Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10 October 2004
Hydrophobic interactions are highly selective, and underestimated. Several different methods have been
differences in surface hydrophobicities between pro- used for bioseparation, all of which exploit differences in
teins can be used as an efficient handle to facilitate physical, chemical and/or functional properties of the
protein isolation. Aromatic amino acid residues are of proteins. To obtain a high degree of purity of the target
particular importance for molecular recognition because protein, several different purification steps are often
they have a key role in several biological functions. The needed. Given that the cost for the bioseparation processes
hydrophobicity of a protein can easily be altered with increases with the number of purification steps used, as
minor genetic modifications, such as site-directed well as with consumed time for the processes.
mutagenesis or fusions of hydrophobic peptide tags. Separation of biomolecules in hydrophobic interaction
An important advantage of hydrophobic peptide tags chromatography (HIC) occurs on the basis of hydrophobic
over traditional affinity tags is the possibility of exploring interactions between immobilised hydrophobic ligands
simple and inexpensive bioseparation materials. Recent and hydrophobic solvent-exposed regions (patches) on
results demonstrate the potential of hydrophobic inter- biomolecules. A protein frequently has hydrophobic
action chromatography and aqueous two-phase sys- patches on its surface and when these are in contact
tems as tools to study relative hydrophobicities of with an aqueous solvent, the water molecules close to the
recombinant proteins with only minor alterations. hydrophobic patches are arranged in an ordered mode
This review focuses on hydrophobic peptide tags as (Figure 1). This creates a thermodynamically unfavour-
fusion partners, which can be used as important able situation because it represents a decrease in entropy
tools in bioseparation. by comparison with a non-solvated protein plus free water
molecules. The displacement of ordered water molecules
Hydrophobic interactions are one of the major driving surrounding hydrophobic ligands and proteins leads to an
forces behind the folding of peptides and proteins. In increase in entropy, resulting in a negative change in free
addition, hydrophobic interactions are highly selective energy (DG), according to the Gibbs function (DGZDHK
and are involved in several biological events, such as TDS, where DH and DS are the changes in enthalpy and
regulation and transport across membranes, enzyme entropy, respectively). Under normal conditions, the
catalysis, association of protein subunits and protein adsorption enthalpy is small and this indicates that
aggregation. Lo Conte et al. studied 75 different protein– adsorption is mainly an entropy-driven process [3,4].
protein complexes. The interfaces in the complexes were Another bioseparation technique, by which hydro-
much richer in aromatic residues (tyrosine, tryptophan, phobic interactions can be explored, is the aqueous two-
phenylalanine and histidine) than the protein surfaces phase system (ATPS). ATPSs are particularly useful for
that remained accessible to the solvent [1]. Hydrophobic primary recovery of biomolecules, and as tools for studying
residues are more deeply buried in protein structures than surface properties. Two-phase systems are formed when
are hydrophilic residues and, therefore, introduction of an aqueous solution of two structurally different polymers,
surface-exposed hydrophobic regions in the target protein or a polymer and salt, separate into two phases when the
can facilitate protein isolation and purification. The concentrations of the components are higher than a
aromatic amino acid residues are highly selective and critical threshold value. Each phase is enriched in one of
important for protein recognition in several biological the phase-forming components and the partitioning of a
functions. For instance, the aromatic residues phenyl- protein depends on the characteristics of the protein and
alanine and tyrosine have key roles in protein–RNA the properties of the two-phase system [5]. The technique
binding [2]; furthermore, tyrosine residues contribute to constitutes a mild method of separation of biomolecules as
one-sixth of the antigen–antibody interface [1]. a result of high water content in both phases (70–95%).
The importance of developing techniques for the Traditionally, HIC and ATPS have been used for
isolation and purification of proteins must not be protein separation of cellular extracts; however, these
Corresponding author: Sara Fexby (sarafexby@yahoo.se).
techniques can be used as tools for measuring relative
hydrophobicities [6–8]. HIC retention is the result of
www.sciencedirect.com 0167-7799/$ - see front matter Q 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.tibtech.2004.08.005
512 Review TRENDS in Biotechnology Vol.22 No.10 October 2004
W
WW W
W WWW WW
W W W W
L W + W
L + W
W W W W W
WWW W WW WW W W
WW W
WW W
TRENDS in Biotechnology
Figure 1. Water molecules (W) are highly ordered around hydrophobic solvent-exposed regions, such as hydrophobic ligands (L) and hydrophobic solvent-exposed protein
patches. The specific ligand–protein interaction is thermodynamically favourable because it results in a release of the ordered water molecules.
specific protein–surface interactions, whereas ATPSs according to their hydrophobic properties. The residues
reflect overall net surface properties such as hydrophobi- are given a relative hydrophobicity value, which depends
city. Here, we describe the possibility of using hydrophobic on the method chosen to determine the hydrophobic
peptide tags as tools in bioseparation and discuss the interactions. These interactions are most commonly
possible evaluation of differences in relative hydrophobi- studied by partitioning of amino acid residues, peptides
cities using HIC and ATPS techniques. or proteins between an oil phase and a water phase [6].
