Professional Documents
Culture Documents
|
.
`
,
1
3
2
IEEE Personal Communications February 1998 1070-9916/97/$10.00 1998 IEEE
I
Spectrum and Technol ogy of a
Wi rel ess Local Loop System
Wi l l i am C. Y. Lee, Ai r Touch Communi cat i ons, I nc.
Abstract
This article shows that the wireless local loop (WLL) may not necessarily provide more capacity than mobile cellular systems if an FDMA or
TDMA system is used. CDMA has proven to have higher capacity than the other multiple access schemes due to the nature of CDMA systems.
In industrial countries, the requirements of WLL are quality and service features. In developed countries, the requirement is a low-cost high-
capacity system, even if voice quality must be sacrificed. Therefore, the system design aspects are different.
IEEE Personal Communications February 1998 50
division multiple access (TDMA), the value of M is given, but
the value of K is a function of C/I.
I n code division mult iple access syst ems ( CDMA) , D
always equals 2R; thus, K is a constant, K = 1.33 from Eq. 2,
but M is a function of C/I. Both K in FDMA (or TDMA) and
M in CDMA expressed as a function of C/I will be shown in
this article.
Th e Th r ee Key Dr i ver s Rel at ed t o C/I
The three key drivers (capacity, coverage, and quality) can be
expressed as a function of C/I.
Qua l i ty, Q, is proportional to C/I:
Ra di o ca pa ci ty, m, is inversed proportional to C/I:
(3)
Cover a ge, R, is inversed proportional to C/I:
(4)
Con si d er a t i on of
D ep l oyi n g a W LL Syst em
Im pact of t h e Requ i r ed C/I
The required C/I in each system is determined from the accept-
ed voice quality or corresponds to the specific frame error rate.
The required C/I of a WLL system under a nonfading fixed-to-
fixed condition is always less than the required C/I of a cellu-
lar system under a mobile radio multipath fading condition.
(5)
It shows that the WLL system can tolerate more Gaussian-
like interference than the Rayleigh-like interference of the
cellular system. Therefore, the frequency reuse distance for
WLL is supposedly shorter than for cellular if the propagation
path losses for both systems are the same.
Im pact of t h e Pr opagat i on Pat h Loss
Cov e r a g e I n cr e a se s i n W LL The cover age of a WLL is
based on a fixed-to-fixed propagation. The path loss of the
fixed-t o-fixed pr opagat ion in a WLL is based on 20
dB/decade. However, the path loss of mobile radio propaga-
tion (fixed-to-mobile) is based on 40 dB/decade, which shows
high excessive loss. Therefore, the same wireless communica-
tion system can cover more area for WLL services than for
mobile radio services.
Capaci t y Decr eases i n WLL ( if FDMA or TDMA is
used). Based on the path loss of 20 dB/decade for WLL and
40 dB/decade for cellular, the formula of C/I and K of both
systems can be obtained as follows:
WLL Systems
Under a condition of six interferers (Fig. 2)
(6)
Substituting Eq. 6 into Eq. 2 yields
(7)
Under a condition of one interferer (Fig. 3)
K
D
R
C
I
w
w w
1
1 1
1
3
2
2
|
.
`
,
|
.
`
,
C
I
R
D
D
R
w
w
w
w |
.
`
,
|
.
`
,
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
6 6
C
I
C
I
w c
|
.
`
,
<
|
.
`
,
R D
C
I
|
.
`
,
1
m
M
K
C
I
|
.
`
,
1
# channels / cell
Q
C
I
C
I
C
I
quality is improving
capacity or coverage is increasing
s Figur e 1. The scenario of a WLL system.
Nonf adi ng
f i xed-t o-f i xed
radi o l i nk
Di rect i onal
ant enna beam
s Figur e 2. Six interferers (co-channel cells) model for frequency
reuse (wireless systems).
f
1
f
1
f
1
f
1
f
1
f
1
D
f
1
R
s Figur e 3. Single interference from co-channel sites in WLL
using directional antennas at both ends.
Co-channel si t es
R
f
1
D
f
1
IEEE Personal Communications February 1998 51
(8)
and
(9)
Cellular Systems Always under a condition of six interfer-
ers (Fig. 1),
(10)
Substituting Eq. 9 into Eq. 2 yields
(11)
Capacity Compar ison The ratio of K
W
/K
C
can be used to
compare the capacity of two systems; if
(12)
the capacity of WLL is greater than that of cellular.
