Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ke
Subtheme: Technology and Food security
The Role of Education in Household Food Security: The Case of Smallholder Tea Famers in
Nandi South District, Kenya
1
Langat, B.K., 2Chumba S. K., 1Ngéno V.K., 1Kipsat, M.J., 1Mwakubo, S.M.
1
Department of Agricultural Economics & Resource Management, 2Department of Education &
Policy Studies
Moi University, P.O Box, 1125, Eldoret, Kenya
langatben2002@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT
Despite being 68 percent arable and having a good climate, Nandi South is a maize deficit zone
(GoK, 2005). Population pressure coupled with unfavourable poverty indicators, has led to
competition for limited land resource and impacted negatively on food access in the district. Mostly
affected are the smallholder tea farmers who have continued to convert land to tea production at the
expense of food production. The main objective of this study was to investigate factors influencing
household food security among smallholder tea farmers in Nandi south district. The study focused on
smallholder tea farmers in Nandi South. A survey of 165 households was conducted using a multi-
stage cluster sampling and both questionnaires and interviews. A modified version of translog cost
function was used to model production constraints to household food security. Results showed
supply side constraints influencing household food security among smallholder tea households
include scale of food production, dependency ratio, education and food storage. It is recommended
that policies should be focused on improving scale of food production, education level, employment
and food storage facilities among the smallholder tea households in Nandi south district.
Key Words: Role of education, Food Security, Smallholder Tea Farmers, Nandi South, Kenya
Introduction
A guarantee of household food security requires adequate home production of food and/or adequate
economic and physical access to food. The concept of Food Security has evolved during the last three
decades to include not only food availability, but also economic access to food (Swaminathan, M. S.,
2000). Adequate per capita availability of food is a function of the balance between food production on
one hand, and growth in population and purchasing power, on the other. Underutilization, inefficient or
non-use of available resources and lack of maximum benefits from the available resources
significantly contribute to poor economic conditions in Africa (Rutto, 2008). Smallholder farming
based on low-input and traditional farming practices coupled with rapid population growth have
is estimated that more than 800 million illiterate people today are food insecure. Education is a
fundamental factor in achieving food security for rural populations in developing countries (Burchi,
2006).
There is a general consensus from research findings and among policy makers that the future of food
agricultural production (Bouis and Haddad, 1990; Kennedy, 1988b; Kennedy and Cogill, 1987;
Braun, V., de Haen and Blanken, 1991; Braun, V., Hotchkiss and Immink, 1989; Immink and
Alarcón, 1992, Immink and Alarcon, 1993). However, after several decades of commercialization in
some parts of Africa, there seems to be no significant improvement in economic conditions and food
Most smallholder farmers in Kenya planted tea due to high income it used to fetch, and they left no
room for food crops and other undertakings such as livestock production. The outcome is that the
miserable pay from the cash crop is making it hard for the farmers to put food on the table. With the
global tea industry facing a crisis, farmers in rural areas are unable to cope with the rising cost of
production. This has resulted in frustrations among smallholder tea farmers following a steady
decline in earnings. Since independence, estate smallholder land under tea production has
persistently increased from 21,448 hectares to 141, 316 hectares by 2005 (International Tea
Committee, 2006). Figure 1.1 below demonstrates the general trend that over the years smallholder
farmers have persistently converted more of their land into cash crop production denying food crop
160000
140000
120000
TOTAL HECTARES
100000
80000
60000
40000
20000
0
1963
1979
1965
1967
1969
1971
1973
1975
1977
1981
1983
1985
1987
1989
1991
1993
1995
1997
1999
2001
2003
2005
YEAR
Smallholder tea farmers are fighting hard to survive, as the odds of harsh global economic times
continue to go against them. With sky rocketing production costs, weakening dollar, oversupply of
the commodity on the international market, and dwindling earnings, the future of the tea industry in
Kenya is gradually becoming bleak. Despite being 68 percent arable and having a good climate,
Nandi South is a maize deficit zone (GoK, 2005). Population pressure has led to competition for
limited land resource, and coupled with unfavourable poverty indicators impacted negatively on food
security in the district. While Maize production in 2005 was estimated at 43,767 metric tons
accounting for over 98 percent of the total cereals produced in the district (MOA, 2005), annual
demand for the same period was estimated at 96,823 metric tons (GOK, 2005).
