This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.

0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 559 Nathan Abbott Way, Stanford, California 94305, USA. Created by Keith A. Watson, CISSP on March 1, 2005

{ABC corp.} Security Assessment Report October 3, 2011

Report Prepared by: {Ehab Abdel Monem}, {Security consultant} {Eng_ehap@hotmail.com} {0114458033} {Raya Corp} {info@raya.net}

The information contained within this report is considered proprietary and confidential to the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION}. Inappropriate and unauthorized disclosure of this report or portions of it could result in significant damage or loss to the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION}. This report should be distributed to individuals on a Need-to-Know basis only. Paper copies should be locked up when not in use. Electronic copies should be stored offline and protected appropriately.

Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know

{CLIENT ORGANIZATION}

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY........................................................................................5
In the last quarter the ABC Company started to give extra focus for the security of the network and production services. Many measures have been taken to protect valuable assets, especially the database server as it contain the valuable customer information. ............................................................5 Top-Ten List....................................................................................................................................................5 1. Information Security Policy.....................................................................................................................5 2. {Using Telnet for remote administration}...............................................................................................5 3. {Week passwords}...................................................................................................................................5 4. {Security Issue #4}...................................................................................................................................6 5. {Security Issue #5}...................................................................................................................................6 6. {Security Issue #6}...................................................................................................................................6 7. {Security Issue #7}...................................................................................................................................6 8. {Security Issue #8}...................................................................................................................................6 9. {Security Issue #9}...................................................................................................................................6 10. {Security Issue #10}...............................................................................................................................6

INTRODUCTION.....................................................................................................7
Scope................................................................................................................................................................7 Project Scope................................................................................................................................................7 In Scope........................................................................................................................................................7 Out of Scope.................................................................................................................................................7 Site Activities Schedule...................................................................................................................................7 First Day.......................................................................................................................................................7 Second Day..................................................................................................................................................7 Third Day.....................................................................................................................................................7

BACKGROUND INFORMATION...........................................................................8
{CLIENT ORGANIZATION}.......................................................................................................................8

ASSET IDENTIFICATION......................................................................................9
Assets of the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} ...............................................................................................9

THREAT ASSESSMENT........................................................................................9
Threats to the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION}..............................................................................................9

LAWS, REGULATIONS AND POLICY................................................................10

Federal Law and Regulation........................................................................................................................10 {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} Policy.........................................................................................................10

Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 2

Security Assessment Report Vulnerabilities...............................................................................................................................................10 The {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} has no information security policy...................................................10 {State the Vulnerability}............................................................................................................................10

PERSONNEL........................................................................................................11
Management..................................................................................................................................................11 Operations.....................................................................................................................................................11 Development..................................................................................................................................................11 Vulnerabilities...............................................................................................................................................11 There is no information security officer.....................................................................................................11 {State the Vulnerability}............................................................................................................................11

NETWORK SECURITY........................................................................................12
Vulnerabilities...............................................................................................................................................12 The {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} systems are not protected by a network firewall..............................12 {State the Vulnerability}............................................................................................................................13

SYSTEM SECURITY............................................................................................13
Vulnerabilities...............................................................................................................................................13 Users can install unsafe software...............................................................................................................13 {State the Vulnerability}............................................................................................................................14

APPLICATION SECURITY..................................................................................14
Vulnerabilities...............................................................................................................................................14 Sensitive information within the database is not encrypted.......................................................................14 {State the Vulnerability}............................................................................................................................14

OPERATIONAL SECURITY.................................................................................15
Vulnerabilities...............................................................................................................................................15 There is no standard for security management...........................................................................................15 {State the Vulnerability}............................................................................................................................15

PHYSICAL SECURITY.........................................................................................15
Vulnerabilities...............................................................................................................................................15 Building Vulnerabilities.............................................................................................................................16 Several key doors within the building are unlocked or can be forced open...............................................16 {State the Vulnerability}............................................................................................................................16 Security Perimeter Vulnerabilities.............................................................................................................16 There is no entryway access control system..............................................................................................16 {State the Vulnerability}............................................................................................................................17 Server Area Vulnerabilities........................................................................................................................17 The backup media are not protected from fire, theft, or damage...............................................................17

Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 3

{CLIENT ORGANIZATION} {State the Vulnerability}............................................................................................................................17

SUMMARY............................................................................................................18
Action Plan....................................................................................................................................................18

REFERENCES......................................................................................................18

Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 4

Security Assessment Report

Executive Summary
In the last quarter the ABC Company started to give extra focus for the security of the network and production services. Many measures have been taken to protect valuable assets, especially the database server as it contain the valuable customer information. Then it was a wise decision to hire security assessment team to assess the effectiveness of the under taken measures. After the security assessment we found some issues in the DB system. As an example Week password policy Using unsecured remote administration methods No patch management policy.

