Professional Documents
Culture Documents
M
EB
A
IJ
Corresponding author:
Email id: jmdnishi@yahoo.com
Phone : +911722727251
M
for enhanced transparency have not only behave in a socially responsible manner. But in
magnified the resonance of Corporate Social developing nations, there is a dearth of deliberate
Responsibility but also heightened the inclination and effective actions to the current need. In
towards integration of CSR principles in the addition to this a very limited research work has
corporate activities. In this regards, actions taken been done to investigate the CSR practices in
by corporate houses and regulatory authorities developing and emerging nations. In fact the
operating in developed nations are quite academic publication on this fiery issue is
satisfactory. However in developing nations the
EB
scenario of CSR activities is not so rosy.
primarily western centric. Belal1 (2001) also noted
that most of the CSR studies conducted so far
Particularly in financial sector there is an absence have been in the context of developed countries
of stringent provisions regarding compliance and such as Western Europe, the USA and Australia
reporting of CSR activities. This has further and we still know too little about practices in ex-
instigated organisations to remain silent to the colonial, smaller, and emerging countries. In this
issue till any mandatory provision is being context, the present paper attempts to examine the
enacted. In addition to this the academic steps initiated by Indian scheduled commercial
publication on this fiery issue also reflects the banks to portray their responsible behaviour. The
Western centric nature of research work. In fact second section unfolds some prominent
there is an availability of very limited research dimensions of CSR practices world-wide. Next
A
work in the context of implementation of CSR section entails the discussion of CSR practices in
practices in context to developing nations. In this banking industry with special reference to Indian
reference the present paper attempts to analyse banks. It unfolds the thrust areas of public and
CSR practices and CSR reporting in India with private sector banks of India. It examines the
special reference to banking sector. recent initiatives of some leading banks of India.
IJ
M
for its stockholders. Davis2 (1973) described CSR
as firm‟s consideration and response to different III. CSR PRATICES IN BANKING
issues which may rest beyond the narrower INDUSTRY
territories of economic, technical and legal
requirements of the firm. In this phase researchers Now-a-days across the globe, banking sector is
pointed out that CSR encompasses the economic, under massive pressure from its shareholders,
legal, ethical and discretionary (philanthropic) investors, media, NGOs as well as its customers to
EB
expectations that society has at a given point of carry out business in a responsible and ethical
time. manner (Bhattacharya et al.12 2004; Frenz13, 2005;
In 80s & 90s a need was being felt to give Jeucken14,15, 2001; 2004). Recently, several
recognition to some new concepts like stakeholder initiatives have been initiated to promote CSR
theory, corporate governance, corporate social practices around the globe. For instance, United
performance, corporate citizenship, corporate Nations Environment Programme Finance
social innovation and communication of CSR Initiative (UNEPFI) was launched in 1990s to
practices through CSR reporting. Gray et al. 3, promote sustainable development within the
(1987) insisted upon the communication of social framework of market mechanisms. Likewise,
and environmental effects of organizations along Bank Tract network was formed by global
with the economic actions to particular interest
A
coalition of NGOs to promote sustainable finance.
groups within the society. Further efforts were Collevecchio Declaration also calls for
being made to operationalise the CSR practices environmental protection and social justice by
for business houses. Wood4 (1991) explained banks. Some countries levied heavy penalties to
operational view of CSR as a firm‟s social banks for violating socio-economic principles. For
performance, which can be assessed by how a instance US Comprehensive Environmental
IJ
firm manages its societal relationships, its social Response Compensation and Liability Act in late
impact and the outcomes of its CSR practices. 1980s has resulted in huge loss to the banks in the
Lee5 (1997) explained CSR as the company‟s US for the environmental pollution of their clients
commitment to operate in an economically and and made them to pay the remediation cost.
