Professional Documents
Culture Documents
August 2011
Economic Affairs and Research Division FICCI Dr. Soumya Kanti Ghosh: soumya.ghosh@ficci.com Anshuman Khanna: anshuman.khanna@ficci.com (with inputs from Anna Mathew, Debashish Pal, Rajsekhar Bhattacharyya & Sakshi Arora)
HIGHLIGHTS
World economy in a tailspin following Standard & Poor (S&P)
downgrading US Economys Long-Term Sovereign Credit Rating to AA+ from AAA with a negative outlook (Page 3)
US recovery post 2008 on a slow path: Debt overhang in Europe
(Page 4)
Relationship between US & India GDP growth (Page 5-6) A quick forecast of drivers / leading indicators of Indias external demand
87% by 2020
Data released by the US do support the contention that the US economic recovery since 2008 has been soft and is taking longer than anticipated. It now turns out that US GDP growth rate in the first 2 quarters of 2011 was still below the levels at the end of 2007. Real
GDP grew by an anemic 1.3% QoQ (annualised) during 2011:Q2 as per advance estimate. The annual GDP growth rates for 2008 & 2009 were also significantly revised downwards. Additionally, on Aug 9, 2011 Fed emphasized its accommodative stance of keeping the interest rates unchanged at exceptionally low levels (0-0.25%) at least through mid-2013. Clearly, headwinds like weakness in the financial and housing sector, sovereign default concerns, flattening of consumer spending and deleveraging issues are likely to be the major concerns going into 2012 and even beyond. Table 2: Revision in US GDP growth rates: real lowdown
Year 2008 2009 2010 2010:Q4 2011:Q1 Source: FICCI Research & www.bea.gov 2011:Q2 Previous estimates 0.0 -2.6 3.0 3.1 1.9 1.8 Latest estimates -0.3 -3.5 2.9 2.3 0.4 1.3
An interesting trend observation from the exposition shows that for India, there is a slowdown in GDP growth rates during quarter 3 / quarter 4. This is corroborated by the low GDP growth rates during quarter 3 of FY09, quarter 4 of FY10 and quarter 4 of FY11. Going by this trend for the current fiscal Q3 & Q4 may possibly witness a further slowdown in GDP growth rate. The duration of this slowdown may vary and may be as much as four successive quarters (as per historical trends). Exposition 1: India mirrors US GDP growth rates: with a lag
9.0 7.0 5.0 3.0 1.0 10.0 9.5 9.0 8.5 8.0 7.5
2007:Q1
2007:Q2
2007:Q3
2007:Q4
2008:Q1
2008:Q2
2008:Q3
2008:Q4
2009:Q1
2009:Q2
2009:Q3
2009:Q4
2010:Q1
2010:Q2
2010:Q3
2010:Q4
2011:Q1
2011:Q2
0
US
India
Oct-07
Oct-08
Oct-09
Apr-07
Apr-08
Apr-09
Apr-10
Oct-10
Apr-11
Jan-08
Jan-09
Jan-10
Jan-11
Jul-07
Jul-08
Jul-09
Jul-10
Source: FICCI research (projected exports are on secondary axis) Note: Exports are projected through a multiplicative H&M method
Actual Exports
Projected Exports
Jul-11
As far as domestic demand is concerned, we analyzed a host of indicators like cellular subscribers, cement dispatches and passenger car sales (refer Expositions 3 till 5). The results indicate a clear slowdown/flattening of domestic demand indicators (for example cellular connections, cement despatches & passenger car sales). We also analyzed the impact of the successive rate hikes on consumer demand to test for the hypothesis of whether the monetary policy transmission was complete. The results revealed that passenger car sales are impacted through rate hikes (increase in PLR rates & repo rates taken as a proxy) albeit with a lag of 2-3 months. Exposition 3: Cellular connections flattening?