In the following sections we will discuss these issues and others.

Top-Ten List
A top-ten list is used to highlight the ten most urgent issues discovered during an assessment. Clients unfamiliar with security may be overwhelmed by a long list of problems. Putting the major issues together may allow the client to easily focus efforts on these problems first. The list below contains the top ten findings, weaknesses, or vulnerabilities discovered during the site security assessment. Some of the issues listed here are coalesced from more than one section of the assessment report findings. Additional information about each is provided elsewhere in the report. It is recommended that these be evaluated and addressed as soon as possible. These should be considered significant and may impact the operations of the {ABC corp.}

1. Information Security Policy

An information security policy is the primary guide for the implementation of all security measures. There is no formal policy specific to the {ABC corp.}. Recommendation: Develop an information security policy that specifically addresses the needs of the {ABC corp.} and its mission. Use that policy as a basis for an effective security program.

2. {Using Telnet for remote administration}

Telnet is one of the most insecure remote administration technologies yet we found that the system administrators are using it, which allow some of the most common attacks as sniffing and spoofing attacks. Recommendation: using a more secured methods for remote access as SSH or VPN tunnels

3. {Week passwords}
We found that has administrator account with very week passwords that can be guessed easily, which my allow unauthorized user to access the system Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 5

{CLIENT ORGANIZATION}

Recommendation: forcing strong password policy.

4. {Security Issue #4}

{Brief description of Security Issue #4} Recommendation: {Brief list of recommendations for Security Issue #4}

5. {Security Issue #5}

{Brief description of Security Issue #5} Recommendation: {Brief list of recommendations for Security Issue #5}

6. {Security Issue #6}

{Brief description of Security Issue #6} Recommendation: {Brief list of recommendations for Security Issue #6}

7. {Security Issue #7}

{Brief description of Security Issue #7} Recommendation: {Brief list of recommendations for Security Issue #7}

8. {Security Issue #8}

{Brief description of Security Issue #8} Recommendation: {Brief list of recommendations for Security Issue #8}

9. {Security Issue #9}

{Brief description of Security Issue #9} Recommendation: {Brief list of recommendations for Security Issue #9}

10. {Security Issue #10}

{Brief description of Security Issue #10} Recommendation: {Brief list of recommendations for Security Issue #10}

Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 6

Security Assessment Report

Introduction
Provide an overview of the report.

Scope
The scope is the boundaries of the project. It is used to describe the on-site activities.

Project Scope In Scope

The following activities are within the scope of this project: Interviews with key staff members in charge of policy, administration, day-to-day operations, system administration, network management, and facilities management. A Visual Walk Through of the facilities with administrative and facilities personnel to assess physical security. A series of Network Scans to enumerate addressable devices and to assess each systems available network services. (These Scans will be conducted from within each centers network and from the outside.) A configuration and security assessment of at most ten key systems at each center.

Out of Scope
The following activities are NOT part of this security assessment: Penetration Testing of systems, networks, buildings, laboratories or facilities. Social Engineering to acquire sensitive information from staff members. Testing Disaster Recovery Plans, Business Continuity Plans, or Emergency Response Plans.

Site Activities Schedule

List the site activities.

First Day Second Day Third Day

Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 7

{CLIENT ORGANIZATION}

Background Information
Use this section to talk about any relevant background information.

{CLIENT ORGANIZATION}
Describe the client organization.

Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 8

Security Assessment Report

Asset Identification
Describe the process of asset identification.

