Professional Documents
Culture Documents
July 7,2006
In compliance with the April 4,2006 schedule agreed upon by the parties in the CREW v.
Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Civil Action No. 06cv0173 (RJL), this letter is
a final response to your Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request dated September 7,
2005. In your request you asked for the following recordslinformation:
1. What portion of the $3.1 billion appropriated to DHS in fiscal year 2005 for
emergency preparedness to "support the Nation's ability to prepare for, mitigate
against, respond to and recover from natural and manmade disasters" was spent to
prepare for potential hurricanes on the Gulf Coast of the United States and on
potential flooding in New Orleans;
2. The amount of money diverted from emergency preparedness for and response to
natural disasters to emergency preparedness for and response to acts of terrorism
and the rationale behind any such diversion;
3. Studies, assessments, presentations, or scenarios of the potential devastation a
powerful hurricane could wreak on the Gulf Coast, including, but not limited to
the eight-day tabletop exercise conducted in July 2004 and intended to prepare
FEMA for a catastrophic hurricane in New Orleans;
4. Plans created regarding the federal government's response to any such scenarios;
5. The potential breaching of the levees that would lead to Lake Pontchartrain
flooding New Orleans and the response to such breaches; and
6. Communications from anyone employed by or associated with the Army Corps of
Engineers regarding the problems with and weakness of the levees surrounding
New Orleans, the potential breaching of the levees and the consequences of such
breaches, as well as proposed repairs or other construction to the levees.
r.
In addition, your letter stated that "CREW further seeks all memoranda, communications
and records of any lund and from any source, regardless of format, medium, or physical
characteristics, from August 26,2005 through the present, discussing or mentioning in
any way:
This release is granted in part at no cost to you. Enclosed are releasable portions of
Hurricane Katrina video-teleconference transcripts, e-mails from William Lokey, Patrick
Rhode, Michael Brown, David Trissell, and Jordan Fried as well as other documents that
relate to your request. After thorough legal review of these documents, I have
determined that portions of them are exempt from disclosure under exemptions 2 , 5 and 6
of the Freedom of Information Act of 1974,5 U.S.C. 552, (b)(2), (5) and (6), as amended.
We are releasing a total of 1786 pages, of which 1632 are released in part, and 154 pages
are released in their entirety. In addition, we are withholding 1168 pages in their entirety.
We are withholding portions of the respective emails under the following FOIA
exemptions. We are withholding Government cell phone numbers, FEMA Readiness
Alert Status information, government e-mail addresses, non-DHS government phone
numbers, security information, and internal administrative information under FOIA
Exemption 2("High 2"). FOIA Exemption 2("High 2") protects information applicable to
internal administrative and personnel matters, to the extent that disclosure would risk
circumvention of an agency regulation or statute, impede the effectiveness of an agency's
activities, or reveal sensitive information that may put the security and safety of an
agency activity or employee at risk.
We are withholding information that reveals internal administrative matters under FOIA
Exemption 2 ("Low 2"). FOIA Exemption 2 ("Low 2") protects information applicable
to internal administrative and personnel matters, to the extent that the material is trivial in
nature and is of no genuine public interest.
We are withholding the name, address, phone number, and e-mail address of non-
government individuals, home phone number and home address of DHS employees, and
personal family information under FOIA Exemption 6. Exemption 6 exempts from
disclosure records the release of which would cause a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy. The interest of the general public in reviewing these portions of
government documents does not outweigh the individuals' right to privacy. The release
of this information adds no detail about agency activities, the core purpose of the FOIA.
In addition, while searching for responsive records we located several that had originated
from other agencies. We have referred these documents to the respective agency for
direct response to you. We have requested that these agencies expedite their processing of
these documents in their queue. Following are the number of pages referred, and to
which agency they were referred to:
I am the official responsible for this determination. You may appeal this determination
within sixty calendar days from the date of this letter. Your appeal should include copies
of your original request and this response, as well as a discussion of the reasons
supporting your appeal. The envelope should be plainly marked to indicate that it
contains a Freedom of Information Act appeal. If you decide to appeal, please send your
appeal to:
For your information, your FOIA request, including your identity and the information
made available, is releasable to the public under subsequent FOIA requests. In response
to these requests, FEMA does not release personal privacy information, such as home
address, telephone numbers or Social Security Numbers all of which are protected from
disclosure under FOIA Exemption 6.
