Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PROSPECTUS
For The Sale of 61,823,968 Ordinary Shares of No Par Value of
ii
Launching and Commencement of the offer .. Thur. 30th December, 2010 10:00AM
Latest date and time for receipt of application .. Monday 31st January, 2011, 4:00 PM
Submission of Report on the offer to SEC Thursday 10th February, 2011, 4:00 PM
Final Notification of Shares allotted to applicants . Mon. 14th February, 2011, 10:00PM
iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
MANDATORY DECLARATION AND STATEMENTS .......................................................................... I KEY MILESTONES AND EXPECTED TIME TABLE ........................................................................ III CORPORATE INFORMATION .............................................................................................................XII EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ..................................................................................................................... XVI SUMMARY OF SELECTED FINANCIAL INFORMATION ........................................................... XIX CHANGES IN STATED CAPITAL ........................................................................................................ XX ASSETS REVALUATION ..................................................................................................................... XXI DIVIDEND RECORDS PAST AND PROPOSED ........................................................................... XXII ELECTRONIC SHARE CERTIFICATION IN GSE DEPOSITORY.............................................. XXII TAX EXEMPTIONS .............................................................................................................................. XXII RELEVANT DOCUMENTS FOR INSPECTION .............................................................................. XXII 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16 1.17 1.18 1.19 2.0 DESCRIPTION OF THE OFFER................................................................................................ 1 THE SHARE OFFER ............................................................................................................................ 1 OBJECTIVES OF THE SHARE OFFER.................................................................................................... 1 SHARE OFFERING .............................................................................................................................. 2 FLOTATION EXPENSES ...................................................................................................................... 3 THE APPLICATION ............................................................................................................................. 4 MINIMUM AGGREGATE TAKE-UP FROM SUBSCRIPTIONS ................................................................. 4 ALLOTMENT, ISSUE OF ADDITIONAL SHARES & OVER-SUBSCRIPTION ............................................. 5 PLAN OF DISTRIBUTION .................................................................................................................... 6 RECEIVING INSTITUTIONS ................................................................................................................. 6 ESCROW ACCOUNT AGREEMENT ...................................................................................................... 6 REGISTRAR SERVICES ....................................................................................................................... 6 DEALINGS ......................................................................................................................................... 7 LISTING ............................................................................................................................................. 7 DIVIDEND WITHHOLDING TAX ......................................................................................................... 7 CAPITAL GAINS TAX ......................................................................................................................... 7 GIFT TAX .......................................................................................................................................... 7 STAMP DUTY .................................................................................................................................... 8 RESTRICTIONS ON FOREIGN SHARE OWNERSHIP OF LISTED SECURITIES .......................................... 8 CORPORATE TAX .............................................................................................................................. 8 THE COMPANY: COMET PROPERTIES LIMITED ............................................................. 9
iv
Comet Prospectus, December 2010 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 2.10 2.11 2.12 2.13 2.14 2.15 2.16 2.17 2.18 3.0 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 3.5.1 3.5.2 3.5.3 3.5.4 3.5.5 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.2.1 BRIEF HISTORY ................................................................................................................................. 9 LEGAL STATUS ............................................................................................................................... 10 OFFICE LOCATION .......................................................................................................................... 10 CORPORATE MISSION AND VISION STATEMENT .............................................................................. 10 COMETS GOAL............................................................................................................................... 10 COMETS CONCEPT ......................................................................................................................... 11 COMETS VALUES ........................................................................................................................... 11 COMETS STRATEGY ....................................................................................................................... 11 COMETS PLEDGE ........................................................................................................................... 12 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE ............................................................................................................. 12 MEMBERS OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS ....................................................................................... 12 POST FLOTATION RECONSTITUTION OF THE BOARD ....................................................................... 14 CORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND BOARD SUB COMMITTEES ........................................................... 15 BOARD SECRETARY ........................................................................................................................ 17 SHAREHOLDING STRUCTURE .......................................................................................................... 17 MANAGEMENT TEAM ...................................................................................................................... 17 OTHER STAFF .................................................................................................................................. 19 FAMILY RELATIONS ........................................................................................................................ 20 INDUSTRY AND MARKET INFORMATION ........................................................................ 22 OVERVIEW OF THE ECONOMY ......................................................................................................... 22 GOVERNMENT POLICIES AND REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT .......................................................... 23 THE STRUCTURE OF THE INDUSTRY ................................................................................................. 25 STRATEGIC OPPORTUNITIES ............................................................................................................ 26 MARKET ANALYSES ....................................................................................................................... 26 Demand and Supply Situation ........................................................................................................ 26 Customer Base ............................................................................................................................... 27 Products.......................................................................................................................................... 27 Promotion ....................................................................................................................................... 29 Competition .................................................................................................................................... 29 PROSPECTS AND RISK FACTORS ........................................................................................ 30 LAND LITIGATIONS ......................................................................................................................... 30 FOREIGN EXCHANGE....................................................................................................................... 30 COMPETITION ................................................................................................................................. 31 LOAN CONTRACTING RISK.............................................................................................................. 31 INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS RISK ......................................................................................................... 31 ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL RISK FACTORS ............................................................................... 32 FINANCIAL INFORMATION .................................................................................................. 33 CLEARANCE ON THE HISTORICAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ........................................................... 33 SUMMARY OF HISTORICAL FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ..................................................................... 35 Accounting Policies ....................................................................................................................... 38
Comet Prospectus, December 2010 5.2.2 5.2.3 5.2.4 5.3 5.3.1 5.4 5.4.1 5.4.2 5.4.3 5.4.4 5.4.5 5.4.6 5.4.7 5.4.8 6.0 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 6.8 6.9 7.0 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.3.1 7.3.2 7.3.3 8.0 8.1 8.2 Notes to the Financial Statements .................................................................................................. 39 Management Accounts March 31, 2010......................................................................................... 45 Technical Analysis of the Historical Financial Statements ............................................................ 48 FINANCIAL FORECASTS ................................................................................................................... 51 Key Underlying Assumptions for the financial Projections ........................................................... 53 SHARE PRICE VALUATION .............................................................................................................. 58 Results of Valuation ....................................................................................................................... 58 Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) ................................................................................. 58 Discounted Free Cash Flow Value ................................................................................................. 58 Net Adjusted Book Value (NABV)................................................................................................ 58 Weighted Market Value ................................................................................................................. 58 Justification for Selection of weights ............................................................................................. 59 Recommended Share Price and Discount offered .......................................................................... 59 The Price Earnings Multiple .......................................................................................................... 60 TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THE OFFER ....................................................................... 62 GENERAL CONDITIONS ................................................................................................................... 62 OFFER TO PURCHASE SHARES ......................................................................................................... 62 ACCEPTANCE OF OFFER .................................................................................................................. 63 PAYMENT FOR SHARES ................................................................................................................... 63 REFUND OF EXCESS CASH............................................................................................................... 64 LATE REFUNDS ............................................................................................................................... 64 WARRANTIES .................................................................................................................................. 64 SUPPLY AND DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION .................................................................................. 64 MISCELLANEOUS ............................................................................................................................ 65 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION ............................................................................................... 66 OVERVIEW OF THE GHANA STOCK EXCHANGE ............................................................................... 66 DEVELOPMENT & TRENDS .............................................................................................................. 67 PERFORMANCE OF THE GHANA STOCK EXCHANGE ........................................................................ 69 Trading Volumes:........................................................................................................................... 69 Traded Values: ............................................................................................................................... 70 Overall Market Performance .......................................................................................................... 70 APPLICATION PROCEDURE AND FORMS ......................................................................... 72 THE APPLICATION ........................................................................................................................... 72 INSTRUCTIONS FOR COMPLETION OF APPLICATION FORM .............................................................. 72
vi
LIST OF TABLES
TABLE 1.1: APPLICATION OF PROCEEDS FROM THE IPO ATTRIBUTABLE TO NEW ISSUE OF SHARES ............... 2 TABLE 1.2: DETAILS OF THE OFFER................................................................................................................. 3 TABLE 1.3: FLOTATION EXPENSES .................................................................................................................. 3 TABLE 1.4: APPLICATION OF MINIMUM AGGREGATE SUBSCRIPTION OF GH18 MILLION .......................... 5 TABLE 2.1: MEMBERS OF BOARD OF DIRECTORS .......................................................................................... 13 TABLE 2.2: LIST OF MANAGEMENT TEAM ..................................................................................................... 18 TABLE 3.1: SELECTED MACROECONOMIC INDICATORS ................................................................................. 23 TABLE 3.2: PRICE RANGE OF HOUSES IN ACCRA-TEMA METROPOLIS........................................................... 27 TABLE 3.3: STANDARD FEATURES OF VARIOUS HOUSE TYPES ...................................................................... 28 TABLE 5.1: PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNTS FOR THE YEARS ENDED 2006 TO 2009 ......................................... 35 TABLE 5.2: BALANCE SHEETS AS AT DECEMBER 31, 2006 TO 2009 .............................................................. 36 TABLE 5.3: CASH FLOW STATEMENTS FOR THE YEARS ENDED DECEMBER 31, 2006 TO 2009 ...................... 37 TABLE 5.4: PROFIT AND LOSS ACCOUNT FOR THE PERIOD ENDED MARCH 31, 2010 ..................................... 45 TABLE 5.5: BALANCE SHEET AS AT MARCH 31, 2010 .................................................................................. 46 TABLE 5.6: CASH FLOW STATEMENT FOR THE PERIOD ENDED MARCH 31, 2010 ........................................... 47 TABLE 5.7: KEY FINANCIAL RATIOS ............................................................................................................. 50 TABLE 5.8: PROJECTED INCOME STATEMENT, 2010-2014 ............................................................................. 55 TABLE 5.10: PROJECTED BALANCE SHEET, 2010-2014 ................................................................................. 56 TABLE 5.11: PROJECTED CASH FLOW STATEMENT, 2010-2014 .................................................................... 57 TABLE 5.12: THE VALUATION MODEL .......................................................................................................... 59 TABLE 5.13: SUMMARY OF THE OFFER AND SHAREHOLDING ANALYSIS ....................................................... 60 TABLE 5.14: PROJECTED PRICE-EARNING RATIOS ........................................................................................ 60 TABLE 7.1: YEARLY TRADED VALUES FOR THE PAST FIVE YEARS ................................................................ 70 TABLE 7.2: GSE PERFORMANCE TRENDS FOR THE LAST FIVE (5) YEARS....................................................... 71
vii
P.O. BOX 525 Cape Coast 233 3321-92862 e-mail atoamponsa@yahoo.com Date: Sept. 30, 2010
TO:
THE DIRECTOR GENERAL THE SECURITIES & EXCHANGE COMMISSION 30, 3RD CIRCULAR ROAD CANTONMENTS, ACCRA GHANA THE MANAGING DIRECTOR THE GHANA STOCK EXHANCE 5TH FLOOR, CEDI HOUSE ACCRA GHANA
Dear Sir, COMET PROPERTIES LIMITED INITIAL PUBLIC OFFERING AND LISTING ON THE GHANA STOCK EXCHANGE 1.0 1.1 Introduction Basis of instructions We have acted as Flotation Legal Advisors to Comet Properties Limited (the company or COMET) and Worldwide Securities Limited (the Sponsoring Brokers and Flotation Managers) in connection with its proposed initial Public Offering (IPO) and formal listing on the Ghana Stock Exchange (GSE).
1.2
Documents Examined We have examined the following documents in their original forms and certified copies and advise that they be made available at the companys offices for public inspection during the period of the IPO. The Regulations of the company adopted pursuant to a special resolution by members at the Annual General Meeting dated 20th September, 2006. Special Resolutions by members of the company dated 30th September 2006 to; i. convert the company to a public limited liability company. ii. authorize the Directors of the company to make the IPO and to list the issued shares on the GSE. The draft Prospectus and other offering documents to be issued by the company in connection with the IPO and the GSE listing. A letter from the GSE approving the provisional listing of COMET. A letter from the Securities and Exchange Commission approving the Prospectus A letter from the Registrar of Companies waiving compliance with sections 274 and 275 (1) (a) of the Companies Code, 1963 (Act 179) in accordance with section 291 A of Act 179. A letter from the GSE approving the GSE listing of COMET shares. The Central Securities Depository Act, 2007 (Act 733) In addition, we have also examined such other documents, certificates, official searches and records as are necessary under the laws of Ghana to enable us to give this opinion and certification. Scope and purpose of the opinion The opinion expressed herein is limited to matters of the laws of Ghana as are in force and applied at the date of this opinion. For the avoidance of doubt we have not investigated the laws of any country other Ghana and no opinion is expressed on the laws of other jurisdiction. The basis of assumptions underlying this opinion are set out in the schedule below.
a.
b.
c.
d. e. f.
g. h. i.
1.3
ix
2.0 2.1
OPINION Incorporation COMET Properties Limited is a public limited liability company duly incorporated under the Companies Code, 1963 (Act 179). Authorization to do Business COMET is authorized by its Regulations and has obtained all the necessary corporate authorizations and approvals necessary or advisable in connection with the IPO and GSE listing. Approvals and Consents COMET has obtained all the necessary regulatory and statutory approvals, consents or authorizations of any governmental or other authority that are necessary or advisable in connection with the IPO and GSE listing. The Prospectus The Prospectus substantially complies with the requirements of schedule 5 of the Securities and Exchange Commission Regulations, 2003 (L.I. 1728) and Schedule 7 of the Companies Code, 1963 (Act 179). Material Contracts All the material contracts of Comet necessary for the conduct of its business are in proper legal form for the particular matters to which they are related and enforceable under the laws of Ghana. The Regulations The Regulations comply with all legal requirements on the contents of the Regulations of a public company. 2.6.2 The Regulations comply with the GSE Rule Book.
2.2
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6 2.6.1
2.6.3 2.7
The proposed IPO and GSE Listing do not contravene any provision of the Regulations. Contractual Obligations To the best of our knowledge and upon enquiry and verification, there are not contractual agreements, obligations or undertakings preventing COMET from undertaking the IPO and GSE Listing.
2.8
Registration and Filings All Statutory or regulatory registration or filing requirements necessary or advisable in relation to or in connection with the IPO and GSE listing have been complied with.
Yours faithfully,
- SCHEDULE ASSUMPTIONS In giving this opinion, we have assumed, and this opinion is given on the basis that; 1. All original documents supplied to us are complete, authentic and up to date, and that all copy documents supplied to us are complete and confirm to the originals. The person or persons who signed the relevant Documents were authorized to do so. The authorizing resolutions of COMET were duly passed at properly convened meetings of members and directors and a duly qualified quorum voted in favour of approving the relevant board resolutions. All material contracts have been reviewed and assurances received from the directors that they are genuine.
