Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Plan 2010
Prepared by:
Magnitude Partners
February 2010
Revised
CFIC Confidential FY 10 Comms Plan Rev 1
Introduction
Branding and Communications Goals for 2010
Create a single brand for the CFIC and its product and service offerings
Position the CFIC as the go-to authority on HR issues in the Canadian Food
Retail/Wholesale Industry
Position the CFIC as the premium leading solution provider for delivering
best-of-breed HR tools to Canadian Grocers
Establish a brand identity that can support an evolving mandate the CFIC
over the next five years
The Brand
Brand is a combination of both tangible products/service benefits and the intangible
values, associations and expectations attached to an organization and its
services/products by stakeholders, in CFIC’s case its industry members, individuals
within the industry, funding bodies, industry partners and others. It is the
“meaning” or “promise” triggered by seeing or hearing a name.
Branding is:
• A 360 degree look at every aspect of the enterprise
• Every touch point with members of the company’s target audiences (external
and internal)
To develop a strong brand that can survive over time, the brand must exhibit the
following characteristics:
• Differentiating: needs to carve out a clear unassailable position
• Compelling: needs to appeal to audience drivers
Positioning a company/products and its brand is based on three core factors: the
market base they serve, the problem they solve, they value they deliver and finally
what is unique about the value or the way it is delivered. The positioning statement
answers these questions and forms the basis of the elevator pitch, the About CFIC
and About LMS boilerplate, the tagline, the visual treatment and all sub-messages.
Part of positioning also includes identifying the organization’s values as well at its
characteristics as an entity. Core to positioning is to place the organization within a
competitive space: people can largely only identify where a brand is located in their
mind relative to the competitors.
At the heart of the CFIC’s positioning and brand position is the unique three-pillar
structure designed to support strong industry-wide HR management
Relevant, practical
Strategic action support and tools
through a neutral, to address the
collaborative industry’s
industry-led The CFIC pressing HR
approach
Brand challenges
Promise of
Value
The draft Positioning Framework developed by the agency is below and will provide
the basis for developing the overall brand identity:
Mission
to enable a collective response to the food retail/wholesale industry’s human resource challenges.
There are a large number of sources where Canada’s grocery industry can turn for
HR support and tools, ranging from U.S. and other off-shore grocery groups, books
publishers, online properties and even competitors. The CFIC, however, brings a
unique, differentiated and highly defendable competition advantage in its
combination of specific focus on Canada’s retail and wholesale grocery industry and
on Human Resource issues, to the exclusion of other areas. The matrix below
illustrates The CFIC’s position in the competitive space and its positioning as the
only organization focused on delivered HR-specific tools and strategies to Canada’s
grocery industry.
HR Focus
The CFIC
HRSDC
CFIG
CCGD
CMC
General
operations
Based on feedback from the CFIC staff as well as from the one-to-one interviews conducted
over the course of the research phase, the following priority audiences have been identified
as the primary targets:
Priority Audiences:
Senior HR executives
HR/training managers and supervisors
Independent store owners and franchisees
Industry associates:
Canadian Federation of Independent Grocers
Canadian Council of Grocery Distributors
Association des détaillants en alimentation du Québec
Comité sectoriel de main-d’oevre du commerce de l’alimentation
Retail Council of Canada
HRSDC
Labour organizations
Teamsters
UFCW Canada
Below are core messaging matrices designed to bring focus to communications aimed at
these groups. These messages are not exhaustive or meant to be limiting: they are intended
to act as a guideline to ensure that communications at a minimum relay these important
elements:
• Credible unbiased partner • Partner with the only third-party national sector
• Non-adversarial forum to organization focused on addressing HR issues within the
discuss issues food retail/wholesale industry
• Coordinated industry effort on • Speak and act together on shared issues through the
common problems CFIC’s unique position as a neutral forum of labour and
• Trustworthy industry research competitive organizations
• Standards and benchmarking • The CFIC invests in developing standards and
• HR decision-support benchmarks
• Strategic direction • Through the coordination of expertise from across the
industry, the CFIC develops high-quality HR tools,
research and resources to better support strategies for HR
best practices.