Sincerely,
FEMA d i e f Counsel
Enclosures
-
- For those following-along via audio conference call
only, we have a Web site established at fema.gov/hlt
Hurricane Center.
- 1
information to tell us whether this -is going to-become
late tonight.
forward speed even more over the next few days. and
Mexico
Gulf of Mexico.
Hurricane Center
the inflow.
significant flooding. ,
-
- briefing. Mr. Lowder, I'll turn i t back over to you
for questions.
to get on?
Liaison.
Executive Order.
At the present time. we have some ~ational
area.
locations.
(No response.)
Is Georgia on?
- GEORG IA : -- Georgia, this is Charlie
-
Dotson, Director of Operations. Department of
That's it. =
--
MIKE LOWDER: Any questions?
(No response.I
(Missing.)
-
EVAL 3 2 3 . We stood up the ROC today at
brief.
in there today. b
As you know. the Response-~iaisonis &-site
-
- support package en route to Lakeland. It's my
required.
15
2 . Todd?
(Missing.)
I .
- 16
we'll continue the duration and other special teams
(No response.)
call?
(No response.)
-
- 12:OO noon. and hopefully we'll be able to
tomorrow at 1 2 : O O noon.
- *.- * -
(Off the record.)
CERTIFICATION. .
PHYLLIS P . YOUNG
AUGUST 26. 2005
briefing.
from the lower Keys here. The bad news is it's still
- 1
for several hours in the Keys, even gusts up to
, * 6.- - *.
drove their car into a downed tree on the side of the
,
road.
. -
The rainfall is the other big concern
(inaudible).
being here.
, - *
.
A
. m -
MR. BILL REED: Okay. Thanks, Max, and I'm
glad to be here because, if I ' m here, i t means they
-
- here yesterday.
The good news for the Keys is that it all
you.
(No response.)
NATIONAL HURRICANE CENTER: Hearing- none.
total.
-
8
Major damage that we've been able to
this storm.
- 10
State of Georgia.
calls.
- .
We are coordinating at the present time
Let's go to Region 4 .
here.
12
-
questions?
(missing).
GEORGIA: Okay.
4?
(No response.)
- posture.
FLORIDA: (Missing) -- Florida area, is that
what we're talking about, the second approach?
-., - *.. * - BILL LOKEY: Yes.
13
.-
significant influence on i t .
later today.
(Missing.)
(Missing.)
declaration. and
. -
we're also coordinating with the State in regards to
(Missing.)
Counties.
-
- go to Lakeland and two to report to the EOC in
(Missing.)
is definitely a shortfall.
- *.- * -
MIKE LOWDER Any questions for Logistics?
(No response.)
(No response.)
?'
Anybody out there have an;thing else-to add
(No response.)
CERTIFICATION
-
- of the oral discussion as possible.
PHYLLIS P . YOUNG
. - *... * -
AUGUST 2 7 . 2005
might think when you see that that means we have more
side of the storm, get the high surge and the high
- 2
days. So, that's the storm total we're looking for
gradually diminishing.
- We have a second axis of preclpltatlon along
4
-
possibilities. The storm is forecast to move right
evacuation processes.
(No response.)
over to you
wrnds --
diminishing.
7
take i t to, I can't totally rule i t out, but there's
(No response.!
reports .
first.
Louisiana?
*. -.. .
TEXAS: This is the State of Texas. - At 4:00
9
preparing shelters In the event that evacuations from
resources
(No response.)
Patrick,
(No response.]
- *.- - Y
(No response.)
Florida.
for questions.
(No response.)
Let's go to Georgia.
continuing to monitor.
go to Region 6
16
Beauregard as well.
to move westward.
Beauregard.
.
MIKE LOWDER: Any other questions for Region
.
6?
Mississippi.
afternoon.
(No response.)
(No response.)
Operations
Sunday
their staging
.
. areas for Atlanta and Birmingham over
(No response.)
(No response.)
(No response )
Secretary.
can do it .
going to hear
-
.
me screaming about i t . So, go right
23
The last thing I want to do before we leave
MIKE BROWN:
-
I ' m on the line, Mike.
say that I appreclate all the support that Joe and the
PHYLLIS P . YOUNG
AUGUST 2 8 . 2005
to cover today. f
here.
update?
Mayf ield.
afternoon.
