Professional Documents
Culture Documents
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Colloid particle deposition was applied to characterize fibrinogen (Fb) monolayers on mica, which were
Received 21 October 2010 produced by controlled adsorption under diffusion transport. By adjusting the time of adsorption and the
Accepted 3 January 2011 bulk Fb concentration, monolayers of desired surface concentration were obtained. The surface concen-
Available online 14 January 2011
tration of Fb was determined directly by AFM enumeration of single molecules adsorbed over the sub-
strate surface. It was proven that Fb adsorbed irreversibly on mica both at pH 3.5 and at pH 7.4 with
Keywords: the rate governed by bulk transport. The electrokinetic properties of Fb monolayers produced in this
Colloid particle deposition
way were studied using the streaming potential method. The dependence of the apparent zeta potential
DLVO theory
Fibrinogen layers on mica
of Fb monolayers was determined as a function of the coverage. It was shown that for pH 3.5 the initial
Heterogeneous surface deposition negative zeta potential of the mica substrate was converted to positive for Fb coverage exceeding 0.16. On
Streaming potential measurements the other hand, for pH 7.4, the zeta potential of a Fb-covered mica remained negative for the entire cov-
Zeta potential of fibrinogen-covered mica erage range. The charge distribution in Fb monolayers was additionally studied using the colloid deposi-
tion method, in which negatively and positively charged polystyrene latex particles (ca. 800 nm in
diameter) were used. An anomalous deposition of negative latex particles on substrates exhibiting a neg-
ative zeta potential was observed. Results of these experiments were quantitatively interpreted in terms
of the fluctuation theory assuming that adsorption sites consisted of two and three Fb molecules, for pH
3.5 and 7.4, respectively. These results suggested that for pH 7.4, the distribution of charge on Fb mole-
cules was heterogeneous, characterized by the presence of positive patches, whereas the average zeta
potential was negative, equal to 19 mV. The utility of the colloid deposition method for studying Fb
monolayers was further demonstrated in deposition experiments involving positive latex particles. It
was shown that for a rather broad range of fibrinogen coverage, both the positive and the negative latex
particles can adsorb on surfaces covered by Fb, which behaved, therefore, as superadsorbing surfaces. It
was also concluded that the colloid deposition method can be used to determine the Fb bulk concentra-
tion for the range inaccessible for other methods.
Ó 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
0021-9797/$ - see front matter Ó 2011 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jcis.2011.01.009
Z. Adamczyk et al. / Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 356 (2011) 454–464 455
A significant spread in the maximum coverage of fibrinogen and the amount of adsorbed colloid, which can be assessed quan-
was reported in these works with the lowest and highest value titatively via microscopic counting. Using the colloid deposition
ranging between 1.4 and 11 mg m2. It seems that this discrepancy method, in conjunction with electrokinetic characteristics of pro-
can be attributed to different adsorption mechanisms of fibrinogen tein-covered substrates, one can determine mechanisms of colloid
on various substrates and for various concentration regimes. For deposition on heterogeneous surfaces, which is the primary goal of
hydrophilic surfaces, and the low concentration regime, fibrinogen this work.
adsorption occurs according to the side-on mechanism with the As shown previously [14,24–27], in the case of heterogeneous
maximum amount of adsorbed protein equal to 1.4–1.7 mg m2, surfaces the standard DLVO theory is not applicable because the
depending on the degree of hydration. This is in accordance with net kinetics of colloid particle deposition is governed by favorable
recent theoretic results discussed in Ref. [16]. areas (patches), whose zeta potential deviates from the average va-
For hydrophobic surfaces and higher fibrinogen concentrations, lue pertinent to the entire substrate surface. In view of these pre-
the end-on adsorption of the protein becomes feasible with the dictions, another goal of our work is to determine the range of
maximum coverage many times higher than for the side-on config- applicability of this theory for predicting deposition kinetics of col-
uration. However, since the binding energy in the end-on configu- loid particles on heterogeneous surfaces produced by controlled
ration is much lower than for the side-on orientation, a partial fibrinogen adsorption.
reversibility of adsorption occurs, which can explain the source The research presented in this work has also a practical impact
of discrepancies. since the colloid deposition method can be exploited for a quanti-
Contrary to kinetic aspects, little is known about the electrostat- tative determination of protein coverage and consequently for
ics of fibrinogen monolayers on solid substrates under wet condi- detecting the bulk protein concentration.