environmentally sustainable manner, while Further socially irresponsible lending banks have
acknowledging the interests of a variety of to face a lot of criticism for their actions many
stakeholders and maximizing economic, social times. Jeucken15 (2004) illustrated that ABN
and environmental value. AMRO attracted massive public criticism for its
In 21st century a general attempt was to engagement in destructive mining practices in
establish the linkage among economic, legal, West Papua New Guinea. Hoare16 (2004) reported
social and ethical standards so as to bring the criticism of the finance institutions of BP and
sustainable development. World Business Council Barclays for the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline
for Sustainable Development 6 (2001) explained project which was ultimately responsible for
CSR as the commitment of business to contribute cutting across nationally protected wetland area
towards sustainable economic development, and causing displacements of local population in
working with employees, their families and the Azerbaijan, Georgia and Turkey. The exponential
ISSN: 2230-7826 @ 2011 http://www.ijaebm.iserp.org. All rights Reserved. Page 60
Nishi Sharma - (IJAEBM) INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ADVANCED ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Vol No. 1, Issue No. 2, 058 - 066
growth of information technology has caused stakeholders. The major thrust areas for CSR
great demand for adoption of CSR activities in practice in Indian banks are common in public
banking sector. State regulatory bodies, media, sector and private sector banks. These areas
NGOs, customers have significantly addressed include children welfare, community welfare,
social responsibility issues in banking sector education, environment, healthcare, poverty
(Jeucken14, 2001; Bhattacharya et al.12 2004; eradication, rural development, vocational
Decker17, 2004). Likewise, international training, women's empowerment, protection to
organisation such as the World Bank also girl child, employment. However the core areas
frequently exert pressures on banks to analyse for reporting CSR activities are slightly different
social and environmental risk involved in projects in both types of banks. The analysis of three core
to be financed. In addition to this, CSR practices activity areas as depicted by these banks reflected
of an organisation have significant impact on its some prominent fields for CSR activities. These
reputation and resultant profitability. Many areas could be shown by the following charts. The
researches like Pava and Krausz18 (1996) and Preston X axis of chart represents these fields and Y axis
and O'Bannon19 (1997) have found positive correlation of the chart represents the number of banks,
between CSR and financial performance of the claiming these areas, out of the selected sample.
M
organisation. Some researches have also proved a Chart 1 reports the thrust areas of the public sector
negative impact of socially irresponsible operation bank while chart 2 reflects those for private sector
on share prices and brand reputation of a bank banks.
(Hopkin and Cowe20, 2003; Ian21, 2005). Around
the globe, banking industry is showing a good
commitment to CSR principles. Decker17 (2004) Chart 1: Core thrust areas for reported CSR
pointed out that banks have exhibited conscious activities in public sector banks
efforts to comply with the relevant provisions to
EB
reduce the regulatory action through depicting a
good environmental citizen image.
(1950s till the nationalisation of banks in 1969), Source: Compiled from respective websites of
Expansion phase (mid-60s to 1984), selected public sector banks
Consolidation phase (1985 to 1991) and Reforms
phase (since 1992). Indian banking industry is
found to be adopting an integrated approach of Indian public sector banks most actively
combining CSR with the ultimate customer participate for alleviation of regional imbalances
satisfaction voluntarily. In recent years an attempt through initiating various activities for promotion
has been initiated to ensure socially responsible of rural development. Besides it, they primarily
behaviour of banking sector in more systematic focus on the issues of gender equality through
manner. RBI has also insisted upon taking women's empowerment. The major areas
measures for sustainable development of economy investigated for reporting CSR activities in private
through realising the dire necessity of CSR. sector banks could be depicted by the following
Reserve Bank of India22 (2007) stated that CSR chart 2:
entails the integration of social and environmental
concerns by companies in their business
operations and also in interactions with their
ISSN: 2230-7826 @ 2011 http://www.ijaebm.iserp.org. All rights Reserved. Page 61
Nishi Sharma - (IJAEBM) INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ADVANCED ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Vol No. 1, Issue No. 2, 058 - 066
