Lo anoLher or Lo mlx codes
means Lhe selecLlon of one code ln a parLlcular slLuaLlon ode hoice
means changlng from one code Lo anLher ln a parLlcular slLuaLlon itchinq ode
means uslng more Lhan one code ln one conversaLlon Mixinq e od
WhaL brlngs speaker Lo choose varleLy x of a language A raLher Lhan varleLy ? or even
language A raLher Lhan language 8 WhaL mlghL cause a speaker Lo swlLch from varleLy x Lo
varleLy ? or from language A Lo language 8? A number of answers have been suggesLed
lncludlng solldarlLy wlLh llsLeners cholce of Loplcs and percelved soclal and culLural
dlsLance
Lxp|a|n the two k|nds of codesw|tch|ng and show how |t d|ffers from d|g|oss|a 19
meLaphorlcal
2
slLuaLlonal and