tions, which is of vital significance. This kind of information can be We focus our attention on fibrinogen whose bulk characteristics
derived from electrokinetic studies, e.g., streaming potential mea- and surface electrokinetic properties have been precisely deter-
surements performed previously for lysosyme [17,18], bovine ser- mined, which enables a quantitative analysis of the experimental
um albumin (BSA), immuno-gamma globulins IgG [19] and for data.
chymotrypsin [20]. Interestingly, a significant protein adsorption
was observed in the latter work despite the fact that both the mica
2. Materials and methods
substrate and the protein molecules were negatively charged. This
effect was explained by a dipolar distribution of the charge on the
2.1. Materials
protein.
There are only few works devoted to electrokinetic measure-
Fibrinogen from bovine plasma, fraction I, type IV (65% protein,
ments of fibrinogen adsorption on solid substrates. Zembala and
containing approximately 20% sodium chloride and 15% sodium
Dejardin [21] determined variations in the streaming potential of
citrate) was purchased from Sigma (F4753) and used without fur-
silica capillaries on fibrinogen adsorption as a function of time
ther purification. Protein was 93% clottable.
for pH 7.3 and the ionic strength of 102 M. A systematic increase
Ruby muscovite mica obtained from Continental Trade was
in the negative potential was observed on fibrinogen adsorption,
used as substrate, and was freshly cleaved immediately prior to
which was also negatively charged under these conditions.
use without any pretreatment.
Similar studies were performed in the work noted above by Kal-
Water was purified using a Millipore Elix 5 apparatus. Chemi-
asin and Santore [15] who determined the zeta potential of nega-
cals and reagents (Trizma base, sodium chloride, hydrochloric acid,
tively charged silica spheres (1 lm of diameter) covered by a
sodium hydroxide) were commercial products of Sigma–Aldrich
controlled amount of fibrinogen using microelectrophoresis. A
and used without further purification.
monotonic increase in the negative zeta potential of silica particles
Positively charged amidine polystyrene latex (Invitrogen) and
was observed on fibrinogen adsorption, which attained a limiting
negatively charged sulfonate polystyrene latex (synthesized in
value of 20 mV for fibrinogen coverage larger than 1 mg m2
our laboratory) were used in this work.
(for the ionic strength of 5–26 mM, NaCl).
Recently, systematic studies of fibrinogen adsorption on mica,
monitored by AFM and streaming potential measurements, were 2.2. Experimental methods
reported [22]. The dependence of the apparent zeta potential of
mica on the coverage of fibrinogen was determined. A quantitative The solutions of Fb used in subsequent measurements were
interpretation of these experimental data was achieved in terms of prepared as follows: a known amount of protein powder was dis-
a theoretic model considering a 3D adsorption of fibrinogen mole- solved in NaCl aqueous solution having an ionic strength of
cules as discrete particles, approximated as strings of touching 1 103 or 1 102 M. The pH of these Fb solutions was regulated
beads. The Gouy–Chapman model, based on the concept of a con- by the addition of HCl or NaOH. Then, the suspension was gently
tinuous charge distribution, was proven to be inadequate. It was mixed using a magnetic stirrer, and filtered through the Millex-
also suggested that anomalous adsorption occurring at pH 7.4 GS 0.45-lm filter to eliminate aggregates and impurities. The
could be explained in terms of a heterogeneous charge distribution experimental temperature was kept constant at 293 ± 0.1 K.
on fibrinogen, whose molecules exhibited patches of positive The true concentration of Fb in these solutions was determined
charge, even if the net charge was negative. using a high precision densitometer (Anton Paar, type DMA5000 M)
Although the streaming potential method offers the unique pos- by measuring the specific density of the fibrinogen solutions (nom-
sibility of direct, in situ measurements, it is tedious, and does not inal Fb content of 200–2000 ppm) and the specific density of the
provide one with information on the local distribution of coverage supernatant solution acquired by a membrane filtration.
and charge within the protein monolayer. These concentrated stock Fb solutions were then diluted prior
Therefore, in this work, a complementary method of analyzing to the adsorption experiments to a desired degree (usually 0.5–
protein layers on solid substrates under wet, in situ conditions is 5 ppm).
