Professional Documents
Culture Documents
"#$
5 6 78 %
''
%&( )
/
12340 .*+ ,-
!
0 /& ' ( "!
%
&'
"
* + ,-.
% ""
! "#$
%1
* .
) -, 2
2 I* " A 2
, G )* @* A 2
)
2
V
" E6
%HLG
)
)* j ,
) 6,"
)QD \
"" ) X* 6
"
4*
.d
)" e
2 E6 i ( "! 2
k
6,"
)
:0
,Y
U* ,
" 6 U*
$
l mD
5A b ! ) J
@D 2 f
F_
HPennsylvaniaG *
] ( "! 2
). " *
"
5" J
2 , ] ^*
LM`a 8
H)
X#' 2 Y J
2
*@
U* V 5"
2Y
)+@
#
R <6
" 6
E*
! W2 & ,
U )
4*
S QT 2
HMorris Jastrow JR G U3
F _ SBh
) )
@,' H( "!
4 , < 2 HLMLPOLMLNG & 4
HgG 1 " )
)]
! 2 *
Q!
"!
E* 2
@,Y Y 4*
!)
/ * ) J
) c
7 8
[ \ )* ,D O8
" 6
) *
9
,
4*
>
BC %
"
) D )W<! " 6 4* %
" 6 BC % !
(# $
2
)
% Z. ) 8
2
* )* ,D * )*
*@ J $)
45
. " * )
2 ,
4 "K %
) "!
! )* @* A
F # BC % ",! " )D
7 8
* : ;#,< = <!
)?'
#$
W@
@2
! )",Q
S* 6
* " *
%k " ) ']
)",Q $
" )
,A *Z
2 A
2
)*
"
3 )9 <!
!S* :
D @ 4*
@ 4*
"!
Q,' D @ "3 (
k" )
J']
)* D ,
"!
V 7<
)
k" )
Q 2
2 *
D @ 4*
X* 9
%k " ) )
E3
25 ,
E*
7<
2 = <! 4*
* @ 2 4 "3 k %
Q! )*
U
V
),
k @ 7<
] q "6. r
) .d ), 5A
n
p@A )
%k*
#] )
2
2 D@ o
7 A 2 S - ",
, . SBh 4*
! )* !_I 2
%k " ) 8 $ J@ 2
,
Q,' SBh 4*
%
@2
2
E
, A 2
c]
)* @* A 2
)*
d
.d
%k " ) J@
:2
Q,' 2 j ,
" 6
)* 8 $ J@ O 8 7<
);D
"The isolated nature of Sumerian is further brought into relief when we take
a look at certain typological features of the language. In contrast to all the
surrounding languages, Sumerian has ergative argument marking and, as
Nichols (1994) has shown, ergativity is relatively stable."
Prof. Piotr Michalowski
University of Michigan
Ann Arbor
http://www-personal.umich.edu/~piotrm/cv1.htm
/ ]
*
25
&B
% !)
),* ,.
U O2
6 HLMMPG( #
) "! s )
! )
,. 2
), T
U*
/ D @ J9
The Life and Death of the Sumerian Language in Comparative
Perspective
: ! ,A .
] 4*
http://www-personal.umich.edu/~piotrm
)j
Sumerian is a language isolate, meaning that it has no relatives living or
dead (though there have been unsuccessful attempts to connect Sumerian to
a number of languages).
"3 G
%1H
XA
),Q o
E* 2
' 2
)"' 4*
-"
U* 2
tQ 2
! V h 2 fB
http://ccat.sas.upenn.edu/psd/
Prof. Steve Tinney, Middle Eastern Languages, Sumerian specialist
:
<
7 ] 4*
# " E6
F _ ( "!
4*
@A
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2002/07/0723_020724_cuneiform.
html
)u
Sumerian is an isolated language: there is no evidence that it is
related to any other language at all, living or dead. It certainly
cannot be connected with Indo-European (IE) or Semitic, nor can these
two be related to each other.
2 E*
,! )
4*
* )*
6
" 2
)
)e Q
" @*
_h
4* %
%1
-" )
,! 2
)e Q
E*
6*
*
*
4*
4* % , "!