• A partner within the industry that • The CFIC is the only neutral organization devoted to
focuses on HR issues addressing HR issues in the food retail/wholesale industry
• A supporting “voice” to • The CFIC is committed to partnerships with
collectively complementary associations in order to ensure a healthy
address broader industry industry
issues • The CFIC encourages its partners to contribute to its
• A partner that adds value to products and resources in order to effectively harness the
their current membership collective expertise within the industry
• A partnership approach to CFIC • By leveraging the products and resources produced by the
products in which they can CFIC, industry associations can offer their memberships
contribute in exchange for expanded offerings
discounted access
• Participation in HR issues and • Speak and act together on shared issues through the
setting direction CFIC’s unique position as a neutral forum of labour and
• Visibility into HR issues and competitive organizations
solutions • The CFIC provides a channel for labour-developed training
• A forum to express the voice of • The CFIC’s tools and products help the grocery industry
the employee improve HR management techniques
• Collaboration with the private
sector
• Helping the private sector
improve its HR management
techniques
Secondary Audiences:
Media:
Trade media
National and regional mass media
- Business, Careers, Human interest
College and university co-op teachers, deans and counsellors
Association of Canadian Community Colleges
The bulk of the respondents worked for chains or franchisees (46%) and
independents (33%) while their roles were skewed to owner (41%), with corporate
HR manager, store manager and corporate executive all ranging near 20%. Based
on these statistics, it appears that the respondents were representative across the
industry but also delivered a larger number of those priority audiences important to
this effort: specifically franchise and independent store owners and HR
professionals.
The results indicated general low brand awareness, surprisingly even among the
CFIC’s own internal list:
% % % #
7-10 Familiar 37 18 58 10
4-6 18 19 17 2
What’s notable here is that 22% of the CFIC’s internal list was not familiar with the
brand, while 42% of the entire surveyed population was not familiar. Moreover, a
whopping 61% of Canadian Grocer’s list was not familiar either. Surprisingly,
although there were few respondents form the purchased list, 10 out of the 17 were
very familiar.
Complementing that example is the fact that the Canadian Grocer list provided over
50% of the respondents, showing that this publication will need to play a key role in
2010 communications.
Among the questions asked during the survey, two dealt with how respondents
preferred to receive communications from the CFIC:
CFIC
Canadian CFIC Internal
How should we raise Total Purchased
Grocer List
awareness with you? n=172
n=93 n=62
List
n=17
% % %
#
Email 53 43 63 12
Websites 38 30 45 9
Tradeshows and conferences 27 23 32 5
Traditional direct mail 22 30 11 3
Seminars 20 13 29 5
Advertising in trade publications 19 28 10 1
Other (please specify) 20 28 10 2
CFIC
Canadian CFIC Internal
What is the best way to Total Purchased
Grocer List
communicate with you? n=172
n=93 n=62
List
n=17
% % % #
Email 66 55 79 14
eNewsletter 23 22 24 5
CFIC Website 19 18 24 1
Traditional direct mail 15 19 10 2
The results also reveal some specific challenges for email and websites that will
need to be factored in and overcome over time. First is the fact that the CFIC is not
properly tooled to take immediate advantage of email outreach in any significant
way. Over 50% of the purchased list bounced (non-existent emails), so other means
will be needed to build solid email lists. Using websites for sponsorships will need to
be handled in balance since banner ads have become increasingly less effective
over the years.
With a need to launch two new brands and the new online learning system, a
national bilingual market and a small budget, the CFIC will focus 2010
communication efforts on three foundational activities:
A balance between offline and online media that build awareness and
drive audiences to fulfillment through the website.
Generating interest and curiosity about the LMS
Strengthening internal email lists through a combination of online and
offline methods
The bulk of the communications activities will centre on two industry tradeshows:
Grocery Showcase West in April and Grocers Innovation Canada in October. The
April show is a smaller regional show compared to the later national GIC event.
Moreover, the fall show is far enough along in the year to provide a greater chance
of customer testimonials and success stores as well as to boast a second module,
Safe Food Handling.