2. 3.
4.
xi
Corporate Information
BOARD OF DIRECTORS : Nana Odeneho Kyeremateng (Executive Chairman) Mr. Samuel Amponsah Kyeremateng Mr. Osei Owusu Mr. Sampson Awuah Mr. Kwasi Sarpong Peprah Mr. Kwasi Sarpong Peprah Comet Properties Limited 3rd Floor Kapital Building Ring Road Central, Kwame Nkrumah Circle Accra PO Box KA 16392 Airport, Accra Telephone: +233 (0)30 2257735/ 2256625 Fax: +233 (0)30 2256625 e-mail: info@comethomesgh.biz comethomes@gmail.com website: www.comethomesgh.biz Cardinal Consult Chartered Accountants PO Box OS 414 Osu, Accra Edward Darlington % Comet Properties Limited PO Box KA16392 Airport, Accra Bankers: Standard Chartered Bank
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
COMPANY SECRETARY
REGISTERED OFFICE
AUDITORS
SOLICITORS
xii
Worldwide Securities Limited No. 80 Yeboah Afari Plaza Ringway Estates, Osu. PO Box OS1072, Osu, Accra. Contacts: Kwadwo Ansah Afari CEO Ms. Juliana Obessey Head of Brokerage Tel: +233 (0)30 2764578/9, 2256001/2 Fax: +233 (0)30 2764580 E-mail: info@worldwidesecurities-gh.com wic@africaonline.com.gh
SUPPORTING ADVISORS:
Legal Due Diligence: Amponsah-Dadzie & Associates Esi Dentewa Chambers P. O. Box GP 2792 Accra P.O. Box 525 Cape Coast Mr. Ollenu Amponsah Dadzie Assets Verification: Apex Valuation, Surveying & Property Consult Melvina House 3rd Suite Three No.8 Okai M Lane Adabraka, Accra Mr. Andrew Kojo Asamoah, M.Gh.I.S. Reporting Accountants/Financial Due Diligence: Delloite & Touche Audit and Assurance
xiii
4 Liberation Road P.O Box GP 453 Accra Contact: Mr. Andrew Ampong Technical & Management Consultants1: Worldwide Investments Co. Ltd. No. 80 Yeboah Afari Plaza Ringway Estates, Osu. PO Box OS1072, Osu, Accra.
Mr. Rexford Adomako-Bonsu President & CEO
Registrars: NTHC Limited Martco House 1st Floor Okai Mensah Link PO Box KIA9563 Airport, Accra, Ghana Website: www.nthcghana.com Email: info@nthcghana.com Tel: +233 (0)30 2238492-3, 235814-5.
The Technical and Management Consultant is a registered Founder Associate Member of the GSE and it shares common shareholder with the Lead Advisor. The two companies are however operationally independent. Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
xiv
Receiving Institutions: Worldwide Securities Limited CAL Brokers Limited Merban Stockbrokers Limited EDC Stockbrokers Limited Strategic African Securities Limited NTHC Securities Limited First Atlantic Brokers Limited Gold Coast Securities Limited Newworld Renaissance Securities Limited SDC Brokerage Services Limited HFC Brokerage Services Limited Prudential Securities Limited SIC Financial Services Limited CDH Securities Limited IC Securities Limited African Alliance Securities Ghana Limited Liberty Capital Ghana Limited Databank Brokerage Limited CDH Securities Limited Ghana Commercial Bank Ecobank Ghana Limited Zenith Bank Ghana Limited
xv
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Company Location The name of the Company is COMET PROPERTIES LIMITED. The company is ran from two sites as detailed below: (i) The corporate administrative office is the Capital Building, at the Kokomlemle end of Kwame Nkrumah Circle, Accra. (ii) Current development site is the Hill City, Brekuso, on the Akuapim Hills. The Company is authorised, to carry on business as follows: a) Real estates developers b) production and distribution of quarry stones c) production and distribution of cement and concrete products d) dealers in wood and furniture COMET presently deals in the following products serviced lands sale of houses | 2 bedroom detached | 2 bedroom semidetached | 3 bedroom detached | 3 bedroom semidetached | 3 bedroom detached with boys quarters (out house) | 3 bedroom storey | 4 bedroom storey | 4 bedroom storey with out house contract services for the construction of houses to specification
Authorized Business
New Products
Comet, after the IPO, will commence the construction of low-cost high-rise residential buildings at its Hill City site. The company xvi
plans to construct at least 20 blocks of these low cost apartments, with each block containing 32 apartments/flats to cater for the housing needs of workers. Comet is in the process of establishing new industries to manufacture downstream products to be used in its housing projects these include, the manufacture of concrete products and roofing materials, plastic T&G, for ceiling and panelling, etc. The facility for producing the concrete products is ready and is undergoing test running. The machinery and equipment for producing the roofing sheets have been acquired and the factory building is nearing completion.
The Members of the Board of Directors of the Company are: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Nana Odeneho Kwaku Kyeremateng (Chairman) Mr. Samuel Kyeremateng Mr. Sampson Awuah Mr. Osei Owusu Mr. Kwasi Sarpong Peprah
Company Secretary Mr. Kwasi Sarpong Peprah The Management Team is made up of: 1. Nana Odeneho Kwaku Kyeremateng Managing Director 2. Mr. Samuel Kyeremateng Technical Director 3. Mr. Sampson Awuah Director, Projects 4. Mr. Nicholas Mensah Finance Manager 5. Mr. Joseph Kodua Head of Estates/Marketing Dept 6. Mr. Edward Cudjoe Acting Project Manager 7. Mr. Kwasi Sarpong Peprah Director for Administration 8. Maame Serwaah Kyeremateng, Manager,
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
xvii
Corporate Affairs 9. Mr. Edward Darlington Legal Officer The Proposed Share Offer The company is offering to the investing public 61,823,968 shares of no par value for subscription. This is made up of 54,095,972 new shares to be issued from Authorised Shares whilst 7,727,996 ordinary shares are being offered by the existing shareholder for sale to the public. The 54,095,972 new shares are anticipated to increase the issued shares outstanding from 154,559,920 to 208,655,892. The new shareholders will hold 30% of the companys post flotation shares. Authorized Shares is 2,000,000,000 ordinary shares of no par value. The share offer is summarised thus;
Authorised Shares Existing Shares Additional Issue From existing Shareholders Total Shares on Offer Total Shares After Flotation Share Price Current Capitalisation Value of New Issues Value of Issues from existing Shareholders Value of Ordinary Shares on Offer Post Flotation Market Capitalisation at GH1.00/share 2,000,000,000 154,559,920 54,095,972 7,727,996 61,823,968 208,655,892 GHC 1.00 GHC 159,810,712 GHC 54,095,972 GHC 7,727,996 GHC 61,823,968 GHC 208,655,892
The objective among other things is to increase the companys capacity to deliver housing units to the public, retire long term debts, set up and/or expand downstream facilities for the production of roofing tiles, concrete products, aggregate stones, wood products and plastic T&G to support the core business of delivering affordable and functional houses as well as support working capital needs. In addition to expanding the production of xviii
the current brand of houses, the company plans to produce highrise low-cost residential houses for workers. Symbol Sponsors The symbol of the Company is COMET Worldwide Securities Limited
5,454,690 1,523,592
18,272,891 3,248,388
19,339,504 4,269,112
14,507,600 4,821,657
850,811 758,311
1,936,877 1,833,427
2,896,630 2,663,564
3,559,355 3,373,685
xix
72,279,960 791,796
73,071,756
1,241,855 8,786,500
87,626,719 7,005,161
85,795,913 11,225,000
41,557,724 85,225,000
xx
And a further transfer of all the accumulated Directors Current Account of GH70,579,460.
These transfers were accompanied by the issue of corresponding additional 722,799,601 ordinary shares, which were further consolidated in consonance with Companies Code 1963 (Act 179) Schedule 2 subsection (8b) to 72,279,960 shares. Available for your perusal is a Special Resolution dated September 20, 2006 on these transfers from the Income Surplus Accounts and the Directors Current Account to stated capital and the corresponding issued shares. Further, on May 17, 2010, the company undertook share split by issuing one additional share to any share held. By this, the total issued shares of the company were increased from 77,279,960 to 154,559,920.
Assets Revaluation
As a result of the dynamic nature of the Real Estate Industry, asset values increase regularly due largely to demand and supply factors. This is particularly true with the price of land which has experienced astronomical increases over the last couple of years. In response to this development, the Company has had to revalue its assets regularly to reflect fair market values. The first of such asset revaluations was conducted in December 2006. This was followed by subsequent revaluations on January 2008 and August 2009. Presented below are the summary findings of the most recent asset revaluations conducted in May 2010.
Land Bank (2,500 acres) Serviced Plots (1,125 Plots) Houses available for sale Houses Under Construction Office Building at site Motor Vehicles Office Equipment Furniture and Fittings Plant and Machinery Total Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited May 2010 (US$) 55,000,000.00 39,375,000.00 7,700,000.00 7,800,000.00 1,020,465.00 600,000.00 350,152.00 392,662.00 8,001,543.60 120,239,822.60
xxi
Tax Exemptions
Comet Properties Limited has been exempted from paying corporate taxes since 2005 and up to 2010.
xxii
1. 2. 3. 4.
Certificate of Incorporation of Comet Properties Limited Certificate to Commence Business of Comet Properties Limited Company Regulations of Comet Properties Limited Share Transfer Agreement between Mr. Samuel Kyeremateng and Nana Odeneho Kyeremateng 5. Annual Audited Financial Statements 2006 to 2009 6. Management Accounts, March 31, 2010. 7. Assets Revaluation Report, May 2010. 8. Regulations of the Company adopted on conversion to a Public Company by Special Resolution dated Wednesday, 20th September, 2006 9. Special Resolutions: a. To recapitalise the company by transfer of income surpluses and credits on Directors Current Accounts to increase the companys Stated Capital from GH500.00 to GH72,279,960 dated September 20, 2006. b. To adopt Regulations of the Company pursuant to conversion of Comet to a Public Company. And a Special Resolution to list the Company on the Ghana Stock Exchange dated September 20, 2006 c. Undertaking to comply with the continuing listing obligations of the Exchange as well as the guidelines for Provisional to listing on the GSE. d. Undertaking to complete the formal listing process within a period of six months from the date of the Provisional Listing or in a shorter period as may be agreed upon with the Exchange. 10. Provisional Listing Statement dated October 20, 2009. 11. Financial Due Diligence Report, May 2010 12. Legal Due Diligence Report, May 2010 13. Stand-still undertaking by the existing shareholder dated 9th August, 2010.
xxiii
1.0
DESCRIPTIONOFTHEOFFER
1.1 THESHAREOFFER
The Comet Share Offer is an open, unrestricted cash Offer made to all interested investors, institutions and individuals resident in Ghana and, resident institutions and individuals in a limited number of other countries whose laws allow them to invest under the conditions of the Offer. The company is offering 61,823,968 ordinary shares of no par value for subscription at a price of GH1.00 per share through a public offering to the general public under the terms of the offer. Comet Properties Limited expects to raise an amount of GH61,823,968 from the proceeds of this Offer. Of this amount, GHC 7,727,996 representing 12.5% shall go to the current shareholder being 7,727,996 shares offered for sale in this IPO. The remaining GHC 54,095,972 being proceeds from new shares to be issued under the offer will be used for the expansion of the operations of the company, by establishing down stream operations for the production of plastic T&G for ceiling and panelling, aggregate stones (stone quarry), expansion of the companys wood processing facility and its aluminium fabrication plant. The amount shall also be used to construct 1,000 residential houses during the plan period as well as low cost high rise buildings for workers. Flotation costs will also be paid out of the proceeds to be raised.
1.2
OBJECTIVESOFTHESHAREOFFER
The objective is to raise additional equity capital: a. To increase the production of houses b. Increase housing units in the existing Key Market-Accra, c. Expand the operations of the Company to other key markets in Ghana notably Kumasi and Sekondi-Takoradi; d. Establish related auxiliary projects- Plastic T&G production facility, stone quarry to support the core business of delivering affordable and functional houses e. To expand existing auxiliary facilities namely: wood processing and aluminium fabrication factories
f. g. h.
Retire all medium term debt, Support working capital needs and Pay flotation and related expenses and other third party expenses
Table 1.1 below details the projected utilisation of the proceeds of the IPO.
Table 1.1: Application of Proceeds from the IPO Attributable to new Issue of Shares
Establish Factory for the production of Plastic T&G Establish Stone Quarry Expansion of Wood Processing Factory Expansion of Aluminium Fabrication Factory Purchase of Motor Vehicles Working Capital for the Construction of High Rise Buildings for Workers Construction of the current brand of houses (1,000 units) Payment of Overdraft from Banks Flotation Expenses chargeable to the Company on new issue of shares Payment of amount owed to the Registrar of companies Acquisition of land in Takoradi and Kumasi Total Amount (GH) 1,450,000 2,175,000 3,625,000 725,000 2,000,000 13,700,000 13,000,000 8,277,900 2,706,070 365,350 6,071,652 54,095,972
1.3
SHAREOFFERING
A total of 61,823,968 ordinary shares are being offered to the public. This is made up of 54,095,972 new shares to be issued from Authorised Shares, whilst 7,727,996 ordinary shares are being offered by the existing shareholder for sale to the public. The 54,095,972 new shares are anticipated to increase the issued shares outstanding from 154,559,920 to 208,655,892. Details of the offer are summarised below.