Hydrophobicity scales can also be based on peptide
retention times in chromatographic techniques [6] or
Design of hydrophobic peptide tags partitioning of peptides in ATPSs [22,23]. A general
A selective molecular recognition site can genetically be trend in ATPS is that the aromatic residues partition to
introduced on a target protein to facilitate its purification the more hydrophobic top phases, such as poly(ethylene
and isolation. Several so-called ‘affinity tags’ are available, glycol) (PEG) or copolymers of ethylene oxide-propylene
ranging from short peptide sequences to fusion partners of oxide (EOPO), whereas the charged residues move to the
protein size and complexity [9]. Polyhistidine tags are hydrophilic bottom phase.
commonly used for bioseparation, wherein the interaction Proline residues have a rigid ring structure and
between histidine residues and divalent metal ions, such prevent secondary structure formation. Adding prolines
as nickel, copper, zinc or cobalt, are utilized [10]. Bio- between a hydrophobic tag and the target protein could
separation can also be performed via thermosensitive have a positive effect because the degree of surface
elastine tags; a temperature increase results in precipi- exposure of the tag might increase. Variants of N- and
tation of the tagged protein [11]. Target proteins fused with C-terminal hydrophobic peptide tags, fused to different
short hydrophobic peptide tags have successfully been used target proteins, have been evaluated in ATPSs [15,20]. All
in bioseparation (Table 1) because additional hydrophobic exhibited improved hydrophobic properties when proline
residues have a strong effect on the relative hydrophobi- residues were added, as a result of the higher degree of
city of the tagged protein [12–15]. The most commonly surface exposure of the aromatic residues. However, the
used are tryptophan-containing tags [12–14,16,17]; how- difference in solvent exposure between similar combin-
ever, other hydrophobic peptide tags have been examined, ations, such as Y3P2- and (YP)3-tags fused to a mutated
including polyphenylalanines [18], polyisoleucines [19] variant of green fluorescent protein, GFPuv, was minor
and polytyrosines [15,20,21]. [21]. The fluorescence emission for tryptophan residues
When designing a hydrophobic fusion tag, the contri- depends on the polarity of the medium around the
bution of both the individual residues and their combined residues, and this can be used to investigate their degree
effects are of significance. Several hydrophobicity scales of exposure. Tryptophan-containing tags fused to cutinase
are available within which amino acids are ranked from Fusarium solari pisi proved to be solvent-exposed,
Table 1. Hydrophobic peptide tags that have been explored for because the tryptophans in the tags exhibited similar
protein purification emission spectra as free tryptophan peptides [24].
Tag Target protein Refs
(TrpPro)2 Cutinase [14] Applications in bioseparation
ZZ-cutinase [16] Partitioning in ATPS
Endoglucanase I [17] When specific properties, such as the hydrophobicity of a
(TrpPro)4 Cutinase [14]
ZZ-cutinase [16]
protein, are to be evaluated, minimised charge-dependent
Endoglucanase I [17] salt effects are desirable. The charge effects can be reduced
(Tyr)3 Lactate dehydrogenase [15] if partitioning occurs at a pH level that is equal to the
Green fluorescent protein [21] isoelectric point of the protein, or at a point when the
(TyrPro)3 Green fluorescent protein [21]
anions and cations are evenly distributed over the two
(Tyr)3(Pro)2 Lactate dehydrogenase [15]
Green fluorescent protein [21] phases in the system. ATPSs that contain potassium
(Tyr)4 ZZ-Cutinase [20] sulphate (K2SO4) as the dominating salt are commonly
(TyrPro)4 ZZ-Cutinase [20] used for hydrophobicity studies, because K2SO4 gives
(Tyr)6 Lactate dehydrogenase [15] potential differences close to zero in several ATPSs [16,25].