9000 8000 7000 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000 10000 9000 8000 7000 6000 5000 4000 3000 2000 1000
Source: FICCI research (projected cellular connections in lakhs are on secondary axis) Note: cellular connections projected through a double exponential smoothening model
Apr-07
Apr-08
Apr-09
Apr-10
Apr-11
Jul-07
Jul-08
Jul-09
Jul-10
Oct-07
Oct-08
Oct-09
Oct-10
Jan-08
Jan-09
Jan-10
Source: FICCI research (projected cement despatches is on secondary axis) Note: cement despatches projected through multiplicative H&M method
Oct-07
Oct-08
Oct-09
Apr-07
Apr-08
Apr-09
Apr-10
Oct-10
Jan-11
Apr-11
Jan-08
Jan-09
Jan-10
Jan-11
Jul-07
Jul-08
Jul-09
Jul-10
Dec-07
Dec-08
Dec-09
Aug-07
Aug-08
Aug-09
Aug-10
Dec-10
Source: FICCI research (projected car sales is on secondary axis) Note: car sales projected through a multiplicative H&M
Aug-11
Apr-07
Apr-08
Apr-09
Apr-10
Apr-11
Jul-11
Jul-11
more optimistic
more pessimistic
Source: FICCI Research Note: *FICCI Resilience Index is derived from the FICCI Business Confidence Survey by looking at the net positive responses.
Q1FY05
Q3FY05
Q1FY06
Q3FY06
Q1FY07
Q3FY07
Q1FY08
Q3FY08
Q1FY09
Q3FY09
Q1FY10
Q3FY10
Q1FY11
Q3FY11
Q1FY12
-0.2 -0.4
2 0
GDP Agriculture & Allied Activities Industry Mining & Quarrying Manufacturing Electricity, Gas & Water Supply Construction Service Trade, Hotels, Transport, Storage & Communication Finance, Insurance, Real estate & Business services Source: PMEAC Economic Outlook 11/12, FICCI EOS. Community & Personal Services
10.5 7.5
10.5 8.8
9.8 8.5
FICCI notes with concern the sharp downward revision in projected growth rate in agriculture during FY12 to 3% (6.6% in FY-2011), a four year low. In fact, the prognosis on agricultural growth is worrisome with Indian Meteorological Department (IMD) forecast that India will receive a below normal monsoon during August- September. There is also concern about inflation as PMEAC believes that headline WPI will remain elevated till Nov 11 at 9% or even higher and will soften only from Dec 11 onwards. Meanwhile, the annual point-to-point inflation rate (provisional) in the first 4 months of FY12 was 9.2% (vis--vis 9.98% during the like period in the previous year) as per the latest data released by Office of Economic Advisor (EA). Given the wide divergence between provisional and final rates, it is likely that the inflation rate is only a shade below 10% now. Table 5: Inflation rates sticky?
FY12 Jul11 All Commodities Primary Articles Food Articles Source: Office of Economic Advisor, Note: YTD Implies year till date (as of July11) Fuel & Power Manufactured Month 0.7 0.2 1.4 2.5 0.3 YTD 3.0 5.2 7.7 5.1 1.5 Year 9.2 11.3 8.2 12.0 7.5 FY11 Year 10.0 19.1 18.5 13.3 5.8
As on Jul1511
FY11
YTD M3 Source: RBI &FICCI Research Note:*non-food component Credit* Deposits 3.9 1.6 4.0
10
PUBLIC FINANCE
The state of Government finances continues to be in a state of bother with the fiscal deficit in the first quarter constituting over 39% of the budgeted fiscal deficit. Total revenue collections during the same period were at a measly 11.7% (vis--vis 27.8% previous year) of the budget estimates. Expenditure pie was at 20.8% of budget, a tad lower than 21.8% last year. Table 7: Fiscal indicators worrisome
FY12:Q1 (Rs bn) FY12Budget FY12Q1
Fiscal Indicators
FY11:Q1 % to Budget
Receipts Expenditure Fiscal Deficit Rev. Deficit Source: CAG Primary Deficit
11
Against this background, FICCI re-estimated fiscal deficit by constructing 3 scenarios with the assumptions that: The government will be able to stick to its estimated expenditure growth target of 3.4%, in FY12 which is the best case scenario The slippage of target will be only on the revenue and capital receipt side. (assuming status quo on expenditure side). In particular, the revenue slippage is based on Govts own estimates of a monthly revenue loss of Rs 1600 crore because of customs duty cut on June 2411. The revised disinvestment receipts are pegged at Rs 200 bn, based on trend estimates. The nominal GDP will be higher than the targeted 14% with a much higher than average inflation rate of 5%.