used. The technique, referred sometimes to as the colloid enhance- The purity of the Fb solutions was checked by the dynamic sur-
ment (CE) [23], consists in unspecific deposition of larger colloid face tension measurements carried out using the pendant drop
particles onto protein monolayers. This enables one to determine shape method. There was practically no change in the surface ten-
a functional relationship between the amount of adsorbed protein sion of the 10 ppm solution of Fb within a 2-h time period, which is
456 Z. Adamczyk et al. / Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 356 (2011) 454–464
much longer than the typical time of DLS and deposition measure- particles considered was ca. 2000, which ensured that these mea-
ments, which usually last 15–60 min. surements had a relative precision below 2%, as determined by var-
The diffusion coefficient of Fb under various conditions was iance analysis. It is worthwhile noting that the coverage was
determined by dynamic light scattering (DLS), using the Zetasizer determined in absolute terms, i.e., H ¼ Sg hNi, where hNi is the
Nano ZS Malvern instrument (measurement range of 0.6 nm– average surface concentration of particles (number of particles
6 lm). This technique measures the time-dependent fluctuations per unit area) and Sg ¼ pa2 is the cross section of the particle (a
in the intensity of scattered light which occur because particles un- is the particle radius). Consequently, the coverage represents the
dergo Brownian motion. Analysis of these intensity fluctuations fraction of the entire surface area occupied by particles.
enables determination of the diffusion coefficients of particles However, because of multiple scattering, the optical microscope
which are converted into size distributions. method became less accurate for coverage exceeding 0.3. In this
The microelectrophoretic mobility le of Fb was measured using case the AFM method was used under dry conditions to determine
the Zetasizer Nano ZS Malvern instrument deploying the laser the surface concentration of particles and their coverage.
Doppler velocimetry (LDV) technique (measurement range of
3 nm–10 lm). The zeta potential was calculated using the equation
3. Results and discussion
3g
f¼ l; ð1Þ The physicochemical characteristics of Fb, latex particles, and
2eFðjaÞ e
the mica substrate, needed for a quantitative interpretation of
fibrinogen adsorption and latex deposition data, were initially
where f is the zeta potential of proteins, g is the dynamic viscosity
determined. These comprised the diffusion coefficient of Fb
of water, e is the dielectric constant of water, and F(ja) the function
(hydrodynamic diameter), microelectrophoretic mobility, and
of the dimensionless parameter ja = a/Le, Le ¼ ðekT=2e2 IÞ1=2 is the
electrokinetic (zeta) potential.
double-layer thickness, e the elementary charge, P k2 the Boltzman It was found by DLS measurements that the diffusion coefficient
constant, T the absolute temperature, I ¼ 12 i c i zi is the ionic
of Fb was independent of its bulk concentration (within the range
strength, ci the ion concentrations, zi is the ion valency, and a the
of 100–2000 ppm), assuming an average value of 2.1 107
characteristic dimension of a particle or a protein molecule (e.g.,
cm2 s1 for the ionic strength range of 103–102 M and for pH
its hydrodynamic radius).
3.5 and 7.4. Using this value the Stokes hydrodynamic radius of
AFM measurements of Fb layers were carried out using the NT-
Fb was calculated using the known dependence [32].
MDT Solver PRO device with the SMENA SFC050L scanning head.
The measurements were performed in semicontact mode using a kT
silicon probe (polysilicon cantilevers with resonance frequencies RH ¼ ; ð2Þ
6pgD
of 240 kHz +/10% or 140 kHz +/10%, a typical tip curvature of
10 nm, and a cone angle less than 20°). The protein solution of a where RH is the hydrodynamic radius, and D is the diffusion
desired concentration was allowed to adsorb on the surface for coefficient.
an appropriate time interval. The substrate was then removed, It was calculated from Eq. (2), that RH = 12.1 nm (see Table 1). It
rinsed for 30 s using double distilled water, and dried under a gen- is interesting to observe that this is much higher than the radius of
tle nitrogen stream. the equivalent sphere equal to 4.5 nm [32] and reflects an elon-
The latex particle size, as a function of ionic strength and pH, gated shape of Fb determined from crystallographic data (see
was determined using a laser diffractometer (LS 13 320 particle Table 1).
size analyzer, Beckman Coulter) with an accuracy of a few percent The electrophoretic mobility of fibrinogen as a function of pH
and independently by the DLS method using the Malvern Zetasizer and the ionic strength was also determined according to the meth-
Nano ZS. od described above. Knowing the electrophoretic mobility of a par-
The zeta potential of the latex was determined as a function of ticle, one can calculate the average number of uncompensated
the ionic strength and pH using the ZetaPals Brookhaven and the electrokinetic charges per molecule Nc from the Lorenz–Stokes
Zetasizer Nano ZS. relationship [32] and the zeta potential of fibrinogen ff from Eq.
