You are on page 1of 191

ACTA ARCHAEOLOGICA Vol.

76; 1, 2005
ACTA ARCHAEOLOGICA SUPPLENIENTA VI
CliXT"E O F W O R L D A R C H A E O L O G Y (Cltil) - PUBLICATIONS 2

LIGA
COPPER AGE STRATEGIES IN BULGARIA

Fieldwork carried out under the Auspecies of


Vincislav Gergov, Telish Museum &' Havs Randsborg, Universip of Copenhagen

Edited by Havs Randsborg

INGA MERKYTE
with contributions by
SBREN ALBEK, JESPER SBRENSEN BSTERGAARD & PETAR ZIDAROV
supported by
Maya Dimitrova, Rumen Peykov & fieldworkers

BLACKWELL MUNKSGAARD
2005
EDITORIAL PREFACE
Excavations and field investigations at the fifth millen- The executive director of the project is Inga Mer-
nium BC settlement of Lı̂ga and other Late Copper kyte, supported in particular by Søren Albek and Jes-
Age sites near Telish in Northern Bulgaria took place per Sørensen Østergård from the Danish side (all of
in 2000, 2001, and 2002. They were based on archae- the Archaeology division, SAXO-Institute, University
ological activities started already in the mid-1940s. of Copenhagen). Merkyte has also been in charge of –
Important excavations were in recent times also car- and herself undertaken – most of the Titanic post-
ried out by Vencislav Gergov of Telish Museum, the excavation work, as well as several in depth techno-
local collaborator and gracious co-director of the logical and other analyses extending to extensive
present project. However, only little information on comparative studies, even ethnographical observa-
earlier efforts has been published till date, not even tions. A number of specialists, acknowledged in the
maps of excavation. text, have assisted in various analyses. Unless other-
Maya Dimitrova (Museum of Lovech), Rumen Pey- wise stated, the chapters of the publication are by
kov (Veliko Tarnovo), and Petar Zidarov (Sofia and Merkyte and adhere to the general bibliography at
Tübingen universities) are a few of the many Bulgarian the end of the volume. For reasons of convenience,
collaborators most valuable to the project. Thanks are other contributions have bibliographies of their own.
also addressed to Svilen Makchev, Vania Ivanova, Asia The Lı̂ga Project was carried out by postgraduate
Yordanova, Cvetelin Cvetkov, Nikolaj Kristanov, Rad- and undergraduate students from a variety of aca-
ka Zlateva-Uzunova, and Yulij Stoyanov. Their dedi- demic fields. It demonstrates the international poten-
cation, insight and energy have been indispensable in tial and engagement of an emerging generation of
carrying the huge burden of very hard fieldwork, in- European archaeologists, willing to acquire new skills
cluding detailed recording in the field. Very many in languages, archaeological science, and organiza-
other Bulgarians participated, students, assistants, and tion, and having the audacity to put these to work in
local workers, lead by the indefatigable veteran of the new fields. Lı̂ga is also one of the most detailed settle-
campaigns, ‘‘Bai Ivan’’ (Ivan Ivanov, aged 74). Grati- ment excavations ever in the Balkans. It has revealed
tude also goes to the ‘‘Sofia families’’ of the Danes, Pet- stunning results in terms of household organization
ia & Emo Stoyanovs and Bogdana, Nikola & Mariana and social life in the Copper Age. The data are ex-
Zidarovs and the ‘‘Telish one’’ of the Todor & Rumi- tremely plentiful and rich due to exceptional con-
ana Petkovs, all making stays most agreeable and ditions of find. In almost all areas are important new
helped solve many problems. observations, including a cemetery from the Copper
From the Danish side, the undersigned accepted to Ageπ. A particular feature is individuality of taste,
act as director of the project and later on as executive revealed between contemporary households. This fact
editor of the publication. Funding was critical. The alone is a challenge to traditional ceramic chron-
Munksgaard Foundation, Copenhagen provided cru- ology – the latter tending to read ‘‘time’’ into diver-
cial support, but heavy financial burdens of both ex- sity. Indeed, Lı̂ga demonstrates the particular utility
cavation and post-excavation work were covered of digging well and having a wide perspective of
mainly privately by the Danish participants. V. Ger- things.
gov accepted a honorarium, while the other partici- It is hoped that Lı̂ga will become a reference point
pants worked for only a limited (Bulgarians) or no in Balkan archaeological research; although a small
salary at all (Danes). Centre of World Archaeology site, and a limited excavation, it is of European sig-
(CWA, www.worldarchaeology.net), with Acta Ar- nificance, not least because of its location on the
chaeologica, provided the means of publication, sup- ‘‘Bridge to Europe’’ in the crucial fifth millennium
ported by the Beckett-foundation, Copenhagen (with BC. The Danes are very grateful for their Bulgarian
a late unquoted donation for Acta Archaeologica link and collaboration, which incorporate many indi-
75:1, 2004). viduals and institutions, including the Institute of Ar-
6 Acta Archaeologica

chaeology, Sofia, and are reaching government levels, the Bulgarian National Museum, sponsored by the
including the former Bulgarian minister of culture, Danish Foreign Ministry.
Ivan Marazov, a friend. In 2000, the Queen of Den-
mark, Margrethe II opened an exibition on Lı̂ga at Klavs Randsborg
I. INTRODUCTION
History may be a myth, but artefacts, which are historical looked’’ in terms of larger Copper Age research pro-
events, are not. They are signifiers, becoming myths as we jects, the latter focusing on the classical tell areas,
interpret them with our words.
J.D. Prown 1996:26, rephrased.
such as the Thracian plain or Northeastern Bulgaria.
Tells are few in NW Bulgaria and studies of temporal
change consequently less straightforward. The ma-
jority of settlement investigations in the region have
THE PROJECT produced a mass of isolated phenomena, which can
The Lı̂ga-project originated in 1999, when the core only be grouped with the help of one or another par-
Danish archaeologists of the project from the Univer- ticular type of ceramic vessel. Therefore, a site for
sity of Copenhagen were guest students at Sofia’s excavation was chosen in a particular sub-area, which
State University, Bulgaria. The supposed ‘‘Tran- perhaps has seen the most substantial research in NW
sitional period’’, covering the gap between the Chal- Bulgaria. The idea was to piece all available evidence
colithic period (or, rather, the Copper Age) and the together, focus on a highly detailed excavation, and
Bronze Age, was one of the issues then discussed. recreate the use of the landscape in the Copper Age
Lack of finds and excavations, confusing C-14 dates, as chains of large and small movements of people,
etc. did not help in finding an answer to the problems. their ideas and actions.
For a scholar with Scandinavian background this
seemed to have an extra dimension, since the ‘‘Tran-
sitional period’’ in Bulgaria was also a transitional THE SITE
period in Danish prehistory – the transition from for- LOCATION: GEOGRAPHY AND GEOLOGY
agers to farmers, indeed from Ertebølle to Tragtbæ- The archaeological site of Lı̂ga (Bulgarian for ‘‘Graz-
ger (TRB)/Funnel Beaker culture. Interaction with ing Fields’’, or pastures) is situated about one kilo-
Bulgarian archaeologists raised aspirations to seek metre north of the modern village of Telish in Cherv-
solutions by taking action. en Briag Municipality, Pleven County (Fig. I.1). The
Northwestern Bulgaria (together with the Rhodop- first major archaeological investigation in the area
es) is considered to be the part of Bulgaria where was undertaken at the nearby Late Copper Age settle-
Copper Age culture survived the longest. Ironically, it ment of Redutite (‘‘Redoubts’’ – the Turkish army de-
is also the part of the country that has been ‘‘over- fending the area in 1877), on the eastern fringes of
Telish. The Turks constructed a lunette at Redutite,
which was at first acknowledged as an archaeological
site during attempts to reconstruct the bastion in 1976
(Neikov 2001). V. Gergov, then of Pleven Regional
Historical Museum, started the excavations in Redut-
ite in 1977. In 1979, he undertook several trench-
surveys in the area. The aim was primarily to gather
information for the Archaeological Map of Bulgaria.
As a result, he found rich graphite-painted pottery at
Lı̂ga, 1.2 km north of Redutite, indicating the pres-
ence of yet another Late Copper Age settlement.
The site of Lı̂ga is situated at the edge of a broad
plateau, 20 m high and 195 m above sea level (Fig.
I.2 & I.3). The Redutite site is located on the same
plateau. Towards southwest and northeast the plateau
Fig. I.1. Geographical position of Telish in Bulgaria. has a wavy appearance. The hillock chosen for the
10 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. I.2. Lı̂ga site (↓), view from SW.

Fig. I.3. Lı̂ga site, view from the North.


Lı̂ga 11

Lı̂ga settlement is delimited by ravines in the south chernozems prevail. These have good water retention
and north, which were created during seasonal runoff and humus contents ranging between 3.00 and
of water. This process is still ongoing and has made 3.55%; they are basically considered highly fertile so-
a negative, though limited, impact on the preser- ils (Neikov 2001). The leached form of chernozems
vation of the archaeological remains at the slopes. was most likely also easily accessible with prehistoric
The topography of the whole region is characterized ploughing techniques.
by a series of plateaus, generated by tectonic block The immediate vicinity of the Lı̂ga site is character-
fractures (Hansen 2000). These are usually running ised by two types of soils. The site itself is situated on
from East to West, determining the dynamics of the an area of the forest soils, which are considered too
distribution of settlement. The North-South orien- heavy to till with prehistoric technology (Dennell &
tation of the regional river flows is also making an Webley 1975). It can be assumed that this area would
impact on settlement patterns. The edges of the pla- have supported forest vegetation and been used for
teaus have been favoured by settlers throughout pre- browsing and acquisition of winter fodder (Dennell &
history, especially during the Late Copper Age. Webley 1975). The soils to the West of the site, across
At the foot of the site there used to be stream. the stream, had a higher sand component and were
However, from 1960–1963 onwards, with the cre- superbly suited for prehistoric crop cultivation.
ation of a local irrigation system, the water of the
stream is collected behind three dams in what is
known as the Lake of Gorni Dabnik (Neikov 2001). CLIMATE
Topographic features indicate that the stream was The climate in Bulgaria is shaped by two adjacent
running towards the north and was part of the catch- major water basins – the Black Sea and the Mediter-
ment area of the Vit. Rivers Vit and Iskar are the two ranean Sea – and, by the ranges of mountains, which
major tributaries of the Danube in the region; they direct or block the movement of air masses. The
are also framing the archaeological sites at Telish. Black Sea and especially the Mediterranean Sea have
The distance to the rivers is about 8 km. River Iskar great water heat accumulation capacites (Issar 2003).
also distinguishes itself by being a major access route This enables the basins to act as temperature regu-
through the Balkan Range. It is runnning in deeply lators of the overall region (Issar 2003). Telish belongs
cut valleys forming gorges, which even today are one to the Danubian hilly plain, which encompasses
of the few transport corridors of the North-South axis. heights between 30 and 200 m above sea level, but is
The area of Telish is also rich in subsurface springs. cut off from these favourable effects by the range of
An 8–10 m thick layer of clay, grey in colour, is the Balkan Mountains. Compared with other regions
making up the upper part of the plateau at Telish. in Bulgaria, the Danubian hilly plain is the coolest
The seasonal erosion of the slopes at the riverbed one, open to chilly Continental winds/air streams
made access to these clay deposits readily available. from North and Northeast (Dimitrov 1979).
The remains of an old bridge, ca. 15 m long, dis- The lowest winter temperatures are reaching minus
covered some 30 m south of the settlement, indicate 30–35 æC, the mean temperature in January being
the site of a wedge. All this is suggesting that access around minus 1 æ (GHCN). By contrast, summer tem-
to freshwater and clay, the main building materials, peratures are the highest in the country. Due to the
together with an easy route across the stream were low altitude, spring is coming early to the region (in
critical in choosing the exact settlement site. mid-March the temperature of the soil is more than
The present variety of soil types in the surround- 5 æC 5–10 cm below surface, and by the 10th of
ings of Telish is also encompassing small patches of April – above 10 æC) (Dimitrov 1979). Autumn is also
alluvial soils, moderately to intensely leached cherno- arriving at the same extended pace.
zems (characteristic of lower altitudes), dark brown In terms of winds, the villagers of Telish are notic-
grey to grey forest soils (characteristic of higher alti- ing that wind directions are affecting the climate; the
tudes, i.e., the plateaus) and, occasionally, islands of population has even created a local etymology to de-
degraded loess (Neikov 2001). Moderately leached scribe the cold western wind and the warm southern
12 Acta Archaeologica

one (Neikov 2001). In wintertime, western winds pre- in a chain of events that caused the termination of
vail. In the summer, winds are mostly blowing from the Copper Age culture.
the West or the North. The effect of the winds is more
extreme on the plateau where the archaeological sites
are situated than in the modern village, lying in the THE COPPER AGE AND ITS CULTURAL
depressed plain. AFFILIATIONS
Indeed, plotting temperature data collected during Use of the term ‘‘Chalcolithic’’ (rather than ‘‘Aeneol-
the period 1951–1990 (GHCN), it can be demon- ithic’’ or ‘‘Copper Age’’), when describing roughly the
strated that the regions of Pleven and Vraca – with time-span between 5000 and 4000 BC, has become
the largest concentration of sites of the Krivodol-Săl- common in Bulgarian writings. Still, the term ‘‘Cop-
cuţa-Bubanj Hum Ia culture, to which Lı̂ga belongs – per Age’’ seems a slightly more handy one and will
are making up a veritable ‘‘depression of cold’’ in the be used here, while the notion of Chalcolithic cultures
winter. The regions have the lowest mean January is also accepted – semantics nonewithstanding.
temperatures in the country (only lowlands were con- In a publication of 1948 by J.H. Gaul, written after
sidered, below 400 m in altitude), namely ª0.9 æC his research in the Balkans, mainly Bulgaria, in 1938–
and ª1.0 æC, respectively. The situation only im- 1939 (and published after his death in 1945, when
proves South of Sofia and East of Ruse/Osam, where shot by Germans as a prisoner of war), this author
the mean January temperatures are above freezing. argues in favour of use of the term ‘‘Chalcolithic’’ as
To what extent this information can be transferred opposed to ‘‘Late Neolithic’’ (Gaul 1948, 79). Gaul
to the Copper Age is too early to say. The pattern was was basing his arguments on the presence of natural
perhaps similar, but the effects of generally warmer copper in Bulgaria and on the plentiful copper im-
climatic conditions – peaking during the climatic opti- plements in the Gumelniţa culture (or ‘‘Bulgarian
mum around 3800 BC – might have made the differ- Mound Culture’’). During the late 1940s, knowledge
ences less perceptible (e.g., in terms of grazing poten- of sites which later became attributed to the western
tial during wintertime). Krivodol culture was still limited. Gaul was men-
More dramatic to Copper Age peoples were the tioning Okol Glava, northwest of the village of Gnily-
consequences of the Black Sea transgression (Todoro- ane and finds from the caves of Morovica and De-
va 1989). By the end of the Copper Age (Phase Varna vetaki (Devetashkata). At the time, material from
III), the level of the Black Sea was lower than at pres- these sites was treated as being part of the ‘‘Bulgarian
ent. H. Todorova’s excavations in Durankulak at the Mound Culture’’, but intuitively Gaul had grouped
Bulgarian coast have thus demonstrated that the the representative finds in the same plate (Plate
water level there was 1 m lower than today. Further LXIV) of the publication. Staying in the Balkans, he
to the south, at Sozopol and Ropotamo, still on the also became acquainted with finds from Bubanj,
coast, water tables were between 3 and 5 meters stored at the museum in Niš and providing him with
lower than today (Todorova 1998). Such differences an opportunity to establish parallels between Okol
were, supposedly, related to tectonic movements Glava and Bubanj (Gaul 1948, 108). The author
caused by rapid melting of the Arctic ice (Todorova rightly concluded that ‘‘the interrelations of our
1998). Mound Culture [ΩGumelniţa] are swiftly observable
According to H. Todorova, the highest water table on the one hand, and on the other, seem to merge
compared to the present one is dated to the end of into as yet unsatisfactorily defined peripheral com-
5th millennium BC and later, reaching a maximum plexes’’ (Gaul 1948, 105).
around 3500 BC. Gradual climatic warming trans- Knowledge about the late Copper Age started to
formed the favourable conditions, experienced by the accumulate rapidly during the post-war period. The
early agricultural communities in the Balkans, into development was paralleled in Romania, Bulgaria
environmental deterioration by droughts and flood- and Serbia. The eponymic site of Krivodol was partly
ings of the fertile plains (Todorova 1998). Thus, excavated in 1946 by V. Mikov (Mikov 1948). He
changing climate is seen as the first ‘‘Domino piece’’ recognised the presence of a Late Roman fortress
Lı̂ga 13

(hence the local name of the site: ‘‘Tepeto’’ or ‘‘Kale- Medieval times. Two shallow moats, ca. 1.0 m and
to’’) on top of thick debris formed during the Copper 1.2 m deep, were dug across the western land bridge
Age. The landscape at Krivodol is indeed dramatic. during settlement phase IIb.
The steep hill where the site is located is practically In Serbia, close to Niš, M. Garašanin started sys-
unapproachable from three surrounding sides. The tematic excavations of Bubanj after earlier trench sur-
only access is across a northern land bridge. At the veys by A. Oršić-Slavetić in 1934 (Garašanin 1957).
foot, River Botunya is running. Concerned with the The excavations continued from 1954 to 1958 (Gara-
management of loose soils, Mikov chose to put his šanin 1957, 1976). The site is situated on a protruding
excavation trenches in the western periphery of the tongue-like plateau, 195 m above sea level, on the left
site. Due to natural landslide, he discovered 8 or 9 bank of Nišava. The cultural layers had a thickness
building horizons. These observations were later cor- of 2.50–3.16 m and contained also Early Neolithic
rected by repeated excavation by B. Nikolov (Nikolov Stračevo finds. The most import result was a subdivi-
1984). The latter subdivided the discovered prehis- sion of the recognized building horizons into phases
toric cultural remains (of 2.4 to 2.8 m in thickness) Ia (Late Copper Age), Ib and II (Early Bronze Age
into 5 building horizons, all belonging to the Late phases Baden-Kostolać and Coţofeni III) & III (Glina
Copper Age. Each main settlement burned down. III of the MBA) (1). A neighbouring site, Velika Hum-
Both Mikov and Nikolov mentioned the existence of ska Čuka, a hill-top settlement, was excavated
fortifications (a stone wall supported by a frame of synchronously with Bubanj. The recovered evidence
wooden poles) on the site in the Copper Age. echoes the findings in Bubanj (Garašanin 1983).
Subdivision of the well-known Gumelniţa Culture Thus, the composite name, Bubanj-Hum Ia, which is
in Romania started in 1951 after the excavation of often used to denote affiliating cultural phenomena of
the hillock of Piscul Cornişorului close to Sălcuţa by the Late Copper Age in Eastern Serbia.
D. Berciu (1961c). Before him, in 1916, and in 1919– A turning point in correlating available infor-
1920, the site was excavated by I. Andrieşescu, who mation and formulating future research directions oc-
performed the first methodologically sound exca- curred in 1959 at an international symposium in
vation in the country, but failed to publish the results. Czechoslovakia (Böhm & De Laet 1961). The leading
In 1917, C. Schuchhardt made a few trenches at Săl- theme was the Neolithic (and ‘‘Aeneolithic’’) in Eur-
cuţa. All the finds were taken to Berlin but never pub- ope. Among 45 delegates from 17 different countries
lished. In 1947, the site attracted attention from a were scientists who today are justly recognised as the
new team of Romanian archaeologists, but their find- major developers of the present perceptions of cul-
ings were not mediated either. So, all knowledge tural developments during the Neolithic-Eneolithic/
about this important site is based on the four trenches Copper Age in the Southeastern parts of Europe: M.
made by Berciu. Gimbutas (Lithuania/USA), N.Y. Merpert (Russia),
The site is located on a tongue-like hillock, which D. Berciu (Romania), M. Garašanin (Serbia), G.
rises some 25 m above the surrounding valley, thus Georgiev (Bulgaria), and several others. This crucial
‘‘naturally fortified’’. A western land bridge is con- event should thus be considered the birth of the no-
necting it with another hillock. Berciu established sev- tion of ‘‘Krivodol-Sălcuţa-Bubanj Culture’’ (here
eral layers at Sălcuţa. On top of layer I of the Early KSB), presented at the gathering in a short, almost
Neolithic Starčevo-Criş culture was the sterile layer telegram-like statement by Berciu (1961b). His obser-
of a hiatus. Above this was found horizon II, subdi- vations made on the characteristics of this cultural
vided into a, b, and c sub-phases. This horizon, to- unit are still correct. Berciu defined the area of the
gether with the following horizon III, marks the end KSB culture as NW Bulgaria, S Romania (Oltenia,
of the Copper Age. Materials from these layers define Eastern Banat) and E Serbia (to Pelagonia and Skopje
the Sălcuţa culture. The last, more or less well defined in the F.R.Y. Macedonia). During the symposium,
phase is horizon IV; this represents the early phase of
the post-Chalcolithic period. Later surface finds at the 1. For the sake of uniformity, the chronological division accepted
site span from the end of the Early Bronze Age till in Bulgaria is applied in the text, cf. Fig. I.5.
14 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. I.4. Main Late Copper Age cultural complexes in Southeastern Europe, according to Todorova and Vajsov (Todorova & Vajsov 2001),
slightly modified.

Berciu also presented his attempts to make the first remains from NW Bulgaria. The valley of Struma, in
correlation of materials from the Sălcuţa, Krivodol, SW Bulgaria, is under the direct influence of KSB,
Bubanj and Gumelniţa sites (1961a). albeit the latter region is also marked by other cul-
tural impulses. The southernmost known site of the
KSB culture in Bulgaria is Vaksevo-Skaleto (Čochad-
PROFILE OF THE KSB CULTURE žiev 2001). In Romania, this cultural group is mainly
The KSB is considered a late Copper Age cultural spread in Oltenia, up to the river Olt, but also known
group, which primarily is recognized through cultural in a narrow strip of W Muntenia (the left bank of the
Lı̂ga 15

Olt and the southern part of Argeş county) and in SE painted (Todorova 1986). Among the distinctive
Banat (the county of Caras Severin), or, shortly, in forms of the Romanian Sălcuţa culture, according to
Southwestern Romania. In Yugoslavia, KSB is spread Berciu, are two-handled cups, small squat cups and
in the Eastern part of Serbia but its influence is also bowls with thickened and inverted rims; decoration
identified in Kosovo, as well as in Macedonian Pela- includes graphite painting and colour incrustation
gonia (Tasić & Tasić 2003). In Eastern Serbia the (Berciu 1961c).
neighbour of KSB to the West is Vinča D. In Ro- Thus, the description of KSB pottery is reflecting
mania and Bulgaria, KSB is bordering towars the different scholarly attitudes towards variations and
East on a big cultural complex termed Kodžadermen- characteristics. The margins in E Serbia are rather
Gumelniţa-Karanovo VI (KGK VI), and Varna (Fig. wide, and any shard with graphite paint would be
I.4). considered as belonging to KSB, while in Bulgaria,
What then is separating the KSB culture from the where graphite painted pottery is prevailing from
neighbouring cultural groups? the coast to the Rila Mountains and beyond, the
In former Yugoslavia, the priority when defining definitions are stricter. Intuition is often at help in
Bubanj-Hum sites was given to their topographic po- the non-written world of semi-conscious filtering of
sition. The settlements were usually found on nat- overlapping cultural traits. Generally, the ceramic
urally protected elevations, or, in caves. Thus, a site assemblage of KSB is defined by vessels with op-
on top of Skopje hill is considered as the most western positely placed handles, which are a rarity in the
KSB outpost. The settlers of the Vinča culture, by KGK VI complex, and dominance of positive
contrast, were linked to multi-layered tell settlements. graphite decoration, also rare in KGK VI, where
Tells are also the prevailing settlement type in the negative patterns overwhelmingly prevail (Todorova
Kodžadermen-Gumelniţa-Karanovo VI (KGK VI) 1986).
culture. Exceptions comprise settlements on pile plat- There are apparently no discussions as to the be-
forms, such as Negovantsi and Krainitsi, in the KSB ginning of the Copper Age in Bulgaria (Fig. I.5).
area, and the so-called plateau settlements in the Thus, the temporal division suggested by B. Nikolov
KGK VI area (Todorova 1986). There have been sev- has so far not been debated (Nikolov 1992). The
eral attempts to define some of the KSB settlements earliest sub-phase is by this author named after the
as tells (Todorova 1986; Nikolova 1999); the issue Brenitsa site, and the subsequent two after the Grade-
rests solely on special definitions and will be further shnitsa site (Nikolov 1992). The middle Copper Age
discussed below. remains somewhat ephemeral, with only Dyakovo site
Pottery styles and decorations are thought to be the as representative in the Struma valley (Todorova
most reliable trait in defining cultural regions. Garaš- 1986; Čohadžiev 1997). In general, there are no dis-
anin defines the characteristic pottery of Bubanj-Hum putes in considering the KSB as the successor of the
as fine, highly polished, and made from micaseous Gradeshnitsa culture (Georgieva 1995b). It is also be-
clays (1976). The characteristic shapes are cups, jars lieved that the KSB culture was formed in Western
with two handles, and beakers (so-called ‘‘kantharoi’’), Bulgaria around the middle of the 5th millennium
as well as voluminous amphoras (Garašanin 1976). and then spread northwards and westwards (Georgie-
Discussing pottery of the Krivodol culture in Bulgar- va 1995b). Therefore, the earliest sites are known only
ia, Todorova notes that the most conspicuous feature in Bulgaria. The later development of the culture has
is the high amount of cups with double handles, pots recently become a subject of numerous discussions,
and jars with narrowed neck and two or four handles, resulting in a variety of chronological schemes (e.g.,
bowls with inverted or thickened rim, biconic vessels, Nikolova 1999). Georgieva has demonstrated that in
plugs for oven, and fire-vessels (cf. below) (Todorova terms of macro-regional trends, the most plausible
1986). The surface is often roughened with the help solution is to view KSB as undergoing four phases of
of barbotine, impressions, incisions or pinched decor- development (Georgieva 1995b). A rapid increase in
ation. Graphite paint is applied on vessel neck or the number of sites is seen during phases II–IV. This
shoulders, in case of bowls the whole interior is often is also the time when the cultural impact of this cul-
16 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. I.5. Chronological table with key sites discussed in the text and main cultural groupings. Grey colour marks the period and sites with
affiliation to the Krivodol-Sălcuţa-Bubanj Hum Ia complex (KSB).

ture advances towards Eastern Serbia and Oltenia definition of two main KSB phases. The boundary is
(Georgieva 1995b) (Fig. I.6). made between sites with painted pottery (graphite or
Eastern Serbia and the regions further west were white or red pigments) and those, which are lacking
the last to experience KSB impact. This is indirectly such decoration (Tasić 1990; 1995; Lazić & Sladić
confirmed by the lack of sites with more than one 1997). Apparently, there is still a lack of consensus on
KSB occupation (as opposed to the multi-horizonal which phase should be seen as the earliest (Tasić
settlements in Bulgaria). The stylistic analyses of pot- 1990; 1995; Lazić & Sladić 1997), creating some con-
tery from the discovered KSB sites, to some extent fusion as to whether Bubanj-Hum Ia, with graphite
supported by stratigraphic data, have resulted in the painted ceramics, represents the first or the second
Lı̂ga 17

Fig. I.6. Distribution of investigated KSB Ia sites (dots). 1 – Kolarovo, 2 – Piperitsa, 3 – Drenovitsa, 4 – Sandanski, 5 – Kochan,
6 – Dragodan, 7 – Vaksevo, 8 – Yunatsite, 9 – Dolna Koznitsa, 10 – Kraynitsi, 11 – Mala Fucha, 12 – Izvor, 13 – Negovantsi, 14 – Radomir,
15 – Pernik-Krakra, 16 – Dushintsi, 17 – Gnilyane-Okol Glava, 18 – Gulubovtsi-Pekliuk, 19 – Teteven-Morovitsa cave, 20 – Rebarkovo-
Mı̂zhin grad, 21 – Rebarkovo-Dzhugera, 22 – Mezdra, 23 – Lovech, 24 – Staro Selo-Yordanovo Kale, 25 – Gorna Kremena-Izvoro,
26 – Gorna Kremena-Zaminec, 27 – Kunino, 28 – Aglen-Ochilata cave, 29 – Kameno Pole, 30 – Devetaki Cave, 31 – Cherven Breg,
32 – Sadovec-Ezero, 33 – Sadovec-Kaleto, 34 – Sadovec-Golemanovo Kale, 35 – Pipra, 36 – Gabare-Marla, 37 – Gabare-Dolnoto Kale,
38 – Telish-Redutite, 39 – Banitsa-Milin Kamak, 40 – Telish-Lı̂ga, 41 – Bukovec-Zanogata, 42 – Okhoden, 43 – Georgi-Damyanovo-
Markovo Kale, 44 – Krivodol, 45 – Barkachevo-Kanov Vrakh, 46 – Rakevo-Chuljov kamak, 47 – Galatin-Chukata, 48 – Belotintsi-
Kremenish, 49 – Okhrid, 50 – Montana, 51 – Lesura-Golata Mogila, 52 – Lesura-Gradishteto, 53 – Malorad, 54 – Beli Bryag-Markov
Kamak, 55 – Lekhchevo-Kostadin, 56 – Lipnitsa, 57 – Krushovitsa-Borovanska Mogila, 58 – Sofronievo-Daneva Mogila, 59 – Yakimovo-
Mogilata, 60 – Miziya, 61 – Staliyska Makhala-Bagachina, 62 – Makresh, 63 – Slatina, 64 – Ostrovul Corbului, 65 – Baile Herculane-
Hoţilor Cave, 66 – Girla Mare, 67 – Vadastra, 68 – Sălcuţa, 69 – Humska Chuka, 70 – Bubanj, 71 – Rudna Glava, 72 – Veljkovo-Kapu
Djaluluj, 73 – Smedovac, 74 – Kovilovo, 75 – Zlotska Pecina, 76 – Krivelj, 77 – Korbovo-Vajaga Pesak, 78 – Hisar, 79 – Gadimilje,
80 – Skopje, 81 – Bakarno Gumno. Squares mark other contemporary sites in the region, mentioned in the text.

stage of KSB development in former Yugoslavia (Laz- REVIEW OF PREVIOUS RESEARCH


ić & Sladić 1997). The relation between KSB sites, The larger region of Telish first came into focus in
especially those of former Yugoslavia, will probably 1934 with the excavations at Sadovec (Fig. I.7). At
remain unresolved until a proper set of absolute dates first, Bulgarian archaeologists, later joined by Ger-
is established. man and Austrian scholars, were investigating Late
18 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. I.7. Satellite map of the Telish region with distribution of known Copper Age sites (etc.).

Antiquity fortifications (6th century AD, as dated by Another important archaeological landmark in
coins) in a vicinity of Sadovec (Welkov 1935; Todoro- Telish region is Pipra, situated 8 km south of the
va Simeonova 1968; Uentze 1992). Of these sites, village. Like the site at Sadovec, Pipra has been val-
Golemanovo Kale also contained prehistoric ma- ued for its natural defensive features; in fact, it was
terial, which later has been subdivided in Late Cop- one of the fortified junctions to protect movement
per Age, Early (Orlea-Sadovec) and Middle (Glina along the Roman road between Oescus (Gigen) and
III) Bronze Age, and Early Iron Age (Hallstatt ma- Stargosia (Pleven) (Neikov 2001). In the early 1970s,
terial) (Todorova 1992; Alexandrov 1992). The site the site was briefly investigated (Gergov, pers.
was occupying a rocky terrace steeply rising to more comm.). It has been established that besides Late
than 20 m above the riverbed of Vit. The site was a Antiquity fortress buildings, spread over an oblong
natural stronghold accessible only from the north. In hill of 65¿35 m, there were traces of an Early Iron
prehistoric times, the location has also been valued Age settlement. Later intensive pitting on the site by
due to abundant resources of flint in the lower part looters has also demonstrated that the central part
of the limestone terrace. holds at least five building horizons, which can be
Lı̂ga 19

Fig. I.8. Sites of Ezero and Kaleto at Sadovec, as seen from E. Note the rampart at Kaleto.

attributed to the Copper Age, primarily the earlier by so-called hiatus layers, which bear witness to sig-
part of the KSB (pers.observation). Significantly, all nificant episodes of abandonment. Hence, the re-
Copper Age settlements seem to have been burned search at Lı̂ga was initially driven by the expectation
down. to fill in these chronological gaps and to trace the
The closest parallel to the settlement at Lı̂ga is dynamics of shifts in settlement in the micro-region.
nearby Redutite, where excavations went on for
nearly 20 years. Separated by the short distance of
only 1.2 km the two sites are not only geographically SADOVEC-EZERO & SADOVEC-KALETO
but also temporally related. Redutite turned out to be During the three fieldwork seasons at Lı̂ga some en-
a well-preserved settlement with four temporal ergy was invested in rescue work at a site, which ap-
phases. The earliest settlement was founded in the peared to hold material from several Copper Age
Early Copper Age (Gradeshnitsa phase), while the settlements. The site was discovered near Sadovec, 7
two subsequent settlements were of late Copper Age, km southeast of Telish, and is actually in two parts: a
and the last one representing the initial phase of the lower and older one named Sadovec-Ezero, and an
so-called Transitional period (Gergov 1992a). No suc- upper and younger called Sadovec-Kaleto (Welkov
cession was recorded between the two Late Copper 1935 (short note); Mitova-Džonova 1979, 61) (Fig.
Age settlements. In fact, all phases were interspaced I.8). Despite the rescue character of this investigation,
20 Acta Archaeologica

soil and vegetation, and no traces of human activity


have left any impact on its appearance. The hillock,
at its highest and most northern point, is approxi-
mately 173 m above the sea level. The range of hills
is rising over the site by 7 m on a northern side and
by more than 15 m on the southern one.
The investigation of the site was initiated during
the summer of 2002 after reports on digs carried on
by very active local looters. The looters had dug three
main trenches reaching rock bottom through cultural
deposits 3.5–4.0 m thick, as well as several other
trenches. The trenches were actually ‘‘archaeological’’
in nature, with vertical profiles, which could easily be
cleaned and studied (Fig. I.9). Six building horizons
were recorded in the largest trench, spanning a full
Copper Age sequence.
Due to the natural remoteness of the site, the con-
ditions of preservation were exceptional. Four of the
settlement horizons had traces of conflagration while
the remaining ones had been left to slow decompo-
sition. Even in layers where clay items were not ex-
posed to fire, their state of preservation was remark-
able (Fig. I.10 & I.11). Among the most important
finds was a burial of a woman, placed in prone posi-
tion in a pit measuring just 65¿45 cm. This event
took place during a period postdating the Copper Age
and presumably before the Early Bronze Age proper.
The two earliest occupation phases of Sadovec-Ez-
ero site are dated to the beginning of the Copper Age.
Fig. I.9. Western trench at Sadovec-Ezero. During the Late Copper Age the settlers started to
occupy also the edge of the northern range of hills,
forming a plateau. The site on the hills is locally
in particular Sadovec-Ezero yielded significant known as Sadovec-Kaleto. Apparently, at that time,
chronological and other information, which will be the inhabitants must have started to use a kind of
presented in full in a future work. drawbridge, for the distance that had to be overcome
Traces of the earliest occupation were found on a between the two heights, abruptly separated by the
saddle-like hillock, measuring 65¿40 m, surrounded river, was only 7 m, or less. Not long after the expan-
by high and nearly 90 degrees steep ranges of lime- sion, the site in the canyon was abandoned, the settle-
stone hills. A narrow passage through the hills is cut ment continuing on the more accessible plateau.
by the river Belilka, a tributary of Vit, which is almost The Sadovec-Kaleto site was also heavily damaged
unnoticeable in the landscape since it runs deep down by the looters, who had even used excavating machin-
below the ranges, encircling the hillock. ery. Rescue work was therefore carried out there, too.
The northern part of the hillock, approximately 14 It appeared that after the close of the Copper Age, the
m above the river, is higher than the southern one. Kaleto settlement continued directly into the Early
Due to this natural form, aeolithic sand forming the Bronze Age, without any significant interruption or
occupation layers only accumulated on the southern dramatic material changes. In that sense, this site is
part. Thus, the northern part remains uncovered by truly exceptional. Pottery of the so-called Transitional
Lı̂ga 21

Fig. I.10. Southern trench at Sadovec-Ezero. Remains of Late Copper Age oven, three times rebuilt, and adjacent storage bin.

Period, as well as of the earliest Bronze Age (Orlea-


Sadovec type), have been recognised in the collected
material. Until now, there are only a dozen of such
Transitional sites known in the whole of Bulgaria.
An interesting structure investigated at Kaleto was
a semi-circular rampart surrounding the site from the
accessible northern side and ending at the steep edges
of the plateau. The rampart was constructed in two
stone walls with compact layers of soil in between and
a soil cover. No doubt there has also been a palisade
at the top. The only archaeological finds recorded in
connection with this unique structure were shards of
the Early Bronze Age.

RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
As implied, the research objectives for Lı̂ga and ad-
jacent sites were to a high degree dictated by the out- Fig. I.11. Storage bin of unbaked clay, Sadovec-Ezero.
22 Acta Archaeologica

come of the excavations at Redutite. Information on at a site as more important than the issues of cultural
two Late Copper Age settlements, supplemented with differentiation within each temporal episode. Scandi-
data on the so-called Transitional Period, was con- navian archaeology suffers from its own limitations:
sidered a good starting point for building-up a local research projects have to give way to an administra-
sequence of land-use and, most importantly, for trac- tive archaeology producing general models of house
ing movements of peoples and ideas. Complex ap- types, settlements and land use but almost completely
proaches to the regional data enabled the perspective devoid of small-scale highly detailed information.
to be broadened in scope and to link a limited project Therefore, conscious efforts were invested at Lı̂ga in
to a much wider cultural-geographical setting. So far, identifying and disclosing all structures to their fullest
the majority of settlement investigations in Western extent, followed by highly thorough documentation
Bulgaria have produced a mass of isolated phenom- procedures. This approach has, for instance, enabled
ena, which have only been coupled up with the help us to study the excavated materials with an explicit
of particular types of artefacts. A different situation focus on individual structures and activities, produc-
presented itself at Telish, with an opportunity to pro- ing case sensitive – or historical – results.
duce and to piece together evidence into coherent his- As derives from the logics of these considerations,
torical sequences, resembling those of the southern answers were also sought to explain the existence of
area of impressive tells. In this light, issues such as the seemingly opposed settlement modes in SE Europe.
spatial organisation of the Lı̂ga site, changes in the The KSB culture is often defined by geographical
planning of settlement and its architecture, duration fluctuation, observed through settlements with limited
and causes of abandonment, etc. could be set in a recurring use. The immediate eastern neighbour of
broader temporal and geographical perspective, the KSB – the KGK VI complex – is traditionally
revealing the ‘‘dialectics’’ of a Late Copper Age settle- characterized by multi-layered settlement mounds,
ment. i.e., tells, reflecting continuous spatial attachments:
The ambition in the present case was never to ex- How can material data explain such differing subsist-
cavate the whole settlement, as at Redutite, but to ence strategies and, in the case of KSB, less tangible
concentrate on few areas where the archaeological mechanisms to sustain the social and spiritual equilib-
contexts could be investigated fully and at great de- rium of society? With a full awareness of the fact that
tail. Thus, the chosen strategy is in contrast to both not all variables can be identified, several specialist
the usual Bulgarian excavation practice and the main studies were designed to produce a detailed cultural
trends within the Scandinavian archaeology. Pres- profile of the Lı̂ga site, hence to provide data for com-
ently, in Bulgaria, with limited funding for archae- parative studies. The main overall objective was to
ological projects, there are no big scale research in- demonstrate the potential of integrated studies tar-
itiatives, like the ones that could be experienced dur- geted to translate the cultural fingerprints of site and
ing the Communist era (e.g., Todorova 1982). Most landscape into proper chronological sequences and
projects are designed to cover the depth rather than cultural structures.
the width, viewing the issues of temporal development
II. THE ARCHAEOLOGICAL PROCESS
METHODOLOGICAL CONSIDERATIONS tion (subdivided into sondages no. 8A and 8B). At the
& EXCAVATION TECHNIQUES same time, it appeared that both the control sondage
The site of Lı̂ga was excavated during three summer (no. 6A, laid across the old survey trench) and the
seasons from 2000 till 2002. During the third season, neighbouring sondage (no. 5) contained substantial
an important task was to undertake rescue exca- traces of habitation. The limits of the latter sondage
vations at Sadovec-Ezero and Sadovec-Kaleto. were eventually expanded, becoming part of a large
The excavated area at Lı̂ga is 275 m2 (excluding trench of 4¿10 m. In order to establish a sensitive
survey trenches) (Fig. II.1). Surface investigations at stratified collection of finds, this trench was in turn
the site in 2000 did not reveal any specific concen- subdivided into four sondages (nos. 5, 7, 6A & 6B).
tration of finds. In order to satisfy both the strati- The westernmost sondage (no. 1) did not reveal any
graphic objectives and to catch the distribution of ex- evident traces of human activity. A dozen of shards
pected structural remains, a transect covering 2¿30 were uncovered in a thin layer of humus (0.16–0.26
m was set along the topographically anticipated cen- m thick) on top of a sterile layer of pebbles. Despite
tral axis of the site, starting from the western limit sloping, it was obvious that this part of the hillock
of the plateau. This transect was orientated W-E. It was never used for construction of any permanent
covered one of the two minor survey trenches of structure. The next sondage, no. 3, also gave limited
1979, still to be seen as depressions in the terrain (Fig. results. After excavating a layer of humus 0.4 m thick,
II.2). The re-opened survey trench, which undoubt- this sondage was abandoned. Later drillings revealed
edly had destroyed the pertaining structural cultural the remains of structures in the easternmost part, 0.8
remains, was intended as a control profile for the ex- m below the surface.
cavation of new trenches, providing a prior under- All sondages were excavated in arbitrary layers of
standing of the nature of deposits and soils. 5–10 cm. The bulk material was sorted and collected
A nearby Thracian (presumably) tumulus, holding separately: pottery, all stones and flints, animal bones,
a local measurement pillar made of concrete at the and burned daub. All individual finds – diagnostic
top became the main reference point for mapping, ceramic pieces, ground stones, flint or bone im-
which ensured a conversion of the relative measure- plements and their concentrations (e.g., a heap of ani-
ments of the investigation to the absolute. A Total mal bones), as well as particular samples, were indi-
Station was used in measuring. The said transect was vidually recorded in three dimensions with the Total
subdivided into smaller units of 2¿5 m. To save time Station.
and man-power, the decision was taken to excavate Water sieving was persistently attempted during
only every second unit. This made possible strati- each season, but did not give the expected results.
graphic comparison between sondages and created a During the first season a special flotation plant was
larger investigated area. Digits and letters of the constructed, while during the second field-campaign
Greek alphabet were applied for labelling (Fig. II.3). a rather more efficient method was applied: The soil
Bearing in mind, that such a strategy would allow was collected into net bags with dense mesh, contain-
to establish only the western borders of the site, partly ing one bucket, and sieved holding the bags directly
determined by the features of the landscape (rather under a rapid water stream. Soil for water sieving was
abrupt slopes), intensive drillings were also under- collected from the areas of special interest, such as
taken, aimed at providing an overview of the entire the floor area around a storage bin or an oven, or
area used for occupation; as a result, a new section soil excavated from the graves. Only a few potential
was selected for excavation. At the southern slopes palaeobotanical remains were collected as the result
the drillings revealed a thick layer of burned daub, a of these efforts. Other residues, such as flint chips and
strong indication of the presence of habitation struc- shards, were also limited in number, perhaps due to
tures. A trench of 5¿5 m was opened for investiga- the already intensive attention given to such finds
24 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. II.1. Topographical map of Lı̂ga with indication of the excavated areas and built structures of Lı̂ga 2 (dark grey shading). EquidistanceΩ
0.5 m. Sondages in light grey were not completed. Strong dashed line marks the area of the Lı̂ga 2 settlement. Weak dashed line marks the
established borders of the Lı̂ga 1 settlement. Dense dashed line marks the extension of Lı̂ga 4 (Early Bronze Age) settlement. a marks
depression in the terrain made by earlier digs of 1979. All measurements were taken by S. Albek.
Lı̂ga 25

Fig. II.2. Place of the central transect, view from E. Note de-
pressions in the terrain – traces of earlier digs/survey trenches of
1979.

Fig. II.3. Plan of Lı̂ga site with excavated sondages. Large digits
and letters indicate sondages excavated in 2000, the remaining –
during the excavation. Generally, it can be stated that mainly in 2001 (additional work in 2002). Sector 1 denotes a set of
only limited information disappeared when water trenches lying on the southern slopes of the site and covering House
sieving was not applied. Dry sieving was also 1 of Lı̂ga 2. Sector 2 indicates a set of centrally lying trenches
covering Houses 2 & 3 of Lı̂ga 2.
attempted, with a sieve mesh of 5¿5 mm, but lumpi-
ness and the severe dryness of the soil made this a
very time-consuming task, also with only limited re-
sults. spaced at intervals of 20 m. Parallel alignments were
The first field campaign partly uncovered the re- set up with help of the Total Station and compas-
mains of three habitation structures. During the field orientated N-S. In some cases, the transect alignment
campaign of 2001 the governing strategy was to un- was dictated by the natural orientation of the field.
cover the total remains of the prehistoric houses. All artefacts were collected per 10 m, then bagged
Therefore, already investigated areas were sur- and counted. Altogether, an area of approx. 1500 m2
rounded by a new set of sondages according to pre- was intensively surveyed. The majority of the fields
dictions of the dimensions of the structures. A system around Lı̂ga were cultivated (especially in 2000), mak-
of sections was also created (Fig. II.4). The new sond- ing the conditions of survey favourable. Sample
ages were assigned a digit and a letter, so that all squares measuring 10¿10 m seemed to be optimal in
sondages with the digit 9 are connected with House responding to the requirements and aims of such sur-
1, with digit 4 House 2, and with digit 10 House 3 vey, i.e., to find the borders of the occupation, or to
(Fig. II.3). uncover possible rotations of settlement. Distribution
maps showed several concentrations, which appeared
to be misleading, though, compared with information
SURVEYS AND DRILLINGS gained by the drillings. Nevertheless, the surveys
Surveys around Lı̂ga were conducted on several oc- helped to establish the existence of an Early Bronze
casions with different degrees of intensity. These were Age settlement partly overlapping the Copper Age
aimed to establish the size of the settlement and its Lı̂ga 2 settlement. This resulted in a higher awareness
land-use, as well as for identifying new archaeological in sorting the excavated materials, which also held
sites. The immediate surroundings of the site were Bronze Age finds. Sounding procedures by drilling
also investigated with the help of drillings with geo- revealed the northern and the eastern borders of the
logical augers. The surveys were based on field-walk- Copper Age occupation.
ing. The procedure entailed a team of 4–5 persons The intensive surveys were focused on two prime
26 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. II.4. Central part (Sector 2) of Lı̂ga in the course of excavation, view from E.

areas: the area between Redutite and Lı̂ga, and the age, as also those of the subsequent periods (data
area around Lı̂ga and the present-day dam. It ap- available until the 6th century AD), moved back to
peared that certain areas had experienced intense hu- the plains at the stream, leaving the highland for rit-
man attention throughout the past, while others were ual activities and erection of tumuli.
completely ignored. The mentioned stretch between Differing traditions of settling are of great interest,
the two sites did not provide a single archaeological since they demonstrate that continuous occupation is
artefact, despite repeated surveys. By contrast, the not needed to create spatial attachments. Cultural
edges of the dam, largely corresponding to the course memories may take a general form and hence mani-
of the past stream, had evidently been a core-area, fest themselves through recognition and identification
attracting settling and exploitation from Neolithic of human alterations in a landscape, such as clearance
times onwards. activities or the presence of plants loaded with cul-
Different requirements for space and occupation tural significance.
are reflected in the settlement dynamics of the area. The Neolithic and Early Copper Age settlements
During the Neolithic and the Early Copper Age the are found on relatively light soils, suitable for prehis-
lower lying areas on the left bank of the former toric tillage (cf. above). Such areas were probably
stream were preferred, while during later periods the cleared long before the Late Copper Age occupation
higher lying and rather more dramatic plateau was on the plateau. Several shards of Late Copper Age
favored for settlement. The people of the Early Iron date discovered in the earlier fields are clearly off-site
Lı̂ga 27

finds connected with the main Lı̂ga occupation. Thus, casionally used for knapping. The gravel is mixed
evidence indicates that the area on the left bank of with coarse and medium (grains 1–2 mm in size) yel-
the stream was heavily and continuously used for cul- low-reddish sand with carbonate inclusions. This
tivation, whether the settlements were situated nearby layer is highly calcareous, despite the absence of lime-
or not. stone. The thickness of the layer is 0.2–0.4 m.
Finally, recurring occupation at the same site – as As the first settlers started to prepare the surface
during the Late Copper Age – seems to indicate the for construction of dwellings, they stripped the top of
existence of certain cognitive templates, which helped the hillock from soil, exposing the pebble layer. The
select particular areas as culturally suitable. Neverthe- surplus soil was deposited down the southern slope,
less, natural conditions (availability of water, clay re- which was witnessing an attempt to expand the area
sources, soil types, etc.) were no doubt at the base of of occupation. The western slope, which is closest to
any prehistoric acknowledgment of ‘‘tamed land- the stream, and the steepest, was not changed since
scapes’’ (sensu Hodder 1990). this would have been inefficient. The northern slopes
were not investigated. Actually, the settlers were not
trying to create a level surface everywhere, only some
SITE FORMATION DYNAMICS even areas. When the houses were built, they would
The site of Lı̂ga has been the scene of many activities appear to have been standing on low terraces, dif-
in the past. As the name (‘‘Grazing Fields’’) implies, fering 0.3–0.4 m in height. The layer of pebbles left
it is today uncultivated and used for grazing of around the houses would have been appreciated as
communal herds of sheep and goat. At the end of natural pavements, as indicated by crushed pebbles
the 19th century, the site was made into a vineyard. and a darker colour created by accumulated organic
Trenches dug for planting wines have caused much matters between the pebbles.
destruction of the archaeological remains. Periods of It is not known what caused the termination of the
land cultivation have formed a thick layer of humus. settlement, which generally was recognised as a grey
Two layers of humus-rich topsoil can be dis- unburned clayey layer rich in organic matters and
tinguished. The lower and darker one has a signifi- small pieces of charcoal (1–2 mm in size). The char-
cant amount of charred remains, indicating repeated coal likely entered the debris after a fire clearing of
clearance by fire – a practice which even today is vegetation at the time of establishment of the sub-
widespread in the country. Based on stratigraphic ob- sequent settlement, Lı̂ga 2. The first settlement was
servations, it can be concluded that both humus-rich only acknowledged in the southern and eastern parts
layers were formed after the 6th century AD. In fact, of the investigated area. Except for the southern and,
long before becoming a nondescript plot of land, the partly, the western limits, its extents have not been
location experienced a series of differing human activ- established, since the drillings did not produce any
ities that inevitably changed its natural appearance conclusive results regarding the area of occupation.
(Pl. 3). The Lı̂ga 1 settlement had a general orientation of
SW to NE. The houses were more widely spaced than
those of the subsequent settlement. The most in-
LÎGA 1: FIRST COPPER AGE SETTLEMENT formative structural remains were discovered at the
The first settlement at the site – Lı̂ga 1 – was estab- southern edge. Clay was the main building material
lished during the earlier part of the Late Copper Age. and a high content of organic matter in the destruc-
The settlers invested much energy in shaping the hill- tion layer points towards the use of a wattle and daub
ock and creating even terrain. Before anthropogenic technique. Massive posts with a diameter of 25 cm
impact, the hillock was covered by a grey layer of were supporting the construction in some parts of the
sandy clay mixed with fine organic matter, slightly walls. On the rather unstable southern side, a shallow
acidic. The layer below is constituted by gravel and 0.45 m wide trench was dug prior to the erection of
pebbles (up to 70 mm in size), including fragments of the wall. The house in questions was orientated N-
well-rounded quartzite and brown opaque flint, oc- S. The external length, as could be measured from
28 Acta Archaeologica

southern profile). It is a flat female bone figurine with


good parallels at other Late Copper Age sites (Pl.
26:6). The archaeological record concerning Lı̂ga 1 is
thus preserved the best at the southern slopes.
For how long the Lı̂ga 1 settlement remained aban-
doned before the new occupation is difficult to tell.
On a material scale – primarily pottery – the change
is dramatic. At any rate, the house mounds were
clearly visible for the new settlers, who used them as
foundations for their own dwellings, thus preserving
the grid of space-use established by the Lı̂ga 1 settle-
ment.

LÎGA 2: SECOND COPPER AGE SETTLEMENT


Around 4400 BC calibrated (cf. below), a new settle-
ment – Lı̂ga 2 – was established at the site. Level
terraces were created on the remains of the Lı̂ga 1
dwellings, causing severe destruction of the debris of
the previous occupational phase. The fact that the
low house mounds comprised of unburned clay was
appreciated, providing fine and easily formed founda-
tions for the new dwellings. Such layers make good
floors, enabling the preservation of a coherent surface
during the entire use-life of a dwelling. As a conse-
quence, terracing was more pronounced now and a
more elaborate design of the settlement created. The
Fig. II.5. Lı̂ga 1, remains of stone pavement. archaeological investigation was mainly concentrated
on the material vestiges of this settlement.
Three dwellings were fully investigated. Their
preserved postholes as well as the extent of destruc- identification was easy due to the fact that the settle-
tion debris, was 7.6 m. The floor inside the house was ment of Lı̂ga 2 was burned down, and reddish burned
lime plastered (Pl. 3, Sondage 8A). Only one layer daub clearly outlined the structures. In the northern
of floor could be recognised. Computer-aided light- part of the excavated area, numerous limestones were
simulations reveal that whitening of floors is the most discovered, which displayed a semi-circular or oval
effective means to increase illumination of interiors as pattern. Stones in such configurations are obviously
light is reflected off the floors (Larsen 2003). By con- structural features, in fact house foundations, even
trast, whitening of the walls are not adding more light when lacking preserved burned daub.
to the internal space. At the SE corner of the house House 1 was discovered almost exactly on top of
was part of a regular stone pavement made of water- the house from the previous occupational horizon.
worn well-sorted cobbles of sandstone and brown flint With a slight deviation towards the East it followed
reaching 10–12¿5–10 cm in size (Fig. II.5). Beyond the orientation of the earlier construction (Pl. 2).
the outline of the house, on the southern slope, was a House 2, as could be deduced from the occasional
thick layer of discarded pottery, animal bones and occurrence of large fragments of pottery, was possibly
stone tools, among which hammer stones were the also covering remains of a previous construction, al-
most frequent. One of the most spectacular finds though the relationship between the two structures
comes from the area inside the house (sondage 9V, could not be established due to lack of more substan-
Lı̂ga 29

Fig. II.7. Pottery of Early Copper Age Gradeshnitsa culture found


at Lı̂ga.

m in width and 0.8 m deep, may now have en-


circled the entire hillock (Fig. II.6). This trench was
dug to create steeper slopes, in particular towards
the West. A posthole (15 cm in diameter) near the
trench on the western slopes perhaps indicates that
a fence was erected along the trench, separating the
latter from the settlement. The survey trenches also
proved that discard of waste was controlled. Only
Fig. II.6 Survey trench dug across the Southern slope. insignificant amounts of shards from the Lı̂ga 2
settlement were discovered on the slopes and at the
foot of the hillock.
Finally, it should be noted that a handful of rather
tial debris. The area East of House 2 was used for big and thick-walled shards, ornamented with deeply
discard of broken pottery, food remains, and espe- incised lines and pits, often with white lime incrus-
cially ashes (Pl. 3, C–D). The same sort of material tation, dated to the Early Copper Age Gradeshnitsa
was discovered at this very site in Lı̂ga 1. The area culture were found (Fig. II.7). The distribution of
below House 3 was not fully investigated, but clear these shards at Lı̂ga does not present any particular
traces of previous occupation were established, dem- pattern, except that the highest number, mere three
onstrating that older structural remains were used to shards, was found in the waste area at House 1. No
create a level terraced platform for a new dwelling, structures or features can be related to this period.
rising higher than House 2, according to the exca- The said shards all have traces of severe secondary
vation profile (Pl. 3, A–B). burning, so the most apparent explanation is that they
Based on these observations it can, tentatively, be were brought to the site by the Lı̂ga 2 inhabitants,
assumed that the gap between the two settlements perhaps as exotica, due to their distinctive ornamen-
was not of a significant length, even though it is tation and contrasting bright red colour. The closest
marked by a dramatic change in pottery technology settlement of Early Copper Age date is situated just
(see below). across the stream. The Redutite site also held evi-
The Lı̂ga 2 inhabitants also made modifications dence on a conflagrated Gradeshnitsa settlement.
to the hillock. With the help of two survey trenches Apart from that, there is only one more known Early
across the western and southern slopes, it has been Copper Age settlement in a vicinity of Telish (Gergov
demonstrated that a shallow ditch or trench, ca. 1.5 1994).
30 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. II.9. Early Bronze Age pottery from Lı̂ga.