With two brands launch, the strategy will be to use raise brand awareness of the
organization by putting more emphasis on the product brand through pushing the
online learning system and “pulling through” the new CFIC brand name. In order to
mitigate the lack of strong email lists and to lever the CFIC’s excellent relationships
with industry publications, the strategy also specifically includes
As much as possible, the website will be used for fulfillment, capturing contact
information and measurement. All material will be available in electronic format,
contact information should be required before downloading certain higher-value
items and landing pages will improve performance and provide specific campaign
metrics.
There are several challenges inherent in trying to build email lists. Among them are
the need to ensure that emails are collected with permission for use, the need to
refrain from contacting certain groups directly as requested by the Board and the
problem of overcoming the industry’s general lag in email usage. Building a solid
email list requires investment in both online and offline outreach, ensuring that
every call to action builds into it a way to capture emails and of course time and
patience. The CFIC already has a strong internal list, but it does recognize the need
to continue building it out.
Recommended Tactics:
Closed downloads: Instead of open downloads, ask for contact information for
higher value items and then send the items to the email address provided. Ensure
that an obvious box is available to check for receiving more form the CFIC. A test
can be run first to gauge reaction on certain items first.
Require email addresses for all purchases: All persons purchasing products should
be required to provide a valid email address. The CFIC could choose to send the
invoice electronically, for example. As well, when the online credit card system is in
place, emails should be a required field.
Purchase existing lists as they become available: The CFIC is already planning to
purchase the email list of defunct Grocer Today.
Instigate a telemarketing program: Lists with phone numbers are available from
brokers and a telemarketing program to both a) offer people an article or some
other time on the LMS and b) collect email addresses would not be prohibitively
expensive. Available lists such as Who’s Who, brokers lists and the Canadian
Grocers subscriber lists are all options here.
Offline and online pull through: A vast majority of the tactics discussed in this plan
include calls to action that require emails:
Budget: Grocer Today purchase -- $750 (regular mail list does not include phone
numbers so only email purchase is recommended)
Telephone Outreach -- $1700 for approximately 2000 calls
List rental -- $1,000 estimate
1. A bold announcement banner on the CFIC home page announcing the coming
availability of the LMS which should coincide with the first industry hitting the
street (second half of March).
3. A home page text callout explaining the new brand for the organization as
well as the products and linking to a temporary page that provides further
details. This page should remain up until June ideally.
4. The product section for the LMS needs to be populated and linked to the
home page announcement. Messaging and downloadable items should
include:
7. Develop the ability to support dynamic landing pages for specific campaigns,
including adwords, email blasts and limited-time sponsorships.
8. The new brand name, taglines and logos implemented on all web content
where appropriate by the end of March.
For the second outreach wave through September and October, some additional
elements will be required:
1. Home page banner announcing the success of the LMS and the launch of a
new Safe Food Handling module.
• Screenshots
• Features and Benefits
• Success Kit
• Pricing and ordering
• PowerPoint demo
• Press kit material
Additionally, SEO is an ongoing effort and should be revisited and tweaked every
several months as resources allow.
Budget: $11,000
Scheduled Completion: March 30 for Phase I and September 15 for Phase II
Web Vendors
Real Decoy
1-205 Catherine Street
Ottawa, Ontario
K2P 1C3 Canada
1.613.234.9330
Richard Isaac
Richard@realdecoy.com
Principle
30 Wertheim Court
Unit 19, 2nd Floor
Richmond Hill, Ontario L4B 1B9
T: 905.737.5905
Vik Bhalla
bhalla@principle.com
Ext 3
www.principle.com
E3 Consulting
1 St. Clair Avenue West, Suite 402
Toronto, Ontario, M4V 1K6
Canada
Brad Bettinson
bbettinson@e3consulting.ca
416.967.6336 x231
9th sphere
[a division of Etalco Limited]
100 York Blvd., Suite 228
Richmond Hill, Ontario
L4B 1J8 Canada
www.9thsphere.com
905.709.2991
1.866.811.5604
Greg Allan
Ext 31
greg@9thsphere.com
info@9thsphere.com
Non-Linear Creations
Ottawa Head Office
987 Wellington St., Suite 201 (Garland St. Entrance)
Ottawa, ON K1Y 2Y1
613.241.2067
marketing@nonlinear.ca
info@nonlinear.ca
Toronto Office
524 Front St. West, Suite 200
Toronto, ON M5V 1B8
Canada
416.203.2997
marketing@nonlinear.ca
info@nonlinear.ca
Toll-free: 1.866.915.2997
Shannon Ryan
sryan@nonlinear.ca
Blackdot.ca
119 Spadina Avenue #602
Toronto, ON, M5V 2L1 Canada
416.907.2976
Eglis Vindedzis
eglis@blackdot.ca
www.blackDot.ca
info@blackDot.ca
April’s soft launch of the new brands and the LMS will be rooted in the CFIC’s
presence at Grocery Showcase West April 25 and 26, 2010. A more aggressive
launch with occur at the Grocery Innovations Canada show in Toronto, October 25
and 26, 2010.
