Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Is tourism contributing to
peace? How can a post-war
country start developing its
tourism potential? Who is a
peaceful traveler? Discover the
connection between peace and
tourism!
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
Peaceful Coexistence?
Principles and Practices” and stated that: “a
positive framework of peace can include influ-
ences such as transparency, material well
being, culture and education”. Is this assump-
tion true, or do we need to question these con-
cepts a bit further?
Can we argue that the idea that tourism pro-
motes peace should not be taken as axiomatic,
but rather as a hypothesis that needs to be
studied? Mistakes can be costly, and can pro-
duce multiple negative results. For example,
many criminologists believe that poverty pro-
duces crime, yet the data seem to contradict
this belief and policies based on this hypoth-
esis have failed. In the same way is the jury still
out as to whether tourism does or does not
promote peace?
To make this assumption even more difficult
there is no one standard definition of tourism.
Many people mean different things when they
say tourism, and there are multiple forms of
tourism ranging from family vacations to busi-
ness trips, from sun and surf vacations to visits
to poverty and disaster sites. In a like manner
there is no one definition of “peace.” When
we use the word peace, do we define it: as the
Tourism professionals and tourism scholars allows people to know each other, to work absence of war, or the absence of violence, or
have long grabbled with the question if tour- with each other, and to learn to appreciate do we define peace as mutual understanding
ism promotes peace. Certainly this is a con- each other’s cultures and by so doing come to and a sense of appreciation of the other? Is
cept that tourism industry professionals want appreciate each other. Tourism then is a giant peace through tourism defined as a lack of hos-
to believe. Yet, the answer to this intellectual “communication generator” that allow mutual tilities between nations or do we define tour-
query is not cut and dry. understanding and therefore appreciation of ism peace as the ability to live or visit a place
The basic assumption of those who see the other. Thus, in 1988 Louis d’Amour called without undue probabilities that the resident
tourism as a peace generator is that tourism tourism “the world’s peace industry”. Others, or visitor will be physically harmed?
May, 2011 — 29 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
May, 2011 — 30 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
May, 2011 — 31 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
May, 2011 — 32 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
to the top of the world agenda, It was against out of 49) have tourism as one of their three
this background that the 189 members of the leading sources of foreign exchange. For many
UN General Assembly unanimously agreed to poor countries tourism remains one of the
the Millennium Declaration in 2000 – as a dec- few – if not the only – opportunity for devel-
laration of intent and a commitment to work opment.
for a better world in the 21st Century. The contribution of tourism to conserva-
Regarding peace the declaration say: “We tion and sustainable development is critical –
are determined to establish a just and lasting the natural environment is the most impor-
peace all over the world in accordance with tant product on which the tourism industry
the purposes and principles of the Charter” depends – whether it is in the form of beaches,
The Millennium Development Goals (MDG) mountains, ski-slopes, or game parks, to name
was drawn from the Millennium Declaration. but a few. Tourism has shown its capacity to
These Goals constituted an unprecedented serve as a tool that can be used to achieve the
promise by world leaders to address, as a right balance between social, economic and
single package, peace, security, development, environmental goals.
human rights and fundamental freedoms. aries are going down and disposable incomes Tourism has the ability to build bridges of
The key to unlock the implementation of the are going up. understanding and tolerance between peoples
Millennium Declaration is Peace and security. and nations – it promotes world peace. Think
According to the figures of the IMF (Interna-
Without a climate of peace we will not succeed about it for a moment: Every peace agree-
tional Monetary Fund) tourism has become
in meeting the Development Goals – they will the biggest export industry – bigger than the ment includes tourism exchanges as one of
stay outside our reach. chemical or motor industries. Tourism is highly its first components. It is people-to-people
One may ask – how does tourism fit into this labour intensive and one of the biggest employ- contacts that establish the first bridges to cul-
picture. Well, as a truly global business and a ers in the world – particularly for women and tural understanding and tolerance. That is why
core sector of the world economy tourism has young people. Tourism consists of more small, UNWTO has quietly been driving tourism proj-
become a major international role player. Over micro and medium sized businesses, provid- ects to help build post-conflicts development
more than half a century tourism has been ing more products and services to the tourism in East Timor, Sri Lanka, Rwanda and even in
the fastest growing economic activity. In 1950 industry, than any other economic sector. It DPR Korea.
International tourist arrivals (the way in which has a strong impact on local farming, fishing, And when it comes to development, Tour-
tourism growth is measured) were 25 mil- handicrafts, services and even on the construc- ism is one of the best – and often the only
lion arrivals. In 2005 (55 years later) it broke tion industry. option – for many of the world’s poor coun-
through the barrier of 800 million and reached Tourism is also a frontline industry when tries to create new jobs, provide opportuni-
843 million in 2006. And, the long term trends it comes to poverty-reduction. International ties – particularly for women – and to help lift
for the tourism industry are incredibly positive. tourism receipts for Developing countries people out of poverty. That is why UNWTO is
The tourism industry is expected to double in amounts to about US$ 250 billion. In the 49 helping countries to place tourism at the core
size over the next 12-14 years – faster in some LDC’s (Least Developed Countries) – of which of their Development and Poverty Reduction
regions than in others – simply because bound- the vast majority are in Africa – 46 (that is 46 Strategies
May, 2011 — 33 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
May, 2011 — 34 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
Tourism and Peace, There are many ways to look at the relation
between tourism and peace. From a perspec-
tive that seems to be purely economic only
Perception of “peaceful
conditions”
Societies whose citizens are generally well-
off in economic turns (not only a tiny “upper
crust” of the society) can only become so
under peaceful conditions. Therefore, tourists
usually are citizens of peaceful, economically
more or less stable states – and they usually
wish or even expect to visit likewise states or
regions.