Fig. II.8. One of the shards discovered in the Early Bronze Age
pit. dimensions being 1.50¿1.20¿1.15 m. The dark
brown clay loam fill can be associated with domestic
activities, including fragmented pottery, a few bones,
and other organic material.
LÎGA 3: COPER AGE CEMETERY Also, at least 10 fragments of one distinctive vessel,
The Lı̂ga 2 settlement was abandoned after a confla- partly intact at the time of deposition, were recorded
gration. The proximity of C-14 and AMS dates avail- from the upper layers of the pit (Fig. II.8). This vessel
able from Redutite and Lı̂ga implies that soon after differs much from the main body of Early Bronze Age
the abandonment of the Lı̂ga 2 settlement a new shards discovered on the site, both in terms of a very
settlement was established at Redutite, Redutite II. fine sand matrix, medium brown colour, and a fine
The abandonment of Lı̂ga site lasted until ca. 4000 surface finish. It is decorated with very shallow
BC. At that time, the southern part of the site was grooves resembling fluting rather than grooving
selected for a cemetery with several burials. In the (hence often called pseudo-flutes), which are organ-
excavated area alone, seven graves have been dis- ised in a herringbone pattern. A 6 mm broad flat-
covered, one grave holding remains of two individ- topped tool was applied for decoration. Such decor-
uals. This significant discovery is described in Chap- ation is common during the Coţofeni I phase (Roman
ter XI, below. 1976). In the same pit were other Early Bronze Age
shards with exact parallels from the neighbouring
sites at Sadovec. In most cases, Early Bronze Age pot-
LÎGA 4: EARLY BRONZE AGE tery could be separated easily from Copper Age pot-
During the Early Bronze Age the excavated area was tery due to its medium to coarse sandy fabrics and
part of a marginal activity zone for a settlement rough feel, since original slipped surfaces were rarely
higher up on the plateau. The occupational debris of preserved (Fig. II.9). The rims are usually cranelated,
this was partly overlapping the eastern limits of the straight or everted, and often with a row of perfor-
Lı̂ga 2 settlement, as has been established through ations just below the lip. Incised decoration is found
drillings. The full extent of the Bronze Age settlement on the handles, which are either broad flat and rib-
was not determined, but surface finds from the sur- bon-shaped or semi-oval and narrow. Applied decor-
rounding fields point to a considerable size. Besides ation is known as well. Such elements of decoration
scattered pottery shards, found mostly in Sector 2, have a very broad spatial distribution and a rather
one pit is with certainty attributed to the EBA. This long temporal duration.
had an oval shape and was orientated SE-NW, the Comparative pottery is found at Sadovec-
Lı̂ga 31

Golemanovo Kale (Todorova 1968; 1992), Sadovec- The cup was placed inside the bowl. Two urn-like
Kaleto (unpublished, cf. above), and Mouselievo vessels with tall necks, horizontally fluted, were decor-
(Gergov 1979). Close parallels are also found at more ated with corded and cardium impressions, organised
distant sites like Ezero (lower horizons, A1) (Gerogiev in festoons. A big limestone was thrown on the urn-
et al. 1979), Yunatsite (lower horizons, XVI–XII) like vessels, which broke them. Immediately after
(Katinčarov et al. 1995), and Dikili Tash (IIIa) (Séféri- that, the pit was filled with the same soil as it was dug
adès 1996). into, soil from the lowest layers being thrown ‘‘back’’
The cultural profile of the larger Telish region is into its original horizon. This actually caused some
not yet completed. Excavations by H. Todorova and confusion in recognition of the extent and depth of
V. Velkov in 1978 at Sadovec-Golemanovo Kale gave the pit, bearing in mind that from first sight the dis-
grounds to support the suggestion by P. Roman of covered fragments of urn-like vessels, with their black
the existence of a distinct cultural unit termed Orlea- shiny surfaces, resembled the pottery of the Lı̂ga 1
Sadovec culture (Todorova 1992). However, recent settlement.
reconsiderations of available, though limited data sug- 0.90 m to the South of this pit was a circular shal-
gest that Orlea-Sadovec should in fact be viewed as low pit (dimensions of 1.10¿0.97 m). This contained
a southern variant of Coţofeni I culture (Alexandrov flecks of charcoal and larger pieces of calcinated wood
1992; 1996). Chronologically, it corresponds with the (up to 7 cm in diameter, and with 10 visible rings).
end of Coţofeni I as recorded in N-NW Romania Two samples of wood taken from the pit were recog-
(the Banat, Transylvania, and N Oltenia) (Alexandrov nized by C. Malmros (2), National Museum of
1992; 1996). Consequently, the Bronze Age pottery Denmark, as being from deciduous oak (Quercus sp.).
from Lı̂ga should also be dated to Early Bronze Age Probably, the two pits are associated, the shallow one
I. Diagnostic flint artefacts support this date. being used as the fireplace where the above vessels
Finally, it should be mentioned that a few shards received their secondary burning.
were found which might be attributed to the Late All four vessels were identified by M. Dimitrova,
Bronze Age. Their provenance is unknown. Historical Museum of Lovech, Bulgaria as representa-
tives of the Basarabi culture, found on both banks of
the Lower Danube (i.e., in Southern Romania and
Lı̂GA 5: EARLY IRON AGE Northern Bulgaria). Bowls with fluted rims as well as
Around 875 BC (charcoal, Ua-20609, 2725∫40 BP) cups with tall handles are widely spread in this region
a strange ritual was taking place in the central part of throughout the whole of the Early Iron Age, while
the hillock of Lı̂ga. An oval deep pit of 1.90¿1.26¿ urns with tall, horizontally fluted necks are less com-
1.12 m was dug and at least four vessels placed in it mon. A fine comparative material is displayed by the
at the bottom (the area below profile baulk, partly grave goods of the Sofronievo tumulus, Vraca region
intersecting the pit, was not investigated and possibly (Hänsel 1976). Based on metal finds, this inhumation
holds additional information) (Fig. II.10) (1). Digging grave was dated to the 7th century BC. So far, all
the pit was not an easy task, since the place chosen temporal ordering of Basarabi material has been
held thick debris of burned Copper Age daub belong- achieved through correlations with metal finds. It is
ing to the walls of House 3. Perhaps an attempt to generally believed that the Basarabi culture started
expand the pit in direction of softer soils resulted in around 800 BC and, according to differing views,
its oblong form. All vessels held traces of severe sec- existed till the 6th or the 4th century BC (Hänsel
ondary burning, including a bowl with fluted lip and 1976).
a big cup with one handle going high above its rim. A settlement of Early Iron Age date was identified
at the foot of the plateau some 100 meters South of
the Lı̂ga hillock (Gergov, pers.comm.). Today, this
1. With few exceptions, all the drawings of the present publication
are made by Izolda Maciukaite, BA on the basis of the pencil
drawings by project participants to whom the authors are grate- 2. The author is grateful to Claus Malmros, MA for analysing the
ful. Contact information: www.worldarchaeology.net wood samples.
32 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. II.10. Vessels discovered in the Early Iron Age pit in Sector 2.

settlement is destroyed by the modern lake and only It provided information on contemporary pottery as
the occasional shard can be found on its banks. well as news on the dating of Basarabi vessels, as
Material of the Early Iron Age is often found in pits based on one rather precise AMS date.
without clear structural affiliations or even purposes
(Georgieva 1991). Sometimes, the contents are sealed
by mud plaster. A comparable situation has been LÎGA 6: LATE ANTIQUITY (6TH CENTURY AD)
palaeobotanically analyzed by M. Lazarova and I. The period between the 4th century and the end of
Stefanova (Lazarova and Stefanova 1997). It ap- the 6th AD (in some studies, the beginning of the
peared that a cup from a sealed Early Iron Age pit 7th AD) is known in Bulgaria as Late Antiquity or
(Pit no. 3) at the site of Cheshmata (Rogozinovo vil- Early Byzantine period. At Telish, settlements of this
lage, Southeastern Bulgaria) contained a considerable period, and most probably also a cemetery, are
amount of seeds of Lens culinaris (lentil); fruits of Ru- known from both banks of the modern lake, but the
mex sp. (sorrel), Carex sp. (sedge), and some seeds of remains are rapidly disappearing due to digs and
Trifolium sp. (native clover) were also found. deep ploughing by the treasure hunters. The end of
The content of the Lı̂ga pit was not investigated Late Antiquity is represented at Lı̂ga.
palaeobotanically; nevertheless, the find is an import- A large, but shallow pit (max. dimensions: 4.5¿
ant contribution to the study of the Early Iron Age. 2.7¿0.6 m) was recorded on the southern slopes of
Lı̂ga 33

the site, partially destroying Copper Age layers. At


the southern edge of the pit was a pile of stones orig-
inating from a Lı̂ga 1 pavement (Fig. II.5). Appar-
ently, this pavement hindered further digging of the
pit; attempts were made to remove the stones, but
eventually the initiative was given up. The bottom of
the pit thus follows the surface of the stones. The pit
had a rather regular, apparently rectangular layout
(just one half of the pit was excavated), much resem-
bling that of a pit house. Very heterogeneous contents
of the pit, including small fragments of pottery and Fig. II.11. Pottery discovered in Late Antiquity pit in Sector 1.
animal bones, suggest that the structure was used for
secondary disposal of waste. Right at the southern
edge of the pit was a shallow posthole with a diameter
of 15 cm; this is doubtlessly associated with the pit, of only 500 years (4900/4800–4370/4330 BC cal.),
but its purpose is uncertain. The nearest Late An- while relative chronology suggests a duration of the
tiquity settlement was identified during surveys less Copper Age of 800–900 years (4900/4800–4100/
than 200 m NW of Lı̂ga. 3900 BC cal.) (Görsdorf & Bojadžiev 1996).
The pottery discovered in the pit finds exact paral- Another problem is that C-14 dates between about
lels in the material known from Sadovec (Kuzmanov 5500 and 4000 BC tend to cluster in certain periods,
1992). It is a matter of local pottery, grey in colour, a phenomenon which is not related to calibration,
made of well-prepared clay without any tempering since the pertaining calibration curve displays no sig-
inclusions or coating of the surface (Fig. II.11). All nificant ‘‘platforms’’ or the like. This chronological
the discovered rim fragments represent kitchenware. peculiarity, which seems to be repeated throughout
Following the suggested dating from Sadovec, the SE Europe, cannot be fully explained at present. Per-
rims date to the 6th AD (Kuzmanov 1992, 219). haps it is due to as yet unknown physical factors, but
more likely to the influence of regional natural
phenomena (Bojadžiev 1994). Studies made by War-
AMS DATING AND POSSIBLE ANOMALIES ren and Hankey in the Aegean have also demon-
Most Bulgarian C-14 dates have been generated by strated that radiocarbon dates tend to cluster and that
the Berlin C-14 Laboratory. Within the framework of there apparently are certain periods, which are not
cooperation initiated in 1962 by the Laboratory (H. covered by the C-14 sequence (Warren and Hankey
Quitta & G. Kohl) and the Bulgarian Institute of Ar- 1989). The most pronounced gap in C-14 dates lies
chaeology (G. Georgiev & H. Todorova), 487 samples between 5050 and 4550 BP, corresponding to the
from 60 different Prehistoric sites have been dated much-disputed Bulgarian Transitional period (War-
(Görsdorf & Bojadžiev 1996). Such large body of in- ren and Hankey 1989). Therefore, it has been sug-
formation is generally a reliable tool for solving the gested that cultural invisibility of the period between
main issues of cultural development, but in this case the end of the Copper Age and the Early Bronze Age
certain peculiarities are revealed. may stem from methodological limitations.
One of the problems concerns the Copper Age. Samples collected from Lı̂ga were submitted to the
Firstly, the Late Copper Age materials from the sites Ångström Laboratory, Division of Ion Physics,
of Banyata (Kapitan Dimitrievo), Galatin, and Kola- Uppsala, Sweden and AMS dated by G. Possnert. All
rovo (all clearly belonging to the KSB sphere of in- samples underwent standard laboratory procedures,
fluence) have been made one thousand years too including pre-treatment with NaOH, and the results
young, to judge from the archaeological record were d 13C corrected (as reported by G. Possnert).
(Görsdorf & Bojadžiev 1996). At the same time, the Altogether, seven samples were submitted: four of
whole Copper Age has been dated to a span of time charcoal and three of bones (Fig. II.12). These
34 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. II.12. Table of all available Late Copper Age radiocarbon dated samples from Lı̂ga and the core area of KSB Ia complex (cf. Fig. II.13).
Lı̂ga 35

Fig. II.13. Conventional and calibrated radiocarbon ages of all available samples recovered from the core area of KSB Ia complex, sorted
by age (cf. Fig. II.12).

samples were selected from quite a significant number wall of House 2, the area of waste disposal; Ua-
of samples based on their representativity, context 20608 – inside House 1; Ua-20610 – close to the oven
and amount of charcoal in the sample. The attention of House 3).
was centered on Lı̂ga 2, AMS dating of this temporal Architectural wood, the source of all three samples,
episode being considered the highest priority. Three can be subdivided into several size/age categories.
selected samples were associated with each of the The postholes indicate that, besides twigs, trees of
three excavated houses (Ua-20607 – outside the E three sizes were used by the house builders. The big-
36 Acta Archaeologica

gest quantity was of trees 8–9 cm in diameter, the same burial. Two of the dates (Ua-21562 & Ua-
next group being about 15 cm in diameter, and the 21563) show close temporal affinity, while the third
third – the internal roof supporting posts – up to 25 (Ua-21564) is marked by a significant divergence and
cm in diameter. In sorting the samples, possible oc- therefore regarded as false. Likely, it was affected by
currences of the last group were discarded in order to the stabilizing chemical treatment exercised on some
minimize the ‘‘old-tree’’ effect. of the badly preserved principal bones.
It should be noted, that no charcoal samples were No charcoal samples could be associated with the
recovered from the earliest settlement horizon, Lı̂ga Early Bronze Age remains at the site. A single sample
1. This settlement was only poorly preserved, since it of charcoal was recovered from the Early Iron Age
was abandoned and left exposed to natural decompo- pit (Ua-20609). Low probability margins do not give
sition. Later on, the debris was incorporated in the grounds to doubt its validity and makes it an import-
base of the subsequent Lı̂ga 2 settlement. ant contribution to the regional chronological se-
The presence of graves within the settlement of quence.
Lı̂ga 2, even with grave goods, raised important ques- Calibration plots of all available C-14/AMS dates
tions regarding their date. For the sake of consistency, from the core area of KSB Ia are presented in a sep-
three human bone samples were selected from the arate table (Fig. II.13).
III. THE COPPER AGE OCCUPATION
AT LÎGA
USE OF SPACE WITHIN THE SETTLEMENT than those of Lı̂ga 2. The general layout must never-
An upland position is common for the majority of theless have been quite similar in the two phases, as
KSB sites. The Lı̂ga settlement with two occupation clearly demonstrated by the N-S orientation of all
phases of Late Copper Age date is not an exception. structures on the site. The estimated external length
Located on an exposed plateau (Fig. III.1), it had to of the one uncovered, partly preserved house of Lı̂ga
cope with the severity of the western and northern 1 is 7.6 m, the estimated internal space being 39–40
winds, which perhaps were less aggressive then due m2 (1).
to generally warmer climatic conditions. One of the A much deeper insight has been achieved about
preventive responses was to create a dense configur- the use of space in the Lı̂ga 2 settlement. Three
ation of houses within the settlement. The idea of a houses were fully uncovered together with parts of
settlement mode with a uniform and dense layout of another three houses. The location of the structures
house structures interchanging with axially orientated in the settlement confirmed the observation that their
streets or paths is no doubt a reflection of contempor- distribution and orientation were predetermined by
ary templates of spatial organisation, which orig- those of the first phase.
inated in the densely occupied tell settlements. The hillock chosen for the Copper Age settle-
Among the best examples are Early Copper Age tells ments – at the edge of a plateau – has only limited
like Polyanitsa (NE Bulgaria) or, even earlier, Neo- defensive properties. Visibility towards the East is
lithic occupations at Karanovo or Ovcharovo-Gorata limited by a raising terrain. Towards the West, the
(Todorova & Vajsov 1993). Such structural clustering field of visibility extends longer, being 7–8 km to-
is also advantageous in terms of protection from hos- wards NW, 3 km towards W and 5–51⁄2 km towards
tile attacks and creation of sheltered workshop places SW. Perhaps this field indicates the direction of local
outside the buildings. But it is restricting in terms of movements and networks with no hostilities to be ex-
rebuilding or expansion of old structures. And often pected from the East (cf. below). A modification of
it had been fatal in promoting fast and unreversible the latter idea is the likely existence of forested en-
destruction of settlements by fire. Within the area of vironments towards the East.
the KSB culture, such traditions of settlement organ- The very edge of the plateau was left unbuilt. This
isation can be traced back to the related Early Copper area of 500–550 m2 was delimited by slopes in the
Age, as demonstrated by the distribution of houses West and rows of houses in eastern direction. As men-
at Gradeshnitsa (Nikolov 1974). Here three building tioned, during Lı̂ga 2, the slopes were made steeper
horizons were applying the same concept of use of by a shallow ditch or trench (only 0.8 m deep). The
space. discovery of a posthole 15 cm in diameter on the east-
A uniform clustered pattern of house structures is ern side of the trench perhaps indicates that a wooden
also noted at Lı̂ga, despite the limited area of re- construction was accompanying the trench. Whether
search. It is even possible to detect temporal changes this was a palisade or merely a fence, such arrange-
in use of space by comparing the two Copper Age ment intended to inhibit movement both down and
occupations. As mentioned, the traces of the first up the slopes. Similar installations were not observed
Copper Age settlement (Lı̂ga 1) are not so well pre- at the eastern edge of the settlement. Also if they once
served as those of Lı̂ga 2, construction of the latter
disturbing the remains of Lı̂ga 1. Nevertheless, it can
1. All measurements, if not stated otherwise, have been undertaken
be concluded that the use of space in Lı̂ga 1 was less with the help of GIS. Therefore, the only possible source of
constrained than in Lı̂ga 2. The dwellings of Lı̂ga 1 mistake may be an inaccurate scale in published plans, which
were spatially more dispersed as well as larger in size were scanned and processed accordingly.
38 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. III.1. Lı̂ga site, view from the West. Note the survey trench across the western slope.

existed here, they would have been made in response slope, was the smallest, the external dimensions being
to interior demands, be it a formal demarcation or 6.50¿5.70 m (total area 36.54 m2), the internally
enclosed spaces for livestock. They could not have available area is 28.3 m2 (Pl. 2). House 2 is perhaps
been an effective protection against attacks. The latter the one, which applies the best to a supposed stan-
might at any rate have come as a surprise, with war- dard, since a partly excavated neighbouring house
riors approaching through the likely forested higher had a similar length (Pl. 1). The external dimensions
lying environments of the plateau. of House 2 are 7.4¿6.0 m, the internal area being
The topographical profile of the settlement also 34.5 m2, the total area 44.45 m2. House 3 was the
hints at a specialised use of the delimited edge area. longest among the investigated houses (Pl. 1). A some-
As the value of livestock was growing in step with what irregular shape is likely a reflection of constrains
the supposed relative decline of ground-water based due to the terrain (cf. the orientation of the eastern
agriculture (Sherratt 1980), it was necessary to ensure wall). Perhaps, achievement of parallel courses of the
protection of this, the main communal commodity. walls was hindered by the circumstance that the alti-
Likely, the most frequent form of Copper Age warfare tude along the eastern wall was higher than along the
was not larger attacks but small-scale ravaging raids western one. House 3 was 8.45 m long and 5.90 m
aimed at steeling cattle. Incidentally, similar enclos- wide in the middle part (external lengths). The intern-
ures at edges have been attested in other Late Copper ally available area was 37.80 m2, the total area 48
Age settlements, including the fortified settlements of m2. Thus, there is a tendency for larger houses to be
Zaminets and Lesura (Golata Mogila), Vratsa region centrally located in the settlement.
(Nikolov 1975) (cf. below). The streets or passages of the settlement were 2.70–
Sounding of the terrain also helped establish that 3.00 m wide and orientated E-W. The houses were
the houses of Lı̂ga 2 were occupying an area of ca. spaced by intervals of 0.80–3.00 m and erected in a
50¿55 m. The total area with burned remains of chequer manner, so that spaces between houses were
buildings extended over ca. 1900 m2, however (Fig. ‘‘closed’’ by the walls of adjacent structures. Based on
II.1). All houses were, as mentioned, rectangular and the available data and assuming a uniform distri-
orientated N-S. House 1, located on the southern bution of the structures, it is safe to predict that the
Lı̂ga 39

Fig. III.2. Suggested reconstruction of the Lı̂ga 2 settlement. Dark grey colour marks houses, which have been established through excavation.
Numbers correspond to the numbering system of the investigated structural remains. Light grey colour marks predicted houses.

settlement contained 20–22 contemporary houses nized, but pots and implements placed outside were
(Fig. III.2). Such estimation is strengthened by obser- perhaps used to mark the territory of a particular
vations from nearby Redutite, almost totally exca- household.
vated, and other Late Copper Age sites, which have Movement across the settlement was not straight-
provided full-scale information on lay-outs of struc- forward. One had to follow the streets and fixed
tures (Gergov, pers. comm.). paths, since the entire interstructural space was often
Several activity areas have been identified in the filled with heaps of household refuse. Procedures for
excavated part of the Lı̂ga 2 settlement. Workshops handling of waste are not completely clear from the
were probably often relocated, since the discovered excavation. Despite the fact that heaps of bones and
remains do not support an idea of permanent task- broken pottery were discovered at the northern wall
specific areas. Rather, we are seeing reflections of un- of House 1, as well as in the area between Houses 2
ambiguous, intense and temporarily restricted events. and 3, and that some concentration was observed at
Some of the activities, not being place dependant, the SE corner of House 2, this probably only repre-
were also carried out inside the houses, but generally sents temporary disposals of refuse connected with
it seems that the majority of chores was conducted household activities. The layer, which had formed be-
outdoors. In fact, such nucleated settlements could tween Houses 2 and 3, is domestic in origin: cooking,
have applied an expanded notion of ‘‘habitus’’ (sensu maintenance, and cleaning of furnaces left an ashy
Hodder 1990), incorporating space surrounding the blueprint with inclusions of carbon. The area varies
houses. No formal outdoor divisions could be recog- between 2.7 and 3.0 m in width and could never hold
40 Acta Archaeologica

vation that the structures of Lı̂ga 2 were repeating


the layout of the previous settlement, and that the
interstructural spaces used for refuse disposal held the
same purpose during both phases. The support rests
with repeated deposits of freshwater mussels of the
Microcondylaea Compressa species, apparently
brought to the site from the neighbouring stream (An-
dreasen, op.cit.). Shells of these mussels were em-
ployed for decorating vessels with so-called ‘‘nail in-
cision’’ patterns.
Apart from the described pattern of disposal im-
mediately outside the houses, the overall handling of
refuse remains unknown. Generally, the streets, where
many outdoor activities were taking place were kept
clean of refuse (Fig. III.3). The few examples of ani-
mal bones recorded in street areas can be attributed
to post-depositional transformation. No indications
have been found of the common practice of disposal
in Telish village – to push everything beyond the edge
of the household area, preferably into the all-con-
cealing stream. On the contrary, as the two trenches
across the slopes have revealed, this was not the case
at Lı̂ga. Several investigators have reported that ref-
Fig. III.3. ‘‘Street area’’ between two rows of built structures, view
use was discarded in pits behind the houses, already
from the East (cf. Pl. 1).
dug to procure clay for buildings. Such pits, although
without distinct references to their contents, are said
to have been found at Zaminets and Gradeshnitsa
the total mass of refuse produced by one or two (Nikolov 1974; 1975). No such pits were discovered
households over some time. Domestic animals, like at Lı̂ga, however, and neither at fully excavated
dogs and pigs, were no doubt used to devour organic neighbouring Redutite. At both sites clay for the
refuse not suitable for human consumption. structures was obtained from clay-rich deposits at the
Malacological data also support an interpretation foot of the plateau.
of this interstructural area as being used for refuse Some of the activity traces are not straightforward
disposal. In fact, it was the only part of the investi- to interpret, like ceramic vessels placed outside
gated area, which held evidence of land snails of the houses, close to entrances. Were they placed there for
Helicidae family (as reported by N. Andreasen (2), cleaning or storage, or did they mark the area of the
Copenhagen & Cambridge universities, in 2001). last meal prior to the fire that terminated Lı̂ga 2? The
Their presence indicates a sufficient amount of or- terminal phase of Lı̂ga 2 is predicted to have belonged
ganic debris present for scavenging. Snails of the He- to the warmer part of the year, most probably the
lix Pomatia species are also suitable for human con- second half of the summer where outdoor meals were
sumption but their limited number and especially the likely common. This prediction is based on the obser-
presence of juvenile representatives do not support vation that no grain was found in the containers of
such an assumption. Lı̂ga 2, regardless of fine conditions of preservation
The malacological data even confirms the obser- and the application of soil flotation procedures. In-
deed, recovered plant macrofossils are few. Only
2. The author is grateful to Niels Andreasen, MA, for analyzing three grains of Triticum diccocum, all within debris
the malacological samples. of daub tempered with chopped straws, were found.
Lı̂ga 41

Other palaeobotanical samples, reviewed by S. Karg


(3) of the National Museum of Denmark, contained a
few seeds of juniper (Juniperus specia) and Cornelian
cherry dogwood (Cornus mas L.), both collected from
the waste area between Houses 2 & 3. The latter spe-
cies ripens from August till the end of September and
may thus indicate the period of settlement confla-
gration; in fact, the beginning of August would be
most likely for this, since, as noted above, none of
the grain bins contained any grains, despite flotation
applied on their contens. Incidentally, the majority of
samples were rejected by not being calcinated, and
therefore regarded as unreliable.
Areas of production are more easily recognized. A
clear concentration of flakes and exhausted cores be-
hind House 2 indicates that flint tools were produced
here. All flakes were identified as belonging to flint
sources at Sadovec, 7.3 km East of Lı̂ga. The direc-
tion of distribution of the flakes suggests that the flint
knapper was sitting at the rear wall of House 2, in Fig. III.4. Red deer antlers found in the ‘‘Street’’ area.
front of House 5. Some 3–4 m West of the area with
flint debitage two red deer antlers were found (Fig.
III.4), perhaps prepared for production of bone tools tracted less attention than the tell settlements in the
or even flintknapping tools, like antler batons or ham- Thracian plain or in Northeastern Bulgaria. The tra-
mers. House 2 also holds other evidence of flint han- dition of research was not emphasizing the need for
dling. Thus, a multitude of small chips was discovered contextual data but was unilaterally orientated to-
both inside and outside this structure. Two core areas wards the collection of ceramic material, considered
of activity were identified, one inside the house at the terra supra for chronological and cultural ordering. It
southern wall, not far from the SE corner (and still was not unusual to make a few small trenches at a
within the zone of daylight coming from the door site, which would reveal the stratigraphic position of
opening), another outside, along the southern peri- pottery but not a fuller context of structures and fea-
phery of the eastern wall until the area of Grave No tures. Often such limited strategies have had disas-
2 of Lı̂ga 3. trous consequences in a country, where looting of ar-
chaeological remains were – and indeed, are – more
common than archaeology proper. Gaul mentions
USE OF SPACE AT OTHER KSB CULTURE that a famous tell, Devebargan at the town of Marica,
SETTLEMEMNTS was excavated by treasure hunters already in 1911
From the very first excavations at Okol Glava and (Gaul 1948). At the site of Pipra, 8 km south of Lı̂ga,
Pekliuk, which eventually became recognised as KSB with rich remains from Copper Age, Early Iron Age
sites, nearly a century has passed (Gaul 1948). Never- and Late Antiquity, several survey trenches were
theless, the amount of available data on settlement made in 1976. The results are still unpublished, but
patterns, use of space, and other arrangements within the site has since almost disappeared as the local
a settlement is still rather modest. There are several looters have dotted it with deep and extensive trench-
reasons for this. For many years KSB settlements at- es, sometimes even employing heavy excavation ma-
chinery. Furthermore, the lack of publications on ex-
3. The author is grateful to Dr. Sabine Karg, National Museum cavations is a severe hindrance when attempting to
of Denmark for analysing palaeobotanical samples. assess the archaeological sites of Bulgaria.
42 Acta Archaeologica

The site of Redutite site East of Telish (and close new structure in place of an old one, or, one of the
to Lı̂ga) is the only KSB site that has been almost walls of the old house could be incorporated into the
entirely excavated (excluding modern destruction at novel structure. In both cases the new house usually
the eastern periphery and two or three houses left occupied a smaller area than earlier. Finally, a new
unexcavated at the N-NE fringes of the site). The site area at the periphery of the settlement could be taken
is considered the best testimony on changing organis- into use. Over time, a slight expansion of the settle-
ation of settlement space during the Copper Age. But ment towards the East was noted, the eastern part
the results of excavation are still awaiting proper pub- also witnessing most of the construction and re-con-
lication. struction initiatives. Preliminarily available infor-
The site was investigated between 1977 and 1992 mation allows the estimation that up to three gener-
(Gergov 1987; 1992a; 1992b; 1994; 1996; Gergov et ations of houses can be recognized in Redutite II. At
al. 1986; and, personal communication). As mention- one time, as many as 30–33 houses may have existed,
ed, the topographical location resembles that of but during the final phase of the settlement only 23–
neighbouring Lı̂ga. Delimited by plain and ravines, 25 houses occupied the site. The internal house space
the site is situated on one of the highest points of the at Redutite II is 37 m2 on the average, but if the
plateau and has a far better field of visibility towards smaller second generation houses are added, only 34
the West than Lı̂ga. The modern village of Telish is m2 .
lying at its foot, where also ran a stream fed by nu- Redutite III, of more than 2500 m2, was established
merous springs in the area. Four building horizons on the top of a 0.20 m thick ‘‘hiatus layer’’, covering
have been recognised. The earliest, No. I, held re- the burned remains of the previous occupation. De-
mains of the Early Copper Age with excised pottery spite a significant temporal difference, this phase also
of Gradeshnitsa type. The houses are reported to be follows both the technological and the architectural
8–9 m long and 5–6 m wide, orientated E-W. The trends of the previous one in terms off coherent con-
internal space would have been approximately 37–38 centration of houses as well as a fixed spatial division
m2. The settlement ceased to exist after a major fire. of the settlement. Redutite III also had 5 rows of
Building horizon No. II of the Late Copper Age houses, but the area occupied by buildings was some-
was found directly on earlier settlement debris, which what displaced towards the South, as compared with
had suffered from subsequent levelling. Redutite II, the Redutite II settlement. The houses preserved an
also ending in a fire, appears to have been well pre- N-S orientation with a slight deviation towards the E,
served and provides valuable data on the spatial ar- but their size is smaller. The average internal area
rangement of a Copper Age settlement. The area was ranges between 27.60 and 28.00 m2, no doubt re-
occupied by structures extending over 3400 m2. The flecting a diminishing family size. The entrances of
settlement and its immediate activity zone ranged be- the houses were still located in the southern wall. The
tween 4700 and 4900 m2. The overall layout of settle- distance between the houses varies from 0.5 to 0.9 m,
ment corresponds with the concepts discussed above. but the ‘‘streets’’ are wider than previously, 3.5–4.5
The houses were organized in 5 rows, orientated N- m. This settlement was probably rather short-lived
S (with a slight deviation towards E) and separated by compared to Redutite II. Traces of rebuilding are few.
streets running E-W. The entrances were in the south- 28–31 houses might have existed at one time.
ern wall. The streets were about 3 m wide, varying Redutite IV was discovered directly on the burned
between 2.6 and 3.3 m. In the first layout, the dis- debris of the previous settlement. Despite a close
tance between the houses was only between 0.6 and stratigraphic relationship, Redutite IV demonstrates a
0.8 m, but the distance grew bigger in the course of clear break with Late Copper Age traditions, both in
rebuilding. When new houses were built in place of terms of pottery and in house orientation. The spatial
old ones the distance between houses could expand arrangement of the settlement is not known (unpub-
to 1.0–1.3 m, or more. Three procedures for building lished), but the houses were now orientated E-W, with
a new structure in the already established settlement entrances at the eastern side. The settlement was
were observed: The house could be built as a truly slightly displaced towards the South relative to the
Lı̂ga 43

Fig. III.5. Results of conventional and calibrated ages of samples available from Lı̂ga and Redutite. All dates cluster in three blocks, marked
with Roman numbers, which correspond to the cultural development attested at Lı̂ga 2, and Redutite II and III, respectively. Dates obtained
for Grave 1 demonstrate this grave’s contemporaneity with Redutite III.

previous ones, four houses were even discovered in liably dated through calcinated seeds. Two other C-
an area not used before. Detailed information is avail- 14 samples from Redutite were perhaps mistakenly
able on one house only (Gergov 1996). This is apsidal, attributed to Phase III instead of Phase II. The hiatus
7.30 m long (9.30 m with the apsidal end) and 4.90 layer between Redutite II and III is also observed in
m wide. The presence of vessels of so-called ‘‘Scheib- the calibrated radiocarbon dates; it is suggested to
enhenkel’’ type is clearly placing this settlement in the have lasted for ca. 300 years. Redutite III corresponds
Transitional Period between Late Copper Age and to the dates obtained for Lı̂ga Grave 1, which thus
Early Bronze Age. may be contemporary with the settlement of Redutite
Seven C-14 dates are available from Redutite (Fig. III occupational phase.
III.5). Taken in conjunction with Lı̂ga, the occu- Other Copper Age sites in a vicinity of Telish have
pational phases of the two sites were clearly inter- not provided any conclusive information on the use
linked. There is a smooth transition between Lı̂ga 2 of space within settlement. Little is known also on the
and Redutite II. Redutite II occupational phase is re- regional scale. A quite different pattern is seen in a
44 Acta Archaeologica

ment by a fence. The area used for building at Zami-


nets was around 2000 m2.
From all three occupation phases (A, B & C, A
being the oldest) at Zaminets comes remains of 12
houses. These were distributed in a relatively dis-
persed pattern, with distances ranging between 21⁄2
and 5 m. Of four square houses belonging to level B,
three were orientated E-W (entrances from E) and
one N-S (entrance from S). The external length was
ranging between 5.50 and 6.70 m, the width between
4.50 and 5.70 m. The mean internal space is 25.30
m2 (the scale of the published plan is unfortunately
not precise, the fault margin being about one quarter
of a metre in both directions). With such spacing, up
to 20–24 houses may have co-existed.
A system of trenches were also recorded at the epo-
nymic Late Copper Age site of Krivodol to the west
of Telish. Two parallel narrow moats were enclosing
the site from the N, and one deep and wide (up to 4
Fig. III.6. Plan of Hotnitsa, latest settlement phase, Horizon I. After m) trench from the E (personal observations made
MA theses of S. Makchev & A. Yordanova by permission from upon inspection of the damage made by intense
Historical Museum, Veliko Tarnovo. Courtesy: Historical Museum, trenching by modern looters).
Veliko Tarnovo. Looking even wider, the best comparative infor-
mation on the use of space is from Hotnitsa, Veliko
Tarnovo (Central Bulgaria), in spite of the fact that
the site is not related to the KSB culture (Fig. III.6).
partly published Late Copper Age settlement at Zam- The spatial organisation is well attested and has par-
inets (Nikolov 1975). Three occupational phases of allels to the sites at Telish. Consequently, the principal
Late Copper Age date were attested here, all burned spatial elements had common origin. Hotnitsa is a tell
down. The site is located on a rocky hill, elongated settlement, 5 m in height. The latest horizon, which
in N-S direction, with maximal dimensions of 70¿40 dates to the latest period of the Copper Age, held 22
m. The area is rich in springs. From N, W and S, the (in the publication 21) houses (Angelov 1958; 1959;
site is protected by steep, abrupt slopes, reaching 16 1961, and field reports). The total area of the site is
m in height, while on the E side, the hillock slopes 2440 m2, but the area used for building only com-
down gradually. The settlement was enclosed by a prises about 1750–1800 m2. The houses were orien-
palisade or fence, running along the edges of the hill, tated N-S, with entrances from the S, and arranged
as attested by postholes. On the southern slopes, al- in a uniform manner with axially cutting streets. Poss-
most in the middle, were traces of yet another parallel ibly, there is also evidence of rebuilt structures. As at
fence-like construction. The eastern land bridge was Telish, the largest houses tend to be placed centrally
fortified by two parallel deep moats and earthen walls (cf. below). The mean internal area of the structures
(towards the settlement) created by the excavated soil; is 30–31.5 m2.
a series of postholes were discovered on the top of In Eastern Serbia, the only certain information on
each wall, indicating the presence of more palisades. use of space at KSB sites is from Bubanj (Garašanin
The western end of the settlement site, measuring 1957; Tasić 1995). Three Copper Age houses were
40¿10 m, was left not built on. This space, similar in discovered, all rectangular. One had the internal di-
structure to the open space near the slopes at Lı̂ga, mensions of 6.4¿5.5 m, the available space being
was separated from the remaining part of the settle- 35.2 m2. The houses were orientated N-S and placed
Lı̂ga 45

‘‘rather close to each other’’ (Garašanin 1957; Tasić ponent in any settlement, provides personified testi-
1995). The entrances were from the S. This evidence monies, arrangements and contents. When conditions
seems to conform to the Bulgarian sites. of preservation are favourable, as at Lı̂ga, observa-
Romanian data on the use of space is limited to tions and interpretations at the household level are
Sălcuţa. Berciu reports that 16 ‘‘huts’’ were recorded indeed possible.
in 1951 from the Late Copper Age layers, primarily As one team of Copper Age architects was sticking
horizon IIc (Berciu 1961b). The maximum dimen- out the layout, moving from one plot to another,
sions were 2.7 m times 1.7 m, one metre wide en- others would already be starting to procure building
trances being in the southern walls. Abundant occur- materials for the dwellings. There was a need for in-
rence of burned wattle points towards a wattle and volvement of every community member. Regular
daub construction. The ‘‘huts’’ were organized along settlement layout and the manner of settlement ter-
an E-W line. However, the small size and irregularly mination – like the sudden abandonment of Lı̂ga 1
rounded shape of these structures, as reconstructed or the conflagration of Lı̂ga 2 – indicate that settle-
from a number of preserved postholes alone, sets ments were constructed communally over a short
doubts as to whether these features were correctly period of time and shared common fates.
interpreted. Reservation is strengthened by the re- Since the main building materials were clay and
mains of ovens. A rather well preserved lower part of water, these must have been among the dictating fac-
an oven was found in ‘‘Hut’’ no. 12. The dimensions tors of the location of the settlements. Both could be
of the oven were 1.5¿1.4 m, thus more than 2/3 of found at the foot of the Lı̂ga site. Procuring of wood
the presumed ‘‘hut’’. The opening of the oven is to- for timber frames and roof support, stones for founda-
wards the N, which contradicts the suggested south- tion, reed or straw for roofing in such an amount that
ern orientation of the entrance to the ‘‘hut’’. The it would satisfy the demands of the whole settlement
postholes are likely delineating workshop spaces (or would not have been unproblematic. It is known that
-platforms) rather than being house walls. each and every stone bigger than a fist was brought
to the site. It has also been established that the nearest
source of limestone, which was abundant enough to
ARCHITECTURE AND HOUSEHOLD supply material for house foundations, was almost 4
ORGANIZATION km to the South of the site. Whether this or even
HOUSE STRUCTURES further sources were used is unknown, but in any
Turning to the issues connected with architecture and case, such task would have been very difficult to ac-
the use of space within a built structure, it is import- complish without the use of tracking oxen. The dom-
ant to emphasize that house and settlement are con- inance of adult cattle in the bone sample confirms the
nected parts of the prehistoric perception of space. significance of these beasts in labour and not merely
Both reflect tradition, awareness, and adaptation. Al- in meat consumption (cf. Chapter X, on animal
though the borders between categories are not strict, bones). It has been calculated that the excavated area
it is believed that they reflect different levels of con- alone held some 200 kg stones.
sciousness when actions were taken during primary as Traces preserved of Lı̂ga 1 houses at the southern
well as secondary constitutional processes. Traditions slopes of the site bear witness to the use of robust
dictate the general layout of settlement, as has been poles for the walls, with a diameter of 20–25 cm. The
illustrated above. Awareness manifests itself in the po- foundations towards the slopes were stabilized, as can
sition of larger houses – for special peoples or house- be seen from a clayey trench 45 cm wide (preserved
holds – centrally in the settlement, while adaptation depth 17 cm). Thick debris of porous unbaked grey
can be noted in construction of smaller houses in in- clay was of course indicating the use of wattle and
hibiting areas like close to slopes. daub building techniques.
Settlement planning is often used to extract under- Prior to construction of the Lı̂ga 1 houses, flat ter-
standing of society as a whole, its social organisation, races were created. Some of the old surface soil was
and even cosmology. A built structure, a central com- removed, resulting in exposure of a layer of pebbles,
46 Acta Archaeologica

for instance in the northern periphery of the house, the case of Houses 1 and 3. The creation of level
outside its northern wall, where it was appreciated as surfaces led to differentiation in altitude, so that the
a natural pavement. The settlers were highly aware overall appearance of the new settlement would take
of this layer and tried to benefit by exposing it, espe- the form of a series of low staircases. For example,
cially in the interstructural areas. The regular manner the difference in level between the foundations and
of exposure even led to early conclusions during the floors of House 2 and its eastern neighbour, House 3,
excavation that the pavement was man-made. In fact, would have been 0.3 m. But the house situated North
the settlers also invested energy in creating stone of House 2, and on the same longitudinal line, would
pavements. A small such patch was investigated in an have appeared to be lying higher than House 2 and
area judged to be just outside the eastern wall of the at the same level as House 3.
excavated Lı̂ga 1 house (Fig. II.5). The pavement was Once the level surfaces were formed, actions were
made of well-sorted and water-rounded stones reach- taken to stabilize the foundations. Several technical
ing 10–12 cm in length. The full extent of the pave- solutions could be observed in the prime case of Lı̂ga
ment and its orientation are not known. 2. A thick layer of shards from the earliest occu-
The technological knowledge of the Lı̂ga 1 settlers pation was spread in the southwestern periphery of
is also manifested in compact lime-plastered floors in- House 1. This part of the house was the weakest as
side the houses, preserved in a patchy pattern at the it was lying very close to the rather steeply de-
same level as the said pavement. All traces of internal scending slope. Thus, the layer of shards helped to
arrangement were disturbed by the subsequent set- maintain a plain surface, stabilize the foundations,
tlers of Lı̂ga 2. In their attempt to even the terrain, and provide floor isolation. In the case of Houses 2
which no doubt had the hilly appearance of old house and 3, shallow trenches were dug and filled with a
mounds, they pushed part of the cultural debris for- compact layer of clay (Pl. 3). Some of that clay was
ward towards the edge of the southern slopes. This also spread inside House 2 in order to even the floor
material stayed together and has provided the largest level. Foundations and especially the corner areas
amount of small finds dated to the earliest settlement. were further strengthened with the help of rubble of
The length of the period between the two occu- limestone. Apparently, limestones for foundations
pations is, as mentioned, not known. Pottery suggests were used to a higher degree for the houses created
that essential changes in ceramic traditions had taken in areas without structural debris from the previous
place in the hiatus period. But both sets of pottery occupation, as was the case with the partly excavated
carry distinctive features of the KSB culture, and a houses in the northern periphery of the investigated
rather early AMS-date of Lı̂ga 2 suggests that the area. These houses were only outlined by rows of
temporal distance between the two settlements was limestones enclosing rather fragmented but compact
not significant. Also, the traces of the structural re- concentrations of pottery. Daub was only occasion-
mains of the Lı̂ga 1 occupation had not disappeared ally found here and only as a thin layer pointing to
at the time of the foundation of Lı̂ga 2. Timber intensive post-depositional destruction. Built on the
frames and poles could well have been visible (even original surface of the hillock with limited levelling
re-used after the abandonment), while unburned measures taken, these houses were protected by a
daub with organic temper would have made a very thinner layer of soil than the fully excavated ones
fertile ground for all sorts of bushy vegetation. further in. This demonstrates that the state of preser-
Such sites acted as supreme agents when support- vation might even be predetermined by circum-
ing local traditions and forming communal identities. stances prior to the construction of a structure.
In spite of its messy appearance and whatever senti- The foundation trenches varied from 0.3 to 0.4 m
ments nested in communal memory such a sight in width. Wooden poles with pointed ends were set
would awake, an old site had practical advantages into foundation. The majority of these were 8–9 cm
too. House mounds of unbacked clay could easily be in diameter. Occasionally, thicker poles, with the di-
transformed into flat platforms for new structures. ameter of 15 cm, were used. Samples of calcinated
The reuse of previous cultural debris was observed in wood collected in House 2 were determined by C.
Lı̂ga 47

Malmros as steming from hornbeam (Carpinus be-


tulus), but it is uncertain whether hornbeam was used
in house construction or as fire wood, since all pieces
were recovered from the area close to the oven. The
thinner poles were grouped in pairs, the distance be-
tween them being about 10–15 cm. The poles were
interwoven with rods and twigs and plastered with
daub. Since all lumps of burned daub were collected,
it was possible to differentiate between various types
of daub matrix in terms of composition. It appeared
that the core area of a wall, at least at the level of
foundation (the preserved parts of walls did not ex-
ceed 0.2 m) was plastered with daub containing
quartz grains 2–4 mm in size as the main tempering
Fig. III.7. Lump of daub with impression of ear of wheat, most
material. Identification of this core helped to establish likely emmer.
the precise course of walls in places of thick accumu-
lation of burned daub. Generally, daub with an ad-
mixture of 15–20% of chopped straw was applied. It
has been calculated that a standard house in the Lı̂ga possibility of being einkorn (Triticum monococum). It
2 settlement would require between 9.6 and 11.6 m3 should be added that all pieces of daub were collected
of non-organic building components. and studied. No traces of colouring was ever found,
The clay deposits at Lı̂ga appear as a homogeneous indicating that the structures appeared as grey boxes.
layer with occasional inclusions of red (haematite) or The roof was supported by internal posts. Of actual
orange (goethite) ochre as well as other ferrous ac- postholes, which could be attributed to the roof sup-
cumulations in the form of thin oxidised flakes. These porting construction, only two were found: one in
were found abundantly in the destruction debris. House 1 and another in House 2, both in the form of
House walls were reaching 0.35–0.40 m in thickness remains of massive poles, 25 cm in diameter, placed
at the foundation level, even though the intended directly on the floor and supported by stones. In the
thickness was not exceeding 0.32 m. Higher up, the case of House 2, the post was supported by fragments
walls must have been less massive, bearing in mind of the same sandstone rock, shaped to correspond
the relative lightness of the timber frame. Compact with the rounded form of the post. Consequently, the
flakes of daub without any admixture point towards discovered sandstone rocks were affected by the high
a clay coating of the walls. Investigation of the recov- temperatures of the final fire and had cracked. Apart
ered lumps of daub have also provided evidence that from that, no other certain traces of internal posts
freshly harvested straws were used for tempering, were found, but the presence of flat limestones inside
pointing to the particular period of the year for house the houses indicate that other posts were resting on
construction. One of the lumps contained part of an such, thus protected from decay.
ear with the grains still sitting in it at the time of daub Little is known about the roofs themselves, except
tempering (Fig. III.7). A wintering ear would not be that clay-plastered wooden logs made up part of the
able to keep its grains due to low temperatures and interior construction. This observation is inferred
humidity. S. Karg, assisted by E. Koch (4), who made from severely burned fragments of daub with imprints
a cast of the hole made by the ear, has established of parallel logs some 10 cm in diameter, as well as
that the ear in question with all probability stems pieces of calcinated timbers found stratigraphically
from emmer wheat (Triticum diccocum), with a slight high in layers of daub. It is also safe to assume that
houses had gabled roofs, as indicated by clay models.
4. The author is grateful to Dr. Eva Koch for making a silicone A highly informative collection of models was dis-
cast of the cavities in the fragment of daub. covered at Kodžadermen (Fig. III.8) (Gaul 1948). Re-
48 Acta Archaeologica

totally new structure. The present owners could not


recall having seen the construction of the daubed
houses in their possession and assumed that they were
built by their parents or grandparents. Thus, the age
of these houses can be estimated to be at least 40 or
50 years (corresponding to the age of the informers).
The clay for recent daubing was mixed with dung
from herbivorous animals, amounting to approxi-
mately 1/5 of the total mass. Animal dung was con-
sidered to be a better admixture than chaff, which
required additional preparation. The owners were
usually complaining about tramped floors, which
have an uneven, pitted surface: once a floor is tramp-
ed, it is impossible to even the surface effectively.
‘‘New clay’’ will not adhere to the old surface in de-
pressions, so levelling of a floor would require plaster-
Fig. III.8. Clay models of houses discovered in the Late Copper ing of the whole area, not just patches.
Age tell at Kodžadermen. After Gaul 1948. The recent gabled roofs were supported by a struc-
ture of posts and beams with the bark peeled off, con-
nected in the manner of ‘‘a matchstick-house’’, i.e.,
gardless their makers, repetition of the same house without use of nails. In case of an earthquake such a
form indicates that the models can be treated as a structure would shake, but not collapse, the informers
convincing and undistorted source of information on said. The round posts had a diameter of approximate-
the general appearance of the structures. Flat roofs ly 15 cm and were supported by flat limestones, since
would also be a serious limitation in terms of finding direct contact with the floor would cause them to rot.
an effective solution to the issue of smoke circulation. This observation was actually used to interpret the
Evidence from archaeological data has been much presence of flat limestones within the houses of Lı̂ga
extended by experimental archaeology, in particular 2 and justified the limited number of postholes.
concerning the nature of prehistoric architecture, Some ideas about house construction, like organis-
building techniques, living conditions, crafts, etc. ation of labour, consumption of building materials,
(Hansen 1961; Pleinerová 1986). Nevertheless, the use of tools, and even living conditions, can also be
best parallels to the data from Lı̂ga are found in re- grasped from the superb Březno experiments de-
cent Bulgarian villages, where daubed houses are a signed to reconstruct semi-subterranean Slavic houses
common sight. Even a short inspection of a few of the from Chechy (Pleinerová 1986). In their use of basic
houses in Telish will promote an understanding of the materials, these houses resemble the prehistoric wattle
principles behind Copper Age dwellings substantially. and daub constructions at Lı̂ga.
Direct parallels were cautiously avoided, but some of The Březno team demonstrated that daubing of
the constructional elements did seem to correspond wattle walls was one of the very last tasks in the con-
very well with the uncovered traces at Lı̂ga. The in- structional chaı̂ne opératoire. It also required a par-
spected houses nowadays serve as storage sheds, so ticular pace, since wattle work can only support a layer
their maintenance is less meticulous (and their use of a certain strength, which has to dry somewhat before
perhaps also less intense) than in the case of dwelling a new layer can be added. I. Pleinerová notes that posts
houses. Occasionally a new layer of daub was added with bark not integrated in daub walls would attract
to close the cracks in the walls, but no one, when wood-eating insects, a circumstance that indicates a
asked, reported that wattle or posts were being re- high demand at Lı̂ga for debarking tools, such as flint
placed during restoration. The usual reply is that in scrapers, which actually are very numerous in the flint
such a case one would feel the necessity to build a assemblage (cf. Chapter VII, below).
Lı̂ga 49

The experiments also gave a hint on the consump- tion of smoke is an important problem. The optimal
tion of materials. A 4.5¿4.2 m wattle and daub house solution seems to be the construction of apertures in
with 15 cm thick walls and a height of 3 m at the the gables of the roof and relatively low-sitting win-
ridge point requires 2.5 m3 wood, 1200 branches dows, so that the colder air stream might push up
(1.5–1.8 m long and 1.5 cm thick) of wattle, 3–4 m3 the smoke (Pleinerová 1986). However, despite much
clay, and 1000 m2 of harvested roofing reeds. A simi- effort, a layer of smoke will always accumulate under
lar house roofed with rye straws also required har- the roof. At Lejre, it has been established that this
vesting of an area of 1000 m2 (present yields). actually is favourable for drying of food-stuffs or for
Such estimations raise serious doubts about the tra- hide smoking, but the amount of CO gasses could be
ditional assumption of reed/straw roofing of Copper fatal for humans.
Age houses. It must have been a very laborious, even House 3 at Lı̂ga contained evidence that the roof
impossible task to meet the demands of just one small construction might have been extended to cover the
settlement. The house models are rather taciturn on entrance of the house, thus creating a sheltered space
the issue of roofing, aside from a few exceptions (e.g., outside it. The assumption is based on the row of
Kodžadermen), where parallel traverse incisions on postholes, 15 cm in diameter, recorded ca. 1 m from
the roof might be interpreted as planks or beams (Fig. the southern wall of the structure (Fig. III.9). Other
III.8). houses were perhaps also porched, but their sur-
In terms of thermic features, the Březno experi- roundings were not investigated, since the excavated
ments demonstrated that roofing was the decisive fac- sondages only disclosed the limits of house walls.
tor in the time needed to heat a house as well as in Thus, the house reconstructions presented here rest
the ability to sustain temperature (Pleinerová 1986). on a complementary base, evidence being combined
Thick roof covers would provide better isolation, but, from both Houses 2 & 3, and supported by evidence
in turn, also an excessive amount of fuel in case of a recovered in House 1. Internal arrangements, as well
fire. Estimations were also made on amount of wood as types and distribution of pottery, are individual for
required for heating (Pleinerová 1986). Although the each house reconstruction; they rest upon the actual
experimental structure was semi-subterranean and situation upon discovery. The reconstructions are per-
therefore thermally somewhat protected, the amounts formed by Architect R. Steponaitis (5)
used for the experiment indicate that when the out-
side temperature was below zero, intensive heating of
a house of ca. 42 m3 (by 0.083 m3 wood in a dome INTERIORS
oven of 0.90 m2) could provide internal temperatures All houses in Lı̂ga were single-roomed. However, the
of up to 7–14 æC. The firewood used just for cooking internal space was subdivided into specific task zones
would, on a yearly basis for one household, reach (Fig. III.10). Such segregation followed the accepted
some 18 m3. The floor space behind the oven, which traditions at the time but was also adapted to the indi-
was placed directly on the floor, remained cold even vidual needs of each household. Occasionally, a relo-
when the fire was lit. At Březno, it was also estab- cation of activity zones was taking place. Among the
lished that two adults and three children would need few immovable house installations was the oven. The
3.0–3.5 m2 of space for their sleeping arrangements size of the oven corresponds to the size of the house,
(Pleinerová 1986). thus, the largest structure (House 3) also had the
A series of climate experiments carried out at the largest oven with dimensions of 1.5¿1.3 m (Fig.
Lejre Experimental Centre, Denmark in 1998–2003 III.11 & 12). A well-preserved smaller oven was dis-
confirm the findings from Březno (N.A. Møller, Cop- covered in House 2, the dimensions being 1.25¿1.15
enhagen university, personal comm.). At Lejre, it was m. Only the floor of the oven could be discerned from
demonstrated that the heating effect of taking animals
into a structure is limited, increasing the room tem- 5. The author is grateful to Architect Rimas Steponaitis for hypo-
perature with one degree, at most. thetical reconstructions of houses and their interiors. Contact
Both projects have demonstrated that the circula- information: www.worldarchaeology.net
50 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. III.9. Suggested reconstruction of Lı̂ga 2 house, based on data recovered from House 3, but complemented by evidence recorded in
other houses. Reconstruction of internal arrangements of pottery, types of pottery and other finds are presented according to excavated data.
Reconstruction drawn by R. Steponaitis.
Lı̂ga 51

Fig. III.10. Suggested reconstruction of Lı̂ga 2 house, based on data recovered from House 2, but complemented by evidence recorded in
other houses. Reconstruction of internal arrangement of pottery, types of pottery and other finds are presented according to excavated data.
Reconstruction drawn by R. Steponaitis.
52 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. III.11. House 3, view from the East.

the surrounding debris of burned daub in House 1, diameter. The clay held organic temper in smaller
and its size cannot be established with certainty. amounts than the daub used for walls. The clay used
It was an accepted principle governing the use of for the base of the oven was tempered with sand and
internal space to place the oven at the rear end of the quartz grains of 2–4 mm.
room, in fact at the middle of the interior northern The ovens in Houses 2 and 3 underwent restora-
wall and up 1 m from it. The oven was opposite of tion, indicating a prolonged used of the device. On
the entrance of the house situated in the southern one such occasion, the case of House 3, a layer of
wall. The only deviation was met in House 1, where shards was incapsulated in the dome by the new layer
the oven was placed at the western wall. No evidence of clay lining. This must have improved the thermal
of the entrance has been discovered in this case. How- properties of the oven, prolonging the period of heat
ever, it can be assumed that access from the South radiation. In the better preserved Houses 2 and 3, a
would have been complicated due to slopes, and clay plug was found at the ovens, respectively 11 and
heaps of waste along the northern wall of the house 13 cm in diameter (Fig. III.13:2, 3). Such plugs were
was hardly indicative in terms of an entrance, making used for closing the oven holes at the top, made to
the eastern wall, and an eastern entrance, the most improve the draft. In both cases the plugs were
likely suggestion. The ovens were constructed on the located ca. 1 m away from the ovens, likely indicating
floor by first erecting a slightly raised platform of that fire was set at the time of the conflagration of
some 15 cm; the opening is towards the room. The the whole settlement. Also a fire-vessel (cf. below) was
ovens were oval in shape and domed. Linings suggest found in close association with the ovens (Fig.
an about 1 cm thick layer of clay plaster covering the III.13:1 & III.14).
core of the oven walls, made of twigs ca. 1–1.5 cm in This accessory set may be extended with clay tubes,
Lı̂ga 53

Fig. III.12. House 3, remains of the oven.