(Tyr)6(Pro)2 Lactate dehydrogenase [15]
Fusions of tryptophan-containing tags to cutinase
(Tyr)8 ZZ-Cutinase [20]
enhanced partitioning in a PEG/salt system to the more
www.sciencedirect.com
Review TRENDS in Biotechnology Vol.22 No.10 October 2004 513
hydrophobic PEG-rich phase, with an increasing number (tryptophan-tagged cutinase in 500 L Escherichia coli
of tryptophan residues [13]. In another study, tags homogenate) was obtained in a water phase after a total
containing tryptophan or isoleucine residues were com- recovery over the extraction steps of 71% and a purifi-
pared, and the aromatic tryptophan residues improved cation factor of 2.5 [28].
the partitioning of the tagged protein to the more hydro-
phobic top phase to a higher extent that the isoleucine Bioseparation using HIC
residues did [19]. The aromatic tryptophan residues HIC takes advantage of the hydrophobicity of proteins for
improved the partitioning of the tagged protein to the selective interactions between proteins and ligands. The
more hydrophobic top phase to a higher extent than it did protein size is relevant because a larger protein has a
the isoleucine residues. Similarly, increasing the number higher probability of forming multi-point attachments to
of tyrosine residues fused to lactate dehydrogenase, LDH, the ligand, resulting in stronger interactions and
enhanced the partitioning of LDH to the more hydro- increased residence time on the column. However, the
phobic top phase [15]. hydrophobic solvent-exposed surfaces are often of greater
Bandmann et al. screened a large number of random- importance. Fausnaugh and Regnier investigated HIC
ized peptides containing nine amino acid residues via the separations of different lysozyme isozymes [29]. Differ-
partitioning of a phage display library in a PEG/salt ences of only a few hydrophilic or charged residues
system [20]. Several tyrosine-containing peptides were substantially altered retention times on a phenyl-based
present in the more hydrophobic PEG-rich phase. The HIC column.
other aromatic residues, tryptophan and phenylalanine, Hassinen et al. investigated the separation of hydro-
which had earlier been found to partition to a high extent phobic fusion tags, containing tryptophan or isoleucine
to hydrophobic phases [13,23,25], were only found in small residues, fused to the ZZ protein (the Z domain is the IgG
amounts in the resulting peptides in the hydrophobic interacting domain of protein A) on PEG-based and
phase [20]. The significant presence of tyrosine residues propyl-based HIC columns [19]. The more hydrophobic
could be due to their more common occurrence on protein propyl-based HIC column increased the retention times of
surfaces than tryptophans and phenylalanines [26]. the fusion proteins by comparison with the PEG-based
Up to 90% of enzyme activity could be extracted in a column. Tryptophan residues had a greater impact on the
detergent-based ATPS in a single step, from Saccharomyces retention times than did isoleucine residues. Recombin-
cerevisae culture broth expressing tryptophan-tagged cuti- antly expressed native GFPuv and tyrosine-tagged GFPuv
nase [14]. The copolymer EOPO is thermoresponsive, and (Y3P2-GFPuv) were also separated on a phenyl-based HIC
heating the polymer solution above its cloud point will column by a descending salt gradient (S. Fexby, unpub-
result in phase separation into a water phase and a lished). The retention time for Y3P2-GFPuv was pro-
polymer phase. The advantage is that the protein can be longed compared to that of native GFPuv.
recovered in the water phase and the polymer can be
recycled (Figure 2) [27]. Escherichia coli cell extracts of Limitations of using hydrophobic peptide tags
native and tyrosine-tagged GFPuv proteins were also Fusions with less common amino acid residues, such as
partitioned in an EO30PO70 (30% EO and 70% PO)/dextran hydrophobic residues, might have a negative impact on
system [21]. The hydrophobic EO30PO70 top phase was the tagged protein, and might effect both protein
heated and the target protein was obtained in a water expression and stability. Several investigations of ter-
solution. A purification factor of 4.5 and an 83% yield were minal fusions of hydrophobic peptide tags have led to
observed for Y3P2-GFPuv, compared with a purification changes in expression. There are several reasons for this
factor of 1.9 and a 46% yield for the native GFPuv. Kepka (see Box 1), for example, hydrophobic fusion can cause the
et al. also demonstrated a successful scale-up of a protein to be membrane-associated [18] or alternatively
thermoseparating ATPS, in which the target protein proteolytic cleavage can reduce the amount of protein
EOPO copolymer
and water
Transfer of top phase Heat
Protein
and water
Dextran
and water EOPO copolymer
Target protein
Contaminating
proteins
Recycling of EOPO copolymer
TRENDS in Biotechnology
Figure 2. Recycling of the ethylene oxide–propylene oxide (EOPO) copolymer. The EOPO copolymer is enriched in the top phase in an aqueous two-phase system, containing
EOPO and dextran. The copolymer can be recycled if the top phase is transferred and heated above the cloud point of the EOPO copolymer. The thermoresponsive copolymer
precipitates and the proteins are obtained in the water phase.