B. Some recent initiatives by Indian Banks
In order to address ecological and environmental
Chart 2: Core thrust areas for reported CSR concerns, Reserve Bank of India has decided to go
activities in private sector banks for energy efficient buildings. Bureau of Energy
Efficiency has awarded the first star rating labels
to the Bank‟s building at Bhubaneswar and New
Delhi. The four buildings located at Bhubaneswar,
Chennai, Kochi, Kolkata are recognised as 5-star
building under the rating system. Nine buildings
at Bhopal, Chandigarh, Hyderabad, Jaipur,
Kanpur, Mumbai, Nagpur, New Delhi and
Thiruvananthapuram have been given 4-star
rating. In consideration of Ozone Depleting
Substances, bank has reviewed the air-
conditioning plant and planned to replace some of
the plants. SIDBI (the prime financer to small and
M
medium scale industries) has also incorporated
environmental and social aspects in its core
business activities so as to ensure sustainable
development. It is providing concessional .and
liberal credit to medium and small scale industries
Source: Compiled from respective websites of which are initiating energy saving projects and are
selected private sector banks adopting pollution control measures. Further
EB stringent provisions have been implemented for
The major areas for reporting CSR activities in financing industries consuming / producing ozone
Indian private sector bank are to enhance the level depleting substances. State Bank of India (SBI),
of education and employment. The other the oldest bank has also adopted green banking
prominent areas for their concern include initiatives in its lending operations. Recognising
community welfare, programmes for child welfare the warning of global warming bank has decided
and protection of environment. to initiate urgent measures to combat the climate
As shown from the above graphs the CSR change through envisaging two pronged approach
practice of the selected banks represents a wide viz. i) to reduce the Bank‟s own carbon footprint
spectrum of different activities including rural and ii) to sensitise the Bank‟s clients to adopt low
carbon emission practices. As a signal of Bank‟s
A
development, community development and social
welfare, family initiatives, women's sincerity and urge in its efforts bank has installed
empowerment and environment protection. A windmills for the Bank‟s captive use with a view
significant part of the bank‟s annual earnings is to substitute the polluting power with green
used to support structures, events and individuals power. IndusInd Bank has recently launched solar-
across diverse areas of child healthcare and powered ATMs. Many banks have participated in
IJ
education, entertainment, environmental the Carbon Disclosure Project. Some banks are
beautification, human capital development and undertaking greenhouse gas (GHG) inventory
arts. The study of core areas as reported by the exercise for calculating their carbon foot-printing
selected banks reveal that primary concern for and undertaking energy audits. ICICI bank has
both type of bank is social welfare. However both shown its commitment to corporate environmental
have different approach to promote the same. The stewardship and extended a great support to clean
general trend of selected public sector banks technology projects. It has also liberalised credit
mainly practices for rural development and to zero emission vehicles. IDBI has set up carbon
removal of gender inequality. On the other hand, desk.
the core operational areas for CSR activities in
private sector banks are focused on education and IV. REPORTING OF CSR
employment for all and mitigating the risk of PRACTICES
environment degradation through their green
banking strategies. During last few decades, as a result of increased
consciousnesses towards sustainability issues a
move from core financial reporting to the adoption
ISSN: 2230-7826 @ 2011 http://www.ijaebm.iserp.org. All rights Reserved. Page 62
Nishi Sharma - (IJAEBM) INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ADVANCED ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Vol No. 1, Issue No. 2, 058 - 066
of triple bottom line principle was being observed. National Green , Agency
The triple bottom line principle entails reporting Goldman Sachs Corp.:
of not only the economic performance of company Goldman Sachs Energy
but also their environmental and social Environmental and Social
performance i.e., reporting of CSR activities. CSR (GSEES) Index, asset
reporting calls for reflection of corporate ethical management in SRI , Index
practices, transparency, sensitivity to the provider
environmental issues, social commitment and Innovest Group Innovest
labour welfare practices of business houses. The Strategic Value Advisors :
concept of CSR reporting has been described by research & screening
different scholars in different ways. Perks23 (1993) service, Agency