Fig. III.13. Items related with handling of fire. 1 – fire-vessel, 2, 3 – oven plugs, 4 – fragment of a clay tube, presumably used for bellows.
54 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. III.15. House 1, internal daub walls.

tine – were found (Fig. III.15). The two walls were


only preserved to a height of 0.15 m. The longer wall,
Fig. III.14. Fire-vessel used to preserve fire by covering ember, thus
limiting supply of oxygen. House 2. running E-W, i.e., parallel to the northern wall of the
house, was ca. 0.80 m long and 0.10 thick. Perhaps
its western end was supported by a massive, likely
roof-supporting post. Part of the installation was cov-
which are often interpreted as phallos symbols and ered by a thick layer of burned daub, which hamper-
seen as counterparts to the common so-called ed a detailed study of the division. The shorter wall
‘‘Mother Goddess’’ figurines, nettling many scholars running N-S was at least 0.60 m long and presumably
(Todorova 1986; Gergov 2000) (Fig. III.13:4). A prag- had a thickness of 0.15 m.
matic interpretation would connect the ‘‘phalloi’’ with House 2 was equipped with a grain pithos, which
metallurgy, seeing them as parts of bellows. The latter made up an important part of the immovable inven-
idea is supported by ethnographical observations and tory. Although the vessel was crushed by a fallen wall,
by smith-graves (Shilov 1975). Nonetheless, modern dimensions could be estimated from the preserved
records on African traditional metallurgical practices, fragments. The pithos had an oval shape, ca. 1 m
magics, and beliefs also support a phallic meaning of long and 0.70 m high. It was placed at the eastern
clay tubes, placing them in a humanized universe wall and surrounded by seven smaller vessels (Fig.
where a melting furnace is considered a female and III.16 & III.17). In spite of high expectations (the
the bellows a male element (e.g., De Barros 1997). pithos had a capacity 500 liters), even soil flotation
The only find of a clay tube at Lı̂ga was made close did not produce any palaeobotanical residue.
to the oven of House 1, suggesting that it may have The storage containers in House 3 were found in
belonged to a household bellows used to rekindle the the same part of the house as above, i.e., close to the
fire from glowing cinders maintained with the help of eastern wall (Fig. III.9). Only one might have been
fire-vessels (see below). Still, the find of three copper dug into the soil, as its base was almost four times
items (see below) in House 1 may support a metallur- narrower than the opening, the height being ca. 75
gical link. cm. The remaining vessels in this cluster – at least
A formal division of space was found in House1, 13 – were not arranged in a particular pattern. On
but its purpose is not clear, nor how high this division the western side of the oven, in the NW corner of the
originally was. Two perpendicular daub walls created house was a permanent installation for grinding: a
an enclosure in the northern part of the room in circular platform, ca. 1 m in diameter enclosed to-
which three ceramic vessels – one deep bowl and two wards the room by a 20 cm high and 5–8 cm thick
big poorly backed containers decorated with barbo- wall (Fig. III.18). The platform was left open at the
Lı̂ga 55

Fig. III.16. House 2, remains of pithos with adjacent vessels.

southern side. Within this enclosure was found a on these. A beam above the oven in House 2 must
massive milling stone (lower part) with a deep use- have been decorated with a clay anthropomorphic
wear depression. Two smaller milling stones (upper figurine, stringed up through suspension holes in the
parts) were discovered close by. item (Fig. VI.2). But apart from this, all other finds
The other houses did not produce any grinding in- were found directly on the floor with no apparent use
stallations and only held finds of hand stones, placed of platforms, tables, or the like. In House 2 were also
at the storage vessels. However, the presence of mass- two limestone rocks – a triangular flat one and a
ive grinding stones, too weighty to reflect significant smaller rounded one – shaped to fit each other. Their
post-depositional transportation, in the ‘‘street’’ area association with the group of vessels at the entrance
indicates that grinding was also carried out outdoors. may indicate that they were meant to sit on, likely
Investigations of artefact distributions, including re- when eating (Fig. III.20).
cordings of the angles of items, point to the existence The most favourable conditions of preservation
of some sort of shelves. Usually, such shelves were were met in Houses 2 and 3. These multi-functional
installed at the eastern wall, as in Houses 3 and 4 buildings were structured somewhat differently in-
(Fig. III.9, III.19 & Pl. 5). The shelves were perhaps ternally, but followed the same mental concepts on
intended as ‘‘exhibition cases’’ for display of the finest the use of space. The simple Copper Age architecture
pottery, but also a necessity to save limited space. At was housing an inherited order, which allowed each
least 15 vessels in House 3 must have been stacked individual household to subscribe to common norms
on such shelves above the big storage containers. The and communal identities. All adaptations and relo-
house walls were also decorated with hanging bowls, cations were undertaken within such framework, but
often reaching 40 cm in diameter (all perforated be- in spite of the uniformity reflected in settlement layout
low the lip with a single hole and with traces of abra- and principles governing the location of household
sions on the back side), much like souvenir plates installations, there was also room for competition and
nowadays. Shelves were probably also installed be- rivalry, as seen in the particular inventory of the indi-
tween the posts supporting the roof construction. vidual house (see below).
Some of the stone implements were probably placed The main axis of the structures is the N-S line
56 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. III.18. Milling platform discovered in the Late Copper Age


tell at Kodžadermen. A similar one was found in House 3 (after
Gaul 1948).

cluding fragments of a big closed water jar found in


Fig. III.17. House 2, the finest vessel of this house was found at the four separate clusters (Fig. III.22 & Pl. 11:1).
pithos, facing the oven.
The floors of the houses were kept clean. In few
areas where parts of unburned floors were recognised
(as a grey greenish clay), even thorough examination
traced between the entrance and the oven, situated brought surprisingly modest results. Apart from the
at opposite ends of the room. Along the eastern wall, flint chips recorded in House 2, the floor debris only
at the oven, was an area assigned for long-term stor- comprised of a few pieces of flints not exceeding the
age, be it food-stuffs or the inedible valuables of the size of a fingernail.
house. Thus, grain bins and shelves, which displayed Besides the utilitarian or potentially utilitarian in-
the finest pottery were discovered there. Notably, the ventory of the structures, it was evident that the
most beautiful vessel found in House 2 was standing houses also held religious elements. House 2 was
at the immovable grain pithos (Fig. III.16 & 17). The equipped with a hanging anthropomorphic figurine,
area west of the oven was connected with food prep- fastened to one of the logs above and to the West of
aration and short-term storage. The grinding instal- the oven. Unfortunately, only the lower half of the
lation of House 3 was found here. The same space in figurine was discovered (Fig. VI.2), but its position
House 2 was occupied by three big open vessels and within the structure as well as use-wear traces around
a smaller one, containing 13 oblong, waterworn a hole made in the area of the feet were convincing
pebbles and a small biconic cup (see below). Other indications of the place of the figurine in the house.
vessels further along the western wall indicate that In the NE part of the partly excavated House 4,
also this area was used for preparation of food, likely surrounded by bowls and pots, was a completely pre-
soaking of cereals or the like. A well-preserved con- served figurine, a so-called ‘‘Sitting Goddess’’ (Fig.
centration of vessels was discovered at the southern III.23). Next to the figurine was a ‘‘bowl’’, which ap-
wall of House 2, not far from the entrance. The situ- peared to be the reversed lower part of the similar
ation exposed during excavation looked almost figurine, containing an egg-like object in clay. The
staged: surrounded by bowls and a closed vessel, a big display is no doubt original, miraculously escaping re-
open vessel, resembling a Late Medieval soup tureen, cent agricultural trench digging by less than 5 cm (Pl.
held an intact spoon (Fig. III.21). Were these the ves- 5). The head of the figurine was recovered ca. one
tiges of a last meal? That eating was taking place in metre North of the body, smoothly cut through the
the southern end of the house, is perhaps confirmed neck by ploughing. The figurine was facing south, to-
by the partially preserved pottery from House 3, in- wards the presumed entrance. Behind it were five bi-
Lı̂ga 57

Fig. III.19. A set of five biconic cups fallen from a shelf-like installation at the E wall of House 4. Note flint blade and end-scraper (with
upward ventral side). See also Pl. 4.

conic cups, stacked one in the other (Fig. III.19). small personal treasures like a collection of long
These must have fallen from a shelf at the eastern blades, kept together in a leather pouch, masterly
wall, above the figurine. Together with the cups were crafted figurines and toys – all were left behind (Fig.
a flint blade and an end-scraper. Close to the stacked III.21 & III.24). The available data are of course
cups were another two cups of the same type. These limited to the three fully excavated and individually
seven cups may even point to the number of inhabi- furnished houses with differing histories of preser-
tants in the house. vation. But it seems that inhabitants of House 1, at
The described displays are thus a reflection of the the margins of the settlement, had some time to col-
multifunctional nature of the Copper Age house, lect their valuables, as can be observed from the
where the utilitarian and the ritual spheres are inte- limited quantity and types of small finds recovered
grated parts of the domus (sensu Hodder 1990). Neigh- when compared with the other two structures. All
bouring Redutite may even have revealed permanent houses experienced the same degree of burning,
installations related to Copper Age rituals. One of the reaching in some places temperatures up to 1500 de-
houses in Horizon III contained a clay stela, inter- grees, as can be judged from pieces of clay slag, espe-
preted as an alter (Gergov 1992b). This was standing cially from House 1 – in fact indicating that fire must
at the northern wall, surrounded by apparent dom- have started from the roof. An experiment at Lejre,
estic pottery. Demark has demonstrated that the effects of a fire are
The Lı̂ga 2 settlement was abandoned as the result much less tangible in wattle and daub houses if
of a destruction caused by a great general fire. The started from the floor level of a house (Hansen 1961).
exposed remains point to a sudden and unexpected The collapsed walls were decisive in preservation
start of the fire, most probably somewhere close to of artefacts. Thus, the eastern wall of House 1, falling
the centre of settlement. Vessels, stone and bone tools, inwards, together with the roof, sealed all inventory
58 Acta Archaeologica

gration, in Redutite all four (including both the Late


Copper Age ones) (Gergov 1992a), in Krivodol all five
(Nikolov 1984), in Sadovec-Ezero four out of six, in
Zaminec all three (Nikolov 1975), just to mention a
few of the Late Copper Age examples. Thus, at least
80% of the well-studied KSB settlements ended up in
flames. In other regions the percentage seems lower,
however. The Copper Age tells of NE Bulgaria, sys-
tematically investigated in the 1970s and -80s, dem-
Fig. III.20. Two lime stones shaped to fit each other, found in
House 2, together with a group of vessels. onstrate that only 33% of the Late Copper Age settle-
ment phases show traces of great fires (the available
data mainly belongs to the earliest phase of KGK VI)
(Todorova 1982). The percentage is even lower in the
in the eastern part of this structure. Favourable con- earlier part of the period.
ditions were also created by the collapse of the west- Different explanations for great fires have been put
ern wall of House 3. This wall covered the oven and forward, ranging from hostile attacks to ritual acts. It
the items adjacent to it. The eastern part of the house cannot be excluded that hostile attacks were a real
was also covered in destruction debris, some of it threat in the Copper Age. It is also possible that a
coming from the roof. The eastern wall of House 2 ritualised perception of settlement was common, see-
collapsed in eastern direction, creating a cover for the ing houses and objects as living organisms, which are
refuse accumulated in the adjacent intrastructural born and can die, even create a line of heritage
space. Seemingly, some parts of the walls of House 2 (Bailey 1990; 1996; Chapman 2000).
remained standing after the fire faded and created M. Stevanović, studying conflagrated Neolithic
sheltered areas for an accumulation of soil, which also Vinča houses, is seeing these as expressions of prac-
filled the cavities of the said oven, preserving to some tices to assure continuity and visibility in the mne-
extent the original shape of the dome. monic domain of society; thus, she is suggesting that
Wattle and daub houses were also built by the Ro- conflagration should be regarded as a cultural trait
mans. Vitruvius, the famous First century BC Roman among early agricultural communities (Stevanović
engineer and architectural theorist, considered such 1997). To support the claim that houses were burned
structures a cheap but dangerous substitute to adobe individually (hence destroyed deliberately in a con-
houses. He wrote, ‘‘As for ‘wattle and daub’ I could trolled fashion), she refers to the lack of effect on
wish that it had never been invented. The more it soils in areas between houses, as demonstrated by
saves in time and gains in space, the greater and the examples at Opovo, Yugoslavia. However, recent
more general is the disaster that it may cause; for it experimental work on the effects of fire on soils have
is made to catch fire, like torches. It seems better, proved that thermal transformation only occurs in
therefore, to spend on walls of burnt brick, and be at very rare cases, e.g, on ferruginous soils which are
expense, than to save with ‘wattle and daub’, and be influenced by heating above 500 æC (Canti & Lin-
in danger. And, in the stucco covering, too, it makes ford 2001). Therefore, the only certain way to sus-
cracks from the inside by the arrangement of its studs tain the idea of controlled conflagrations is to dem-
and girts. For these swell with moisture as they are onstrate that a house, or a group of houses, in a
daubed, and then contract as they dry, and by their settlement were singled out to be put on fire.
shrinking, cause the solid stucco to split’’ (Vitruvius, Such practices were actually carried out at the
‘‘De Architectura’’ II.viii.20, pp. 57–58, as cited by Danish Iron Age village of Hodde (2nd century BC–
Rapp 2002, 265). 1st century AD), where conflagration was an instru-
It was almost a rule rather than an exception that ment of control of space (Hvass 1985). As regards tell
a Copper Age settlement was terminated by fire. At settlements, clearing an area by burning decaying
Lı̂ga, one out of two settlements ended in confla- houses also seems to be the best choice in terms of
Lı̂ga 59

Fig. III.21. A group of vessels discovered inside House 2, at the entrance. A spoon was found in a big vessel – a ‘‘soup terrine’’. Traces of
the last meal?

time and energy spent. Indeed, several such sites, e.g., etons were covered by Late Copper Age house debris,
the Copper Age Ruse tell, NE Bulgaria, hold evi- pointing towards a violent death, as is also supported
dence on partial burning, of whatever nature (Bojad- by skeletal analyses (Matsanova 2000 & pers.comm.
žiev 2001; Georgiev & Angelov 1957). Possibly, also and observation). This indirectly contradicts Stevano-
the Ovčarovo VII settlement of Middle Copper Age vić’s adjunct suggestion that the amount of organic
date was partially burned (Todorova 1982). But the material used in wattle and daub architecture was not
total abandonment of KSB settlements in the wake of large enough to serve as fuel to bake the clay to a
great fires calls for other explanations. reddened state (Stevanović 1997).
Regarding hostile attacks, such may have taken Based on the observations at Lı̂ga 2, a ritual reason
place without leaving traces of human victims. In fact, for the conflagration, which terminated the settle-
only at the tells of Hotnitsa (Angelov 1958) and Yun- ment, cannot be established. Rather, the evidence
atsite, and possibly also Ruse, as demonstrated by the supports evacuation at the time of the breaking out
latest re-evaluation of the excavation results (Todoro- of fire, a situation similar to the one recorded at the
va 1986; Matsanova 2000; Bojadžiev 2001), skeletons fully excavated Redutite settlement (Gergov 1992a).
were found inside the burned structures. These skel- Bearing in mind the high numbers of conflagration
60 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. III.22. Water jar discovered in four separate clusters in House 3. Reconstruction is presented in Plate 11:1.

cases, a ritual activity of such a nature would point probably intact (many of the items were indeed unaf-
towards a self-destructive even suicidal psychology of fected or only modestly affected by fire), but there
society, which is unlikely. Rejuvenation acts might were no signs of pragmatic actions to fetch or look
have been refreshing, but regular starts from scratch for re-usable items.
were probably perceived as a frightening perspective. Some estimation can also be made on human re-
In fact, each generation of the KSB culture was prob- sources employed. It has been generally accepted that
ably marked by such unhappy conflagration experi- the smallest socio-economic unit of early agricultural
ences. societies is the household, comprising a nucleated or
Indeed, the fires should rather be regarded as acci- extended family (Tringham & Krstić 1990). Acknowl-
dents, feared and real, as described by Vitruvius. Nu- edging the conceptual complexity of the term (cf.
cleated settlements situated on elevated sites have en- Sahlins 1972), in this study, a household is taken to
joyed fresh winds from the plains, which would pro- be a kin-based residential group (Tringham & Krstić
mote the spread of fire within a settlement, especially 1990), which integrates all members, also the aged
during the summer when the house walls were dried and the children. The integration is sustained by com-
of winter humidity. mon housing, involvement in daily activities, and in
Modern thatchers, advertising their roofing ser- caring. Although division of household activities is
vices, always start by naming their means of pre- confined to a rather speculative level in archaeology,
caution against fire. Some make a layer of gypsum, or the internal installations and inventories at Lı̂ga clear-
use other recently developed fire-resistant materials. ly indicate the autonomous nature of the social units,
Perhaps this explains why every wooden pole at Lı̂ga, which inhabited the architectural spaces. Hence, in
even in the roof, was plastered with clay: isolation this very particular case, it is possible to employ house
measures that were also fire protecting. What remains and household as synonyms.
puzzling, however, is that when a conflagrated settle- Estimations of household sizes vary between 3–5
ment was abandoned, there was no looking back, as persons (basic family) to 6–8 (extended family)
if taboo laws were protecting its contents. At Lı̂ga, (Chapman 1981; Tripković 2003). Recently, these
some of the house inventories stayed exposed and numbers have been supported by an excavations at
Lı̂ga 61

Fig. III.23. ‘‘The Sitting Goddess’’ discovered in House 4.

the tell of Yunatsite, Pazardjik (Matsanova 2000). In layout of E-W ‘‘streets’’ and structures orientated N-
layers belonging to the final Late Copper Age settle- S. Generally, there was a marked differentiation in
ment (originally occupying ca. 0.85 ha), skeletal re- house size. Six of the houses contained skeletal re-
mains of 41 individuals were found (Matsanova mains (although some were lacking a full set of
2000, Fig. 1; partly preserved remains, like skulls, bones, perhaps an indication of scavenging by wild
are included in this number). 28 persons were found animals after the abandonment of the settlement).
lying on house floors, often on top of fragmented or The skeletal finds between the burned houses, as
intact ceramic vessels, and covered with burned stated by V. Matsanova, are proper burials where
architectural debris. Several skeletons were found in the body was put into a hocker position and ac-
unnatural postures, some bearing traces of fire. One companied by grave goods, usually pottery. The
male had clear signs of head injuries. This remark- scenario thus implies a return of the surviving part
able discovery is the first well-documented testimony of the community, giving proper treatment to their
to inter-communal clashes in the prehistory of Bul- dead members. This in itself is a significant state-
garia. Moreover, it provides evidence on the num- ment about social behaviour of a Copper Age popu-
ber of inhabitants attached to each house. Remains lation, indicating that the apparent lack of burials in
of nine houses were recorded, but only one was in- the region, including the Thracian plain, with the
vestigated fully. The rest were either eroded to vary- exception of NE Bulgaria (the famous Varna graves),
ing degrees, lying at slopes, destroyed by later should not be taken as negative evidence but rather
trenches, or lying partly in the not yet investigated as an archaeological problem. One house contained
half of the settlement. The houses were arranged in skeletal remains of two individuals, two houses of
a rather dispersed pattern, although with the usual four, while the remaining three houses contained re-
62 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. III.24. Eight flint blades and part of a blade (proximal end) found together at the oven in House 3. These were most likely kept together
in a pouch, perhaps made of leather or other perishable material. Note also the oven plug.

spectively five, six and seven individuals, including 100–150 individuals. This is in accordance with im-
children. Bearing in mind the total number of indi- plications from recent studies in brain development
viduals (41), divided among nine houses, the average and social interaction – larger populations having
household amounts to 41⁄2 individuals, plus the sur- difficulties in functioning as one.
vivors. Probably the larger houses also held more R. Dunbar has thus noticed a strong correlation
people than the smaller ones. between the social behaviour of primates and the size
The mean available house space of a settlement of their neocortex, suggesting that the need to in-
can also be used to predict the size of the com- crease group size, and hence social complexity, acted
munity. According to R. Naroll, one individual aver- as a mechanism of selection in the evolvement of
ages 10 m2 (external measures), including storage, large neocortices (Dunbar 1995; 1996). Establishing a
stables etc. (Naroll 1962). The latter are not present neocortex ratio to the rest of the brain as 1:4, he pre-
at Lı̂ga where each person, on the average, may dicts that the most effectively functioning human
have required only half this space or slightly more. group will consist of approximately 150 members (i.e.,
The Lı̂ga 2 houses, of 30–40 m2 internally and 40– three times as many as chimpanzees). Apparently,
50 m2 externally, may thus have accommodated an such prediction of the optimum group size is sup-
extended family of about seven individuals. Ac- ported by grouping patterns prevalent at different
cepting the size of the household as 5–7, it is ex- levels of human society, as exemplified by Dunbar’s
pected that a whole settlement the size of Lı̂ga 2, research on modern and historic data.
i.e., composed of 20–22 houses, had a population of The main challenge of the Lı̂ga project was to un-
Lı̂ga 63

cover and study the structural remains in their full Nevertheless, it is already now possible to state that
extent, attempting not only to look at the variations the conceptual starting point for Redutite was the
in pottery production but also to recognize the set- same as for Lı̂ga. For instance, it has been revealed
tings in which the pottery was used. Allowing a in discussions with the excavator that, among other
friendly irony towards local passion for pottery re- similarities with Lı̂ga, the houses at Redutite also had
search (perfectly understandable in the light of the ovens installed at the middle of the northern wall,
amount and apparent approachability of pottery as a entrances in the southern one (cf. Gergov 1992a).
source of information), efforts were made at Lı̂ga to Some confusion has been created in the termin-
include other ‘‘tokens’’, with equal degree of atten- ology used to describe building techniques. For in-
tion, into the universe created by the pottery. stance, V. Gergov, when discussing the findings at Re-
The anthropology of technology offers an instru- dutite, mentions that a special building technique was
mental approach aiding in recognition of social applied to erect the houses (Gergov 1992a; 1994,
groups through analyses of mundane products such as 304). Without definition, and with a mere reference
utilitarian pottery, tools, and architecture (Lemonnier to the structures at various Tripolye sites excavated
1992). It is believed that social information is stored by T. Passek half a century ago, he applies the term
in the steps and choices made during manufacture as ‘‘glinobitna’’ in Russian. At the same time, Gergov
well as use of material culture (Stark et al. 1995; with mentions the use of poles (7–12 cm in diameter) dug
references). Such behavioural variation reflected in into foundation trenches at every 50–60 cm., and that
the material culture is determining what is named a the dwellings of each Redutite settlement were
technological style. Architecture is considered the burned, hence the good preservation (Gergov 1992a;
most complex although also the most informative me- 1994, 304). ‘‘Glinobitna’’ in Russian should be trans-
dium of technological style (Stark et al. 1995). Con- lated as pisé or terre pisé (6). Therefore, H. Todorova,
struction techniques, choice of materials, and use of in her presentation of the prehistoric development of
domestic space are traits that demonstrate a particu- Bulgaria, writes that ‘‘the buildings excavated in Tel-
lar resilience to change (as opposed to stylistic vari- ish have thick clay-covered walls without posts or
ation), and are often significant indicators of social wattle’’ (Todorova 2003, 288). The early publications
boundaries (Stark et al. 1995). by Passek on the structures at Tripolye have also led
According to various definitions of culture, regard- others to perplexing conlusions, e.g., the use of
less of whether these are emphasizing behavioural ‘‘adobes’’ in construction of the houses (Lazarovici &
patterns or recurring sets of material remains, techni- Lazarovici 2003, 412).
cal style is part of the ‘‘package’’. Not all aspects of a Pounded earth, or pisé/terre pisé, are terms ap-
cultural package are being transmitted from a given plied to describe earth compacted by ramming (Rapp
core area, however, making conglomerates such as 2002). This advantegeous technique is more compli-
the KSB culture less well defined. Thus, it is import- cated than e.g., wattle and daub. Pisé walls do not
ant to account not only for one trait such as the styl- burn, and burning of a thatched or reed roof would
istics of pottery, but also for architecture and use of have very limited thermal effects, not even causing
space, among many other things. a redening of the clay. The erection of pisé walls is
Despite limitations in the architectural data from dependent on a well-balanced composition of raw
sites attributed to the KSB culture, it is possible to materials in order to prevent shrinkage. In fact, only
undertake several overall comparisons, adding to a a small amount of clay is needed and more than 30%
better understanding of the KSB cultural profile. clay results in rapid erosion (Rapp 2002).
Seemingly, variation can be used as a temporal signa- The rammed earth technique is known in Bulgaria
ture, especially in cases where information is obtained
on the general layout of a settlement. A great poten-
tial in this respect is displayed by the Telish-Redutite 6. Cf. the Russian edition of ‘‘A Dictionary of Archaeology’’, W.
site, which still awaits a detailed publication concern- Bray & D. Trump 1970 (not quoted in the General Bibli-
ing the issue of use of space in domestic contexts. ography).
64 Acta Archaeologica

in both the Neolithic and the Early Copper Age (Čo- exceptionality of the Telish-Redutite site is based on
chadžiev 2003a). At the Neolithic site of Gulubnink, false premises (cf. Bailey 2000; Todorova 2003).
situated in the Struma Valley, the technique has cor- Knowing that many other Late Copper Age sites
rectly been described as a ‘‘beaten-clay’’ technique, in Bulgaria have houses with substantial wooden pol-
when the building material ‘‘did not differ from that es in their walls (diameter of 15–25 cm), it is probable
of the surrounding terrain’’ (Čochadžiev 2003a). In that the light wall construction in the Telish region
the ethnographic record of Bulgaria, rammed earth reflects environmental constrains. Even the houses of
techniques are also known, primarily in the northern the Redutite IV building horizon of post-Copper Age
part of the country, including the region of Pleven date – demonstrating a general break with earlier styl-
(Čochadžiev 1997, 10; Georgieva 1983, 197). The istic and technological traditions – had a light frame
walls of these houses are described as being 0.5–0.6 constructed for daubing (Gergov 1996). The con-
m thick, made of a clay mixed with chaff, which is sumption of wood and possibly clearing too could well
shaped in a wooden frame outlining the house (Geor- have been greater than the natural regeneration pace
gieva 1983, 197). The walls are built of layers 0.50 m of the trees of the region.
high, the finished house composed of five such layers Looking at the broader picture, the available infor-
(Georgieva 1983, 197). mation on KSB houses is restricted.
Returning to the Tripolye houses, these have been There are only a few cases of fully excavated archi-
described as ‘‘built of thick poles, joined by wicker- tectural remains. Generally, the built structures com-
work and plastered over with clay’’ (Mongait 1959; ply with the described principles. Few exceptions,
but also Gimbutas 1956; Passek & Chernykh 1963; such as the stone houses at Galatin, NW Bulgaria
Stanko et al. 1997, 253, Figs. 64 & 65). The use of (Georgieva 1995b) and Beligovo, E Serbia (Nikolić
pounded earth is only found in connection with floors 1998) erected on the top of stony hills may reflect an
and grinding terraces (ibid.). Thus, it is not correct to adaptation rather than changing architectural prin-
apply the pounded earth term to Tripolye features. ciples. Copper Age societies were not devoid of inno-
The architecture of the Tripolye culture and, to a vative potential, but the faithful subscription to con-
certain extent, of the Gumelniţa culture (as known in stant patterns of settlement arrangement and house
Moldavia and Ukraine, i.e., the areas of Lower Danu- building may indicate that architecture was governed
be and Lower Prut) is characterized by so-called by less tangible ideas than the mere need for shelter.
house platforms. The house platforms were created The settlement and the house can thus be viewed as
with the help of clay rolls tempered with plant matters an agent of communal identity.
laid tightly upon a wooden base und fired (in some
cases the rolls were fired prior to their arrangement)
(Chernysh 1965; Passek 1965, 8, as cited by Bejlekchi TYPES OF SETTLEMENT SITES
1978, 61 & 67). Such a technical solution for making Regional and supra-regional perspectives have proved
floors is more closely related to adobe than to the highly valuable for the understanding of Lı̂ga and
rammed earth technique. Walls, celings and ovens in yielded a far more complex picture of a Late Copper
Tripolje were made with the use of wattling and Age settlement than hitherto assumed. The tra-
daub, however (Chernysh 1965; Passek 1965, 8, as ditional idea is that the seemingly short-lived KSB
cited by Bejlekchi 1978, 61 & 67). settlements were mainly located at high altitudes, or
Bearing all this in mind, it is safe to conclude that in caves, in contrast to the long-lasting tell settlements
the houses in Redutite were daub houses with a rela- of the KGK VI complex on the Thracian plain to
tively light, but dense wattle construction. This is also the east of KSB (e.g., Todorova 1986). The simplistic
indicated by the fragments of walls from Redutite of assumption that tells always represent a permanent
burned daub with a high content of clay exhibited at occupation has been challenged by investigations at
the Historical Museum of Pleven. The same construc- the Podgoritsa tell in NE Bulgaria, demonstrating that
tion technique was, as noted, recorded in adjacent repeated episodes of rising water tables forced settlers
Lı̂ga. Hence, it can be demonstrated that the stated to abandon the tell and move to dry locations (Bailey
Lı̂ga 65

1999). On the other hand, excavations at Redutite, ive measures. Despite the lack of topographic restric-
next to Lı̂ga, have produced evidence that KSB set- tions, such settlement sees a dense concentration of
tlers felt a strong attachment to certain places, per- houses, creating a sharp division between the built
ceived to be pivotal in the geographical and cultural and the unbuilt space. The area occupied by houses
landscape. This is seen not only through reoccupation ranges between 0.18 and 0.40 ha; the majority of sites
of the same space but also in rebuilding and extension are around 0.2 ha, with between 20 and 35 houses.
activities, especially during Redutite II (Gergov, per- (D) Open-air low-lying settlements were also established.
s.comm.). One such was recorded between Telish and Sadovec,
In and around Telish (mainly to the east) there are following information from local residents. The site is
at least five types of settlement, thus. marked as NN on the map (Fig. I.7), since no local
(A) Strongholds, such as Sadovec-Golemanovo Kale, name could be obtained. It is lying on the lower ter-
with one occupation phase (Todorova 1992), and Pip- race by a stream, gradually sloping upwards towards
ra, with a minimum of five (pers. inspection of treas- the North. The top of the terrace is marked by two
ure hunter pits in 2000, 2001 & 2002). These sites are presumable Thracian tumuli. In a ploughed field and
naturally protected by steep slopes at three sides, an area of ca. 0.2 ha were very many sherds of Late
being only accessible by land bridges or less steep Copper Age pottery and milling stones. Late and
slopes. Unfortunately, Pipra has never been properly post-Roman pottery was also present, as well as hu-
investigated, and the remains of the Late Copper Age man bones. No indications of settlement could be
settlement at Golemanovo Kale have been damaged found on the higher lying areas around. Such low-
by later occupation. Other strongholds found else- lying settlements have been somewhat ignored and
where in the KSB area appear to have been addition- are merely noted in survey reports. The majority is
ally fortified by earth or even stone walls, double- also severely damaged by intensive cultivation and
trenches and palisades – e.g., Okhoden Kaleto (Niko- thus less attractive archaeologically than the high alti-
lov 1968), Zaminets (Nikolov 1975), Krivodol (Niko- tude sites.
lov 1984 and pers. observations of treasure hunter (E) Caves are common in the Telish-Sadovec area.
trenches in 2001 and 2002). The strongholds are Unfortunately, the biggest, suitable for extensive oc-
usually oblong, tongue- or ellipse-shaped hills, which cupation, have suffered damage by modern use, e.g.,
impart limitations on the settlement size, the available production of feta-like cheeses. Upstream, on the
area being around 0.2 ha with a maximum capacity river Vit, occupational debris has been discovered in
of 20–23 houses. Not accidentally, all these locations the caves of Ochilata and Îglen. Devetaki at Lovech,
were later chosen for heavily fortified Late Antiquity further away, remains the finest example of cave
strongholds. settlements (Mikov & Džambazov 1960). Cave settle-
(B) Minor sites with difficult access were established at ments can be differentiated according to the intensity
obscure locations and hence tentatively interpreted as of occupation, but the majority seems to be temporal
refuges. The only example in the Telish region is Sa- shelters for herdsmen, despite presence of built struc-
dovec-Ezero, a saddle-like hillock in a canyon below tures.
ranges of high rising hills. The area useable for struc- By the end of the Copper Age a new type of settle-
tures was 0.075–0.08 ha, thus only 8–10 house may ment emerged in the KSB area, (F) pile dwellings,
have existed at one and the same time. The occu- found in wetland areas such as Negovatsi (Georgieva
pational debris of Sadovec-Ezero can be subdivided 1995a) and Krajnitsi close to Pernik (Čochadžiev
in 6 building horizons with a total thickness of almost 2003a); they resemble the earlier settlements at Varna
4 m. Elsewhere in the KSB area, refuge places are Lake on the Black Sea coast.
established on hilltops in remote areas, e.g., Pekliuk None of the abovementioned sites are static but
at Sofia (Petkov 1964). rather changing in function and purpose. Sadovec-Ez-
(C) Open-air plateau settlements, such as Redutite and ero stands out as the best example. During the end of
Lı̂ga, were established at the edge of a plateau with a the Copper Age, at the time of its 4th settlement (out of
commanding view of the surroundings, but no defens- 6), the site also included part of the neighbouring Sado-
66 Acta Archaeologica

vec-Kaleto locality. The two-partite settlement was re- vec-Kaleto; Lı̂ga 1 ceramics shares features with
jected in favour of Sadovec-Kaleto – with no restriction pottery from the Sadovec sites. However, as long as
on settlement – during the time of the so-called Tran- the full chrono-typological sensitivity of the pottery in
sitional period, as well as in the Early and Late Bronze question has not been established, such considerations
Age, and in Late Antiquity. Later on, the site was used have little value. Tentatively, it can be assumed that
as a Christian burial site. In the Early Bronze Age the at least two settlements coexisted, e.g. an open-air
site was fortified by a massive wall. settlement and a defended site in its hinterland (6–10
It is difficult to establish how many of the settle- km away). Acknowledgement of the flint sources at
ments in the Telish region were contemporary. Pot- Sadovec and Pipra indicates that the settlers at Lı̂ga
tery from Golemanovo Kale has exact parallels in Sa- were familiar also with these localities (cf. Chapter
dovec-Ezero at the time of its expansion onto Sado- VII, below).
IV. CERAMIC FINDS
PRESERVATION methods for processing pottery were designed with
Despite the relatively limited thickness of the cultural reference to the material produced by the Lı̂ga 2
deposits at Lı̂ga, conditions of preservation vary sig- settlement. First of all, the investigators were faced
nificantly depending on depth, the effects of which with a huge amount of shards from disturbed or un-
being clearly observable on pottery. In the lowest certain contexts. Secondly, especially during the first
layers, Lı̂ga 1, the surface of the pottery shards is ce- season, the qualitative differentiation of pottery ap-
mented by the calcareous soils. The patination of flint peared to be limited to just two categories, coarse and
artefacts is likewise progressed. In the upper cultural very coarse wares, as based on fabric and surface
horizon of Lı̂ga 2, the calcareous environment has treatment. All attempts at this stage to differentiate
created high pH values of the soil (8, according to between excavated shards did not produce categories
litmus paper). Protected only by a thin layer of hu- that could be readily and unambiguously recognised.
mus, the pottery is further affected by moisture and Recovery of whole vessels provided information on
fluctuations of temperature. During the summer dry – morphological features and substantiated shape-
as observed on location in 2000 – the soil sees cracks orientated recording. Eventually, three processing
up to 0.5 m deep. The combined actions of physical procedures evolved, with varying degrees of com-
and chemical properties of the soil have thus resulted plexity: streamlined sorting of shards according to
in relatively poor conditions of preservation for top- tempering, coded sorting of shards according to
level pottery. Some shards appear with washed out or morphological traits and surface treatment, and, de-
exfoliated surfaces, in some cases to such a degree tailed description of whole or reconstructable vessels
that the original surface can hardly be recognised. or conspicuous vessel parts. For all three processing
This is particularly common for areas outside the procedures a standardised data sheet was designed
houses where the pottery was not affected by second- corresponding to the entries of a pottery database.
ary burning or protected by a less permeable layer of The main excavated area of 275 m2 (excluding sur-
fallen structural debris. Often the upper layer of a vey trenches) yielded almost 1,300 kg of pottery. Pot-
shard is flaking in thin scales making recognition of tery fragmentation turned up to be low with an aver-
decoration and finishing a complicated task. Appar- age of 20 g per shard (excluding whole vessels or pot-
ently, none of the described factors had any note- tery concentrations on house floors). The degree of
worthy impact on bones. fragmentation did not appear to be fluctuating in any
pattern depending on the depth: indicating that the
excavated area had undergone limited post-depo-
POTTERY: SORTING PROCEDURES sitional disturbance. In fact, it can be concluded, that
Pottery processing at Lı̂ga was dictated by realities the excavated part of the settlement was the better
already presenting themselves during the excavation. preserved one. When all the land of Telish became
As work progressed, it became evident that the main intensively cultivated, the excavated part of the settle-
body of pottery was related to the Lı̂ga 2 episode at ment – separated from the arable by a road – was
the site. Significant amount of pottery was also col- not deep-ploughed. In fact, the best-preserved re-
lected from Lı̂ga 1 layers but discrete qualitative dis- mains were discovered under the road.
tinctions between the two sets of pottery allowed for
an immediate separation of mixed materials. The
same was even more apparent in the case of oc- SORTING OF SHARDS: TEMPERING MATERIAL
casional occurrences of shards from later periods. General crudeness of the pottery created the im-
Almost all studies focused on the numerous and pression that it was related to the latest phase of the
better preserved remains of Lı̂ga 2, allowing for close- Copper Age, supposedly marked by an increasing use
up investigation of a homogeneous data set. Thus, the of organic and especially shell tempering (Georgieva
68 Acta Archaeologica

counted, weighted and coded according to definitions


on the data entry sheet. Shards of other periods than
the Lı̂ga 2 settlement were separated and treated ac-
cordingly. When possible, a note was made on vessel
size (big or small). In cases of rims, the rim diameter,
thickness of wall and vessel type (open/closed vessel)
were noted as well. Comments and drawings were
made of rare and exceptional features of shape and
decoration. The data entry sheet allowed one to re-
flect on relations between several shards or shards
with several morphological attributes.
Acknowledging that different vessel types have dif-
ferent life-spans and varying patterns of fragmen-
Fig. IV.1. Table of defined tempering groups, with percentage of tation (Rice 1987, Table 9.4; Orton et al. 1993), this
each in the Lı̂ga 2 material. sorting procedure was considered meaningful in es-
tablishing a general profile of the pottery production
during the Lı̂ga 2 settlement. As noted, the sorting
1993). Therefore, non-plastic inclusions became the procedure did not include whole vessels or shard con-
most significant variable in shard sorting during the centrations observed on house floors. Furthermore,
first season. In most cases, inclusions were easily dis- the initial sorting procedure based on non-plastic in-
tinguished by fresh breaking with tongs, only rarely a clusions demonstrated, as just mentioned, that the de-
hand lens was used. The procedure involved sorting gree of fragmentation was the same throughout the
of shards from the same excavation unit into groups layers (again with exception of the pottery discovered
according to tempering materials. Within each group, on house floors), pointing towards related post-depo-
shards were further subdivided according to morpho- sitional histories. Albeit the numbers are not con-
logical traits, decoration, and exceptional or note- sidered absolute, the frequency of appearance of for-
worthy features. When sorted, all shards were mal attributes or surface treatment techniques was
counted and weighted. The total number was 12,642 considered to be diagnostic, exhibiting general ideas
shards weighting 248 kg. As a result, 15 different tem- on pottery production. Information was entered into
pering groups were established, but only 11 of these a database stemming from 230 bags or 575 kg of ce-
appeared to be statistically significant (Fig. IV.1). ramic shards.

CODED SORTING OF SHARDS: MORPHOLOGICAL DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF VESSELS AND SHARD


CHARACTERISTICS & SURFACE TREATMENT CONCENTRATIONS
This sorting procedure was applied when significant Pottery recovered in closed and undisturbed contexts
evidence was collected on pottery shapes and surface (in situ) was treated with special attention. This in-
treatment as based on finds of whole or nearly whole cluded whole vessels as well as shard concentrations
vessels. It was constructed in two steps. Firstly, all and single diagnostic or otherwise informative shards.
shards from the same excavation unit were sorted into Thorough recording was undertaken both inside and
rims, shoulders, handles/lugs/bosses, bases, body outside the buildings, in places of waste deposition
shards and fragments of ‘‘standard forms’’ (that is, and in areas of particular outdoor activities. Field re-
pottery types, varying in size but repetitive in terms of cording procedures included 3D measurement of in-
shape, like pot-stands, milk strainers, or biconic cups). dividual pottery scatters as polygons or points
Then, each group was subdivided into plain speci- mapped with Total Station (TS) (Pl. 4.A), graphic rep-
mens and specimens with decoration or a particular resentation of contextual information (drawing Pl.
surface treatment. Shards within each subgroup were 4.B), photo documentation and immediate descrip-
Lı̂ga 69

tion of vessel types, states of preservation, directions proper tempering material, based on the assumption
of fall, positions (rim/bottom position in relation to that it reflects a technological choice. Of course, it is
each other), etc. Such description was further ex- also possible that another source of clay with such
panded when shards/vessels were collected and constituents was mined, e.g., at the stream, where sea-
bagged, and assigned individual numbers of Total sonal re-deposition of clays was taking place. Finally,
Station measurement. Soil from the vessels was also a small part of all shards (among these a few frag-
sampled. The post-excavation procedures included ments of Late Antiquity pottery) contained very fine
careful cleaning, mending and partial restoration, if mica, indicating that at least one other source of clay
needed, drawing, and metrical, morphological, and has been in use.
technological description. Almost 300 whole or recon- The sorting of pottery shards according to non-
structable vessels were discovered from primary con- plastic inclusions occurring in the fabric produced the
texts (and 100, predominantly smaller cups and above list of 15 different combinations, termed tem-
bowls, recovered from uncertain ones). However, pering groups. Four groups are represented by very
1/3rd of the 300 vessels was only graphically recon- small numbers and might in fact reflect experiments
structed in part, since their reconstruction, due too or foreign origins. Organic matter was the most com-
high fragmentation or/and fragility, would be too mon. Such may be fresh plant material (from very
time-consuming. fine grasses leaving linear voids in a section to crude
straws with corresponding somewhat angular voids),
or animal dung. The second and third in importance
POTTERY RAW MATERIALS AND FABRICS is quartz and chamotte (grog), of almost equal import-
Initial information on raw materials used in pottery ance. Quartz/sand is found in a range of sizes,
production at Lı̂ga was gained through burned pieces though most frequently in grains between 1–2 mm.
of daub. Besides intentionally added aplastics, the Fine pottery may contain quartz particles of only 0.5
daub contained bigger lumps of calcareous inclusions mm. The inclusions are mostly rounded, but angular
and ochre, indicating that these were occurring nat- ones are also occurring, usually in quite high frequen-
urally in the clay deposits in question. Therefore, any cies. Several grainy sandstones, one reaching 22 cm
modest occurrence of calcareous inclusions or ochre in length, discovered on the site were severely burned
in pottery was considered natural. A rich deposit of and brittle, easily crumbling into separate grains. The
sedimentary clays (likely 6–8 m in thickness) was dis- angular form and size of these grains correlate with
covered at the foot of the plateau where the site is the quartz inclusions found in the fabric of part of the
situated. The clay is light grey in colour and contains shards, allowing the assumption that such stones
very fine plant material. Other impurities, as oc- could indeed have served as a source for quartz tem-
casionally lenses of sand or iron rich flakes, tend to pering. Chamotte (or grog) is appearing in great
lump in separate layers. The low level of impurities abundance. It can be coarsely (2–4 mm) or finely
was appreciated by Late Antiquity potters settled in crushed (0.5–1.0 mm); when it appears in combi-
the area: these did not need levigation to refine the nation with other tempering materials, it usually
clays for high quality products. The Copper Age pot- dominates. Like the other tempering materials, cham-
ters, by contrast, had to make proper choices of tem- otte was used for production of both coarse and fine
pering material to achieve a balanced composition of wares, in both Lı̂ga 1 and 2. In the case of coarse
paste suitable for prehistoric firing conditions. wares, it was almost always present. The main part
Examination of the paste raised the known prob- of the chamotte originate from crushed pottery but
lem of when presence of aplastics in clays should be fired clays are also noted (distinguished by a more
regarded as natural, or, intentional. The focus is on pulverulent state). Evidently, the basic technological
fabric types containing quartz inclusions. The upper prescriptions involved clay mixed with organic matter
layers of the clay deposits at the site contain fine- and strengthened with one or both of the hard-core
grained sand, and the decision was thus made to treat elements – quartz/sand and chamotte.
any considerable amount of quartz inclusions as The use of calcareous inclusions was also import-
70 Acta Archaeologica

ant. At least 1⁄4th of all shards contained some thus parallel in time to Lı̂ga. The material, stemming
amount of calcium carbonates (lime or calcite, but from 21 houses, is, however, attributed to the KGK
never shells), in fired state, these appeared as white or VI cultural complex. Due to the large quantity of
yellowish soft inclusions, easily scratched with a nail. finds, only material from two houses was investigated,
The amount of these non-plastic constituents was described and photographed (1). Concerning temper-
moderate in frequency and only when evenly distrib- ing materials, a great uniformity in combination exists
uted considered as intentionally added. at Hotnitsa. Calcareous inclusions dominate, often in
Among the curiosities were several coarse pottery combination with organic matter, seldom with cham-
shards richly tempered with crushed flint (3–4 mm) otte. The use of sand is very limited, while some pot-
and quartz/sand. Such tempering practice was at- tery is only tempered with organic matter. The dis-
tested on a handful of shards only, representing big, covery of a relatively high representation of organic
thick-walled and relatively well-fired vessels (at least matters led to the recognition that organic tempering
two), the function of which has not been established. is often overlooked in Copper Age pottery from Bul-
Pottery found in the Lı̂ga 2 settlement differs from garia. Other comparative studies suggest that the
the pottery of Lı̂ga 1 not only in quality, but also in variation in tempering combinations during Lı̂ga 2 is
composition of the tempering constituents. Whereas a reflection of social phenomena discussed in sections
Tempering Groups IV and IX (cf. Fig. IV.1) make up below.
the preferred composition in both Copper Age settle-
ments, the occurrence of Groups I and II is much
higher in Lı̂ga 1 than in Lı̂ga 2. Group III occurs in DECORATION
both settlements, but with a slightly higher percentage The frequency of decorated shards from Lı̂ga 2 (in-
in Lı̂ga 2. Lı̂ga 1 potters also produced pottery with cluding rims, which are more often left undecorated
tempering materials of Group V but were less in fa- than body shards) is high: 31%, in kg. This is perhaps
vour of calcareous clays than the potters of Lı̂ga 2. not surprising since the most common form of ‘‘dec-
Remarkably, virtually no pottery with organic con- oration’’ is surface rustication, no doubt intended to
stituents alone has been attributed to the Lı̂ga 1 settle- be functional. In general, rustication of the surface is
ment, which sees only six tempering groups. achieved by applying a thick layer of clay to a vessel
The size of inclusions is the other variable that dif- in leather-hard state. Depending on the pattern of
ferentiates Lı̂ga 1 pottery from that of Lı̂ga 2. distribution of the applied clay, Bulgarian scholars dif-
Whereas the greatest proportion of non-organic in- ferentiate between ‘‘barbotine’’ and ‘‘finger trailing’’
clusions in Lı̂ga 2 pottery fall within the size interval (other archaeologists would call both forms barbotine
1–2 mm, the most frequent inclusion size lies around surface treatment). According to the Bulgarian tra-
0.5 mm in the case of Lı̂ga 1. dition of description, barbotine is an application of
Generally, the pottery of Lı̂ga 1 is represented by thick slip, which creates rough surfaces in no particu-
fine wares made of well-sorted fabrics with moderate lar pattern. While finger trailing, as the name is sug-
amounts of inclusions, homogenous in size and with gesting, is also a rough relief application, the slip
colours ranging from grey to black (Munsell Colour being distributed on the surface by trailing fingers so
Chart, 10YR-3/1, 10YR-4/1, 10YR-5/2). Evenly that parallel ridges are raised in a certain pattern,
burnished, lustrous, and often extremely shiny sur- usually horizontal or vertical (reflecting the direction
faces add a further dimension to these ceramics, in of trailing). Although sometimes both types of rusti-
contrast with the coarse brown coloured pottery of cation might be combined with other decorative ele-
Lı̂ga 2 (see below). ments and create a certain impression of exclusivity,
In an attempt to obtain comparative data, studies such surface treatment is mainly reserved for ‘‘dom-
were also undertaken on finds from the Hotnitsa Tell
(History Museum of Veliko Tarnovo). The upper 1. The author is grateful to Nedko Elenski, MA, curator at the
settlement of this tell is well investigated and dates to Historical Museum of V. Tarnovo, Bulgaria for the opportunity
the Late Copper Age (Angelov 1958; 1959; 1961), to study materials from Hotnitsa at first hand.
Lı̂ga 71

estic ware’’, that is, big storage vessels, barrel shaped


vessels, and biconic ‘‘soup/soaking tureens’’ (Type
‘‘G’’, see below). The functionality of such surface
treatment can be appreciated in several ways: cre-
ating better gripping surfaces, reinforcing vessels, and
minimising abrasive impact. The proportion of rusti-
cated ware is very high in the assemblage of Lı̂ga 2.
Based on 126 kg of decorated shards, 60% was of
finger trailing and 15% of barbotine proper. The re-
maining types of decoration make up only 25%. A
horizontal band or a cordon of fingernail or/and -tip
impressions often separates the smoothed rim/neck
from the rusticated body. A combination of two (or
three – 11 cases in all) decorative elements is found
on 3% of the shards, a frequency no doubt underrep-
resented to judge from whole vessels. The most fre-
quent type of combination involves barbotine or fin-
ger trailing. Generally, decoration composed of more
than one element is rare, allowing the assumption
that pottery rustication must have been viewed as a
functional, rather than as a decorative surface treat-
ment technique.
The repertoire of more elaborate decoration tech-
niques, as can be seen from the collected fragments,
is limited to different combinations of the said fin-
gernail and fingertip impressions, often on cordons;
also shell impressions and rounded or triangular
punctates/pits, impressed with sticks, incised decor-
ation, raised bosses, flutes, scratched and brushed sur-
face decoration are seen. Excised and graphite
painted decoration is also present, but in very small
quantities.
Looking at the distribution of decoration types
within 25% of the whole amount of fragmented dec-
orated pottery (that is, disregarding barbotine and
finger trailing), the most common type of decoration
is incised (26%). Incision is made with a sharp or Fig. IV.2. Big storage jar found in House 2 decorated with incised
pattern of spirals. Note the dots.
blunted thin stick (up to 2 mm) moved in horizontal
lines or in more complex patterns over the whole
body. Complex patterns of joint lines organised in cir-
cular, spiral or curvilinear patterns characteristic of dots (Fig. IV.2). There is a certain regularity observed
graphite painted pottery have also been executed with in a distribution of dots, implying that spiral orna-
the help of incisions. Thus, incisions might be seen as mentation was created using two sticks – bound to-
a substitute for graphite painted decoration, the latter gether with a cord (the distance between them could
raising certain demands on raw materials (graphite), be regulated by rolling the cord) – which then could
fabric and surface treatment (burnishing). Patterns be used in the same way as modern callipers.
composed of incised spirals are often associated with A common type of decoration is horizontal im-
72 Acta Archaeologica

pressions with fingernails and fingertips (25%), which tally separated with incised lines, creating a honey-
can be unidirectional, from either side, or double-di- comb pattern.
rectional (less common) and performed in a pinching Impressions made with shells at right angles are
manner. This type of decoration can also be con- often found on shoulders of biconic or other bipartite
sidered a rustication of the surface, since often the vessels (3%). Similar type of decoration can also be
whole vessel surface was treated in such manner. Fre- created with fingernails being pressed into clay at
quently, this type of decoration is used to create a right angle (2%). In both cases, impressions have a
raised band intended to separate the neck from the narrow crescent shape, but the ones made with shell
remaining part of the body. It might also be used to edges (most likely freshwater mussels of the Microcon-
terminate barbotine or finger trailing rustication, dylaea Compressa species, as identified by N. Andre-
which usually does not involve the neck. Related to asen, Copenhagen and Cambridge universities, in
the type of decoration is a true relief decoration: an 2001) are significantly broader. Ideally, this type of
applied cordon with fingernail and/or fingertip im- ornamentation was intended to create a pattern of
pressions (20%). As the previous, this is also used to vertical waves, as the orientation of impressions was
separate (e.g., the neck from the body) or to accentu- changing from row to row.
ate certain parts (usually the shoulders) of a vessel. Among the rare types are excised decoration (3%)
The same decoration effect as fingertip impression and graphite (2%). Both types represented by a num-
could also be achieved with a stick with flattened tip. ber of shards giving impression of complex patterns
Raised decoration was also used in a more elabor- consisting of multiple lines. Excised decoration is
ate manner. Applied cordons (occasionally with somewhat deeper than the incised, but is similar in
evenly spread fingertip impressions on top) could be groove width.
used to create complex patterns organized in circles The last significantly represented decoration type
and spirals and oblique protuberances (5%). Another (1%) is pottery with scratched or brushed surface. Soft
type of raised decoration is small bosses organised in clay was brushed with a bundle of coarse grass stems
a single horizontal row or covering part of the vessel or similar material. Such decoration is usually applied
body (2%). This type of decoration has not been dis- on the whole vessel surface in interchanging direc-
covered on whole vessels at Lı̂ga. tions; sometimes a more regular pattern was created
Fine-ware pottery such as biconic jars and bowls by brushing only selected patches of the surface.
are frequently decorated with fluting techniques (6%). Pottery rustication techniques have also been ap-
Flutes can be arranged in concentric circles or oblique plied by the potters of Lı̂ga 1, but less frequently. In-
lines around the shoulder of bipartite, closed vessels. stead, painted pottery held a much greater proportion
Bowls are decorated around the lip and rim on the of the sherdage, with complex graphite patterns pre-
inside. Seemingly, this decoration type is reserved to vailing, but in combination with red, yellow and
more exclusive pottery types. white paints (Pl. 6). Graphite motives were usually
A relatively common type of decoration during the made in combinations of line groups (3–5 lines, 1.5–
Copper Age is created with the help of punctates/ 2.0 mm broad), but other elements such as hatched
shallow pits, which are produced with a small stick triangles or meanders are also present. Often graphite
with either oval, triangular, or, occasionally, narrow is combined with fluting. Painted decoration was
rectangular tip (5%). Sometimes the stick was stuck mainly found on the upper part of vessels. Sometimes
into the clay at an angle, the resulting pattern resem- rims were also ornamented from within, the most
bling triangular fingertip/nail impressions. This type elaborate patterns being found in the interior of
of decoration was applied in repeated rows and some- bowls, covering the whole surface. Incised decoration
times covered the whole surface. Frequently, rows of is also common, occasionally with white or red incrus-
oval or narrow rectangular punctuates are horizon- tation.
V. POTTERY AS SOURCE
OF INFORMATION
PRESENTATION OF DATA between Copper Age Redutite III and Redutite IV,
Prior to a discussion of the issues related to pottery the latter phase attributed to the so-called Tran-
production, there is a need to make a presentation of sitional Period (to the Early Bronze Age). Such dating
the dataset, which this study is based on. As informa- was in concordance with published information and
tive the shard material is, it can never disclose the full furthermore confirmed by consultations with Bulg-
complexity, technological as ideational of the ceramic arian scholars. However, after the full disclosure of
production: hence, the below considerations are based House 3, as well as partial disclosures of other built
on complete or nearly complete specimens discovered structures, these ideas were abolished.
in certain contexts, primarily inside built structures. House 3 was the biggest structure encountered at
House 1 (Pl. 7) is represented by 30 complete or the site (internal space of 37.8 m2). The pottery was
reconstructable ceramic vessels, found in an area of distributed in a much more concentrated manner
28.3 m2; this number is significantly lower than those than in the other houses. 51 reconstructable vessels
of the remaining two houses. Nevertheless, the dataset were discovered (Pl. 10–12). The bulk part was found
is important since it includes vessels with analogies in in a heap of shards at the eastern wall. Clearly, this
the other houses. indicates vessels arranged on shelves. The biggest
House 2 probably reveals the fullest information on containers (volumes reaching 250 litres) were standing
an original collection of vessels (Pl. 8 & 9). Despite on the floor, while above, smaller vessels were stacked
the fact that rims of vessels in situ were in some places in at least two levels. Mending of vessels concentrated
discovered just 15 cm below the surface, the area oc- on qualitatively outstanding pottery with well-bur-
cupied by the house has suffered little damage due to nished light surfaces, decorated with painted or com-
subsequent activities than have the other houses. In plex incised patterns. Even the biggest storage con-
general, the material of House 2 (internal space of tainers had only a moderate inclusion frequency and
34.5 m2) is dominated by unsophisticated, rusticated were better fired than the crude pottery from the first
or plain surface pottery, fired at low temperatures, mentioned houses. 11 whole or nearly whole graphite
and abundantly tempered (with organic matter and painted vessels were discovered (Pl. 12). In fact, this
chamotte as the main constituents). Surface burnish- was the only house at Lı̂ga 2 that contained graphite
ing is applied on the interior of only a few bowls. Out painted pottery. Some archaeologists have tried to ex-
of 42 vessels, 16 can be classified as coarse, 24 as very plain the lack of graphite painted pottery on Copper
coarse and only 2 as fine ware pottery. The latter Age sites with poor preservation (Todorova et al.
are thin-walled biconic jugs (wall thickness ranging 2003). At Lı̂ga, this is not the case, since graphite
between 3–5 mm), decorated with fluting and small painting was done prior to burnishing, which had a
bosses on the shoulders. The prevailing decoration durable protective impact on pottery surfaces.
technique, except for barbotine and finger trailing, is It is important to note, that graphite paint was not
fingernail/fingertip impressions (22 vessels). No reserved for smaller vessels, often interpreted as food
painted ware has been discovered in this house. The serving ones, but was also applied to voluminous
number of shapes is limited to 9, all falling within the closed containers used for storage. The manner of
formal repertoire of the KSB culture. surface treatment and decoration is thus closer to the
Houses 1 & 2 were mainly investigated during the early part of the Copper Age than to its terminal
first field campaign (2000). Based on the pottery, both phases, according to the typological ordering systems
structures were dated to the very end of the Copper set up in Bulgaria. In fact, H. Todorova, visiting the
Age. The settlement of Lı̂ga 2 was initially placed in site in 2001, raised the issue whether this pottery
between the last two settlements of Redutite, that is, should be dated to the Early Copper Age. All three
74 Acta Archaeologica

ket and satisfying the demands of the well-


informed mainstream population. However, as
much as the knowledge on the Copper Age is re-
stricted, such a simplified (and intentionally exag-
gerated) picture can hardly be true. The evidence
on the pottery production at Lı̂ga conforms to
that of all better investigated sites. The graphite
Fig. V.1. Items associated with production of pottery. 1 – pot stand, painted pottery often has the character of mass
possibly a tournette, 2 – cone of graphite (lengthΩ2.4 cm, ØΩ1.15 production, indicating that it was based on locally
cm). available knowledge. How then might it be ex-
plained that one woman from a particular house
was carrying water from the stream at the foot of
houses were however temporally bound through their Lı̂ga in a dull water jar, while her neighbour for
spatial relatedness as well as certain vessels with a the same purpose was using a well-burnished,
high degree of resemblance, most likely products of shiny graphite painted jar – if not in terms of indi-
the same potter. vidualism?
Thus, the existence of qualitatively divergent vessel (3) As to the implications for archaeological research
assemblages stemming from contemporaneous struc- strategies: Are we doing the right things? – With-
tures poses several important questions, hopefully out going into deeper discussion, it is evident that
answered in the following: only context-designed excavation and recording
(1) As to the built structures: Can contemporary procedures can provide a reliable profile of a site.
structures with qualitatively different contents be The usual Bulgarian practice: trench excavation
functionally equated? – The usual concern of an in limited areas is creating false suppositions, tem-
excavator is to assign different meaning to related porally as well as culturally.
but divergent sets of finds, trying to demonstrate
the functional variability of structures, often with
ill-founded explanations and expectations. At POTTERY PRODUCTION
Lı̂ga, this process was reversed, and an attempt All three houses subjected to detailed investigation
was made to show that qualitative exclusiveness contain some evidence on pottery production, which
and find variety is not enough to ‘‘transform’’ a can be considered as complementary to at least a par-
dwelling house into a sanctuary or a community tial reconstruction of the pottery technology. House 3
house. As has been noted above, categories were held the most sophisticated pottery, contrasting the
not exclusive. other two pottery sets to such a degree that external
(2) As to the diversity of pottery production traditions influences were considered among possible expla-
and their temporal sensitivity: What are the cul- nations (Pl. 13). Such were gradually discarded,
tural-chronological implications? – In many cases, though, as it appeared that exclusive graphite paint
evolutionary explanations have been suggested to occurred on different types of utilitarian pottery,
interpret prehistoric developments in the Balkans. mainly on big storage containers.
Societies are presented as homogenous masses, The production process of graphite painted pottery
collectively stockbreeding or harvesting, sharing requires a proper surface treatment and graphite as a
and accepting each others ideas on the surround- naturally found mineral. Careful selection of temper-
ing world. Anything extraordinary is explained ing material was important in order to minimize the
with the existence of itinerant masters with an risk of cracking during firing. Coarse particles could
urge to travel and a good geographical knowl- also complicate surface treatment. So, not surprising-
edge, knowing that his, or her, work will be ap- ly, graphite painted pottery is made of clays with
preciated. Less travel-keen masters tend to estab- moderate amounts of fine tempering constituents,
lish production centres, closely following the mar- preferably of Group III (sand and organic matter) and
Lı̂ga 75

Fig. V.2. Cone of red ochre (ØΩ1.8 cm). (One square of the back-
ground plate equals 1 cm.)

occasionally Group VI (organic matter). Such consist-


ency is no doubt significant in the light of the possible
combinations attested at the site. A local origin of Fig. V.3. Stones found in a spherical pot standing at the oven of
House 2.
graphite painted pottery was also confirmed by the
discovery of a graphite cone in House 3, which was
broken across the perforated hole for suspension. The
item had a characteristic pointed tip (Fig. V.1:2). nishing was carried out with stones and possibly
Similar cones are known from Karanovo and other bones with a narrow burnishing tip of 2–3 mm, as
sites (Mikov 1966). Graphite is a quite common poly- can be deduced from the size of the burnishing
morph mineral, appearing in the schist layers of the strokes. An important find was made in House 2.
Balkan and Rhodopi mountains, but it is most readily Along with big storage jars placed to the West of the
available in the mountain regions of Northern Bulgar- oven, a vessel of Type ‘‘J’’ (restricted spherical two-
ia (N. Zidarov, pers.comm.) (1). In any case, its pres- partite pot) was discovered. This contained a small
ence in Lı̂ga attests to a considerable movement of biconic cup with small knobs but without handles plus
people and/or objects – another important statement 14 water rolled stones (Fig. V.3). The latter can be
about Copper Age society and its mobility and/or grouped according to size, shape, and stone type. The
network. main group is made up of quartzite with whitish or
Graphite painted pottery was accomplished reddish tinge, 3 pieces (fragmented) are of brownish
through painting with graphite on a vessel’s surface black siltstone. As to shape and size, there are 5 oval
in a leather hard state. Perhaps the motives were out- and flat quartzite stones (2.7–3.1 cm long), 4 big
lined as incised lines, for the complexity of the mo- quartzite balls (3.0–4.8 cm long), 3 oblong pointed
tives implies that they were well planned before actual siltstones (3.8–4.5 cm long), and 2 triangular quartzite
decoration. Graphite painted motives may cover the pieces (4.6 cm long). Despite the enigmatic numeric
upper part or the whole vessel. Graphite was kept in order, the stones ought be connected with smoothing
place by subsequent burnishing of the surface, which and burnishing. Their small size may indicate that
enhanced the vessel’s visual and functional properties. such stones were associated in particular with produc-
Surfaces painted with graphite were better burnished tion and surface treatment of the popular small bi-
than surfaces, which were left without it. The bur- conic cups.
Several fragments of pot stands with flat top were
1. The author is grateful to Dr. Nikola Zidarov, Director of the
also discovered at Lı̂ga. One reconstructed fragment
Institute of Geology, Sofia for this and other information quoted comes from House 3 (Ø 21 cm) (Fig. V.1:1), two
in the text. others (parts of the same artefact) from a refuse area
76 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. V.4. Abraded shards. 1 – modern West African examples, 2 – a Copper Age example from Lı̂ga.