6*
-" )
2
%1
0
2]
! ) 2
^*
-,
56 2 5 ,
) *
) j , 4*
: ]
4, 4 , < %
w* 2
]
x Y
7 8
2 "
H4* 5"D 4 G
2 ,-. )
+ z" A
%
2
%
x AB
o
!
4*
\
4*_E* ]
2 ,
, 4* 2
4*
% !) t
4* k
R<6
4* 45
) "] )
"Y
"Y
^8
])
)
B
_
7 8 yL``
Q* @
% ! ) ^*
2
1J'A 8 '- JY A0 S 9 2
! ;6 2
), "!
, B
2
. . *
# ] ,
) 4* % "* ) # ]
4*
2 ,
2
)
)0S W _
4 "K %
)
_ _
E6 i 2
!)
4* ,5
2
.) 4 '
s ] J'A JW, 2
. 2
U )
,
3.
4*
4*
c
, .
2,
4 '
R <6
. }*
) }QY }* d
% }
) %k "
-,
,-. |\
"'
,5
poets
" A
"' 2
Post position
~ "* ^ ~ d
s h!
Y ! )"'*
ergative
8 C 2 % ! ,A .
)#Y A cD $
h* 2 I
V 5- "3 | {
! ) ,-. ),D
open J'A ) #E
)D '-
" %
7 S QY * d
-,
^ % "* . )
! Q,!
%k "
# ]
)k )
8 C 2 % " ) ;* '
"* ^ k
)
-,
). _ 2 7D 3
/) "!
}3 4}
)D '- O)#Y A
!)
4}
)*
6 2 #
5] 4*
A 2 i* 2 2 !
"!
! ) A { J'A
< was )
# ] )
V + J'A
J'A 2 ,
. 4< * discourse
% * E Q,!
) " x YG
4,A
2 E*
6 *
m j ,
! , "!
Y2
U*
2
, 2
%1
j ,
"Y
%
! , "!
7 V
2]
WY )D
Y % * . )* 6._ ),
* .2
4* 45 2
4*
5] 2
0
)
)< p 8
A9
l -m 2 ,
6*
!)
[ D
)
) :
6A ) 2 )E E*
"K 2
1
m
2
6*
,
$A
.d 0
*
)[
,A * '
2
)D
4, < 2
4* %
! %V%u V
_ 8 e
2
2
j "]
2
] j ,
* .) .
m )
4* 45
j "]
"Y 2
7
)#9 2
S T k :Y
)Q "
%1 !
)Q,
A
2
B
0
7 yL``
7 g```
! 4*_. 2 ] H)# O2 ! G
_. 2
4* )
-" )
% !
. "* .
! A
E* 2
WY
'
'
G
s ]
E*
"
j,
) "! 2
2 j, 4
4, < j,
X @m
) )
2 D@ o
) " ( "! 2
"" ) )! A J?A
% ",
) "!
%)* ,D 2
)D
3
"3
-. )
-,
ID
( "!
) ,
S #
4*
6*
4*
Je B 2
: 4*
)
%
T
8+ ,
)"'
) #E )#9 4,
CA
)E6*
"
A 4* 8+ ,
2 h
I )'$
bb
q "6. r
)$ W,D
-# 2
] 2 h
F _ ( "!
S #
Q,' "
: k*
Z +
) * 2 Y 4 "K
2
) .d
\
% ",
,
]k
8 'h
)e A R<! 4*
_A S ID
6* 4,
)
U* 2
S -, 2
4*
) * )* ,D
) A
h 2 A LML 8
A 4* * %
* E
%k*
O V 7<
" 2 h
#h G Q,' S * 6
! * A 4 "K %
,6 2
2 D@ ) ,
){ A
2
d
2 2
& _. 2 Y
. X* e )D % ! ) 2
6 S QT _ )* ,D O8
5] Hb)
CA ) 5] Q,' #h
E6 4* F _
U* o /8 7< h ,
,
2 h
" 6
Q ,
6* )
2 % !
6* U*
H)* ,D )D
6 %
4*
x A2
-,
2 h
* ,D O)D
) )" ' 2
,-. 4
%
)" d 2 *
5"
"
{ * k
%k " A ) ) E 2 h . t A 4*
A
k*
"
! 8+ ,
"6
,!Z. 8
)#
2 4
,
! , "! )
,Y J $
2 ).i*
"3
) "!
