Professional Documents
Culture Documents
/
#
:df
"
,df
#
\F]
where Fl(1k h#)
h# l(#
g
)\[(#
g
)j(#
e
\r)].
,
h# l(#
g
)\[#
g
)j(#
ge
\l)j(#
e
\lr)].
* Expressed as the ratio ( %) of the condence interval width relative to the heritability point estimate.
Table 3. Correlations of DSI rating for 227 F
$
derived-lines among three RTo Cuarto environments and phenotypic
correlations between DSI rating and agronomic traits
Environment
Environment* Agronomic traits
BU99 SA00 Plant height Leaf surface Leaf border Leaf length Tassel type
SA99 0n06 NS 0n19** k0n60** 0n27** 0n34** 0n42** 0n54**
BU99 0n19** k0n55** 0n12** 0n26** 0n32** 0n44**
SA00 k0n61** 0n41** 0n52** 0n40** 0n64**
Across environments k0n73** 0n38** 0n57** 0n44** 0n62**
* SA99 lSampacho (1999) ; BU99 lBulnes (1999) ; SA00 lSampacho (2000).
** Signicant at the 0n01 probability level ; NS, not signicant.
Table 4. Broad-sense heritability estimates with 90% condence limits for agronomic traits of 227 F
$
derived-lines
across environments in RTo Cuarto
Trait Heritability Low limit Upper limit Width*
Plant height 0n48 0n37 0n57 41n67
Leaf surface 0n00
Leaf border 0n12 0n00 0n27 225n00
Leaf length 0n00
Tassel type 0n38 0n24 0n49 65n79
* Expressed as the ratio (%) of the condence interval width relative to the heritability point estimate.
DISCUSSION
The primary cause for the abundance of disease in the
SA99 and SA00 environments was probably the result
of the sowing of the experimental trial in a lot of oat.
Oat appears to be one of the preferred hosts for the
vector (D. kuscheli) since the insects nd an optimum
environment to complete their development and then
migrate to adjacent maize crops. Considering this, the
SA99 and SA00 environments were the most severely
stressful and the BU99 environment appeared as the
least stressful.
The reaction to MRC disease, which is quan-
titatively inherited and probably controlled by a
polygenic system, showed transgressive segregation
suggesting the possibility of deriving resistant material
52 x. :. bi rrNzo ET AL.
from this segregating F
$
population. The absence of
dierences between the disease rating mean of the
susceptible parent Mo17 and the disease rating mean
of F
$
lines suggests partial recessiveness of resistance
for MRC disease indicating the presence of non-
additive gene eects (i.e. dominant and\or epistatic
gene action). These ndings are consistent with
previous reports about the quantitative inheritance of
MRC resistance (Presello 1993; Presello et al. 1995).
These authors found that additive and epistatic eects
were signicant. Because of the partial recessiveness,
which preclude any simple additive gene action model,
a portion of the genetic variance (#
g
) for reaction to
MRC is attributable to a non-additive component.
Epidemics of MRC are produced when there is a
combination of environmental conditions which lead
to abundant populations of migrant forms of D.
kuscheli, and when vectors spread during an early and
vulnerable growing stage of maize (Ornaghi et al.
1993). In a study with a segregating F
$
population
there is a wide range in plant development at the time
of inoculation and there is the risk of escape or limited
infections. The inconsistent responses of most families
across environments account for the substantial
genotypeenvironment interaction and the poor as-
sociation between DSI values in the dierent environ-
ments. These results indicate that evaluation of F
$
derived-lines for disease resistance to MRC requires
additional environments to obtain estimates of DSI
that are predictive of the performance of lines at other
environments and also explain why the breeding
eorts have been so laborious and time consuming.
The heritability estimates for partial resistance to
MRC showed consistent trends over the three
individual environments. Despite the signicant geno-
typeenvironment interaction, heritability estimates
are of a similar magnitude among the environments
and across environments. Accuracy among estimates
were similar as demonstrated by similarity in the
REFERENCES
Br:bri1r, O. E., Tr.ss:Nbirr, E. E., M:riNo, E. M. &
Dobb, J. L. (1981). Reolike virus associated with maize
R!o Cuarto disease in Argentina. Phytopathology 71, 205
(Abstract).
CoN1i, M. (1976a). Epidemiology of maize rough dwarf
virus. II. Role of the dierent generations of vector in
virus transmission. Agriculture Compectus Scienticus 39,
149156.
CoN1i, M. (1976b). Epidemiology of maize rough dwarf
virus. III. Field symptoms, incidence and control. Maydica
21, 165175.
CoN1i, M. (1984). Epidemiology and vectors of plant
reoviruses. In Current Topics in PathogenVectorHost
Research (Ed. K. F. Harris), pp. 11139. New York:
Praeger.
F:icoNrr, D. S. & M:ci:., T. F. C. (1996). Introduction to
Quantitative Genetics, 4th Edn. London: Longman.