Based on these scenarios, our analysis suggests that the fiscal deficit during FY12 could be around Rs. 4598 bn against the budget estimate of Rs. 4128 bn. Accordingly, fiscal deficit ratio could be anywhere between 5.04% and 5.12%, against the budget estimate of 4.6% for FY12. However, a word of caution on the expenditure side. FICCI feels containing expenditure growth at 3.4% for FY12 will be difficult given that trend estimates reveal expenditure growth at 20% for the 5 year period ended Mar11. The lurking fear of expenditure overrun gets more real considering among others, the case of oil subsidies. Oil subsidies are pegged at only Rs 240 bn in FY12, even as average crude prices were $113/bbl for Indias import basket during Apr-June11.In contrast, during FY11, based on an average crude price at $ 84/bbl, the oil subsidy bill was at a much higher Rs 384 bn. Table 8: FICCI fiscal deficit projections
Scenarios Nominal GDP growth Source: FICCI Research. Note: Receipts slippage of Rs 470 bn factored in. Fiscal deficit as a % GDP 1 / Least Likely 14% 2 / Less Likely 15.2% 3 / More likely 15.9%
5.12%
5.07%
5.04%
12
INDUSTRY
Index of Industrial Production (IIP) data for June 2011 notched up a smart 8.8% growth rate -the second highest in the last 10 months. The good thing about the IIP growth rate for the first 3 months of the current fiscal is the minor revisions in IIP data for the months prior to June 2011. FICCI analysis shows that, IIP growth based on the assumption of unchanged IIP numbers (no revision in past IIP data) for months prior to June 2011 are nearly identical with the IIP growth based on the assumption of revised IIP numbers (revision in past IIP data). Table 9: IIP Growth Apr-Jun11
Mining IIP growth unchanged numbers for months prior to June 2011 Manufacturing Electricity General
1.08%
7.32%
8.24%
6.69%
IIP growth-revised numbers for months prior to June 2011 Source: FICCI Research
1.06%
7.47%
8.24%
6.8%
However, the bad thing is the continued month-on-month volatility in crucial sectors like capital goods (for example, 37.7% in June11 against 6.1% in May11). At the use-based level, while investment demand (capital goods growth at 16.9% during Apr-Jun2011 vis--vis 17.2% in the same period in the previous year) growth was marginally lower, consumer demand (consumer durables goods growth at 3.3% during Apr-Jun2011 vis--vis 19.7% in the like period previous year) was down significantly. Clearly, there are signs of a downturn in consumer demand as a result of a higher interest rate regime. FICCI believes that investor sentiments are likely to remain depressed going forward. Our analysis from CMIE data shows that there has been a significant increase in the projects under implementation stalled to number of new projects for the quarter ending June 2011 underlining the weak investment sentiments. Table 10: Projects Under Implementation Stalled / New Projects
Implementation stalled / new projects 39% 28% 47%
Quarter ended Jun09 Jun10 Source: CMIE & FICCI Research Jun11
13
EXTERNAL SECTOR
Indias exports continue to sustain growth momentum. During June 2011 merchandise exports were valued at $29.2billion substantially higher than $19.9 billion during the same month in 2010. An upsurge in imports has also been evident in last few months. Jun11 is no exception as imports amounted to $36.9 billion during this month as compared to $25.9 billion recorded in Jun10. Trade deficit increased to $7.6 billion in Jun11. Meanwhile, as per the latest press release (Aug 112011) issued by Press Information Bureau (PIB), Govt. of India, Indias exports logged in a staggering 81.8% growth during the month of Jul2011. Indias imports, too, registered a growth of 51.5 % during the month. During the period Apr-Jul2011 while Indias exports were valued at $108.3 billion (54% growth), imports reached a level of $151 billion (40% growth) during the same period. This rate of export growth is unprecedented and may be difficult to sustain specially in the context of an uneven global recovery and recent down turn in US and Euro zone. Contraction of demand from the international markets is likely to withhold Indias emerging story of export growth. However, on the upside, increasing product diversification in Indias export basket and successful implementation of Indias Foreign Trade Agreements (FTAs) and bilateral trade and investment treaties with some major economies may continue to act as an enabling factor for export growth.