Assets of the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION}

The following lists document some of the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} tangible and intangible assets. It should not be considered a complete and detailed list but should be used as a basis for further thought and discussion to identify assets. Tangible Assets {List tangible assets.}

Intangible Assets {List intangible assets.}

Each item on these lists also has value associated with it. Each items relative value changes over time. In order to determine the current value, it is often best to think in terms of recovery costs. What would it cost to restore or replace this asset in terms of time, effort, and money?

Threat Assessment
Describe the process of threat assessment.

Threats to the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION}

The following lists document some of the known threats to the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION}. It should not be considered a complete and detailed list but should be used to as a basis for further thought and discussion to identify threats. Natural Threats {List Natural Threats.}

Intentional Threats {List Intentional Threats.}

Unintentional Threats {List Unintentional Threats.}

Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 9

{CLIENT ORGANIZATION}

Laws, Regulations and Policy

Talk about the role of laws, regulation, and policy on the client organization.

Federal Law and Regulation

Outline federal laws and regulation that impact the client organization.

{CLIENT ORGANIZATION} Policy

Talk about the current policy at the client organization. Describe what policy they currently have.

Vulnerabilities
Listed below are the vulnerabilities discovered during the assessment relating to law, regulation, and policy. These are considered significant and steps should be taken to address them.

The {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} has no information security policy

Explanation The {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} has no information security policy that is specific to its needs and goals. Risk There are several risks in not having an information security policy. Mistakes can be made in strategic planning without a guideline for security. Resources may be wasted in protecting low value assets, while high value assets go unprotected. Without a policy, all security measures are merely ad hoc in nature and may be misguided. Create a policy that is in compliance with {CLIENT ORGANIZAION} security goals. Periodically review and update the policy.

Recommendations

{State the Vulnerability}

Explanation {Explain the vulnerability.} Risk There are several risks in not having {this vulnerability}. {Provide a list of risks.} Recommendations Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 10

Security Assessment Report

{Provide a list of recommendations}.

Personnel
Describe the personnel at the client organization. Organize them into related groups. In this example, we have Management, Operations, and Development.

Management
Describe the management group.

Operations
Describe the operations team.

Development
Describe the development team.

Vulnerabilities
Listed below are the staff vulnerabilities discovered during the interviews with the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} staff. These are considered significant and steps should be taken to address them.

There is no information security officer

Explanation An information security officer is responsible for the overall security for an organization. He or she must help create security policy, enforce it, and act as the primary security contact. Risk Without an information security officer, important security issues may not receive the proper attention. The overall security of the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} may suffer. Recommendations Designate an existing employee to fill the role of information security officer, or hire a qualified candidate for the position. Provide training opportunities to the information security officer. Encourage and support the acquisition of security certification(s).

{State the Vulnerability}

Explanation {Explain the vulnerability.} Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 11

{CLIENT ORGANIZATION}

Risk There are several risks in not having {this vulnerability}. {Provide a list of risks.} {Provide a list of recommendations}. Recommendations

Network Security
Describe the state of network security at the client organization. List public network resources and sites. List partner connections and extranets.

Vulnerabilities
Listed below are the network security vulnerabilities discovered during the assessment. These are considered significant and steps should be taken to address them.

The {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} systems are not protected by a network firewall

Explanation A firewall is a network gatekeeper. Based on a configurable set of rules, the firewall determines which network connections to allow or deny. There are generally three types of attacks that can be prevented (or at least slowed) using properly configured firewalls: intrusion, denial-of-service, and information theft. There are two types of firewalls. One type is incorporated into operating systems (software-based). The other type consists of a networking hardware platform that protects a group of networked systems (hardware-based). The {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} systems are inconsistently protected by softwarebased firewalls. Most of the workstations have firewall software installed and configured. Some do not. Risk There are several risks in running network services without a firewall. Page 12 Incoming network-based scans and attacks are not easily detected or prevented. Attackers target vulnerable network services. Attacks are not isolated and damage cannot be contained. Network probing for vulnerabilities slows system and network performance. Enable operating system firewalls where available. Install a hardware-based firewall. Configure firewall rule sets to be very restrictive. Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know

Recommendations

Security Assessment Report

{State the Vulnerability}

Explanation {Explain the vulnerability.} Risk There are several risks in not having {this vulnerability}. {Provide a list of risks.} {Provide a list of recommendations}. Recommendations

System Security
Describe the state of system security at the client organization.