Peaceful conditions in their travel destina-
tions are expected by tourists – but what
exactly are these peaceful conditions? Peace-
May, 2011 — 35 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
May, 2011 — 36 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
decide what kind of experience they want to It is therefore rare that a complete boycott of a
have. country may contribute to an improvement in
For some, the Club Med experience is exactly the conditions of the host society.
what they are looking for in a vacation. For the The strongest candidate for this kind of boy-
rest of us, it is important to keep in mind that cott could be Apartheid-era South Africa. But
risk is manageable in most situations. Just as such boycotts based on an ethical or moral
there are some neighbourhoods to be avoided objection to a political system only work when
in and around Paris, there are areas which those most affected are those who have the
should be avoided in countries in conflict. One power, as was the case in South Africa. More
must be aware of one’s surroundings. The often, those affected are from among the
payoff can be an unforgettable and wonderful poorer segments of society, who already face
experience in a new and captivating culture. hardships imposed by an unjust political, eco- guests when we limit our impact on the local
nomic or social system. environment, when we do not take advantage
Impact of tourism The result is the same when there is a drop of poverty to engage in sex tourism, when we
in tourism due to internal conflicts. Many are treat the local population with dignity and
The more interesting questions may be ethi- dependent on tourists for earning their liv- respect.
cal in nature. What is the relationship between ing. Without this income, many are faced with
the tourist and the local country and society? When our interaction is that of one human
greater poverty and misery. Tourists cannot being with another human being, recognizing
What is the impact on the conflict itself, on the bring peace to a country. But we can bring
local society? What is the impact if tourists our common humanity and celebrating our
resources in terms of economic stimulation, diversity, we make that small personal contri-
stop going to such places? What is, in the end, as witnesses to the conditions and realities on
better for the people who have to live year- bution to peace. And most of all, we may find
the ground, and in terms of sharing our own that on our return home, we continue on this
round in these countries? The short answer is, knowledge and experience with our hosts.
“it depends”. path, making our own society just that much
The presence of tourists, which is often vital more peaceful.
Countries in conflict tend to have serious eco- for governments’ budgets, also tends to have (Originally published in Integra 'Tourism and Peace /
nomic problems, with high levels of inequality a moderating impact on internal repression. Tourism and conflict'.)
and poverty. When tourists stop coming, there It is easier to do dirty work with no witnesses
is little that can replace the lost income. Suffer- around. By Karin Chladek and Augustin Nicolescou
ing increases. And this must be the measure of Augustin Nicolescou has worked with the IICP (The
ethical tourism – not only in areas of conflict, Institute for Integrative Conflict Transformation and
Good guests contribute to peace Peacebuilding) since it was founded. He coordinates the
but everywhere.
IICP’s dialogue project in Sri Lanka, conducts research,
Ethical tourism in a conflict area reduces suf- Most of all, we should remember that when trainings, and manages the office IT and website.
fering. It increases the wellbeing of the local we travel to another country, we are guests of
Karin Chladek is editor-in-chief of Integra and respon-
population. Beyond the economic dimensions, that host society. And guests have the respon- sible for press and public relations of respect – Institute
it increases the visibility of their plight, expos- sibility of behaving well. Our presence will have for Integrative Tourism and Development. Her academic
ing the internal situation to the outside world. a positive effect on a larger scale, as long as background is science journalism and communication.
It brings in new perspectives from the outside. we make sure to be good guests. We are good http://www.respect.at
May, 2011 — 37 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
May, 2011 — 38 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
visit such a country or region, therefore: Local The first businesses that will open in a post- respective conflict zone also bears some
authorities must be encouraged to guarantee conflict area are likely markets, restaurants, problems. Information on conflicts should
the safety and security that is needed for a stalls at beautiful locations. Mediators could, not be propaganda with the potential to stir
touristic environment. Without the willingness together with tour operators, encourage this up renewed trouble. Again, international
and the sources to provide security, the whole kind of soft tourism first by directing day-trips mediators might be helpful to avoid exactly
project will end in disaster if only a single tour- into such a region. It is important that local that.
ist is killed. All former conflict parties that are people get the chance to participate in the busi- There are a few success stories where tour-
present in such a region will have to participate ness. Otherwise the entrepreneurs will all be ism has encouraged the peace building pro-
in negotiations and must be convinced that outsiders who have the money to create busi- cess: Sarajevo after the war, Cambodia (despite
tourism will benefit both sides. Otherwise we ness (another potential for renewed conflict). other problems that tourism has brought
have a potential for renewed conflict. Next might be information centers – tourists along). There is also high potential for the
Peacekeeping forces or other security forces want to know about the conflict – but without success of tourism and peace in many other
in a former conflict zone will often say that being overrun by extreme views. Sensitive, yet regions of the world: Palestine, South Leba-
tourism hinders their operations or that an open, ways of information are needed. Hotels non, Iraq, many African countries, Timor... the
area is not fit for tourism. I, personally, have and resorts will follow last. An investment into list is endless.
not seen a single local civilian in a former con- such a project needs long-term stability and
flict zone who is not keen and happy to wel- sustained peace.
come tourists! That, of course, does not mean Getting local governments on board of plan- By Armin Hermann
that certain preconditions are to be ignored... ning and realizing tourism projects in their http://www.internationalpeaceandconflict.org
May, 2011 — 39 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
May, 2011 — 40 —
ETHICAL Tour i s m & P e a c e H a nd i n H a nd
May, 2011 — 41 —