14
Product group
Impact
15
As per the latest data, FDI inflows into India touched a new high of $5.65 billion during Jun11 as against $1.38 billion in Jun10. During the first quarter of current fiscal, FDI inflows jumped by 133% to reach $13.4 billion from $5.8 billion observed during the same period in FY11. The portfolio investments declined to $789 million in Jun11 from $1.3 billion in Jun10. During the first quarter of FY12 portfolio investments declined to $2.7 billion from $ 4.6 billion in FY11.
Indias foreign exchange reserves observed much acceleration during the last fiscal. In May 10, the reserves stood at $273.5 billion and crossed the level of $300 billion in Feb11. In Jun11, the figure further rose to $316 billion. The latest data available by RBI show foreign exchange reserves at $314.6 billion on July 8, 2011. Indias total external debt increased significantly from $261.0 billion in end March 2010 to $ 305.9 billion in end March 2011. This increase in external debt was mainly attributed to the rising share of ECBs and short term debt. These two components together contributed around 68% of total increase in Indias external debt during this period. The share of NRI deposit in Indias external debt observed a declining trend in recent years. Indias debt service ratio has been declining over time [2009-10 being an exception when debt service increased on account of large ECB repayments] and stood at 4.2 % during FY11.
16
CORPORATE PERFORMANCE
The latest available data on corporate sector performance reveals that during the quarter ended Jun11, many sectors saw a significant downward pressure on profit margins. Comparing profit margin figures for quarter ending Jun11 with Jun10 across sectors, it is evident that sectors like banking services, coal & lignite, crude oil & natural gas construction & real estate, health services, IT services, and metal & metal products witnessed a squeeze in profit margins. High interest cost and inputs prices took a toll on the profitability of these sectors during the quarter under review. Interestingly, Indian companies from sectors like food & beverages, hotel & tourism, machinery and textiles witnessed an improvement in their profit margins during the quarter ended Jun11 vis--vis performance during the same quarter last year. Table 16- Profitability of Indian Corporates (in %)
Indicators PAT / Total income
Jun-11 Banking services Chemicals Coal & lignite Crude oil & natural gas Fee based financial services Food & beverages Health services Hotels & tourism Industrial & infrastructural construction Information technology Machinery Metals & metal products Real estate Note- PAT: Profit after tax Source: FICCI Research & CMIE Textiles 10.34 6.48 10.63 31.99 5.2 12.29 5.53 14.11 5.05 18.07 9.1 9.5 14.74 5.16
Jun-10 12.63 1.24 14.86 32.34 18.8 5.18 9.17 6.35 6.86 19.1 5.14 10.49 26.26 3.81
17
POLICY CALENDAR
Table 17: Policy calendar
Sector Date July 711 Financial July 2511 Description Draft Microfinance bill put out for comments Pension bill to be passed in Parliamentary Standing Committee Lock-in-period in foreign portfolio investments in infrastructure halved Premature redemptions from mutual funds to be taxed Manufacturing policy passed by Ministry of Labour Announcement of construction of New DelhiMumbai industrial corridor Nuclear regulator bill to be tabled in Parliament Mines bill to seek cabinet nod Empowered Group of Ministers approves National Food Security bill Setting up of Environment regulator Draft Land Acquisition policy finalized Ministry moves new aviation policy
Aug511 Aug2311 July2811 Corporates Aug911 July811 July1211 July1211 Others July2511 July2811 Aug511