expressed CSR reporting as the disclosure of those Institutional Shareholder
costs and benefits that may or may not be Services (ISS) :Corporate
quantifiable in money terms arising from Governance Quotient,
economic activities and substantially borne by the Agency
community at large or other stakeholders. A
M
Investor Responsibility
further extension in this field is the emergence of
Research Centre
a new theory of reputation risk management. In
(IRRC):research &
this regard, Bebbington et al.24 (2008) viewed
screening service , Agency
CSR reporting as part of the organizational
Social Investment
reputation risk management process and proposes
Research Service (SIRS):
an image restoration framework. Rating of a
web based Screening
company could be use as a screening indicator. In
platform 'SIMON', Agency
EB
practice different nations have their distinct
different agencies and index providers which UK Accountability Rating:
disseminate information to track the economic, research services, agency
financial, corporate governance, environmental Business in the Community
and social performance of corporate. At present, (BITC): Corporate
numerous companies around the world are already Responsibility Index
documenting their performance and successes (BITC-CR-Index) , Index
through environmental and social reporting. In Provider
addition to this, CSR rating could be done through Core Ratings Ltd.: research
in-house research teams, rating agencies or index & screening service ,
provider. These institutes attempt to provide a Agency
A
reliable and objective benchmark of the best CSR Ethical and Environmental
practices in the country to investors. The detail of Screening Service (ESS)
some prominent rating houses is as follows: :research & screening
service , Agency
Country In-house Research Teams, Rating Ethical Consumer
IJ
M
Pty Ltd.: Agency
Canada Corporate Knights: Best 50 Table 2: CSR rating of Indian commercial banks
Corporate Citizens in Level No. of Name of Banks
Canada (annual ranking) , (0-5) Banks
index provider
Ethiscan Canada Ltd.: The Level 0 3 City Union Bank, Karur
Corporate Ethics Monitor, Vysya Bank and Vijay
Bank
EB
Corporate 1,500 DataBase ,
Agency Level 1 6 Central Bank of India,
Jantzi Research Inc.: Indusind Bank, Karnataka
Canadian Social Bank, Kotak Mahindra
Investment Database Bank, South Indian Bank
(CSID), Jantzi Social and UCO Bank
Index (JSI), Agency / index
provider Level 2 15 Allahabad Bank, Andhra
Bank, Bank of Baroda,
Most of the above rating agencies measure Bank of India, Bank of
corporate practices against a set of comparable
A
Maharashtra, Bank of
standards based on international indices. Some Rajasthan, Corporation
rating agencies like Allianz Global Investors Bank, Federal Bank, HDFC
(AllianzGI) work for more than a specific country Bank, IDBI Bank, Indian
also. According to the recent reports provided by Overseas, State Bank of
different agencies and institutes developed and Bikaner, State Bank of
IJ
M
international level. Unlike credit rating there is no
strong consensus about methodology. Further and Journal, Vol.16, pp. 312-322, 1973.
criteria used in CSR rating have a great diversity 3. R.H. Gray, D.L. Owen and K.T. Maunders,
(Sjostrom29, 2004). As a result this leads to a wide Corporate Social reporting: Accounting
spectrum of rating criteria (Schafer et.al. 30, 2006) and and Accountability, Hemel Hempstead:
lack of common standards for comparative study. Prentice Hall, 1987.
Tencati et al.31, (2004) found that the lack of public 4. D. J. Wood, Corporate social performance
support and publicity on CSR are the main reported revisited", Academy of management review,
obstacles.
EB Vol.16 No. 4, pp.691-718, 1991.
5. M. Lee, Responsible Business
Development through Community
V. CONCLUSION Economic Development and Corporate
Banking sector in India is showing interest in Social Responsibility, Burnaby, BC: CED
integrating sustainability into their business models but Centre, Simon Fraser University, 1997.
its CSR reporting practices are far from satisfaction. 6. World Business Council for Sustainable
There are only few banks which report their activities Development: 2001, the Business Case for
on triple bottom line principles. As a matter of fact, the Sustainable Development: Making a
standards for rating CSR practices are less uniform in Difference Towards the Johannesburg Summit
comparison to that for financial rating. This leads to 2002 and Beyond. [Online] available:
A
problem in comparison of corporate houses and http://www.wbcsd.org.
determining the CSR rating. Absence of mandatory 7. L. Uhlaner, A. van Goor-Balk and E. Masurel,
provisions regarding reporting of CSR practices Family Business and Corporate Social
further cause negligence on the issue of reporting. Responsibility In A Sample of Dutch Firms,
Further, the study found that among the reporting Journal of Small Business and Enterprise
banks also, some banks are just making false gestures Development 11(2), pp. 186–194, 2004.