Despite being 68 percent arable and having a good climate, Nandi South is a maize deficit zone
(GoK, 2005). Population pressure has led to competition for limited land resource, and coupled with
unfavourable poverty indicators impacted negatively on food security in the district. While Maize
production in 2005 was estimated at 43,767 metric tons accounting for over 98 percent of the total
cereals produced in the district (MOA, 2005), annual demand for the same period was estimated at
96,823 metric tons (GOK, 2005). This indicates that the district’s own production can only last for
five months resulting in imports from neighboring districts of Nandi North and Uasin Gishu.
Table 1.1 below indicates the trend in land size, output and corresponding demand and prices of
Table 1.1:
Trend in land Size, output and the corresponding demand and prices for maize from
2005-2009 in Nandi East district
Unit 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Total Land size Hectares 23,750 27,474 31,479 14,014 10,000
Maize Output 90 Kg Bag 456,000 812,390 755,496 424,920 250,000
Average Demand 132 Kg/capita 669,500 830,686 845,140 923,156 975,200
Average Price Ksh/2kg Tin 20 30 30 60 80
Source: DAO Nandi East, 2010
From Figure 1.1 land size allocated to maize production has been decreasing drastically, farmers
seem to shift from staple food production to cash crop. From the figure also maize production has
been declining at least for the past four years, hitting the lowest ever in the district in 2009. With the
increasing demand for maize coupled with rising maize prices in the market, household food access
is impacted negatively.
This paper examines the supply side socio-economic constraints to household food security among
smallholder tea farmers in Nandi south district. The paper is subdivided into four sections. Section
one, introduces the background to the problem. Section two contains the materials and methods used.
Section three presents results and discussions while section five gives the conclusions.
Materials and Methods
The choice of a functional form to use is important in all empirical econometric studies. Economic
theory provides mainly generic conditions of specification with little guidance for specifying a
function to describe a particular production process (Hall, 1998). All functional forms implicitly
impose maintained hypotheses on the analysis. This is significant since the outcome of a specific
hypothesis test will depend on the validity of the hypothesis under examination and on the validity of
the maintained hypotheses used in the model (Fuss, et al. 1978).. However, if invalid maintained
hypotheses are imposed, later rejection in a specific hypothesis test may be a consequence of the
invalidity of the maintained hypotheses, rather than of the primary hypothesis that is being tested. It
is therefore useful to work with functional forms that embody few maintained hypotheses (Fuss, et
al. 1978).
The functional forms that may be chosen to model producer behavior include: Cobb-Douglas
((Strauss, 1986, Varian, 1987), CES (Arrow et al., 1961, Denny 1974), Leontief functions (Fuss,
1977, Hall, 1973) and Translog functions (Christiansen, Jorgenson, and Lau, 1971, 1973). Cob-
Douglas function is commonly used in modeling producer behavior. It is the simplest, but at the
same time, the most restrictive functional form. The maintained hypothesis of a model based on a
Cobb-Douglas production, cost, or profit function is that the elasticities of substitution between input
pairs are equal to unity for all input pairs over the entire input space. It is this property of Cobb-
Douglas functions, among others, that has led econometric modelers to seek more flexible forms
(Zaloshnja, 1997). Another simple but somewhat less restrictive function used in empirical studies is
the Constant Elasticity of Substitution (CES) function. This function is less restrictive than the Cobb-
Douglas because elasticities of substitution between input pairs, although they remain constant over
the entire input space; they are not constrained to equal one. On the other hand, while the Cobb-
Douglas is very convenient for econometric estimation, the CES function is difficult to estimate
because it is non-linear in parameters. The Leontief production function is easy to estimate since
only factor shares are needed to estimate the function, but limited input substitution restrict its
applicability.