Gr:i, C. R. & R:bir, V. L. (1982). Resistance of soybean
condence interval, suggesting that few environments
provided a reliable assessment of heritability
estimates. The heritability estimates are broad-sense
because they are based on dierences among F
$
derived-lines that reect both additive and non-
additive genetic dierences. On the basis of high
genotypeenvironment interaction and these heri-
tability estimates, selection for an increased resistance
to MRC disease in maize would require evaluation of
germplasm across multiple years and locations. A
predictive model for MRC disease intensity was
developed using weather variables during the winter
season, JuneJulyAugust (March et al. 1995). Ac-
cording to this model, the MRC disease intensity can
be adequately predicted before the planting period. If
maize is planted according to this predictive model
and is grown in alternation with winter cereal such as
oat, wheat and rye, reliable selection could be made in
the eld.
The correlations between MRC severity and plant
height, leaf surface, leaf border, leaf length and tassel
type across all environments indicate that greater
susceptibility was associated with shortened and
stunted aspects, deformed and partial or totally sterile
tassel, and deformed leaves. Leaf traits showed a low
heritability and a weak association with DSI while
MRC severity is closely associated with plant height
and tassel type with similar heritability. Tassel type
appears to be a useful predictor of DSI and can be
used eectively to improve screening procedures.
The authors acknowledge the assistance of I.
Mart!nez for improvements to the English. This work
was supported by grants from Agencia Nacional de
Promocio! n Cient!ca y Tecnolo! gica, Agencia
Co! rdoba Ciencia and Universidad Nacional de R!o
Cuarto, Argentina.
cultivars to Sclerotinia sclerotiorum. Plant Disease 66,
506508.
H:ii:irr, A. R. & Mir:Nb:, J. B. (1981). Quantitative
Genetics in Maize Breeding. Ames: Iowa State University
Press.
H:ri:z, I. (1972). Maize rough dwarf. A planthopper virus
disease aecting maize, rice small grains and grasses. Tel
Aviv: Israel University Press.
KN:ii, S. J., S1roii, W. W. & Ross, W. M. (1985). Exact
condence intervals for heritability on a progeny mean
basis. Crop Science 25, 192194.
LrN:rboN, S. L., M:rcn, G. J., Noxr, S. F. & OrN:cni,
J. A. (1998). Recent outbreak of Mal de R!o Cuarto
virus on corn in Argentina. Plant Disease 82, 4.
M:rcn, G. J., B:iz:riNi, M., OrN:cni, J. A., Brvi:cqi:,
J. E. & M:riNriii, A. (1995). Predictive model for Mal
de R!o Cuarto disease intensity. Plant Disease 79,
10511053.
Resistance to viral disease in maize 53
M:rz:cni, C., Bocc:rbo, G., MiiNr, R., Isoc:i, M. &
U.rb:, I. (1995). Genome structure and variability of
Fijiviruses. Seminars in Virology 6, 103108.
Noxr, S. F., LrN:rboN, S. L., R:i, B. C., L:ciN:, I. G.,
Lovr, S. K. & Doc:xio, D. (1981). Association of
reovirus-like particles with Enfermedad de R!o Cuarto
of maize in Argentina. Phytopathologie Zhurnal 101, 715.
OrN:cni, J. A., Boi1o, G., S:Ncnrz, G., M:rcn, G. &
Brvi:cqi:, J. (1993). Studies on the populations of
Delphacodes kuscheli Fennah in dierent years and
agricultural areas. Journal of Genetics and Breeding 47,
277282.
OrN:cni, J. A., M:rcn, G. J., Boi1o, G. T., M:riNriii, A.,
Brvi:cqi:, J. E., Giicci:, J. & LrN:rboN, S. L. (1999).
Infectivity in natural populations of Delphacodes kuscheli
vector of Mal R!o Cuarto virus. Maydica 44, 219223.
Prrsriio, D. (1993). Herencia de la tolerancia a Mal de R!o
Cuarto en tres l!neas endocriadas de ma!z. In ResuTmenes
Workshop Mal de RTo Cuarto del MaTz, pp. 7273.
Co! rdoba: INTA IFIVE.
Prrsriio, D., Criiz, A. & Fri1os, E. (1995). Efectos
gene! ticos asociados con la resistencia a la enfermedad Mal
de R!o Cuarto en l!neas endocriadas de ma!z. In
Proceedings of III Latin American and XVI Andean Zone
of Maize Researchers Meeting, Tomo I (Eds L. G. Avila L.
& L. M. Ce! spedes P.), pp. 407413. Bolivia: Fundacio! n S.
I. Patin4 o.
Rrxrs LrNicov, A. M. M. br, TrsoN, A., D:conrr1o, E.
& Hicir1, N. (1985). Hallazgo de uno de los vectores del
Mal de R!o Cuarto en ma!z. Gaceta AgronoTmica 25,
251258.
S1:1is1ic:i AN:i.sis S.s1rx INs1i1i1r (1990). SAS\STAT
Users Guide: Statistics, Version 6, 4th Edn. Cary, NC:
SAS Institute.
S1inrr, C. W. (1995). Mapping and manipulating quan-
titative traits in maize. Plants 11, 477481.