at the northern wall of House 1. The latter was often elongated rim shards with one or, in some cases
slightly smaller in diameter, but in terms of paste, two, edges smoothly abraded (Fig. V.4:2). The pattern
colour (light grey) and general appearance closely of abrasion shows that they have been used in vertical
resembled the first one. The surface was carefully direction. The contact area of such a shard is around
smoothed and the thick walls were made to resist a 4–5 cm in length, much too extensive for successfully
significant weight. Such stands are also known from compacting a surface. Therefore, it is more likely that
other Copper and Bronze Age sites (Mikov 1966, the abraded shards were used for scratching and
Figs. 10–11). V. Mikov has suggested that they smoothing of vessel surfaces, resulting in a more even
should be considered hand-tournettes (a turntable distribution of the clay. Such conclusion is also con-
device), placed on flat bases with the conic protuber- firmed by observations made in Western Africa,
ance to set the stand on (Mikov 1966). Although the where shards with similar abrasion pattern have been
functionality of such a device seems dubious in prac- seen in action by the author (Fig. V.4:1). Indeed,
tice, it is likely that the stands were indeed used in analyses of vessel surfaces confirm that scraping was
pottery production. The main part of the vessels has used as one of shaping techniques. The vessels of Lı̂ga
simple flat bases (81%, based on shard material, in 2 were built using coiling techniques. Only tiny
kg), demonstrating that they were formed on flat miniature vessels were occasionally made by hand
surfaces. Some bases also show a raised quantity of molding, i.e., forming in the palm without using ad-
sand grains, indicating that a layer of sand was sep- ditional clay, the same way as bases are formed. Bowls
arating the vessel from the modelling surface, so that were also made using coil techniques, the use of
a vessel would not adhere to the surface. By con- molds could not be demonstrated. Closed containers
trast, a part of the clay figurines have impressions of were built starting from the base, while carinated ves-
leaves of grass on their feet, promoting the sugges- sels seemingly were built in two parts and joined at
tion that special workshop areas were not needed for the shoulders. The lower part of the body was in a
their production. Concerning possible rotating de- leather hard state before being joined with the coil of
vices, their employment would have been more im- a rim. At this stage, when the basic shape was
portant for burnishing, which involved repetitive achieved, further refinement of the shape and thin-
streaking in one direction. All the investigated ves- ning of the walls were carried out by scraping. Some-
sels with burnished surfaces had traces of long hori- times, excessive scraping was done in less visible
zontal strokes. areas, like the interior surface of the shoulders. Be-
A frequent find among the Lı̂ga 2 material are re- sides abraded pottery shards, another group of im-
cycled pottery shards. These appear in different plements might also have also been employed in
shapes and reflect distinct functions. Several shards scraping. These are rounded or oval stone discs, 4.5–
were interpreted as pottery burnishers. These are 5.0¿3.1–4.6 cm and 0.8–1.0 cm thick, thinning out
Lı̂ga 77

towards the edges. Such implements were discovered


in Houses 1 & 2 (Fig. V.5).
Yet other stone tools may also be related to pottery
production. However, their interpretation is not al-
ways clear-cut. For example, based on formal simi-
larity with the abraded shards, flat stones, ca. 6¿9
cm, with a flat dorsal edge and ground surface on
both sides along the flat edge are also interpreted as
being used for pottery smoothing. But without micro-
scopic studies such interpretations remain guesswork.
Besides the graphite cone used for pottery painting,
several lumps of haematite or red ochre were found.
This pigment has also been used as pottery paint.
However, compared to other Late Copper Age sites,
it is represented rather sparsely. Several shards with
red and yellow (goethite) paint were discovered in
layers dated to the Lı̂ga 1 settlement. In Lı̂ga 2, only
House 3 held some evidence of use of red pigments.
A big storage container with a globular body was Fig. V.5. Stone discs presumably applied for pottery scraping in a
painted both with graphite and red ochre, mainly to leather hard state.
enhance the vertical loop handles (Pl. 12:13). In such
a case, paint was applied after the vessel was fired. In
another case, pulverized haematite was applied to the fired during a longer period, since the core has the
surface of vessel in leather-hard state and then bur- same colour as the surface, and the pottery is gener-
nished. This happened prior to firing. All occurrences ally harder. Along with the light coloured pottery –
of haematite lumps were treated with caution, since presently partly discoloured due to weathering and
their presence in burned daub indicated that they other post depositional effects – was a small group
were naturally occurring in local clay sources, so that of darker vessels: brown (10YR-5/3), greyish brown
their presence at the site could be explained by de- (2.5Y-5/2) and even dark grey (10YR-4/1). Since
composed daub. Several big lumps were discovered many archaeologists take colours as an indication of
in House 2. Among these was a small hemispheric firing conditions, darker colours are automatically ex-
piece with abraded edges and a diameter of 1.8 cm plained by firing in reduced atmospheres. Proper re-
(Fig. V.2). The pattern of abrasion bears witness that duction occurs when iron oxides, present in the clay,
the haematite piece was rubbed against a hard, flat are being affected over lengthy periods and at tem-
surface. peratures in excess of 850 æC (Gibson & Woods 1997).
Evidence on firing – the most demanding part of Such firing conditions were not impossible to achieve
the production cycle – has only been indirectly col- by the firing installations known from Lı̂ga, but to
lected. Many vessels had traces of fire clouds – a result sustain them over a longer period, a potter would
of the deposition of carbon during open firing. The need a kiln (Gosselain 1992) (Fig. V.6).
light colours of Lı̂ga 2 vessels: pale yellow, Munsell Evidence on pottery kilns is very sparse, as on other
Colour Chart: 2.5Y-8/3), reddish yellow (7.5YR-6/ types of firing installations. Even putting all security
8, 6/6), light red (2.5YR-6/8), red (2.5YR-5/6), light measures aside, firing of pottery within the settlement
brown (7.5YR-6/4), and the like all point towards fir- at Lı̂ga would not have been possible, partly due to
ing in oxidizing conditions. Investigations of vessel co- space limitations but mostly to windy conditions at
res show that oxidation was not always complete, the the top of the plateau, making combustion control
combustion of organic matter not always being con- impossible. So, it is predicted that firing would have
cluded. Graphite painted pottery seems to have been been carried out at a more sheltered site below the
78 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. V.6. Temperature ranges for five kinds of firing, based on thermometric data. 1 – open firing, 2 – open firing with shards covering the
pots, 3 – pit firing, 4 – pit firing with shards covering the pots, updraft kiln firing (after Gosselain 1992, in David & Kramer 2001).

plateau, probably close to the stream (and the clay Cucuteni culture (Gheorghiu 2002, with refs.). The
sources). This area has experienced significant erosion earliest remains of a kiln in Bulgaria were found in
and exploitation through its history, leaving minimal the Jagodinska cave in the Rhodopi mountains and
chances for discovery of a firing site. There is, how- are dated to the Transitional Period (Avramova
ever, another source of information, namely represen- 1992). Such kilns would have been suitable for cre-
tations in clay, often found on Copper Age sites and ating a reduced firing atmosphere.
acting as tokens of non-verbal communication. An in- More readily even, dark colour is achieved through
teresting find in this respect was made at Sadovec- smudging – a technique of depositing carbon immedi-
Ezero: a fragment of a rectangular table-like item ately below the surface (Gibson & Woods 1997),
with several perforations on the upper face was inter- which also improves the surface resistance to abrasion
preted as a model of a subterranean up-draught kiln, (Skibo et al. 1997). Smudging is easily achieved in
based on better-preserved historical (Fig. V.7 & V.8), open firings, when organic material, for example
but also Copper Age examples from the Romanian green leaves, are placed near hot vessels still covered
Lı̂ga 79

Fig. V.7. Clay item discovered in Ezero and interpreted as a model of an up-draught kiln.

with fuel (oxygen deficiency is needed). Smudging is influence of the KSB complex) and Sudievo Tells
considered a vessel improvement due to the glossy (under influence of the KGK VI complex) in the
surface. Interestingly, even though this procedure is Thracian Plain ‘‘light-brown burnished pottery is not
very simple, smudged vessels are being sold at 1/3 ornamented’’ (Todorova et al. 2003). The trend at
times higher prices than their oxidised equivalents Telish is not clear. Graphite painted pottery from Sa-
(personal observations at potters’ workshops in Bénin dovec Golemanovo Kale has dark surfaces, Redutite
and Ghana). Another widespread surface-darkening II and III have light-coloured surfaces, and the same
technique is quenching (Carlton 2002). Still hot pots is the case at the multi-layered site of Pipra. Hence,
are being submerged in a soupy organic solution (e.g., it might be suggested that dark-coloured graphite
flour mixed with water) immediately after firing, and painted pottery is earlier. However, a different pattern
as a result, the solid component of the solution car- emerges at the sites of Sadovec-Ezero and Sadovec-
bonise, creating a dark surface colour (Carlton 2002). Kaleto, where there is no clear-cut division regarding
Evidence on firing conditions is also gained in- background colour. In earlier Late Copper Age layers
directly from graphite painted pottery. Contrary to all light colours prevail here, while towards the latest
assumptions about pyrotechnological advancements – phase of the Copper Age darker colours dominate.
including the idea of firing taking place at 750–950 æ Interestingly, when comparing pottery of all three
(Todorova 1986) – it appears that graphite painted fully excavated houses at Lı̂ga, only House 2 has dark
pottery only requires relatively low firing tempera- surfaced vessels. A most striking case is that all three
tures, since graphite tends to burn out at tempera- houses had at least one vessel of the pear-shaped Type
tures above 700 æC (Milwaukee Archaeological Re- ‘‘S’’, which, identically, is decorated with fingernail
search Laboratory 2003). True professionalism thus impressions (pinching) on the main part of the body
rests with the ability to sustain temperatures above below the neck and equipped with two horizontal
500 æC, needed to combust carbon from core areas, handles. Houses 1 and 3 contained a light coloured
and below 700 æC. Hence, smudging must be re- representative, while House 2 had a dark coloured
garded as the most probable reason for dark pottery one.
colours, as it penetrates deeper and creates a more So, despite the uniformity of shapes, an important
even layer than quenching. pattern of pottery variation emerges, based on tech-
Firing conditions along with post-firing treatment nological traditions, individual skills, and perhaps
may hold cultural implications. It has been noted that even competition in stressing personal/household
the graphite painted pottery of Lı̂ga 1 has a dark particularities – as expressed through material cul-
background, while during Lı̂ga 2, graphite paint is ture.
only found on light coloured vessels. Similar obser- In terms of evidence on pottery production, House
vations are made at other Late Copper Age sites. It 1 is somewhat underrepresented. Perhaps the great
has been noted, for example, that at Yunatsite (under amount of figurine parts and miniature vessels, some
80 Acta Archaeologica

but nevertheless opening new possibilities to get closer


to the daily life of prehistoric communities.

TYPOLOGY, MENTAL TEMPLATES AND


TECHNOLOGY
Most archaeologists starting to work in ceramics have
the intrinsic belief that pots can tell us more than just
exposing their material features or aesthetic values, as
comprehended with a modern eye. But often a great
deal of studies only results in detailed and compre-
hensive typological lists, which, despite their
thoroughness, have little to offer in terms of wider
perspectives. Typology has become a justified goal in
itself for many archaeologists working with the rich
prehistoric material in Bulgaria (Todorova & Mats-
anova 2000; Todorova et al. 2003; Katsarov 2003 –
just to name a few recent studies). The strength of
typological ordering as a tool is the search for repeti-
tiveness, recognition of primal forms and not – as
often misperceived – a detection of certain unique
characteristics like lip variation. Such arbitrary over-
classification is producing a lot of behavioural
Fig. V.8. Roman up-draught kiln from the region of Hotnitsa, Veli-
‘‘noise’’, with little cultural significance (Arnold 1985).
ko Tarnovo (after Sultov 1969). B. Hayden offers a useful definition of typology that
‘‘should properly refer to systems of categorisation,
which [...] reveal something about the nature of hu-
man behaviour in relation to artefacts, whether this
of which can be regarded as experimental, may in- information is by nature evolutionary, functional,
directly indicate that clay was also a familiar medium technological, temporal, social, or other’’ (Hayden
for the residents of this house. The other two houses 1984, 80).
have undoubtedly produced pottery for their own Ethnoarchaeological research presents a number of
needs. At the same time, there is also some evidence studies accounting, for instance, for varieties in func-
for exchange at the settlement level: The canonic ap- tional distinction among pottery types to a degree
proach to certain vessel types – the already mentioned which is by no means accessible for archaeologists
pear-shaped vessel (Type ‘‘S’’), for example – may, dealing with prehistoric materials. Thus, in present
however, complicate the detection of fingerprints of day Ghana, food serving bowls with a distinct classi-
individual potters. So far, certain evidence on ex- ficatory name can be subdivided into several sub-
change relates to two untypical biconic cups without groups depending on their size, which reflects the age
the usual vertical handles, found in Houses 2 and 3 of a male person consuming the meal (Bredwa-Men-
(symbolic exchange?) (Fig. V.9). Furthermore, a jug sah 2001).
from House 2 – an exact parallel is found in Redutite Therefore, for the purpose of revealing ‘‘the role of
III – exhibits advanced ceramic skills in forming material entities as potentially active components of
highly curved and only 4 mm thick walls, and thus human behaviour’’ (Fletcher 1992), typology is being
stands out from the remaining part of the vessels of based on ‘‘mental templates’’ or ‘‘prototypes’’
this house (Fig. III.17). Several more examples can be (Kempton 1981), understood as the ideal form of an
given, based on comparisons and some speculation, artefact, existing in the cognition of people who share
Lı̂ga 81

Fig. V.9. Biconic cups discovered in, respectively, House 2 and 3. Difference in colour and surface is due to different post-depositional effects.

the same culture. Of course, the results produced tery assemblage. They also tend to be overrepre-
within the framework of this theoretical category can- sented in archaeological reports, since a formal recon-
not be tested against the classification, which existed struction can often be performed on a single shard.
among the pottery users themselves. But through For this reason, only bowls represented by two or
mapping of basic attributes and subsequent seriation more shards are taken into present consideration.
it is nevertheless possible to arrive at some basic Bowl variation manifests itself through orientation of
shapes, which at least would have been recognised by rim and shape of lip. Inverted or straight rims domi-
the potter, who thought not only in socially con- nate. Everted rims are usually sharply carinated. Ca-
structed concepts by also in terms of technological rination might have a chronological significance, as it
possibilities and a chaı̂ne opératoire. Such an approach occurs in great numbers at the Sadovec sites, and is
is in the present case supported by pottery analyses comparatively rare at Lı̂ga. Lip thickening is also con-
from other KSB sites, confirming that the process of sidered a diagnostic feature of the late Copper Age, at
‘‘cultural replication’’ during the late Copper Age was Lı̂ga it is usually reserved for bowls of better quality.
well progressed (cf. Fletcher 1992). Furthermore, bowls were often modified by adding
Our own typological ordering is presented in a handles or other attributes with the same functional
scheme (Pl. 14 & 15) (and below). Geometrical shape property. Volumetrically, bowls are a highly varied
is taken as the starting point for classification: The group.
number of geometrical forms used determines the B. Deep straight-sided bowls with thickened rim and
hierarchical order, unrestricted bowl (or a cone) being height around 1⁄2 of the maximum diameter, wall-
regarded as the simplest form. Names given to typo- base angle ranging between 50 æ and 60 æ.
logical categories encompass their supposed function, C. Deep hemispherical bowls. Knobs maybe applied
which may not always correspond to the intended use below the turning point: Highly placed turning point,
but at least is easing verbal communication. diameter of the orifice being 11⁄2 times (and less) big-
ger than the bottom diameter. A subcategory may
have rounded base.
BOWLS AND THEIR DERIVATIVES D. Deep hemispherical bowls with marked inverted rim.
A. Simple bowls. This category incorporates vessels of The turning point is marked with a pair of handles,
unrestricted cone shape, with heights varying between tabs or knobs. Volumetrically this group is uniform.
1⁄ and 1⁄ of the maximum diameter and with a wall- E. Dishes: a shallow vessel form with unrestricted
2 3
base angle ranging between 35 æ and 45 æ. Simple orifice and a height being more than 1⁄3 of its maxi-
bowls is the most numerous category of the Lı̂ga pot- mum diameter. Dishes in Lı̂ga have wide orifices with
82 Acta Archaeologica

a diameter of 40 cm and beyond. The transition be- the orifice equalling the diameter of the base. This
tween the low body and a relatively long straight rim group is closely related to Group ‘‘J’’.
is marked with a cordon, decorated with fingernail/ M. Globular vessels drawn slightly down, straight or
fingertip impressions or shell impressions. Knobs or inverted cylindrical rims.
tab handles are also found on this protrusion. The
interior is well smoothed. Volumetrically, this group
is uniform. BICONIC VESSELS WITH CYLINDRICAL NECKS
F. Barrel shaped jars: two-partite vessels with the di- N. Biconic jugs with cylindrical neck: This group is numer-
ameter of the orifice roughly equalling the height of ous and comes in a variety of different appearances
the vessel. The orifice is twice larger than the bottom. in spite of the fact that they seem to be functionally
Volumetrically, it is a uniform group, which indicates akin. In general, these thin-walled, symmetrical, and
a well-defined and fixed function. All have rusticated thoroughly made vessels can be regarded as fine pot-
surfaces and are equipped with massive vertical tery. They come with two or one vertical loop handle,
handles or knobs either on or below the turning point. sometimes with small horizontally perforated knobs
G. Upright jars with highly placed, sharply angled or tab handles, placed on or below the turning point.
shoulders and upright or (inverted) flaring necks. The Another subgroup contains juglets without handles. A
shoulders can be marked with pseudo-winding cor- particular representative of this group is an amphora-
dons. Pairs of knobs or horizontally perforated tab like jug with highly placed shoulders and vertical loop
handles (or a combination of both) are also placed on handles connecting rim with shoulder. No parallels
the shoulders. As a rule, the lower part of the body is have been discovered so far. Generally, this group is
rusticated, while the neck is smoothed and burnished. considered as typologically robust, since it is also
If decorated, patterns are displayed on the neck and widely represented at other KSB sites, primarily Re-
shoulders. The interior is well-smoothed or burnish- dutite and Sadovec. As a rule, the jugs are decorated
ed. Volumetrically, these jars fall in two size cate- in the most protruding area, i.e., the shoulders.
gories: medium sized and very large containers. The O. Closely related to the previous group are biconic
interior is well-smoothed. cups. These are shallow vessels usually equipped with
H. Biconic jars with rounded shoulders, which can two opposing vertical loop handles connecting the
be placed either high or in the middle. Massive verti- shoulders with the rim. But representatives without
cal handles are placed on or below the turning point. such handles occasionally appear. This group is nu-
The surface is rusticated. merous and probably one of the most frequent mem-
I. Bucket-shaped pot with a conical body and cylindri- bers of a standard pottery set of a household.
cal neck, represented by a single only partly preserved P. Big biconic jars with cylindrical or slightly everted
specimen. neck. This group comprises voluminous closed ves-
J. Restricted spherical two-partite pots with inverted rim sels. The turning point is exactly in the middle of the
and the turning point being in the middle of the ves- shape. Half the vessels is equipped with vertical
sel’s body. This group is one of the most numerous handles, placed either on the shoulders or below. Al-
within the pottery assemblage. A subgroup includes though similar in shape, the volumetric difference and
vessels with highly placed turning point. Vessels of the difference in pottery treatment (smooth versus
this type are found in a variety of contexts and come rusticated surface) imply that, functionally, this group
in a variety of volumetric sizes, but mainly in middle might have been heterogeneous. The type is also
and small sizes. widespread on contemporaneous sites.
K. Small biconic pots with marked straight rim, R. Similar to ‘‘P’’, but highly placed turning point
closely related both to the ‘‘H’’ and ‘‘J’’ types. Usually, and a more globular appearance of the body.
the turning point is in the middle, but occasionally S. Biconic jugs with slightly everted rim and two horizontal
also higher up. Functionally, these pots might be simi- handles placed at the beginning of the neck (pear-
lar to the ‘‘J’’ pots. shaped). In this case, the handles seem to be a strong
L. Spherical pots with marked necks, the diameter of typological attribute, as exactly the same shape with
Lı̂ga 83

the same type and position of the handles can be


found at other sites. Variation may only appear in the
type of decoration. The most frequent type of decor-
ation, also appearing at other sites, is made by fin-
gernail impressions on almost the entire surface. All
three houses in Lı̂ga contained this type of vessel. A
subgroup is fashioned in a similar way, but the orifice
is much wider as compared with the closed represen-
tatives of the main group.
T. Biconic storage containers can appear with a short
everted rim or a long cylindrical neck: wide orifice.
U. Globular storage containers with cylindrical neck:
wide orifice. Fig. V.10. Example of a biconic vessel from Hotnitsa, a Late Cop-
V. Storage containers with cone-shaped lower part and per Age tell settlement under influence of the KGK VI cultural
long, cylindrical, occasionally slightly inverted upper complex. Drawing by S. Makchev.
part.

VESSEL SHAPES not included). This marked statistical difference must


Without exclusion, the above list of Lı̂ga pottery have cultural explanations. To my best knowledge,
types – primarily based on vessel shapes – are ethno-archaeological studies are silent on such mat-
squarely included in the general typological repertoire ters, morphological attributes like handles entering
of the KSB, as well as in the KGK VI cultural com- the formal repertoire of pottery making through func-
plex. This demonstrates that the source of origin is tional considerations. Even when shifted into the styl-
the same for both complexes and must go back to a istic domain (by incorporating handles into the gen-
period before the start of the Copper Age. Where the eral design of a vessel), a functional significance is still
difference between the two cultural complexes be- preserved. Quite logically, it has been stated that one
comes visible is in application of secondary morpho- of the main sources of technological change is ‘‘feed-
logical attributes such as handles, knobs, and sup- back from the context of use’’ (Schiffer & Skibo 1987,
plemental thickening, altering the profile curves. For 598). Consequently, handles may reflect much deeper
example, characteristic for KGK VI are broad ap- structures than simple stylistic experiments or bor-
plied bands covering the shoulders of biconic vessels, rowing under influence from other regions with dif-
thus creating the visual effect of a cylindrical body ferent cultural affiliations.
element inserted between a cone-shaped lower and Handles are disadvantageous in terms of produc-
the upper parts of the vessel (Fig. V.10). More puz- tion, since they are bringing an extra complication
zling is, however, the abundant use of handles and to into the process. They are also uneconomic in terms
some extent also knobs within the KSB culture. A of space requirements, unless placed below the turn-
comparative analysis of the material from two houses ing point. Bearing these arguments in mind, it be-
of the Late Copper Age site of Hotnitsa, Veliko Tar- comes clear that handles must have a behavioural ex-
novo (considered as belonging to the KGK VI sphere planation. Their use must be connected with chang-
of influence) has showed that only 4% of the whole ing ideas on use of space and furniture, for example,
vessels were equipped with handles or perforated when vessels are being kept hanging rather than
tabs. In Lı̂ga this number is more than 70% in the standing on floors or shelves. But most importantly,
group of closed biconic vessels with cylindrical necks. handles increase the portability of a vessel, making
What is even more striking is that bowls are also it more suitable for transportation. Hence, increased
equipped with multiple and varied types of handles, frequency in the use of handles advocates for an in-
thus 37% of the Lı̂ga 2 bowls and derivatives (knobs creased mobility of the population: a cultural phe-
84 Acta Archaeologica

nomenon of the bearers of the KSB tradition, which below) highly acute. The reasoning only ends with a
is not as yet fully acknowledged. suggestion and not conclusive statements. But what-
ever interpretation is chosen, it always has cultural
implications. Lids for cooking pots would indicate a
FUNCTIONAL CONSIDERATIONS type of cuisine based on stewed meals. Clay pans
Perhaps the most important issue in pottery studies is would imply baking of wheat bread. Luckily, such
function. A vessel is considered to be a utilitarian tool interpretations may be tested against organic residue
(Rice 1987, 208), which occasionally may or may not analyses. For example, it has recently been demon-
enter the symbolic domain. The variety of pottery strated that a vessel type, which for half a century has
shapes and sizes, surface treatment techniques and been known in SE Europe as a ‘‘milk jug’’ due to its
decoration designs can be seen as cultural expressions form and ethnographic analogy, appears to bear no
with a clear functional aspect as regards the needs traces of being used as a milk container (Craig et al.
and requirements of the users. Most pottery re- 2003).
searchers agree that form, temper and surface treat- In terms of tempering materials used in pottery
ment reflect and are determined by function (Rice production, there is a growing body of evidence that
1987, 208). Consciously, or through ‘‘try and error’’, selection of tempering materials is governed by pot-
each artefact is evaluated according to its ‘‘perform- tery function (Steponaitis 1984; Rice 1987). For ex-
ance matrix’’, that is how the production (procure- ample, cooking pots are expected to withstand ther-
ment of raw materials, tempering, consumption of mal shock during episodes of repeated heating, which
fuel, etc.), use and maintenance rely to a vessel’s per- may reach 300–500 æC. Effective resistance to thermal
formance characteristics (Schiffer & Skibo 1987). By shock can be achieved through the use of organic
comparing longevity of vessel types one may establish tempering materials which create greater porosity of
some particularly robust types: culturally rooted and a vessel and thus arrests eventual cracks (Rye 1976;
functionally stable, as well as some weaker types: in- Arnold 1985). Chamotte is also a suitable tempering
terim phenomena reflecting the innovative potential material as it expands at the same rate as the clay
of a society. But revealing such variables as form, tem- matrix and will not cause cracking (Rye 1976; Arnold
per and surface treatment cannot always be unam- 1988). This also means that the shrinkage rate is the
biguous, as a range of other factors may bias their same, making chamotte tempered pottery resistant
selection, not least the narrow analytical background even to freezing temperatures. Organic tempering
of the investigator. Take for example the so-called materials can be appreciated for a better workability
early Slavic clay pans: clay disks with turned up edg- of the clay and greater strength during forming pro-
es. These have been identified on sites of the sixth- cesses (Schiffer & Skibo 1987). In terms of fiber use,
seventh century AD, which were regarded as Slavic. thatch or straws have a reinforcing effect on non-fired
Clay pans are interpreted as facilities for baking bread or low-fired dry storage containers. Organic tem-
leaves, based on typological links with ethnographic pered vessels are appearing to be friable. In order to
data from the Balkans, where clay pans have been in increase abrasion resistance – for instance, in the case
use until recently (Curta 2002, 295). However, of cooking, serving and recurrent cleaning actions –
artefacts of the same form are also known from a potter had to consider additional constituents that
Hallstatt assemblages in Slovakia and Volhynia, will enhance the performance characteristics of such
where they were used as lids for urns (Curta 2002). vessels. In the case of Lı̂ga, potters have achieved
Hence, based on the latter analogy, it has recently mitigation of friability through addition of chamotte
been suggested that clay pans should be regarded as or sand, or through thickening of the walls. It has
lids for cooking pots (Curta 2002). No argumentation been noted, that organic tempering is preferred for
has been provided as to why the last and not the first production of big vessels, as it decreases the total
analogy is more reliable. Such observations make the weight of such. A medium size vessel weighs 6–7 kg,
problems of functional interpretation of clay pans so weight must have been considered as an issue,
from Lı̂ga and other prehistoric sites in Bulgaria (cf. which could not be treated casually.
Lı̂ga 85

Less well understood is the use of calcareous com- may cause dental or nutrition problems. Instead of
ponents in the clay. At Lı̂ga it is used in rather moder- using complicated explanations, more simple and ef-
ate quantities, probably partly due to its natural oc- fective ones are chosen: ‘‘Use the hard rock types and
currence in the clay sources, but still, its presence can- stay healthy/alive’’.
not be explained away as accidental. In other The same might be the case with the use of cal-
contemporary sites, like Hotnitsa Tell at Veliko Tur- careous materials. Potters simply believe that this
novo, calcareous components make up the most im- tempering material is superior. Pottery technicians
portant tempering constituent of the clay matrix (pers. are trying to understand why technologically compli-
observations). The thermal expansion rates of cal- cated materials are chosen, while others, with a
careous materials (CaCO3) is close to the clay they chemical background, provide the plausible expla-
are incorporated into (Rye 1976). At firing tempera- nation: Calcareous materials create an alkaline en-
tures of 620–900 æC, CaCO3 starts to decompose (into vironment and thus inhibits the growth of bacteria,
calcium oxide and carbon dioxide), leading to spalling which need an acidic environment to interact with
and desintegration (Rye 1976). Many recovered ves- alimentary products (Rehhof et al. 1990). Hence, ves-
sels do have lime blows but these are believed to be sels tempered with calcite or storage containers plas-
the result of secondary burning, which occurred when tered with lime or gypsum plasters are highly suitable
the settlement burned down. The use of calcareous for keeping grain and other dry foodstuffs. Obser-
clays in any case excludes the use of firing kilns, point- vation must have led to similar conclusions in prehis-
ing to the fact that their utilisation must have been toric times and then transmitted as a culturally en-
limited. Modern potters, producing vernacular pot- forced idiom.
tery in the Balkans, also consider calcareous materials An important issue in the case of Lı̂ga is to explain
(usually calcite) as the superior tempering material the existence of several different combinations of tem-
(Carlton 2002). Which qualities exactly make calcite pering materials. The existence of a high 11 Temper-
superior are not being formulated, since such matters ing Groups – which can be further subdivided ac-
do not seem to occupy the minds of these potters cording to prevailing constituents within a combi-
(Carlton 2002). nation – shows that such are not accidental but
This leads to another area of understanding of the practically tried and accepted combinations. Hence,
technological dimensions of tempering materials, it would not be wrong to equate tempering groups
namely that their selection (as also the selection of with technological traditions.
clays) may well be culturally biased. By stating this, The usual pattern that emerges from ethnorachae-
technological reasons for favouring one or another ological research is that ceramic traditions are trans-
element are not rejected, but the real reason may well mitted through the female line of the family (Graves
be coated in different layers of folk beliefs or techno- 1991; David & Kramer 2001). Circumstantially, this
logical inertia: ‘‘this is how we do it’’. Certain dis- is even proven by archaeological evidence at Franch-
coveries may lead to results which might be difficult thi, Greece (Vitelli 1993). The variability of combi-
to mediate directly, instead a set of more understand- nations of tempering materials might thus be ex-
able constrains are being put on community mem- plained in terms of existence of differing pottery tra-
bers. For example, in selecting milling stones, the ditions, reflecting a range of mating network relying
population of southern Bénin is constrained to use on patrilocal principles of residence. Actually, male
rock types, which can only be exploited in the north- potters would not alter the outcome of this reasoning,
ern part of the country, spreading the folk belief that for in any case such diversity of technological tra-
the use of other types of rocks will cause heart diseases ditions advocate for a significant movement of people
and death. This is not an economic attempt to ma- and a wide breadth of communication networks of
nipulate the population for the benefit of certain rock the settlers of Lı̂ga 2.
quarries. In fact, the issue is less dramatic, for the Turning to the Lı̂ga 1 material, which reflects a
message is meant to warn against soft rock types rather high uniformity in terms of pottery traditions
found in southern Bénin, which easily pulverize and (especially as to surface treatment), one may in this
86 Acta Archaeologica

tery function is surface treatment. In many cases sur-


face treatment alone is informative enough to help
deducing the function of a vessel. Thus, the automa-
tism of ‘‘big vessel π surface rusticationΩstorage ves-
sel’’ certainly holds true in many cases.
A great variety of surface treatment techniques
have been recorded from the Lı̂ga 2 settlement. Sur-
Fig. V.11. Biconic vessels. 1 – from Redutite III (after Gergov
1992a), 2 – from Lı̂ga, House 2.
face rustication with barbotine and finger-trailing
have already been mentioned under decoration tech-
niques, but the most common type of Lı̂ga 2 surface
treatment is simple smoothing while the paste is still
find a clarification of the issue of technological plastic. Perhaps some of the water-worn quartz
change, which occurred after the abandonment of the pebbles found were employed for that, besides usual
pertaining settlement. The qualitative differences be- finger smoothing. A true slip achieved through coat-
tween the two settlements signify a change of social ing with another layer of clay in order to change the
focus, from self-centred to out-going, from adaptive colour or to reduce the permeability is very rare.
to explorative, from passive to active. The causes of When found, it is clearly distinctive as a separate layer
this change deserve a separate discussion, but more reaching up to 1.5 mm in thickness. Mainly it occurs
than that, they need to be elaborated through a differ- on the interior of closed vessels or, sometimes, bowls,
ent approach to the already excavated material, pref- which therefore are interpreted as liquid containers.
erably fresh excavations, since regional data are still More often, self-slip occurs, a technique where the
very weak on this account. surface is being smoothed with a wet hand or cloth,
Albeit pottery from the neighbouring site of Redut- thus concentrating the finest particles of the clay ma-
ite is not available for closer investigation, whole ves- trix as an outermost covering layer (Hodges 1965).
sels presented in publications or museum collections The main surfaces of fine pottery, the exteriors of jugs
show a great affinity with the pottery of Lı̂ga. Very and graphite painted vessels, and the interiors of
close parallels are found both in Redutite II and in bowls had burnished surfaces. As mentioned, burnish-
the temporarily more distant Redutite III (Fig. V.11). ing reduces permeability and provides effective
This underlines two important points: the longevity methods to fasten colour pigments. Despite such tech-
of certain vessel types and a sense of territoriality. I nological advantages, burnishing was primarily val-
here employ the term ‘‘type’’ to indicate an end result, ued for its visual qualities. Thus, the interiors of
expressed through a combination of shape π second- closed vessels were mainly burnished in the area of
ary morphological attributes π decoration & zones of the rim. But interiors were not left untreated. Quite
decoration. Accidental congruence of the three main often, traces of brushing are recorded on the interior
variables is statistically improbable and can only be of closed vessels. Besides surface smoothing this could
explained with a conscious handover of ‘‘production also be used to better distribute the clay, especially
recipes’’. In turn, this indicates that genealogically minimizing the transition between the coils. Brushing
connected people were constantly resettling the same was done with a tuft of fine twigs or other kinds of
territory during several hundreds years. In fact, the fibers. Sometimes the interiors have traces of deep
hiatus layer of 0.2 m between Redutite II and III need striations, covering the entire surface. Their presence
considerable time to be formed, much longer than on big biconic jars with long narrow necks shows that
suggested by the excavator: 60–120 years (Gergov this was a special surface compacting technique, car-
1992a) (cf. above). Further implications of this reason- ried out in the state when the vessel was leather-hard.
ing would be a return to an earlier (and not very orig- Therefore, striations almost appear as deep grooves.
inal) assumption, namely that pottery functionality is The striations are usually 2 mm wide, made with a
type bound. brush of relatively stiff stems or similar materials, gen-
The last variable to be considered in terms of pot- erally following a horizontal direction. It should be
Lı̂ga 87

stressed that vessel shape may also dictate the type intended and actual use (Skibo 1992). The last may
and areas of decoration, as can be seen from vessels be complicated to achieve without supplementary
with formal and decorational affinity but volumetric microscale analyses, such as residue analysis. In-
and functional differences. Generally, as it can be tended use may be too broad a category to be in-
seen from the overview of main pottery shapes exem- formative at all. Nevertheless, an attempt is being
plified by whole vessels, there is a clear correlation made below to unveil the functional variability of the
between vessel shape and surface treatment. Lı̂ga 2 vessels.
The very strength of the research at Lı̂ga is a fourth Bowls is the largest group of all pottery types. They
dimension or variable, the context. The position of a are traditionally connected with food serving, and as
vessel within a house, as well as its association with such experience the greatest stress and the shortest
other vessels or artefacts, is an important testimony use-life (Rise 1987, Table 9.4). Investigation of the
to the use of such vessel. The following considerations refuse area between Houses 2 and 3, interpreted as
on functionality are therefore explored through the an immediate discard area of domestic waste, has
combination of the abovementioned variables: shape, showed that the highest frequency among pottery
temper, and surface treatment, and, the context. fragments was held bowls and small cups. Moreover,
Following the functional categorisation suggested these were discovered in big fragments, and occasion-
by P. Rice (Rice 1987), pottery is treated in terms ally as halves of whole vessels. Two sizes of bowls –
of storage, processing, transfer, and other. The last up to 25 cm in diameter, and beyond that (usually
category is a mixed one, encompassing pottery types around 40 cm) – may indicate personal versus group
with special or uncertain functions, e.g., fire-vessels. consumption. Slightly inverted rims, as the majority
The conviction, that functionality can be deduced of the bowls has, would prevent spillage but also be
from the available pottery sets, is supported by the very unsuitable for pouring. Numerous bowls found
fact that despite technological variation, there is a around the ovens imply that such may also have been
clear trend towards replication among the sets (cf. the involved in food processing, but probably not in con-
above section dealing with production technology). nection with liquid foodstuffs, simply because the size
Furthermore, this issue can be elucidated through (usually shallow with wide orifices) and the shape of
ethnoarchaeological work, providing examples that the bowls recorded at the ovens have practical limi-
potters may have great flexibility in their methods of tations, making pouring from one container to an-
production (Skibo 1992). Thus, stability may not only other a complicated task.
be seen as cultural inertia, but as a reflection of The use of bowls for storage of dry foodstuffs can-
evolved functional pottery types corresponding to the not be excluded, even though this would be unecon-
needs of the people. omic in terms of space; in fact, this may explain the
Revealing pottery function is the optimal goal for need for handles or the like. Rounded ear handles,
any ceramic study, since such is connecting a range tab handles perforated both horizontally and verti-
of complicated issues, like subsistence, diet, and even cally, or pierced rims are found on almost half the
architecture and furniture. It is interesting to observe bowls. In two cases, horizontally perforated tab
that the notion of luxury wares as objects visually handles were fashioned as an anthropomorphic face
standing out has also been recognized by the settlers with protruding nose, placed immediately below the
of Lı̂ga, but such wares were not excluded from the turning point and yielding extra character to a recog-
utilitarian sphere. Part of the graphite painted ware nized pot. There is a certain regularity in the way
has decoration rubbed off as a result of use. So, the different types of handles are placed. Vertically per-
exclusiveness was stated through active use and expo- forated tab handles are placed on turning points/
sition and not as passive exhibition on shelves. Hence, shoulders if these are marked (i.e., the widest part of
socio- and ideafunctions sensu Skibo (Skibo 1992) can- a bowl), or just below the lip if a bowl has a straight
not be separated from technofunctions (Skibo 1992), profile line. Piercing is also made immediately below
at least not in the case of the Lı̂ga 2 material. the lip. Clearly, this indicates that such bowls were
Functional deductions are possible on two levels, adapted for (horizontal) suspension. Vertical handles
88 Acta Archaeologica

tive diagnostic features. One of the jugs found in


House 2 contained a small worked sheep/goat as-
tragalus.
Vessels of Types ‘‘F’’ (barrel shaped jars), ‘‘H’’ (bi-
conic jars with rounded shoulders), and ‘‘I’’ (bucket
shaped pot) are interpreted as short term (?) dry stor-
age vessels through their association with each other
and with the grain pithos in House 2. All have rusti-
cated surfaces and wide orifices but are volumetrically
smaller than the following category of dry storage ves-
sels. All vessels of the group are equiped with handles
or massive functional knobs, demonstrating their
portability. Rusticated surfaces provide firmer grip-
ping and increase abrasion resistance.
Long term storage containers are the most vol-
uminous pottery type, corresponding functionally to
the permanently installed pithoi, as in the House 2.
Their typological and stylistical variety is quite large
Fig. V.12. Bowl decorated with painted pattern of snakes, from and probably not fully represented since mending of
Redutite II, exhibited at the Regional Historical Museum, Pleven big containers is a complicated task. The recon-
(ØΩca. 40 cm). structed types include simple containers with cone-
shaped lower part and long, cylindrical upper part
(Type ‘‘V’’), which can be rusticated and decorated
or horizontally perforated tab handles are found with cordons and bands of fingertip impressions, or
either above or below the turning point (and could have smooth surfaces with incised patterns. Biconic
also be used for suspension). Abrasion marks found or globular shapes (Types ‘‘T’’ and ‘‘U’’) could also
on the exterior of several pierced bowls (or their frag- be chosen for such voluminous types as storage con-
ments) below the holes show that these were in re- tainers. Decoration seems to play a double role for
peated contact with hard surfaces. Hence it was sug- these vessels. With few exceptions, voluminous stor-
gested that some bowls were hung vertically on the age containers are decorated. They can be perceived
walls. as static sculptures, rarely moved and attracting atten-
Jugs, juglets and biconic cups (Types ‘‘N’’ & ‘‘O’’), tion of eventual visitors, signalising the wealth of the
abundantly represented in each house at Lı̂ga, should owner. At the same time, decoration could have been
also be seen as part of a serving set. These are often used for protective purposes in the realm of magic.
found in association with bowls. Through association, Spiral-snake patterns are numerous, especially on
jugs of Type ‘‘S’’ (pear-shaped) may be included in bowls, where snake heads are added to the spirals,
the same group. Their closed orifices and long necks making the equation between snakes and spiral orna-
are suitable for pouring. All vessels of the group are mentation more convincing (Fig. V.12). This orna-
so-called strong types, reflecting longevity of tradition, mentation is found on female figurines, stelae inter-
cultural adherence and, through close parallels with preted as altars, and other ritual objects, and is also
the KGK VI pottery, affiliation with broader regional applied to the group of storage containers, either in
associations. Like the well-known beakers of the TRB the form of incisions (Fig. IV.2) or graphite paint (Pl.
culture (Sherratt 1987), such vessels can be seen as 12). Certainly, vessels holding the vital resources of a
tokens of social behaviour connected with common household needed this extra protection to withstand
eating and drinking practices. Vessels of this group putridity and bacteria, and other menaces.
are acknowledged as the most distinct pottery of the Little doubt can arise in relating vessels of Types
Late Copper Age, but cannot be used as time-sensi- ‘‘P’’ and ‘‘R’’ with liquids. Both types have biconic
Lı̂ga 89

shapes expanding to an almost globular appearance. base would enable to concentrate the main part of
In terms of shape, the vessels are typologically related the food higher up, where heating is most intense.
to other biconic specimens, but volumetrically they The relatively open orifice would enable handling of
are much bigger. Uniform in shape, these types cover food more easily, while the slightly inverted neck
two functional categories, transfer and storage, vessels would prevent ‘‘boiling over and reduce evaporation’’
with smoothed surfaces equipped with handles being (Rise 1987). The relative depth would permit to con-
seen as connected with transfer. Furthermore, based serve the heat (Rise 1987). However, such assump-
on a common ethnographic analogy, such jars are tions are not supported by scientifically collected eth-
interpreted as being used for carrying water. The big- nographic data from contemporary traditional societ-
gest one, with well smoothed exterior and interior ies, where food preparation is made over an open
compacted by deep striations, and equipped with two fire-place, posing different requirements for cooking
massive handles, had a capacity of 44 litres, the total pottery, such as rounded bases (see Rice 1987, 239).
weight, when full, being 60 kg. It was found close to Examples of close affinities to the group in question
the entrance of House 3, which would indicate that can still be found in remote Russian villages, where
it had a higher mobility than a storage container. It cooking continues to be made inside an oven, now-
is not unusual to carry manual loads of 60 kg in tra- adays in metal pots of similar biconic shapes. The
ditional societies, perhaps with a helper. Other repre- circumstance that many vessels of Lı̂ga 2 were
sentatives of this group, without handles and with rus- affected by secondary burning made it difficult to rec-
ticated surfaces, were used for storage. One such ves- ognise eventual bands of soot caused by cooking.
sel was found at the pithos of House 2 with a Within the present group, part of the jars did have
corresponding flat lid. traces of soot on the lower part of the body, but the
The last major functional issue to be discussed in origin could not be established with certainty. Perhaps
this generalised presentation concerns food processing the discovery of a spoon inside such a jar in House 2
pottery. The main division is whether the processing can be used as evidence that these vessels, resembling
is made with heat or without heat (Rise 1987). Cook- modern soup tureens, were connected with food pro-
ing pottery has a very low use-life, higher than food cessing, both hot and cold.
serving pottery but much lower than for example pot- On the other hand, the great number of Type ‘‘J’’
tery used for storage (Rise 1987). The use-expectancy vessels (closely related to Types ‘‘K’’ and ‘‘L’’) may
is usually around one year. Most of the cooking ves- indirectly be used in stating their involvement in food
sels are not discarded immediately after being evalu- preparation processes. One of the pots of this group
ated as no longer suitable for cooking (for various rea- had indeed a band of soot over the lower part of the
sons, but usually due to appearing surface cracks). In- body (Fig. V.13). These vessels are found in a number
stead, they enter another functional domain (pers. of sizes: from small cup-like specimens to medium
observations, various ethnographic situations). In ones of 3–4 litres. They are believed to be the func-
Lı̂ga, there are two big pottery groups that can be tionally most universal vessel type, as observed from
associated with cooking and food processing without their reuse. These vessels were for example used for
heat. storage of tools. A vessel found west of the oven of
Based on surface treatment of interiors (well- House 2 contained a small biconic cup without
worked and compacted through smoothing or bur- handles, which was placed on top of water-worn
nishing), it has been estimated that upright jars with pebbles used in pottery production (cf. the section
highly placed, sharply angled shoulders and upright above of production technology). Another vessel of
or slightly inverted necks (Type ‘‘G’’) were suitable for the same type was found close to the entrance of the
holding liquids, e.g., for soaking purposes. Their same house, it contained a still functional adze. Sec-
shape is also optimal for the function of cooking ves- ondary modifications are also observed on vessels of
sel. When placed inside an oven, the lowest heating this type. One smaller representative had a perfor-
temperature would be at the base, which would be ation, ca. 1 cm in diameter, made centrally in the
standing at the same level as the fuel. So, a narrow base (another base of a small vessel with similar per-
90 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. V.14. Fragmented vessel with centrally placed bottom perfor-


ation.

exclusion, comprised by miscellaneous vessel types or


ceramic types one way or another related to vessels.
Deliberately, these items are not listed together with
Fig. V.13. Vessel (Type ‘‘J’’) discovered in House 2 bearing band the pottery types, which is the usual practice in Bulga-
of soot over the lower part of the body.
ria. Most of the items have a rather obvious function,
which does not depend on the shape, like a lid.

foration is also known); both items are from House 1


and were probably intended as a funnels (Fig. V.14). MISCELLANEOUS
Vessels of this group are without handles, but in- MINIATURE AND VERY SMALL VESSELS
stead almost always equipped with two or four knobs This group includes a number of very small vessels
placed on the shoulders. The surface is rusticated, which fall outside the usual functional categories dis-
usually by finger-trailing which is well-organised and cussed above. Miniature vessels are less than 5 cm in
has decoration effect. Such exterior texturing, which height, but in a way, their shapes echo the shapes of
has also been noted on a previous group (vessels of the big vessels, especially biconic jugs (Pl. 16:1–12).
Type ‘‘G’’), does not increase a vessel’s heating effec- Other vessel types like simple or footed bowls are also
tiveness (Skibo et al. 1997), contrary to some belief. represented. While some of the tiny vessels may be
Deep exterior texture protects from spalls and reduces considered models or even toys, as for example hand
cracking produced by thermal shock (Skibo et al. molded ‘‘bowls’’ made of untempered clay and low-
1997). In any case, the bigger representatives of this fired, others appear to have a more regulated func-
group may have been involved in cooking. Even tional determination. This assumption is based on the
though the search for external soot was a more or less observation that certain miniature vessel types occur
vain task, since impact from secondary burning in as exact copies also at other sites: in the neighbouring
most cases could not be ruled out (except for the one Sadovec sites, but also in a remote site like Yunatsite
rather certain case above), several vessels were in fact (Todorova & Matsanova 2000) (Pl. 16:13–14). Their
discovered with another indication of possible use in porous surfaces do not seem to be suitable to contain
food processing with heat. These externally light col- liquids, and it can only remain a speculation whether
oured vessels, volumetrically resembling each other charms or herbal medicine was kept in such vessels.
(3–4 litres) were found with totally blackened in- The function of small vessels the size of a coffee
teriors, until the edge of the rim. This may suggest, cup is not clear either and can in fact cover a range
that a process similar to quenching was taking place: of different purposes (Pl. 16:15–19). The majority has
boiling of wheat or any other flour soup/porridge. inverted rim, which makes them unsuitable to be used
The last category to be discussed is a category by as cups. Two vessels attributed to the group had 2
Lı̂ga 91

cm long cylindrical spouts with a diameter of 0.5 cm lower ring-foot. The diameters are 10–18 cm. The
(‘‘feeding bottles’’). Barrel-like in shape with slightly surfaces are either plain or decorated with incised
everted rim, they were too fragmented to be com- spirals. None of the pot stands have traces of having
pletely reconstructed, but the height was estimated to been in contact with fire.
be 6 cm. Both were found in House 1. None of the
representatives of this group has decorated surface.
PANS
In layers attributed both to Lı̂ga 1 and Lı̂ga 2, flat ce-
LIDS ramic discs with upturned edges have been found, simi-
Fragments of lids (Pl. 16:20–24) were very often re- lar to the earlier discussed ‘‘Slavic bread pans’’ (Pl.
covered, but their proper identification is not always 16:30–32). Such items are discovered at every KSB
straightforward. They can have an appearance of flat site. The size ranges between 15 and 20 cm in diam-
discs, just slightly curved. Or they can resemble rather eter. The interpretation as lids (Curta 2001, cf. above)
deep, straight-sided bowls. Tempering Group IV pre- is disputable, due to their massiveness and, especially,
vails. The lids fall in two size categories: those with a to the fact that a variety of more elaborate lids are
diameter of 10–15 cm and those of 20–25 cm. Oc- abundantly represented in the repertoire of Copper
casionally, they can be larger, up to 36 cm in diam- Age pottery. Furthermore, a fragment of a similar
eter. shape with an upright handle has been discovered.
One exceptional example allows reconstruction of What can be disputed is whether such pans were used
a vessel type as yet unknown among the archaeologi- for bread baking or something else – like salt produc-
cal material, thick walled and with a narrow neck: a tion. It is quite certain that this type of pottery was
bottle-like vessel. A single discovered rim shard might created to be exposed to high temperatures.
perhaps give some idea of the shape of such vessel
(Pl. 16:25). The lid in question is circular, 8 cm in
diameter, with slightly concave top and a plug-like FIRE-VESSELS AND STRAINERS
circular protuberance that can be inserted into a con- These two types of artefacts are similar in appearance
tainer with the diameter of 4.2 cm (Pl. 16:24). but completely different in function. They have the
shape of a bowl and are dotted with holes. The differ-
ence between them is that fire-vessels (Fig. III.13:1 &
POT STANDS AND FOOTED VESSELS 14) (often rather misleadingly known as Rauchgefässe)
Pot stands have been a constant member of the Cop- have two orifices, a narrow one and a broad. Fire-
per Age house inventory (Pl. 16:26–28). They are vessels have been a typical inventory of every house-
often associated with bowls to provide extra stability hold. In the Lı̂ga 2 settlement complete representa-
if the base is narrow, but it cannot be ruled out that tives were discovered in both House 2 and 3, close to
their use was connected with social aspirations rather the oven. The use of such special clay devices has
than practicalities. The existence of footed bowls, been comprehensively discussed by E. Cosack (Co-
which perhaps derive from the same aspirations, may sack 1994). Examples without wholes are also known,
be regarded as a kindred type. Footed bowls were but their purpose can be deduced due to traces of
rare in Lı̂ga and are only represented as fragments secondary burning. The fire-vessels were used to pre-
(Pl.16:29). Each house contained 3–4 pot stands. serve fire during periods when the oven was not in
They are of two types. The usual type has the shape use, typically at night. Ashes with ember could be
of a low double-cone with an identical size of the ori- covered by a fire-vessel, which would then minimize
fices. Abrasion marks inform about the standing sur- the supply of air, keeping the ember/coal glowing but
face. Another type resembles an egg-cup: a shallow not burning. Such vessels are known to have been
ring-foot supports a deep bowl-like upper part. The used from the Neolithic through the Migration
difference between the last type and the footed bowls Period, at least (Cosack 1994).
is that pot stands are supported by a broader and Quite often shards with perforated walls were
92 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. V.15. Double-conic clay item discovered at the oven in House 3.


Fig. V.16. Bowl with antropomorphic tab handles.

found among the excavated material. Through the the oven and close to the milling platform. It is con-
discovery of fully preserved items, it was established sidered enigmatic since several possible interpreta-
that there are some repetitive differences helping to tions of its function can be suggested. It is equipped
distinguish between fire-vessels and strainers (Pl. with four small vertical handles approximately in the
17:1). Although the size of the perforations may be middle, probably intended for a wide orifice (height
the same, their density is twice as great on strainers 16 cm, Ø1: 18 cm, Ø2: 8 cm) (Fig. V.15, Pl. 11:5).
(35 pr 3 cm2 as compared with the fire-vessels’ 16 pr Such objects are also known from other Copper Age
3 cm2). The holes in strainers tend to get narrower and later sites, usually without handles or occasionally
from the centre towards the outer surface, while fire- with small bosses on the edge of the rim. Tradition-
vessels keep the same size of the holes. Holes on ally, the items have been interpreted as drums. But
strainers are distributed from immediately below the other, more mundane functions are also possible, for
edge, while the edge of fire-vessels has a band without example a sieve or a funnel, which could be fixed to
perforations. Fire-vessels have far better smoothened hide bags or the like.
outer surfacse than strainers. The inside surfaces are
not worked in either.
Three nearly complete strainers were found. They VESSELS WITH ANTHROPOMORPHIC AND
have a greatest diameter of 10 cm and a height of 6– ZOOMORPHIC REPRESENTATIONS
7 cm. The smoothly abraded central part – opposed One bowl discovered in House 2 was equipped with
to a rough rim and rounded bottom – indicates that vertical tab handles horizontally perforated in such a
strainers must have been used together with vessels way that a human face with protruding nose and in-
with an orifice not exceeding 9.5 cm. cised eyes was created (Fig. V.16). House 1 contained
a vessel, which was equipped with flattened bosses
and small protruding zoomorphic heads, most prob-
DOUBLE-CONIC CERAMIC ITEM ably resembling an ox (Pl. 17:2). An ox representation
An enigmatic double conic object with two orifices was also found in House 3. A fragment of a spherical
was found in House 3 of Lı̂ga 2, immediately West of thin-walled vessel (‘‘oil lamp’’?) had a triangular head
Lı̂ga 93

(representation of horns?), a dewlap on the neck and the original technology if no constrains of this kind
incised almond-shaped eyes (Pl. 17:3). are imposed (David & Kramer 2001).
Hence, it is suggested that the technological vari-
ability of the pottery production of Lı̂ga 2 mirrors a
SPOONS mixed composition of the occupants. This observation
A number of spoons (Pl. 17:4–6), mainly fragmented, is reinforced by comparative studies of ceramics from
have been discovered. They can be divided into two Lı̂ga 2 and Hotnitsa Tell at Veliko Tarnovo, the latter
types: with a handle of circular, or with flattened showing a much greater uniformity, thus implying the
cross-section. The last group is slightly bigger in size, existence of different patterns of social behaviour. It
but generally the length of the spoons varies between has been proposed that these differences should be ex-
8 and 9 cm. A spoon with flattened handle was found plained by a higher mobility and expanding networks
inside a vessel of Type ‘‘G’’ (Pl. 17:4). Surprisingly, all of interaction, which, most importantly, have led to ex-
spoons contain some amount of sand in the clay ma- change of people through distant alliances and mating
trix, usually combined with organic matter. strategies. Further studies may confirm the antici-
pation based on Lı̂ga material, that such differences re-
flect a general diachronic trend and perhaps can be
SUMMARY & PERSPECTIVES considered as a diagnostic temporal marker.
The body of ceramic data collected during the three Another important observation is that the pottery
field campaigns of 2000–2002 at Lı̂ga is too large to production of Lı̂ga 2 was organised on a household
be presented in its full extent. Nearly every shard has level, since two of the three fully investigated houses
been entered into the artefact database, which has contained certain direct as well as circumstantial
become a vital and as yet not exhausted tool for pieces of evidence about pottery production. House 3
further studies. The strength of the base lies not only is the most striking example, with evidence on manu-
in a very high degree of detailed information regard- facture of utilitarian graphite painted pottery, which
ing material attributes, but also, due to coupling, in apparently was reserved for the household itself. Ex-
contextual information bridging the past with the change between the households was limited and prob-
present. Answering the questions regarding pottery ably exclusively symbolic in nature. Detailed pottery
variability posed at the beginning of this chapter, the analysis has also revealed that technological superior-
following conclusions can be made regarding the Lı̂ga ity cannot be assumed on the basis of pottery decor-
2 settlement. ation and surface treatment. The chief difference be-
Firstly, since cultural transmission operates in a tween plain and decorated pottery is the investment
hierarchical order, the most important feature is of time. Thus, burnished graphite painted pottery
shape, or rather its idealised version, often termed a needed the longest period of manufacture, but was no
mental template. Secondary morphological attributes technological necessity.
such as handles are often integrated into the general This raises questions about the composition of the
perception of vessels but their place is not always de- household, assuming that women were responsible for
termined, as they drift between demands of the prac- the pottery. If each household required a more or less
tical and cultural constructs (which again can over- stable number of vessels per member, how can it be
lap). Temper, decoration, and method of manufacture explained that some households could afford to invest
also take a secondary significance in the broader cul- three times or more energy in pottery production?
tural perspective, reflecting different technological The issue of human resources needs further clarifi-
traditions or ‘‘technological styles’’, helping to deter- cation, while the value of visually outstanding pottery
mine social rather than cultural boundaries (cf. Stark as a medium of socially loaded messages remains be-
et al. 1995, with references). There is a number of yond doubt. Active pottery display even in the most
ethnographic examples of potters changing the reper- casual situations, like fetching water, can be seen as
toire of their production as they move to new places an instrumental non-verbal claim to maintain the so-
or when market demands change, while they preserve cial position of household members.
94 Acta Archaeologica

Investigations of shard materials have resulted in nificant part of the information may still be lacking),
two basic conclusions. Stylistic variation taken separ- there is apparently no niche left for organic tools. The
ately has a very coarse chronological sensitivity, more presence of ceramic spoons – the most usual type of
coarse than is desired by archaeologists. What seems artefact rendered in bone or wood – underlines the as-
to ensure greater confidence in chronological sensi- sumption that pottery production has covered most of
tivity is the percentage of decoration styles and tech- the needs in terms of containers etc., except for vol-
niques represented. Quite remarkably, even super- uminous and light baskets.
ficial studies of Late Copper Age pottery from the The potters of Lı̂ga were familiar with the main-
Vaksevo tell in the Sruma valley has already produced stream of pottery production, both locally and else-
evidence supporting this assumption, although with- where. Cultural replication can be seen through the
out full acknowledgement of the excavator (Čochadži- shapes and composition of vessels types recovered in
ev 2001). each house. But this did not exclude the manifestation
The wealth of pottery even allows us to question the of an individual fingerprint, telling about varying
widely accepted assumption that much prehistoric evi- skills, motoric abilities, and, not least, varying tastes
dence – such as bone and in particular wooden items – and artistic talents. Much archaeological fine-ty-
has vanished and left a serious artefactual gap. Looking pology is simply household variation. The Lı̂ga inves-
at the numbers of vessels represented, the distribution tigation has brought the individual Copper Age
of their shapes and sizes (with the reservation that a sig- household, and its members, into historical focus.
VI. SMALLER OBJECTS OF CLAY
TABLET son being a highly detailed investigation. Two (nearly)
Among the more exceptional finds from Lı̂ga is a clay complete pieces and 20 fragments were found, all but
disc – a so-called clay tablet with incised lines and dots one attributed to the Lı̂ga 2 settlement. The most
in a manner that is beyond the accidental. Although common part among the fragmented pieces are legs
simplistic, a communicative load is supposed, as in a (incl. feet: 9, right leg – 4, left leg – 3, both legs – 2)
letter (Fig. VI.1). The tablet was found in the area of and heads (6). Torsos and arms are seemingly lacking,
House 3, in a disturbed top layer, 0.20 m below the sur- although there is one wavy clay item with pointed
face and therefore not attributed to any particular fea- end which could have been part of an arm (Pl.
ture. Although fragmented (with recent breakage 19:4251). Single pieces account for hips (Pl. 19:8099),
traces), it provides enough information as to the form knees (Pl. 18:9, Pl. 19:4040) and rump (Pl. 19:5043).
and pattern. The tablet has a round shape, 47 mm in Two figurines are represented by their lower part of
diameter, 10–12 mm thick with flat and smoothed the body only (Pl. 19: 11 (9086) & Fig. VI.2 (7045).
backside. The tablet is light grey brown in colour, well- 14 items come from apparently undisturbed units and
baked (no traces of secondary burning) and made of only two do not have a precise provenience, being
clay tempered with fine sand (some amount of organic accidental finds in loose soil (Pl. 19:UN005/9A,
matter is also present). Its original estimated weight is 2001/17). The remaining six pieces were discovered
35 g. Incised lines were made with a wooden tool with during the course of excavation, but in redistributed
a flat 2 mm wide nib. The dots are slightly deeper than fills.
the lines. Parts of the lines contained traces of light Part of a figurine, which can be attributed to the
(whitish) paste, possibly incrustation. This observation Lı̂ga 1 settlement was discovered below the SW part
is only based on visual analysis with magnifier. There of House 1 of Lı̂ga 2 (Fig. VI.3 (8099)). This house
are, however, other finds, including clay disk from Yun- was constructed on remains of an earlier one, the SW
atsite (also known as Ploskata Mogila) discovered in the part, at the descending slopes, being stabilized by oc-
1950s, with white incrusted incisions and dots (Gim- cupational debris of the previous settlement (cf.
butas 1986, 251, Fig. 9.55). above, Chapter II). Hence, the original position of the
Clay tablets remain an enigmatic type of objects, a
feature shared with other – no doubt related – items,
such as so-called stamp seals and bottoms with signs,
abundantly found at the site of Gradeshnitsa (Nikolov
1974). What is conspicuous, is that already in the Neo-
lithic such objects, loaded with communicative value,
markedly outweighs the western part of Bulgaria com-
pared with the far better investigated eastern part of the
country (see Dzhanfezova 2003, 98, Map 1; Čochadži-
ev 2003b; Todorova 1986; 1993). At present, no con-
vincing interpretation can be given. Structurally, the
Lı̂ga tablet resembles a map, whether of stars or points
in a landscape, perhaps even a social chart.