Translog functional forms are of more recent vintage and belong to a class of flexible functional
forms (Zaloshnja, 1997). They are pliant enough to capture all the distinct economic effects (Hall,
1998). The translog production function and the translog cost function do not generally correspond to
the same technology, although they can be regarded as close approximations for the same
function mathematically (Christensen, et al 1973). The translog cost function has the advantage of
Thus, the Translog cost function is most useful in studies of factor demand and product supply.
an arbitrary cost function (Christiansen et al 1973, Banda, and Verdugo, 2007). A more general
specification of the translog cost function imposes no prior restriction on the production structure. It
does not impose neutrality, homotheticity, homogeneity, constant returns to scale, or unitary
1
ln 𝐶 = 𝛼0 + 𝛼𝑖 ln 𝑃𝑖 + 𝛾𝑖𝑗 ln 𝑃𝑖 ln 𝑃𝑗 + 𝛼𝑦 ln 𝑄
2
𝑖=1 𝑖=1 𝑗 =1
1
+ 𝛾𝑦𝑦 (ln 𝑄)2 + 𝛾𝑖𝑗 ln 𝑃𝑖 ln 𝑄, (1)
2
𝑖=1
Where 𝑖, 𝑗 = 1, … … . . , 𝑁 index of the N different inputs considered and 𝛾𝑖𝑗 = 𝛾𝑖𝑗 , 𝐶 is total cost, Q is
output and Pi’s are the prices of the factor inputs. A well behaved cost function must be
homogeneous of degree one in prices, meaning that, for fixed level of output, total cost must increase
proportionally when all prices increase proportionally Verdugo, L.E.B, 2007. Therefore, the
Homotheticity means that the cost function can be written as a separable function of output and
factor prices (Truett et al, 1994, Banda H. S and Verdugo, L.E.B, 2007). For homotheticity,
𝛾𝑖𝑦 = 0, ∀𝑖 (4)
If the elasticity of cost with respect to output is constant, then the cost function will be homogeneous
Following Shepard’s Lemma, the derived demand for an input is obtained by partially differentiating
the cost function with respect to input prices to obtain cost-share equations as follows:
𝜕 ln 𝐶 𝑃𝑖 𝜕𝐶 𝑃𝑖 𝑋𝑖
= = = 𝛼𝑖 + 𝛾𝑖𝑗 ln 𝑃𝑗 + 𝛾𝑖𝑗 ln 𝑄, (6)
𝜕ln𝑃𝑖 𝐶 𝜕𝑃𝑖 𝐶
𝑗 =𝑖
Where
𝑃𝑖 𝑋𝑖
𝑃𝑖 𝑋𝑖 = 𝐶. if 𝑆𝑖 ≡ , then 𝑆𝑖 = 1 (7)
𝐶
𝑖=1 𝑖=1
The necessary restrictions given by (3.25) and (3. 26) are imposed to the constraint
𝑆𝑖 = 1 (8)
𝑖=1
That implies that only N-1 of share equations in (3.31) is linearly independent.
From the estimated coefficients, we can construct partial elasticities of substitution between two
factors i and j (Uzawa, 1962). Elasticities will help to describe the pattern and degree of
substitutability and complementarity among factors of production for example the percentage change
in factor proportion due to a one-percent change in their relative prices is given by:
𝛾𝑖𝑗
𝜎𝑖𝑗 = +1 for 𝑖 ≠ 𝑗 (9)
𝑆𝑖 𝑆𝑗
Following Nyangweso et al, (2007), the intercept of equation (3.30) is augmented in order to allow
for the influence of household composition, factors of production and environmental factors. The
model is modified by replacing input cost shares 𝑆𝑖 by months of adequate household food
provisioning (MAHFP) reflecting household food availability. The indicator has the advantage of
capturing the combined effects of improved agricultural production, storage, and the household’s
Where
𝑷 ≡ Input prices
X≡ Farm household characteristics, factors of production and environmental factors; these include:
X1 Dependency ratio, the ratio of the total number of children and adults not working to
collage/university=3
X5 Ratio of land on tea: ration of acres of land allocated to tea to that allocated to
food crops.