Vulnerabilities
Listed below are the system security vulnerabilities discovered during the assessment. These are considered significant and steps should be taken to address them.

Users can install unsafe software

Explanation Since users have privileged access to their workstations, they are free to install software that can impact the operations at the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION}. Most of this software is freely available from the Internet. Unsafe software is any software that impedes the productivity of the staff, collects information on the user or the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} network environment, launches attacks or probes internal systems. Risk There are several risks in allowing users to install unsafe software. The software may contain a virus, worm, or some other dangerous electronic threat. The software may be a Trojan Horse to fool users. The software may capture, disclose, delete, or modify sensitive data. The software may impact system performance and user productivity. Significant time may be wasted attempting to remove software.

Recommendations The operations team should Remove user privileges to install software. Remove unsafe software from workstations. Reinstall systems as needed. Establish a process for the evaluation and installation of new software. Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 13

{CLIENT ORGANIZATION}

{State the Vulnerability}

Explanation {Explain the vulnerability.} Risk There are several risks in not having {this vulnerability}. {Provide a list of risks.} {Provide a list of recommendations}. Recommendations

Application Security
Describe the state of application security at the client organization.

Vulnerabilities
Listed below are the application security vulnerabilities discovered during the assessment. These are considered significant and steps should be taken to address them.

Sensitive information within the database is not encrypted

Explanation Sensitive information in databases can be encrypted to protect confidentiality. If an attacker gets unauthorized access to the database, sensitive information still cannot be read. Risk If an attacker gains access to the database, sensitive information stored in the database can be viewed and modified. Recommendations Examine changes required to support encrypted database tables. Modify web and database software to work with encrypted data. Safely store and protect the encryption keys.

{State the Vulnerability}

Explanation {Explain the vulnerability.} Risk There are several risks in not having {this vulnerability}. Page 14 {Provide a list of risks.} {Provide a list of recommendations}. Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Recommendations

Security Assessment Report

Operational Security
Describe the state of operational security at the client organization.

Vulnerabilities
Listed below are the application security vulnerabilities discovered during the assessment. These are considered significant and steps should be taken to address them.

There is no standard for security management

Explanation A security standard is a document that defines and describes the process of security management for an organization. Risk Without a guideline for security practices, those responsible for security may not apply adequate controls consistently throughout the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION}. Recommendations Evaluate existing security standards such as ISO 17799. Modify an existing standard for use within the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION}. Inform and train personnel on use of the standard. Audit information systems and procedures to ensure compliance.

{State the Vulnerability}

Explanation {Explain the vulnerability.} Risk There are several risks in not having {this vulnerability}. {Provide a list of risks.} {Provide a list of recommendations}. Recommendations

Physical Security
Describe the state of operational security at the client organization. Specifically, list the building, security perimeter, and server room vulnerabilities.

Vulnerabilities
Listed below are the physical security vulnerabilities discovered during the assessment. These are considered significant and steps should be taken to address them. The list is divided into a list of vulnerabilities that relate to the building, the security perimeter, and the server rooms. The Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 15

{CLIENT ORGANIZATION}

building group contains vulnerabilities within the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} office. The security perimeter group includes the exterior office windows, doors, alarm system, and the surrounding area. The server room are specific to rooms containing server equipment.

Building Vulnerabilities Several key doors within the building are unlocked or can be forced open
Explanation There are several important doors in the interior {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} office area that are normally unlocked or can be forced open even when locked. The door to the utility room is a hollow core wooden door with no lock. The utility room contains the wiring panel for the telephones, a junction for the fiber optic cable, and the alarm system box. The room containing the modem pool is normally open and unlocked. The system administrators office containing the office file and web server is usually unlocked and open. Risk These doors protect valuable assets of the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION}. A determined attacker, thief, or disgruntled employee could get through these important doors with minimal effort to steal and/or destroy. Recommendations Replace current doors with stronger fire doors. Replace existing door hardware with high security locks. Weld exterior hinge pins in place.

