Promoting Sustainable Consumption and Production

China Higher Efficiency Power and Distribution Transformers Promotion Project

ICA China 22nd June 2011

Slide 1

Promoting Sustainable Consumption and Production

EU-Switch HEE Transformer Project Overview Current EE standard of Distribution Transformer Background of China Distribution Transformers Market Proposed Higher Energy Efficiency Standard (MEPS) Promotion Plans of HEE DT through the Supply Chain

Slide 2

EU-Switch HEE Transformer Project Overview

Project name: China Higher Efficiency Power and Distribution Transformers Promotion Project Total duration of the action: Dec. 2009 to Dec. 2012 Locations: China Sponsorship by: EU Switch-Asia Program Total Amount of Budget: 781,832.95 EUR Coordinator and Key Operator: International Copper Association Partners: Action Sustainable Development France (ASD) China Electricity Council (CEC) China Electrical Equipment Industry Association (CEEIA) China National Institute of Standardization (CNIS)
Slide 3

EU-Switch HEE Transformer Project Overview

The Goals of Switch Program:
In Asia, main challenge to sustainable development is the increasing GHG emissions caused by rising energy consumption. Therefore, improving energy efficiency to alleviate global warming is an important way to achieve sustainable development

ICA coordinated with 4 partners to enhance the awareness of higher efficient transformer producing, procurement with policy making with the following aspects:
1. 2. 3. 4. 1. 2. Upgrade Energy Efficiency Standards for Transformers Capacity Building for End-Users Capacity Building for Chinese Manufacturers of Transformers Project Management, Evaluation and Monitoring Market Survey Issued policies and standards, project activities reports, and investments;

Measurement and Verification:

Slide 4

Current EE standard of Distribution Transformer

Title: The minimum allowable values of energy efficiency and the evaluating values of energy conservation for three phase distribution transformer (GB20052-2006) Issued at Jan of 2006 and effective at July 1, 2006 3 Efficiency Values: no load loss & load loss
Oil-immersed
Minimum: mandatory Target Minimum: mandatory @ 2010

Dry typed

S9

benchmark Respective deviation < 15%; Total deviation < 10% No load loss fall with 30% average Vs. S9;

SC9

benchmark Respective deviation < 15%; Total deviation < 10% No load loss fall with 10% average Vs. S9; load loss fall with 5% average Vs. SC9 Respective deviation < 7.5%; Total deviation < 5%

S11

SC10

Evaluated higher efficient : voluntary

S11

Respective deviation < 7.5%; Total deviation < 5%

SC10

Slide 5

Current EE standard of Distribution Transformer

Comparison with the world MEPS
%E 99.60% World Distribution Transformers Energy Efficiency Level Comparison

99.40% 99.20% 99.00% 98.80% 98.60% 98.40% 98.20% 30 50 80 100 160 250 315 500 800 1000
kVA 1600
NEMA TP1 2002 Australia AMEPS EU prEN50464-1 China GB20052 S11 USA MEPS-2010 Canada EE standard India BEE Star 3 China S9 Mexico NOM-002-SEDE-1999 EU HD428 C'-C level Japan Top Runner

Slide 6

Background of China Dist Transformers Market

Market Size of China Distribution Transformer:
From 2006-2009, the number of distribution transformers has been increased from 639,000 units/year in 2006 to 878,000 units/year in 2009, an average annual increase rate of 11.2% in the 4 years; The total capacity has been increased from 268.96million kVA/year in 2006 to 372.72million kVA/year in 2009, an annual increase rate of 11.5% over the 4 years.

Market share of energy efficient DT

Slide 7

Proposed Higher Energy Efficiency Standard (MEPS)

New items at the proposed EE standard: (2011.5.11)
Oil immersed
Grade 3: minimum & mandatory Grade 2: evaluated higher efficient & voluntary Grade 1: evaluated highest efficient & persuaded

Dry typed SC10 SC11 SCH15

benchmark No load loss fall with 10% average Vs S11; load loss fall with 5% average Vs. SC10 Amorphous metal DT characteristics

S11 S13 SH15

benchmark No load loss fall with 20% average Vs S11 Amorphous metal DT characteristics

Remark: still in the discussion and analysis

Estimated CO2 emission reduction and energy saving

Electric power saving/ year Coal saving/ year CO2 emission cut/year SO2 emission cut/year 887 GWh 332 kt 846 kt 47 kt

Slide 8

Promotion Plans of HEE DT through the Supply Chain

Supply Chain at the Distribution Transformer Market

Product Designer Power Utilities Raw or Unprocessed Material Suppliers Distribution Transformer Manufacturers Customers

Industry & Commercial electric power users Distributor & EPC Service providers

Logistic providers Finance providers Operation management M&V

Higher primary procurement cost of higher efficient transformers Weak communications between raw material suppliers, manufacturers and customers Lack the awareness and guidelines to evaluate the contribution of energy saving Lack technical support and finance support

Government support at the energy saving Top 2 power utilities support to use higher efficiency transformers
Slide 9

Promotion Plans of HEE DT through the Supply Chain

We do in the project at the following aspects:
Standard & specification upgrading Education communication platform development Create tools for customers to select higher efficient DT Enhance the supervision and management for DT

Slide 10

Promotion Plans of HEE DT through the Supply Chain

Standard & specification upgrading 1. MEPS standard run through the project period; 2. Develop TOC guideline for end users 1) DL/T985 standard upgrading launched by CEC;
Title: Guide for Determining Energy Efficiency for Distribution transformer Draft standard was completed at Jan of 2011; Focus at the total owing cost at the total life of DT, and guide users to assess old transformer replacement, capacity calculation and payback period calculation at the procurement of higher efficiency transformers;

2) DL/T985 software launched by CEC/ICA;

Slide 11

Promotion Plans of HEE DT through the Supply Chain

Standard & specification upgrading 1. MEPS standard run through the project period; 2. Develop TOC guideline for end users 3. Develop Eco-design for manufacturers
Eco-design standard launched by CEEIA; Title: Guide of eco-design for power and distribution transformers Draft standard was completed at end of 2010;

4. Develop labeling program

After MEPS proved, labeling program will be started based on the items of MEPS;

5. Support government to enhance the finance incentive with MEPS and labeling program
Beijing energy conservation center launched the case study to support users at the old transformer replacement with finance insensitive based on MEPS
Slide 12

Promotion Plans of HEE DT through the Supply Chain

Education communication platform development 1. International WORKSHOP for DT in 2012 2. Workshop for Chinese provincial energy conservation and

supervision centers in 2012

3. Training for 3000 energy managers, engineers

Slide 13

Promotion Plans of HEE DT through the Supply Chain

Create tools for customers to select higher efficient DT 1. Software for users to select higher efficiency transformers

2. Website to support users to know well about the market

and related knowledge;

http://www.efficienttransformer.org/default.aspx
3. Database of transformer manufacturers to support users

Slide 14

Promoting Sustainable Consumption and Production

China Higher Efficiency Power and Distribution Transformers Promotion Project

THANKS!
Slide 15