www.sciencedirect.com
514 Review TRENDS in Biotechnology Vol.22 No.10 October 2004
40/60 20/80
HBVE
BVE
TRENDS in Biotechnology
Figure 3. A schematic illustration of a novel HIC medium with altered hydrophobic properties. A series of the novel media was obtained by varying the reaction ratios of the
two monomers HBVE (hydroxybutyl vinyl ether) and BE (butyl vinyl ether) in the polymer grafting reactions. The reaction ratio of HBVE (RHBVE) and BVE (RBVE) in each
medium is written as RHBVE/RBVE above each illustration. The hydrophobic properties increased as the reaction ratio of the more hydrophobic monomer, BVE, increased from
0% to 80% in the polymer grafting reaction.
www.sciencedirect.com
Review TRENDS in Biotechnology Vol.22 No.10 October 2004 515
24 Nilsson, A. et al. (2003) Tryptophan-tagged cutinase studied by steady 32 Lollike, K. et al. (2001) Biochemical characterization of the penta-EF-
state fluorescence for understanding of tag interactions in aqueous hand protein grancalcin and identification of L-plastin as a binding
two-phase systems. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1646, 57–66 partner. J. Biol. Chem. 276, 17762–17769
25 Nilsson, A. et al. (2002) Cutinase-peptide fusions in thermoseparating 33 Gulyaeva, N. et al. (2003) Relative hydrophobicity and lipophilicity of
aqueous two-phase systems. Prediction of partitioning and enhanced drugs measured by aqueous two-phase partitioning, octanol-buffer
tag efficiency by detergent addition. J. Chromatogr. A. 946, 141–155 partitioning and HPLC. A simple model for predicting blood–brain
26 Miller, S. et al. (1987) Interior and surface of monomeric proteins. distribution. Eur. J. Med. Chem. 38, 391–396
J. Mol. Biol. 196, 641–656 34 Palliser, C.C. and Parry, D.A.D. (2001) Quantitative comparison of the
27 Persson, J. et al. (2000) Polymer recycling in aqueous two-phase ability of hydropathy scales to recognize surface.beta.-strands in
extractions using thermoseparating ethylene oxide-propylene oxide proteins. Proteins 42, 243–255
copolymers. J. Chromatogr. B Biomed. Sci. Appl. 743, 115–126 35 Welling, G.W. et al. (1985) Prediction of sequential antigenic regions in
28 Kepka, C. et al. (2003) Pilot-scale extraction of an intracellular
proteins. FEBS Lett. 188, 215–218
recombinant cutinase from E. coli cell homogenate using a thermo-
36 Rao, M.J.K. and Argos, P. (1986) A conformational preference
separating aqueous two-phase system. J. Chromatogr. A. 103, 165–181
parameter to predict helices in integral membrane proteins. Biochim.
29 Fausnaugh, J.L. and Regnier, F.E. (1986) Solute and mobile phase
Biophys. Acta 869, 197–214
contributions to retention in hydrophobic interaction chromatography
37 Lienqueo, M.E. et al. (2002) Mathematical correlations for predicting
of proteins. J. Chromatogr. 359, 131–146
protein retention times in hydrophobic interaction chromatography.
30 Jones, T. and Ferandez, E. (2003) a-Lactalbumin tertiary structure
changes on hydrophobic interaction chromatography surfaces. J. Chromatogr. A. 978, 71–79
J. Colloid Interface Sci. 259, 27–35 38 Huang, H-M. et al. (2003) Microcalorimetric studies of the mechanism
31 Ihre, H. (2003) Post-modification of a porous support. Patent WO of interaction between designed peptides and hydrophobic adsorbents.
03/046027 A1 J. Colloid Interface Sci. 263, 23–28
The Health Internetwork Access to Research Initiative (HINARI) of the WHO has launched a new community scheme with the UN Food
and Agriculture Organization.
As part of this enterprise, Elsevier has given 185 journals to Access to Global Online Research in Agriculture (AGORA). More than 100
institutions are now registered for the scheme, which aims to provide developing countries with free access to vital research that will
ultimately help increase crop yields and encourage agricultural self-sufficiency.
According to the Africa University in Zimbabwe, AGORA has been welcomed by both students and staff. ‘It has brought a wealth of
information to our fingertips’ says Vimbai Hungwe. ‘The information made available goes a long way in helping the learning, teaching
and research activities within the University. Given the economic hardships we are going through, it couldn’t have come at a better time.’
www.sciencedirect.com