FIGURINES
ANTHROPOMORPHIC FIGURINES
The corpus of anthropomorphic figurines from Lı̂ga
is very large compared to the area excavated, the rea- Fig. VI.1. Fragment of clay tablet (‘‘letter’’).
96 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. VI.2. Lower part of clay figurine (TS 7045) discovered in


House 2 (height – 7 cm). Photo: R. Kolev.

fragmented figurine could not be established, al-


though the mixed and compact character of the layer
of shards where the fragment was found may indicate
that the materials were extracted from an area of reg-
ular waste.
This would certainly fall in line with observations
made on the distribution of figurines in the sub-
sequent Lı̂ga 2 phase. Seven pieces with established Fig. VI.3. Fragment of clay figurine of Lı̂ga 1 settlement (TS 8099)
(height – 8.4 cm). Photo: R. Kolev.
provenience were found in waste areas, mainly along
the northern and eastern wall of House 1 (6 cases),
one fragment was discovered between Houses 2 and
3 (Pl. 19:10061). trench, had a much darker brown color. The total
Figurines were also present within the houses. A height of the figurine is 18 cm. Notably, this woman
rather exceptional situation was uncovered in the is clearly pregnant. To the left of the figurine was
area of House 4, only partly excavated. Close to the placed a seeming bowl (Ø – 10 cm) with what ap-
eastern wall, facing the presumable entrance in the peared to be a clay egg in it (Fig. VI.4). The ‘‘bowl’’
South, an enstooled clay figurine was discovered, was of the shape of a funnel narrowing to half of its
commonly known as a ‘‘sitting goddess’’ (Fig. VI.4, upper diameter. The general outline and traces of the
Pl. 5 & 19). The head appeared 1 m North of the breakage at the narrower end suggest that, originally,
body, evenly cut through the neck, in all probability this clay ‘‘funnel’’ was in fact a skirt (fused with a
by a plough blade. The body stood somewhat deeper, stool) of a sitting figurine, similar to the discovered
hence the difference in color: the head being pre- whole figurine. Thus, this find also serves as an ex-
served in drier conditions and therefore light brown ample of shifting usage within the same – ritual –
in color, while the body, located at a humus rich domain.
Lı̂ga 97

Fig. VI.5. Drawing of a ‘‘clay egg’’, part of the composite find


centred on the sitting figurine (height – 65.5 mm, Ø max. 44¿48
mm, weight – 90 g).

the Roman period, similar egg-shaped crucibles are


known from other parts of Europe, e.g., England,
where their use was made possible by the use of metal
tongs (Tylecote 1992, Fig. 13:g). Finally, the con-
firmed crucibles found at Lı̂ga are of a wholly differ-
ent open shape with flat bottoms (see below).
Therefore the allusion of an egg, held in the skirt
of a figurine seems more convincing. The coherence
of the items is strengthened by the fact, that all three
Fig. VI.4. Clay figurine, type known as ‘‘The sitting goddess’’, and have identical clay fabric (see below). Moreover, they
its accessories at the moment of discovery (height of the figurine – are related through the same variation of brown
18 cm).
colors. M. Gimbutas has noticed that many hollow
figurines of the Cucuteni period contained within
their hollow bellies one or two small clay ‘‘eggs’’, or
The ‘‘clay egg’’ turned to be a hollow container clay balls (Gimbutas 1986, 245, Fig. 9.40). The sym-
with slightly inverted rim and pointed bottom (Fig. bolism of an egg is rather straightforward, and most
VI.5). Such items are known from other contempor- likely universal. Furthermore, it corresponds with the
ary sites. The most numerous collection (at least 18) pregnant state of the woman in question.
is held by the Bagachina site at Montana (Bonev & The figurine, placed on the floor along with its ac-
Aleksandrov 1996, 49, Fig. 91, 92), where the ‘‘eggs’’ cessories, was surrounded by vessels beginning to ap-
are interpreted as crucibles. The authors mention that pear 0.36 m below the surface (Pl. 5). All were found
some of the items had vitrified surfaces, tentatively on a greenish clayey layer interpreted as a stamped
confirming their function (Bonev & Aleksandrov floor (the floor level being ca. 0.55 m below surface).
1996, 49). However, it remains puzzling, that items At the time of the conflagration, some vessels were
with pointed bottoms and relatively closed form were placed higher, perhaps on shelves installed at the east-
used for crucibles, since their handling would be com- ern wall, as their position implies. Ca. 2 m from the
plicated by instability. However, in later times, during northern edge of the trench, and 5 cm from the figur-
98 Acta Archaeologica

ine, all material remains were swept away by later corded in line with other items (information based on
trenching probably in connection with establishing of sketches by T. Krı̂steva).
a vineyard. Hence, the preserved information is A rather high number of figurine fragments dis-
limited to the NE corner of the house, which is suf- covered in the waste area along the northern and
ficient to state that the ritual and the profane were eastern wall of House 1 indicates that clay figurines
not formally segregated (see Chapter III). were in active use and that the domains of their use
House 1 contained a fragmented head (Pl. 18:2 may have been several. Ever since the classical work
(9427)) and a rolled clay lump furnished with anthro- of P. Ucko in 1968 on figurines (Ucko 1968), nearly
pomorphic features (Pl. 18:7 (9405)). The head is every scholar treating the issues of prehistory in
interpreted as deriving from a figurine of the ‘‘sitting Southern Europe has felt the urge to contribute to
goddess’’ type, very much alike the above mentioned the interpretation of figurative art. But as D. Bailey
one (cf. below). A find of a fragment with bent knees has rightly noticed, approaches were few and sup-
(Pl. 18:9 (4040)) outside the SW corner of House 5 ported mostly by personal convictions and ephem-
may support the assumption that sitting figurines eral assumptions of psychoanalysis (1994). M. Gim-
were a rather common attribute of any household in- butas’ work (1974; 1986; 1989) had the greatest im-
ventory, and that only due to difficulties in recogniz- pact on forming widely accepted interpretations of
ing them in a fragmented state, the false image of figurines as ‘‘sacred images of divine entities’’ (Gim-
their exclusiveness has been created (Todorova 1986, butas 1986, 226). Regardless this uniformal ap-
200). The same observation was made by V. Gergov proach, many observations put forward by Gimbut-
on materials from the neighboring Redutite site (Ger- as are still valid and evoking. She stressed the con-
gov 2000). ventionalism seen in the molding of figurines with
House 2 also contained two pieces of figurines. little attention given to details of the human body,
One of these – a clay rump discovered in the NW but with much effort devoted to ‘‘proper placement
corner – may also represent a sitting figurine but of of fortifying and appropriate symbols’’ (Gimbutas
different kind than the above mentioned (Pl. 1986, 226). Such symbolically charged conventional-
19:5043). First of all, the stool is not integrated with ism can also be recognized in the Lı̂ga material,
the body, and, secondly, it bears a rather naturalistic especially when compared with other finds of the
rendering of a human part which usually is not em- period. The most clear cut manifestation is the ‘‘sit-
phasized. Another fragment discovered in House 2, ting goddess’’ with repeated minimalistic rendering
the lower part of a flat standing figurine with collected of a bird-like face, slightly raised, emphasized hips,
legs and oversized hips (Fig. VI.2), indicates that and arms collected on the belly. To a modern ob-
figurines also had an imovable position within the server, the reclining obese females seated on a stool
house. This figurine of about 15 cm in height must with the face pleasantly directed towards the sky first
have been fastened to one of the timbers above the of all emanate a feeling of ‘‘good times’’, perhaps
oven (see Chapter III) through a hole of 1.0¿0.7 cm, the basic intention, like a happy Buddha. In this
shaped prior to firing and having traces of wear. The context, the observation that the Lı̂ga figurine is vis-
position of the fragment is in concordance with the ibly pregnant is important. At the same time, there
fall direction of the northern wall – from North to- are also certain signs of individuality, which ask for
wards South. The traces of breakage were fairly re- alternative explanations. In Lı̂ga, this is seen in
cent, but the upper part was not recovered. some crudely yet precisely captured details, like two
House 3, with the richest inventory of pottery, con- cases of rendering of a hucklebone and toes.
tained the poorest evidence regarding figurines. Just Ethnographic data provide a string of options (for
a single head was found in the southern part (Pl. 18:4 summaries, see Ucko 1968; Talalay 1993), but what
(10654)). In the same area was also a clay stool, which they fail to demonstrate is a multi-dimensional use of
could be intended for a sitting figurine. Unfortunately, figurines within the same society. Examples are also
this find was made after the Danish party has de- lacking on co-existence of figurines made of different
parted from the excavation site, thus, it was not re- materials, e.g, clay and wood. Despite these limi-
Lı̂ga 99

Fig. VI.6. Clay items produced by an nine year old girl from East Gonja District, Northern Region of Ghana. Courtesy J.A. Okoro. Note
traditional devices such as grinding stones and mortar with pestle along with modern ones: a mobile phone and a microphone.

tations, ethnographic records still remain a source of objects, but this does not imply that adult observers
inspiration. would get the same impression. A good example is
A valuable lesson can be gained from fieldwork in ‘‘cousin on a scooter’’, which looks like an asexual
Northern Region of Ghana carried out by J.A. Okoro figurine without legs and holding something in its
(pers.comm.) (1). Following the work routines of local hands resembling bucranion. A ritual performance?
pottery producers, all aged woman, he discovered No. In a young potters mind this ‘‘boy of 21 years’’
that their 8–10 year old granddaughters were using is holding the handles of a wheel, the legs of the
clay to produce toys, which occasionally could be sold ‘‘cousin’’ being placed on the riding platform – hence
to their playmates. Incidentally, the daughters of the they are not important, as they virtually disappear
potters were not attracted to the craft. The items that behind the scooter screen. Significantly, these items
girls were producing are: humans, furniture, grinding are true images of real objects, if read properly.
stones, microphones, mobile phones, burnished small Figurines produced by different children had sev-
vessels, ‘‘cousin driving a scooter’’ and so on – every- eral common features. Massive legs, for example,
thing that is surrounding the children in their daily were necessary to keep the humans upraised. In that
life (Fig. VI.6). At the same time, the girls tried to way, they appeared as ‘‘standardized’’. When asked
come as close as possible in their rendering of the about the lacking hair, girls stated that hair would
burn during the firing process. However, later on, one
1. The author is grateful to Dr. John Ako Okoro, University of
of the young potters reflected on this limitation and
Ghana, Legon (Accra) for allowing to use unpublished data from produced two figurines, a female with long hair was
his studies, ‘‘The Salaga Research Project’’. left unfired, while a male figurine was fired together
100 Acta Archaeologica

other fetishes of the village not taking human embodi-


ment. The members of a community could often de-
code the meaning of the figurines on the basis of just
one single appropriate element. Additional accessor-
ies or the position of a figurine could further
strengthen the meaning.
In Bénin, different extended families would also
have a special box where several anthropomorphic
wooden figurines were kept together. These represent
deceased relatives. Although lacking individual fea-
tures, only sexual ones, the figurines are coupled up
with the deceased through special ceremonies. Indi-
vidual ownership of figurines is often seen among the
children. As the cult of twins is very powerful,
children who lost their twin would be provided with
a figurine representing the deceased twin, fasten to
their waist to be used as lucky charm but also as a
doll and as an actual person, often being fed.
When discarded, or, nowadays, usually sold to
tourist-minded merchants, the figurines release their
Fig. VI.7. Wooden figurine representing the Yoruban deity Baba, powers or spirits in a ceremonial way, which com-
Bénin. monly involve cut marks on arms or legs – a ritual
destruction (though not affecting the value of the item
as a commodity).
with a bowl-like device which could be put on as its Without attempting any direct analogy, the points
hair. presented here serve to underline the amplitude of
During work in Bénin, West Africa, although un- levels on which figurines may circulate both mentally
connected with studies of figurines, there were several and contextually. First of all, the possibility of identify-
occasions to observe the function of figurines within ing children as producers inspired to look more thor-
different communities. Figurines protecting the vil- oughly at the way figurines were produced. Pro-
lages could be found at their limits, figurines could be cessing of the flint material from Lı̂ga has yielded
seen both inside and outside houses, and they could some evidence, that local brownish flint, found on the
have different levels of ownership. At the village of site, was used as a medium of training. No tools have
Gekoli to the East of Abomey (the area of Fon) the been made of this poor quality flint, but several
main fetish was installed in the corner of a kitchen at knapped cores indicate the practice.
the chief’s house. A wooden figurine of a male with All discovered clay figurines, except one, were
bent knees and emphasized phallos was said to repre- three-dimensional (Pl. 19). The one two-dimensional
sent Baba – a Yorouban deity protecting the whole figurine (7045) was discovered in House 2, where, as
village against illnesses (Fig. VI.7). It was dug into a already mentioned, it must have been attached to one
10 cm high platform and literally surrounded by kit- of the timbers above the oven. For manufacturing of
chen ware. Outside the house, right at its western wall figurines, two basic techniques were applied. At least
were two other figurines, a female and an apparently in five cases figurines were modeled from one and the
asexual being, confirmed to be a child – both said to same lump of clay (7045, 9405, 9024, 9086, 2001/
represent Yorouban Abikou, made for dead children 127). This is seemingly also the case of the only figur-
and connecting the world of the living with the world ine of the Lı̂ga 1 settlement (8099). Incidentally, three
of the spirits (Fig. VI.8). These figurines were also in of the one-lump-figurines were made of untempered
the ownership of the whole community, as well as clay (9405, 9086, 2001/127). Another technique in-
Lı̂ga 101

volved individual modeling of separate body parts


and then assembling. This was the prevailing tech-
nique at Lı̂ga 2. The more informative fragments in-
dicate that solid limbs and head were attached to a
hollow body. The body would be simply modeled
with fingers. Small protrusions were made to attach
the limbs. This can be seen from the majority of the
figurine legs, which were broken off at junctions. In
more demanding cases, a wooden stick of 4–5 mm in
diameter was used as a core, around which the figur-
ine would be assembled. Thus, holes after such sticks
can be seen in both heads (4446, 8000) and legs/feet
(9005). In two cases within this group the figurines
were manufactured of untempered clay (10226,
UN009/9B). Fig. VI.8. Wooden figurines outside Beninoise house, representing
Fragments of figurines made of untempered clay the Yoruban deity Abikou.
have attracted special attention, since they appear as
exceptions in the total body of pottery products.
Natural clay was readily available at the Lı̂ga site.
This availability could certainly inspire even unskilled interpreted by L. Talalay as a kind of contractual de-
members of the community to express their creativity. vices or identifying tokens enchaining distant contrac-
Natural clay would also be used for ad hoc tasks. Im- tors, presumably holding the other half of the same
portantly, the discovered fragments of five figurines figurine (Talalay 1993, 45–46, Plates 11 & 12).
made of untempered clay were fired, so these items The remaining three fragments, deriving from un-
were treated the same way as the others. Of course, tempered clay figurines might well have been pro-
the amount of unfired figurines will never be known. duced by inexpert makers. They include a rolled clay
All five pieces are somewhat special. One of them – lump with anthropomorphic features and shallow ob-
a head (2001/127, unknown provenience) made of a lique incisions on the back, found in House 1 (9405).
lump of clay – was carved in the manner of a wooden Another example is a rather crudely made leg, broken
object. The cut marks were slightly smoothened with off at the junction and found in the ‘‘street’’ area at
wet fingers. Carving of clay lumps can be seen as an the back of House 3 (10226). The third item is a leg
attempt to transfer manufacturing techniques applied of a short-legged figurine with oversized hucklebone
on wooden objects. At the same time, it signalizes a (UN009/9B, disturbed fill) – perhaps an attempt to
group of items which has disappeared, namely imitate the details seen on masterly produced figur-
wooden artifacts. Another fragment within this group ines (cf. 9005).
is the right half of the lower part of a standing female These suggestions do not exclude that other items
figurine. This figurine has also been produced of a made of tempered clay could have been produced
single lump of clay. The shape and incision of a pubic by children. Indeed, all fragments of figurines can
triangle are made with nearly mathematic precision. be divided into those made by skillful masters, ap-
This was not a product of a novice. The cut made in plying well balanced fabric and surface treatment
the middle of the figurine has apparently been con- techniques and those manufactured in more rudi-
trolled, leaving a very plain surface of longitudinal mentary fashion.
breakage. The item was found in the lower layers of Certain artistic signatures can be recognized when
waste accumulated along the eastern wall of House 1. viewing all the small finds together. It has been men-
Without going into further considerations it can be tioned that the sitting figurine found in House 4 to-
mentioned, that similar fragments of Middle Neolithic gether with its accessories was made of identical fab-
(5000–4500 BC) figurines at Franchthi, Greece were ric – clay abundantly tempered with sand (quartz par-
102 Acta Archaeologica

quire special skills to achieve the wanted results. The


‘‘sitting goddess’’ would still be perceived as ‘‘the sit-
ting goddess’’ no matter if one views the elaborate
examples found at Lı̂ga and Redutite (Gergov 2000)
or the unsophisticated creations from Zaminec (Niko-
lov 1975) and Okol Glava (Pernicheva 2002). Re-
liance on conventionalism probably explains why
some of the sitting figurines were not equipped with
sexual attributes (see Nikolov 1975) – perhaps the
general shape was allusive enough to decode the
meaning of such figurine. This could also be true
Fig. VI.9. Clay figurine representing pig.
about other types of figurines, like, e.g., the bell-
shaped figurine discovered in the lower layers of
waste East of House 1 (Pl. 18: 1). Produced of a single
ticles being 1–2 mm) and organic matter. The same lump of clay with perforated arm stumps stretched
fabric (with the same size and proportion of temper- out and seemingly raised and with a raised head, it is
ing components) was also identified in a skillfully being seen as asexual, although similar figurines from
made zoomorphic figurine rendering a pig (Fig. VI.9). Redutite were equipped with breasts (Grancharov
Apparently, this temper combination was considered 1999, Fig. 25). Nevertheless, avoiding premature con-
as minimum risk temper, ensuring that the work in- clusions, the mentioned bell-shaped figurine along
vested in production of these items would not be jeop- with a rolled lump figurine from House 1 are here
ardized during the firing process. Perhaps it can also considered ‘‘asexual’’.
be interpreted as an individual signature of a potter. Certain sexual determination within the Lı̂ga ma-
The lower part of the figurine discovered in House terial can be made in four cases, and in all, it is a
2 (Fig VI.2) could be linked with a tripod found in matter of females. The one and only Lı̂ga 1 figurine,
House 5 (Pl. 19:42026, Pl. 20:1) – both have received preserved only in half, had incised pubic triangle and
the same grooving of the surface and were made of a hip belt, an emphasized belly was most likely a ref-
the same fabric: abundant presence of organic matter erence to pregnancy. Also the back was covered with
and chamotte (0.5–3 mm) and moderate amount of incisions.
sand (up to 1 mm). Two massive legs (9014 & 9022) Turning to the Lı̂ga 2 material, the fully preserved
discovered in the waste area at House 1 were made sitting figurine has both breasts and incised pubic tri-
of the same fabric, had the same dark gray brown angle. Pubic triangle was also seen on a fragment of
color and both were burnished in the same fashion. a sitting figurine discovered in a ‘‘street’’ area (prob-
On their soles were impressions of grass leaves, point- ably re-deposited later, since it had traces of second-
ing to the fact that their production took place in a ary burning, contrary to the finds from the same
not formalized working environment and during area). Within the pubic triangle it was richly decor-
warmer part of the year. The legs could easily be ated with incisions forming a double spiral (¬) and
taken as belonging to the same standing figurine if dots. A ribbon of linear incisions was running across
only they were not left legs both of them. Incidentally, the thighs (Pl. 18:9). This band is perhaps replicating
a similar leg was discovered at Ezero-Kaleto, indi- clothing. A double spiral motif on pubic triangles is a
cating that this is a type of figurine having a wider frequently applied element of Copper Age figurines.
regional and temporal distribution. The proportion of In fact, this fragment was the only truly decorated
the legs suggests that such figurines would have been figurine fragment at Lı̂ga 2. The third Lı̂ga 2 case
around 30 cm in height. where a sexual distinction could be made is the lower
The conventionalism, which is seen in stressing cer- part of a figurine found at House 1. As already men-
tain elements in figurines, repetitiveness, and depend- tioned, its femininity is revealed through a sharply
ence on rules of assembling the figurines, did not re- incised pubic triangle (Pl. 18:11).
Lı̂ga 103

It should also be mentioned that one of the heads slip. Pattern decoration using incisions was observed
can perhaps be interpreted as male due to a promi- only in three cases (8099, 4040, 9405).
nent chin, alluding beard (Pl. 18:4). Two perforations Little can be said on organization of production of
on each side of the head mark the ears. Such perfor- the figurines. There is, however, some evidence that
ations were not reserved for female figurines only, at least part of the figurines was produced in the same
since there are several examples of male figurines with setting as pottery. The most skillfully made item
ear perforations (Nikolov 1970, 62; Fig. 11; Todorova among the discovered pieces of figurines is considered
1979, Fig. 1). While female figurines are usually to be a pair of legs/feet (9005) (Pl. 18:10). This not
equipped with three or more perforations, male only received the best surface treatment in form of
figurines tend to have only two. self-slip, but it also demonstrates an exceptional de-
Needless to repeat that no individual, naturalistic gree of artistic attention paid to such ‘‘small’’ details
facial features can be deduced from the preserved as toes and hucklebones. The fragment was tempered
heads. Protruding nose is usually considered sufficient with fine organic matter and chamotte; on the soles
in reproducing human images. Eyes may be rendered were many particles of sand, as in the case of vessel
as dots, perforations or protrusions. Mouth is repro- bottoms. So, a layer of sand was separating the feet
duced as a depression or a series of dots. Ears would from a flat surface, in order to avoid adhesion during
only be marked as perforations. Such artistic puritan- the modeling.
ism was arguably a conscious choice or restriction in Looking at the patterns of breakage, there are five
order to avoid blurring of the message. Accepting this fragments which can be linked to deliberate breaking.
view, more stress should be put on the decoration de- Naturally, this group might be bigger. The criterion
signs of the figurines, perceiving these as symbolic no- chosen to distinguish between deliberate breaking and
tations with specific meaning. ‘‘natural’’ relies on two observations. First of all, the
Attempts were made to reconstruct the scale of fragment should not be broken at its juncture point.
figurines. The smallest fully preserved one was the And, secondly, the breakage should reflect a con-
bell-shaped figurine of 4.8 cm (9024). The biggest are trolled action, like separating figurines into equal
represented by two massive legs (9014, 9022), one of halves or creating plain cuts (2). Following these
which is preserved in its full extent. Such figurine is guidelines of separation, the group of deliberately
estimated to be around 30 cm. The remaining would broken items includes the left buttock of the Lı̂ga 1
fall into groups: 7–12 and 14–20 cm, respectively. figurine (8099), the lower left part of a figurine (9086),
The fully preserved sitting figurine was 18 cm in a leg of a massive figurine (9014), and a pair of legs/
height. It can be noted that similar figurines at Redut- feet (9005) – all found in a waste area at House 1 –
ite range between 14 and 25 cm (Gergov 2000). plus a head discovered in House 3 (10654).
In terms of color, there are three basic color cate- The Lı̂ga material, although limited, also provides
gories. Those figurines, which were made of un- some clues on ownership of the figurines. The par-
tempered clay stand out by their light gray to gray ticular location of a sitting figurine on a house floor
brown color. In three cases the color is gray black at the rear end of the room and presumably close to
(legs 9014 & 9022, head 10654), which is unusual for the oven indicates that this was serving group de-
Lı̂ga 2 materials. The remaining pieces range be- mands. As evidence from Lı̂ga and Redutite sug-
tween light yellow brown to medium brown color (oc- gests, every house could have been equipped with
casionally, with reddish patches). Surface treatment is such a sitting figurine. This also narrows the owner-
usually limited to smoothing and evening. Some ship to a household level. The same can be said
items, like the fragment attributed to Lı̂ga 1 (8099) about the figurine of which the lower part was dis-
and legs from the waste area at House 1 (9014, 9022), covered in House 2 and which was hung above the
bear traces of burnishing. Regular burnishing is ob-
served on the surface of the head from House 3 2. The head of the complete sitting figurine, found in a higher
(10654). The surface of the skillfully made pair of layer, 1 m away from the body, also has an even cut, but this is
legs/feet (9005) was smoothed with the help of self- caused by recent ploughing.
104 Acta Archaeologica

Lastly, accepting the special role of the sitting


figurine, it should once again be stressed, that settle-
ment conflagration was not a planned act (cf. Stev-
anović 1997), but a nasty surprise, which forced the
inhabitants to leave even their idols behind. Such situ-
ation can perhaps be illuminated through comparison
with historical events. In 1892, in Ghana, the British,
under threat of canon fire, forced the whole com-
munity of Krobo Hills to flee and abandon their be-
longings. Thus, community idols can still be found
among the ruins, house walls and broken vessels of
this huge settlement (Fig. VI.10).

Fig. VI.10. Clay figurine discovered in ruin of a house at the an- ZOOMORPHIC FIGURINES
cient main settlement of the Krobos, Ghana.
Anthropomorphic and zoomorphic protomes have
been discussed in above sections related to the pot-
tery. Briefly it can be stated that only one anthropo-
oven (Fig. VI.2). Accepting that part of the figurines morphic protome and two zoomorphic ones (resem-
could have been toys produced by children, it is bling ox) were found, both attributed to the Lı̂ga 2
possible to state that some specimens were individu- settlement (Fig. V.16 & Pl. 17:2,3). One proper zo-
ally owned. Bone figurines, treated by P. Zidarov, omorphic figurine was discovered behind House 4, in
also provide important points (Chapter IX). As a the ‘‘street’’ area. It was made of a single clay lump,
rule, clay figurines were seemingly designed to serve tempered with fine organic matter and chamotte. The
group demands, while bone figurines belonged to length is 6.6 cm. Although fragmented (part of the
the more individualised sphere of use and owner- head and legs are missing), it holds several details of
ship. Bone figurines, which are easy to carry, for in- identification. A hump on the back is typical for oxen
stance in clothing, are thus not uncommon among (Pl. 17:7). A pair of nubs between the back legs may
grave gifts (see Chapter XI). Manufacturing of bone indicate that it was a bull.
figurines is also less straightforward and requires The second zoomorphic figurine can truly be con-
special skills compared with production of clay sidered an artwork, when compared with other figur-
figurines. This naturally sets some restrictions on the ines of the time. It is made in the best Gumelniţa
number of possible owners as well as putting such tradition, with naturalistic, elaborate details not leav-
items into a different category of value. ing space for speculations on what it was representing.
Bone figurines are also presenting evidence about Citing Gumelniţa is not accidental, for the closest par-
shifting ownership (see Chapter IX). The only anthro- allels are from the KGK VI area. The head of the
pomorphic figurine found at Lı̂ga (attributed to the figurine is missing as it was made using a less common
Lı̂ga 1 settlement) was decorated twice, maybe even ‘‘head-hole’’ insertion technique. The body – length
three times. The first time it received all the conven- 13.5 cm – bears characteristic features of a pig (Fig.
tional markings of the period, the next time a new VI.9 & Pl. 17:8). The clay used to manufacture this
owner made a more forthright marking of the pubic figurine contained organic matter and abundant
triangle – but at knee height – seemingly unsatisfied amounts of rather coarse sand, the same combination
with the allusiveness of the original markings (Pl. and proportion as in the case of the fully preserved
26:6). While the clay figurines seem to belong in the sitting human figurine. Hence, it is likely that the
female sphere of pottery production, it is not unlikely same person was responsible for the creation of both.
that the flat and portable bone specimens were male This animal figurine was found in a top layer South
products. of House 4, where the sitting figurine was discovered.
Lı̂ga 105

SMALL TABLES AND SIMILAR DEVICES


Among the rather peculiar finds at Lı̂ga are fragments
of small table-like devices, which usually are denomi-
nated as altarpieces, cult-tables, oil lamps and the like
(Bánffy 1997, 8–9; Elster 1986, 303). Such variety in
characterization may not only reflect personal convic-
tions of a describing observer, but also a functional
amplitude of such items. Moreover, other artefacts,
like small bowls or plates, may have overlapping use
functions. Use of the self-constructed term ‘‘table-
like’’ is an attempt to avoid straightforward interpre-
tations.
Eleven fragments of table-like devices have been
discovered at Lı̂ga (Pl. 19–21). One is derived from
Lı̂ga 1 materials, the remaining from Lı̂ga 2 data.
Among the fragments are four legs, two of which were
broken at or below their junction point, so strictly
speaking it cannot be determined what they have Fig. VI.11. Model of oven discovered among debris attributed to
been supporting. The material provides a very mixed the Lı̂ga 1 settlement. Photo: R. Kolev.
picture, all shapes and types being represented. There
are both tripods (4: 42026, 2000/15, 14000, 10659),
rectangular (3:2001/250, 9028, 4625), and hexagon Despite formal variation there are several com-
pieces (2:8001, 4646.4, 10659). Two speciemen may mon characteristics. Firstly, all but one specimen
be considered as nearly complete, since only their legs show manufacturing skills beyond the ordinary, both
are partly damaged (42026, 9028). in terms of surface treatment and decoration. Con-
A common feature for this group of items is an trary to the figurines, table-like devices were pro-
integration of a basin with legs supporting it. As the duced by skillful masters. Only one example, tem-
only exception, the one fragment attributed to the pered with organic matter, was made in a crude
Lı̂ga 1 settlement was not equipped with legs (2001/ manner with no attention given to the surface finish
250) (Pl. 20:3). This was rectangular in shape, while (9028). Secondly, the range of original colors is
the outline of a basin was rounded. The item well- limited to light brown and light reddish brown.
burnished and brown in color. One of the sides was Thirdly, all Lı̂ga fragments share a very significant
decorated with graphite decoration. The find spot feature, namely that one geometric form is incorpor-
was beneath the western wall of House 1, which was ated into another. The round basin is thus incorpor-
stabilized by debris from the Lı̂ga 1 settlement. ated into triangular, rectangular or hexagonal
Three of the fragments attributed to the Lı̂ga 2 shapes. Such formal antithesis had no doubt a sym-
settlement were found in uppermost layers, hence bolic meaning, thus elevating the table-like devices
their provenience is unclear (4625, 9000, 14000). above the profane. In this light, it becomes matters
Three fragments (8001, 9028, 9000) were found in of peripheral interest to determine whether the de-
layers of waste accumulated at the NE corner of vices were oil-lamps or, more abstractly, altarpieces.
House 1. Two fragments can be associated with Certainly, the issue will require more elaborate
House 2 (4646.4, 2000/15). One fragment was attri- studies than observations under microscope (cf.
buted to House 3 (10659), and one was found in the Banffy 1997; Schwarzberg 2003).
‘‘street’’ area at the SW corner of House 5 (4343). Rather more fully preserved fragments show that
The best preserved table-like item was found upside legs of the table-like devices experienced the most
down in House 5, at the southern wall (Pl. 20:1 stress. They bear traces of intense abrasions, caused
(42026)). by rough surfaces. Seemingly, the device continued to
106 Acta Archaeologica

items also have traces of secondary burning, but of


less regular nature (4625, 4343, 8001). Hence, ma-
nipulation of fire in relation with table-like devices
cannot be excluded. In terms of fabric, the clay is
abundantly tempered, the prevailing combination of
tempering materials being organic matter, well-sorted
sand and chamotte.
Although these considerations have not clarified
the function of the table-like devices, it has been dem-
onstrated that the production required experienced
potters, thus indicating that the context of their use
was more restricted than that of the figurines.

MODEL OF OVEN
Models of houses or ovens belong to a group of rar-
ities in Copper Age sites. Only one such item was
discovered at Lı̂ga. It is an oven model with arched
Fig. VI.12. Fragment of crucible (4¿4.3 cm). Photo: R. Kolev.
opening found beneath the SE part of House 1 of
the Lı̂ga 2 settlement (Fig. VI.11 & Pl. 17:9). As has
been mentioned before, this slope area was stabilised
be used after breaking of one or even two legs. This with debris deriving from the Lı̂ga 1 settlement,
indicates, that table-like devices had a long duration which thus was redistributed. The oven model was
of use. The smallest among the discovered pieces is an integrated part of a larger item. The most plaus-
the crude one (9028), its dimensions are only ible interpretation is that it was a part of a lid. It
6.5¿3.8¿3.8 cm, the diameter of the basin being 2 remains unclear, however, why a hole of ca. 1.5 cm
cm. Other pieces are twice as big, the length varying in diameter was made in the bottom wall of the
between 9–12 cm, while the diameter of the basin is dome (for pouring?). The hole was made after firing.
4 (10659), 5 (42026) and 6 (8001) cm, respectively. The ridge of the furnace was originally furnished
The greatest variation is seen in height, from 4.5 to with three protrusions, of which only two are intact.
10–12 cm. Based on such variety of shapes and sizes, The surface of the dome is covered with 10 longi-
when practically there are no pieces repeating each tudinal, parallel incisions.
other, it can be assumed that alter-like devices were
objects used in exchange. In this sense they can in-
deed be considered as social ceramics, and not only CRUCIBLES & METALLURGY
due to their non-utilitarian purpose, as pointed out The excavations at Lı̂ga have also provided evidence
by E. Elster (1986, 303). for metallurgy. It was attested in both Copper Age
The upper surface – the ‘‘visible’’ part – has re- settlements, as well as in Grave 1 (see Chapter XI).
ceived the most attention. Table-like devices can be Incidentally, all items related to metallurgy were
slipped and burnished (8001), burnished (10659), cov- found in the same excavated area, at the southern
ered with grooves (42026), incised in angular patterns slopes of the site.
(4343, 10659, 4625), or equipped with extra-modeled Two fragments of two crucibles were recovered be-
protrusions (14000, 2000/15). One of the pieces de- neath the SW part of House 1. They were in a dense
serves extra attention (10659). Its outer surface is light layer of shards and other finds from Lı̂ga 1, which
reddish brown, while the basin is gray black due to was created after leveling and stabilizing the slope
even distribution of sooth. Besides, the basin is in- area prior to construction of House 1 of the Lı̂ga 2
tensely burnished and virtually non-permeable. Other settlement. Both crucibles were rectangular in shape
Lı̂ga 107

with rounded basin and flat bottom. Both were made


of clay tempered with moderate amounts of well-sort-
ed sand and were affected by secondary burning, al-
though not vitrified.
The bigger one was better preserved, and more
crude than the smaller one (Fig. VI.12 & Pl. 17:10)
Its estimated length was 7 cm, the width 4 cm, the
total height 2.5 cm. One of the sides was equipped
with two holes placed on the same level at the middle
of the wall. The diameter of the holes is 0.5 cm. The
holes were presumably used to fix a handle, two
wooden sticks, for example. By using two sticks, a
steady grip would be provided and spoiling of melted
copper would be avoided. Copper deposit was dis-
covered attached to the bottom of the crucible.
The smaller crucible was more thoroughly manufac-
tured with a smooth surface of the internal basin. The
preserved fragment, a corner of the crucible, may only
allow rather coarse estimations of external dimensions,
which were not exceeding 4.5¿5 cm, the height 2.3 cm
(Pl. 17:11). As the previous item, it was also equipped
with two holes in the middle of the wall. But the holes
were only half as big, around 0.25 cm, the diameter
narrowing from outside towards the inside.
Actual copper items were found in later layers,
namely inside House 1 of the Lı̂ga 2 settlement. The
finds include one awl and two pins, lying encapsu-
lated in burned layers of daub at the floor level but
in different parts of the house.
The awl (8597) was 7.1 cm long and 0.9 cm wide
at its widest part. It was gradually narrowing towards
one end, which was slightly bent (Fig. VI.13). How-
ever, due to corrosion it could not be established with
certainty, which end was the working one. The awl
had a quadrangular cross-section along its whole
length and a pointed end. It was found just outside Fig. VI.13. Copper awl and pointed bone tools (length of the Cu
the dividing structure of House 1. awl – 7.1 cm). Photo: R. Kolev.
The longer pin (9425) measured 4.1 cm in length
and was 2.9 mm wide (Fig. VI.14). It had a quad-
rangular cross-section. Part of the surface was eroded House 1. This pin also had a quadrangular cross-sec-
away, but it could be deduced that the pin was taper- tion. It is very well preserved and therefore gave
ing to a point. The pin was found together with the grounds to think that it was made of bronze. The
head of a presumably sitting figurine (Pl. 18:2 (9425)) item was analyzed with X-ray flourescence by B.
in House 1. Gottlieb (3), National Museum of Denmark. It was
The shorter pin (9089), measuring just 2.4 cm in
length and 2.5 mm in width, was found near the 3. The author is grateful to Birthe Gottlieb, MA, for carrying out
major concentration of storage and other vessels of this analysis.
108 Acta Archaeologica

ing impressions of a presumably copper pin with


quadrangular cross-section (Fig. VI.15).
Metal could also be associated with the graves (see
Chapter XI). Several copper beads, both wide cylin-
Fig. VI.14. Copper pin (length – 4.1 cm). drical (ca. 1.5 cm in length) (Fig. VI.16) and narrow
cylindrical (0.2–0.3 cm in length) were found in
Grave 1, in the area of the breast of the body. Grave
1 was dug under the NW corner of House 1. The
remains of the skeleton together with adjoining soils
were moved to the Historical Museum of Pleven for
more controlled investigation. As a result, more cop-
per beads were discovered. The beads were made of
rolled copper sheet with overlapping edges. The roll-
ed cylinder was then cut into single pieces. The diam-
eter of the beads was around 0.5 cm.
The most exclusive item discovered at Lı̂ga is a
golden pendant (see Chapter XI) (Fig. VI.17). The
circumstances of its discovery are unclear, as it was
discovered in loose soil close to Grave 1. It was made
Fig. VI.15. Bone handle with impression presumably of copper pin of a narrow strip of golden sheet, 0.1 cm thick cut
of quadrangular cross-section (Ø – 1 cm). longitudinally until its approximate midpoint. The
terminals were then rolled in opposite directions into
spirals. The total length of the pendant is 4.3 cm. At
the other end, a hole for hanging was made by cold
hammering. The surplus/excessive metal was then re-
curved.
Regardless its uncertain provenience, the golden
pendant, likely a phallos (with testicles) can be attri-
buted to the Late Copper Age. The best parallel, also
in gold, is exhibited at the National Museum of Gree-
ce (Fig. VI.18). Although it is merely part of a bigger
confiscated hoard of 70 golden items, the association
with so-called ring-idols (Todorova, Vajsov 2001,
Pl.22) places it securely in the period around the end
of the fifth millennium BC.
Copper pins with double spiral head are relatively
common on Bulgarian Copper Age sites (Todorova &
Vajsov 2001, Pl. 9). Such a pin was also discovered at
Fig. VI.16. Cylindrical copper bead found in Grave 1 (length – 1.2 the neighboring Redutite site (Gergov 1987), indi-
cm). Photo: R. Kolev.
cating that gold pendants as tokens was not foreign
to the symbolic realm of the Copper Age at Telish.

demonstrated that the pin was made of copper deriv-


ing from two different sources, a result perhaps VARIOUS MINOR ITEMS
achieved through remelting of different copper items. SPINDLE WHORLS
It should be mentioned that at the western wall of The number of spindle whorls is limited to six com-
House 3 was found a bone socket (Pl. 27:6) still bear- plete and one unfinished specimens, all in clay and
Lı̂ga 109

all from uncertain contexts. However, due to their


general appearance and clay matrix they can be attri-
buted to the Lı̂ga 2 settlement, despite the fact that
shapes of spindle whorls show limited temporal sensi-
tivity. Four different shapes are represented in the
Lı̂ga material:
(a) Biconical; represented by two of the whorls. One
of these has truncated top and base (Pl. 17:12,13).
(b) Spherical; represented by one finished and one
unfinished whorl (Pl. 17:14).
(c) Flat; made of recycled pottery shards, which were
shaped into a rounded disc and pierced, repre-
sented by two items (Pl. 17:15).
(d) Conical; with a flat base, represented by one item
(Pl. 17:16).

The dimensions of the whorls are indicated in Fig.


VI.19. In terms of temper, there is an equal division
into two groups – those produced of natural clay and
those tempered with organic matter and coarse-grain-
ed sand.
One wheel-like object also deserves to be mention-
ed in this context (Fig. VI.20). It has the form of a
flat perforated rondel, but the hole is seemingly too
small for the rod of a whorl. The rondel itself is 5.3 Fig. VI.17. Golden pendant (‘‘phallos’’) (height – 4.3 cm). Photo:
cm in diameter, while the diameter of the perforation R. Kolev.
is just 3.5 mm. The edges are well smoothed, indi-
cating that these were in repeated contact. The func-
tion remains uncertain; perhaps it is a miniature
wheel due to the small hole.
Despite thorough investigations, traces of textiles
were only found in one case at Lı̂ga. An impression
of a Z-laid cord 0.77 cm thick was found below the
rim of the big pithos in House 3 (Fig. VI.21). Appar-
ently, the cord was used to withstand the pressure
during drying of this huge container. Fig. VI.18. Golden pendant (height ca. 6 cm), exhibited at the
National Museum of Greece. Unknown provenience.

LOOM WEIGHTS
Three loom weights were discovered at Lı̂ga, two ly-
ing together outside the northern wall of House 4,
close to the surface and hence with uncertain proveni-
ence. All weighs are conical in shape with rounded
base and horizontal perforation at the top (Fig.
VI.22). Their height varies between 9–10 cm, the di-
ameter of the base being 7–8 cm. Such weights are
interpreted as parts of warp-weighted looms. The Fig. VI.19. Table of spindle whorls.
110 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. VI.20. Perforated clay rondel.

Fig. VI.21. Shard of storage container with impression of cord.

weight of each item is around 0.5 kg, pointing to rela-


tively thick threads. cedures (see Chapter X). The total absence of fish
All loom weights were made of untempered clay remains at most Copper Age sites cannot be ex-
with single inclusions of larger sand grains (ca. 3 mm), plained merely by excavation procedures. Some
occasional small pebbles and ochre. In terms of fab- meticulously carried-out fieldwork, as recently at Kar-
ric, they do not differ from clay used for daubing the anovo or in the Drama valley, have not produced fish
upper layers of house walls. bone material at all (Bökönyi & Bartosiewicz 1997,
The strikingly small number of loom weights is 386). At Sadovec-Ezero, two fish vertebrae were
perhaps an indication that these artefacts were used found, both with secondary abrasions of the edges,
unfired and thus disintegrated if not exposed to fire which transforms the pieces into a category of tools/
during settlement conflagration. At the same time, worked bone, and certainly ruling out an assumption
the lack of such evidence within three rather well- of unfavourable conditions of preservation. On the
preserved houses opens up for two options: (a) that other hand, very few fish bones would survive passing
weaving was carried out outside the houses, ac- through dogs.
cepting that the conflagration took place during the To add to the confusion, both items discovered at
warm period of the year; (b) that weaving was not Lı̂ga are made of poorly baked clay, abundantly tem-
as common as generally assumed, and in fact nar- pered with organic matter and therefore seemingly
rowed to a limited number of specialists, unlike the unsuitable for lengthy periods in water.
pottery production.

BEADS
CYLINDRICAL WEIGHTS Three clay beads were discovered, all attributed to
Two cylindrical clay weights were recorded from dis- Lı̂ga 2 layers (Pl. 17:17–19). A common feature is that
turbed layers in the area of House 2 (Fig. VI.23). Tra- they are made of untempered clay. Two of the beads
ditionally, by analogy, such are associated with fishing are spherical (10 and 20 mm in diameter), one dis-
nets. Some Late Copper Age sites, for instance, Baga- coidal (21 mm in diameter). Traces of wear indicate
china have produced abundant numbers of weights that the latter was hung with the rounded side out,
(Bonev & Aleksandrov 1996). However, only two fish perhaps as a cloth weight. Two beads were found in
bones were collected from Lı̂ga, despite flotation pro- a ‘‘street’’ area, one in front of House 2.
Lı̂ga 111

Fig. VI.22. Clay loom weights (one square of the background plate
equals 1 cm).

MODIFIED VESSEL SHARDS


Recycling of pottery shards has been a wide-spread
practice at Lı̂ga. In most cases their secondary func-
tion could be deduced either through the shape (e.g.,
spindle whorls) or traces of wear (e.g., pottery bur-
nishers). But there is a group of modified shards,
which do not provide any explicit clues as to their
function. These are ceramic discs of nearly regular
circular shape, ca. 2 to 4 cm in diameter (Pl. 17: 20–
21). There are no explicit traces of wear. A handful
of such items were recorded in Lı̂ga 2 layers, those
with exact provenience came from areas outside the Fig. VI.23. Cylindrical clay weights (length of the item to the left –
houses. A suggestion is that they were gaming pieces. 7.4 cm). Photo: R. Kolev.
VII. FLINTS
by
Søren Albek et al.

THE INDUSTRY Cores and Fragments of Cores comprises exhausted


Smaller flint tools and debitage are often overlooked and non-exhausted cores, and fragments and flakes of
in common excavations. At Lı̂ga, after the short initial cores, the latter from making or rejuvenation of strik-
phase of the excavation, all flints, worked and un- ing platforms. Blades are oblong flakes – length more
worked, were collected, washed, recorded and than double the width – made in direct percussion
studied. Many pieces of very poor quality flint – technique. However, most tools were made in indirect
washed out and brittle – were found, the majority percussion techniques, since bulbs, ripples and even
unworked. Among the worked flints – almost all of scars are mising. The quality is generally high. Many
good quality material – the percentage of tools is un- speciments are broken.
usually high. The finds are of a blade industry, only The tools are classified according to functional
a very few tools are made from cores (or flakes). The characteristics: primarily, shape (morphology, includ-
measures below are of complete items. ing dressing and retouche), secondarily, work traces
Some Hammerstones at Lı̂ga are in flint (Pl. 24:1). (traces of hafting, macroscopic use-wear marks, gloss,
All are of fist size or a little smaller, with clear crush- crushing-marks). Accordingly, a number of macro-
ing marks. Apart from a single oval specimen, all are morphological types have been established (Fig.
spherical. Debitage makes up a very heterogeneous VII.1), although some items cannot be determined
group, with items ranging from 1–10 cm. Some items any closer than ‘‘Knife or Sickle-blade’’, or ‘‘Un-
are cores or spalls, others flakes large and small. No- known Tool’’, the former are often very small or frag-
tably, the debitage is only making up some 30% of mented specimens, difficult to determine due to
the worked flints items (Fig. VII.1). Artefact group limited size. The latter group comprises items made
from blades or blade-like flakes, which cannot be de-
termined, either because they are reworked or multi-
purpose in character. The cross-section is triangular
or trapezoid, the length 3.0–4.0 cm, the width 1.5–
3.0.
Items here classified as Scrapers are made from
thick flakes, drop-shaped in outline and with a steep
scraping edge (Fig. VII.2:1, Pl. 22:1,4). The length is
3.5–5.0 cm, the width 1.5–2.5.
End-scrapers make up a highly uniform group of
tools: all made on long and well-shaped blades or
flakes, typically 5.0–7.0 cm long, the width being 2.0–
2.5. Many have traces of hafting; the scraping edge is
less steep than at the above Scapers. Many specimens
are broken (Fig. VII.2:2–5, Pl. 22: 2–3,5–8).
Borers make up a heterogeneous group, all made
on massive blades, often triangular in cross-section;
the length is 3.0–6.0 cm, the width 1.5–3.0 (Pl. 23:6–
Fig. VII.1. Flints. Debitage, blades & tool types (numbers). 8).
Lı̂ga 113

Fig. VII.2. Some of the scrapers of Lı̂ga 2 settlement. Photo: R. Kolev.

Knives is a large group of retouched blades used piece of a handle. Many sickle-blades are broken,
for cutting. The variation in length is considerable, likely during use.
4.0–8.0 cm, the width 1.5–3.0 – no doubt a reflection Burins do not enter this assemblage; the above
of differential use (Pl. 22:9–12, Pl. 23:10–14). The End-scrapers, etc. were probably used for working in
cross-section is usually trapezoid, either equilateral or both wood, bone and antler.
oblique, the long side used for cutting. Many speci- Additional Tools comprises bifacial points (arrow
mens carry traces of hafting, which likely was longi- heads) (Pl. 23:16, 18), a fragment of a biface (likely a
tudinal. core axe), a biface knife with fine pressure flaking of
Sickle-blades are, like the above End-scrapers, a the surfaces (Pl. 23:17), and a heavy pointed oblong
very homogeneous group of tools made on medium- tool with secondary retouche on two sides (dagger
sized blades (Pl. 23:2–5). They all have gloss on the blade or large borer?) (Pl. 23:1). The fact that the
one edge, sometimes on both. Most of the sickle- points were seemingly made from cores (or flakes),
blades have smooth or only lightly retouched edges, not blades, is perhaps surprising, as is certainly their
only very rarely are these dented. The length is 4.0– small number. Other weapons than the above ones
5.0 cm, the width 2.0–2.5. The cross-section is usually in flint are unknown, except perhaps for some bone
oblique trapezoid with the steep short side used for points, which may have served as arrow heads (cf.
cutting. To judge from wear marks and gloss, there Chapter IX) and, of course, the stone axes, which also
were seemingly two types of sickle. The first type had were tools (cf. Chapter VIII).
one (or more) blades attached at the one end directly Finally, a few of the flints might be (Early) Bronze
to the shaft, the second type had blades inserted along Age in date, including one of the arrow heads (Pl.
the one side of a curved shaft or even into the middle 23:18).
114 Acta Archaeologica

Senon and Maastricht (Valev 1992) (Fig. VII.5). Pipra


is c 8 km to the south of Lı̂ga; Pipra flint is quite
sturdy. Much of the foreign flint – supposedly, mainly
from far away, often to the South of the Balkan
range – is of high quality.
From the table (Fig. VII.3), it transpires that half
the flint is local, one third is regional, and the rest
Fig. VII.3. Flint types, tools and debitage. Table of percentage of foreign. Interestingly, there is a high percentage of
flint items recovered at Lı̂ga according to flint sources. debitage only in local flint, suggesting that non-local
flint arrived mainly in finished or nearly finished
form. In House 3 at Lı̂ga is a group or hoard of 9
blades (only the proximal end is preserved of one
specimen) stemming from the same core (Fig. III.24,
Fig. VII.6, 7). Otherwise, flint is rare inside the struc-
tures, no doubt a reflection of floors being regularly
swept. It should be added that flint was commonly
found in spaces between structures, likely temporary
work-shops, while animal bones mainly came from
particular garbage areas.
Looking at the most common artefact types, two
Fig. VII.4. Flint types, chaı̂ne opératoire, and selected tools. Nu- thirds of the Sickle-blades, with a short life span, are
merical/percental distribution of worked flint according to flint made from local Sadovec flint, but only one third of
sources. the knives, of which even a fourth is of foreign flint
(Fig. VII.4). The End-scrapers are divided equally be-
tween local and regional flints, only a tenth being for-
RAW MATERIALS eign (Fig. VII.4). The foreign (and regional) flints –
The types of flint employed were mainly determined in particular the knives – probably reflect exchange
on the basis of known geological occurrences and only systems, perhaps articulated through sheep/goat
to a limited degree on data from other settlements. Foci transhumanence (cf. elsewhere in the publication, in-
of the determination are colours, inclusions (including cluding Chapter XII).
fossils), grain size, specific surface conditions (both cor-
tex and fractures). Local sources were isolated and
samples taken from two localities. Visiting Bulgarian CONCLUSIONS & COMPARISONS
geologists assisted in the work. Also an archaeologist, The following observations should be noted regarding
R. Zlateva-Uzunova, Sofia, highly knowledgeable on the flints of Lı̂ga (cf. Fig. VII.1). There are virtually
flint in Bulgaria, has provided valuable advice, includ- no weapons or hunting-related tools among the flints.
ing a detailed table of reference for stone and flints. A By contrast, the sample is dominated by scrapers,
general introduction to the problems is by C.I Nach- knives, borers and sickle-blades for crafts and agricul-
ev & I.K. Nachev (Nachev & Nachev 1986). tural work. Local flint is widely used and has deliver-
A division has been made between local, regional, ed the majority of cores, flakes and flakes. Artefacts
and foreign flint sources (Fig. VII.3). The identified with a short life span (sicles) are mainly of local flints.
sources used at Lı̂ga are the following: Local flints, Knives are often of foreign flints, suggesting an import
including Sadovec and Pipra (0–10 km – return the of fine blades. Numerically, a standard tool-kit seems
same day); regional flints (10–30 km – return the next to have consisted of an end-scraper, a knife, a sickle-
day); foreign flints (⬎30 km, often much more – re- blade plus one to two blades, or multiples thereof. To
turn after some days). Sadovec is c 9 km East of Lı̂ga, this comes some raw material.
the locality comprising two flint-bearing formations, Almost no parallel materials have so far been exca-
Lı̂ga 115

Fig. VII.5. Flint nodules at Sadovec. For scale: knife ca. 20 cm, left Fig. VII.6. Eight flint blades and part of a blade (proximal end)
part of the photo. found together at the oven in House 3.

vated and published in Bulgaria. However, what little


data there are, seem to confirm findings of Lı̂ga. From
Neolithic-Copper Age Karanovo, Southern Bulgaria
comes a rich sample of flints, but mainly from early
phases (Gatsov & Kurčatov 1997). Blades and blades
with various retouches dominate; some are sickles.
From beyond Bulgaria, a few parallel data-sets
have been published. With a few exceptions, no de-
cent typology or numerical tables have been pre-
sented, though. In Serbia, the Neolithic material from
Divostin (sixth millennium BC) has been studied by
somewhat other methods than at Lı̂ga (Tringham et
al. 1988). Nevertheless, a dominance of blades/knives
and end-scrapers is noted, while sickle-blades seem
relatively few (correct identification?), as are also
scrapers that are not end-scrapers; by contrast, borers
are quite plentiful.
From Neolitic Anza (late seventh-sixth millennium Fig. VII.7. Collectively found flint blades in House 3 refitted to-
BC), former Yugoslav Macedonia, comes a sample gether.
studied by yet other methods (Elster 1976). Borers are
rare, as are end-scrapers, while blades and knives are
common. Sickle-blades are only identified as a sub- heads (14) are relatively rare. In other words, the sug-
set of blades. A more recent study is on Neolithic gested ‘‘Lı̂ga’’ tool-kit is present in a version with a
Selevac (early fifth millennium BC) in Serbia (Voytek high number of blades. Microliths have not been
1990). Here end-scapers are very common, and identified at Lı̂ga.
knives (including denticulated specimens), borers, and From the settlement of Hotnitsa-Vodopada, North-
sickle-blades common. ern Bulgaria, dated to the so-called Transitional
A somewhat atypical sample, however Copper Age Period (to the Bronze Age, cf. elsewhere in this publi-
in date, and Bulgarian, comes from Durankulak cem- cation), comes a sample dominated by ‘‘flakes’’, per-
etery (Sirakov 2002). Here, according to N. Sirakov, haps, indeed, flakes (65) (Sirakov & Tsonev 1995).
is a clear dominance of blades (117), while knives (28), There are some blades (18), as well as blades with
end-scrapers (16), and microliths/transverse arrow- various retouches, etc. (including knives) (19), and
116 Acta Archaeologica

end-scrapers (15). There are also various tools with Gatsov, I. 1993. Neolithic Chipped Stone Industries in Western
gloss – including ‘‘truncations’’ – no doubt sickle- Bulgaria. Varia CCCXIII. Kraków (Jagellonian University
Publications).
blades (14), arrow heads (7), borers (4), plus other – 1998. Technical and Typological Analysis of the Chipped Stone
tools and demi-tools. It should be noted that also this Assemblages from Troia. Studia Troica 8. 115ff.
classification is differing from the present one con- Gatsov, I. & V. Kurčatov. 1997. Neolitische Feuersteinartefakte.
cerning Lı̂ga. Nevertheless, some resemblance with Mineralogische Untersuchung und technisch-typologische
Lı̂ga is noted. Charakteristik. Hiller & Nikolov 1997. 213ff.
Gergov, V., I. Gatsov & S. Sirakova. 1985. Kremachni orudija ot
The material from Sitagroi, northern Greece praistoricheskoto selishte v m. Redutite pri s. Telish, Plevenski
(sixth-third millennium BC) is of several different okrag. Izvestija na muzeite v Severozapadna Balgarija 10. 11ff.
types of raw-material, even a very little obsidian Gimbutas, M. (ed.). 1976. Neolithic Macedonia. As reflected by
(Tringham 2003). Also so-called honey-flint, which Excavation at Anza, Southeast Yugoslavia. Monumenta Ar-
makes up a little more than half the material, was chaeologica 1. Los Angeles (Institute of Archaeology, University
of California).
brought to the site seemingly from far way, possibly Hiller, S. & V. Nikolov. 1997. Karanovo. Die Ausgrabungen im
even northeastern Bulgaria (although other sources Südsektor 1984–1992. Österreichischbulgarische Ausgrabung-
have also been suggested). Blade-tools dominate the en und Forschungen in Karanovo Vol. 1;1–2 (Text & Tafel).
sample, including 192 sickle-blades, 169 end-scrapers Salzburg (Archäologisches Institut, Universität Salzburg)/
and 114 so-called truncated blades (knives). There are Horn, Wien (Ferdinand Berger) & Sofia (Archäologisches Insti-
tut, Bulgarische Akademie der Wissenschaften).
47 so-called retouched blades (also knives), 17 small McParron, A. & D. Srejović (eds.). 1988. Divostin. And the Neo-
points (likely drills), 16 borers, 13 so-called denticu- lithic of Central Serbia. Ethnology Monographs 10. Pittsburgh
lates (saw-blades), and a few other artefacts. Notably, (Department of Anthropology, University of Pittsburgh).
only three arrowheads were found at Sitagroi. A cer- Nachev, C.I. & I.K. Nachev. 1986. Distribution and Evolution of
tain resemblance to Lı̂ga is noted. the Siliceous Rocks in Bulgaria. Comptes rendus de l’Académie
bulgare des Sciences. 39;8. 81ff.
Incidentally, at (Early) Bronze Age Troy, with in- Sirakov, N. 2002. Flint artifacts in prehistoric grave-good assem-
dustries dominated by ‘‘flakes’’, there is a high num- blages from the Durankulak necropolis. Todorova 2002/1.
ber of ‘‘notched tools’’ (supposedly for smoothing 213ff.
rounded objects like arrows) (366), end-scapers (224), Sirakov, N. & T. Tsonev. 1995. Chipped-Stone Assemblage of Hot-
‘‘truncations’’ (possibly sickle-blades) (195), and ar- nitsa-Vodopada (Eneolithic/Early Bronze Age Transition in
Northern Bulgaria) and the Problem of the Earliest ‘‘Steppe
row-heads (170), while ‘‘retouched blades’’ (likely Invasion’’ in Balkans. Préhistoire Européenne 7. 241ff.
knives) are relatively rare (40) (Gatsov 1998). Also this Todorova, H. (ed.). 2002. Durankulak II. Die prähistorischen
study is following classifications of its own. Gräberfelder 1–2. Berlin (Deutsches archäologisches Institut).
Indeed, both the relatively high number of items Tringham, R. 2003. Flaked Stone. Elster & Renfrew 2003. 81ff.
found (652) and their detailed treatment and study Tringham, R. & D. Krstić (eds.). 1990. Selevac. A Neolithic Village
in Yugoslavia. Monumenta Archaeologica 15. Los Angeles (In-
makes the Lı̂ga sample quite unique and a highly stitute of Archaeology, University of California).
valuable reference base for the future. Tringham, R.E., A. McParron, J. Gunn & G. Odell. 1988. The
Flaked Stone Industry from Divostin and Banja. McPharron &
Srejović 1988. 203ff.
Uenze, S. (ed.). 1992. Die spätantiken Befestigungen von Sadovec
BIBLIOGRAPHY (Bulgarien). Ergebnisse der Deutsch-Bulgarischen-Österreich-
Elster, E.S. 1976. The Chipped Stone Industry. Gimbutas 1976. ischen Ausgrabungen 1934–1937. Münchner Beiträge zur Vor-
257ff. und Frühgeschichte 43. Text.
Elster, E. & C. Renfrew. 2003. Prehistoric Sitagroi. Excavations in Valev, P. 1992. Geologische und geographische Einführung. Uenze
Northeast Greece, 1968–1970 Vol. 2. The Final Report. Monu- 1992. 23ff.
menta Archaeologica 20. Los Angeles (Cotsen Institute of Ar- Voytek, B. 1990. The Use of Stone Resources. Tringham & Krstić
chaeology, UCLA). 1990. 437ff.
VIII. STONE TOOLS
(including contribution by Søren Albek)