1.4
FLOTATIONEXPENSES
The total cost of the flotation of the shares of Comet is estimated to be 5.00% of the amount to be raised and will be paid pro rata by the Company and the selling shareholder. The expenses shall therefore be borne by the Company and the selling shareholder in the ratio of 87.5% (GH2,704,799) to 12.5% (GH386,400) respectively. Table 1.3 presents the summary. Table 1.3: Flotation Expenses
Item GSE SEC (0.05% of the offer) Registrars Vendors Commissions Media, road show and Prospectus Printing Provisional Listing Expenses Stamp Duty to the Registrar of Companies (0.5% of GH54,095,972) Consultants' Fees (Mgt, Financial, legal, valuation, assets verification/valuation, reporting accountants, lead managers) Success Fees Total Amount (GH) 47,400 30,912 10,000 927,360 261,040 12,365 270,480 1,039,415 492,227 GH3,091,198 % 0.08% 0.05% 0.02% 1.50% 0.42% 0.02% 0.44% 1.68% 0.80% 5.00%
1.5
THEAPPLICATION
The minimum subscription for each application must be for 50 shares, and thereafter, in multiples of 10 shares. Close of day, Monday 31st January, 2011 will be the latest date and time for the receipt of an Application Form. The share offer commences on Thursday, 30th December, 2010 and ends on Monday 31st January, 2011. Should it become necessary however, the offer will be extended by two (2) weeks to end on Tuesday 15th February, 2011. If an application is successful, in whole, or in part, the number of shares allotted shall be kept electronically on GSD and the applicant notified. If there is excess demand under the Share Offer, the applicant may receive fewer shares than he/she might have expected to receive on the basis of the maximum amount he/she had expressed willingness to invest in the Share Offer. If an application is unsuccessful, or is accepted in part, or if the amount of the application divided by the offered price does not equal a whole number of shares, a refund for the appropriate amount, without interest, will be returned to the applicant within 14 working days after the allotment without interest (excluding holidays). Late refunds will attract an annual interest rate of 5%. The right is reserved to present for payment all cheques, bankers drafts, and money/postal orders on receipt. It is a condition of the Offer that all cheques or other remittances must be honoured on first presentation. No interest will be paid to applicants on any monies held on behalf of applicants, or on behalf of the Company.
1.6
MINIMUMAGGREGATETAKEUPFROMSUBSCRIPTIONS
Comets Offer is expected to raise a total of GH61,823,968 but the Company has set itself a minimum aggregate subscription of GH18 million, which is deemed a reasonable threshold to meet significant part of the companys projected capital expenditure for 2010 as well as increase its working capital to carry through the strategic objectives of the Company. In the event that this amount is not obtained, all application monies received will be refunded without interest to the applicants within three weeks
(21) days of the close of the Offer and the Offer accordingly cancelled. Refunds after this time period will attract the prevailing Bank of Ghana prime rate. In the event of the IPO not meeting the projected full subscription target of GH61,823,968, but realising the minimum aggregate subscription of GH18 million, the application of funds will be prioritised in accordance to the disbursement schedule in table 1.4. Table 1.4: Application of Minimum Aggregate Subscription of GH18 million
Amount (GH) 1,450,000 2,175,000 725,000 2,000,000 6,850,000 365,350 1,440,000 2,994,650 18,000,000
Establish Factory for the production of Plastic T&G Establish Stone Quarry Expansion of Aluminium Fabrication Factory Purchase of Motor Vehicles Working Capital for the Construction of High Rise Buildings for Workers Payment of amount owed to the Registrar of companies Flotation expenses Construction of the current brand of houses
1.7
ALLOTMENT,ISSUEOFADDITIONALSHARES&OVERSUBSCRIPTION
The allotment of shares will ensure widespread ownership. In the event of oversubscription, monies in respect of applications not allocated will be returned to applicants. The Managers reserve the right to accept or reject any Application in whole or in part, if it is determined to be incomplete, illegible, or if it is determined that the Applicant is not eligible to participate in this Offer. Applications, which are received after closure of the offer, will not be considered. In the case of an oversubscription, the Company will issue additional shares of up to 40% of the current offer, representing a maximum of 24,729,587 ordinary shares. These shares will be additional to the total shares of 61,823,968 offered for sale.
1.8
PLANOFDISTRIBUTION No director or senior management or staff has declared his intention to subscribe to the Offering. However, there is no restriction on any of these parties who want to acquire some of the shares during the Offer period at the price of GH1.00/share. None of the Shares on Offer has been reserved for any targeted investors.
1.9
RECEIVINGINSTITUTIONS
This public share offer is under the management of Worldwide Securities Limited. The shares are also available at the offices of all registered brokers, the list of which can be read from page xv of this prospectus. Other receiving agents are Ghana Commercial Bank Limited, Ecobank (Ghana) Limited and Zenith Bank Ghana Limited.
1.10 ESCROWACCOUNTAGREEMENT All application monies collected on behalf of Comet by Vendors and Agents are to be paid into the Escrow Account Number 0006010138280 at the Premier Towers Branch of Zenith Bank Ghana Limited, Accra. Vendors and Agents will operate a separate bank account designated Comet Share Offer Account into which all payments in respect of this Comet Share Offer shall be placed. A vendor/Agent will thereafter issue a cheque for the bulk amount on a weekly basis to the order of Comet/WSL Escrow Account. A copy of the Escrow Account Agreement has been lodged with the SEC.
1.11 REGISTRARSERVICES The Register of the members of the Company will be maintained by NTHC Limited, Martco House 1st Floor, Okai Mensah Link, PO Box KIA9563, Airport, Accra, Ghana. Shares allotted pursuant to the offer will be registered in the Register alongside the shares already issued. Shares of the company will be held electronically in the GSE Depository System.
1.12 DEALINGS Dealings in Comets shares is expected to commence on the Ghana Stock Exchange on Monday 14th February, 2010 and can only take place through a licensed dealing member of the Exchange. The shares will be traded on the GSE in Cedis and dealings are expected to take place in lots of 100 shares among the licensed dealers. However shareholders can legally sell any number of shares.
1.13 LISTING Application has been made to the Ghana Stock Exchange for all of the 154,559,920 ordinary shares outstanding and any additional new shares issued as described herein to be admitted to the Exchanges First Official List. The Ghana Stock Exchange has given approval for the listing of the said shares.
1.14 DIVIDENDWITHHOLDINGTAX Under current Ghanaian legislation, tax is withheld from dividend payments by the Company at the rate of 8%. No further Ghanaian tax is payable on dividends received.
1.15 CAPITALGAINSTAX Exemption from the payment of capital gains tax on disposal of securities was in force from November 1990 to November 2010. It is the expected that this will be extended for another term.
1.16 GIFTTAX Under the Internal Revenue Act 2000, liability to gift tax may arise by gift of shares in the Company if the open market value of the shares at the time of the gift exceeds GH50.00 (subject to certain exemptions). The tax is payable by the donee of the gift at 10% of the excess over GH50.00. Any value up to GH50.00 does not attract a gift tax.
1.17 STAMPDUTY The Stamp Duty (Amendment) Act, 1996, (Act 510) has granted foreigners as well as Ghanaians general exemption from all stamp duties in respect of transfers of shares in companies listed on the Ghana Stock Exchange.
1.18 RESTRICTIONSONFOREIGNSHAREOWNERSHIPOFLISTEDSECURITIES Foreign Exchange transactions are currently governed by the Foreign Exchange Act, 2006 (Act 723). It grants permission for external residents to deal in securities listed on the Exchange without prior Exchange Control approval, and assures full and free foreign exchange remittability of original capital or principal amounts, any gains, dividends or interest payments, and related earnings and refunds in respect of investments made by external residents in such securities.
1.19 CORPORATETAX The Internal Revenue Act 2000 (Act 592) prescribes a general corporate tax of 25% for all listed companies. This rate was reviewed in the 2006 fiscal budget and thus new companies being listed will enjoy a 3% rebate on the corporate tax rate for the first three years of full listing.
2.0
THECOMPANY:COMETPROPERTIESLIMITED
2.1 BRIEFHISTORY
COMET PROPERTIES LIMITED was established in Ghana by Mr. Samuel Kyeremateng in the year 2002, as a Real Estate firm, with the primary objective to construct and deliver into the Ghana Property Market, functional and comfortable houses. The company was issued with a certificate of incorporation number CA-1,505 on April 24, 2002 and on the same day was issued with a Certificate to Commence Business as a Private Company limited by Shares. Mr. Samuel Kyeremateng after acquiring initial land for residential real estate development decided to transfer all his 100% interest in the company to his senior brother Nana Odeneho Kyeremateng, a legal practitioner and a Land broker in Accra. The deed of transfer is duly registered with the Registrar of Companies and copies are available for inspection. The company in fulfilment of its Mission Statement of transforming virgin lands into modern cities, develops and services residential plots with utilities like water, electricity and access roads and leases them to the general public at competitive prices. The company has chalked a lot of successes during the few years of operation since its inception. From a meagre 200 acres of land as its maiden acquisition, Comet now possesses a land bank of over 2,000 acres in and around the capital of Ghana, Accra. Comets maiden Estate known as HILLSIDE HOUSING ESTATE, is located at the Southern End of AKWAPIM HILLS near ASHONGMANG HOUSING ESTATE ACCRA. The general public response to the companys services and products has been very encouraging and this has necessitated the extension of its geographical area of operations to cover new acquisitions since 2004, at Obosomase, on the same Akwapim Hills. The company is a respected member of Ghana Real Estate Developers Association (GREDA). Comet, in its maiden entry into the prestigious Ghana Club 100 in 2008 impressively placed 47 in the over all rankings and 1st in the Real Estates Industry rankings.
Comet Properties Limited is currently expanding its operations to cover other regional capitals of the country. Current development site is at the Hill city at the Akuapim Hills, near Accra.
2.2
LEGALSTATUS
Comet Properties Limited by the adoption of a special resolution on September 20, 2006 was converted from a private limited liability company to a Public Company Limited by Shares. The Regulations of the Company has been submitted with this offer document to the Ghana Stock Exchange and it is available at the offices of Comet Properties Limited and Worldwide Securities Limited for the perusal of interested prospective investors during the offer.
2.3
OFFICELOCATION
The Head Office of Comet Properties is located in the Kapital Building at the Kokomlemle end of Kwame Nkrumah Circle. Its present development sight, the Hill City, Brekusu on the Akuapem Hills has offices for the technical and the construction staff.
2.4
CORPORATEMISSIONANDVISIONSTATEMENT
The companys vision is To be the leading and the most sought after property developer in Ghana and the ECOWAS sub-region by delivering high quality functional and affordable houses to meet the needs of society. The mission is: dedicated to transforming virgin lands to modern cities with the development of modern infrastructure and provision of utilities within its township.
2.5
COMETSGOAL
Comets goal is to: Become an urban and residential estate developer of preferred choice within Ghana and the ECOWAS sub-region, Achieve high standards of excellence in residential development and post constructional management services,
10
Achieve sustainable levels of long term growth and stability in order to meet the needs of the various stakeholders including customers, residential dwellers, shareholders, employees, the townships and the immediate environs.
2.6
COMETSCONCEPT
Comet is dedicated to supporting private urbanisation as a choice of residential real estate development. Comet has four project concepts designed for the Hill City Project and these are as follows:
Concept 1 Workers High rise Housing Scheme Affordable Homes 2 Exclusive/Executive Scheme 3 Middle Class Scheme 4 Serviced Plots Units 30 acres units) 400 acres 200 acres 200 acres Location Hill Side Brekusu Hill Top Brekusu Hill City Brekusu/Ashongman Hill Top Brekusu
(20
2.7
COMETSVALUES
COMET PROPERTIES LIMITED expects all employees to conduct themselves according to the core values and ethics established by the company, namely: Service quality and excellence Hard work and team play Work life balance Integrity and respect Open communication Commercial viability
2.8
COMETSSTRATEGY
Comets strategy is to: be totally customer focused develop a dynamic organizational structure that addresses the changing needs of the industry and customers recruit and retain the best people for every position
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
11
maximize the usage of information technology for the delivery of its services, Be efficiency and productivity driven.
2.9
COMETSPLEDGE
COMET realizes that the success of the Companys operations is rooted in the commitment of its employees to achieving the companys goals and objectives and the satisfaction of its customers. COMET is thus committed to providing its employees with a positive work environment that provides opportunity for personal growth. Each employee is encouraged to contribute to improve the effectiveness of Comet. COMET PROPERTIES LIMITED customers are the essence of its business. Employees of the company are encouraged to extend to each other and to each customer utmost respect and personal attention.
2.10 CORPORATEGOVERNANCE The Board of Comet, with the determination to ensure high performance and compliance with acceptable industry standards established by regulatory authorities, is committed to good corporate governance. They thus continually monitor and review policies and processes affecting all aspects of the operations of the company. Of particular concern are the issues of employee welfare and the assurance of strong leadership that gives room for skills development and improvement in their capacities through formal and onthe -job training.
2.11 MEMBERSOFTHEBOARDOFDIRECTORS At the apex of the companys organisational chart is a five-member Board of Directors. Their brief profiles are listed in table 2.1 below.
12
53 47
Banker Administrator
Nana Odeneho Kyeremanteng, 53 years, is the Executive Chairman of the Company. He holds a BA Law (Hons) degree from the University of Ghana, Legon (1981), and Barrister at Law (BL) from Ghana School of Law (1988). Between 1981 and 1986 he was a Teacher at Oyo State Central Schools Board. He joined J B Da Rocha Chambers as a Junior Counsel/Solicitor from 1988-1994. Between 1994 and 1996 he worked with the State Housing Corporation as Legal Consultant. In 1996 he set up his own Legal Consulting Firm, Kwaku Kyeremanteng & Co where he was the Chief Legal Consultant from 1996 to 2004. He has been the Executive Chairman of Comet since 2005. Nana Odeneho Kyeremanteng joined the Board of the Company in 2005 Mr. Samuel Kyeremanteng, 48 years, is the Executive Director in charge of operations and Technical duties. He holds a B.Sc. Degree in Engineering (1986) from the Ryerson University, Toronto Canada. Before setting up Comet in 2002, he had worked as an Assistant Researcher with the Ministry of Environment (1987); Ontario Province, Canada, as Production Supervisor with Shopsys Foods Limited- a subsidiary of Lever Brothers-(1988); and finally as the CEO of Smoth and Natural Limited Toronto , Canada (1992-1999). He joined the Board of COMET in 2002.
13
Mr. Osei Owusu, 53 years, is a Non- Executive Director of Comet Properties. Mr. Osei Wusu holds B.A. Degree in Political Science from University of Ghana (1985) and Certificate in Marketing from the Chartered Institute of Marketing (UK) 1995. He has a wealth of experience in Banking having spent over 10 years with the Bank for Housing & Construction (BHC) (from1987-2000). Before joining BHC he was employed by Produce Buying Company (PBC) as District Monitor of Akuafo Cheques from 1985-1986. He rose to the level of Regional Manager in 1987, a position he held until he resigned to join Bank for Housing &Construction (BHC) in 1987. He joined the Board of COMET in 2004. Mr. Sampson Awuah, 46 years of age, is an Executive Director of Comet. He holds Diploma in Civil Engineering from the Institute for Foreign Students, Sofia Bulgaria (1984-1985) and obtained the MSc Architecture from the Higher Institute for Architecture, Sofia, Bulgaria from 1985 to 1991. He is an Associate Member of the Ghana Institute of Architects (since February 1994) Mr. Awuah was employed by the State Housing Corporation (SHC) from February 1992 to January 1998. He held various Managerial positions including being the Acting Architect for the Northern, Upper and Upper West Regions. He was at one time the Chairman of the Greater Accra Interim Management Committee (IMC) of SHC Limited. He also acted as the Construction Supervisor for the construction of the National Theatre which was constructed by the China State Construction Corporation. He has been a Business Partner of Avangard Design Series, an Architectural Consulting firm based in Accra since March 1998. He joined Comet Properties Limited as an Executive Director in charge of Operations in 2006.