The ratio of K
W
1
/K
C
under a condition of six interferers is
(13)
The rat io of K
W
2
/K
c
under t wo different condit ions, one
interferer for WLL and six interferers for cellular, is
(14)
Equations 13 and 14 are plotted in Fig. 4 with a variable a
(15)
where a is always greater than that shown in Eq. 5.
Assume that the required (C/I)
W
of WLL is 6 dB or more;
then several observations can be stated from Fig. 4 as follows:
The region in which WLL capacity is greater than cellular
capacity is below the line of
A WLL system under the condition of six interferers cannot
have a capacity greater than that of cellular.
The WLL system under the condition of one interferer can
most likely have a capacity greater than that of cellular.
When t he value a becomes gr eat er , t he r at io of K
W
/K
C
increases.
Capaci t y Is In depen den t of t h e
Pr opagat i on Pat h Loss i f CDM A Is Used
In a CDMA system, every cell operates the same radio chan-
nels; therefore, D = 2R has been stated previously and K is a
constant, K = 1.33. However, M is known and is a function of
C/I. The following deviation shows that the propagation path
loss does not impact capacity use. The scenario in Fig. 5, with
the mobile unit at position A, would be the worst case. The
home cell site and two close-in interference sites I
1
and I
2
are
at the same distance R from the mobile unit. The C/I at posi-
tion A can be expressed as
(16)
where I is the total interference, I
s
the self-interference, and I
a
the adjacent interference. E
b
is the energy per bit and I
0
the
interference power per hertz. B is the allocated spectrum band,
R the transmit rate per second. In Eq. 16, E
b
/I
0
and B/R are given.
I n W LL syst em s, the 20 dB/dec loss is used, that is, R
2
with a
transmit power at the base (Fig. 5). We assume that the domi-
nant adjacent interferers are from I
1
and I
2
.
(17)
where
I
S
= (M
W
1) P
t
R
2
I
a
= I
1
+ I
2
+
1
= 2M
w
P
t
R
2
+
1
2M
W
P
t
R
2
Then from Eq. 17, the total number of traffic channels is
(18)
M
C
I
w
w
|
.
`
,
+
]
]
]
]
]
]
1
3
1
1
C
I
P R
I I
P R
M P R M P R M
w
t
s a
t
w t w t w
|
.
`
,
+
( ) + +
2
2
2 2
1
1 2
1
3 1
C
I
C
I I
E
I
B
R
s a
b
o
+
K
K
w
c
1.
C
I
a
C
I
c w
|
.
`
,
|
.
`
,
K
K
K
K
w
c
w
c
2 1
1
6
|
.
`
,
K
K
C
I
C
I
C
I
C
I
w
c
w
c
w
c
1 1
2
2
3
2 45
2
|
.
`
,
|
.
`
,
|
.
`
,
|
.
`
,
.
K
K
w
c
<1
K
D
R
C
I
c
c c
|
.
`
,
|
.
`
,
1
3
2
3
2
C
I
R
D
D
R
c
c
c
c |
.
`
,
|
.
`
,
4
4
4
6 6
K
D
R
C
I
w
w w
2
2 2
1
3
1
3
2
|
.
`
,
|
.
`
,
C
I
R
D
D
R
w
w
w w
|
.
`
,
|
.
`
,
2
2
2 2
2
2
2
|
.
`
,
m
M
K C
I
C
I
w
w
w w
1
1
1 1
49
2
24 5
|
.
`
,
|
.
`
,
.
+
|
.
`
,
]
]
]
]
]
]
+
|
.
`
,
m
M
K
s
E
I
E
I
w
w
b
o
b
o
1
1 33
1
3
128
1 1 875
128
1
.
.
C
I
E
I
b
o
128
M
C
I
c
c
|
.
`
,
+
]
]
]
]
]
]
1
3
1
1
C
I
P R
I I
P R
M P R M P R M
c
t
s a
t
c t c t c
|
.
`
,
+
( ) + +
4
4
4 4
2
1 2
1
3 1
`
,
+
|
.
`
,
m
E
I
w
b
o
1 875
128
1 1 875
128
3 16
1 77 76 . .
.
.
IEEE Personal Communications February 1998 54
In a WLL syst em in a developed count ry, C is very low.
Therefore, you need t o have an I value t hat is much lower
than C in order to make a profit. This is a big challenge.
How t o Bu i l d a W LL Syst em In Devel oped Cou n t r i es
On th e Equ i pm en t Si de The cost of each piece of customer
premises equipment (CPE) needs t o be lower. This means
that a WLL has to:
Use an existing cellular system The same phone can be
used in both WLL and cellular. This will lower the cost by
sharing the same wireless communication network.