INTRODUCTION side. All except one of the crushing stones were found
Ground stone tools, despite their abundance on outside the houses.
many prehistoric sites, are usually only listed by Pounders and hammers, on the other hand, were
naming their assumed functional properties. There found in the houses. Some of these, lying close to
are few attempts to treat ground stone industries the ovens, may be connected with food processing
with methodological consistency (Kanchev 1970; activities, while others, found on the floors, had likely
Kanchev & Nikolov 1983). Therefore, besides gen- fallen down from their storage places (as the hammers
eral statements, as with the flints (Chapter VII), de- in the middle of House 2). Stone hammers are mass-
tailed comparisons are not possible. However, the ive, frequently flat stones with an almost rectangular
present study is inspired by the methodology applied shape, and are often heavily flaked with stepped scars
at the Neolithic site of Divostin in Serbia (Prinz indicating striking blows on solid surfaces (Pl. 24:2–
1988; Galdikas 1988). 4). The majority was produced of very hard, dense
The excavations at Lı̂ga have produced a consider- and smooth stone (like diabase and diorite porphyry,
able amount of stone tools, indeed nearly 400 in all, or other igneous rocks, but sandstones are not un-
reflecting the diversity of daily activities in the Copper usual either) and they are generally ground over the
Age. Every rock discovered was treated as a potential entire surface. In several cases both ends were used.
implement, since the geological environment of Lı̂ga Some hammers were reused broken large stone axes.
holds pebbles and small cobbles only (rarely reaching The length varies between 8.5 and 10.0 cm.
8–9 cm). Thus, raw-materials for the larger stone im- Pounders were also made of hard smooth stone
plements, if not the tools themselves, must have been bearing less heavy traces of macro-wear, such as chip-
carried to the site from a distance. Micro-wear analy- ping scars or flaking. The ends usually have a uni-
sis has not been possible, so the present classification formly abraded or roughened surface. Pounders are
is based on morphology combined with functional as- elongated in shape, often cylindrical; the cross-section
sumptions, as reflected by macro-wear traces. is rounded (Pl. 24:5,6).
The first and main set of definitions, mainly by I. A few tools held multiple functions. A combination
Merkyte, is analytical and primarily broadly func- tool (16.6 cm long, 5.8 cm maximum width) made of
tional. The second set of definitions, by S. Albek, is diorite porphyry was used as a pestle (the circular flat
primarily typological and relates to the numerical end has grinding traces at the edges and roughened
specifications of a table (Fig. VIII.6) (cf. below). surface), as a hammer (the opposite bevel end witness-
ed heavy flaking), and, possibly, as a hand stone (the
rounded sides reflecting mis-colouring) (Pl. 25:1).
HAMMERSTONES, HAMMERS, POUNDERS, It should be mentioned that practically every stone
AND PESTLES found had some traces of use, often due to short
Stone tools used for crushing and pounding/ham- periods of ad hoc working – like pecking and crush-
mering make up the most numerous group. Although ing – which leave traces which are not unambiguous
similar in function, the specimens reflect different ap- macroscopically.
plications. Hammerstones are regular, water rolled
flint/chert rocks or, occasionally, sandstone balls with
a diameter reaching 9–9.5 cm (Pl. 24:1). There are MILLING STONES (QUERNS)
usually no preferences as to the surface used, since the A dozen milling stones (querns), usually complete,
hammerstone is rotated around its own axis. Some were discovered at Lı̂ga. The majority was found out-
hammerstones are slightly flattened on the ventral side the houses or in uncertain contexts. However, a
118 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. VIII.1. Stone adze discovered outside northern wall of Fig. VIII.2. Stone adze (serpentine).
House 3.

walled grinding platform with a massive permanently Milling stones dominate over hand stones (includ-
installed milling stone (45¿40¿18 cm) was discover- ing mortars), which are smaller, not exceeding 20 cm.
ed in House 3, at the oven (Fig. III.12). In the vicinity Remarkably, all four hand stones were found within
was found a smaller milling stone with a flat surface, houses. Apart from the one mentioned as coming
which most likely was used as a hand stone together from House 3, three specimens were found at big
with the stationary milling stone. A third milling stone storage containers in, respectively, House no. 1 (two
also comes from this area, but the original context is specimens) and 2 (one). Two types can be dis-
uncertain (found outside the house next to the wall) tinguished: big flattened specimens with rounded
(Fig. III.11). Only the stationary milling stone had sides to work with both hands in a back-and-forth
traces of intensive use, which resulted in deep troughs motion, and smaller round ones (not exceeding 11 cm
on the grinding surface. in diameter, only one found) to work in rotary mo-
A number of both intact and fragmented milling tion. Both types were found in House 1.
stones were discovered in ‘‘street areas’’ and at House Excavations at Sadovec-Kaleto have demonstrated
1. One big square milling stone (39¿16¿14 cm) that utilization of milling stones was not limited to
made of fine-grained sandstone was found along with cereal processing. Colour pigments, such as ochra,
limestone rocks in the wall basis of House 4 (i.e., re- could also be ground on such stones. Some worn-out
used as a foundation stone). Some specimens, espe- milling stones or querns with time became mortars
cially those fashioned of sandstone, were fire-crazed. with different ranges of application. Ethnoarchaeol-
All the discovered milling stones were flattened on ogical analogies suggest that even soft foods could be
one side and had a plano-convex cross-section, indi- processed on milling stones.
cating their unifacial utilization, a fact supported by
macro-wear analyses. The length varies between 27
and 37 cm with a maximum width of 20–25 cm, the AXES, ADZES, AND CHISELS
thickness between 11 and 13 cm. The weight of the in- In separating these three categories of implements,
tact portable speciments is between 5.0 and 7.5 kg. The attention was paid to their shape, especially the cross-
usual shape is oval, only one specimen is rectangular. section of the cutting edge, where axes have a sym-
The grinding surfaces are smooth and slightly concave, metrical cross-section with the working edge located
reaching a depth of 5–11 mm measured from sur- in the middle, while the working edge of adzes is
rounding edges. Some milling stones showed traces of skewed. Attention was also paid to use-wear striations
deliberate pecking to roughen the grinding face. All seen on the cutting edges. Micro striations perpen-
were fashioned from medium-grained (in one case, dicular to the cutting edge indicate the utilization as
coarse-grained) rocks, often sandstones but also other an adze (i.e., chipping), while utilization as an axe
types, like granite, which has quartz components and a (i.e., chopping) is leaving striations diagonal to the
grainy structure, were appreciated. cutting edge (Semenov 1964; Prinz 1988).
Lı̂ga 119

The majority of adzes have a regular trapezoidal


shape with the sides tapering towards the butt end
(Fig. VIII.1, Pl. 25:2). The working edge is convex
(only in some cases straight and oblique) with a
characteristic adze asymmetry. The cross-section is
usually rectangular, but sometimes ellipsoidal. The
butt end is rounded or straight. The length varies be-
tween 5.0 and 6.5 cm, the maximum width being
about 4.0–4.3 cm. One of the discovered adzes was
almost triangular in shape, reaching 7.8 cm; it had a
flat base and a straight cutting-edge. Such implements
were used to work on or to create rounded surfaces
(Prinz 1988). Several implements had traces of hafting
noted by opposite/diametrical depressions, ca. 1/3
from the butt end. Such traces indicate that adzes
were hafted perpendicularly to the shaft.
Another adze type has similarities with the chisels, Fig. VIII.3. Stone axe discovered in House 1 (length – 10.8 cm).
being narrower than the first type, width ca. 2.5 cm. Photo: R. Kolev.
It is rectangular and symmetrical in shape while the
convex working edge with perpendicular striations re-
flects utilization as an adze. Fine-grained igneous
rocks, like basalt, were preferred but softer rocks, like
serpentine, were also used (Fig. VIII.2). Macroscopic
flaking is often seen on the cutting edge, especially on
the lower face; butt ends are usually intact.
Axes appear in a variety of sizes and shapes. The
common feature for them all is heavy use-wear traces.
Often axes are broken, despite the use of hard types
of rock. The prevailing rock type among the large
axes is diorite porphyry, while it is basalt among the
smaller types. The smaller axes (up to 9.0¿4.5 cm)
are almost rectangular with slightly tapering sides to-
Fig. VIII.4. Two chisels (1, 2) and axe (3) made of soft white stone.
wards the rounded butt end (Pl. 25:3, 4). The cross-
section is rectangular and the working edge straight
and symmetrical. Another type (10.8¿4.5 cm) is the
highly ground axe, also rectangular in cross-section macroscopic chipping may be found on the edge, and
and with straight cutting edge, but with a more elab- rounded flake removals on the butt end. The function
orate side curvature, being twice as thick as the above of this implement type is not certain. The lack of
described types (Fig. VIII.3, Pl. 25:5). flakes on the cutting edge indicates a rather short use-
The third type is not known as a whole piece; the life while the narrowing towards the edge suggests
discovered fragments indicate that it was rather long, that such tools might have been used as chisels for
reaching perhaps 15 cm with a maximum width not working with hard materials.
extending beyond 5 cm. It was rectangular with a Among the axes there is also a conspicuous speci-
convex edge and flattened butt end, the sides tapering men made of soft white stone (Fig. VIII.4:3, Pl. 25:8).
towards the cutting edge, which is the narrow part of Precise identification of the rock type is not possible
the implement. The edge is symmetrical, bevelled, the without specialist studies, since a variety of rocks re-
angle from the side being 40 æ (Pl. 25:6, 7). Some semble white compact chalk (Antonović 1997). The
120 Acta Archaeologica

implement of 8.6¿3.3 (maximum) cm, made of fine-


grained soft and porous sandstone, with a bevelled
asymmetrically rounded edge and flattened butt end.
It has ellipsoidal cross-section and a rough surface.
The cross-section of the edge indicates that it might
have been used as a digging implement (Pl. 23:19).

SHAFT-HOLE AXES: CORES


Although no shaft-hole axes was found, the discovery
of two cylindrical cores from axe-hole drills indicates
that this type of axes was also known and produced
on the site. One core was complete, 3.2 cm long with
end-diametres of 1.00 and 0.75 cm. It was made of
Fig. VIII.5. Stone chisel (basalt).
schist with clear groves reflecting the rotating move-
ment of the drilling tool. The other specimen was
made of serpentinite with an overall diameter of 1.35
butt end of this axe has been broken in prehistory, cm; this was broken, the maximum preserved length
but the axe was used after that. The convex sym- being 2.7 cm. The two cores show that two different
metrical edge was damaged during the excavation. perforation techniques were known.
The present dimensions are 4.8¿3.8¿1.6 cm. Flake
removals over the surfaces and the direction of the
flaking indicate that the flattened butt end had been SLING-STONES
exposed to blows. The cross-section is ellipsoidal. Al- A number of sling-stones was discovered, mainly in
though macro-wear traces reveal that this soft axe was the area of Sector 1/House 1. These are 3.5–4.0 cm
in active use, its utilization remains unclear. long double-conical pebbles with a round cross-sec-
Two types of chisels have been identified. The tion (Pl. 24:7). It should also be mentioned that
first type is a rather massive implement up to 6.0 some sling-stones were in clay (Pl. 24:8). Presence of
cm in length and 2.5 cm in width, with a heavily sling-stones supports the zoological analysis (Chapter
battered butt end (Fig. VIII.5). The chisels are al- X), demonstrating hunting of small animals, in par-
most rectangular and symmetrical, with bevelled ticular.
curved edges and a triangular or rectangular cross-
section. Basalt is the preferred type of rock for these
heavy duty chisels. The cutting edge often has traces RUBBING STONES AND POLISHERS
of bilateral macroscopic flaking. The second type of Several items, different in form, can be attributed to
chisel is a relatively long and narrow one, reaching this group. Flattened shiny surfaces indicate that the
4.2 cm in length with the width varying between 1.2 tools were applied on organic materials like leather or
and 1.6 cm (Fig. VIII.4:1, 2, Pl. 25:9). The cross wool. Two schist pebbles had a natural bowl form
section is rectangular (angular or rounded). Despite (4.0¿3.7 and 5.9¿3.0 cm), one piece was used on
the small size and the assumption that soft woods the rounded ‘‘bottom’’ side, while the other had wear
were worked with such chisels, damage can be seen traces on the ‘‘edges’’. Other finds include a rounded
on both the cutting edge and the butt end. The cut- quartzite pebble (5.4¿3.6¿3.3 cm) (Pl. 23:20).
ting edge of both chisel-types is located in the Within House 1, a fine-grained reddish flat sandstone
middle. was discovered, rectangular in shape (10¿12 cm),
Careful and fine grinding is noted on all the men- which could be identified as polisher, used both for
tioned implements within this group of tools. To the stone and bone tools: firm conclusions not possible
group should also be attributed a unique adze-like without micro-wear analysis.
Lı̂ga 121

STONES CONNECTED WITH POTTERY PRODUCTION plication of stone implements in food processing nu-
An interesting find was made in House 2. One me- merically far outweighs their use in wood-working.
dium size vessel contained a small biconical vessel and Besides milling, stone tools were used for crushing,
14 water-rolled pebbles (Fig. V.3). These can be pounding, smashing, and so on.
grouped according to their size, shape and stone type. Stone tools were also very important in pottery
The main part is quartzite with whitish or reddish production. Some stones were used for their natural
tinge while three pieces (fragmented) are of brown appearance, hence, a cone of locally found flint/chert
black siltstone. As to shape and size, there are five was recorded from Lı̂ga. This had a round cross-sec-
oval and one flat quartzite stone (2.7–3.1 cm long), tion; a natural hole through the middle of the stone
four big quartzite balls (3.0–4.8 cm long), three ob- made a use likely as loom-weight possible without
long pointed siltstones (3.8–4.5 cm long), and two tri- further modifications.
angular quartzite pieces (4.6 cm long). In spite of the Prehistoric carpentry is a relatively unknown field,
remarkable numeric order of the stones, these are since little evidence on the final products has survived.
most likely tools connected with production and sur- Often, suggestions can only be made on the basis of the
face treatment (smoothing and burnishing) of tiny bi- tools identified as relating to wood-working. Wooden
conical cups. Analyses of burnished pottery have led supports and split-logs used for construction of houses
to the identification of a tool with a pointed edge, 2– evidently demanded massive axes and chisels, and ad-
3 mm broad. Among the discovered implements such zes or flint scrapers for debarking. The presence of
a tool seems to be lacking, the siltstones being the finer tools, especially those made of bones, suggests
only pointed ones. broader demands and skills for more sophisticated
Another group of implements connected with pot- tasks than construction. Stone tools were no doubt also
tery production is also found in structures (House 1 used in other, as yet not fully acknowledged areas such
and 2). It is a matter of rounded or oval stone discs, as masonry, including extraction and fashioning of the
4.5–5.0¿3.1–4.6 cm, and 0.8–1.0 cm thick, thinning lime slabs found at Lı̂ga.
out towards the edges, used in smoothing, for evening A separate issue is identification of the sources of
of surfaces, and for scraping surplus clay away (Fig. the raw-materials used, including both geological and
V.5). The shape was more significant than the rock thorough comparative studies; such have not been
type and hence tools of both sedimentary and meta- possible in the present case.
morphic rocks were found. Pottery surfaces could also
be smoothed with rather more massive stone im-
plements, flat in cross-section, with a flat dorsal edge, ARCHAEOLOGICAL TYPES
and a ground surface on both sides of the edge. The The table Fig. VIII.6 refers to the following typology
shape of such tools resembles pottery shards, which of stone artefacts developed by S. Albek, which devi-
are also used for pottery smoothing (Fig. V.4). Two ates some from the above classification:
finds of heavily burned fragile coarse-grained sand- Stones with facets are of fist size and with one or more
stones should also be mentioned, perhaps prepared facets. Rock types are quartzite and finely grained
for crushing and use as pottery tempering material. granite. The type is very common and no doubt had
several functions.
Ball-shaped stones are small smooth quartz-stones, 1–
SUMMARY 2 cm in diameter, often found several together. These
Ground stone implements are a varied and important are quite common, perhaps used in production of col-
class of artefacts, finding application in all spheres of ours and medicines.
daily life. The identification of their utilization is often Quern-stones are of two parts: a sleeper and a runner.
problematic, probably explaining why these tools – The oval sleeper is 35–50 cm in length. It is usually
perhaps apart from the wood-working ones – only made of reddish and greyish granite or sandstone.
have received limited attention in scientific publi- The runner can be rectangular, circular or oval, vary-
cations. At any rate, during the Copper Age, the ap- ing in size from 35 to less than 12 cm, it is often in
122 Acta Archaeologica

ments, the original size being 5–15 cm. The real


number is higher, since some specimens not identified
during excavation.
Stone hammers and pounders are finely worked tools of
very hard finely grained rock or diabase, often with
sharpened or finely polished areas. Some are re-used
axes (without edge), others made for hammers; cross-
sections are rectangular or square.
Stone chisels are finely made in diabase or basalt, the
edges fine and sharp; the length is about 5 cm, the
width 1–2 cm.
Stone axes & adzes are, like hammers and chisels,
finely made, often polished to the like of metal. Two
drilling cores were found but no shaft-hole axes (see
Other).
Fig. VIII.6. Table of stone artefacts. Other comprises a fragment of a mould for a likely
copper axe with slightly protruding edges, a fragment
of a possible mould for metal plate (both sandstone),
hard fine-grained stone. These are quite common, a drop-shaped flat limestone with very smooth sur-
and several were found in situ. face, and two cylindrical cores from shaft-hole axes
Mortars are oblong, slender stones with percussions (cf. above).
at one or both hemispherical ends, diameter about 5 Tempering. Many stones found had the surfaced sys-
cm; hard rocks were used, mostly granite, length 10– tematically hammered away, likely to produce temper
15 cm. for ceramics. The material is coarse sandstone, red
Polishing stones are smaller stones, less than 6–8 cm, with coarse grains, or yellow-green with fine grains,
the whole surface of which is usually finely polished and with mica.
and shiny, probably used in ceramic or textile produc-
tion. Quartzite is used or other very hard finely grain-
ed rocks. The shape varies from egg, flatly oval to COMPARISONS
ball-shaped or other. A few may well be sling-stones. The best parallel to Lı̂ga in terms of stone tools is the
Hammerstones are up to fist size and used for ham- settlement of Sitagroi, Northern Greece (sixth to third
mering or crushing; there is much variation and both millennium BC), one of the very few localities in the
single and multiple hammering/crushing areas: no Balkans with published stone material from the Neo-
doubt both an ad-hoc and a specialized tool, the latter lithic-Copper Age (Elster 2003). The determined raw
probably specimens in near perfect ball shape. Hard materials used at Sitagroi are local (46 cases), non-
materials were selected; some specimens are just a local (67), and unknown (58), respectively. The high
coarse piece of unworked rock, of which one or two number of non-local rock likely reflects high mobility.
areas were used. Sitagroi also used much foreign flint (Chapter VII).
Whetstones come in two types: finely grained sand The artefacts from Sitagroi were divided into Pri-
stone and very hard amorphous rock. The specimens mary Tools (axes, etc.), Processors (stationary and
are flat, one or both sides with traces of sharpening, movable grinding stones etc.), and Presenters (sym-
about 8 cm in length. bols, including mace heads), 505 specimens in all.
Stones with smooth areas do not form a type of tool per The primary tools comprise 171 specimens (or 34%).
se. Nevertheless, they have been used by man, and The pertaining artefact types are: axe blades, 143
smaller or larger areas were being polished. Some or specimens, shaft-hole axes, 13, adze blades, 7, and,
all may originally be cobbles. Hard granite but also other, 8. The processors make up 307 specimens
some quartz and basalt were used. Most are frag- (61%). The pertaining types comprise: oval grinders/
Lı̂ga 123

rubbers (106), flat querns (61), saddle querns (39), BIBLIOGRAPHY


balls/pounders (37), hammer stones (29), and, other Antonović, D. 1997. Use of Light White Stone in the Central Balk-
(37). The presenters make up 27 specimens (5%). ans Neolithic. Rsaqinaq XLVIII, Belgrade. 33ff.
Elster, E. 2003. Grindstones, Polished Edge-Tools, and Other
The most marked difference to Lı̂ga is the high Stone Artifacts. Elster & Renfrew 2003. 175ff.
number of primary tools, mainly axes, at Sitagroi in Elster, E. & C. Renfrew. 2003. Prehistoric Sitagroi. Excavations in
relation to other worked stone. The reason for this is Northeast Greece, 1968–1970 Vol. 2. The Final Report. Monu-
probably that all stones were collected and studied at menta Archaeologica 20. Los Angeles (Cotsen Institute of Ar-
Lı̂ga, since they evidently had come from some place chaeology, UCLA).
Galdikas, B. 1988. Milling Stones. McPherron & Srejović 1988.
else. This raises the number of ‘‘non-axe tools’’ at the 338ff.
Bulgarian site. By contrast, at Sitagroi, ‘‘common’’ Hiller, S. & V. Nikolov. 1997. Karanovo. Die Ausgrabungen im
stones have only been collected (and recorded) in the Südsektor 1984–1992. Österreichischbulgarische Ausgrabung-
case of evident tools, not just ‘‘somewhat worked’’ en und Forschungen in Karanovo Vol. 1;1–2 (Text & Tafel).
stones. Finally, at Lı̂ga some ‘‘worked stones’’, suppos- Salzburg (Archäologisches Institut, Universität Salzburg)/
Horn, Wien (Ferdinand Berger) & Sofia (Archäologisches Insti-
edly, in the main common ‘‘hammer stones’’ and tut, Bulgarische Akademie der Wissenschaften).
‘‘stones with facets’’ may, as least in part, have been McParron, A. & D. Srejović (eds.). 1988. Divostin. And the Neo-
cobble stones from the first phase (Lı̂ga 1) re-used in lithic of Central Serbia. Ethnology Monographs 10. Pittsburgh
Lı̂ga 2. (Department of Anthropology, University of Pittsburgh).
The stone artefacts from Karanovo, in spite of an Prinz, B. 1988. The Ground Stone Industry from Divostin.
McPherron & Srejović 1988. 255ff.
Early Copper Age date, make up the best compara- K{nxfc K., 1970: Kamfnni oq{eiÄ os nfolisnoso rflizf
tive material to the Lı̂ga sample (Hiller & Nikolov kqai r. Xaceaq, Rouiirki okq{d. AqvfolodiÄ, kn. 4,
1997). At Karanovo there is a very high number of XXX.
axes (mostly adzes) – about 2/3 of the tools collected; K{nxfc K. & Nikoloc B. 1983. Oq{eiÄ na sqtea i rsopan-
there are some chisels too. In addition were found: rkiÄ gicos na rfliza os valkolisnasa fpova c{c
Cqaxanrko. IhcfrsiÄ na mthfisf c rfcfqohapaena
quernstones (sleepers and runners), many hammer- B{ldaqiÄ, 8, Cqawa. 9ff.
stones, polishers (including round ones of quartzite) Semenov, S. 1964. Prehistoric technology: An experimental study
and stones with traces of polishing, etc., including sev- of the oldest tools and artefacts from traces of manufacture and
eral types not found at Lı̂ga (f.ex., polishers of arrow- wear. London, Cory, Adams and Mackay.
shafts).
IX. BONE ARTEFACTS
by
Petar Zidarov

STATE OF RESEARCH posits (Kanchev & Nikolov 1983). Such studies are
The primary data under study here come from recent therefore considered irrelevant to the Lı̂ga material
excavations at the settlement and cemetery of Lı̂ga in and will not be considered here.
Telish, Pleven district, Northern Bulgaria. In previous Since 1998, the author has had the opportunity to
publications the site is referred to as Telish-Lı̂ga, or study several unpublished bone artefact collections re-
simply, Lı̂ga (Gergov 2001; etc.) to discern it from covered during systematic excavations at various sites
neighboring Telish-Redutite, the latter being the only roughly synchronous to Lı̂ga. These are the tell settle-
completely investigated Copper Age multi-layered ments at Durankulak, Kableshkovo-Kozareva Mogi-
settlement in the area of the Krivodol-Sǎlcuţa-Bubanj la, Yunatsite, Hotnica, and Krivodol, as well as the
Hum Ia (KSB) cultural complex (Gergov 1985; cemeteries at Durankulak and Varna, courtesy of the
1992a; 1992b). Redutite also has an important bone respective project directors and museum curators,
artefact assemblage. Prof. Dr. H. Todorova (Archaeological Institute and
The site of Lı̂ga, located 1.2 km from Redutite, is Museum at the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences), Dr.
supposed to have been settled during periods when P. Georgieva (Sofia University), Mrs. V. Matsanova
Redutite was not occupied. Unfortunately, the worked and Mrs. S. Ignatova (Museum of Pazardjik), Mr. N.
bone finds from Redutite have not yet been made Elenski (Museum of Veliko Turnovo), Mr. G. Gane-
available with only a few single objects being pub- covski (Museum of Vratsa), and Dr. V. Slavchev (Mu-
lished (Gergov 1987; Ribarov & Boev 1997) or ex- seum of Varna). The purpose of the present study is
hibited at the Historical Museum in Pleven. Thus, in to offer a general presentation of the characteristic
the present study it will only be possible to present an traits of the assemblage. Thus microscopic examina-
account of the observations from Lı̂ga, leaving out tions of use-wear patterns will not be addressed here.
possible discussions on diachronic processes. Other
archaeologically related sites are Sadovec-Golemano-
vo Kale (Todorova 1968; 1992), Devetashka Peshtera THE SAMPLE
(Mikov & Dzhambazov 1960; Kunchev 1973), Krivo- The bone artefacts from Lı̂ga belong to three distinct
dol (Nikolov 1984) and Zaminec (Nikolov 1975) in periods of human activity at the site, from subsequent
Bulgaria, as well as Sǎlcuţa in Romania (Berciu 1961) phases of the Late Copper Age. Following the termin-
and Selevac in Serbia (Tringham & Krstić 1990). ology developed for this publication, they are de-
Only Selevac has furnished comparable material, all scribed respectively as: Lı̂ga 1 – the initial occupation,
other sites having only been studied through test a level greatly disturbed by activity in subsequent
trenches aimed at establishing the stratigraphic se- building horizons although recognizable as a distinc-
quence. tive unit on the basis of architectural elements (so-
The only attempt to evaluate the role of bone called House 0 – postholes, walls, plastered floor), pot-
tools – in comparison to chipped and polished stone tery, small finds, etc., Lı̂ga 2 – three completely exca-
tools from Copper Age sites in NW Bulgaria – is thus vated buildings with adjacent inter-building spaces
based on relative calculations of tools recovered from and waste areas, and Lı̂ga 3 – a cemetery. The strati-
sounding trenches (of different dimensions) at various graphic distribution of the bone tools is shown in Fig.
sites, disregarding association with archaeological IX.1. The majority of artefacts (72%) come from an
structures as well as the nature of the particular de- intensively occupied area of Lı̂ga 2. It represents an
Lı̂ga 125

Fig. IX.2. Functional classes of bone artefacts: chronological distri-


Fig. IX.1. Stratigraphic distribution of bone tools.
bution (count).

area with the highest percentage of bone tools per


household as compared to contemporary settlements
at Durankulak, Yunatsite, Hotnitsa or Kableshkovo-
Kozareva Mogila (Zidarov in print; unpublished per-
sonal observations). However, it must be noted that Fig. IX.3. Lı̂ga 2. Spatial distribution of functional classes of bone
all of the latter are at least 200–350 km from Lı̂ga artefacts (count).
and located in different types of landscapes, present-
ing various adaptive challenges and resulting in econ-
omic specializations. The said sites also differ signifi- have held a metal awl to judge by contemporary
cantly from Lı̂ga in terms of methods of recovery and examples from other contemporary sites. Ornaments
examination. Lı̂ga is the only site where extensive comprise beads, pendants and appliqué. ‘‘Miscel-
screening was used during excavation and where all laneous’’ is the term used to group non-utilitarian ob-
faunal remains were checked for traces of manufac- jects such as figurines or flattened short bones. To a
ture and wear. great extent this division is mirrored in the archae-
From a functional point of view, one can divide the ological context. Body ornaments at Lı̂ga for instance,
finds roughly into classes by identifying the tools and are almost exclusively recovered from graves, unlike
the handles for tools as critical objects, in order to the other two categories, occurring in habitation
distinguish them from body ornaments, figurines, and areas.
flattened short bones, all referred to as ‘‘non-utili-
tarian’’ objects. Fragments bearing traces of manufac-
ture and/or use, as well as manufacturing waste, are LÎGA 1: FIRST SETTLEMENT
grouped as ‘‘other’’ (Fig. IX.2). Interestingly, whereas Seven bone artefacts can be attributed to the earliest
the proportional ratio between utilitarian and non- occupational level at the site (Fig. IX.1): two bevel-
utilitarian finds in Lı̂ga 1 and Lı̂ga 3 tends to match edged tools (Pl. 26:1,4), one point (Pl. 26:3), one antler
the expectation that there would be more tools found haft (for a polished stone chisel?), one flat anthropo-
in a habitation area and more body ornaments and morphic figurine (Pl. 26:6), one transversely sawn
figurines in graves, Lı̂ga 2 contained 55% non-utili- deer antler tine without signs of use, probably manu-
tarian finds. Specifics about their distribution related facture waste (Pl. 26:2) and finally, a fragment of boar
to dwelling structures in Lı̂ga 2 are provided in Fig. tusk with rounded edges that has undergone dramatic
IX.3. alteration due to extreme heat and subsequent weath-
From a typological point of view, bone artefacts ering, but which was likely employed as a scraping/
constitute three main groups: tools, ornaments, and smoothing tool (Pl. 26:5). All tools from Lı̂ga 1 are
miscellaneous. Typically for prehistoric sites, the most made in an expedient manner from long bones of
numerous tools are points, followed by bevel-edged large mammals, seemingly from pieces retrieved from
and spatulate implements. The category of tools is kitchen refuse, unlike the tools from Lı̂ga 2 discussed
closely associated with bone and antler hafts. At Lı̂ga, below. The single point and one of the bevel-edged
antler was used to fasten chipped- or ground-stone tools are most likely from cattle tibia splinters,
tools. The single handle from sheep metacarpus may whereas the second bevel-edged tool is from cattle
126 Acta Archaeologica

Lı̂ga 2 are very carefully planned, manufactured in a


uniform way, and often reworked. The large numbers
of worked bone per household clearly demonstrates
that as a category of artefacts they must have had a
certain importance, in spite of the co-existence of cop-
per technology, revealed in by metal implements
(Lı̂ga 2) and crucibles (Lı̂ga 1), cf. Chapter VI.

LÎGA 3: CEMETERY
Several graves held artefacts made of animal skeletal
Fig. IX.4. Lı̂ga 2. Summary: bone artefacts and their spatial distri- materials, mostly different combinations of bone and
bution (count). shell. In possible association with Grave no. 1 – a
child of 6–7 years – a domestic pig metatarsus with a
flattened distal articulation was found (Fig. IX.5, Pl.
ulna. In all three cases, the natural form of the pieces 28:1). Such finds are specific for the Late Copper Age
is basically preserved and only the active ends are in Bulgaria and are usually interpreted as a particular
elaborately shaped through rubbing against abrasive kind of anthropomorphic figurine, having very close
stone. Although relatively worn from use, the working counterparts made in clay (cf. Fol 1988, 254ff.; Biehl
parts of all the tools are fully functional after minor 2003). They are termed ‘‘prismatic figurines’’ (Comşa
sharpening. Recent damage on two tools prevents dis- 1984), based on the outline, or ‘‘stupalni [foot] idoli’’
cussion on whether they were discarded when fully (in Bulgarian), emphasizing their biological origin
functional, or deposited in another way. (Chilingirov 1910). In this particular case, the proxi-
mal end is missing but the important distal end is
seemingly intact. To judge by other specimens with
LÎGA 2: SECOND SETTLEMENT preserved copper earrings (Todorova & Vajsov 2001,
The finds of bone tools from Lı̂ga 2 and their types, Pl. 44), this part is supposed to represent the head of
are listed in Fig. IX.4, cf. Pl. 27. As noted, tools are the figurine. Deposition of pars pro toto goods is often
relatively evenly distributed. Each of the houses seen in Late Copper Age burials in Bulgaria, for in-
yielded at least two pointed tools. There were points stance at the cemeteries of Durankulak (Todorova
only in House 2, while there is a tendency for further 2002), and Varna (Ivanov & Avramova 2000; Fol &
specialization in the others. In House 3 there was a Lichardus 1988). The attention paid to various small
concentration of bevel-ended tools while in House 1 bones in the Copper Age is discussed below. Another
five spatulate tools were found as well as 3 bone awls possible pars pro toto item from Lı̂ga is the cattle
π 1 copper awl (Fig. VI.13) and 2 copper pins (Fig. horncore recovered in Grave no. 5 (Fig. XI.7–9), cf.
VI.14). All hafts were concentrated in House 3. These the cattle skulls (bucrania) recovered in cemetery of
belong to different types: one is an antler sleeve with Durankulak (Todorova 2002). Another prismatic
two openings, one of which was inserted into a figurine, with an identical fragmentation pattern, was
wooden shaft. The other was meant to hold a polish- discovered 1.2 m NE of Grave no. 2 (Pl. 28:2). The
ed stone tool, possibly an adze (Pl. 27:8). The third grave pit is dug into settlement debris, making the
one, made of sheep metacarpus, served as a socket association with the grave questionable. A rectangular
for a tiny metal tool: a copper pin or drill (Fig. VI.15, bone plate decorated with diagonal rows of encircled
Pl. 27:6). The distribution of the non-utilitarian finds dots (Pl. 28:11) was discovered in Grave no. 4, in the
also reveals a clear asymmetrical pattern with a sig- area of the chest, under the bent left arm. It is made
nificant concentration in House 1. The possible impli- on the split rib of cattle or aurochs and has perfor-
cations are discussed below. ations on both short sides. With regards to context, it
Generally speaking, the majority of the tools from seems to have hung on a long string around the neck.
Lı̂ga 127

Similar specimens are known from the Varna cem-


etery (exhibition, National Historical museum, Sofia)
and from Kirilovo (Todorova & Vajsov 2001, Pl. 24).
Shell necklaces of different compositions were recov-
ered in Graves nos. 6 and 7. In the first case, the
necklace consisted of 8 cylindrical dentalium beads
divided at the front by a bone imitation of a red deer
canine (Fig. XI.12, Pl. 28:10); it was recovered under
the mandible and between the skull and the atlas of
an 18–19 year old male, thus, hanging around his
neck. In Grave no. 7, a double grave of an adult male
(25–30 years) embracing a ca. 11⁄2 year old child,
dentalium shells again dominate, this time comple-
mented by cardium shells (Fig. XI.11); a single large
dentalium bead was found below the scapula of the
adult, thus showing that it either hung loosely from
the neck or was a separately deposited grave gift. A
double necklace of altering dentalium and cardium
shells ornamented the neck of the child (Fig. XI.15).
The composition of the necklaces requires particu-
lar attention. The two shell families, Dentalium and
Cardium are marine species and their presence more
than 300 km from the nearest seashore raises the
question of their provenance. A study by Willms
(1985), updated by Todorova (1995), demonstrates
that the Spondylus and Dentalium finds have their
highest concentration in the area of the Varna culture
Fig. IX.5. Pig metatarsus with flattened articulations of the distal
but also spread gradually along the Danube and its
epiphysis, a so-called prismatic idol, found in Grave 1. Photo: R.
tributaries North-Westwards to the Rhine Valley. Kolev.
Thus, the proximity of Lı̂ga to the river Vit, one of
the principal southern tributaries of the Danube in
Bulgaria conforms well with the general distribution
pattern. Nevertheless, a working hypothesis was tested has a representative pair of such teeth. During the
that the shells could be mined fossils. In fact, in the Holocene, with very few exceptions, the wearing of
vicinity of Pleven (25 km from Lı̂ga) fossil dentalium red-deer canines as beads is a phenomenon charac-
and possibly cardium shells have been collected on teristic for a timeline starting at the end of 6th and
the surface at least until the 1970s (N. Zidarov, per- ending sometime in the 4th millennium BC. The cus-
s.comm.). Although the survey of the Lı̂ga team in tom was widely spread throughout Europe only to be
2001 was not successful in obtaining reference replaced by predators’ canines sometime in the early
samples, a report by N. Andreasen, Copenhagen & 3rd millennium BC, possibly reflecting a significant
Cambridge universities, discards the fossil interpreta- change in ideology towards warrior/hunter-related
tion. values mediated through symbolic display. Usually
Another interesting issue is raised by the discovery found in very rich graves, the canines are seen as signs
of the imitation of a red deer ‘‘Grandel’’, a canine, of prestige or clan affiliation (Choyke 2001). Contem-
in Grave no. 6. Its central position on a necklace of porary graves from Varna and Durankulak – with
imported exotic shells suggests a particular value, necklaces of dozens of real canines (Todorova &
likely due to the fact that only the adult red deer stag Vajsov 2001, Tab. 24) – are highly suggestive. The
128 Acta Archaeologica

phenomenon of hoarding larger amounts of rare and Hence, it cannot be excluded, that certain items
valuable items becomes clearly articulated towards might have been intentionally deposited under the
the end of the Bulgarian Late Copper Age (Gaydarska floor of House 1 in a foundation ritual.
et al. 2004). Particularly characteristic for the Lı̂ga 2 assem-
blage is the attention paid to the shaping of various
kinds of short bones, such as astragalus, the 1st and
NON-UTILITARIAN BONE FINDS 2nd phalanges of medium-size ungulates, and pig me-
Lı̂ga assemblages are particularly interesting because tapodials (Pl. 28). To avoid confusion, the adjective
of the number and variety of so-called ‘‘non-utili- ‘‘short’’ applied to a bone in the following discussion
tarian’’ bone finds. Most of those interesting finds will be used in a casual sense and thus somewhat in-
come from reliable archaeological contexts. correctly in terms of anatomy. In general, skeletal ele-
The flat anthropomorphic figurine from Lı̂ga 1 (Pl. ments are divided into three principal classes: long
26:6) raises key questions regarding attitudes towards bones – the tubular bones of the extremities that are
such objects in Copper Age society. Close examina- roughly round in section at the diaphysis and have
tion reveals at least two (if not three) superimposed distinct epiphyses, such as the femur, tibia, etc.; flat
patterns of incised decorations on both faces. As pre- bones – mainly the bones of the cranium, the pelvis
viously recognized, the use-life of this kind of figurines and the ribs; and short or irregular bones – mainly
was extended by reshaping after damage, unlike the from elements of the vertebral column and the cubic
clay figurines which, to my knowledge, were never bones of the extremities, such as phalanges, astragali,
repaired or reused after breaking. A classic case of etc. Strictly speaking, the metapodials are always
novel use is a flat bone figurine from Kableshkovo- classified as long bones, but in fact pig metapodials
Kozareva Mogila (Zidarov in press); this was broken do, in size, anatomical position, as well in overall ap-
in two at the ‘‘waist’’, but the important lower part pearance, closely resemble phalanges and would
was carefully preserved and furnished with a suspen- probably be approached accordingly by anyone who
sion hole. The dotted decoration pattern on this piece is not aware of present day taxonomy. That is why,
(as well as numerous others) corresponds closely to with regards to past cognition and for the purposes
the Lı̂ga specimen in the organization of the motive. of the present study, it was found appropriate not to
Thus, it possibly designates an element of the costume separate these bones from the short bones.
that in this particular archaeological context might be The flattening of the lateral sides of the astragali is
associated with the round gold cloth appliqués, found a characteristic trait for Anatolia, the Balkans and the
in great numbers in the Copper Age cemetery of Carpathian Basin since the Neolithic. The assigning
Varna I. of stylized anthropomorphic features to pig metapod-
The two superimposed decoration patterns on the ial is documented repeatedly at Late Copper Age sites
Lı̂ga figurine show that it was decorated by two differ- from the eastern parts of the Balkans, the two major
ent owners having differing ideas about the motif. cultural areas of Krivodol-Sălcuţa-Bubanj Hum Ia
The first carver prepared a stylized outline with pro- and Kodžadermen-Gumelniţa-Karanovo VI. Both
portions closely following the natural ones, the ter- bones appear commonly in excavation reports, often
mination of certain body parts being marked with in- with the assumption that the former were used as
cised lines. The second carver, by contrast, departed gaming pieces and the latter anthropomorphic idols.
completely from the nature of the female figure, sig- Flattening of phalanges has only occasionally been
nificantly changing the place of the pubic triangle, reported. R. Popov published a flattened red-deer
thus imposing rather abstract signifiers for body parts phalanx from Tell Kodžadermen, mentioning that
and ornamental elements (costume?). Unfortunately, similar finds were discovered in his earlier excavations
the reasons for the deposition of the item cannot be at Salmanovo and Madara (Popov 1918:91f.). An-
determined: it was found ca. one metre from the other single find of a 2nd phalanx of sheep is known
outer southern wall of a house belonging to the Lı̂ga from Tell Kozareva Mogila near Kableshkovo, in the
1 settlement, under the floor of House 1 of Lı̂ga 2. Burgas region (Zidarov in print). This has been flat-
Lı̂ga 129

tened on its palmar side, like the finds from Lı̂ga, but significant opening at the lower part. Flattened pris-
also on the caudal one at the distal epiphysis where, matic figurines are likely to be identified with female-
additionally, a suspension hole was drilled. To my related powers, whereas their modest size implies
knowledge, the interpretative implications of these apotropaic use as personal talismans. Often it is hard
finds has never attracted particular scientific interest. to find contextual information in the excavation re-
They seem to be underrepresented in excavation re- ports about these artefacts. Luckily, during the first
ports as well. One of the reasons could be that faunal excavation season at Lı̂ga, one slightly worked pig
material was often sampled during recovery and such metapodium was found in Grave no. 1 (Pl. 28:1), an-
minor modifications would easily go unnoticed by other might be associated with Grave no. 2 (Pl. 28:2),
non-specialists. It is noteworthy that the major part of cf. Chapter XI.
the worked phalanges from Lı̂ga were recovered only The flattened astragali are traditionally seen as
after a thorough search of the faunal remains (cf. gaming pieces due to their similarity to the ones used
Chapter X). in the game of knucklebones. Varieties of this game
Here an interpretative analysis of the possible util- have been recorded in written and pictorial sources
ization of various flattened short bones will be sug- from the Mediterranean ever since Homer (Iliad
gested, taking into account contextual data. Phal- XXIII.88). The rapid decrease in popularity of the
anges from the extinct Equus Hydruntinus were recov- game seems to coincide with the industrialization of
ered in Copper Age graves at the cemtery of traditional societies. In the past, astragali were also
Durankulak (Todorova 2002). H. Todorova pays intentionally deposited as votives in sacred places.
special attention to the strict association of these items This custom is frequently documented during Classi-
with male graves rich in supposed ceremonial finds, cal Antiquity but often overlooked by archaeologists
and suggests their possible use in ritual practices. dealing with prehistoric periods. Again, the limited
Along the same line of interpretation is the discovery attention paid in the early days of archaeology to the
of more than 200 phalanges and astragali intention- particular context of finds is not helpful when search-
ally deposited under the floor of a Late Copper Age ing for the possible ritual use of flattened astragali.
building at Tell Hotnitsa in the Veliko Turnovo re- Nevertheless, a golden model of a sheep astragalus
gion (Chokhadzhiev & Elenski 2002:15). This assem- furnished with a suspension hole, was recovered from
blage, recovered within half a square meter, pertains Grave 36 from the Copper Age cemetery of Varna I.
to a wide range of wild and domesticated animals, Grave 36 is a symbolic grave (cenotaph) in which no
including red-deer, cattle, aurochs, wild boar, sheep human remains were found. Still, it is extremely rich
and goat; the find could be interpreted as a founda- in goods, among which gold and copper regalia, zo-
tion deposit. These cases also give rise to the idea that omorphic representations in gold and clay, as well as
unworked phalanges could have been associated with numerous cloth and body ornaments were mostly
apotropaic powers over individuals and property. found arranged as if ornamenting a human figure (Iv-
The identification of flattened pig metapodials as anov 1998:196f.). The composition of this extraordi-
stylized anthropomorphic representations – prismatic nary find complex is certainly intended to reflect con-
figurines or ‘‘stupalni idoli’’ in Bulgarian – was the ceptual constructs, furnishing clear evidence that dur-
subject of one of the very first articles on worked bone ing the late 5th millennium BC laterally flattened
artefacts in Bulgarian archaeological literature, the astragali played a role in ritual activities. As indicated
morphologically identical clay figurines being known by the suspension hole, in this particular case, the
already at that time (Chilingirov 1910). A century golden astragalus must have been worn as an orna-
later, there are many publications of such finds, both ment, probably signaling a role in society not linked
in clay and bone, some allowing a better understand- per se to a particular person but rather – as indicated
ing of the stylized details encoded in the image. On by the symbolic grave – to the institution that the
some figurines, facial traits are marked and metal ear- powers in question embodied. Thus, the various small
rings attached to the articulations of the distal epiphy- bones with flattened sides – the prismatic figurines
sis, thus, identifying the head, whereas others have a from pig metapodials and the laterally flattened astra-
130 Acta Archaeologica

gali, even palmar-flattened phalanges, all seem to be wide variety of tool types, especially in the Lı̂ga 2, is
associated with ritual practices. a testimony to the many craft activities practiced by
If one considers the particular archaeological situ- inhabitants of the village. Of special interest is the
ations in which various flattened short bone objects abundance of non-utilitarian objects in the same
were recovered at Lı̂ga, noteworthy patterns emerge phase. The association of flattened astragali and phal-
(Fig. IX.4). The plotting of bone artefacts reveals a anges with other special finds, or their occasional oc-
significantly high concentration of various kinds of currence in funeral contexts, suggest that these small
objects in the interior and the area immediately out- bone items could have been possibly used for apotro-
side House 1. Interestingly, this structure also displays paic purposes rather than as gaming pieces. Finally,
a concentration of a wide spectrum of special finds, body ornaments recovered in the graves help in the
like ‘‘clay altars’’, ‘‘baby feeding bottles’’, copper reconstruction of the personal ornaments of the
artefacts, anthropomorphic figurines, in addition to period. The necklaces, mostly composed of marine
the astragali, etc. (cf. Chapter VI). The latter come in shells, likely travelled several hundred kilometres,
two sizes (cattle and sheep), one, with a perforation, demonstrate the wider limits and the directions of
is also decorated (Pl. 28:5). This combination of finds contacts at Copper Age Lı̂ga.
having a presumably ritual use reveals some particu-
lar aspects of the life of the occupants, as well as a
context for the use of flattened phalanges and astra-
gali in ritual practices. By contrast, the occurrence of BIBLIOGRAPHY
Berciu, D. 1961. Contributii la problemele neoliticului in Romania in lumina
few astragali and phalanges in dwellings with mostly noilor cercetari. Bucuresti.
mundane inventories probably indicate their popu- Biehl, P. 2003 Studien zum Symbolgut des Neolithikums und der
larity as personal talismans, possibly also used in divi- Kupferzeit in Südosteuropa. Saarbrücker Beiträge zur Altertumskunde
nation (rather than as a gaming piece). It should be 64. Bonn: Habelt.
mentioned, that one of side-flattened sheep astragalus Choyke, A.M. 2001. Late Neolithic Red Deer Canine Beads and
Their Imitations. In: Choyke & Bartosiewicz (eds.), Crafting Bone:
was discovered inside a fine ware vessel in House 2 Skeletal Technologies through Time and Space, 251ff. Proceedings of
(Pl. 9:1). the 2nd meeting of the (ICAZ) Worked Bone Research Group,
Budapest. BAR IS 937. Oxford: Archaeopress.
Comşa E. 1984 Figurines d’os prismatique d’epoque Néolithique
SUMMARY en Roumanie. Pontica XVII: 15–23.
Fol A., Lichardus, I. et al. 1988. Macht, Herrschaft und Gold. Saar-
The bone artefacts from Lı̂ga are significant in several brücken.
respects, in particular since their general contexts are Gaydarska B., Chapman J., Angelova I., Gurova M., Yanev, S.
known – occupation levels, houses, and graves, as well 2004 Breaking, Making and Trading: the Omurtag Eneolithic
as differences in the composition of the documented Spondylus Hoard. Archaeologia Bulgarica VIII/2, 11–34.
assemblages. Interestingly, the Lı̂ga 1 assemblage is Georgieva, P. 1990. Periodization of the Krivodol-Sălcuţa-Bubanj
Culture. In: Vinca and It’s World. 167–171. Beograd.
characterised by expediency with regards to craft Ivanov, I., Avramova, M. 2000. Varna Necropolis. The dawn of Euro-
peoples’ attitude towards bone as a worked material. pean civilization. Sofia: Agatho.
By contrast, a clearly attested tendency towards plan- Jovanović, B. 1998. Sălcuţa IV, Krivodol and Bubanj: Similarities
ning and careful execution of manufacture seems to and Differences in the Late Eneolithic of the Central Balkans.
In: In the Steps of James Harvey Gaul, vol. I, 197–202. Sofia.
have been customary in Lı̂ga 2.
Todorova Simeonova, H. 1968. Die vorgeschichtlichen Funde von
The remarkable flat figurine reveals high work- Sadovec (Nordbulgarien). Jahrbuch des Römisch-Germanischen Zen-
manship skills compared to the less careful work on tralmuseums Mainz 15:15–63.
most Lı̂ga 1 tools. The secondary decoration of the Todorova, H. 1992. Bericht über die Kontrolgrabung von 1979
figurine testifies to development in decorative con- auf Golemanovo Kale und Neueauswertung des prähistori-
schen Fundgutes in die spätantiken Befestigungen von Sadovec
cepts through time (or across space, if imported) and
(Bulgarien). Münchner Beitrage zur Vor- und Fruhgeschichte 43.
the co-existence of different perceptions. Change of München.
ownership is suggested by re-location of lines demark- Todorova, H. 1995. Bemerkungen zum frühen Handelsverkehr
ing body regions on the same figurine. The rather während des Neolithikums und des Chalkolithikums im
Lı̂ga 131

westlichen Schwarzmeerraum. Hänsel, B., Hrsg., Handel, Tausch K{nxfc, K. 1973. Ha obqaboskasa i ihpolhcanfso na korssa
und Verkehr im bronze- und früheisenzeitlichen Südosteuropa. Prähist. pqfh nfolisa, fnfolisa i bqonhocasa fpova. Aqvfolo-
Arch. Südosteuropa 11: 53–66. München, Berlin. diÄ XV, 2.
Todorova H. 2000. Die Spondylus-Problematik heute. In S. Hiller K{nxfc, K., Nikoloc B. 1983. Oq{eiÄ na sqtea i rsopan-
and V. Nikolov (eds.), Karanovo III: Beiträge zum Neolithikum in rkiÄ gicos na rfliza os valkolisnasa fpova c{c
Südosteuropa, 415–422. Wien. Cqaxanrko. IhcfrsiÄ na mthfisf c rfcfqohapaena
Todorova, H., 2002: Durankulak, Band II. Die prähistorischen Gräberfeld- B{ldaqiÄ, 8: 9–35, Cqawa.
er von Durankulak. Teil 1. Deutsches Archäologisches Insititut in Mikoc, C. 1934. Ieolnasa plarsika pqfh nocokamfnnasa
Berlin. Sofia. fpova. IhcfrsiÄ na B{ldaqrki aqvfolodixfrki inrsi-
Todorova, H., Vajsov, I., 2001. Die kupferzeitliche Schmuck Bulgariens. sts 8: 183–214, RouiÄ.
Stuttgart: Franz Steiner. Mikoc, C. 1948. Pqfeirsoqixfrkoso rflizf eo Kqicoeol,
Tringham, R., Krstić, D., 1990. Selevac: A Neolithic Village in Cqaxanrko. Qahkopki i pqotxcaniÄ. 1: 26–56. RouiÄ.
Yugoslavia. Monumenta Archaeologica 15. Los Angeles: University Mikoc, C., Egambahoc N. 1960. Efcfsaykasa pfzfqa.
of California. RouiÄ.
Willms, C. 1985. Neolithischer Spondylusschmuck. Hundert Jahre Nikoloc, B. 1975. Haminfw, pqairsoqixfrkoso rflizf
Forschung. Germania 63: 331–343. pqi r. Doqna Kqfmfna. RouiÄ.
Zidarov, P. In press. Worked Bone Collection from Tell Kozareva Nikoloc, B. 1984. Kqicoeol – eqfcni ktlstqi. RouiÄ.
mogila, Southeastern Bulgaria. Proceedings of the 3rd Meeting of the Popoc, Q. 1918. Koega-Efqmfnrkasa modila pqi dq. Yt-
(ICAZ) Worked Bone Research Group in Basel, Switzerland. Basel. mfn. IhcfrsiÄ na aqvfoloditfrkoso eqtgfrsco VI,
Dfqdoc, C. 1985. Pairsoqixfrkoso rflizf c m. Qfetsisf 1916–18. RouiÄ.
pqi r. Sfliy. Mthfi i pamfsniwi na ktlstqasa XXV Qibaqoc, D., Bofc, H. 1997. Korsni orsanki os eici i eo-
1: 31-33. mayni gicosni os pqairsoqixfrkoso rflizf ‘‘Sfliy-
Dfqdoc, C. 1987. Mfeni navoeki os pqairsoqixfrkoso rfl- Qfetsisf’’ pqi r. Sfliy (Plfcfnrko). Historia naturalis bul-
izf c m. Qfetsisf pqi Sfliy, Plfcfnrki okq. Aqvfol- garica 7: 61–70. RouiÄ.
odiÄ XXVIII 4: 44–48. RouiÄ. Xilindiqoc, A. 1910. Rs{palni korsni ieoli. IhcfrsiÄ
Dfqdoc, C. 1992a. MÄrsoso na rflizfso Sfliy-Qfetsisf c na aqvfolodixfrkoso eqtgrfrsco. RouiÄ.
PqfvoeniÄ pfqioe k{m QBF. AqvfolodiÄ 2. RouiÄ. Xovaegifc, R., N. Flfnrki 2002. Aqvfolodixfrki pqotx-
Dfqdoc, C. 1992b. Eoirsoqixfrkof porflfnif Sfliy- caniÄ c rfliznasa modila kqaĭ rflo Vosniwa,
Qfetsisf. Studia Preaehistorica 11–12: 347–357. RouiÄ. Cflikos{qnocrko, pqfh 2001 d. XLI Nawionalna aqvfo-
Dfqdoc, C. 2001. Aqvfolodixfrki qahkopki na pqairso- lodixfrka konufqfnwiÄ. Aqvfolodixfrki oskqisiÄ i
qixfrkoso rflizf c m. ‘‘L{da’’ pqi r. Sfliy, Plfcfnrka qahkopki 2001: 15. RouiÄ.
Oblars, pqfh 2000 d. Aqvfolodixfrki oskqisiÄ i qah-
kopki ha 1999–2000 d., c. 15–17. XL HAK. RouiÄ.
X. ANIMAL BONES
by
Jesper Sørensen Østergaard

THE SAMPLE modest extension of excavated area (275 m2) (Fig.


The animal bones from Lı̂ga were studied already X.4). it is much higher than at other sites. Many
during excavation and analyzed in the field (Fig. X.1). bones suffering from drying and splintering were re-
Close instruction of the excavators raised the number fitted. Unfortunately, it was not permitted to take the
of animal bone fragments recovered several times bones to Denmark for a period of comparative studies
over. The location of every specimen was mapped (for this reason, teeth and jaws were excluded when
and the item individually classified according to de- determining age of individuals).
gree of preservation: no damage, damage old, or 716 of the fragments (N) could be identified as to
damage recent (Fig. X.2). A distinction was also made species. The rather more uncertain minimum num-
between natural damage, damage due to context, to ber of individuals (MNI) was also established for each
excavation tools, recovery, drying, transportation, or species (on the basis of paired bones). Among the
to storage (in paper bags). Such notes are quite useful domesticated animals (164 MNI), cattle amounts to
since damage is much harder to classify after a period
of storage (and drying). In addition, information was
thereby obtained on the level of preservation of or-
ganic material in the different areas and levels of the
excavation, which aided the procedure of work. An
example is sondages 8A and 8B (refuse area), with
good preservation throughout.
The thin bones, such as shoulder blades, ribs, and
hips, are the weakest (large surface). These bones also
tend to generate a lot of fragments when excavated,
especially when dry. Also here notes on the state of
preservation are helpful, as are words on the weather
conditions during excavation (dryness generate more
fragments). Such time-consuming exercises are
necessary to determine the degree of representation
of a bone sample from different areas and layers in
an excavation. Flotation was carried out on important
soil samples (in and around ovens, for example). Dry
sieving was not productive and was abolished. Some
bone microfossils were probably lost, but not too
many (for details of excatation techniques, see above).
4820 bone fragments (N) were identified and ana-
lyzed according to standard methods and procedures
(Fig. X.1). All data were entered into an Access data-
base – point of departure for further studies as well
as the present tables and statistics. The number of Fig. X.1. Amounts and percentages of animal bones distributed in
fragments may seem limited, but compared with the the excavated sondages, cf. Fig. II.3.
Lı̂ga 133

36, sheep/goat to 94, pig to 17 and dog also to 17;


wild animals amount to 24 MNI. The ratio domesti-
cated animals versus wild ones is, in percentages, 87
to 13% on basis of the limited MNI numbers of the
present sample. Also age profiles were tentatively es-
tablished, by looking at the stage of growth of the
bones and joints. In the end, fragment numbers (N)
were employed generally, including teeth, to deter-
mine the differing weight of the species (Fig. X.3).

