Professional Documents
Culture Documents
L. A. Prieto-Portar 2008
Humans have always admired tall structures since ancient times because of their social status: they are visible to all. Their builders were held in the highest respect of their societies, and their structures are the subjects of legends:
The famous architect Louis Sullivan coined the phrase that in buildings, form follows function. Perhaps a better phrase that applies to skyscrapers came from Case Gilbert in 1900 (he was the designer of the Woolworth Tower in 1913, the Worlds first skyscraper). Gilbert said: A skyscraper is a machine that makes the land pay. Gilberts assertion is evident in the figure on the left, taken from a real estate publication of 1903. It shows the prices of land values in Lower Manhattan that same year. Practically every firm in New York wanted to be located within a few hundred feet within the tight canyons of Broadway and Wall Street. Notice the contrast of the prices within a few hundred feet (from $400/sf to only $10/sf).
Chicago
1891 16-story Monadnock Building reaches the limits of masonry with 2 m thick walls. 1885 11-story Home Insurance Building, the first high-rise totally supported by a metal frame (wrought iron). 1889 9-story Rand-McNally Building, first all steel frame high-rise. 1891 20-story Masonic Temple, diagonal bracings introduced in the faade frames to form vertical trusses.
New York
1913 60-story Woolworth Building (considered the worlds first skyscraper). 1931 102-story Empire State Building (1,250 ft tall). The golden age of American skyscraper construction ended with the depression of the 1930s. It was not until several years after WW II that skyscraper construction recommenced. Instead of increases in height, modern developments brought new structural systems, improved material qualities, and better design and construction techniques. It was not until 1970 that the Empire State Building was eclipsed by the 110-story WTC North Tower (1,353 ft), and then in 1974 by the Sears Tower (1,450 ft).
100 80 60
Otis elevator Cast iron era New York
40 20 0 1850
1870
1890
1910
1930 Year
1950
1970
1990
2010
Electric elevator
1890
1910
1930
Years
1950
1970
1990
2010
A projection of all the building planned and under design versus existing tallest.
Propose prelim. beams and slabs based on M and V via the 2-cycle moment distribution or using midand end-span values
Review and coordinate all documents with the Architect, and HVAC, plumbing and electrical specialty engineers
Prepare final construction documentation: - CAD drawing set - Specifications - Engineer's cost estimate
yes Finalize documents for permitting and clarify comments Check creep and shrinkage effects
no
FINISH
yes Add 2nd-order gravity loads on lateral deflections (P- ) no Prepare the final accurate design with a refined model yes
Are there changes to the plans by the Architect or the Ow ner?
START
Site visit
Propose preliminary xsections of all vertical members (columns and shear wall)
Prepare final construction documentation: -CAD drawing set -Specifications -Engineers cost estimate Review and coordinate all documents with the Architect, HVAC, plumbing and electrical specialty engineers
Proposed preliminary beams and slabs based on M and V via the 2-cycle moment distribution or using mid and end-span values
Check the drift index = ?/H = 0.0015
yes
Prepare the final accurate design with a refined model no yes Are there changes to the plans by the Architect or the Owner? Finalize the satisfactory preliminary design
FINISH
no
Office buildings need large open spaces for flexible rental arrangements.
Residential buildings are heavier and many partitions separating each apartment.
Wind Steel
References
Monograph on Planning and Design of Tall Buildings, Volumes CB, CL, PC, SB and SC, ASCE, 1980. 1. www.greatbuildings.com 2. www.engr.psu.edu/ae/wtctragedy.html 3. www.kaleidagraph.com/teach.htm
Sweet Williams