X6 Geographical location, the location of the household in the district: If household is from
Kaptien cluster =1, from Kosoiywo cluster =2, from Siret cluster=3, from Kaplelmet cluster
X7 Food store: ―1‖ if household owns a food store with stock of food, ―0‖ otherwise
X8 Credit access; ―1‖ if a member of a cooperative society, ―0‖ otherwise.
𝜶, 𝜸, 𝝓 are the parameters to be estimated, while 𝜀 is the error term. During one survey period, input
𝑴𝑨𝑯𝑭𝑷 = 𝛼 + 𝛾 ln 𝑸 + 𝜙𝑿 + 𝜀 (11)
Methodologies
All smallholder tea farm households in Nandi South District were targeted. A multi-stage
proportional-to-size cluster sampling involving four (4) stages was used. Smallholder tea households
owning less than 10 acres of land on tea production were surveyed. Both primary and secondary data
was used. Primary data was collected through a household survey. Household characteristics data
included age, gender, employment, and education level of head of household and household size.
The total arable land owned by each household in acres and the effective area allocated to produce
tea, maize, and other crops, and their respective yields in Kilograms, and Metric tons. Input
quantities in Kilograms and prices in Kenyan Shillings of the respective enterprises. Quantities of
input use in production included labour; both family and hired labour, fertilizer, seeds, pesticides and
weeding and ploughing costs. Data on other off-farm and on-farm income generating activities was
also collected from the households. Savings, access to credit facilities, and cooperative membership
of the household head. Geographical location and distance to the nearest market in Kilometers. The
secondary data was obtained by perusing annual agricultural reports, economic surveys, statistical
abstracts and development plans. Both interviews and questionnaires were used as instruments for
data collection. Interviews were used to supplement the questionnaires. Household surveys were
administered using the questionnaires while interviews were used on key informants in the district.
and key informants in the division. The instrument was then reviewed and corrected as necessary.
Five enumerators were recruited and trained to assist in administering the questionnaires on
households. The survey questions were numerically coded and responses stored in computer
spreadsheet software, Microsoft Excel Version 2007. Descriptive statistics such as bar charts,
histograms and measures of central tendency were used to describe existing relationships between
household variables. Multiple regression analysis was used to estimate factors influencing household
food security among smallholder tea farmers in Nandi South District Kenya from the survey data
using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 16.0 software. Before the analysis, key
Table 1 shows Education distribution across the sampled households in the district.
Table 2 : Education distribution across households
Frequency Percent
PRE-PRI/PRIMARY 84 51.2
SECONDARY/VOCATIONAL 48 29.3
COLLEGE/UNIVERSITY 32 19.5
Total 164 100.0
Source: Author’s Survey Data, 2009
Results (table 2) show that about 51.2 percent of respondents had pre-primary/ primary education,
29.3 percent had vocational/secondary training while 19.5 percent had college/university level of
education. The results indicate that majority of the household heads in Nandi South have basic level
of education. Those with post secondary education would be expected to engage in off-farm
employment with extra and regular sources of income cushioning households from food insecurity.
Therefore food security of households whose main source of income is farming is dependent on
resources they command. Figure Error! No text of specified style in document.: Show the
Results show that he persons responsible for food preparation in the sample indicate that 73 percent
of the respondents are knowledgeable of balanced diet with only 27 percent not having basic
knowledge of what a balanced diet is. The implication is that food security programs should focus on
improving the household purchasing power rather than knowledge base on nutrition.
To estimate production side constraints, months of adequate household food provisioning index
(MAHP) was used as a modification of the dependent variable of translog cost function. Months of
adequate household food provisioning (MAHFP) indicator is used as a proxy indicator to measure
household food availability throughout the year. Results for production side constraints are presented
in Table 3.
significantly influenced household food security among smallholder tea households. Gender, land
size, geographical location, ratio of land under tea production and access to credit did not have
significant influence on household food security. All the variables, however, had the expected signs.