SECONDARILY IDENTIFIED TOOLS AND WEAR


TRACES
Some bones with traces of wear and work – even frag-
ments of bone tools – were recovered during the de-
tailed study of the bone sample, otherwise consisting of
refuse from meals and work (cf. Chapter IX on quality
bone artefacts). These fragments of tools, worked
bones etc. are not added to the species list. Fragments
of bone tools and figurines, and bones with marks of
work and wear amount to 150 (cf. Fig. X.2). Among
Fig. X. 2. State of preservation and patterns of use of/damage to
these bones, a few are with certainty cervidae (dear ant-
the Lı̂ga bone sample.
ler) or bos (horn of cattle). Pig-phalanxes without wear,
which may have been used for gaming pieces (or in rit-
uals), are included in the above species lists. BULGARIA
The techniques of manufacture and the function of Karanovo, Nova Zagora. Largest Neolithic tell in Bulgar-
tools were also studied. A correlation exists between ia, 250¿150¿121⁄2 m. Continuity Early Neolithic-
the thickness of the wall of the bone and the type of Late Copper Age, and Early Bronze Age. Excavated
tool. Bones with walls above 0.5 cms are used for by V. Mikov 1936, G.I. Georgiev & V. Mikov 1947–
heavy tools (blows and stabs), bones with walls below 57, S. Hiller & V. Nikolov 1988–2000.
0.5 cms are used for light tools (awls, etc.). Tools were Sofia-Slatina, Sofia. Early Neolithic (Karanovo I &
never made from casual fragments: quite the con- II). Bones (from upper level of settlement strata)
trary, a thorough selection is noted with regards to studied by S. Bökönyi.
hardness of the material – soft tissue being ignored Vaksevo, Kjustendil. At River Elesnica feeding
and older animals preferred. Probably, the heavy duty Struma. 850 m2 excavated. Early Neolithic, Late
tools came from old large animals, in particular cattle, Copper Age, and Early Bronze Age. The Vaksevo
with large massive tick-walled bones. The smaller sample is a collective one from neighbouring sites
tools are likely from sheep/goat, the bones of which (two) at Studeno Voda and (one) at Skaleto; studied
are easily turned into awls. by H. Uerpmann & L. Ninov.
Ovcharovo-Gorata, Targoviste. Investigated by H. To-
dorova at the beginning of the 1980s. Karanovo II.
COMPARISONS Bones studied by G. Nobis.
SELECTED SETTLEMENTS WITH ANIMAL BONE Golyamo-Delchevo, Varna. Tell 4.9 m high. Karanovo
SAMPLES I–II, III–IV, V & VI. Excavated by H. Todorova
The following settlements in the Balkans have yielded 1968–70. In Karanovo VI a cemetery of 31 inhu-
published animal bone samples of some size and in- mations in hocker.
terest to the current study (cf. Fig. X.5). Ovcharovo, Razgrad. Tell 60 m across¿41⁄2 m. Poly-
134 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. X.3. Lı̂ga bone sample. N – number of bones, MNI – minimal number of individuals.

anica (Karanovo V) & Gumelniţa-Kodžadermen-Ka- anovo V, VI & Early Bronze Age. Excavated by Bulg-
ranovo VI. Excavated by H. Todorova 1971–1973. arian-German team 1983.
Vinitsa, Shumen. Tell 55¿45¿5 m. Karanovo V, Ezero, Nova Zagora. Tell 200¿145¿10 m. Karanovo
Sterile layer VI. Totally excavated 1965–69 by A. Ra- III, IV, V, VI & Early Bronze Age/Ezero A-B. Exca-
duncheva. At the site were 46 inhumations from Kar- vated by V. Mikov 1952–58, by Bulgarian-Soviet
anovo VI. team 1961–71 headed by V. Mikov, R. Katincarov &
Drama, Yambol, Tundza Valley. Tell 160¿20 m. Kar- N.J. Merpert.
Lı̂ga 135

Fig. X.4. View from NE towards the excavated area. Front – area of Sector 2, back – area of Sector 1. In the background, the plain where
Telish village is situated.

GREECE the end of the 1970s. Early Bronze Age to Iron Age.
Sitagroi, Thessaly. Northeast of Thessaloniki, East of the Ca. 90,000 bones from all layers, 35,104 determined
mouth of Struma. Tell. Cultural layer of 101⁄2 m, according to species, of which 926 Early Bronze Age.
Neolithic & Early Bronze Age. Close similarities to
the Balkan cultures in pottery and figurines. Exca- MACEDONIA
vated 1968–69 by international team headed by M. Anza. Between Skopje and Stip (Ovce Polje region),
Gimbutas & C. Renfrew. Ca. 15,000 bones studied near Nikolskaja, a tributary to the Vardar. Excavated
by S. Bökönyi. in 1960, and 1969–70 by a joint Yugoslav-American
Platia Magoula Zarkou (P.M. Zarkou), Thessaly. On campaign headed by M. Garašanin and M. Gimbut-
Volos Bay near River Peneios. Tell. Neolithic to Early as. Cultural layers mainly from Early Neolithic to
Bronze Age. 11,613 animal bones studied by C. Copper Age. Ca. 45,000 bones of which 19,185 could
Becker. be identified as studied by S. Bökönyi.
Otzaki Magoula, Thessaly. On Volos Bay near River
Peneios. Tell. Neolithic to Early Bronze Age. 776
bones studied by J. Boessneck COMMENTS
Achillion, Thessaly. On Volos Bay. Neolithic to Early The data from Telish-Lı̂ga have been compared to
Bronze Age. 7,779 bones studied by S. Bökönyi. published samples from Bulgaria and Northern Gree-
Kastanas, Macedonia. On River Axios. Excavated at ce, and, in a single case, from Macedonia (cf. above &
136 Acta Archaeologica
Lı̂ga 137

Fig. X.5. Comparative table of studies other than Lı̂ga of animal bones in Bulgaria, Greece, and F.Y.R. Macedonia. BGΩBulgaria, GRΩ
Greece, YMCΩ(Former) Yugoslav Macedonia. EΩEarly, MΩMiddle, LΩLate; NΩNeolithic, CAΩCopper Age, BAΩBronze Age. Karano-
vo: traditional settlement phases of Karanovo tell are applied here for the sake of temporal orientation (Roman numbersΩrespective phases).
Figures: either nos. of bones (N), or calculated minimum nos. of individuals (MNI), all in% under individual species.
Scholars use two approaches concerning statistical presentation. In some cases, percentages of domesticated animals are calculated on the
basis of the whole sum of species, i.e., including the wild animals (marked here with grey colour). In these cases, wild animal percentages
must be added to the domesticated ones to give 100%. In most cases, however, domesticates are calculated separately, adding up to 100%
without incorporating the wild animals. Site references: Sofia-SlatinaΩBökönyi 1992; KaranovoΩHiller & Nikolov 1997; VaksevoΩNinov
2001; Ovcharovo-GorataΩNobis 1988; Golyamo-DelchevoΩIvanov & Vasilev 1975; DramaΩBökönyi 1990; Brenitsa, Gradeshnitsa, Krivo-
dol, Ovcharovo & VinitsaΩVasilev 1978; EzeroΩGeorgiev & Merpert 1979; SitagroiΩBökönyi 1986; P.M. Zarkou, Achillion & Otzaki
MagulaΩBecker 1991; 1999; KastanasΩBecker 1986; AnzaΩBökönyi 1976.

Fig. X.5). Other Yugoslav (or ex-Yugoslav) sites, like list of species (Ribarov & Boev 1997). In northwestern
famous Bubanj in eastern Serbia, has only yielded Bulgaria as a whole there are few published studies;
poor data (only the Early Bronze Age evidence is per- exceptions are Brenitsa, Gradeshnitsa and Krivodol
haps of some value, including 11 horse bones: early (Vasilev 1978). Apart from the fine work of Bökönyi,
evidence of domesticated horse in the Balkans) Boessneck & Driesch, there is substantial variation in
(Bökönyi 1991). Also the published Romanian data the quality of study in the Balkans (and Greece), in
are of low quality (Comşa 1989). A single KSB-cul- particular concerning investigations before the mid-
ture site, at Sfogea near Cuptoare in Southern Ro- 1980s. Very uncertain samples are not included here.
mania, has only 52% domestic animal bones – per- A general trend is the decline of cattle in the Late
haps an indication of flexible economic strategies (1). Neolithic and the Copper Age, which also see more
The Copper Age settlement of Redutite near Lı̂ga old individuals. Sheep/goat is on the rise in the same
is particularly interesting, but, unfortunately, the periods, but also these individuals are older than be-
data – amost 6,000 animal bones – were not collected fore. The number of pig is the same, but most were
stratigraphically and have only been published in killed young in later times. These comments on age
terms of measures of certain bones, plus a summary do not transpire from the tables. Wild animals
amount to about 10% or a little more in the Neo-
lithic, but the percentage rose in the Copper Age
1. A recent excavation at the Copper Age settlement of Măgura
(tell) Gorgana at Pietrele near the Danube has yielded a small
(sometimes very high percentages of hunted animals
animal bone sample seemingly with a lot of fish (76 fragments) are seen, as at Sfogea), as well as in the Early Bronze
(N. Benecke in Hansen et al. 2004). Wild animals are common Age. Thus, in the Copper Age, with older domestic
(⬎50 fragments, mainly wild boar, plus some deer. Among the animals, more stress was probably put on the so-
domesticated animals are 11 fragments of cattle, 28 of pig, but called ‘‘secondary’’ products, like power (cattle), milk,
only 7 sheep/goat; 5 fragments were of dog. This sample is not
entered in the tables, or otherwise. Adaptation to a particular
and wool. Likely, a more mobile system of husbandry
environment is clear. The high number of fish bones is raising was also introduced, including transhumance (sheep/
questions about their rarity at Lı̂ga. goat). This may also explain the high percentage of
138 Acta Archaeologica

wild animals, making up for losses in meat, and any- la Pevkakia in Thessalien. I. Die Nichtwiederkäuer. Aus dem Insti-
way more available to mobile populations. tut für Paläoanatomie, Domestikationsforschung und Ge-
schicthe der Tiermedicin der Universitet München. Inaugural-
The composition of a particular domestic animal Dissertation zur Erlangung der tiermedizinischen Doktorwürde
population – even as seen from the dry bones of exca- des Fachbereichs Tiermedizin der Ludwig-Maximilians-Uni-
vation – is usually a close reflection of the natural versität München. München.
catchments of a settlement and its potential, in fact Boessneck, J. & Driesch, A. 1979. Neue Tierknochenfunde aus der Magu-
the availability of water and fodder for the animals la Pevkakia in Thessalien. II. Die Wiederkauer. Aus dem Institut für
Paläoanatomie, Domestikationsforschung und Geschicthe der
throughout the year. As to pig, these are often, if nu- Tiermedicin der Universitet München. Inaugural-Dissertation
merous, indicators of nearby forests, while a high zur Erlangung der tiermedizinischen Doktorwürde des Fach-
number of sheep/goat is a reflection of open land- bereichs Tiermedizin der Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität
scapes, including dry plains and mountains; cattle München. München.
may be kept where water is plentiful, along streams, Bökönyi, S. 1974. History of Domestic Mammals in Central and Eastern
Europe. Budapest.
and in forests too. The lower-lying meadows at Lı̂ga Bökönyi, S. 1976. The Vertebrate Fauna from Anza. In Gimbutas,
(at the stream) would have been a fine and easily M. 1976. ed., Neolithic Macedonia: as reflected by excavation at Anza,
guarded area for cattle; such may also have grazed in Southeast Yugoslavia. Monumenta archaeologica 1: 313–316. Los
the supposed light forest ‘‘behind’’ Lı̂ga. Open plains Angeles.
are optimal for sheep/goat herding. Probably, the lat- Bökönyi, S. 1986. Faunal Remains. In Renfrew, A.C., M. Gimbut-
as & E. Elster 1986, eds., Excavations at Sitagroi, vol. 1. Monu-
ter also took place further away, during the summer
menta archaeologica 13: 63–132. Los Angeles.
likely in the lush mountains to the South. Bökönyi, S. 1989. Animal Remains. In: Gimbutas, M., Winn, S.,
Shimabuku, D. 1989, eds., Achilleion: a Neolithic settlement in Thes-
saly, Greece, 6400–5600 BC. Monumenta Archaeologica 14:
BIBLIOGRAPHY 315–332. Los Angeles.
Becker, C. 1999. The Middle Neolithic and The Platia Magoula Bökönyi, S. 1990. Erster vorläufiger Bericht über Tierknochenfun-
Zarkou – a review of current archaeozoological research in de der Karanovo-V-Besiedlung in Drama. Berichte der Römisch-
Thessaly. Anthropozoologica 30: 3–22. Berlin. Germanischen Kommission 70: 123–127.
Becker, C. 1986. Kastanas. Ausgrabungen in einem Siedlungshügel Bökönyi, S. 1992. Eine vorläufige Mitteilung über die Tierknoch-
der Bronze- und Eisenzeit Makedoniens 1975–1979. Die Tier- enfunde von Sofia-Slatina, Bauhorizont I. Acta praehistorica et ar-
knochenfunde. Prähistorische Archäologie in Südosteuropa, Band 5. chaeologica 24: 245–247. Berlin.
Spiess, Berlin. Bökönyi, S. 1991. Prehistoric animal remains from Bubanj-Hum
Becker, C. 1991. Die Tierknochenfunde von der Platia Magoula at Niš. Starinar XL–XLI, 1989/1990. Belgrade.
Zarkou – neue Untersuchungen zu Haustierhaltung, Jagd und Clason, A.T. (ed.), 1975. Archaeozoological studies. Papers of the archaeo-
Rohstoffverwertung im neolithisch-bronzezeitlichen Thessalien. zoological conference 1974, held at the Biologisch- Archaeologisch Institute
Prähistorische Zeitschrift 66/1: 14–78. of the State University of Groningen. Amsterdam, North Holland/
Biegel, G., ed., 1986. Das erste Gold der Menschheit – Die älteste Zivili- American Elsevier.
sation in Europa. Freiburg. Comşa, E. 1989. Le développement socio-économique en territoire
Binford, L. 1981. Bones. Ancient Men and Modern Myths. Academic roumain pendant l’Enéolitique. Prehistorica XV-XIV. Interna-
Press, New York. tionales Symposium, Univerzita Karkova. Praha. 115–120.
Boessneck, J. 1956. Zu den Tierknochen aus Neolitischen Siedlung- Davis, S.J.M. 1987. The Archaeology of Animals. London: Yale Univer-
en Thessalien. Berichte der Römisch-Germanischen Kommission 36: 1– sity Press.
51. Degerbøl, M og Fredskild, B. 1970. The urus [Bos primigenius Bojanus]
Boessneck J., 1960. Zu den Tierknochenfunden aus der präkeram- and Neolithic domesticated cattle [Bos taurus domesticus Linné] in
ischen Schicht der Argissa-Magula, Germania 36, Heft 3/4, 336– Denmark: With a revision of Bos-remains from the kitchen middens: Zoo-
340. logical and palynological investigations. Det Kongelige Danske Vi-
Boessneck, J. 1962. Die Tierreste aus der Argissa-Magula vom präkeram- denskabernes Selskab, Biologiske Skrifter 17,1. København.
ischen-neolitikum bis zur mittleren Bronzezeit. Beiträge zur ur- und Driesch, A. von den, 1976a. A Guide to the Measurement of Animal Bones
frühgeschichtlichen Archäologie des Mittelmeer-Kulturraumes from Archaeological Sites. Peabody Museum Bulletin 1. Harvard:
2: 22–99. Leinen. Peabody Museum.
Boessneck, J., Müller, H.-H. & Teichert, M. 1964. Osteologische Driesch, A. von den, 1976b. Die Tierreste aus der Agia Sofia-Magula in
Unterscheidungsmerkmale zwischen Schaf (Ovis aries Linné) Thessalien. Beiträge zur ur- und frühgeschichtlichen Archäologie
und Ziege (Capra hircus Linné). Kühn-Archiv, Band 78. Berlin. des Mittelmeer-Kulturraumes 15: 15–54. Bonn.
Ss. 1–129. Driesch, A. von den, 1987. Haus- und Jagdtiere im vorgeschicht-
Boessneck, J. & Driesch, A. 1979. Neue Tierknochenfunde aus der Magu- lichen Thessalien. Prähistorische Zeitschrift, 62/1:1–21.
Lı̂ga 139

Elenski, N. 1997. Kosteni idoli. Izvestiya na Istoricheskiya Muzei na ungen auf der Argissa-Magula in Thessalien, I. Das Präkeramische Neoli-
Veliko Turnovo XII: 81–90. tikum sowie die Tier- und Pflanzenreste. Bonn: Rudolf Habelt Verlag.
Georgiev, G. Merpert, N. 1979. Ezero: rannobronzovoto selishte. Sofia. Ninov, L. 1990. Animal bones from boreholes and Early Neolithic
Gimbutas, M. ed., 1976. Neolithic Macedonia: as reflected by excavation settlement near village Kovacevo. Studia Praehistorica 10: 197–
at Anza, Southeast Yugoslavia. Monumenta Archaeologica 1. The 200. Sofia.
Institute of Archaeology The University of California, Los An- Ninov, L. 2001. Zhivotnite ot praistoricheskoto selishte kraj s. Vek-
geles. sevo, biotopat im i izrabotenite ot tekhnite ostanki artefakti.
Gimbutas, M., Winn, S., Shimabuku, D. eds. 1989. Achilleion: a Čohadžiev, S., Vaksevo – praistoricheski selishta. Veliko Turnovo
Neolithic settlement in Thessaly, Greece, 6400–5600 BC. Monumenta Nobis, G. 1988. Ovcarovo-Gorata (Fauna). Studia Praehistorica 9:
Archaeologica 14. The Institute of Archaeology The University 37ff. Sofia.
of California, Los Angeles. Noe-Nygaard, N. 1987. Taphonomy in Archaeology with Special
Grayson, D.K. 1978. Minimum Numbers and Sample Size in Ver- Emphasis on Man as a Biasing Factor. Journal of Danish Archaeol-
tebrate Faunal Analysis. American Antiquity 43:53–65. ogy 6: 7–26.
Grayson, D.K. 1979. On the Quantification of Vertebrate Archae- Payne, S. 1975a. Partial Recovery and Sample Bias. In Clason,
ofaunas. In: Schiffer, M.B., 1979, ed., Advances in Archaeological A.T. 1975, ed., Archaeozoological studies: 7–17. Amsterdam.
Method and Theory 2: 199–237. Academic Press, New York. Payne, S. 1975b. Faunal Change at Franchthi Cave from 20,000
[Schiffer, M.B., 1979, ed., Advances in Archaeological Method B.C.–3000 B.C. In Clason, A.T. 1975, ed., Archaeozoological
and Theory 2: 199–237. Academic Press, New York.] studies: 120–131. Amsterdam.
Grayson, D.K. 1981. The Effects on Sample Size on Some Derived Payne, S. 1985. Zoo-Archaeology in Greece: A Reader’s Guide. In
Measures in Vertebrate Faunal Analysis. Journal of Archaeological Wilkie, N.C. & Coulson, W.D.E., 1985, eds., Contributions to Aege-
Science 8: 77–88. an Archaeology: Studies in Honor of William A. McDonald: 211–44.
Greenfield, H.J. 1986. Paleoeconomy of the Central Balkans (Serbia): A Minneapolis.
Zooarchaeological Perspective on the Late Neolithic and Bronze Age (ca. Raduncheva, A., Matsanova, V., Gatsov, I. 2002. Neolitno selishte
4500–1000 B.C.). B.A.R., International Series 304, Vols. 1 & do grad Rakitovo. Razkopki i Prouchvaniya 29. Sofia.
2. Reitz, E.J. & Wing, E.S. 1999. Zooarchaeology. Cambridge Manuals
Greenfield, H.J. 1989. Zooarchaeology and Aspects of the Second- in Archaeology. Cambridge.
ary Products Revolution: A Central Balkan Perspective. Zooar- Renfrew, C., Gimbutas, M. & Elster, E. S. (eds.), 1986. Excavations at
chaeologia, 3 (1–2): 191–200. Sitagroi. A prehistoric village in Northeast Greece, vol. 1. Monumenta
Halstead, P. 1989. The economy has a normal surplus: economic Archaeologica 13. The Institute of Archaeology The University
stability and social change among early farming communities of California, Los Angeles.
of Thessaly, Greece. In Halstead, P. & O’Shea J., 1989, eds., Ribarov, G. & Boev, Z. 1997. Kostni ostanki ot divi i domashni
Bad year economics: cultural responses to risk and uncertainity. Cam- zhivotni ot praistoricheskoto selishte ‘‘Telish-Redutite’’ pri s.
bridge University Press, Cambridge. Telish (Plevensko). Historia naturalis bulgarica, 7. 61–70.
Hansen, S., A. Dragoman, N. Benecke, J. Görsdorf, F. Klimscha, Sherratt, A. 1997. Economy and society in prehistoric Europe: changing
S. Oanţă-Marghitu & A. Reingruber. 2004. Berich über die perspectives. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Ausgrabungen in der kupferzeitlichen Tellsiedlung Măgura Todorova, H. et al., 1975. Selishtnata mogila Golyamo Delchevo.
Gorgana bei Pietrele in Muntenien/Rumänien im Jahre 2002. Razkopki i prouchvaniya V. Sofia.
Eurasia 10. Deutsches archäologisches Institut. Eurasien Abteil- Todorova, H. 1986. Kamenno-mednata Epoha v Bulgariya. Sofia.
ung. 1ff. Todorova, H. 1978. The Eneolithic Period in Bulgaria in the Fifth Milleni-
Hiller, S. & Nikolov, V. 1997. Karanovo. Die Ausgrabungen in Südsektor um BC. B.A.R. International Series 49.
1984–1992. Band 1. Salzburg und Sofia. Todorova, H., 1982: Kupferzeitliche Siedlungen in Nordostbulgarien. Ma-
Ivanov, S., & Vasilev, V., 1975. Prouchvane na zhivotinskiya kosten terialien zur Allgemeinen und Vergleichenden Archäologie,
material ot praistoricheskata selishtna mogila pri s. Golyamo Band 13. Verlag C.H.Beck München.
Delchevo. In: Todorova et al., 1975, Selishtnata mogila Golya- Tringham, R. & Bruckner, B., 1985. The Opovo Project: a Study
mo Delchevo. Razkopki i prouchvaniya V: 245–302. Sofia. of Socio-economic Change in the Balkan Neolithic. Journal of
Leshtakov, K., ed., 1997. Maritsa Project. Rescue archaeological Exca- Field Archaeology 12: 425–444.
vations along Maritsa Motorway in South Bulgaria. Vol. 1. Sofia. Vasilev, V. 1978. Sravnitelnı̂e issledovaniya roli zhivotnovodstva i
Lichardus, J. (ed.), 1991. Die Kupferzeit als historische Epoche. Symposium ohotı̂ dlya praistoricheskih poselenij Bolgarii. Thracia Praehistor-
Saarbrücken und Otzenhausen 6.–13.11.1988. Teil 1 und 2. Saar- ica, Supplementum Pulpudeva 3: 301–310.
brucker Beiträge zur Altertumskunde 55. Bonn. Wilkie, N.C. & Coulson, W.D.E. eds., 1985. Contributions to Aegean
Miljocić, V., et al. 1976. Die deutschen Ausgrabungen auf Magulen um Archaeology: Studies in Honor of William A. McDonald. Kendall Hunt
Larisa in Thessalien 1966: Agia Sofia-Magula, Karagyös-Magula, Bu- Publishing Co., Dubuque, Iowa Minneapolis.
nar Baschi. Beiträge zur ur- und frühgeschichtlichen Archäologie Wilson, B. 1996. Spatial Patterning among Animal Bones in Settlement
des Mittelmeer-Kulturraumes 15. Bonn: Rudolf Habelt Verlag. Archaeology. An English regional exploration. B.A.R., British Series
Milojcić, V., Boessneck, J. & Hopf, M. 1962. Die deutschen Ausgrab- 251.
XI. CEMETERY
INTRODUCTION nised as human. The grave pit was also only dis-
Seven graves (with eight bodies, all males and tinguished at its lower level.
children) were found in the southern half of the Lı̂ga Despite possible loss of information, this burial con-
settlement (Fig. XI.1 & Pl. 29) (1). Bone samples taken tained the richest grave goods as compared with the
from Grave no. 1 were AMS-dated by the Uppsala other burials. In the area of the chest were 5 tiny
laboratory. Calibrated, this burial is dated to ca. 4000 copper beads made of rolled-up copper sheet (Fig.
BC (Fig. II.12, II.13 & III.5). The scanty grave goods VI.16). Due to the presence of these beads it was de-
also support a final Copper Age date. Grave no. 1 cided to lift the grave in a metal frame with the inten-
was discovered in 2000, the remaining in 2001. tion of a more controlled excavation. In the area of
The age and sex of the skeletal remains (except the the chest was also found a zoomorphic bone idol
poorly preserved Grave no. 3) were determined by Y. made of pig metatarsus (Fig. IX.5; Pl. 28:1). Two
Yordanov (2) of the Bulgarian Academy of Science. rather big flint blades, perhaps representing cutting
In his report is noted that the adults have a medium tools, were discovered at the skull and at the feet,
to expressed massiveness of the post- and cranial respectively; these might also be associated with the
bones, and medium to strong relief, indicating a well- burial. During the cutting of the soil, when the metal
developed musculature. plate of the frame was pushed under the skeleton, a
Reconstruction of the burial arrangements was rounded shell ca. 2 cm in diameter and with a hole
complicated by the circumstance, that all graves were in the middle reaching almost 1 cm in diameter was
intrusive in relation to earlier Copper Age debris with discovered below the right hip. Unfortunately it was
very rich material remains. crushed in the process. The nasal bone of the child
had a greenish discolouration indicating perhaps a
vanished copper item.
GRAVE NO. 1. INFANT I, 7–8 YEARS It remains a mystery whether the only gold find
This burial of a child was found 0.65 m below the at the site – a pendant with rolled up terminals, and
surface at the southern slopes of the site in an oval hence interpreted as a phallic symbol – can be as-
grave pit of 0.93¿0.72 m, intersecting the outer west- sociated with the grave (Fig. VI.17). It was found in
ern wall of House 1. The skeleton was orientated N- loose soil close to the grave but a few days after the
S, the head being in the S with a slight eastern devi- burial was recognised. All the soil around the skel-
ation (159 æ/360 æ N). The body was placed in supine eton in the demarcated area of 2¿2 m was being
position with flexed legs, the head lying on the left collected separately for flotation. Thus, the attention
side facing WNW (Fig. XI.2 & XI.3). The legs were invested in the excavation of the grave and the fact
contracted on the left side and the arms collected on that it was only superficially excavated before being
the abdomen. The dead child was placed on a nat- taken out in the metal frame speaks against direct
urally deposited layer of pebbles. Unfortunately, the association with the gold find. The pendant has
burial was only recognised when the top of the skull raised many speculations not only due to its uncer-
became visible. Situated in an area with abundant tain association, but also its uncertain and possibly
remains of animal bones, the higher lying fragmented late date. However, the form and manner in which
bones of the underarm were not immediately recog- the pendant is produced can also be found in a
group of copper pins known from Late Copper Age
sites (Todorova & Vaisov 2002). Such a pin has been
1. The graves were recorded together with Petar Zidarov.
discovered in the neighbouring Redutite settlement
2. The author is very grateful to Prof. Yordan Yordanov, Institute
of Experimental Morphology and Anthropology, Sofia for (Gergov 1987).
undertaking anthropological investigations of the recovered The skeleton was exhibited in its frame at the Na-
bone material from the graves. tional museum in Sofia in 2000 (in connection with
Lı̂ga 141

Fig. XI.1. Photo of graves during the excavation process, view from the West.

the official visit to the country by the Queen of child was bearing traces of an artificial deformation
Denmark). On that occasion, Yordanov inspected the made by a single ribbon bound behind the coronal
skeletal remains and concluded that the skull of the suture (Yordanov, pers. comm.).
142 Acta Archaeologica

lection and arrangement at the bottom of the grave


pit. The biggest density of shards was observed below
the head and the upper part of the body. Beyond the
southern edge of the burial pit two postholes were
seen, each measuring 0.17 m in diameter, the distance
between them being 0.32 m. The postholes are quite
shallow in relation to the burial, just some 0.16 m
deep as measured from the level of the skull and
therefore their temporal association with the grave is
not certain. The preservation of the bones is very
poor with high fragility and surface erosion. The
upper part of the skull has been cut-off by ploughing.
It should be noted that all teeth of the skeleton,
including the frontal ones, show very heavy wear,
with exposed dentine. The heaviest attrition is seen
on the premolars and the molars of the mandibula,
their buccal edges being abraded away. These traces
would indicate, that the teeth were actively exploited
Fig. XI.2. Drawing of Grave no. 1 prior to its lifting in a metal
as a tool for a purpose which demanded chewing,
frame. The lower part of the skeleton is covered with soil contain-
ing pieces of burned daub. Strong lines mark pottery shards stem- pulling and tracking while the molars were kept
ming from house debris of Lı̂ga 2. A coherent nodule of burned clenched. The cranial walls were twice as thick as
wattle is marked with oblique striation. those of the other individuals, reaching 0.8 cm.
Thickened cranial walls were one of the indications
of an artificial cranial deformation in Grave no. 1.
GRAVE NO. 2. ADULT MALE However, the poor preservation of the cranial bones
This person was buried in a flexed (hocker) position, of the present grave does not allow any conclusion on
on the right side and with the knees tightly contracted this account.
at the chest, the hands collected and placed under the No recognizable grave-gifts were found in the
head (Fig. XI.4). The grave was discovered 0.47 m grave, although it might be assumed that a bone idol
below the present surface, its orientation being N-S, made of a pig metatarsal bone found 1.20 m NE of
the head orientated towards the N with a slight devi- the burial might be associated with this (Pl. 28:2). The
ation towards the E (25 æ/360 æ N, following the main same type of idol was discovered in Grave no. 1.
axis, connecting the top of the skull with the middle
point of the pelvis); the face was facing West. The
burial was found in an oval pit with maximum dimen- GRAVE NO. 3. INFANT I, 4–6 YEARS
sions of 1.10 (N-S)¿0.82 (E-W) m. The burial is in- The dead person is an Infant I, according to the den-
trusive in relation to the Copper Age settlement and tition of 6 years; however, the size of the humerus,
was placed in the area between two dwelling struc- 134 mm, corresponds to an individual of 3.5–4.5
tures (Houses 2 and 3). A large amount of flint chips years (Bass 1987). The skeletal remains were found
was collected during the excavation, indicating pro- 0.49 m below the present surface (Fig. XI.5).
duction and re-sharpening of flint tools in the area This burial was almost totally destroyed by plough-
during the time of the Lı̂ga 2 settlement. The skeleton ing as refelected by wavy depressions, one of which
seems to have been placed on top of a layer of rather was exactly overlapping the skeleton, as seen in the
large ceramic shards. The shards originate from dif- profile. The position of the legs is not known. The
ferent vessels (all could be recognized as stemming traces of the other bones (a few fragments of skull and
from Lı̂ga 2 assemblages) and their even distribution mandibula, outlines of the right humerus, part of the
underneath the skeleton points towards deliberate col- right radius and three ribs) indicate a flexed position
Lı̂ga 143

Fig. XI.3. Grave no. 1.

Fig. XI.4. Grave no. 2.


144 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. XI.5. Grave no. 3.

with the right hand placed under the head. The as- The skeletal remains were fairly well preserved, not
sumed orientation of the head is N-NW. The grave is taking into account the missing upper part of the
intrusive in relation to cultural debris of the Lı̂ga 2 skull, parts of the pelvis bones, and ribs and feet.
settlement. A bone plate was discovered as the only grave gift
(Pl. 28:11). This was located beneath the left hand
on the breast, placed upside down, i.e., the decor-
GRAVE NO. 4. INFANT I, 1–11⁄2 YEARS ated face towards the ground. It was rectangular in
The skeletal remains of this child were discovered shape (measuring 7.4¿3.8 cm, the thickness being
0.53 m below the surface. The body was lying in a 0.25 cm) and decorated with evenly spaced dots sur-
flexed position, the legs being bent and contracted at rounded by circles. The reconstructed corner holes
the front until the line of the pelvis (Fig. XI.6). The indicate that it was used as a breast-plate. Although
child was placed on the right side, the right hand the described type of punched decoration makes its
under the head, the left hand bent and placed over wide appearance during the Bronze Age, a pendant
the right one. The burial was found in an oval pit with similar decoration is known from Cucuteni
with maximum dimensions of 0.80 (NNE-SSW)¿ (Schmidt 1932). Similar bone plates, sometimes
0.60 (NNW-SSE) m. The dead was orientated to- supplemented with anthropomorphic heads, are not
wards the N, with a slight eastern deviation (25 æ/ unusual in Late Copper Age contexts and are re-
360 æ N, following the main axis, connecting the top corded from Karanovo VI levels, e.g., Merdžumeki-
of the skull and the pelvis); the face was turned to- ja at Drama, and other sites (Sidéra 1997). Breast-
wards the West. The grave pit was dug through the plates are also occasionally found in graves (Todoro-
outer wall of House no. 2 of the Lı̂ga 2 settlement. va & Vajsov 2002).
Lı̂ga 145

Fig. XI.6. Grave no. 4.

GRAVE NO. 5. INFANT II, 8–9 YEARS upper part of the body. The first set was found 0.68
The outline of this grave pit was visible 0.35 m below and 0.49 m E of the grave. The set at the head was
the surface, immediately beneath the ploughing layer. just 11–12 cm North of this. The western set of post-
The skeletal remains appeared at a depth of 0.48 m. holes was 0.50 m from the skeleton. A single posthole
The dead child was placed in flexed position (tightly was found 0.09 m from the feet. The state of preser-
drawn-up hocker), the legs being bent and fully con- vation of the main part of the bones was rather good,
tracted (to the chest) (Fig. XI.7). The body was lying despite the shallow depth. Several ribs were eroded,
on the right side, both hands bent and pressed to the or displaced, like the upper part of the skull.
chest, both wrists turned towards the claviculae. The The only recognizable burial gift was a cattle horn,
orientation of the skeleton is N-S, with a small devi- 14.5 cm long with a maximum width of 5.5 cm (Fig.
ation towards the E (the head is towards the N), XI.8). Both the proximal and the distal end of the
24 æ/360 æ N. The face was turned towards the West. horn were framed by two vertically placed pottery
The maximum dimensions of the oval pit was 1.04 shards, almost like bed-posts. The horn was situated
(N-S)¿0.62 (E-W) m. The skeleton was dug into cul- 7 cm to the N-NW of the skull, with the pointed end
tural debris of the Lı̂ga 2 settlement at the inter-struc- towards the head. The horn was otherwise following
tural space between Houses 2 and 3. The burial car- the orientation of the skeletal remains.
ried traces of special marking: three pairs of postholes, A particular aspect is the presence of intrusive hu-
6–8 cm in diameter, were surrounding the area of the man bones in association with the grave, most prob-
146 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. XI.7. Grave no. 5.

ably due to displacement by ploughing (Fig. XI.9). 360 æ N, following the main orientation line, con-
0.07–0.10 m from the maxilla, in northwestern direc- necting the top of the skull and the pelvis. The face
tion, was a left adult clavicula. 0.10 m in northwestern was turned towards the West. The outline of the
direction from the right tibia was the proximal end of burial pit was not clear, albeit it could be recognised
an adult radius with totally fused epiphysis. None of through a looser soil structure and a slightly darker
the excavated adult specimens were lacking these coloration in the western periphery of the grave.
bones. Somewhat higher, an occurrence of small particles of
charcoal was observed around the bones and espe-
cially in the area around the sternum when compared
GRAVE NO. 6. JUVENILE MALE, 18–19 YEARS with the surrounding soil. The preservation of the
These skeletal remains of a young man were discover- bones was very good. All bones were present and in
ed 0.76 m from the surface. The body was placed in anatomic order. The only exception was the phal-
a flexed position, legs bent and contracted until the anges of the left hand and of the left foot, which were
line of the pelvis. The body was laid to rest on the detached from their original place due to post-depo-
right side, hands bent and collected below the ster- sitional disturbances.
num so that the underarm of the right hand was per- The burial deposits include 8 dentalium shells (Fig.
pendicular to the axis of the spinal column, while the XI.11) in a row and a polished bone pendant
left hand embraced the upper part of the right hand (2.0¿1.5 cm) made as an imitation of a red deer
(Fig. XI.10). The orientation of the dead was N-S, the tooth, the so-called Grandel (Pl. 28:10). The pendant
head towards N, with a slight eastern deviation, 40 æ/ was in the middle of the row of dentalium shells,
Lı̂ga 147

Fig. XI.8. Cattle horn found in Grave no. 5.

forming a rather tight necklace (Fig. XI.12). All shells


and the pendant were found under the mandible or
between the mandible and atlas.

GRAVE NO. 7A–7B. ADULT MALE,


25–30 YEARS & INFANT I, 11⁄2 YEARS
This is a double grave containing an adult male and
a small child (Fig. XI.13, 14). The grave was dis-
covered 0.80 m below the surface. The adult body
was placed in a supine flexed position. The legs Fig. XI.9. Drawing of Grave no. 5, with specification of discovered
bones.
were bent and originally the knees were pointing
upwards, calves and haunches forming and angle of
some 45 æ with 0.13–0.14 m between the heels. In a
course of decay, the legs had fallen down to the child to a lesser degree those of the adult. All the
right side. The left arm was contracted and the principal bones of the skeleton of the adult were
hand placed on the manubrium (the top part of the found in anatomical order. There is a seeming dis-
sternum). The right arm was contracted to the right placement of the bones of the left leg, where the dis-
shoulder, which, from below and above, was holding tance between the distal end of the femur and the
the head of the child. The head of the adult was proximal end of the tibia is 0.15 m. The displacement
laid on the right side, facing the child, and West. occurred in the process of decay, when the vertically
The child was buried in a flexed position on its right placed flexed legs had fallen to the right side. The
side, the upper part of the body lying on the chest, bones of the child are disturbed. The hipbones were
the legs bent. The left leg was contracted till the line found 0.30 m from each other, the sacrum 0.25 m to
of the pelvis bones (forming a 90 æ angle with the the SW of the right hipbone. Also the teeth carry
spinal axis), while the right leg was slightly contrac- signs of post-depositional disturbances, found scat-
ted, forming a 135 æ angle with the spinal axis. The tered in the area of the mandible and the neck. One
hands of the child were placed under the head, tooth was found close to the left hipbone, which was
which was also turned towards the West. The child the northernmost bone belonging to the skeleton of
was placed at the right side of the adult. the child. Post-depositional disturbances were also at-
All bones were well preserved, but the bones of the tested through the presence of one metatarsus and
148 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. XI.10. Grave no. 6.

few phalanges belonging to another adult found close with a retouch at the proximal end and utilisation
to the child’s right femur. traces on the lateral edge. 0.02 m South of the right
Yordanov estimates the height of the adult to be patella was a flint blade, which association with the
between 165.78 cm (after the formula of Pearson-Lee) burial is not certain, however. Under the right scap-
and 174.29 cm (the formula of Trotter-Gleser). The ula of the adult, close to the right humerus, was a
atrition of the masticatory teeth of the adult is deter- dentalium shell, 2.7 cm long. The only burial gift of
mined to be of 3rd degree, i.e., a strong attrition the child was a rather loose double necklace of shells,
reaching the pulp chamber. For the same adult, a where each pair of dentalium was separated from the
pathology of the vertebral column was established, subsequent one by a cardium shell (Fig. XI.15).
manifested in spondylosis and spondilo-chondrosis of Both skeletons were placed on a layer of shards.
the articular surfaces. The less ordered distribution of the shards does not
Several animal bones were found in the grave, the indicate obvious intentionality, but the high concen-
majority being of Bos Taurus (Fig. XI.13). A part of tration together with the fact that the shards belong
these bones was close to the adult human bones, a to different vessels speak in favour of a built layer, in
cattle calcaneaus at the bones of the right foot. 0.04 fact a mat. The layer was more compact in the area
m South of the neck vertebrae was a molar of young of the legs and feet of the adult.
cattle. A massive cattle rib was crossing both the left Finally, a dozen shells of the Zebrina Detrita spe-
human ulna and the radius in the medial area. It is cies (as reported by N. Andreasen, Copenhagen &
probable that these bones were part of the burial in- Cambridge universities, in 2001) were collected from
ventory. At the 2nd lumbar vertebra of the adult, on Graves nos. 6 and 7. These shells were discovered
the southern side, was a 5 cm long flint end-scraper everywhere in the excavated area, although mostly in
Lı̂ga 149

Fig. XI.12. Grave no. 6, reconstruction of necklace.

Fig. XI.11. Dentalium and cardium shells discovered in Graves


Nos. 6 (upper row) and 7B (lower row).

tially staggered, so that Grave no. 5 was slightly be-


hind Grave no. 2, yet in a more westerly position
the lower layers, belonging to the Lı̂ga 1 settlement, than Grave no. 2. The remaining burials were also
and should not be considered as intentional depo- organised in this manner, Grave no. 7 being behind
sitions in the graves. Grave no. 4, and Grave no. 6 behind the destroyed
Grave no. 3. The distance between the rows was
limited. Only 0.36 m was separating the grave pits of
CONCLUSIONS Graves nos. 4 and 7. A similar distance was observed
All graves were discovered in the southern to south- between the Graves nos. 2 and 5.
western part of the Lı̂ga hillock. The regular distri- Despite the fact that several fragments of human
bution allows the area to be interpreted as a formal bones were discovered in sondages nos. 7 and 6B of
burial ground or cemetery, consciously chosen for the the excavation, Graves nos. 2, 3 and 4 were marking
purpose. Except for Grave no. 1, the graves were or- the northern edge of the burial ground. Grave no.
ganized in both longitudinal and latitudinal rows. 5 was the easternmost grave, and Grave no. 1 the
Graves nos. 3, 4 and 5 were forming a frontal line of southernmost. In 1979, during sounding work at the
burials organized along an E-W axis. These graves site, skeletal remains of a child were found (V. Gergov,
were remarkably evenly spaced. Measuring from the pers.comm.). Nobody realized the significance of the
presumed centres of the skulls, the distance between find, then. The said skeletal remains were presumably
Graves no. 3 and 4 was 3 m, the distance between discovered in ‘‘Trench II’’ (‘‘Izkop II’’). During the re-
Graves no. 4 and 5, 3.20 m. (Similar results are excavation of this trench, two cranial bones of a child
achieved by measuring the distance in a straight line were discovered, indicating that the western borders
from the humerus to the border of the next grave pit, of the burial ground are probably somewhere in area
i.e., 2.40 m and 2.36 m. The humerus was the only of ‘‘Trench II’’. Thus, it is possible to predict that the
bone of Grave no. 3 with a fully preserved outline). burial ground originally was occupying an area of 120
The distance between the burial pits of Graves nos. 4 m2, with a predicted number of graves at 25.
and 5 was 2.22 m. Graves nos. 6 and 7 are forming One important question remains unsolved, namely
the next row of burials, orientated E-W and confirm- the burials of the females, made ever more acute since
ing the latitudinal spatial organisation of the burials. children were interred with adult men. Possibly, the
The distance between Graves nos. 6 and 7 was ca. 2 explanation lies in regulation of burial space between
m, as measured from the centres of the skulls (skull the sexes, women being buried in a separate part of
7B, child, of the double grave). the Lı̂ga cemetery. Such interesting division is, e.g.,
The protrusive position of Grave no. 2 demon- observed in the Copper Age cemetery at Târgovište,
strates that the burials were also organised in a longi- also in an old settlement (data, Angelova 1991), where
tudinal manner, following the N-S direction but par- 11 graves were discovered. Among these, four were
150 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. XI.13.Graves nos. 7A-B.

identified as male and four as female, lying in two grouped regularly around the skeleton, demonstrate
separate clusters. that the place and position of the dead were held in
Thus, at Lı̂ga, affiliation with a gender-defined la- respect.
bour group was more important to stress in death, Despite some 400 years, which temporarily separ-
than the family-groups evident in the highly individ- ate the last Copper Age settlement and the establish-
ual households of this egalitarian society. The ment of the burial ground, the position of the graves
children are likely of the same sex as the adults they was clearly influenced by the structural debris of Lı̂ga
are accompanying, thus the boys with men. 2. Thus, the burial pit of Grave no. 1 was dug
It is uncertain whether the two big postholes found through the outer western wall of House 1. Graves
at the rear end of Grave no. 2 are related to the nos. 3 and 4 were intersecting the outer southern wall
burial, while the association of the sets of smaller post- of House 2. The latter graves, together with neigh-
holes with Grave no. 5 is certain. The latter posts, bouring Graves nos. 2 and 5, had the smallest depth
Lı̂ga 151

Fig. XI.14. Upper part of Graves nos. 7A–B.

below the present-day surface, not exceeding 0.50 m. of whether this number was higher or lower at the
It is known from other Copper Age burial grounds, end of the Copper Age, house mounds formed of
like Varna and Durankulak, that differentiation in burned daub were distinguishable for several centur-
depth was used to reflect status, gender and age (To- ies. Hence, it can be assumed that the collapsed house
dorova 2002). In the case of Lı̂ga, another factor was walls of the Lı̂ga 2 settlement created prominent
seemingly also playing a part. points in the terrain, which were selected for burials.
The terrain after the abandonment of the Lı̂ga 2 Later impact has levelled the terrain to its present
settlement was sculptured by disintegrating walls of state. Thus, the depths of the graves at Lı̂ga bear wit-
burned houses, which eventually formed house ness to the level of the ancient surface and can hardly
mounds. Through field work in Southern Mexico and be considered a reflection of social differences among
southwestern Iran, M. & A. Kirkby have actually the dead.
demonstrated that the disintegration process of mud The above observations should perhaps be applied
houses has a certain pace and can even be used as a to other Copper Age sites where insufficient obser-
means of dating (Kirkby & Kirkby 1976). Thus, in vations are limiting understanding of the proper re-
the Oaxaca valley, with 500–700 mm annual rainfall, lations between graves and dwellings, mainly the issue
the house mounds survive with recognisable profiles of intermural burials versus formal deposition sites
for 500–800 years. Lower precipitation rates signifi- (Bojadžiev 2001). Thus, V. Mikov notes that at the
cantly prolong the period of survival. The present Kubrat (Balbunar) tell in NE Bulgaria, where 25 skel-
yearly precipitation in NW Bulgaria is 500–600 mm etons were found, the majority of the burials concen-
(as measured during 1950–1990 (GHCN)). Regardless trated in the area with remains of destroyed houses
152 Acta Archaeologica

were also used in the graves, bucrania, for example,


is an important token in both houses and burials
(Hodder 1990; Todorova 2002). Following this line of
argument, it is natural to assume that the arrange-
ment of wooden poles around Grave no. 5 acted not
only as a marking but also as an enclosure, indeed, a
metaphoric house. In the same grave was a cattle
horn, likely a replacement of the deer antlers of the
Mesolithic as a most valued agent within the symbolic
and ritual sphere (cf. Tilley 1996). Nevertheless, the
red deer is not entirely removed from the symbolic
repertoire. In Grave no. 6 was a bone pendant in
Fig. XI.15. Grave no. 7B, reconstruction of necklace.
imitation of a red deer tooth. The tooth is a Grandel,
a rudimentary upper canine (caninus) of the male red
deer (Cervus elaphus), which never erupts and thus
(Mikov 1927, cited by Bojadžiev 2001). Based on the preserves its pearlwhite colour (Todorova 2002, 187).
uniformity of the treatment the dead, it can be argued The practice of imitation is well-known from the Late
that the site was used as a formal burial ground and Copper Age Varna I burials (Todorova 2002). Both
therefore should be separated in time from the settle- imitation and real teeth are here found in association
ment. with male burials (Todorova 2002).
Despite the temporal congruence between the Two graves at Lı̂ga contained necklaces made of
settlement and the burials, an apparent link exists be- shells. The necklace of Grave no. 6 combined a bone
tween the two. The burials should be seen as reflec- pendant and dentalium shells (Fig. XI.11, 12). The
tions of the same ideas that governed the spatial or- child of Grave no. 7A-B had a double necklace com-
ganisation of the settlement, similarity being observed prised of dentalium and cardium shells (Fig. XI.11,
in the matching N-S orientation of the dwellings and 15). The relative ages of the dentalium shells actually
the burials, and in the uniform and regulated spacing correspond to those of the accompanying humans:
patterns. In addition, the cemetery arrives as a virtual tiny, not fully grown juvenile representatives with the
Lı̂ga 3 ‘‘settlement’’. Such translation of the principles child, while the dimensions of the dentalium shells
applied for establishing settlements into the sepulchral found in the grave of the young adult are significantly
sphere is challenging strictly functional interpretations bigger, reaching 30¿9 mm. Dentalium shells are esti-
of settlement organisation, which have been criti- mated to be a rather costly item in the graves of Dur-
cized, e.g., by J. Brück and M. Goodman (Brück & ankulak and Varna (Todorova et al. 2002, 185). They
Goodman 1999). The idea of a conceptual affiliation might be collected in the Mediterranean and prob-
between houses and burials, as seen through their ably the Black Sea close to Bosporus (Todorova
architectural similarity, has also been cultivated in 2002). In the region of Pleven are several outcrops
NW Europe for quite some time (Milisauskas 1978; with fossils of different geological periods (Granch-
Hodder 1984; 1990). Evidence of interrelatedness be- arov 1999). The most readily available deposits are
tween realms of the living and the dead is thus found found at the village of Opanets (with a possible Cop-
in SE Europe too, albeit in a rather circumstantial per Age settlement), where fossilized dentalium (of
manner. Miocene date) can be collected on the surface (as re-
Connections between houses and burials have ported by N. Zidarov, Director of the Institute of Ge-
lately been attested at Durankulak, where the stone ology, Sofia). This source lies less than 25 km from
architecture of this multi-layered settlement was par- Lı̂ga. Malacological analysis has, however, proved a
alleled in graves covered or framed with stone slabs recent marine origin of the dentalium shells, which
(Todorova 2002). Besides echoing the orientation of were not affected by a long process of fossilization (N.
the houses, certain elements of the domestic inventory Andreasen, Copenhagen and Cambridge universities,
Lı̂ga 153

2001). Whether of eastern or southern origin, these hence the separation of the child compared to the
shells are found at considerable distance from their other dead persons discovered at Lı̂ga: no doubt a
natural source. Even the cardium shells included in testimony to a growing complexity of society, which
the necklace of the child of Grave no. 7A–B, were may even have encompassed hereditary positions.
juvenile (1.2¿1.4 cm). Part of the umbo was inten- Skull deformations gain an even wider distribution in
tionally ground away and a small hole created for the Early Bronze Age: thus, 14 of the 36 skulls dis-
threading. This type of marine shells is more wide- covered in the burials of the Grave-Pit culture in Bul-
spread and might have been collected anywhere in garia have traces of changes in the morphology of the
the Black Sea and the Mediterranean (Todorova skull, conducted through the same one-ribbon
2002, 186). method (Yordanov & Dimitrova 1989).
In terms of treatment of the dead, no apparent dif-
ferentiation can be noted, as might have been ex-
pected from the data in NE Bulgaria, in casu the fam- BURIALS IN THE KSB CULTURE AND THE
ous Varna graves. The only striking exception is ‘‘TRANSITIONAL PERIOD’’
Grave no. 1. The two AMS-dates (based on bone col- Despite the surprising Lı̂ga discovery, the absence of
lagen), giving a late Copper Age date, are both from burials in the area occupied by the KSB culture re-
this grave, so it is possible that the remaining graves mains unresolved; the same can be said of the Thra-
(with another orientation) are of a different, likely cian plain, densely dotted with tell settlements. This is
later date, possibly the ‘‘Transional Period’’ (3). If so, in stark contrast with NE Bulgaria, where large burial
they are contemporary with the nearby Redutite IV grounds, along with smaller deposition sites at the
settlement. The relative proximity of the burials, to- settlements, have produced several thousands of
gether with the whole grave material, allows for a graves. Y. Bojadžiev lists nine localities with regular
holistic view, however. burial grounds and two sites with possible intra-mural
The exclusiveness of the young dead person in burials in the NE part (including the coastal areas) of
Grave no. 1 is stressed by the ‘‘reverse’’ southern Bulgaria (Bojadžiev 2001). In the Thracian plain,
orientation (the head still facing West, though) and there are only two known burial sites, so far, both
the comparative richness of the grave gifts, as well as containing multiple Late Copper Age skeletal re-
the artificial deformation of the skull, even though the mains, Okrazhna Bolnitsa in Stara Zagora (three skel-
practice of deformation during the Copper Age was etons) and Yunatsite at Pazardžik (Bojadžiev 2001).
not unusual and commonly applied towards the end In NW Bulgaria, graves associated with Copper
of the period (Yordanov & Dimitrova 2002). Hence Age remains were found in the Devetaki Cave. The
almost 11% (23) of all skulls studied (mostly frag- temporal position of the earliest skeletal find of 1926 –
mented) at Durankulak and attributed to the Middle the body being placed in a flexed position – is not
and Late Copper Age have traces of morphological known with certainty (Gaul 1948). During an exca-
changes of the one-ribbon circular type (Yordanov & vation in 1952, burials of four children were recorded,
Dimitrova 2002). Perhaps the child of Grave no. 1 loosely attributed to the Copper Age (Boev 1959). Re-
originated in Eastern Bulgaria. peated excavations in the cave in the 1990s have pro-
In Anatolia and other Near Eastern regions, where duced one more child burial, which held pottery typi-
artificial deformation is widespread in the Neolithic, cal of the KSB culture (Gergov, pers. comm.).
the practice is interpreted as the result of a need for The Yugoslavian data on burials in the area of the
ethnic markers in an expanding system of communi- KSB culture are even more penurious than in Bulgaria.
cation and exchange (Özbek 2001). The distribution The only grave, which can be associated with the KSB
of the phenomenon is tightly clustered in the Near culture, was discovered in 1967 at Lepenski Vir (Letitsa
Eastern region. Skull deformations in Bulgarian 1972). It was the burial of a female, 40–60 years old
graves should probably also be seen as exceptions, and 1.54–1.56 m tall, dug into an area occupied by nu-
merous Mesolithic and Early Neolithic burials. The
3. Further samples will be submitted for dating later. skeleton was found orientated N-S (163 degrees), with
154 Acta Archaeologica

the head towards the S. The dead person lay in a prone males are usually found in a stretched supine position
position and on the face, with backwardly crouched (Todorov 1986), even though a right hocker has oc-
legs. The Lepenski Vir grave was dated on the basis of casionally been applied. In Lı̂ga, all bodies rested on
four vessels characteristic of the KSB culture. One of the right side, in flexed positions of varying degrees.
these vessels, a big bowl (destroyed prior to the depo- Two of the bodies (Graves nos. 2 and 5), one of which
sition), was almost completely covering the legs, a fea- was determined to be a male by Yordanov, were even
ture typical of Gumelniţa burials. post-mortally bound in an extreme flexed position,
Records of the Romanian burial material related with the knees pressed towards the breast.
to the KSB culture is also very limited. With some The coastal areas of Bulgaria have been defined as
reservation, three single child burials from as many divergent in terms of burial practices, when compared
sites, Bãile Herculane (Nikolova 1999, 55), Vadastra, to the sites of the inland (Todorova 1986, 2002). The
and Orlea (Letitsa 1972), can be attributed to the governing principle in the inland ever since the Neo-
latest phase of the culture. The same can be said of lithic was to bury the dead in a flexed position on the
two burial grounds, Ostrovul Corbului at the Iron left side, the head orientated towards the East (Todo-
Gates and Drãganeşti-Olt at Corboaica (Nikolova rova & Vajsov 1993). Almost without exception, such
1999, 57, 58 & 359 ff.). 51 graves were discovered at rules of burial were recorded in the Copper Age
Ostrovul Corbului, dominantly with bodies in a flex- burial grounds at Golyamo Delcevo, Ovčarovo, Poly-
ed position on the left side and orientated towards the anitsa, Radingrad, and others, all in the NE part of
East (Nikolova 1999, 57, 58 & 359 ff.). The presence the country (Todorova 1986).
of Bodrogkeresztur pottery among the grave goods In this light, the ritual behaviour recorded at Lı̂ga
dates these burials at least 100–200 years later than poses interesting questions about cultural traditions.
Grave 1 from Lı̂ga (Forenbaher 1993). Similar rites The investigations at Durankulak have demonstrated
were employed in the somewhat later burial ground that throughout the whole Copper Age a northern
of Drãganeşti-Olt, with 9 skeletons (Nikolova 1999, orientation was dominant, and that the shift from a
57 & 363). northern to an eastern orientation (in flexed position
on the left side) only took place with the emergence,
even the arrival, of novel social groups during the
RELATIONS WITH THE COAST so-called Transitional Period (termed ‘‘Proto-Bronze
In general, the Lı̂ga graves demonstrate close ties with Age’’ by I. Vajsov) (Vajsov 2002,159 ff). Hence, the
the burial traditions known in the coastal areas of Bul- burials at Lı̂ga might be seen as witnesses to the ar-
garia, despite a temporal difference: the last Copper rival in the Northwest of people with affiliation to the
Age burials in the East being dated to ca. 4200 BC, coastal areas. Or, if preferred, they can be viewed,
as at Durankulak (Todorova 2002, 61ff). In all known neutrally, as regionally specific elements of the KSB
burial grounds – Varna, Devnya, and Durankulak, as cultural package. The presently available material
well as Lı̂ga – a northern orientation of the skeletons does not allow any conclusive generalisations con-
dominates. A flexed position on the right side is pre- cerning the rites of the KSB, although the parallel to
vailing among female burials (Todorova 1986). The the East is evocative.
XII. CONCLUSIONS
FACTUAL SUMMARY the present. The earliest occupation – Lı̂ga 1 – is dat-
The archaeological Late Copper age site of Lı̂ga is ed to the beginning of the Late Copper Age. Traces
situated about one kilometre north of the modern vil- of this settlement were only established in some parts
lage of Telish in Cherven Briag Municipality, Pleven of the excavated area. Remains of one dwelling were
County (Fig. I.1). Nearby, 1.2 km south of the site, recorded on the southern fringes of the site. This
lies another famous site from the same period known structure was supported by a wattle frame, resting on
as Redutite. This contained three building horizons of massive timbers. It was 7.6 m long, the estimated
the Copper Age and one of the so-called Transitional internal space being 39–40 m2. The orientation of the
Period. The research objectives for Lı̂ga were to a dwelling was N-S. At the SE corner of the house was
high degree dictated by the excavations at Redutite, part of a regular stone pavement made of water-worn
supplemented by information from Sadovec-Gole- well-sorted cobbles of sandstone and brown flint (Fig.
manovo Kale and Pipra sites. These data were con- II.5). The pottery from the house had dark lustrous
sidered a good starting point for building-up a local surfaces, often painted with graphite and occaionaly
sequence of land-use at Lı̂ga, and, most importantly, with red and yellow pigmens (Pl. 6:1–7), in this sharp-
for tracing movements of peoples and ideas. So far, ly contrasting the generally light pottery of the follow-
the majority of settlement investigations in Western ing phase. The Lı̂ga 1 settlement was abandoned for
Bulgaria have produced a mass of isolated phenom- reasons as yet unknown.
ena, coupled up merely with the help of particular Around 4400 BC (calibrated) a new settlement –
types of artefacts. A different situation presented itself Lı̂ga 2 – was established at the site. Level terraces
around Telish, with an opportunity to produce and were created on the remains of the Lı̂ga 1 dwellings,
to piece together evidence into coherent historical se- causing severe destruction of the debris of the pre-
quences, resembling those of the southern area of Bul- vious occupational phase. The archaeological exca-
garia (with the impressive tells). In this light, issues vations at Lı̂ga were concentrated on the material
such as spatial organisation, changes in the planning vestiges of this settlement. Three dwellings were fully
of settlement and its architecture, duration and causes investigated. Their identification was uncomplicated
of abandonment, etc. could be set in a broader tem- due to the settlement was burned down, and reddish
poral and geographical perspective, revealing the burned daub clearly outlined the structures. In the
‘‘dialectics’’ of a Late Copper Age settlement. northern part of the excavated area, numerous lime-
The site of Lı̂ga is situated at the edge of a broad stones were discovered, displaying a semi-circular or
plateau, 20 m high, 195 m above sea level (Fig. I.2 & oval pattern. Stones in such configurations obviously
I.3). The Redutite site is located on the same plateau. belong to structural features, in fact house founda-
Towards southwest and northeast the plateau has a tions, even when lacking preserved burned daub.
wavy appearance. The hillock chosen for the Lı̂ga House 1 was discovered almost exactly on top of
settlement is deliminated by ravines in the south and the house from the previous occupational phase. With
north, created during seasonal runoff of water. At the a slight deviation towards the East, it even followed
foot of the site there used to be stream, presently a the orientation of the earlier construction (Pl. 2). The
system of three dams known as the Lake of Gorni size was 6.50¿5.70 m, the internally available area
Dabnik. In all, 275 m2 were excavated, excluding sur- 28.3 m2. House 2 is perhaps the one, which applies
vey trenches. The depth of the excavated trenches the best to a supposed standard, since a partly exca-
varied between 0.5 and 1.2 m. The excavation strat- vated neighbouring house had a similar length (Pl. 1).
egy was aimed to concentrate on few areas where the External dimensions of House 2 are 7.4¿6.0 m, the
archaeological contexts could be investigated fully internal area being 34.5 m2. House 3 was the longest
and at great detail (Fig. XII.1). As a result, it has been among the investigated houses (Pl. 1). It was 8.45 m
established that the site was in use several times until long and 5.90 m wide in the middle part (external
156 Acta Archaeologica

Fig. XII.1. Working at Lı̂ga, view from the East.

lengths). The internally available area was 37.80 m2. lected for a cemetery with several burials. In the exca-
The houses were orientated N-S. Except for House vated area alone, seven graves have been discovered,
1, the uncovered remains indicate that usually the en- one grave holding remains of two individuals.
trance was in southern wall, while the oven of the During the Early Bronze Age, the excavated area
house stood at the northern wall. was part of a marginal activity zone for a settlement
The western part of the Lı̂ga site was left unoccu- higher up on the plateau. The occupational debris of
pied. During Lı̂ga 2, the slopes of the hillock were this was partly overlapping with the eastern limits of
made steeper by a shallow ditch or trench (0.8 m the Lı̂ga 2 settlement, as has been established through
deep), an arrangement intended to inhibit movement drillings. Besides scattered pottery shards, found dur-
up and down the slopes, thus perhaps made to protect ing the excavation, one pit is with certainty attributed
livestock, kept in the 500–550 m2 unoccupied area. to the EBA, Orlea-Sadovec culture. Another pit, in-
Sounding of the terrain established that the houses of tersecting House 3, contained vessels of Early Iron
Lı̂ga 2 were occupying an area of ca. 50¿55 m. The age Basarabi culture. This pit is dated to 875 BC.
total area with burned remains of buildings extended Some materials from Lı̂ga are attributed to the Late
over ca. 1900 m2 (Fig. II.1). Antiquity.
The Lı̂ga 2 settlement was abandoned after the con- Material recovered from the Lı̂ga site was subjected
flagration. The proximity of C-14 and AMS dates to several specialist studies. Pottery investigations
available from Redutite and Lı̂ga implies that soon (Chapters IV & V) demonstrated a great degree of
after the abandonment of the Lı̂ga 2 settlement a new individuality in pottery production, questioning estab-
settlement was established at Redutite – Redutite II. lished chronology. Ceramic sets from widely different
The abandonment of the Lı̂ga site lasted until ca. 4000 periods of the Copper Age, according to traditional
BC. At that time, the southern part of the site was se- chronology, were found in contemporary houses.
Lı̂ga 157

Fig. XII.2. Comparative chronological table. KSB Ia – the Krivodol-Sălcuţa-Bubanj Hum Ia cultural complex, KGK – Kodžadermen-
Gumelniţa-Karanovo cultural complex, LN – Late Neolithic, FN – Final Neolithic, TN – Early Neolithic, MN – Middle Neolithic.