1. Presence
Both shows are part of the Canadian Federation of Independent Grocers (CFIG).
The spring show will be attended by approximately 3000 people, many of them
from the main target groups, while the latter will be at least 6,000 attendees.
The CFIC will have a 10 x 10 presence there using their existing booth
infrastructure with new panels (space has already been reserved and the space
costs are not part of this overall budget.) As well, a new pull-up on the LMS will
be included as well (see Support Collateral).
Registration
Breaks/lunches/receptions
Seminars and breakouts
Delegate bags and lanyards
In addition, the CFIC at the same time will discuss sponsorship opportunities for
Grocers Innovations Canada as well as speaking opportunities at the event with
a focus on presenting case studies with the relevant customer(s). Conferences
and tradeshows need to be approached with summaries of timely, relevant
topics and pitched to ensure acceptance. Speaking opportunities are generally
extended first to those organizations that are exhibiting and to presentations
that focus on customer success.
3. Show Guide
The CFIC will also take a one page, full-colour ad in the Show Guide (being
published by Western Grocer) inviting attendees to experience to the benefits of
online training at the booth. The ad will feature a strong benefits message and
call to action. The Show Guide is being bound inside the March issue of Western
Grocer and will also be available as a separate booklet at the show. Copies of
the March Western Grocer will be distributed at the show as well, and these will
include the Show Guide as well.
4. Press
The CFIC’s media kits with press releases announcing the LMS as well as the new
brands and an information sheet on the LMS will be available in the press room.
The CFIC is also working with CFIG to understand if there will be a list of press
member pre-registered for the show available in order to set up interview times
with appropriate editors and writers. (see Media Strategy)
GSW:
Show Guide Budget: $3,500
Sponsorship Budget: $5,000
GIC
Show Guide Budget: $4,000
Sponsorship Budget: $5,000
Print advertising remains the favoured and most predictable method of raising
general awareness of a brand (Forrester 2008) particularly when used in
conjunction with ads on the digital versions, regular email campaigns to subscriber
lists and leveraging presence at tradeshows and conferences owned by the same
publishing houses.
Unlike PR and media efforts, paid advertising allows the CFIC to control the
message and alleviates the problem of gaining customer cooperation in order to win
placed editorial. Since 2010 is a building year for the brand, it makes sense to
invest in increasing awareness, particularly since awareness programs will reap
benefits in years to come if maintained.
The following print advertising plan is recommended to support the April soft
launch:
The following print advertising plan is recommended to support the October hard
launch (see Media Plan for discussion on editorial/advertorial placements):
Ads in all of the publications, with the possible exception of RADAR, will have the
same theme and messages. An integrated approach to advertising across vehicles
boosts effectiveness and awareness building by building on visual recognition cues.
Total April Launch Print Ad Budget: $10,756 (all but RADAR is for ads that will
appear before March 31) (excluding Show
Guide)
1) Presence on Showcase West page on CFIG site -- $800 for three months
2) CFIG banner index page – October inviting people to booth and post-show
messages -- $1000
3) Western Grocer – Two banner ads on main site for one year -- $2,000
The CFIC has a list of permission-based emails of those who have signed up for its
newsletters and other digital publications. As well, the CFIC has a purchased list
(albeit of not top quality) that can also be used for pre-show emailing. Finally, the
CFIC should also, as an exhibitor, have access to pre-registrant email lists from
Grocery Showcase West and Grocery Innovations Canada if these are offered.