Mr. Kwasi Sarpong Peprah, 46 years of age, is the Director for Administration and Head of Human Resources. He is a graduate of Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology (BSc. Biochemistry) (1986). He has attended various Management programs to enhance his capacity. These include Certificate of Achievement in Project Management, (July 2006), and Post graduate Certificate in Business Administration (November 2006) at the Ghana Institute of Management and Public Administration (GIMPA).
2.12 POSTFLOTATIONRECONSTITUTIONOFTHEBOARD In line with good governance practices, the Board of Comet shall be reconstituted after the flotation to reflect the post flotation shareholding structure. The reconstitution of the Board will lead to the following changes.
14
The Executive Chairmanship position will be abolished and a new Chief Executive Officer of the Company shall be appointed, who will serve on the Board in executive capacity. The number of Executive Directors will be restricted to three appointees. At least two other independent Directors shall be appointed to the Board in non executive capacity. Board representation may be offered to one or two major Institutional Investors and these shall be non Executive Directors. In line with the proposed Board changes, the following Board Subcommittees shall be constituted. i) Sub-Committee on Finance, Accounting and Audit Matters ii) Sub-Committee on Procurement, Operations and Technical Matters iii) Sub-Committee on Legal, Administration and Employee Relations
The reconstituted Board shall be subject to the approval of the first post flotation Annual General Meeting of shareholders of the Company.
2.13 CORPORATEGOVERNANCEANDBOARDSUBCOMMITTEES The Board subcommittees would meet and deliberate on technical issues impacting on the performance of the company with respect to: a) Finance, Accounting and Auditing matters, b) Operational and Technical issues c) Legal, Administrative and Employees Relations and compensations matters These structures are meant to improve governance and further enhance Board oversight responsibilities. Decisions of the subcommittees would be subjected to ratification by the full Board. At full listing, these subcommittees shall be in place. 1. The Finance and Audit Board sub committee will have the following members: (i) Non executive Director, Chairman (ii) Executive Director (iii) Non-Executive Director The terms of reference and scope of functions of the Audit sub committee will include: a) To recommend the appointment of the external auditors of the company;
15
b) To liaise with the external auditors for the purposes of maintaining and ensuring audit quality, effectiveness, risk assessment, interaction with internal auditors and dealing with situations governing the resignation of the external auditors; c) To review with the auditors their report on the financial status of the company. d) To review the adequacy of systems of internal controls and of the degree of compliance with material policies, laws and the code of ethics and business practices of the company; e) To provide a direct channel of communication between the Board and the external and internal auditors of the company, Accountants and Compliance officers(if any) of the company; f) To review and approve the companys Capital and Operating Budgets and to prescribe guidelines for their disbursement; g) To report to the Board on all issues of significant extraordinary financial impact; and h) To assist the Board in developing policies that will enhance the controls and operating systems of the company. The sub-committee would have the authority to investigate any matter under its terms of reference and would be given full access to all necessary information. The subcommittee would also perform an annual review of the companys internal controls over financial, operational and compliance matters and report on the same to shareholders in the Annual Report of the company. 2. Sub Committee on Operational and Technical Issues will be made up of: (i) Executive Director in charge of Operations as Chairman (ii) Non Executive Director (iii) Non Executive Director 3. Sub Committee on Compensation Executive Directors who may be appointed members of this subcommittee would exclude themselves from deliberations concerning their own remuneration. The Terms of Reference and scope of functions of the remuneration subcommittee are a) To establish a formal and transparent procedure for developing policy on executive remuneration; b) To ensure that a proper system of short and long term compensation is in place to provide performance oriented incentives to management; c) To scrutinise executive service contracts with a view to ascertaining any inordinate losses which the company may be liable to incur in the event of an early termination of services/contracts.
16
d) To report on its activities and functions for inclusion in the Annual Report to shareholders.
2.14 BOARDSECRETARY Mr. Kwasi Sarpong Peprah, is the Secretary to the Board of Comet Properties Limited. He is also the Director for Administrative of the company.
2.15 SHAREHOLDINGSTRUCTURE Nana Odeneho Kyeremateng, the Executive Chairman is the sole shareholder of Comet Properties Limited. The Authorised Shares of the Company is 2,000,000,000 ordinary shares of no par value of which 154,559,920 have been issued and fully paid for. The Stated Capital of Comet as at March 31, 2010 stood at GH72,269,960.
2.16 MANAGEMENTTEAM The Company is managed by a 8-member Management Team who receives policy direction from the Board of Directors. The Internal Auditor position is vacant and the company will appoint an incumbent by December 2010. The company presently employs a total of 81 people including the Managing Director who is also the Chairman of the Board. After the flotation, the position of the CEO and the Chairman will be separated giving way for the appointment of new Chief Executive Officer of the company. To befit its status as a reputable listed company, Comet will appoint a professionally qualified accountant as its Financial Controller. Fifty (50) of the employees are permanent staff while the remaining 31 are temporal.
17
The Profiles of the Management Team are outlined below: 1. Mr. Odeneho Kyeremanteng (See Profile of Directors) 2. Mr. Samuel Kyeremanteng (See Profile of Directors) 3. Mr. Sampson Awuah (See Profile of Directors) 4. Mr. Kwasi Sarpong Peprah (See Profile of Directors) Mr. Nicholsa Mensah is the Manager in charge of Finance and Accounting. He graduated from the Institute of Profesional Studies in 2008 with BA Degree in Administration. He is a student member of Institute of Chartered Accountants (Ghana) having written and passed all subjects on level 1. He has been with Comet since June 2008. Mr. Mensah was on attachment training at Cocoa Processing Company Limited from June 2000 to June 2001. He worked with Compliance Trail, a Chartered Accounting firm from June 2001 to the end of 2003. Mr. Darlington Ankamah is the Legal Officer of the Company. He holds BA Degree from the University of Ghana, Legon (1980) and Barrister at Law (BL) from Ghana School of Law, Accra (2003). He has had a number of years of experience including being a Tutor at St. Thomas Aquinas Secondary School, Accra from 1980 to 1982; as a Contract Officer for the Rivers State Government in Nigeria from 1982 to1990 and was a Special Assistant to the Secretary to the Governor, Rivers State Government Nigeria from 1990 to 1996. Between 2000 and 2003, he was a Budget Analyst at the Ministry of Finance, Ghana. He joined Kwaku Kyeremanteng & Co., a Legal Firm in Accra from
18
2003 to November 2006 where he was detailed as legal consultant for Comet. He formally joined the Management of Comet Properties in December 2006. He is a member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants, Nigeria and the Ghana Bar Association. Maame Serwaah Kyeremateng, 30 years of age, is the Manager for Corporate Affairs of Comet Properties Limited. She had her Elementary School education at Datus Preparatory at Dansoman - Accra between 1986 t-o 1995. She was admitted at Holy Child Senior High School for her Secondary education from 1995 to 1999. Maame Serwaah entered the University of Ghana in 2001 for BA (Hons) degree and majored in Economics in 2005. She did her National Service in October 2005 and completed in July 2006 at the Foreign Affairs Ministry of the Republic of Ghana. Maame, after the National Service secured an employment with the Ghana Commercial Bank as Banking Officer in June 2007 and resigned in March 2008 to take appointment with Comet Properties Limited. In April, 2008 she was appointed Marketing Officer in charge of (Buildings and houses) sales until 1st April 2010 when Maame was offered a new position as Manager for Corporate Affairs. Mr. Joseph Kodua (29 years) is the Head of Estate and Marketing Department of Comet Properties. He holds the Bachelor of Arts Degree in Political Science from the University of Ghana. He joined Comet Properties in 2004 as a marketing assistant for period of 2 years. After obtaining his Bachelors Degree, he was promoted to the position of Head of Estates and Marketing.
2.17 OTHERSTAFF In addition to the eight (8) Management staff there are seventy-two (72) other employees, that are based in Accra and Brekusu-the maiden project site. The total staff strength of Comet stands at 81. The Organogram and the accompanying table below show the distribution of staff by department. Fifty (50) of the employees are permanent staff while the remaining 31 are temporal.
19
2.18
FAMILYRELATIONS
Two (2) of the Directors, Nana Odeneho Kyeremanteng and Mr Samuel Kyeremanteng, are siblings.
2.19 Emoluments of Directors and Senior Management Staff Staff remuneration in the year 2009 amounted to GH433,703. Of this, the salaries of the top management staff accounted for 32% amounting to GH140,916. Details of Directors Remuneration for the period under review, 2006 to 2009 are as follows. 2006 6,000 6,000 12,000 2007 6,000 6,000 12,000 2008 6,000 6,000 12,000 2009 12,000* 6,750** 18,750
* Board Meetings are conducted quarterly. Board sitting allowance is pegged at GH300 per Director per sitting (i.e. GH300 per quarter) In 2009 however, Board sitting allowance which had been stable for sometime was doubled. ** In 2009, the Chairmans fixed allowance was increased by GH750 per annum whilst that of the other Board members remained unchanged.
20
Board of Directors
Personal Assistant
Marketing Officers
Accounts Officers
HR Officers
Estate Officers
Workshop Officers
Services Officers
Road Officers
Building Officers
21
3.0
INDUSTRYANDMARKETINFORMATION
3.1 OVERVIEWOFTHEECONOMY
The macro-economy of Ghana has sustained relative stability over the past nine years in the face of difficult turns in the world economy. Although oil prices have increased astronomically, prudential fiscal and monetary measures instituted by government over the years have enabled the country maintain a stable macro-economy. End of year inflationary rate declined from 40.5% in 2000 to 21.3% in 2001 and declined further reaching 10.9% in December 2006. End of year inflation in 2008 and 2009 were 18.1% and 15.9% respectively. The country has since August 2010 maintained single digit inflation hovering around 9.5%. Gross international reserve measured in months of imports cover was 1.0 month in 2000. This increased steadily over the years to 3.8 months of imports cover in 2004. The situation however reversed after 2006. The 2009 national budget reported gross international reserves at 1.8 months of import cover for the year 2008. The situation improved significantly in 2009 with gross international reserves registering 3.2 months of imports cover. Interest rates have generally followed declining trends in the past 10 years, the only exception being 2008 (table 3.1). Following improvements in the macroeconomic situation in the country, the Monetary Policy Committee of the Bank of Ghana revised the BoG prime rate downwards from 24.5% in 2002 to 21.5% by the end of 2003. This was further reduced to 18.5% in 2005, and 12.5% in 2006. The prime rate however inched upwards to 12.75% in 2007 and also in 2008. The Central Banks prime rate in December 2009 was 18.0%. Interest rates for the 91-Day Treasury bill trended downwards in the period under review (table 2.1). The year 2008 however saw a reversal in the trend recording a year end 91day Treasury bill rate of 24.6%. The year 2009 saw a recovery trending downwards into 2010. Commercial banks base rates have responded positively to the general decline in interest rates as described above. With the general economic recovery after the 2008 slum, banks have begun to reduce their base rates.
22
The impact of the declining interest rates on the real estate industry is evident in the reduction in interest on mortgage loans, having reduced from the average of 40% in 1999/2001 to a current average of 24.5%. A declining mortgage rate into the future is expected to boost the real estate industry by expanding its market base to cover the expanding middle income workers, businessmen and entrepreneurs. The prudent management of the economy has translated into higher real GDP growth rates, with the rates rising from 3.7% in 2000 to 5.6% in 2004 and 6.4% in 2006. Real GDP growth in 2008 was 7.2% against the backdrop of the global economic meltdown and high crude oil prices. In 2009, the economy of Ghana grew by 5.4%. It is however provisionally estimated to grow at 6.5% in 2010 reaching over 10% in 2011 when commercial oil production comes on stream.
Source:BudgetStatementVariousYears,BoGAnnualReports.
3.2
GOVERNMENTPOLICIESANDREGULATORYENVIRONMENT
Access to housing is a fundamental human right recognized by the government of Ghana. The government, in furtherance of its obligation to ensure access to housing, has put in place various institutions to oversee the industry. The general policy direction of the government seeks to strengthen these institutions to function effectively. The state at different periods has been directly involved in the provision of housing facilities. For example, the 2006 budget statement outlined governments policy to construct 113
23
apartment blocks i.e. a total of 1,138 units of flats for the lower and middle income workers. The government in 2009 acknowledged and indicated its readiness to champion the cause of the real estate industry as an engine of growth. The potential for growth is clearly evident by the fact that the country has a deficit in its housing stock to the tune of one million. The main business law governing the operations of companies in Ghana is the Ghana Companies Act, 1963 (Act 179). Among other things it gives guidance on issues such as the roles and responsibilities of the board of directors, management, professional advisors to the company and general corporate governance. The Companys regulations are in line with standard provisions of the Act. Aside the Companies Act, the real estate sector in Ghana has specific operating guidelines that entities in the sector must comply with. For example, the National Building Regulations, 1996 issued under Section 63 of the Local Government Act 1963 (Act 462) has specific provisions on requirements for site development, structural fire precautions including fire resistance, fire escapes etc, drainage, sanitary conveniences, refuse disposal, water supply and lighting and electrical installations. Concerns have however been expressed about the cumbersome approval process for acquiring building permits. The Local Government Act 462 (1993) and the National Building Regulations give the District Planning Authority the sole responsibility of issuing building permits. There are nine (9) steps for acquiring a building permit. If an applicant is not informed of the grant or refusal of his or her application within three months of receipt by the Town and Country Planning or the Works Department, the application is considered to have been approved and the applicant may start work provided no queries are raised about the application. At the subsequent stages of the building project, the applicant must contact the Works Department for inspection before proceeding further. According to the Ghana Statistical Service Report on the 2000 Population and Housing Census, While the maximum period for processing a development permit is ninety days, the average processing time is six months. In fact, delays could be up to five years. Response is not timely and has contributed to the chaotic development in, for example, Accra Metropolitan Area (AMA).