Develop a low-cost WLL system with low-cost CPE and with
the capability to upgrade the system in the future In devel-
oped countries, the markets for WLL are huge; therefore, it
may be justified to choose a low-cost system solely for WLL.
In a WLL system, the standard is not an issue. The WLL
links ar e fixed, not moving; t her efor e, t he CPE does not
require any standard.
I n the Technol ogy Ar ea In order to lower the cost of equip-
ment per line, we may have to have more users share one line.
The following examples can reduce the cost:
Use multiplexing on one radio. We can use frequency-divi-
sion mult iplexing ( FDM) or t ime-division mult iplexing
( TDM) on one r adio t o incr ease t alk channels, but of
course the voice quality may be reduced.
Use t he part y line feat ure for t hose subscribers who are
willing share one subscribed line.
Con cl u si on
The WLL always provides large coverage but not necessarily
mor e capacit y t han mobile cellular syst ems if FDMA or
TDMA is used. The WLL always provides more capacity than
t he cellular syst em if CDMA is used. In WLL syst ems, t he
capacity of CDMA is always greater than that of FDMA or
TDMA. Using CDMA schemes, t he capacit y of WLL is
roughly double that of cellular. The requirements of WLL sys-
tems for industrial countries are the quality and service fea-
tures. It is wise to choose a bundled services system to share
the same wireless communication network in order to lower
operational cost and offer the subscriber, in the meantime,
only a single handset to please the customers.
The WLL system of the future, in developed countries, is a
low-cost system, even if voice quality has to be sacrificed. Of
course, to adapt an existing cellular system, which can have both
services, mobile cellular and WLL, share the same spectrum is
possible. Many suggestions to lower the cost by developing low-
cost WLL systems have also been addressed. WLL is a future
business for both industrialized and developed countries.
Ref er en ces
[ 1] W. C. Y. Lee, Mob i l e Cel l ul ar Tel ecommuni cat i on Syst ems, Anal og and
Di gi t al , M cGraw -Hi l l , 1995.
[ 2] W. C. Y. Lee, M o b i l e Co mmu n i cat i o n s Desi g n Fu n d amen t al s, Wi l ey &
Sons, 1993.
[ 3] W. C. Y. Lee, The Wi r el ess Local Loop In t he Fut ur e, Tel ep hony, Oct .
23, 1995, pp. 3638.
Bi ogr aph y
WILLIAM C. Y. LEE [ F] r ecei ved hi s Ph.D. f r om Ohi o St at e Uni ver si t y i n 1963 i n
elect rical engineering. Chief Scient ist and Vice President of St rat egic Technology
at Ai r Touch Communi cat i ons, Inc., he j oi ned t he company (f or mer l y PacTel
Mobi l e Compani es) i n Apri l 1985 t o devel op i mprovement s t o syst em perf or -
mance and capacit y. Prior t o joining AirTouch Communicat ions, he w orked f or
ITT Def ence Communicat ions Division (ITTDCD) engineering milit ary mobile pro -
j ect s. Pr evi ous t o ITT, he w as emp l oyed at Bel l Lab or at or i es, f r om 1964 t o
1979, w here he st udi ed w ave propagat i on i n an ani st ropi c medi um, ant enna
t heor y, mobi l e r adi o pr opagat i on and syst ems, mi l l i met er and opt i cal w ave
pr opagat i on, sw i t chi ng syst ems, and sat el l i t e communi cat i ons. He w as t he
f ounder and co-chair of CTIA s subcommit t ee f or Advanced Radio Technologies
in 1987 and w as involved in digit al cellular st andard set t ing. He assist ed in and
support ed pursuing t he CDMA syst em f or cellular, and he also int roduced t he
CDMA syst em t o Korea where it lat er became t he nat ional st andard syst em. He
i nvent ed and pat ent ed a new mi crocel l syst em i n 1990 t hat reduced t he f re-
quency reuse f act or f rom K = 7 t o K = 3 and i ncreased radi o capaci t y by 2.5
t imes over t he convent ional microcell. His UHF mobile radio propagat ion model
is know n as t he Lee Model. He conduct s t hree t hree-day courses sponsored by
George Washingt on Universit y. He is a Radio Club of America Fellow and a dis-
t inguished alumnus of t he Ohio St at e Universit y. He has received t he IEEE VTS
Avant Garde Aw ard, t he Bel l Laborat ori es Dedi cat ed Servi ce Aw ard, and t he
ITTDCD Technical Cont ribut ion Aw ard. He has w rit t en more t han 200 t echnical
papers and t hree t ext books. Most recent ly in 1998, he revised his book Mobile
Communicat ions Engineering (McGraw-Hill).