{State the Vulnerability}

Explanation {Explain the vulnerability.} Risk There are several risks in not having {this vulnerability}. {Provide a list of risks.} {Provide a list of recommendations}. Recommendations

Security Perimeter Vulnerabilities There is no entryway access control system

Explanation An entryway access control system limits physical access to a secure area to authorized personnel with the correct PIN number or access card. These systems have either a control panel where a correct PIN number must be entered before entry is allowed or a Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 16

Security Assessment Report

unique access card (contact or contactless) for each person to enter. Advanced systems provide log information each time personnel enter the secure area. Risk There are several risks in not having an entryway access control system. Unauthorized people can enter secure areas unescorted. There is no record of personnel entries into secure areas. It is not possible to disable access for a specific person. Evaluate available and suitable entryway access systems. Develop appropriate procedures for assigning and removing access. Install an appropriate system and assign access rights.

Recommendations

{State the Vulnerability}

Explanation {Explain the vulnerability.} Risk There are several risks in not having {this vulnerability}. {Provide a list of risks.} {Provide a list of recommendations}. Recommendations

Server Area Vulnerabilities The backup media are not protected from fire, theft, or damage
Explanation The backup media are stored near the backup system on an open shelf in the server area. The media could be stolen, misplaced, accidentally erased, dropped, or destroyed in a fire. If a system or data must be recovered, the media may not be available or functional when needed. Risk The operation of the {CLIENT ORGANIZATION} can be impacted if the backup media are not available due to theft, damage, or fire. Recommendations Purchase and install a lockable, fireproof media safe. Secure it to the floor and/or wall.

{State the Vulnerability}

Explanation Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 17

{CLIENT ORGANIZATION}

{Explain the vulnerability.} Risk There are several risks in not having {this vulnerability}. {Provide a list of risks.} {Provide a list of recommendations}. Recommendations

Summary
Summarize the report findings.

Action Plan
Provide an action plan that lists steps to be taken to improve security at the client organization.

References
Anderson, R. Security Engineering: A Guide to Building Dependable Distributed Systems. Indianapolis: John Wiley & Sons, 2001. Archer, Tom and Whitechapel. Andrew. Inside C#. Redmond: Microsoft Press, 2002. Deraison, Renaud. The Nessus Security Scanner. http://www.nessus.com/ Garfinkel, Simson, Spafford, Eugene H., and Schwartz Alan. Practical Unix & Internet Security, 3rd Edition. Sebastapol: OReilly, 2003. Gordon, Lawrence, Loeb, Martin, Lucyshyn, William and Richardson, Robert. 2004 CSI/FBI Computer Crime and Security Survey, San Francisco: Computer Security Institute, 2004. International Standards Organization, International Electrotechnical Commission. Information technology Code of practice for information security management. ISO/IEC 17799:2000(E). Switzerland: ISO/IEC, 2001. Open Web Application Security Project. The Ten Most Critical Web Application Security Vulnerabilities 2004 Update. OWASP, 2004. http://www.wasp.org/documentation/topten.html Peltier, Thomas R. Information Security Risk Analysis. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 2001. Public Law No. 100-235. The Computer Security Act of 1987. Stoneburner, Gary, Goguen, Alice, and Feringa, Alexis. Risk Management Guide for Information Technology Systems. NIST Special Publication 800-30. National Institute of Standards and Technology, 2001. Stoneburner, Gary, Hayden, Clark, and Feringa, Alexis. Engineering Principles for Information Technology Security (A Baseline for Achieving Security). NIST Special Publication 800-27 Rev A. National Institute of Standards and Technology, 2004. Swiderski, Frank and Snyder, Window. Threat Modeling. Redmond: Microsoft Press, 2004. United States Department of Agriculture. USDA Information Systems Security Policy. USDA 3140-001. Washington: USDA, 1996. Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 18

Security Assessment Report

Viega, John and McGraw, Gary. Building Secure Software. Indianapolis: Addison-Wesley, 2002. Wood, Charles C., Banks, William W., Guarro, Sergio B., Garcia, Abel A., Hampel, Victor E., and Sartorio, Henry P. Computer Security. New York: Wiley, 1987. Zwicky, Elizabeth D., Cooper, Simon, and Chapman, D. Brent. Building Internet Firewalls, 2nd Edition. Sebastapol: OReilly, 2000.

Confidential and Proprietary Information: Need to Know Page 19