IJ
in respect of their efforts for socio-environmental 8. E. Juholin, For Business or the Good Of
concerns. According to some critics companies, on
All? A Finnish Approach to Corporate
socio-environmental concerns, having significant
blemishes on their record riddle it and baffled real Social Responsibility, Corporate
issues. In addition to this, the credibility of rating Governance, 4(3), pp. 20–31, June 2004.
agencies has also been sometimes questioned. 9. M. Longo, M. Mura and A. Bonoli , Corporate
However its importance can not be overlooked as it Social Responsibility and Corporate
may be used as a good media for providing inherently Performance: The Case of Italian SMEs,
useful information. The adaptation of reporting CSR Corporate Governance 5(4), pp. 28–42, 2005.
practices though quite slow in India, still it would 10. A. Quazi and D. O‟Brien, An Empirical Test
definitely get a great pace in near future. In fact there of a Cross-National Model of Corporate Social
is a great need for enacting some stringent regulatory Responsibility, Journal of Business Ethics 25,
provisions to ensure the adherence to social pp. 33–51, 2000.
responsibility principles. The recent initiatives of 11. D.M. De la Crus Deniz and K. Cabrera
Reserve Bank of India in this regard are expected to Suárez, Corporate Social Responsibility and
bring a drastic change in near future. Further voluntary Family Business in Spain, Journal of Business
actions are required to be taken by the financial bodies Ethics 56, pp. 27–41, 2005.
to ensure the socio-environmental feasibility of 12. N.C. Bhattacharya, C. Smith and D. Vogel,
ISSN: 2230-7826 @ 2011 http://www.ijaebm.iserp.org. All rights Reserved. Page 65
Nishi Sharma - (IJAEBM) INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ADVANCED ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS MANAGEMENT
Vol No. 1, Issue No. 2, 058 - 066
Integrating social responsibility and marketing Stockholm, 2004.
strategy: An introduction, California 30. Schafer, H., J. Beer, Zenker, J. and Fernandes,
Management Review, 47(1): pp. 6-8, 2004. P. (2006), Who is who in Corporate Social
13. Frenz. “Multinationality Matters in Innovation: Responsibility Rating? , A survey of
The Case of the UK Financial internationally established rating systems that
Services”.Industry and Innovation, Vol.12, No. measure Corporate Responsibility.
1, pp. 65, 2005. Bertelsmann. Online:
14. M. Jeucken, Sustainable Finance and Banking http://www.bertelsmannstiftung.de/bst/de/medi
–The Financial Sector and the Future of the a/xcms_bst_dms_18175_18176_2.pdf.
Planet, Earthscan Publishing, London, 2001. 31. A. Tencati, F. Perrini and S. Pogutz, New
15. M. Jeucken, Sustainability in Finance: Tools To Foster Corporate Socially
Banking on the Planet”, Eburon Publishers, Responsible Behavior, Journal of Business
the Netherlands, 2004. Ethics 53, pp.173–190, 2004.
16. S. Hoare, It is not easy being green”, Financial
World, pp. 38-42, June 2004.
17. O.S. Decker, Corporate social responsibility
and structural change in financial services,
M
Managerial Auditing Journal, Vol. 19 No.6, pp.
712-728, 2004.
18. L. Pava and J. Krausz, The Association
between Corporate Social Responsibility and
Financial Performance, Journal of Business
Ethics, 15, pp.321-357, 1996.
19. L. Preston and D. O‟Bannon, The Corporate
Social-Financial Performance Relationship,
EB
Business and Society, 36(1), pp.5-31, 1997.
20. M. Hopkins and R. Cowe, Corporate Social
Responsibility- Is there a business Case,
ACCA UK, London, 2003.
21. M. Ian, A UK Retail Banking Manifesto:
addressing the challenges that lie ahead for the
industry and its stakeholders”, British Bankers‟
Association
http://www.bba.org.uk/content/1/c4/45/25/man
ifesto_flyer.pdf, accessed 6 July, 2005.
22. RBI notifications retrieved from www.rbi.org
23. R. W. Perks, Accounting & Society.
A
London: Chapman & Hall, 1993.
24. J. Bebbington, C. Larrinaga-Gonza ́lez, and J.
Moneva, „Corporate social responsibility
reporting and reputation risk management‟,
Accounting, Auditing & Accountability
IJ