24
To avoid the frustrations associated with the above procedures, prospective home owners prefer to buy houses from Real Estate Companies such as Comet Properties Limited who have the capacity, resources and expertise to follow through the approval processes and deliver houses free from litigations and other limiting encumbrances.
3.3
THESTRUCTUREOFTHEINDUSTRY
The real estate industry in Ghana has over the past two decades experienced tremendous growth. Currently the real estate industry is made up of two groups of operators. These are (i) the well organised and well resourced progressive Real Estate Developers whose numbers and influence continue to grow within the industry, and who are responsible for the development of most of the major real estate projects located in the regional capitals, especially in Accra and Kumasi. Companies in the category include Regimanuel Gray, Taysec, State Housing Company, ACP Estates, Trassaco, Elm Capital etc. (ii) the numerous micro-small scale artisans who have traditionally been the backbone of the industry, and who are the preference of the dominant lower to middle income earners who normally undertake single units development at a time. The construction industry which is made up of roads, highways and bridges, coastal works as well as housing is the second major contributor to real industry output after manufacturing. The sector also constitutes about 10% of GDP. Thus its importance cannot be overemphasized. The growth rate of the sub-sector has been one of the driving forces behind the real GDP growth as it has always grown more than the GDP growth rate. For example the sector grew by 8.2% in 2006. This increased to 15% in 2007 and then dropped to 14% in 2008. Real estate companies operating within the formal sector vary in sizes, areas of coverage and indeed experience. It is important to note that, SSNIT as a pension fund institution has invested extensively in real estate to qualify as one of the market leaders. The industry is also made up of professionals whose expertise has over the years shaped the direction of the industry. These professionals include valuers, architects, surveyors, and town and development planners. Other supporting activities have been developing alongside the construction industry. These include producers and distributors of cement, iron rods, roofing sheets and tiles,
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
25
nails and other accessories. These industries provide good substitutes for imported building materials which in turn saves the country needed foreign exchange.
3.4
STRATEGICOPPORTUNITIES
The Real Estate Industry affords stakeholders unique investment opportunities in Ghana. With secured land tenure, an investor in real estate is assured of continued flow of returns and appreciation of the financial value of the property over time. Investment in housing therefore constitutes significant store of value of resources of investors with no risk of loss of value in the absence of natural disasters. It is these natural advantages offered by the Real Estate Industry that Comet Properties Limited seeks to fully enjoy and extend to prospective investors.
3.5 3.5.1
MARKETANALYSES
DemandandSupplySituation
Available data indicate a large demand gap for housing facilities in the country estimated at between 45,000 to 60,000 housing units per annum. At the moment, the accumulated housing stock deficit stands at one million. The situation is more acute in the urban areas of which Accra and Tema Metropolis are considered as key. According to the 2000 Population and Housing Census of the Ghana Statistical Service, a significant percentage (45%) of households within the Accra Metropolis occupy one room with shared amenities. The remainder occupy two rooms or more. This state of affairs is directly attributable to low income levels, and supply bottlenecks among other things. Key supply bottlenecks include inadequate mortgage facilities provided at relatively prohibitive terms to potential home owners. Another important contributor to the inadequacy of housing stock is cost which in turn affects the price of houses. Observed price ranges of houses of noted real estate companies are presented in Table 3.2. The price differences are determined by location factors, type and quality of materials used, additional facilities like garage, garden and car port, presence of boys quarters and the number of storeys (floors).
26
3.5.2
CustomerBase
Real estate companies deal with two broad markets: local market and foreign markets. The companies have devised various means including flexible payment terms to attract customers. Most of the companies have established links abroad for the purpose of targeting Ghanaians in the Diaspora. The strategy is to access potential customers with the ability to pay for the houses at the shortest time possible. The housing needs of Ghanaians living abroad have been increasing in recent years. Several reasons account for the increase. Most of the Ghanaians who travelled abroad in the 1970s and the 1980s are returning home either as pensioners or as businessmen having accumulated substantial funds to continue their lives at home. Ghanaians in the Diaspora also find established real estate companies credible and are increasingly utilizing their services. The expansion of the economy of Ghana is evidently increasing the middle income bracket and thereby providing market for housing, a critical household valuable asset. With appropriate mortgage terms, Comet and indeed other real estate companies would have a large market.
3.5.3
Products
Comet Properties Limited has developed houses with different specifications to meet the needs of their varied customers. They also offer serviced plots of various dimensions. The range of houses includes: (a) 2 bedroom detached (b) 2 bedroom semi-detached
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
27
3 bedroom detached 3 bedroom semi-detached 3 bedroom detached with out-house 3 bedroom story 4 bedroom storey 4 bedroom story with out-house Building to the specification of customers
Table 3.3 details the standard features of various house types provided by Comet.
Comet appreciates the importance of using quality materials to ensure durability and longevity of its houses to the satisfaction of customers. The company, in the effort to provide customers with unique products, has created its maiden township called the Hill City, designed to contain 4,000 residential plots located at the Southern end of the Akuapem Hills near Ashongmang Housing Estates. The Hill City has been provided with the necessary facilities including water, electricity, and paved roads. Provision has been made for landline telephones, markets, worship centres, play grounds and other social
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
28
facilities. The township has been divided into suburbs, namely Hill Crescent, High Point, Mountain View and Hillside Extension. Comet offers competitive prices for its products and associated services.
3.5.4
Promotion
Comet has extensively studied the dual market for housing and has positioned itself to take advantage of these markets. Both Ghanaians living at home and abroad have been targeted by the company by offering them with flexible terms of payment either by dealing directly with the company or utilising the services of Mortgage Companies. Special needs of customers are also provided. The company has demarcated certain suburbs for customers willing to put up houses to specification. The serviced plots were designed for such customers. Comet utilises all manner of media forms to reach its customers. These include the print and the electronic media, outdoor advertisements and the use of the Internet.
3.5.5
Competition
Several real estate companies are located within Ghana. Whilst it is important to recognise the apparent supply gap within the industry, it is also important to appreciate the existence of some competition within the industry. Competition finds expression in factors including pricing, terms of payment, and the aesthetic value of the houses which is also determined by location factors, the design, availability of essential facilities, and accessibility, among other things. Comet Properties aims at 10% of the lucrative residential real estate market in AccraTema areas within the next five years. This will be a significant increase from its prevailing share of 2% of the total annual housing starts in the two cities.
29
4.0
PROSPECTSANDRISKFACTORS
Investing in the stocks of any company or relating to any company in any form entail some prospects as well as risks. These prospects and risks may be attributed to the general conditions of the market place or to the character of the specific stock or company or the industry. Notwithstanding the foregoing, it must be noted that an investment in the securities of a company entails certain risks. We have identified the risks in investing in the real estate sector to include the following;
4.1
LANDLITIGATIONS
The Land Tenure system in Ghana is fraught with numerous and lengthy litigations. This has been a major disincentive to investment in the country and is seen as a key risk factor in doing business in Ghana. Comet seeks to mitigate this risk by acquiring and establishing land banks with relevant and valid documents to necessitate easy transfer of lease titles to home owners and other investors.
4.2
FOREIGNEXCHANGE
An estimated 40% of the cost of building houses is spent on imported building materials notably tiles, sinks, basins, bathes, lighting and sometimes roofing materials, paints, wires and fittings. Foreign exchange risks are high in periods of continuing depreciation of the value of the Ghana cedi. Where such declines in the value of the Ghana cedi are unexpected, the potential for exchange losses increases for companies that rely heavily on imported inputs. Fortunately, the cedi has remained relatively stable and efforts are being made to stabilise it. However, Comet, realising this risk, indexes the prices of its houses to the US dollar, although prices are payable in Ghana cedis. The purpose for doing this is to mitigate the potential foreign exchange loss associated with the weakening Ghanaian cedi.
30
4.3
COMPETITION
There are presently over 50 real estate companies operating within the Accra-Tema Metropolis that compete directly with Comet Properties. Comet, in the midst of the competition is developing a niche for itself in a way that the company envisages shall significantly differentiate its products and offer unique value to its customers. The companys Hill City concept creates a unique township provided with all necessary amenities. The community has its own water supply source from the deep valleys of the Akuapem Mountains independent of Ghana Water Company Limited. Comet thus provides its customers with value for their money and shall continue to do so. Comet is able to compete effectively as far as pricing is concerned partly because of bulk delivery of service on large track of land that ends up reducing the fixed cost per unit of house. The company in addition has various specifications of houses to meet the pockets of its varied customers.
4.4
LOANCONTRACTINGRISK
There is minimal interest bearing debt standing in the books of Comet. Whilst loans, effectively utilised increase the profits of the company, the interest on the loan when not managed properly could erode the profits of the firm. The risk of default and the consequent legal burdens are carefully considered in loan contracting. All significant credit balance on Directors Current account which constituted about 94% of current assets in earlier years have been converted to equity. With injection of fresh capital through public flotation, the possibility of the company going in for loan facility shall be reduced considerably.
4.5
INDUSTRIALRELATIONSRISK
This risk emanates from disputes among management, staff and owners of the company. Comet expects to employ over 350 staff and subcontractors at its Hill City Estate alone. This will require effective management of human resources by providing channels for addressing grievances of staff and dealing with such grievance with utmost diligence and speed.
31
Additionally regular staff durbars, job analysis and evaluations, regular staff appraisals and other methods designed to create conducive working environment for high performance and to motivate the staff would be implemented.
4.6
ENVIRONMENTALANDSOCIALRISKFACTORS
The construction industry is noted for its environmental risks and attendant social upheavals. Comet addresses these twin problems on two levels: (a) taking care of the environment and (b) addressing the needs of the communities affected by Comet projects. Comet undertakes thorough appraisal in planning its projects so as to fit it within the natural environment in which it finds itself. For example, because the current project is being sited on virgin land, the company has designed the project to preserve the streams and spring waters in the valleys as well as selected trees of commercial value. The community shall benefit immensely from these water sources so preserved. Moreover, the company has a property management team to manage the township Comet is creating by collecting and dumping refuse, maintaining the landscape, attending to the water pumping station and responding to the concerns of members of the community as far as the environment is concerned. Comet relates very well with the Chiefs and people of Brekuso, the village sharing boundary with Comets Hill City. To provide security to the area, Comet has built a modern Police Station for the people. Comet is encouraged to continue with this proactive and positive attitude toward the environment and be sensitive to social issues so as to operate peaceably and add value to its products. The company, as indicated in this prospectus plans to produce aggregate stones, quarry dust, etc for its construction activities. Prior to the establishment of such a vital facility, all relevant permits will be secured and mitigating measures to address attendant environmental damage instituted.
32
5.0
FINANCIALINFORMATION
5.1 CLEARANCEONTHEHISTORICALFINANCIALSTATEMENTS
Deloitte & Touche Ibex Court, 4 Liberation Road Dr. Ako Adjei Interchange PO Box GP 453 Accra Tel: +233 (0) 21 775 355 +233 (0) 21 773 761 Fax:+233 (0) 21 775 480 www.deloitte.com May 25, 2010
INDEPENDENT REPORTING ACCOUNTANTS OPINION The Board of Directors Comet properties Limited High Street P. O. Box 768 Accra Gentlemen, Issue of Ordinary Shares We have examined the audited financial statements of Comet Properties Limited (the "Issuer") for the years ended 31 December 2006,2007,2008,2009 and the unaudited financial statement for the three months period ended 31 March 2010. J K Attobrah and partners have acted as Auditors of the Company for the years 2006 to 2008 and Comet Properties Limited changed their auditors to Cardinal Consults in 2009. For each of the relevant years, the Auditors issued an unqualified audit report. The Board of Directors approved the audited financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2009. No audited financial statements have been prepared for submission to the shareholders for any period subsequent to 31 December 2009.
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
33
The audited financial statements have been prepared on the basis of the accounting policies set out below. For all the accounting periods dealt with in this report, the financial statements have been, in all material respects, prepared in accordance with the Ghana National Accounting Standards. Our work has been carried out in accordance with the Auditing Guidelines: Prospectuses and the Reporting Accountant In our opinion, the financial information set out below gives a true and fair view of the profits and cash flows of the Company for the years stated and of the state of affairs of the Company at the end of those years, in accordance with Ghana National Accounting Standards. Yours faithfully,
34
5.2
SUMMARYOFHISTORICALFINANCIALSTATEMENTS
Tables 5.1, 5.2 and 5.3 summarises the Comets historical financial statements from 2006 to 2009.
Table 5.1: Profit and Loss Accounts for the Years Ended 2006 to 2009
ITEM Amount in Ghana Cedis (GH) Turnover Cost of Sales Gross Profit Less: General & Admin Expenses Net Profit Before Interest & Taxation Finance Cost Profit After Tax Income Surplus Account Balance at January 1 Net Profit for the Year Transfers to Stated Capital Balance at December 31 1,733,485 758,311 1,700,000 791,796 791,796 1,833,427 2,625,223 2,625,223 2,663,564 5,288,787 5,288,787 3,373,685 8,662,472 5,454,690 3,931,098 1,523,592 672,781 18,272,891 15,024,503 3,248,388 1,311,511 19,339,504 15,070,392 4,269,112 1,372,482 14,507,600 9,685,943 4,821,657 1,262,302 2006 2007 2008 2009
35
2,759,273* 2,759,273
225,493,909 225,493,909
227,843,065 227,843,065
229,368,035 229,368,035
Current Assets Stocks Receivables & Prepayments Bank & Cash Balances
Total Assets EQUITY AND LIABILITIES Capital and Surpluses Stated Capital Income Surplus Capital Surplus Total Equity Current Liabilities Trade & other Payables Short Term Loan Total Current Liabilities Long Term Liabilities Total Liabilities Total Equity and Liabilities
*Note: Non-current property and equipment assets value for 2006 reflected what was originally carried in the books, prior to the December 2006 assets revaluation and additions to land banks in 2007, which resulted in significant increase in the value of
36
assets under this line item in the subsequent years. The same resulted in significant capital surpluses recognised from 2007 and beyond.