We reject the hypothesis that socioeconomic factors do not significantly influence household food
It is plausible that the scale of food production since an increase in the scale of food production
ensures sufficient supply of food over a longer period of time. Dependency ratio had a negative and
imply low household labour supply and consequently low food output. Dependency ratio implies that
household food demand is higher compared to those responsible for supply of the same.
Education level of the head of head of household significantly influenced the household food
provisioning with expected positive sign (Table 2). This imply that households with highly educated
heads of households are not likely to experience food insecurity compared to those households
whose heads are less educated. With better education heads of households can make better decisions
and they are likely to be competent, efficient in resource allocation and adaptive to modern
technology. Consequently they realize more output from both food and cash crops resulting in better
food provisioning. Besides, educated heads of households are likely to be employed with steady off-
farm income. Increased income affords households to purchase enough and quality inputs used in
Food store also had a positive and significant influence on household food provisioning. This implies
that households who own food stores with food stock guarantee consistent supply of food throughout
the year. Gender, land size and access to credit were not significant but with expected signs.
Goals (MDGs). However hunger targets have been noted to be the worst performing of all the MDGs
(UN, 2009). Education level of the resource constrained farmers is one of the reasons why
millennium development goals will not be attained by the year 2015. Supply side constraints
influencing household food security among smallholder tea households included scale of food
Farmers’ education plays a central role in food security. Therefore, government should promote
informal adult education among the resource constraint famers. Current formal education facilities in
the district should be improved also. Ministry of agriculture should complement this with intensive
and effective extension education program. The ratio of extension personnel to that of famers should
be increased by government. It is also recommended that farmers be taught how to utilize the
Acknowledgement
I would like to thank Dr. Sulo, Mr. Nyangweso, Mark Korir, Vincent Ngéno and Dr. Kipsat and
other colleagues for their tireless support in writing this paper. I also appreciate Moi University
References
Arrow, Kenneth J., Hurwicz, L. and Uzawa, H., (1961), "Constraint qualifications in
household resource allocation and nutrition in the Philippines, Research Report No.79,
Guatemala: effects on production, income and nutrition. Research Report No. 73.
Braun, V. J., de Haen, H. & Blanken, J., (1991) Commercialization of agriculture under
Report No. 85, Washington, D.C., International Food Policy Research Institute.
Burchi, F., (2006) Identifying the Role of Education in Socio-Economic Development in:
Christiansen, L.R., Jorgenson D.W, and L.J. Lau (1973) ―Transcendental Logarithmic
Denny, M., (1974) "The Relationship Between Functional Forms for the Production System,"
Canadian Journal of Economics, Canadian Economics Association, vol. 7(1), pages 21-31,
February.
Fuss, M., McFadden, D. and Mundalk, Y. (1978) "A Survey of Functional Forms in the
Economic Analysis of Production".
GoK (2005) Nandi District Development Plan for 2002-2008-Kenya’s International Trade,
Facts and figures 2004/2006.
Hall H. H., (1998) Choosing an Empirical Production Function: Theory, Nonnested
Immink, M.D.C. & Alarcón, J.A. (1993) Household Income, Food Availability and
consumption effects in Kenya, Food Policy Volume 13, Issue 1, Pages 104-105,
Kennedy, E.T. & Cogill, B., (1987) Income and nutritional effects of the commercialization of
Rutto W., (2008) Commercialization of Smallholder Production: Key to Food Security, The
Strauss, J., (1986) ―Appendix: The Theory and Comparative Statics of Agricultural Household
Models: A General Approach.‖ In Inderjit J. Singh, Lyn Squire and John Strauss (eds.),
Swaminathan, M. S, (2000) Global Food Security for Tomorrow; The United Nations and
Varian, H. R, 3rd edition (1992) Microeconomic Analysis, New York, W.W. Norton and
Company.
Policy Improvement.