Flint studies (Chapter VII) revealed reliance on both The original aspiration was to arrive at an under-
local but also regional sources of flint. Research on standing of the the ‘‘Copper Age Gap’’, the ephem-
ground stone tools (Chapter VIII) shows that these eral period of transition to the Bronze Age. But
were as important as flint and bone tools. Bone arti- gradually it was acknowledged that the Copper Age
facts (Chapter IX) demonstrate the amplitude of con- proper held the key to an understanding: a period
cepts applied to bone as medium for answering both following upon the Neolithic, but powered to become
utilitarian and non-utilitarian demands. Finally, im- a historical shortcut which – if it had been successful –
portant in understanding past economies, the animal would have created a totally different European de-
bones (Chapter X) show a stress on sheep/goat but velopment in the fourth millennium BC (Fig. XII.2).
also cattle as being a vital source of subsistence. The excavations at Lı̂ga were at first regarded as
the crucial bit of evidence, which, when pieced to-
gether with regional data – including the neighbour-
PERSPECTIVES ing site of Redutite – would provide data to bridge
The main challenge of the Lı̂ga project has been to the ‘‘Gap’’. Contrary to expectations, Lı̂ga has instead
carry out highly detailed excavations producing a become a cornerstone anchoring data and studies, not
huge data-set, other fieldwork, analyses, and studies least the still unpublished material from Redutite.
of the available archaeological data from the Telish Through a context orientated research programme,
region in Northern Bulgaria during the Late Copper with maximum focus on details, new standards have
Age of the fifth millennium BC; this in order to create been set for future projects in the area. Although very
a historical perspective on a general cultural process. time consuming (1.3 tonnes of ceramic sherds were
In addition, very may other studies in and out of Bul- analyzed, for example), such a strategy has provided
garia were accomplished. a new basis for understanding daily life in a Late Cop-
158 Acta Archaeologica

per Age settlement and – through this – detected and support of this are the few studies on paleoecology
explained the main currents of regional socio-econ- related to the Copper Age conducted in Bulgaria so
omic development and thereby even larger processes. far. For instance, palynological evidence collected
Several archaeological periods are represented at from Pirin Mountains in South-western Bulgaria (be-
Lı̂ga, but the fullest account was achieved in the longing to the KSB area) points towards seasonal up-
layers of Lı̂ga 2. This settlement provided testimony land pasturage beginning in the Copper Age (Stefano-
on a community, which possessed the operational in- va & Bozilova 1995).
struments to organize its members into viable cooper- Distribution maps of KSB sites show that these
ative networks ensuring day-to-day survival. This de- were located on routes of ancient communication, de-
pendence on fellow members is manifested by the termined by passages across the Balkans. Emphasis
uniform layout of the nucleated settlement, resem- on geographical setting is clearly demonstrated by the
bling most of all the hutments of a military camp. remains of Roman roads, which used the same localit-
Bigger houses reflect bigger households and are not ies to build their strongholds and road stations in or-
openly aimed to undermine the communal equality. der to protect traffic. Telish, as attested through the
Arenas for rivalry and competition – so to say – were remains of Late Roman strongholds at Sadovec and
created inside the houses, for example by various Pipra, was situated at a very cross-roads, which later
forms of display of graphite painted pottery. From the on, in Roman times (as also today), led along the Iskar
outside, all structures might well have looked the River to the Oeskus (at Gigen, where the Romans
same: clay houses with dull grey walls likely undecor- built a bridge across the Danube in 328 AD) in the
ated. North and to Serdica (Sofia) in the South, to Mon-
It has been demonstrated that proliferation of tech- tana in the West and to Storgozija (Pleven) in the
nological variability in pottery production is a reflec- East, and from there on to mighty Philippopolis
tion of new modes of networking, based on, and with (Plovdiv) in the southeast (Neikov 2001).
implications for, the economic orientation. The tra- The high degree of mobility in the Lı̂ga-societies
ditional archaeological approach to the Copper Age can even be observed from the flint where a high 18%
in the Balkans views the Krivodol-Sălcuţa-Bubanj of the tools are from localities more than 30 km away.
Hum (KSB) Ia-complex’s open settlements (in the Analyses of 16 copper items from Redutite show that
West) in contrast to the tells in rich plains of the Kod- these come from 15 different sources (Pernicka et al.
žadermen-Gumelniţa-Karanovo VI group (in the 1997). One of the awls is probably from the Majdan-
East). A main achievement of the present study is that pek-region in Eastern Serbia, also under influence
such settlement strategies should not be viewed as ex- from the KSB-complex.
cluding and opposing each other, but as parallel in Higher mobility required a more complex settle-
nature. In terms of social complexity, sense of terri- ment system, which even encompassed five different
toriality, and settlement arrangements they exhibit types of settlements in the Telish area, from fortresses
and stem from a common background. to permanent open settlements like Lı̂ga and caves
By shifting from the easily tillable plains to exploi- used only temporarily. By contrast, the patterns of
tation of new and varied environments, wholly differ- settlement in areas dominated by tells, e.g. around
ent requirements were set on these innovative and the Polyanitsa Tell in NE Bulgaria (Todorova 1982),
symbolically intelligent communities, recognised as demonstrate close range networking between several
the bearers of the KSB-complex (cf. Sherratt 1980). coexisting settlements within a distance rarely exceed-
A point, which has also been developed in the present ing five km. The contemporary KSB sites are not
study is that animal husbandry (mainly sheep/goat spaced that densely; instead the settlers were relying
but also cattle) was increasing in importance over on a system of strongholds and refuge places and bas-
time, from being merely a supplement to agriculture ing their networking on regionally remote alliances.
to an equally vital source of subsistence. Animal hus- They were thus delineating a structure characteristic
bandry would inevitable lead to increased mobility of much of Europe in the fourth millennium BC and
and, likely, to a regular practice of transhumance. In later.
Lı̂ga 159

Detachment from ground-water agriculture (cf. and even migration along the alliance routes, likely
Sherratt 1980) was the one factor which first of all towards the North. Significantly, Central Europe is
provided the higher flexibility of the bearers of the seeing marked growth almost everywhere, eventually
KSB-complex – the last of the Copper Age groups – also in metallurgy, in the fourth millennium BC, while
thus preparing them for the changes that caused the the ‘‘Copper Age Gap’’ signals a decline in South-
termination of the Copper Age: Likely climatic Eastern Europe.
worsening, decline in population, perhaps warfare
PLATES

Plate 1. Sector 2. Plan of archaeological remains. L2 – Lı̂ga 2 (CA), L3 – Lı̂ga 3 (CA), L4 – Lı̂ga 4 (EBA), L5 – Lı̂ga 5 (EIA), R – recent
disturbance. 1 – Layer of compact daub, 2 – Layer of less compact daub, 3 – Layer with loose particles of daub, 4 – Mixed artefacts: shards,
animal bones and stones, 5 – Layer of charcoal, 6 – Traces of wattle.
Lı̂ga 161

Plate 2. Sector 1. Plan of archaeological remains. L1 – Lı̂ga 1 (Late Copper Age), L2 – Lı̂ga 2 (Late Copper Age), L3 – Lı̂ga 3 (Late Copper
Age), LA – Late Antiquity/Lı̂ga 6; p – posthole of undetermined date, later than L1 & L2, R – recent disturbance. 1 – Layer of compact
daub, 2 – Layer of less compact daub, 3 – Layer with loose particles of daub, 4 – traces of calcinated wood, 5 – mixed artefacts: shards,
animal bones and stones, 6 – remains of oven.
Plate 3. Profile drawings of the central area of Sector 2 and of the Southern wall of Sondage 8A. Debris accumulated in this sondage held the most complete information
on the earliest settlement, Lı̂ga 1, including remains of a lime plastered floor destroyed by later construction. 1 – humus layer, dark brown, h2 – older humus layer containing
charcoal, brown black, 2 – layer of naturally deposited pebbles, 3 – layer of clay and coarse sand with moderate amounts of organic matter, dark grey; very compact
(original surface of the plateau), 4 – layer of clay mixed with gravel, grey (together with Layers 2 and 3Ωthe original surface), 5 – layer of grey clay, like 3, but without
coarse sand, therefore interpreted as anthropogenically created, i.e., transported clay for house foundations, medium to light grey, 6 – layer of compact burned daub, red
to orange, 7 – like 6, but less compact, 8 – mixed layer of humus, burned daub, animal bones and shards: house debris (note the dashed line which marks the floor level),
brown reddish, 9 – like 8, but with higher contents of humus, 10 – layer of domestic waste with high contents of ashes, light grey, 11 – clay-rich layer, firm, abundant
organic matter and lime, with small (1–2 mm) particles of charcoal containing finds attributed to Lı̂ga 1, light grey, 12 – posthole, attributed to Lı̂ga 1, medium grey, 13 –
blackish spots, clay rich with high content of organic matter, possibly traces of wooden beams, 14 – sandy silt loam, light grey, 15 – layer no 11 mixed with humus layer
(layer no 1), 16– layer of burnt organic matter, grey black, 17 – clay loam with high content of lime, loose, grey whitish, 18 – remains of lime plastering (floor level of Lı̂ga
1 structure, Sondage 8A), 19 – lime rich layer, grey yellow, 20 – posthole, consisting of fill from layers nos. 8 and 11 mixed with organic matter, post-Lı̂ga 2 date (indicated
by presence of particles of burnt daub), 21 – layer (pit), consisting of fill from layer no. 8 mixed with layer no. 11, post-Lı̂ga 2 in date, 22 – stones, 23 – pottery shards.
ST – survey trench 1979, R – Recent disturbance, L4 – Bronze Age pit (Lı̂ga 4), L5 – pit interpreted as ritual and attributed to the Early Iron Age (Lı̂ga 5).
Lı̂ga 163

Plate 4. Example of a section plan produced with Total Station (A), and as hand drawing (B). The area includes Sondages 5, 7, 6A & 6B –
mainly House 2.
164 Acta Archaeologica

Plate 5. Floor level at the E part of House 4 (Sondage 4G). Signaturec: cross – bone, right striation – limestone, x – flint blade, dashed line –
profile balk.
Lı̂ga 165

Plate 6. Examples of pottery from Lı̂ga 1 settlement (1–7) and pottery recovered from Lı̂ga 2 settlement (8–21), varying provenience.
166 Acta Archaeologica

Plate 7. Pottery from House 1.


Lı̂ga 167

Plate 8. Pottery from House 2.


168 Acta Archaeologica

Plate 9. Pottery from House 2.


Lı̂ga 169

Plate 10. Pottery from House 3.


170 Acta Archaeologica

Plate 11. Pottery from House 3.


Lı̂ga 171

Plate 12. Pottery from House 3. 1–3 – pottery with incised decoration, 4–17 – pottery with graphite painted decoration.
172 Acta Archaeologica

Plate 13. Comparative arrangement of pottery from Houses 2 & 3.


Lı̂ga 173

Plate 14. Scheme of typological ordering of shapes of vessels discovered in Lı̂ga 2 settlement. Bowls and their derivatives.
174 Acta Archaeologica

Plate 15. Scheme of typological ordering of shapes of vessels discovered in Lı̂ga 2 settlement. Biconic vessels with cylindrical necks.
Lı̂ga 175

Plate 16. 1–19 – Small and miniature vessels from Lı̂ga 2 settlement (7 – possibly a template for biconic cups, see Pl. 6:21); 20–24 – lids;
26 – vessel rim; 26–29 – pot stands and a lower part of a footed vessel; 30–32 – clay pans. 13–14 – miniature vessels from the Late Copper
Age site at Sadovec-Golemanovo Kale (after Todorova 1992).
176 Acta Archaeologica

Plate 17. 1 – milk strainer; 2–3 – vessels with zoomorphic representations; 4–6 – clay spoons; 7–8 – clay zoomorphic figurines; 9 – model of
oven; 10–11 fragments of crucibles (no. 10 contained copper deposits at the bottom); 12–16 – spindle whorls; 17–19 – clay beads; 20–21 –
abraded pottery shards.
Lı̂ga 177

Plate 18. Fragments of anthropomorphic clay representations, all of Lı̂ga 2 settlement. 1 – 9024 (internal numbering system of finds at Lı̂ga,
given here for reference), 2 – 9427, 3 – 8000, 4 – 10654, 5 – 2001/127, 6 – UN005/9A, 7 – 9405, 8 – 2001/4, 9 – 4040, 10 – 9005, 11 –
9086, 12 – 9022.
Plate 19. Distribution chart of fragments of anthropomorphic representations (1) and small table-like devices (2). Numbering stems from the
system applied during excavations. Fragments nos. 14000, UN005/9A, and 2001/127 are of unknown or uncertain contexts. Weak proveni-
ence has been established for items nos. 2000/15 & UN009/9B, therefore, their position is only specified as to sondage. Numbers in white
correspond to house numbering. a – scale applied for fragments, b – scale applied for the background plan, 3 – Late Copper Age houses,
4 – place of oven inside Lı̂ga 2 houses, 5 – graves, 6 – destructions of post-Copper Age date.
Lı̂ga 179

Plate 20. Representations of table-like devices and fragments of such, nos. 1 & 2 of Lı̂ga 2 settlement, no. 3 – of Lı̂ga 1 settlement. – No. 1 –
42026 (internal numbering system of finds at Lı̂ga), 2 – 9001, 3 – 2001/250.
180 Acta Archaeologica

Plate 21. Fragments of representations of table-like devices, all of Lı̂ga 2 settlement. – No. 1 – 4625 (internal numbering system of finds at
Lı̂ga), 2 – 10659, 3 – 14000, 4 – 2000/15, 5 – 9028.
Lı̂ga 181

Plate 22. Flake and blade tools, including scrapers (1–6, 8), scraper with concave working edge (7), knives (9, 10–11) & retouched crested
blade (knife?) (12).
182 Acta Archaeologica

Plate 23. Flint (1–18) and stone tools (19–20), including heavy pointed tool (a large borer?) (1), sickle-blades with gloss (2–5), borers (6–8),
exhausted core (9), knives (10–14), scraper (15), part of a pointed biface (16), biface knife (17), and an arrow head (18). Stone tools: digging
implement (?) (19), and rubbing stone (20).
Lı̂ga 183

Plate 24. Items of stone (1–6) and clay (8), including hammerstone (1), stone hammers (2–4), pounders (5–6), sling stone (7) and ‘‘sling stone’’
of clay (8).
184 Acta Archaeologica

Plate 25. Some ground stone tools, including combination tool (1), adze (2), different types of axes (3–8), and chisel (9).
Lı̂ga 185

Plate 26. Lı̂ga 1 – Various objects. Bevel-edged tools on long bone splinter (1) and cattle ulna (4); unfinished object/debitage on antler tine
(2); pointed tool on long bone splinter (3); side-scraping tool on boar’s tusk (5); and, flat anthropomorphic figurine (6).
186 Acta Archaeologica

Plate 27. Lı̂ga 2 – Various tools. Pointed tools on metapodium of small (1–2) and large ungulates (7, 9); pointed tools on long bone splinters
(3, 5); manufacture waste from production of pointed tool on metapodium of small ungulate (4); haft for metal tool on metatarsus of small
ungulate (6); and, antler haft/sleeve (8).
Lı̂ga 187

Plate 28. Lı̂ga 2 and 3 – Non-utilitarian finds and body ornaments. Prismatic figurines of pig metapodium (1–2), side-flattened sheep (3–5),
and, cattle (12); astragals with (3, 5) or without (4, 12) incised decoration or stringing hole (3); palmar flattened phalanxes of small ungulates
(6–8, 13); unworked incisivus of large ungulate (9); imitation of red-deer canine bead made on long bone splinter, from Grave no. 6 (10);
decorated pectoral on rib, from Grave no. 4 (11); unidentified worked bone object, possibly manufacture waste from production of flat
figurine (14).
Plate 29. Distribution of graves in Sector 2.
GENERAL BIBLIOGRAPHY

Alexandrov 1992/Alfkraneqoc, R., 1992: O ktl}stqnoj Danube, à la lumière des nouvelles fouilles faites en Roumanie.
vaqaksfqirsikf komplfkra «OqlÄ – Raeocfw». Studia Böhm, J., De Laet, S., eds., L’Europe à la fin de l’âge de la pierre.
Praehistorica, 11-12. Sofia. pp. 358–361. Actes du Symposium consacré aux problèmes du Néolithique européen.
Alexandrov, S., 1996: The Early Bronze Age in Western Bulgaria: Prague-Liblice-Brno 5–12 octobre 1959. Praha. pp. 101–124.
Periodization and Cultural Definition. Bailey, D.W., Panayotov, Berciu D., 1961b: Les nouvelles fouilles de Sălcuţa (Roumanie) et
I., eds., Prehistoric Bulgaria. Monographs in World Archaeology le problème des groupes Bubanj (Yougoslavie) et Krivodol (Bul-
No. 22. Prehistory Press. pp. 253–270. garie). Böhm, J., De Laet, S., eds., L’Europe à la fin de l’âge de la
Angelov 1958/Andfloc N., 1958: Rflizna modila pqi r. pierre. Actes du Symposium consacré aux problèmes du Néolithique euro-
Vosniwa. Rboqnik ihrlfecaniÄ c xfrs na akae. péen. Prague-Liblice-Brno 5–12 octobre 1959. Praha. pp. 125–
E.Efxfc. RouiÄ. pp. 389–404. 135.
Angelov 1959/Andfloc N., 1959: Hlasno r{kqocizf os Vos- Berciu, D., 1961c: Contribuţii la problemele neoliticului in Romin-
niwa. AqvfolodiÄ, 1–2. pp. 38–46. ia in lumina noilor cercetări. Bucuresţi.
Angelov 1961/Andfloc N., 1961: Qabosilniwa ha plorki Boev 1959/Bofc, P., 1959: Palfoansqopolodixni pqotx-
korsni ieoli c rfliznasa modila pqi r. Vosniwa, caniÄ c B{ldaqiÄ. AqvfolodiÄ, kn. 3–4. pp. 46–54.
S{qnocrko. AqvfolodiÄ, 2. pp. 34–38. Bojadžiev 1994/BoÄegifc, `., 1994: Abrolsna vqonolodiÄ
Angelova, I., 1991: A Chalcolithic Cemetry near the Town of Târ- i pfqioeihawiÄ na b{ldaqrkasa pqairsoqiÄ. Pqoblfmi.
govište. Lichardus, J., ed., Die Kupferzeit als historiche Epoche: Doeiynik na Efpaqsamfns AqvfolodiÄ, NBT, s. 1.
Symposium Saarbrücken und Otzenhausen 6.–13.11.1988, Teil RouiÄ. pp. 249–254.
1. Saarbrücker Beiträge zur Altertumskunde 55. Bonn: Habelt. pp. Bojadžiev 2001/BoÄegifc, `., 2001: Podqfbalna pqaksika
101–105. intra muros pqfh nfolisa i valkolisa c b{ldaqrkisf
Arnold, D.E., 1985: Ceramic Theory and Social Process. Cambridge hfmi: obixaj ili ihklxfnif. AqvfolodiÄ, doe. XLII,
University Press, Cambridge. kn. 3–4. pp. 16–24.
Avramova 1992/Acqamoca, M., 1992: `doeinrkaÄ pfzfqa c Bonev & Aleksandrov 1996/Bonfc, A., Alfkraneqoc, D., 1996:
Wfnsqal}n|v Qoeopav. Sudia Praehistorica, 11–12. Sofia. pp. Badaxina. Rflizf os k{rnasa kamfnno-mfena fpova i
240–247. sqakijrki ktlsoc wfns{q (III-I vilÄeolfsif pq. Vq.).
Bailey, D., 1990: The Living Houses: Signifying Continuity. Sam- Monsana.
son, R., ed., The social Archaeology of Houses. Edinburgh: Edin- Bökönyi, S., Bartosiewich, L., 1997: Tierknochenfunde. Hiller, S.,
burgh University Press. pp. 19–48. Nikolov, V., eds., Karanovo. Die Ausgrabungen im Südsektor
Bailey, D., 1994: Reading Prehistoric Figurines as Individuals. 1984–1992. Bd. I.1 Text. Salzburg-Sofia. pp. 385–405.
World Archaeology, vol. 25:3. Taylor & Francis Ltd. pp. 321– Böhm, J., De Laet, S.J., eds., 1961: L’Europe à la fin de l’âge de la
331. pierre: Actes du Symposium consacré aux problèmes du Néolithique euro-
Bailey, D., 1996: The life, times and works of House 59, Tell Ovča- péen, Prague-Liblice-Brno, 5–12 octobre 1959. Praha.
rovo. Darvill, T., Thomas, J., eds., Neolithic houses in Northwest Bredwa-Mensah, Y., 2001: Historical-Archaeological Investigations
Europe and Beyond. Oxford: Oxbow. pp. 143–156. at the Frederiksgave Plantation, Ghana: A Study of Slavery and
Bailey, D., 1999: What is a tell? Settlement in the fifth millennium Plantation Life on a 19th Century Danish Plantation on the
Bulgaria. Brück, J., Goodman, M., eds., Making Places in the Pre- Gold Coast. University of Ghana, Legon. Unpublished doctoral
historic World. Themes in Settlement Archaeology. University of Cam- thesis.
bridge, UCL Press. pp. 94–111. Brück, J., Goodman, M., 1999: Introduction: themes for a critical
Bailey, D., 2000: Balkan prehistory: exclusion, incorporation and identity. archaeology of prehistoric settlement. Brück, J., Goodman, M.,
London: Routledge. eds., Making Places in the Prehistoric World. Themes in Settlement Ar-
Bánffy, E., 1997: Cult objects of the Neolithic Lengyel Culture. chaeology. University of Cambridge, UCL Press. pp. 1–19.
Connections and Interpretation. Archaeolingua, Series Minor 7. Canti, M.G., Linford, N., 2001: The Effects of Fire on Archae-
Budapest. ological Soils and Sediments: Temperature and Colour Re-
Bankoff, H.A., Winter, F.A., 1990: The Later Aeneolithic in South- lationships. Proceedings of the Prehistoric Society, vol. 66. pp. 385–
eastern Europe. American Journal of Archaeology, 94: 2. pp. 174– 395.
191. Carlton, R., 2002: Some comments on the Technology of Prehis-
Bass, W.M., 1987: Human Osteology. A Laboratory and Field Manual. toric Pottery in the Western Balkans in the Light of Ethnoar-
3rd edition. Missouri Archaeological Society. Columbia. chaeological Research. D. Gheorghiu, ed., Fire in Archaeology.
Bejlekchi 1978/Bfjlfkxi, C., 1978: Qannij ^nfolis nihoc- Papers from a session held at the European Association of Archaeologists.
}fc Pqtsa i EtnaÄ. Kiyinfc. Sixth Annual Meeting in Lisbon 2000. B.A.R. International
Berciu, D., 1961a: Chronologie relative du Néolithique du Bas Series 1089. pp. 63–81.
190 Acta Archaeologica

Chapman, J., 1981: The Vinča culture of South-East Europe: studies in Forenbaher, S., 1993: Radiocarbon dates and absolute chronology
chronology, economy and society. Oxford: British Archaeological Re- of the central European Early Bronze Age, Antiquity 67. pp.
ports. 218–220, 235–256.
Chapman, J., 2000: Fragmentation in archaeology. London Routledge. Garašanin, M., 1957: Ausgrabungen in Bubanj bei Niš (Serbisches
Chernysh 1965/Xfqn|y, F., 1965: Dlinobisn|f giliza Moravagebiet). Germania, Jahr. 35, Heft 3/4. pp. 198–207.
ktl}stq| Dtmflniwa c nignfm Poetnac}f. Nocof c ro- Garašanin, M., 1976: Zur Chronologischen und Kulturellen Wer-
cfsrkoj aqvfolodii. Morkca. pp. 84–86. tung der Bubanj-Funde. Jahrbuch des Römisch-Germanischen Zen-
Cosack, E., 1994: Vorgeschichtliche Feuerstülpen. Archäologisches tralmuseum Mainz. 26. Jahrgang. pp. 154–166.
Korrespondenzblatt 24 (3). pp. 319–323. Garašanin, M., 1983: Les sites archéologiques Bubanj et Velika Humska
Craig, O., Chapman, J., Figler, A., Patay, P., Taylor, G., Collins, Čuka. Catalogue. Nis.
M., 2003: ‘‘Milk jugs’’ and other myths of the Copper Age of Gaul, J.H., 1948: The Neolithic period in Bulgaria. Peabody Museum
Central Europe. Pearce, M., ed., European Journal of Archaeology, of Harvard University.
vol. 6.3. pp. 251–265. Georgiev & Angelov 1957/Dfoqdifc, D., Andfloc, N., 1957:
Curta, F., 2001: The Making of the Slavs. History and Archaeology Qahkopki c rfliznasa modila eo Qtrf pqfh 1950-1953.
of the Lower Danube Region, ca. 500–700. Cambridge: Cam- IhcfrsiÄ na AqvfolodixfrkiÄ inrsists, XXI.
bridge University Press. RouiÄ. pp. 41–129.
Čochadžiev, R., 1997/Xovaegifc, R., 1997: Rlasino – pqair- Georgiev et al. 1979/Dfoqdifc, D., Mfqpfqs, N., Kasinxaqoc,
soqixfrki rfliza. Cfliko S{qnaco. Q., Eimisqoc, E., 1979: Fhfqo. Qannobqonhocoso rfliz-
Čochadžiev, R., 2001/Xovaegifc, R., 2001: Cakrfco – pqair- sf. B{ldaqrka AkaefmiÄ na Natkisf. RouiÄ.
soqixfrki rfliza. Cfliko S{qnaco. Georgieva 1983/Dfoqdifca, B., 1983: Sipocf giliza.
Čochadžiev, S., 2003a: Settlement Pattern During the Neolithic FsnodqauiÄ na B{ldaqiÄ. Masfqialna ktlstqa, II.
and Copper Age in Struma Valley. Topography, Fortification RouiÄ. pp. 193–211.
and Building Techniques. Nikolova, L., ed., Early Symbolic Sys- Georgieva 1991/Dfoqdifca, Q., 1991: Obqfeni Ämi c SqakiÄ
tems of Communication in Southeast Europe. B.A.R. International (kqaÄ na II–I vil.pq.n.f.). AqvfolodiÄ, XXXIII: 1. pp. 1–
Series 1139. pp. 443-446. 15.
Čochadžiev, S., 2003b: Vorschriftliche Zeichen aus dem Früh- Georgieva, P., 1993: Galatin culture. Georgieva, P., ed. The Fourth
chalkolithikum in Westbulgarien. Nikolova, L., ed., Early sym- Millennium B.C. Proceedings of the International Symposium
bolic systems of communication in Southeast Europe, vol 1. Nessebur, 28–30 August 1992. Sofia. pp. 109–115.
BAR S1139. Oxford. pp. 113–118. Georgieva 1995a/Dfoqdifca, P., 1995a: Pqairsoqixfrkoso
David, N., Kramer, C., 2001: Ethnoarchaeology in Action. Cambridge rflizf pqi r. Nfdocanwi, Qaeomiqrko. Doeiynik na
World Archaeology. Cambridge University Press. RouiĭrkiÄ Tnicfqrisfs «Rc. Klimfns Ovqierki», 86,
Dzhanfezova, T., 2003: Neolithic Pintaderas in Bulgaria. Typology 1993. RouiÄ. pp. 5–25.
and Comments on their Ornamentation. Nikolova, L., ed., Georgieva, P., 1995b: The Settlement at Galatin-Čukata. Aspes,
Early symbolic systems of communication in Southeast Europe, vol 1. A., ed., Settlement patterns between the Alps and the Black Sea 5th to
BAR S1139. Oxford. pp. 97–108. 2nd Millennium B.C. Symposium, Verona – Lazise 1992. Verona:
de Barros, P., 1997: Ironworking and its Cultural Context. Vogel, Museo cinico di storia naturale. Milano: Università degli studi.
J., ed., Encyclopaedia of Precolonial Africa. Walnut Creek, pp. 35– pp. 87–91.
148. Gergov 1979/Dfqdoc C., 1979: Pqairsoqixfrki navoeki os
Dennell, R.W., Webley, D., 1975: Prehistoric settlement and land pfzfqasa pqi r. Mtrflifco, Plfcfnrki okq{d. Ihcfr-
use in southern Bulgaria, Higs, E.S., ed., Paleoeconomy, Cam- siÄ na mthfisf os Rfcfqohapaena B{ldaqiÄ, 3. Cqawa.
bridge, University Press, pp. 97–109. pp. 36–55.
Dimitrov 1979/Eimisqoc, C., 1979: Pqinor k{m opohnacanf Gergov 1987/Dfqdoc C., 1987: Mfeni navoeki os pqairso-
cieociÄ r{rsac na pqacokqilasa uatna c qajona na qixfrkoso rflizf c mfrsnorssa Qfetsisf pqi Sfliy,
Plfcfnrki okp{d. IhcfrsiÄ na mthfisf os Rf- Plfcfnrki okq{d. AqvfolodiÄ, XXVIII: 4. RouiÄ. pp.
cfqohapaena B{ldaqiÄ, 3. Cqawa. pp. 277–292. 44–48.
Dunbar, R., 1995: Neocortex size and group size in primates: a Gergov 1992a/Dfqdoc C., 1992a: Eoirsoqixfrkof porflfnif
test of the hypothesis. Journal of Human Evolution 28. pp. 287– Sfliy – Qfetsisf. Sudia Praehistorica, 11–12. Sofia. pp. 347–
296. 358.
Dunbar, R., 1996: Grooming, Gossip and the Evolution of Language. Fab- Gergov 1992b/Dfqdoc C., 1992b: Dlinfn olsaq os pqairso-
er and Faber, Harvard University Press. qixfrkoso rflizf pqi Sfliy. IhcfrsiÄ na mthfisf
Elster, E.S., 1986: Tripods, Plastic Vessels, and Stands: A Fragmen- os Rfcfqohapaena B{ldaqiÄ, 18. Cqawa. pp. 26–31.
tary Collection of Social Ceramics. Renfrew et al. 1986. pp Gergov 1994/Dfqdoc C., 1994: Pqairsoqixfrkoso rflizf
303–344. Sfliy – Qfetsisf i pqoblfma ha pqfvoea mfget fnfol-
Fletcher, R., 1992: Time perspectivism, Annnales, and the potential isa i bqonhocasa fpova c B{ldaqiÄ. Doeiynik na Ef-
of archaeology. Knapp, B., ed., Archaeology, Annales, and ethnohisto- paqsamfns AqvfolodiÄ, NBT, s. 1. RouiÄ. pp. 303–
ry. Cambridge University Press. pp. 35–49. 306.
Lı̂ga 191

Gergov, V. 1996: A dwelling of Telish IV. Early Bronze Age Settlement Hvass, S., 1985: Hodde. Et vestjysk landsbysamfund fra ældre jernalder.
Patterns in the Balkans (ca. 3500–2000 BC, calibrated dates), part 2. Arkæologiske Studier, vol. VII, København.
Reports of Prehistoric Research Projects, vol. 1, nos. 2–4. Sofia. Issar, A.S., 2003: Climate Changes during the Holocene and their Impact on
pp. 309–322. Hydrological systems. International Hydrology Series. Cambridge.
Gergov 2000/Dfqdoc C., 2000: Kfqamixni rsastfski na rfeÄ- Katinčarov et al. 1995/Kasinxaqoc, Q., E., Mfqpfqs, N., Si-
zi bodini os Sfliy – Qfetsisf. SqakiÄ i r{rfenisf soc, C., Mawanoca, C., Aciloca, L., 1995: Rflizna modi-
qaĭoni pqfh nfolisa i valkolisa. RouiÄ. pp. 101–105. la pqi r. _nawisf (Pahaqegiyko). S. 1. Adaso i Eior.
Gergov et al. 1986/Dfqdoc C., I. Dawoc, R. Riqakoca, 1986: RouiÄ.
Kqfm{xni oq{eiÄ os pqairsoqixfrkoso rflizf c Katsarov, G., 2003: Earlier Chalcolithic Decorated Pottery from
mfrsnorssa Qfetsisf pqi r. Sfliy, Plfcfnrki okq{d. Plovdiv-Yasa Tepe Tell. Nikolva, L., ed., Early Symbolic Systems
IhcfrsiÄ na mthfisf os Rfcfqohapaena B{ldaqiÄ, 10, for Communication in Southeast Europe. Vol. 1. B.A.R. International
pp. 11–20. Series 1139. pp. 209–239.
GHCN – www.worldclimate.com Kempton, W., 1981: The folk classification of ceramics: a study of cognitive
Gheorghiu, D., 2002: Fire and Air Draught: Experimenting the prototypes. New York. Academic Press.
Chalcolithic Pyroinstruments. D. Gheorghiu, ed., Fire in Archae- Kirkby, A. & Kirkby, M.J., 1976: Geomorphic processes and the
ology. Papers from a session held at the European Association of Archaeol- surface survey of archaeological sites in semi-arid areas. David-
ogists. Sixth Annual Meeting in Lisbon 2000. B.A.R. Interna- son, D.A., Shackley M.L., eds., Geoarchaeology. Earth Science and
tional Series 1089. pp. 83–94. the Past. Duckworth. pp. 230–253.
Gibson, A., Woods, A., 1997: Prehistoric Pottery for the Archaeologist. Kuzmanov, G., 1992: Die lokale Gefässkeramik. Uenze, Syna,
2nd edition. London: Leicester University Press. 1992: Die spätantiken befestigungen von Sadovec (Bulgarien):
Gimbutas, M., 1956: The Prehistory of Eastern Europe. Cambridge, Ergebnisse der deutsch-bulgarisch-österreichischen Ausgrab-
Mass.: Peabody Museum. ungen 1934–1937. Münchner Beiträge zur Vor- und Frühgeschichte,
Gimbutas, M., 1974: The Gods and Goddesses of Old Europe: Myths and 43. 2 bd. München: Beck. pp. 201–219.
Cult Images. London: Thames & Hudson. Larsen, N.G., 2003: Digital ReKonstruktion. Lyngstrøm, H., Stor-
Gimbutas, M., 1986: Mythical Imagery of Sitagroi Society. Ren- gaard, B., eds., Specialer fra Vandkunsten 1999–2003. København:
frew et al. 1986, pp. 225–301. Insttitut for Arkæologi og Etnologi, pp. 35–44.
Gimbutas, M., 1989: The Language of the Goddess. London: Hudson & Lazarova, M., Stefanova, I., 1997: A Palaeobotanical Investigation
Themes. in Harmanli Region. Maritsa Project. vol. 1. Sofia. pp. 243–244.
Gosselain, O., 1992: Bonfire of the enquiries. Pottery firing tem- Lazarovici, G., Lazarovici, M., 2003: The Neo-Eneolithic Architec-
peratures in archaeology: What for? Journal of Archaeological ture in Banat, Transylvania and Moldavia. Grammenos, D.V.,
Science. Vol. 19:3. pp. 243–259. ed., Recent Research in the Prehistory of the Balkans. Publications of
Grancharov, M., ed., 1999: Historical Museum – Pleven. Cata- the Archaeological Institute of Northern Greece, Nr. 3. Thessa-
logue. loniki. pp. 369-386.
Graves, M., 1991: Pottery Production and Distribution among the Lazić & Sladić 1997/Lahiå, M., Rlaeiå, M. 1997: Fnfolisrko
Kalinga: A Study of Household and Regional Organization and narfäf t Ykoeqinom poät koe Kãagfcwa. Lazić, M. ed.,
Differentiation. Longacre, W., ed., Ceramic Ethnoarchaeology. Tuc- Archaeology of Eastern Serbia. Symposium. Belgrade. pp. 211–221.
son: University of Arizona. pp. 112–143. Letitsa 1972. Lfsiwa, H., 1972: Dqob Ralktèa ktlstqf ra Lfp-
Görsdorf, J., Bojadžiev, J., 1996: Zur Absolute Chronologie der fnrkod Ciqa. Starinar, XXI, 1970. Beograd. pp. 117–126.
bulgarischen Urgeschichte. Berliner C-14 Datierungen von bul- Lemonnier, P., 1992: Elements for an anthropology of technology. Anthro-
garischen archäologischen Fundplätzen. Eurasia Antiqua, 2. pological Papers, Ann Arbor 88. Univerisity of Michigan.
Mainz. pp. 105–174. Matsanova 2000/Mawanoca, C., 2000: Insqamtqalni «podqf-
Hansen, O., 1961: Ungdommelige oldtidshuse. KUML. Aarhus. bfniÄ» os k{rniÄ valkolis c rfliznasa modila pqi
Hansen, A.M., 2000: Geological formation of the area around Tel- _nawisf, Pahaqegiyko. Kaqanocrki konufqfnwii ha
ish, Bulgaria. Field-report. pqairsoqiÄsa na Balkanisf, 1. SqakiÄ i r{rfenisf
Hayden, B., 1984: Are Emic Types Relevant to Archaeology? qajoni pqfh nfolisa i valkolisa. RouiÄ.
Ethnohistory 31(2). pp. 79–92. Mikov 1927/Mikoc, C., 1927: Rfliznasa modila pqi r. Bal-
Hodder, I., 1984: Burials, houses, women and men in the Euro- btnaq. IhcfrsiÄ na BaldaqrkiÄ aqvfolodixfrki in-
pean Neolithic. Miller, D., Tilley, C., eds., Ideology, Power and rsists, 4, 1926/1927. pp. 236–284.
Prehistory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 51–68. Mikov 1948/Mikoc, C., 1948: Pqfeirsoqixfrkoso rflizf
Hodder, I., 1990: The Domestication of Europe: structure and contingency eo Kqicoeol, Cqaxanrko. Qahkopki i pqotxcaniÄ, I.
in Neolithic societies. Oxford: Blackwell. Mikov 1966/Mikoc, C., 1966: Sfvnika na kfqamixnoso
Hodges, H., 1965: Aspects of pottery in the temperate Europe be- pqoihcoersco pqfh pqairsoqixfrkasa fpova c B{ldaqiÄ.
fore the Roman Empire. Matson, F., ed., Ceramics and Man. New IhcfrsiÄ na aqvfolodixfrkiÄ inrsists. XXIX.
York, pp. 114–123. B{ldaqrka akaefmiÄ na natkisf. RouiÄ. pp. 163–210.
Hänsel, B., 1976: Beiträge zur regionalen und chronologischen Gliederung Mikov & Džambazov 1960/Mikoc, C., Egambahoc, N., 1960:
der älteren Hallstattzeit an der Unteren Donau. Teil 1 (text) & 2. Bonn. Efcfsaykasa pfzfqa. RouiÄ.
192 Acta Archaeologica

Milisauskas, S., 1978: European Prehistory. New York: Academic Press. Pleinerová, I., 1986: Březno: Experiments with building old Slavic
Milwaukee Archaeological Research Laboratory 2003. Milwaukee houses and living in them. Památky archeologické, LXXVII.
Archaeological Research Laboratory, 2003: Pit Firing. Early Iron Prown, J.D., 1996: Material/Culture: Can the Farmer and the
Age Ceramic Project. University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee. http:// Cowman Still Be Friends? Kingery, W.D., ed., Learning from
www.uwm.edu/Dept/ArchLab/experimental/pitfiring_ Things: Method and Theory of Material Culture Studies. Washington:
2003.html Smithsonian Institution Press. pp. 19–27.
Mitova-Džonova 1979/Misoca-Egonoca, E., 1979: Aqvfolo- Rapp, G., 2002: Archaeomineralogy. Berlin (Springer).
dixfrki pamfsniwi c Plfcfnrki okq{d. RouiÄ. Rehhoff, I., Akkermans P., Leonardsen, E, Thuesen, I. 1990: Plas-
Mongait, A., 1959: Archaeology of the USSR. Moscow. ters: Gypsum or Calcite? A preliminary case study of Syrian
Naroll, R. 1962: Floor area and settlement population. American plasters. Paléorient: revue interdisciplinaire de préhistoire et de protohistoire
Antiquity, 27. pp. 587–589. de l’Asie du Sud-Ouest, vol. 16:2. Paris. pp. 79–87.
Neikov, H., 2001/Nfĭkoc, N., 2001: Pqfei 7000 doeini i Renfrew, C., Gimbutas, M. & Elster, E.S., eds., 1986. Excavations
rlfe soca – r. Sflny, Plfcfnrko. Plfcfn. at Sitagroi. A Prehistoric Village in Northeast Greece. Vol. 1.
Nikolov 1961/Nikoloc, B., 1961: Dq{nxaqrka pfz pqi r. Al- Monumenta Archaeologica 13. Los Angeles.
simiq. AqvfolodiÄ, 4. pp. 51–53. Rice, P., 1987: Pottery Analysis: A Sourcebook. University of Chicago
Nikolov 1970/Nikoloc, B., 1970: Ieolnasa plarsika os r. Press, Chicago.
Dqaefyniwa. AqvfolodiÄ, 4. pp. 56–67. Roman, P.I., 1976: Cultura Coţofeni. Bukureşti.
Nikolova, L., 1999: The Balkans in Later Prehistory. Periodization, Chron- Rye, O.S., 1976: Keeping Your Temper Under Control: Materials
ology and Cultural Development in the Final Copper and Early Bronza and Manufacture of Papuan Pottery. Anthropology and Physical
Age (Fourth and Third Millenia BC). With contributions by Ma- Anthropolgy in Oceania 11(2). pp. 106–137.
zura, I. & Schuster, C. BAR International Series 791. Sahlins, M., 1972: Stone Age economics. New York: Aldine de Gruyter.
Nikolov 1968/Nikoloc, B., 1968: Pqairsoqixfrkoso rflizf Schiffer, M., Skibo, J., 1987: Theory and Experiment in the Study
pqi r. Ovoefn, Cqaxanrki okq{d. AqvfolodiÄ, kn. 1. pp. of Technological Change. Current Anthropology, vol. 28:5. pp.
65–75. 595–619.
Nikolov 1974/Nikoloc, B., 1974: Dqaefyniwa. RouiÄ. Schmidt, H., 1932: Cucuteni in der oberen Moldau, Rumänien.
Nikolov 1975/Nikoloc, B., 1975: Haminfw. RouiÄ. Schwarzberg, H., 2003: On problems in identifying ritual pottery:
Nikolov 1984/Nikoloc, B., 1984: Kqicoeol-eqfcni ktlst- the example of the so-called ‘‘cult-tables’’. Nikolova, L., ed.,
qi. RouiÄ. Early symbolic systems of communication in Southeast Europe, vol 1.
Nikolov 1992/Nikoloc, B., 1992: PfqioeihawiÄ na nfolisn- BAR S1139. Oxford. pp. 79–84.
isf ktlstqisf c Rfcfqna B{ldaqiÄ. IhcfrsiÄ na mthf- Séfériadès, M., 1996: Deshayes’ Excavations at Dikili Tash: the
isf os Rfcfqohapaena B{ldaqiÄ, 18, Cqawa. pp. 11–23. Early Bronze Age levels. Nikolova, L., ed., Early Bronze Age Settle-
Nikolić 1998/NikoliÉ, E., 1998: Bflidoco – pqilod pqotx- ment Patterns in the Balkans (ca. 3500–2000 BC, calibrated cates).
caãt fnfolisrkiv ktlstqa irsoxnf Rqbiâf. Qae Eqa- Parts 2–3. RPRP Vol. 1, Nos. 2–4. Prehistory Foundation and
dorlaca Rqfâocixa na irsqagicaãt pqairsoqiâf Agatho Publishers. pp. 95–128.
Wfnsqalnod Balkana. Kqadtâfcaw. pp. 105–111. Shilov 1975/Yiloc, C., 1975: Eca podqfbfniÄ lisfjzikoc-
Orton, C., Tyres, P., Vince, A., 1993: Pottery in archaeology. Cam- mfsalltqdoc. RocfsrkaÄ aqvfolodiÄ, 1. Morkca. pp. 5–
bridge manuals in archaeology. Cambridge. 10.
Pasek 1965/Parfk, S., 1965: IrsoqiÄ plfmfn c V–III s|rÄxf- Sidéra, I., 1997: Rapport d’étude de l’assemblage osseux de Drama
lfsii eo n.~. na sfqisoqii Moleacii. Kqaskif roob- (Bulgarie). Bericht der Römisch-Germanischen Kommission, band 77,
zfniÄ Inrsistsa aqvfolodii AN RRRQ, c|p. 105. 1996. Mainz am Rhein. pp. 120–129.
Morkca. Sherratt, A., 1980: Water, soil and seasonality in early cereal culti-
Pasek & Chernysh 1963/Parfk, S., Xfqn|y, F., 1963: vation. World Archaeology 11:3. pp. 313–330.
PamÄsniki ktl}stq| ltnfjno-lfnsoxnoj kfqamiki na Sherratt, A., 1983: The Eneolithic period in Bulgaria and its Euro-
sfqisoqii RRRQ. Rcoe aqvfolodixfrkiv irsoxnikoc pean Context. Poulter, A.G., ed., Ancient Bulgaria. Nottingham.
RRRQ, B1–11. Sherratt, A., 1987: Cups That Cheered: The Introduction of Alco-
Pernicheva 2002/Pfqnixfca, L., 2002: RfeÄzi gfnrki ui- hol to Prehistoric Europe. Waldren W., Kennard R.C., eds.,
dtqki os valkolisnoso rflizf Okol Dlaca (DnilÄnf), Bell Beakers of the Western Mediterranean. BAR International. Series
Rouijrko. Doeiynik na aqvfolodixfrkiÄ inrsists 287. Oxford.
i mthfj – BAN, 2, 112–119. Skibo, J.M., 1992: Pottery Function. A Use-Alteration Perspective. New
Pernicka, E., Begemann, F., Schmitt-Strecker, S., Todorova, H., York: Plenum.
Kuleff, I., 1997: Prehistoric copper in Bulgaria. Its composition Skibo, J. Butts, T.C., Schiffer, M.B., 1997: Ceramic Surface Treat-
and provenance. Eurasia Antiqua: Zeitschrift für Archäologie, bd. 3. ment and Abrasion Resistance: An Experimental Study. Journal
Mainz am Rhein. pp. 41–178. of Archaeological Science 24. pp. 311–317.
Petkov 1964/Qfskoc, N., 1964: Dq{nxaqrka pfz os fnfolis- Stanko 1997/Rsanko et al., 1997: EacniÄ ársoqiÄ Tkqaàni.
noso rflizf pqi r. D{l{bocwi, Rouijrki okq{d. som 1. Ktàc.
AqvfolodiÄ, 1. pp. 48–60. Stark, M., Clark, J., Elson, M., 1995. Causes and Consequences of
Lı̂ga 193

Migration in the 13th Century Tonto Basin. Journal of Anthropo- Kulturen zwischen 7000 und 100 v. Chr. Nänsel, B., Machnik,
logical Archaeology, 14: 2. pp. 212–246. J., eds., Das Karpatenbecken und die Osteuropäische Steppe. Südost-
Stefanova, I. & Bozilova, E., 1995: Studies on the Holocene His- europa-Schriften, bd. 20. Prähistorische Archäeologie in Süd-
tory of Vegetation in the Northern Pirin Mts. (South-western osteuropa, bd. 12. München.
Bulgaria). Bozilova, E., Tonkov, S., eds., Advances in Holocene Todorova, H., 2002: Durankulak, Band II. Die prähistorischen Gräberfel-
Paleoecology in Bulgaria. Sofia-Moscow. pp. 3–31. der von Durankulak. Teil 1. Deutsches Archäologisches Insititut in
Steponaitis, V., 1984: Technological studies of prehistoric pottery Berlin. Sofia.
from Alabama: physical properties and vessel function. Van der Todorova, H., 2003: Prehistory of Bulgaria. Grammenos, D.V., ed.,
Leeuw, S., Pritchard, A., eds., The many dimensions of pottery. Ce- Recent Research in the Prehistory of the Balkans. Publications of the
ramics in archaeology and anthropology. pp. 81–127. Archaeological Institute of Northern Greece, Nr. 3. Thessaloni-
Stevanović, M., 1997: The age of clay: the social dynamics of house ki. pp. 257–228.
construction. Journal of Anthropological Archaeology, 16. pp. 334– Todorova, N., Leshtakov, P., Kuncheva-Russeva, T., 2003: Late
395. Chalcolithic Pottery from Sudievo Tell, Nova Zagora District.
Sultov 1969/Rtlsoc, B., 1969: Nocooskqis kfqamixfn Nikolva, L., ed., Early Symbolic Systems for Communication in South-
wfns{q pqi r. Vosniwa os qimrkasa i rsaqob{ldaqrkasa east Europe. Vol. 1. B.A.R. International Series 1139. pp. 241–
fpova. AqvfolodiÄ, kn. 4. pp. 12–24. 289.
Ucko., P.J., 1968: Anthropomorphic Figurines of Predynastic Egypt and Neo- Todorova, N., Matsanova, V., 2000: Late Chalcolithic Ceramic
lithic Crete with Comparative material from the Prehistoric Near East and Style at Yunatsite Tell (Approach to Systematization of the Ce-
Mainland Greece. London. ramics from the Newly Excavated Levels). Nikolova, L., ed.,
Uenze, S., 1992: Die spätantiken befestigungen von Sadovec (Bulgarien): Technology, Style and Society. Contributions to the Innovations between the
Ergebnisse der deutsch-bulgarisch-österreichischen Ausgrabungen 1934- Alps and the Black Sea in Prehistory. B.A.R. International Series
1937. Münchner Beiträge zur Vor- und Frühgeschichte, 43. 2 854. pp. 331–362.
bd. München: Beck. Todorova & Vajsov 1993/Soeoqoca, V., Cajroc, I., 1993:
Talalay, L.E., 1993: Deities, dolls, and devices Neolithic figurines from Noco-kamfnnasa fpova c B{ldaqiÄ. RouiÄ.
Franchthi Cave, Greece. Excavations at Franchthi Cave, Greece, Todorova, H., Vajsov, I., 2001: Die kupferzeitliche Schmuck Bulgariens.
9. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner.
Tasić, Nikola, 1990: Cfhf Poetnacala i Pfladoniâf t fnfol- Tringham, R., Krstić, D., 1990: Selevac: A Neolithic Village in
isrkom pfqioet. Balcanica, XXI. Belgrade. pp. 5–23. Yugoslavia. Monumenta Archaeologica 15. Los Angeles: University
Tasić, Nikola, 1995: Neolithic cultures of Central and West Balkans. Bel- of California.
grade. Tripković, B., 2003: A Dialogue between the Household and Com-
Tasic, N. & Tasic, N., 2003: Serbian Prehistoric Archaeology in munity: A Case Study of Banjica. Nikolova, L., ed., Early Sym-
the 1990s. Grammenos, D.V., ed., Recent Research in the Prehistory bolic Systems for Communication in Southeast Europe. Vol. 2. B.A.R.
of the Balkans. Publications of the Archaeological Institute of International Series 1139. pp. 447–457.
Northern Greece Nr. 3. Thessaloniki. pp. 73–128. Tylecote, R.F., 1992 (2nd edition): A History of Metallurgy. London
Tilley, C., 1996: An etnography of the Neolithic: early prehistoric societies in (The Institute of Materials).
Southern Scandinavia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Vajsov, I., 2002: Das Grab 982 und die Protobonzezeit in Bulgari-
Todorova Simeonova, H., 1968: Die vorgeschichtlichen Funde von en. Todorova, H., ed., Durankulak, Band II. Die prähistorischen Grä-
Sadovec (Nordbulgarien). Jahrbuch des Römisch-Germanischen Zen- berfelder von Durankulak. Teil 1. Deutsches Archäologisches Insti-
tralmuseums Mainz 15. pp. 15–63. tut in Berlin. Sofia. pp. 159–176.
Todorova, 1979/Soeoqoca, V., 1979: ^nfolis Boldaqii. Vitelli, Karen D., 1993: Franchthi Neolithic Pottery. Vol. 1: Classifi-
RouiÄ Pqfrr. cation and ceramic phases. Vol. 2: The Later Neolithic Ce-
Todorova, 1982/Todorova, H., 1982: Kupferzeitliche Siedlungen in ramic Phases 3 to 5. With a contribution on the Post-Neolithic
Nordostbulgarien. Materialien zur Allgemeinen und Vergleichend- Remains by James A. Dengate. Fascile 8 & 10: Excavations at
en Archäologie, Band 13. Verlag C.H. Beck München. Franchthi Cave, Greece. Indiana University Press.
Todorova 1986/Soeoqoca, V., 1986: Kammfnno-mfenasa fpo- Warren, P., Hankey, V., 1989: Aegean Bronze Age chronology. Bristol:
va c B{ldaqiÄ. RouiÄ. Bristol Classical Press.
Todorova, H., 1989: Ein Korrelationsversuch zwischen Klima- Welkov, I., 1935: Eine Gotenfestung bei Sadowetz (Nordbulgarien).
änderungen und prähistorischen Angaben. Praehistorica XV–XIV. Germania. Anzeiger der römisch-germanischen komission des deutsches Ar-
Internationales symposium. Praha. chäologischen Instituts, 19. pp. 149–158.
Todorova, H., 1992: Bericht über die Kontrollgrabung von 1979 Yordanov, Y., Dimitrova, B., 2002: Results of an anthropological
auf Golemanovo Kale und Neuauswertung des prähistorischen study of human skeletal remains in the prehistoric necropolis in
Fundgutes. Uenze, Syna, 1992: Die spätantiken befestigungen von the vicinity of the village of Durankulak. Todorova, H., ed.,
Sadovec (Bulgarien): Ergebnisse der deutsch-bulgarisch-österreichischen Durankulak, Band II. Die prähistorischen Gräberfelder von Durankulak.
Ausgrabungen 1934–1937. Münchner Beiträge zur Vor- und Teil 1. Deutsches Archäologisches Institut in Berlin. Sofia. pp.
Frühgeschichte, 43. 2 bd. München: Beck. pp. 361–374. 325–353.
Todorova, H., 1998: Probleme der Umwelt der prähistorischen Yordanov & Dimitrova 1989/Ĭoqeanoc, I ˘ ., Eimisqoca, B.
194 Acta Archaeologica

1989: Ansqopolodixfrki eanni ha podqfbanisf c mod- Özbek, M., 2001: Cranial Deformation in a Subadult Sample from
ilnisf nfkqopoli os Rfcfqoihsoxna B{ldaqiÄ (Qanna Deǧirmentepe (Chalcolithic, Turkey). American Journal of Physical
Bqonhoca fpova). Qahkopki i pqotxcaniÄ, XXI. RouiÄ. Anthropology 115. pp. 238–244.
pp. 175–190.

You might also like