Table 5.3: Cash Flow Statements for the Years Ended December 31, 2006 to 2009
Amount in Ghana Cedis (GH) Operating Activities Profit from Operations Adjustment for Depreciation on Property, Plant & Equipment (Profit)/Loss on sale of Assets Operating Cash Flows before movement in working capital Increase in Stocks Increase in Receivables Increase/(Decrease) in Payables Cash Generated by Operations Interest Paid Net Cash from Operating Activities Investing Activities Purchase of Property, Plant & Equipment Proceeds from sale of Assets Net Cash used in Investing Activities Financing Activities Long Term Loans Repayment of long term liabilities Overdraft Net Cash used in Financing Activities Increase in cash & cash equivalents Cash & cash equivalents at the beginning of the period Cash and Bank Balance 2006 850,811 2007 1,936,877 2008 2,896,630 2009 3,559,355
404,873 24,000
1,263,143
1,625,007
1,046,626
(4,997,779) (4,997,779)
(3,974,163) (3,974,163)
37
5.2.1
AccountingPolicies
The principal accounting policies adopted by the company in the preparation of these financial statements are set out below: (a) Basis of Accounting These financial statements have been prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. The financial statements have been prepared under the historical cost convention. Comet will take the necessary steps to be IFRS compliant by the end of 2010. (b) Property, Plant and Equipment All fixed assets are stated at historical cost less depreciation. Depreciation of fixed assets is calculated on the straight line method to write off the cost of each asset to their residual values over their estimated useful lives as follows: Buildings 10% Motor Vehicle 20% Plant & Machinery 15% Office Equipment 15% Furniture and Fittings 15% (c) Stocks Stocks are stated at the lower of cost and net realisable value. Cost of all stocks is determined by all expenses incurred in bringing these stocks to their current destination and present condition. Net realisable value is the estimate of the selling price in the ordinary course of business less the selling expenses. (d) Cash and Cash Equivalent Cash and cash equivalent are carried in the balance sheet at cost. For the purpose of the cash flow statements, cash and cash equivalents comprise cash in hand and deposit held with banks. (e) Debtors Debtors are carried at anticipated realisable values. Estimates are made for doubtful receivables based on reviews of all outstanding amounts at the year end. Bad debts are written off during the year when they are identified.
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
38
5.2.2
NotestotheFinancialStatements
1. Directors Accounts This represents funds invested into the company in the form of cash and fixed assets. 2. Stated Capital The company is registered with two billion (2,000,000,000) shares of no par value of which 154,559,920 has been issued for a cash and non-cash consideration of GH72,279,960. 3. Debtors This has been carried at anticipated realizable value. Estimates are made for doubtful receivables based on reviews of all outstanding amounts at the year end. Bad debts are written off during the year identified. 4. Foreign Exchange Transactions denominated in foreign currencies are translated into Cedis at the rate of exchange prevailing at the transaction date. Balances denominated in foreign currencies are translated into cedis at the rate of exchange ruling at the companys balance sheet date. 5. Cost of sales
2006 34,757,612 2007 75,820,500 2008 106,118,670 2009 115,110,310
ITEM Amount in GH Stock as at January 1 Purchases Land Lease & Cost of Preparatory Works Building Materials Development Levies Depreciation
39
6.
Stocks
2006 55,500,000 14,740,500 5,580,000 75,820,500 2007 16,465,250 7,653,420 71,000,000 11,000,000 106,118,670 2008 23,456,780 13,085,094 64,603,486 13,964,950 114,810,310
ITEM Amount in GH Stock at December 31 Serviced Plots & Buildings Building Materials Buildings Development & Civil Works Total
ITEM Amount in GH Stock at December 31 Houses Available Houses under construction Building Materials Serviced Plots Development & Civil contracts services Total
7.
ITEM Amount in GH Salaries Directors' Emoluments Printing and Stationery Fuel and Lubricants Electricity and water Travelling & Transport Bank Charges Registration and Licensing Communication Expenses Accountancy Charges Site Expenses General Expenses
40
2006 42,327 6,227 33,337 10,810 4,000 1,100 24,000 224,680 672,781
8.
Accounts Receivable
2006 3,048,917 1,363,946 3,600 4,416,463 2007 8,953,014 6,677,349 4,167,442 19,797,805 2008 8,027,106 3,210,199 2,412,324 13,649,629 2009 5,438,506
ITEM Amount in GH Debtors (Land & Houses) acquisitions Contract Service Prepayments Land & Admin Development Levies
1,759,003 7,197,509
9.
ITEM Amount in GH Trade Payables (Land Owners) Suppliers & Subcontractors PHC Motors Landline Properties Ltd Accruals Interest Payable Registrar General's Dept.
41
10.
ITEM Amount in GH i) Loans (Financial Institutions) Opening balance Jan. 1 Additions Payments Balance as at Dec. 31 ii) Other Liabilities Landline Properties Ltd Land Owners Balance as at Dec. 31 TOTAL
2006
2007
2008
2009
2,311,500 2,311,500
11.
ITEM Amount in GH Fixed Assets Schedule Cost at January 1 Land bank Office Building Plant & Machinery Motor Vehicles Office Equipments Furniture & Fittings 2006 100,000 568,800 341,900 16,000 15,000 1,041,700 2007 1,850,000 1,201,286 341,900 18,113 18,487 3,429,786 2008 219,000,000 3,278,651 3,654,558 454,416 490,213 549,727 227,427,565 2009 219,000,000 3,278,651 7,282,161 800,976 490,213 549,727 231,401,728
1,850,000 632,486
3,627,603
4,421,596
42
4,421,596
1000,000 100,000 -
1,850,000
1,850,000
Cost as at December 31 Land Office Building Plant & Machinery Motor Vehicles Office Equipments Furniture & Fittings
Depreciation as at Jan. 1 Office Building Plant & Machinery Motor Vehicles Office Equipments Furniture & Fittings
185,000 180,193
245,750 543,725
327,864 1,061,052
73,770 795,789
43
40,000
40,000 Depreciation as at Dec. 31 Office Building Plant & Machinery Motor Vehicles Office Equipments Furniture & Fittings
Net Book Value Land Office Building Plant & Machinery Motor Vehicles Office Equipments Furniture & Fittings
44
5.2.3
ManagementAccountsMarch31,2010
Below is the Management Accounts for the first quarter of 2009 ending March 31, 2010. Table 5.4: Profit and Loss Account for the Period ended March 31, 2010
For the period ended 31 March 2010 Turnover Cost of sales Gross profit General and administrative expenses Profit before taxation Finance Cost Profit after tax transferred to income surplus account Income surplus account For the period ended 31 March 2010 2010 GH 8,662,472 752,364 9,414,836 9,414,836 2009 GH 5,288,787 3,373,685 8,662,472 8,662,472 2010 GH 3,077,965 (1,846,779) 1,231,186 (381,172) 850,014 (97,650) 752,364 2009 GH 14,507,600 (9,685,943) 4,821,657 (1,262,302) 3,559,355 (185,670) 3,373,685
45
72,279,960 9,414,836 78,115,916 159,810,712 8,349,290 8,277,900 16,627,190 7,456,710 24,083,900 183,894,612
72,279,960 8,662,472 182,046,550 262,988,982 34,307,450 7,250,274 41,557,724 58,225,000 99,782,724 362,771,706
46
Table 5.6: Cash Flow Statement for the period ended March 31, 2010
2010 GH Operating activities Profit from operations Adjustments for depreciation on Property, Plant & Equipment Operating cash flows before movement in working capital Increase in stocks Increase/(Decreases) in Receivables (Decrease) in Payables Cash generated by operations Interest paid Net cash from operating activities Investing activities Purchase of property, plant and equipment proceeds on sale of Asset Net cash used in investing activities Financing activities Increase in Long term Liability Repayment of long term Liability Overdraft Net cash used in financing activities Net increase in cash and cash equivalents Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of the period Cash and bank balance 850,014 501,345 1,351,359 42,148,402 473,333 (25,958,160) 18,014,934 (97,650) 17,917,284 (4,270,888) (4,270,888) (14,348,924) 1,027,626 (13,321,298) 325,098 2,276,560 2,601,658 3,559,355 1,046,626 4,605,981 (9,119,292) 6,452,120 (51,488,463) (49,549,654) (185,670) (49,735,324) (4,421,596) 1,850,000 (2,571,596) 56,900,000 (9,900,000) 7,250,274 54,250,274 1,943,354 333,206 2,276,560 2009 GH
47
5.2.4
TechnicalAnalysisoftheHistoricalFinancialStatements
Gross Income Gross income has seen Gross Turnover significant growth in the GHC 19 ,3 3 9 ,50 4 GHC 18 ,2 72 ,8 9 1 review period increasing by an average of 100% per annum from 2005 to 2008. The company recorded gross income of GH2.18 million in 2005. This increased to GH5.5 million in 2006 and GHC 5,4 54 ,6 9 0 then increased by a GHC 2 ,18 1,9 78 whopping 235% in 2007 to GH18.17 million. In 2008, Comet recorded GH19.34 2005 2006 2007 2008 million in gross revenue. The year 2009 saw a reduction in gross revenue by 25%.
2009
This significant growth has been achieved due to a myriad of reasons, mostly attributable to the quality of products offered by Comet onto the real estate market and the strong marketing drive of the company. The companys Revenue is generated from four (4) main sources namely: Serviced lands and administrative charges (39%) Development levies (16%) Contract services and other income (9%), and Houses sold (37%) Cost of Sales Cost of sales generally consist of land lease and cost of land preparation, building materials, development service charges and apportionment of depreciation to direct operating cost. Cost of sales averaged 74% of turnover from 2005 to 2009. Selling, Administrative and General Expenses These indirect expenses have been significantly controlled over the period under review and was at about 7% of gross income. Selling, administrative and general expenses for 2005 was GH123,300. This increased to GH672,781 in 2006, GH1.31 million in
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
48
2007, GH1.37 million in 2008 and then declined to GH1.26 million in 2009. Staff remuneration in the year 2009 amounted to GH433,703 representing 34% of total selling, administrative and general expenses. Of this, the salaries of the top management staff accounted for 11.2% amounting to GH140,916. Profits after Taxes The company performed Profits After Tax significantly well by way of GHC 3 ,3 73 ,6 8 5 its net earnings. In 2005, comet recorded a net profit GHC 2 ,6 6 3 ,56 4 after tax of GH661,109. This increased by 15% to GHC 1,8 3 3 ,4 2 7 GH758,311 in 2006 and then by 446% to GH1.83 million in 2007 and finally GHC 758 ,3 11 GHC 6 6 1,10 9 by 45% to GH2.66 million in 2008. In 2009, the company made a net profit of GH3.37 million 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 representing 27% increase over the previous years profit. The companys gross balance on its Income Surplus Accounts at the end of 2005 stood at GH1.73 million. In 2006, a transfer of GH1.70 million was made from the income surplus account to stated capital. Comet, as a result of continuously posting profits has increased its income surplus account balance from GH791,796 in 2006 to GH5.29 million by the end of December 2008 and further to GH8.66 million in December 2009. The Companys Management Accounts as at March 31, 2010 recorded an income surplus balance of GH9.41 million. Working Capital Working capital though impressive especially in 2006, a large part of it is in stocks of land. In 2008, lands that are undeveloped which were hitherto classified as stocks were re-classified as fixed assets. In 2008, therefore an amount of GH219 million in the name of land was reported in that years financial statement. Cash Balances The cash balances for the period 2006 to 2009 show that the company is in quite a good financial health.
The total bank overdraft as at March 31, 2010 amounting to GH8,277,900 stood in the names of the following banks.
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
49
Name of Bank Barclays Bank Ghana Limited Prudential Bank Limited HFC Bank Limited Total
Ratio Analysis Table 5.7 below shows the summary of key financial ratios from 2006 to 2009. Table 5.7: Key Financial Ratios
ITEM Liquidity Current Ratio Quick Ratio Asset Management Fixed Assets Turnover Total Assets Turnover Debt Management Total Debt Ratio Debt/Equity 2006 64.69 3.64 2007 1.44 0.23 2008 1.50 0.16 2009 3.21 0.02
1.98 0.07
0.08 0.05
0.08 0.05
0.06 0.05
0.12 0.14
0.27 0.37
0.27 0.37
0.04
Profitability Profit Margin Basic Earnings Power EBIT/Total Assets Return on Equity
14% 1% 1%
10% 1% 1%
14% 1% 1%
23.3% 1% 1.3%
50
5.3
FINANCIALFORECASTS
Deloitte & Touche Ibex Court, 4 Liberation Road Dr. Ako Adjei Interchange PO Box GP 453 Accra Tel: +233 (0) 21 775 355 +233 (0) 21 773 761 Fax:+233 (0) 21 775 480 www.deloitte.com
The Board of Directors Comet properties Limited Ghana Limited High Street P. O. Box 768 Accra
Gentlemen, Reporting Accountants report on forecast and projections We have examined the accounting policies and calculations for the profit forecast and projections of the Company for the five years ending 31 December 2014, set out on Pages 54 to 56 of this report in accordance with the Listing Rules of the Ghana Stock Exchange (GSE), the companys Code, Act 179 and L.I.1728 of the Securities and Exchange Commission applicable to the examination of prospective financial information. The directors are responsible for the forecast and projections, including the assumptions set out on page 53 on which it is based. The forecasts and projections have been prepared for inclusion in the offering Circular. These forecasts and projections have been prepared using a set of assumptions that include hypothetical assumptions about future events and managements actions that are not necessarily expected to occur. Consequently, readers are cautioned that these assumptions may not be appropriate for purposes other than those described above. Based on our examination of the evidence supporting the assumptions, nothing has come to our attention which causes us to believe that these assumptions do not provide a reasonable basis for the projections.
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
51
In our opinion the forecast financial statements, so far as the accounting policies and calculations are concerned, have been properly compiled on the basis of the assumptions made by the Directors of the Company, and are presented on a basis consistent with the accounting policies normally adopted by the Company. We do not express an opinion as to whether the actual results for the forecast period will approximate the forecast because events and circumstances do not frequently occur as expected, and those differences may be material. Yours faithfully,
52
5.3.1
KeyUnderlyingAssumptionsforthefinancialProjections COMET PROPERTIES LIMITED sells its properties for prompt cash payment. In view of this, clients who cannot afford immediate cash payment are introduced to the various mortgage institutions especially the Ghana Home Loans Company limited who can offer prompt payment on behalf of clients. The five years financial projection is based on the sales and marketing plans for the next five years.