_D
2]
,!
4,
'$ 4* 0
k#$
* !
*
"Y
! ,!
E 2 2 Y$%
2 ).i*
02
!)
$ S -, )*
k @0
Q! % . )
",
2
%%
!)
) .d
%% )* *_D
%%)._D 2
) D 2
6*
)*
* 2
)#
8C 2
K )* @* A 2
K 2 *
D , )
2 + )"K3 )] .
2 <
'
"3 2 ,
1%
:
*_
"" ) S QT
Q! k E*
) .d ) "!
@* A
7 i
)
" 7<
4*
E6 i
2Y JD
2 "'
! *
! ,!
1% "" ) [ \
] D @ 4*
). K 4 Y
! " $BY
Q! 2 d
2Y
.d
4*
" 6 4* 2
J Y
, 2
E*
) ] 4*
] 2
, 4*
t
" ) 8\ _
D @ J9 %
)*
K )*
@-$ 2
" 2
. )* *_ )# 2
)D
)* ,D 2
2
"
)*
" )
2 < 8C 2 0/ * .)
4*
2 <
^ o
) p
)Y {
. ] * )-* W 2
k - 4* 4
$ Z.
. *
* *
)E,
/V
h , 4*
"Y
"
2 ).i*
)-* W
H . ]
E* k "
) * 5"
ID ,
ID ,
)-* W 2
ID ,
"
QY
8C 2 %
7
.d
4*
2
)" d 2 *
2
5"
k*
) .d
{ * k
)*
" )
% ! )
xA
E*
: 4*
4*
5] 4*
.
2
"
2 "
)* *
\
A2
" 2
)
)#
_ G
. )
\ G 2 #5
)
"K
k 2Y ^ o 8
6 %
"
U B
) Y
2 ,D O)D
4*
, 2
G .
4 "K % ""
)-* W
l mD 2
h,
@
1%
"! ) )-* W )
2 h
7 i 5D
) #E
parent, parenthood
" *
)D
)E E3 4 :
k "! ) J@, )
2 J'A ,
2
)
$ *
2 " ,
4*
! 2
)#
4* " 2 ).i*
)$
! ,A *Z , 4*
%
4 "K
U* '
2 h
2
, .
2
)
x A2
-,
) )" '
)
U* *
%
)D
*+&
T
* ]2
, cD $ G )#9 )*
8 5h 8 '- k
He (was) hit
D
"
1 ,!Z.
2 ,
0 H2 "
2]
* .f
) , ] ) h"
A H4 ' ){
JY A H2 5 G k @,
$ H)* *
" 2
8 '-
k* $ 2 _
,!Z.
2 % A .)
]
* ]
2 ,
) *2
by me .
h,
k* $ ) #
D G k @,
% A.
).i* 4*
3%
; '{
! * ).i*
x 9
% Q)
& 9 )D
2 %
) . .s
4* \
) .d k -
).
x A )D
25
S 9
B
!)
S QT
* )" $
"3 % !
2 ).i* )
.S 9
x A
62 %
,A *
-,
1d . 0 )
'
]
GF #
4 +
BY %
k @ ,
4* * t Q
2 "
.0
# ] ,
* ] ) #E
Q! ,6 2 ,
!k
2 ,
)
2
6*
)" 3
"3 2 ,
2 ,
*@ J $)
. t
)* h U 2 4 4,!
",
8 !
] o
Hy``` 7 *G y```
!) 4 '
] 2 d
#E 2
* @ 2 I* O " A 2
"3 *
5" J'A
]
) "!
,
)# D
).i* 4*
) C
6*
%)
5]
@,' H( "!
_A J'A
%1
2 "
2 @-$ 2
'
] H)* ,D G)D
)*
)D
.) S 9
D U* S ! _
! )6*
! > ;* ' 0
) "3
) 2 ,D
] )D '- * { %
14 0
. ).i*
"3 %
BY 2
) 2
).i*
A U*
k
), "!