-
- to do that. When you have a large diameter eye like
this, and as strong as this one is. I really don't
hurricane.
north-northwesterly track.
period
The strong winds, the heavy rains, and the tornadoes '
- will spread well inland, along this path that you see
- 4
based on the last forecast that came out about an hour
ago that has the center coming over here, passing just
these areas are already going under water out near the
-- mouth of the Mississippi River. The colors that you
see here show inundation over the land areas.
- much.
Mr. JIM STETHKOVICH: We do have a question
here in Al.abama.
bit high.
we're forecasting --
not just the intensity. but it's the size that really
that
to the HPC.
period.
States.
~ s n t e r . Back to you
moves north and then east and accelerates like Max and
' and local folks deal with this really serious storm
course
you and your team will do all you can to help the good
states. Louisiana?
Doriant .
of emergency.
the key.
too late.
Federal Government.
-
ALABAMA: (Missing) right now, Toby Roth.
-
the Governor's Chief of Staff is here, so we've got
=
all.the documents ready to go, Mike. So as soon as
t
the panhandle.
response.
Thanks. Craig.
them to mobilize.
organized.
we're up to.
Go ahead, Tony
staging area.
Region 4?
Mr. Carlisle?
30
PAUL: I'd like to call bn Mr. ~herkan in
- ..- - color.
imagery.
We have made arrangements with the Coast
-
33
(missing) half a million MREs, which is a two-and-a-
- 34
MIKE BROWN: Questions for Recovery?
Others? Mike?
today.
for you. OK
us. And I hope we never have to call you and tell you
them?
. - - -.- * -
MIKE BROWN: We have DOD assets over here at
(Missing.)
(Laughter.)
=
MIKE BROWN: Are there any other questions
record.)
CERTIFICATION
PHYLLIS P . YOUNG
AUGUST 3 0 , 2 0 0 5
area. and the good news for the recovery area is that
over the next few days we'll see an intrusion of dry
won't see those until- later in the week and the early
-
part of next week for the recovery area as another
(No response.)
- east .
NATIONAL HURRICANE CENTER: Mr-.Rhode, this
forecast?
(Inaudible.)
time .
anyway.
PATRICK RHODE: Thank you, Max. Please keep
those as far away as possible
I believe that Director Mike Brown may be on
Louisiana, Louisiana?
COLONEL JEFF SMITH: Y e s . This is Col. Jeff
Smith, and I'm going to be very brief because. as you
indicated. we're up to our ears with operational
we finish.
you all are doing for us, and all I would ask is that
block
-
the lake water from coming into that -- back up
(
to move contractors into'that area. but for watching.
Bill?
MR. LOKEY: Okay, I can, Patrick. I'm
- here,
and we've got several critical situations, but I.'11
brief you quickly on what we're trying to do to
-
effort was impacted by the flooding, so they are
13
then to a staging area the State has established. and
on now, Patrick.
(No response.)
-
Anyone from the State of Mississippi?
State --
right
-
up near Biloxi.
L
As far as Harris County, there's one road in
and that's US 49. We're having significant problems
with congestion just trying to get the responders in
and resupply.
affected counties.
PATRICK RHODE : Understood. This is
19
around this table who will speak further to thdse. and
that was the only one that was not damaged as far as
yet?
- hand.
PATRICK RHODE: Understood. Know that we're
operatlons.
(No response.)
VTC .
today? -
down there.
doing that.
Colonel?
- EMAC .
MISSISSIPPI: That's great. As you can see,
help.
it.
-.- - e.- s -.
PATRICK RHODE: Thank you, Florida. Thank
28
(No response.)
Hearing none, let's move on. Texas?
deployment on arrival
. - 4.- -- We have two CH-47 cargo aircraft en route
request.
.. - *.- Q.'. ,
-
30
available. We also have additional four CH-47s
- Texas?
-
(No response.)
- south.
PATRICK RHODE: Tennessee, thank you very
(No response.)
(No response.)
appreciate i t .
(No response.)
immediately go to Region 4
(No response.)
Transportation.
38
As far as other air resources that we've got
We've got three P-3 aircraft that are up. and we've
got two of them that have broken the area down for
-
Louisiana and Mississippi to provide us with safety of
any questions.
- ED BUIEKEMA: Reggie, the question that was
raised by the State of Mississippi bout 1-10 from New
closed.
-
MR. BUIKEMA: Thank you, ESF-1. Are there
any specific questions for ESF-1 at this time?
(No response.)
If not. we'll move on. We've heard a lot of
please?
ready for sites that are going to need those, and they
40