Macroeconomic Assumptions We assume a strong and stable economy with no major recession; We assume a healthy growth trend in the national real estate market, along with continued strong national economy; We assume that COMET will continue to stay in the real estate industry with either a continuing or an evolving technology; Though the inflationary trend has been flexible downwards in the last few years with the exception of 2008 and 2009 which posted erratic inflationary trends, this year has been recording declining inflation rates posting a low of 10.5% at the close of 2006, we assume a conservative inflationary rate of 15 percent per annum throughout the planning period; Although, the Ghana cedi has sustained relative instability in the past 3 years, we expect it to remain relatively stable in the next five years. Our assumption is based on the concerted efforts by government and Bank of Ghana through various restrictive fiscal and monetary policies that have sought to reduce inflation and stabilise the cedi. We anticipate the cedi to remain stable averaging GH1.45 to the US Dollar over the next 12 months. Subsequently, we assume that the cedi will depreciate in nominal terms by 5% per annum for the projection in the out years. We expect the economy to register growth rates per annum averaging 7.0%. Production and Sales Assumptions Cost of construction is based on the bill of quantities and is expected to increase by 5 percent per annum per housing unit constructed and is expected not to exceed 60% of selling price of the houses; The company through the past few years has accumulated stock of houses (completed and uncompleted) to the tune of GG33,778,952 as at December 31, 2009 and then to GH22,165,000 as at March 31, 2010. The company plans to
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
53
reduce its stock holdings by embarking on aggressive sales drive whilst embarking on massive construction of new houses to meet the increasing demand for housing in the country. Based on these conservative performance rates, average revenue growth for the planned period calculated on revenues from houses sold is 25% and this is expected to continue into the out years; It is expected that the values of properties would increase by 7 percent per annum; with prices expected to escalate by the same rate. General and Administrative Expenses Salaries and wages is expected to increase by 10 percent per annum; Printing and stationery is expected to increase by 8 percent per annum; Fuel and lubricants will increase by 15 percent per annum; Electricity and water will increase by 8 percent per annum; Bank charges and interest will increase by 3 percent annum; Communication expenses is expected to increase by 3 percent per annum; Accountancy charges is expected to increase by 5 percent per annum; Miscellaneous expenses is projected to increase by 15 percent per annum; Directors emoluments is projected to increase by 8 percent per annum; Advertising is projected to increase by 15 percent per annum. In total, Direct Operating Expenses is projected to increase by 21% per annum. Depreciation The Corporate office building is depreciated at 3 percent on the straight line basis. All other fixed assets are depreciated at 15 percent per annum on straight line except motor vehicles which is depreciated at 10 percent per annum on straight line method. Other Assumptions Work in progress made up of houses under construction is assumed to be 15% percent of end of years stock of properties; The Company owes its land owners (creditors) an amount of GH7,456,710. This has been budgeted to be repaid over three (3) year period in equal instalments. Taxes are paid one year in arrears; Transaction cost is assumed to be 5.5% percent of the total funds to be raised from the capital market or any other sources;
54
Land bank is utilised at a rate of 2% per annum amounting to GH1,246,074. This fixed amount is transferred to stock for processing into serviced plots for direct sale or to be developed into houses for sale. Table 5.8: Projected Income Statement, 2010-2014
Amount in Ghana Cedis (GH)
Serviced Plots Development Levies Dev & Civil Contract Services Houses sold Turnover Direct Expenses Depreciation Gross Profit General Expenses Depreciation Flotation Cost EBIT EBT Taxation Profit After Tax
2010 4,978,854 2,987,312 347,467 9,208,619 17,522,252 8,726,001 2,096,118 6,700,133 1,049,419 120,323 618,240 4,912,151 4,912,151 4,912,151
2011 5,807,335 3,484,401 364,840 14,388,468 24,045,044 12,590,755 2,096,118 9,358,171 1,206,832 661,932 618,240 6,871,167 6,871,167 1,717,792 5,153,375
2012 6,271,922 3,763,153 383,082 17,985,585 28,403,742 15,173,284 2,096,118 11,134,340 1,387,857 661,932 618,240 8,466,311 8,466,311 2,116,578 6,349,734
2013 6,773,676 4,064,206 402,236 22,481,981 33,722,098 18,324,410 2,096,118 13,301,570 1,596,035 661,932 618,240 10,425,363 10,425,363 2,606,341 7,819,022
2014 7,315,570 4,389,342 422,348 28,102,476 40,229,736 22,180,185 2,096,118 15,953,432 1,835,441 661,932 618,240 12,837,820 12,837,820 3,209,455 9,628,365
55
Net Assets Shareholders Fund Stated Capital Equity injection Income Surplus Capital Surplus
216,347,218
219,696,912
223,824,239
228,906,604
235,165,041
56
Changes in current assets/liabilities (Increase)/Decrease in stock (Increase)/Decrease in receivables Increase/(Decrease in Payables) Cash generated by operating activities Payment of Overdraft Payment of Long term liabilities Taxation Dividend Payments to Reg Gen Dept Payment of Flotation Expenses Investing Activities Plastic T&G Equipment Stone Quarry Plant Expansion of Wood Processing Plant Expansion of Aluminum Fabrication Plant Motor Vehicles Financing Activities Equity Injection Cash and Cash Equivalents Opening bal Closing balance
(11,550,359) (2,036,950) 115,176 (13,472,133) (5,725,301) (8,277,900) (2,485,570) (270,480) (3,091,198) (14,125,148) (1,450,000) (2,175,000) (3,625,000) (725,000) (2,000,000) (9,975,000) 54,095,972 24,270,523 2,601,658 26,872,181
(2,485,570) (1,719,253)
(2,116,578) (2,222,407)
(2,606,341) (2,736,658)
(4,204,823)
(6,007,043)
(4,338,985)
(5,342,999)
57
SHAREPRICEVALUATION
ResultsofValuation WeightedAverageCostofCapital(WACC)
The WACC which was used to calculate the Present Values of the Free Cash Flow was derived from the debt to equity ratio of 4%:96% for the company, required returns on equity of 17.5%, cost of debt of 28% and a tax shield of 75%. Despite the in built risk factors in the various variables, the composite was adjusted by a risk premium of 10% to arrive at a WACC of 27.7%.
5.4.3
DiscountedFreeCashFlowValue
From the above assumptions and the forecasts the FCF Model yielded a value of GH187,395,382. 5.4.4 NetAdjustedBookValue(NABV)
The open market values of the company based on the Revaluation of all the landed assets of COMET Properties Limited undertaken in March 2010 by Messrs APEX Valuation, Surveying & Property Consult was GH174,347,742 or (US$ US$120,239,822). The Net Assets of the Company as at January 01, 2010 was GH159,810,712 and it is considered as the Adjusted Net Assets for the valuation of the company.
5.4.5
WeightedMarketValue
The estimated market value of Comet was derived by calculating a weighted average of the two valuation models used and the results are presented in table 5.12. The resulting value of GH168,086,113 is considered a fair market value for Comet Properties Limited.
58
5.4.6
JustificationforSelectionofweights
1. The assignment of a weight of 70% to the Net Adjusted Book Value approach is designed to reflect the fundamental importance of the stock of land and other facilities including the buildings, machinery and equipment in housing delivery, which ultimately determines the ability of the enterprise to generate products for sale. 2. The viability of any enterprise is significantly reflected in its ability to generate and retain cash flow for reinvestment and for dividend payment. Every investors preference is to hold equity in a firm which has the potential to generate cash flow over and above its operating requirements. Firms in this category have the potential to pay dividends and also to reinvest, resulting in higher future cash flows and dividends. The assignment of a weight of 30% to the FCFE model of share pricing is to reflect this importance.
5.4.7
RecommendedSharePriceandDiscountoffered
From the analysis of the companys operating circumstances and past financial performance as contained in our share price valuation, we recommend a price per share of GH1.09 and the recommended minimum quantity to be purchased by an applicant is 50 shares. The company has offered a discount of 8% amounting to GH0.09. The price per share is therefore GH1.00.
59
5.4.8
ThePriceEarningsMultiple
Table 5.14 presents the projected PE ratios for Comet. Table 5.14: Projected Price-Earning Ratios
P/E Analysis Price Per Share Earnings Per Share (old) PE Ratio Clydestone (Dec. 31, 2009) maximum as at date PBC, SWL and CFAO (Dec. 31, 2009) Minimum as at date HFC (Dec. 31, 2009) Average for the market (Dec 31, 2009) 2010 GH 1.00 GH 0.0318 43 132 2011 GH 1.00 GH 0.0333 41 2012 GH 1.00 GH 0.0411 33 2013 GH 1.00 GH 0.0506 27 2014 GH 1.00 GH 0.0623 22
2 15 17.61
The value of Comet Properties is quite tangible and easily verifiable as it's a land based investment with a value which could be easily ascertained at the market place. Hence the Company cannot be overpriced. There is clearly not a market comparable for purposes of assessing the value and P/E of Comet, since there is no real estate firm listed on the market. HFC being a-Financial Institution (i.e. a Universal Bank) cannot
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
60
serve as a useful proxy for the evaluation of Comet, the two are in completely different but complementary industries. Hence in assessing the value of Comet there has been overwhelming reliance on the prevailing market value of the landed assets of the Company, as opposed to relying on fanciful assumptions and projections of Revenues and costs to arrive at a Net present Value. Traditionally, P/E ratios of viable real estate firms tend to be high. This is especially the case in Ghana due to the slow rate of outright housing purchases by individuals and institutions, and non availability of financial intermediation services to support the financing of home purchases or commercial property development. It is also influenced by the type of homes being developed. Comet with its huge landed asset stock has for sometime concentrated on developing homes for sale to upscale clients, hence the slow rate of development influenced by the slow rate of housing purchases which is underlined by the high cost of such developments. Moreover such developments attract few buyers. This partly explains the low level of earnings vis-a-vis the high landed asset stock: and hence the high historical PIE ratio. However this does not in anyway pose a threat to the financial viability of the Company. With the injection of funds, Comet will along side its current development initiative, concentrate on developing complementary lower income/workers housing, which will be lowly priced and will attract more purchases i.e. increase earnings vis-a-vis the stock of landed assets and hence improve the P/E of the Company over time.
61
6.0
TERMSANDCONDITIONSOFTHEOFFER
6.1
GENERALCONDITIONS
If applicant receives a copy of this document and/ or application form in any territory other than Ghana, one may not treat it as constituting an invitation or an offer, nor should one use such application form, unless in the relevant territory, such an invitation and offer could lawfully be made to applicant without compliance with any unfulfilled registration or other legal requirements. It is the responsibility of applicant, if she/he is outside Ghana and/or subject to the laws of any territory other than Ghanaian territory and if he/she receives a copy of this document and/or an application form and wishes to make an application, to satisfy himself/herself as to the full observance of the laws of the relevant territory in connection therewith, including the obtaining of any governmental or other consents and compliance with other necessary formalities, and to pay transfer or other taxes or duties required to be paid in such territory in respect of the offer of shares acquired by applicant under this offer.
6.2 i.
OFFERTOPURCHASESHARES
ii.
iii. iv.
The Applicant offers to purchase from Comet such number of shares that when multiplied by the offer price, nearest to but not more than, the amount indicated in his/her application Form on these terms and conditions and subject to the Regulations of the Company. The Applicant agrees that his/her offer cannot be revoked after 31st January, 2011 or such later date as the Directors and the Advisors may agree, and promises that any cheque, bankers draft or money or postal order will be honoured on the first presentation and that this paragraph constitutes an agreement between the applicant and Comet. It becomes binding when application is posted by registered mail or in the case of delivery by hand is received by the company. The applicant must pay all bank commissions and transfers and other bank charges. A thumbprint on application form will be accepted instead of a signature thereon only if it is duly certified in accordance with the Laws of Ghana. If the application form is not completed correctly or is amended, or if any cheque, bankers draft, money order or postal order is found to be less than the amount stated on the application form, it may still be treated as valid. In such cases, the Advisors 62
v.
decision as to whether to treat the application as valid and how to construe, amend or complete it shall be final. The applicant will not however be treated as having offered to purchase a number of shares on offer which, when multiplied by the offer price, is more than the amount of remittance upon allotment of shares. An application may be rejected in whole or in part at the discretion of the Advisors and Management of Comet for applications that are incomplete, illegible, or if it is determined that the applicant is not eligible to participate in this public offer.
6.3 i.
ACCEPTANCEOFOFFER
ii. iii.
Acceptance of an offer will be made (if application is received, validated or received valid, processed and not rejected) by notifying acceptance to the Advisors and Management of Comet. The acceptance may be of the whole or any part thereof and in the latter event, the number of shares applicant offers to purchase may be scaled down; If the offer to purchase is accepted (in whole or in part) there will be a binding contract under which the applicant will be required to purchase the shares in respect of which the offer has been accepted and has not been repudiated
6.4 i.
PAYMENTFORSHARES
ii.
iii.
Applicant undertakes to pay the purchase price for the shares in respect of which the offer is accepted. The cheque or bankers draft or other remittances may be presented for the payment before acceptance of the offer, but this will not constitute acceptance of offer either in whole or in part; If the application is invalid, rejected or not accepted in full, or if the amount of the application divided by the offer price does not result in a number which is in a multiple of 10 of shares the proceeds of the cheque or other remittance or the unused balance of those proceeds will be refunded without interest; If the remittances are not honoured on the first presentation, then at any time until the company received, cleared funds in respect of a share on offer, the Advisors, on behalf of Comet may terminate the agreement to purchase that share. The termination will be effected by notice being dispatched to the applicant.
63
6.5
REFUNDOFEXCESSCASH
Excess cash for applications that have not been honoured under the Allocation Strategy outlined in this document will be returned to investors within 14 days after the share allotment following the closure of the IPO. In line with the Escrow Account Agreement, WSL and Comet will approve the refund of the excess cash and would be paid before any other disbursements are made.
6.6
LATEREFUNDS
Late refunds will be treated in line with the provisions of Section 284, subsection 4 of the Companies Code 1963, Act 179. It will attract an annual interest rate of 5%.
6.7
WARRANTIES
The Applicant warrants that: i. He/she is qualified to apply; ii. In making the application she/he is not relying on any information or representation concerning the company and or the offers or any of them not contained in this mini prospectus or the Full Prospectus. She/he agrees that no person responsible for this document or any part of it will have liability for any such other information or representation. iii. If any person signing, or making a thumb print on the application form is not the applicant, that person warrants that he or she has authority to do so on behalf of the applicant and that this authority is vested in him or her by virtue of a power of attorney which (or a copy of which certified by a solicitor) accompanies the application. iv. If the applicant is other than a natural person, the person signing the application form warrants that he/she has authority to do so on behalf of the applicant.
6.8
SUPPLYANDDISCLOSUREOFINFORMATION
The Company, Directors, Advisors and their agents shall have full access to all information relating to, or deriving from, the cheque or bank draft or other remittance
64
accompanying the application, and its processing. If the Directors or their agents request any information about the application, it must be promptly disclosed to them.