2
2 6*
2
)
4*
R <6
H)
, G )* @* A 2
56
4 , < 2 G LMLP
%1
: h,
)D
)* ,D 2
k "
%2
2 )
ID "3
S ID
"
ID
5A U* D @ 4* 4,!
.V
5A 4* % "! )
,"*
2Y
S #'] /V
Q,'
]
7<
"3 ,
4
4*
" Y
2 S -
ID ) ,
U* )
]
l mD 2
4*
ID
)
ID 4* % !
ID ,
'
",ID
/ ! )
) *
W 2 % , A
" J'] 2
.d
), Q! o
m-9 4*
Q,'
www.sumerian.org
:
k*
",ID 4* q "6. r
* .)
) Y
)
BC 2
4 "K
4* %k " ,A . *
k,- 8 $ J@ 'D \
"
) Y
"
4 "K % ",
!
"
) k
! ) 2
%
) Y
2
)"'*
6* U* (umum)
1 0 d
4* 4 "K
k" )
Q! ) 9 :
) D O
k )
) D
d 4* k V
%k
) s ] D @ 4* V 7<
2
j u
U* 2
H G)
ID ) #E
% ! ) )
h"*
(Omm) V 0
! h"*
2
* (ama)
", d
W 2
.d
% ! ) 2
)"'* ) D
"" Y
ID
2
2
1 0
2
! )Y
",ID U*
X @m
,A
% ! ) iki- )
di, a
Iten
min
ina
ala
limmu
Erbe
ia
hami
edi
imin
sebe
ussu
samane
ilimmu
tie
10
eer
11
u-di (?)
iteneret
13
alaer
17
sebeer
20
ni
era
30
uu
alaa
40
nimin
erba
50
ninnu
hama
60
gi, ge
ui
100
me'at
600
geu
nerum
1000
lim
limum
3600
ar
arum
4* 2
Y * b
ikki
:k ,A *
Y 4*
Y )*
14 0
, ), Q! o
k* E k
k" J Y ,
Y R<! 4* 4 "K
H7* G 2
a`a`ya``
2
)
! ) -# 14 0 2
ya``
6+ 2
"* . )
<
2 E" d
! )
) ,"*
",ID
)"'
) *2
E"*
"
= W
.
A .
)*
k* E
Aj
k 2 E* S #
4*
3 * )"'* 2
E"* d
)
)"' 2
-. ,
" 2
"
:k ,A .
)"'* )
2
Y 2
",
E"* 7 *
"2
. % ! ) L`L`L``` k
G i d
2
"
4 + 14 0
b1 0 )
)\ )*
1) * 0
"
4 "K
HyG2
* + )*
U*G2
4
! k
6* U* H)
.
b ",
# BC % "! U* _
2 E" d )D %
5A %f 7 ! d * % ! 6 H2
2 d
a` (
. ,QD %
"K
)"'* binary d
3 k " J Y 5,
% ",
j
b4 +
Y ! ) L`
Y " )
.d
! ,
!)
"
,"*
.
! 4*
|* - 2
] 4*
Q,' #h "3
Q! ] 4*
% "
4 "K
E HLG "
/ h"*
4 "K
5 6 ] 4*
)* @* A
6 ] 4*
H "
/2
E HLG "
)* D ,
6 ] 4*
T % "!
2.
H%%2 *
)
! ;* m
p#
4* 2 ]
" 6
7*
" ), G
)5 6
7
", -
)# Y 4 "3
63
"*
4*
5A 4* b " ) )
,QD
2
5A " +
"" )
5] Q,' #h U*
Vh
,5 2
8
JA
2 D@
, * ! "" ) )5 )D B
% ""
6*
! U* )
"" fB
2
2
)*
% "" Y
5] ) #Y JA m
"
)@* @
: "
1)
Responses to Sumerian-Ural-Altaic Affinities (CA 1971)
2)
A New Aspect of the Sumerian Question (AMJSLL 1906)
3)
Sumerian Lexicon (2000)
4)
On the Idea of Sumerian-Uralic-Altaic Affinities (CA 1973)
5)
Are the Sumerians and the Hungarians or the Uralic People Related? (CA
1976)
G %
39 % F
'
&( %
'
K L $ H I 7J