Conversations with CFIG suggest that they are not: hence the tactic above of
sponsoring the pre-show emails that CFIG will send to registrants.
1) CFIC will send 3 email blasts to its internal and purchased lists to advise
people of the upcoming launch and availability of the LMS as well as the new
brand and the CFIC’s presence at Grocery Showcase West. The emails should
go every March 24, April 7 and April 21 (dates are approximate and will be
finalized closer to the time) in the spring and Sept30, Oct 7 and Oct 21 in the
fall.
2) CFIC’s newsletters, Food for Thought and Fresh Thinking, should include
prominent banner, callout box and text copy promoting the upcoming LMS
and CFIC’s presence at Grocery Showcase West starting in early March and at
GIC starting in early September.
3) The CFIC will be disciplined in collecting and recording in a usable but simple
database all contact information of booth visitors and other persons at GSW.
These contacts should be followed up immediately. As well, GSW/GIC
organizers may make the show attendee list available for post-show contact
although their unwillingness to provide the pre-show registrant list is likely an
indication of their position on this overall.
4) The CFIC should follow-up the show with two to three mailings to the same
lists as used in the first activity thanking those who attended, inviting those
who did not to visit at GIC in October and providing information on how to
demo and order the LMS. These emails are also opportunity to further
communicate the new brands. Likewise, follow-up emails should be sent two
to three times post GIC in late October and early November. If the CFIC has
plans to attend shows in 2011, this email can also provide a pre-alert.
The CFIC should run a three-month test of paid search to augment print and digital
advertising and other outreach mechanism. Adwords reach a different audience
than regular advertising: those who are actively seeking products and services and
are more likely ready to buy. Although there are several popular search engines, it’s
recommended the CFIC start with Google since it’s the most common and has an
excellent adword management system.
In order to capitalize on increased awareness from the show support activities and
to fall within the new fiscal year, the test should ideally run through April, May and
June. A certain amount of experimentation will be required to ensure optimal results
and to capture interest from keywords that already do not return the CFIC at the top
organically.
A maximum budget of $500 per month has been budgeted for this program,
although actually monthly costs will be determined by the selected keywords and
the going rate for them.
Over the three months, the CFIC must continuously monitor and adjust the
campaign as needed. This function can be outsourced if the CFIC prefers. At the end
of the three months, the CFIC can decide whether to continue to the program or
cancel it. Should the CFIC decide to continue, then the maximum commitment
should be no more than $3,000 for the rest of the year, not counting any outside
help with monitoring the campaign or adding new landing pages.
Collateral Support
Several pieces of collateral and other communications support pieces will need to
be produced in order to support outbound activities and tradeshow attendance.
Once the visual themes have been approved, action will be needed quickly to
design, produce art files and go to print for the various elements in order to have
them on time.
This sheet should be simple and generally inexpensive since many will be
thrown out after the show and because it will change again with the addition
of the Safe Food Handling Module later in the year.
Budget: $3,000
3. LMS Success Kit should be produced in time for the launch. While the kit
should not be distributed at the show, samples should be there so that
attendees can request the kit. Contact names, emails and addresses should
be carefully collected and recorded. The Kit should be
Budget: $10,000
PPT Demo Budget: $2,000
7) New booth panels will be needed for the CFIC’s existing booth infrastructure.
The booth type has been checked and it is still in production and therefore
new panels can be created for it. The booth design will be provided as part of
the organizational brand visual them and specific messaging on the panels
themselves should be kept to a minimum for longevity. Pull-ups are
recommended for product or event specific messages.
Budget: $4,000
Budget: $2,000
9) Give-Aways
The CFIC wishes to have give-aways available the booth for both GSW and
GIC. Ideally, these give-aways should be relevant, useful or engaging and be
integrated or reflective of the LMS’s key benefits and messaging. Upon
approval, the CFIC should begin researching various options. AS well, the
CFIC should consider branding the give-away with the product brand rather
than the organization brand. A budget has been set aside for this: depending
on the choice made, the budget may have to be increased and saving found
elsewhere. Based on the brand message of “perfect pairings” and the food
visual, a strong potential is matching salt/pepper shakers or grinds. Any RFQ
issued for this should include the cost of recommendations based on the
vendor’s stock for keeping with the brand messages.