6.9
MISCELLANEOUS
a) The rights and remedies of the Company and Advisors under these Terms and Conditions are in addition to any rights and remedies, which would otherwise be available to each of them, and the exercise or partial exercise of one will not prevent the exercise of others. b) If applicant delivers the application form to the Company or the Advisors, she/he authorizes the company to send any money returnable to the applicant and a share certificate for the number for which the applicant is accepted by registered mail in the same manner. If the application was sent by post, the applicant authorizes the company to send a share certificate for the number of shares for which the application is accepted and/or a cheque for any money returnable by registered mail to the address (or in the case of joint applicants, the address of the first-named person) as set out in the application form. c) All documents and monies sent or delivered to or by applicant will be sent or delivered at the applicants own risk. Any cheque will be made payable to applicant (or the first person-named person) as set out in the application form. d) The applicant agrees to be bound by the Regulations of Comet Properties Limited once the shares agreed upon have been transferred to the applicant. e) The application and acceptance of the application and the contract resulting therefrom will be governed by, and construed in accordance with the laws of Ghana. The applicant irrevocably submits to the jurisdiction of the Ghanaian courts in respect of the matters relating to this transaction. This does not prevent an action being taken against the applicant in any other jurisdiction. f) Words defined in the Prospectus and not defined in these Terms and Conditions have the same meaning in these Terms and conditions and in the application form and in the guide to the application form as in the Prospectus. In the case of joint applicants, references to an application in these terms and conditions are to each of the joint applicants and their liability is joint and several.
65
7.0
ADDITIONALINFORMATION
7.1 OVERVIEWOFTHEGHANASTOCKEXCHANGE
The Ghana Stock Exchange (GSE) was incorporated in July 1989 as a company limited by guarantee. It is a non-governmental organization governed by a thirteen (13) member council. Members of the GSE include eighteen (18) Licensed Dealing Members (brokerage firms) and forty-one (41) associate members. The Exchange is regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission under the Securities Industry Law, PNDCL 333 of 1993, as amended by Securities Industry (Amendment) Act, 2000, (Act 590). Key Information: Trading Days: Daily Trading; from at 9.30 am. To 1.00pm of each working day Automated Trading carried via Wide Area Net Work (WAN). Trade day plus 3 working days (T+3) No Paper Certificate is issued, because of the GSE Securities Depository (GSD). All trades are recorded instantly in the clients GSD Account upon settlement.
Trading Method:
Access to trade and general information on GSE: This is obtained through Bloomberg Reuters, the Internet, GSE website, Official Trading Results, Local Newspapers, GSE Fact Book, and periodic publications put out by member brokerage firms. Settlement of Trades: Trades are settled through a centralized system thus making sure that no member defaults.
66
7.2
DEVELOPMENT&TRENDS
Trading on the Exchange began on 12th November 1990 with eleven listed Companies. The number of listed Companies has since then increased to 35 with the formal listing of Ecobank Transnational Incorporated Limited (ETI) in 2006 and UT Financial Services in 2008. One Corporate Bond and many other Government of Ghana Bonds also listed. To deepen the growth and broaden the base of the Exchange, the GSE has been reaching out to SMEs to list on the stock market through a two-tier arrangementProvisional Listing. The first equity to be listed under this arrangement was Clydestone Ghana Limited. Two other SMEs including Starwin Products Limited and Golden Web Company Limited have benefited from this arrangement. AYRTN is the 4th Company to be listed on the Ghana Stock Exchange using the Provisional Listing Approach. Cross-Boarder Listings: The Ghana Stock Exchange has in conjunction with the under listed Stock Exchanges listed the following; Trust Bank of Gambia (TBL) The Gambia Stock Exchange Ecobank Transnational Incorporated Limited (ETI) - across the West and East African Stock Exchanges, Golden Star Resource Limited (GSR) Toronto Stock Exchange AngloGold Ashanti Limited (AGA) on Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE) and New York Stock Exchange (NYSE).
Mergers and Acquisition: Adcock Ingram Holdings Limited of South Africa, a Pharmaceutical company acquired 65.59% of Ayrton Drug Manufacturing Company Limited in March 2010. GSE Securities Depository: The Ghana Stock Exchange has come a long way with Central Securities Depository Act 2007 (Act 733) being passed in 2007. With the passing of the law it has paved the way for companies to issue un-certificated shares and also dematerialise shares already in their Share Register. Shareholders are advised to open account with the GSE Securities Depository Company Ltd. Automated Trading System is now in operation. GSE Securities Depository Company is in operation The Clearing and Settlement System and Clearing House also in operation.
67
MARKET CAPITALISATION BY BUSINESS SECTORS: The distribution of companies listed on the Ghana Stock Exchange and the market capitalization for the various sectors as at the end of March 2010 are as shown below.
Industry Financial Institutions CAL Ecobank EIC ETI GCB SCB HFC Bank SCB PREF SG-SSB SIC TBL UTF Paper Converters/IT Camelot Clydestone Sam Woode ACI Transol Manufacturing/Trading Aluworks CFAO MLC PKL PZ Cusson Uniliver AGRIBUSINESS/ AGRO PROCESSING BOPP No. of Companies 12 Market Cap (GH Million) 3,781.05 45.37 885.99 51.65 1 ,487.17 251.75 630.48 84.00 9.09 150.25 52.82 79.80 52.68 14.20 1.05 2.38 0.65 2.92 7.20 279.62 18.34 7.25 9.02 2.33 30.80 211.88 % Market Cap. 21.22%
0.08%
1.57%
95.37 17.40
0.54%
68
Comet Prospectus, December 2010 No. of Companies Market Cap (GH Million) 33.02 1.75 43.20 5 13,221.11 12,285.39 29.37 766.28 39.94 100.13 424.14 24.94 30.10 136.51 228.89 3.70 17,815.49 % Market Cap.
Industry CPC Golden Web PBC METALS/Oil AGA AADS Golden Star Goil Total Pharma/ Beverages Accra Brewery Ayrton Fan Milk GGBL Starwin Total Market Capitalisation
74.21%
2.38%
100%
7.3 7.3.1
PERFORMANCEOFTHEGHANASTOCKEXCHANGE
TradingVolumes:
At the end of December 2009, the total volume of shares traded stood at 96.77 million compared with 531.66 million shares recorded at the end of 2008. The rather bearish performance of GSE in 2009, resulting in the big drop in volume of shares traded could be attributed to a number of factors including the world wide economic downturn and the effect of the change in government and the Ghanaian attitude of waiting to see how the economy performs during the recession. Nevertheless, over the past five (5) years, trading volumes have averaged 219.07 million shares, which is quite encouraging for an emerging stock market, with relatively limited listed stocks. It is therefore expected that as more companies are listed, the market will continue to deepen resulting in higher traded volumes.
69
7.3.2
TradedValues:
The total value of shares traded on the GSE from January through December 2008 amounted to GH365.51 million compared to GH 74.19 million recorded for the same period in 2009. The relatively lower value is due to the world wide recession and the drop in prices of all shares traded. In 2009 the Exchange did not have any major IPOs. Over the last five (5) years, trading values have averaged GH134.89 million due to a number of factors, which include favourable macroeconomic conditions, increased foreign participation on the Exchange, and unstable share prices.
Table 7.1: Yearly Traded Values for the past five years
GSE All Share Index GSE ALL SHARE INDEX (Y-O-Y) Market Capitalisation (Gh) Million Total Number Of Listed Equities Value Traded (Gh) million Volume Traded (000) 2009 5,572.34 -46.58% 2008 10,431.60 58.06% 2007 6,599.80 31.48% 2006 5,006.00 4.97% 2005 4,769.00 -29.85%
15,941.92 35 74.19
17,844.00 35 365.51
12,370.00 34 140.71
11,250.00 33 47.60
9,186.00 29 46.44
96,767.39
531,660.00
287,221.70
98,286.00
81,400.00
7.3.3
OverallMarketPerformance
Since the inception of GSE, the exchange has performed commendably as shown by the GSE All-Share Index, which measures the overall performance of the GSE. Over the period under review, the GSE All-Share Index rose from 4,769.00 points at the end of 2005 to 10,431.60 points at the end of December 2008, before dropping to close 2009 at 5,572.34 points. Although year on year performance has been mixed, returns have been significant for long-term investors averaging about 3.60% over the last five years. Market performance on the exchange over the past five years (2005 2009) is shown in the table and table below.
Lead Advisor and Sponsoring Broker: Worldwide Securities Limited
70
Table 7.2: GSE Performance Trends for the last five (5) years.
2009 GSE ALL SHARE INDEX 5,572.34 2008 10,431.60 2007 6,599.80 2006 5,006.00 2005 4,769.00
-46.58%
58.06%
31.48%
4.97%
-29.85%
71
8.0
APPLICATIONPROCEDUREANDFORMS
8.1 THEAPPLICATION
Each application must be for a minimum of 50 shares and in multiples of 10 shares thereafter. The latest time for the receipt of application forms is Monday, 31st January, 2011 at 4.00pm. If an application is successful in whole or in part, the number of shares allotted to applicant shall be credited to the applicants accounts with the GSE Securities Depository. If there is excess demand under this offer, applicant may receive fewer shares than might be expected to receive on the basis of the maximum amount expressed without interest. If an application is not accepted or is accepted in part, or if the amount of the application divided by the offer price does not equal a whole number of shares, a refund for the appropriate amount without interest will be returned by registered mail to applicant within two weeks after the offer closes i.e. by 15th February, 2011 (excluding holidays). The closing date for the offer is extendable by Two (2) weeks, in which case the closing date shall be Tuesday, 15th February, 2011. Should there be extension to the offer period, the last date for the refund of excess application funds, if applicable, shall be 30th February, 2011. The right is reserved to present for payment all cheques, bankers draft and money or postal orders on receipt. It is a condition of the offer that all cheques or other payments must be honoured on first presentation. No interest will be paid to applicants on any monies held on behalf of applicants or on behalf of the company. If there is excess demand under the proposed offer, applicants may receive fewer shares than applied for.
8.2
INSTRUCTIONSFORCOMPLETIONOFAPPLICATIONFORM
Read this carefully before completing an application form: PLEASE USE BLOCK/ CAPITAL LETTERS PLEASE RETURN THE COMPLETED APPLICATION FORM BY 31st JANUARY, 2011
72
1. Multiple applications are not permitted. Applicants must please read the declaration carefully before he/she signs (or if unable to sign, make a thumb print) and date the space provided on the application form. 2. The Application Form may be signed by someone on behalf of applicant if he/she is duly authorized to do so. An agent must enclose the original power of attorney appointing him/her (or a copy by a notary public) unless he/she is a selling agent or financial intermediary and states the capacity in which he/she signs. 3. The application form of illiterates should bear their right thumb print on the Application Form and be witnessed by an official of the offices at which application is lodged, who must first have explained the meaning and must record in writing that he has given this explanation to the illiterate in the language understandable by him/her and the illiterate appeared to have understood the same before affixing his/her thumb impression. If applying for someone under the age of 18 years, applicant (rather than that minor) must sign the Application form, and put the minors name in the box provided. 4. Fill in your Surname (i.e. Family Name) all your Forenames (i.e. First/Other names) and the title by which you are addressed. In the case of Corporate Applicant, appropriate Form must be used. Applications from corporations and partnerships must bear the institutions common stamp and be completed under the hand of a duly authorized official who should also state his/her designation/title 5. Only people over 18 years of age can buy shares in their own name but shares can be bought for children by a parent, grandparent or guardian of the child. The adult can complete another application to buy shares in his or her own name. 6. Put in the number of shares (minimum is 50) that you are applying for. Please use figures. Your payment must be in a form, which will realize cleared funds for the full amount payable by 4.00pm GMT on 31st January, 2011. The last day a local cheque can be presented to the company or Advisors is 27th January 2011 to allow for three working days for clearance of the cheque. Cheques, Money Orders, and Bankers Drafts should be made payable to Comet/WSL Escrow Account and endorsed COMMISSION TO DRAWERS ACCOUNT. The amount is to be paid into the ESCROW Account Number 6010138280 at Zenith Bank, Premier Towers, Accra. All Bank commissions and transfers must be paid by the Applicant. MINIMUM APPLICATION IS FOR 50 SHARES, THEN IN MULTIPLES OF 10 SHARES THEREAFTER
73
When the basis of allocation under the Comet public offer is set, successful applicants will be allocated a number of shares. Any balance owing will be refunded. 7. Put in your postal address 8. Provide the information for the Bank where you wish to receive dividend payments. If you have no bank, leave it blank. Ask the Brokers for Assistance if you have any difficulties. 9. Tick the Relevant line to indicate your citizenship (whether or not a resident in Ghana) 10. GSE Securities Depository System You are required to register with the GSD as shares purchased under this offer will be kept electronically in line with the GSE Securities Depository system. 11. By signing the Application Form you will be applying for shares on offer on the terms and conditions set out in the Prospectus and the Application Form. Proceedings may be instituted against anyone knowingly making a false representation. This applies to whether application is made solely or jointly with other persons. 12. Joint Applications: You may apply jointly with up to three (3) people, provided each applicant is an adult of over 18 years of age. They should complete their names and sign the appropriate places by their names. Power(s) of Attorney must be enclosed if any one is signing on behalf of any joint applicant(s).
74
6. Nationality: Ghanaian Resident Non Resident Ghanaian Resident Foreigner Non Resident Foreigner COUNTRY OF RESIDENCE: 7 Joint Applicants: I/We join in this application and give the Declaration in Box 8 below Other Applicants 2nd Joint Applicant 3rd Joint Applicant 4th Joint Applicant Surname: Forename(s) in full: Signature or Thumbprint 8 Declaration: I/We hereby apply for offer Shares on the terms and conditions set out in the Prospectus. I/We declare that I/we am/are a Qualified Applicant(s) and that to my/our knowledge there is no other application being made for my/our benefit (or that of any person for whose benefit) I/We am/are applying for Comet Properties Limited Shares for which I/we have applied on this form. To be completed by receiving Broker/Bank and then signed by the applicant and retained by applicant as evidence of payment SHARE OFFER: COUNTERFOIL for COMET PROPERTIES LTD Title (Mr./Mrs./Ms.): Forename(s) in full: Surname/Organisation: Address (Hse No./Street) P. O. Box: Region: Country: NUMBER OF SHARES: Town: Amount Paid (Gh): Name Of Broker GSD Account Number Applicants Signature/Thumbprint Receiving Agents Signature & Stamp
75