Budget: $5,000
Promotional Vendors:
Daquin
165 Colonnade Road South
Ottawa, ON K2E 7J4
Ena Bernetti
613.226.8680 x112
enab@daquinsales.com
Barebrands
89 Sabrina Drive, Unit #2
Toronto, Ontario M9R 2J8
416-815-8000
Dave Burnett
dburnett@anopportunityknocks.com
Ext 222
disco@barebrands.com
Promos Canada
Clarington Promotions Inc.
2377 Hwy #2 unit 120
Bowmanville, Ontario L1C5E2
PromosCanada.Com
905-983-1128 Phone
1-877-552-6068 Toll Free
Alex Subotich
alex@promoscanada.com
sales@promoscanada.com
www.promoscanada.com
Promo Pays
1101 Clarkson Road North,
Suite 306
Mississauga, ON L5J 2W1
905-823-8999 or 416-233-3325
John Simos
John@promopays.ca
www.promopays.ca
Adwear
Mishail Pawa, Sales, ext. 23
801 Eglinton Ave. West, Suite 404
Toronto, Ontario M5N 1E3
Tel: 416-785-0777
Lorne Merkur
Ext. 29
lorne@adwear.ca
info@adwear.ca
Brymark
Head Office
2405A St. Laurent Blvd.
Ottawa, Ontario
Canada K1G 5B4
Tel: (613) 737-4556
877-521-1102
Warren Gencher
warren@brymark.com
613 737 4556 ext. 119
greatideas@brymark.com
Toronto Office
312 Dolomite Dr., Suite 218
Toronto, Ontario
Canada M3J 2N2
10) An allowance has been made for some design and production work to produce
needed collateral pieces.
Budget: $10,000
Less emphasis and fewer resources will be placed behind media relations for the
softer April launch. However, several activities will help garner media coverage in
support of the LMS announcement:
Press release: : write internally, using board member quotes and release on
relevant wires as well as circulate to internal press lists.
Editorial: The CFIC will be provide Canadian Grocers, Western Grocer and the
Independent Grocer with invited editorial (“column” style)
Pre-pitching: Hire a media relations person to pre-pitch the press release and
possibly write an article on the training issues facing the industry, how good
training contributes to easing attraction and retention problems and using as
much as possible industry spokespeople if there is sufficient interest. This
person’s work can help with the CFIC’s invited columns (see above) and can also
be pitched to selected national print and digital publications:
Selected industry publications both here and in the United States can also be pre-
pitched or Additional industry publications (offline and online properties):
Press release: write internally, using board member quotes and release on relevant
wires as well as circulate to internal press lists.
Press meetings: Arrange as much as possible meetings with attending press at GIC.
The CFIC will engage with CFIG to determine if press registrant lists are available.
Press kits with information about the LMS and the new brands must be available in
the press room.
Measurement
Measurement is an on-going challenge for most marketing activities, particularly
off-line. Moreover, measurement can be expensive and given the small budgets, it’s
recommended that measurement be driven digitally. Digital efforts can be more
easily measured, ranging from bounce-back and open rates through to click-
Organic search placements: SEO efforts are harder to measure. However, Google
Analytics provides referring websites as well as search string data to help establish
how many people go to the CFIC site from an organic search.
Contacts collected at shows: This is critical and must be met with discipline.
Investment in a tradeshow in significant and is a prime opportunity to meet and
engage with prospects face-to-face.
Downloads of Success Kit and Demos: Downloads of specific offerings can also be
measured by using specific landing pages and by requiring a minimum amount of
contact information beforehand. These types of downloads can also be measured
and extrapolated to judge the amount of interest in the LMS and whether marketing
activities are motivating actions.
Downloads of CFIC products overall: Over time, the CFIC should measure overall
purchases and usage of CFIC products overall. While the focus is on the LMS for
2010, outbound communications should also pull through increased awareness of
the additional offerings and help prompt an increase in buying.
Increase in permission-based email lists: It’s important that the CFIC lever every
opportunity to build its internal permission-based email capacity. The section above
provides more information on recommendations, but measurement of increases in
emails will help measure the overall success of the program.