Streaming potential measurements were carried out using a (1). It was determined that ff was positive, equal to 24 and
home-made apparatus, exploiting the parallel-plate channel flow, 28 mV for pH 3.5 and the ionic strength of 102 and 103 M,
according to the procedure described previously [22,28–30]. respectively (see Table 1). On the other hand, for pH 7.4, ff became
Fibrinogen adsorption was carried out in a diffusion cell of a negative, equal to 19 and 21 mV for the ionic strength of 102
volume equal to 40 ml, filled with a protein suspension of a desired and 103 M, respectively (see Table 1). From the electrophoretic
concentration, ionic strength, and pH. Freshly cleaved mica sheets mobility measurements, it was also determined that the isoelectric
(usually 4–8) were placed vertically in the cell for a desired time. point of fibrinogen (zero value of its zeta potential) was pH 5.8.
Afterward, some of the mica sheets (2–4) were rinsed with a The size of the latex particles was determined by laser diffrac-
stream of pure buffer solution for 30 s and dried under a gentle tometry and the DLS method. Both values fell within the experi-
stream of nitrogen. Afterward, the number concentration of fibrin- mental margins of error estimated to be 5%. Thus, the average
ogen was directly determined by AFM examination. diameter of the A800 (positive) latex for the pH range 3–7.4 was
The rest of the mica sheets were used in latex deposition exper- 810 nm (ionic strength 103–102 M) and for the L800 (negative)
iments performed in another diffusion cell, having the dimensions latex 800 nm, for the same range of pH and ionic strength (see
of 2 2 5 cm. It was filled with the latex suspension, typically Table 1). The size and shape of latex particles were also checked
having the number concentration of 1–2 1010 cm3. Wet mica by electron microscopy (SEM); see Fig. 1. The average diameter
sheets, precovered by Fb monolayers as described above, were of the A800 latex (determined from ca. 200 particles) was practi-
then immersed vertically into the latex suspension. Latex article cally the same as that determined by the laser diffractometer.
deposition proceeded over a desired time. The true coverage of The zeta potential of both latex particles was also determined as
particles was determined by a direct optical microscope counting a function of pH and ionic strength. As can be seen (see Table 1),
under wet conditions, as described in our previous works the A800 zeta potential was fairly independent of pH, assuming
[28–31]. Particles were counted over 10–20 equal sized areas cho- 77 mV for I = 103 M and 95 mV for I = 102 M. The zeta potential
sen randomly on the mica sheet. The net number of deposited of the L800 latex was also practically independent of pH assuming
Z. Adamczyk et al. / Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 356 (2011) 454–464 457
Table 1
Physicochemical properties of particles and the mica substrate.
Substance Property
Mica Latex A 800 Latex L 800 Fibrinogen
Zeta potential f (mV) pH 3.5
103 M 63 77 82 28
102 M 52 95 102 24
Zeta potential f (mV) pH 7.4
103 M 112 75 80 21
102 M 80 95 105 19
2 RH (nm) averaged I = 102–103 M – 810 800 24.2
47 nm
7nm
Fig. 1. Latex particles on mica, SEM images, (a) the L800 latex, (b), the A800 latex.
counting. The topology of fibrinogen monolayers on mica deter- The results shown in Fig. 3 have interesting practical implica-
mined this way is shown in Fig. 2 for pH 3.5 and 7.4. As can be seen, tions showing that one can determine in a quite precise and conve-
fibrinogen molecules appear as isolated entities, which facilitates nient way the bulk concentration of Fb if it is unknown. This can be
their enumeration by AFM. Therefore, using this counting proce- done by plotting N determined by AFM vs. the square root of
dure the kinetics of Fb adsorption can be determined. adsorption time, t1/2. Knowing the slope of this dependence
It is interesting to note that a similar AFM counting procedure of sf ¼ DN=Dt1=2 , one can determine the concentration of fibrinogen
isolated fibrinogen molecules was used by Tsapikouni and Missirlis in the bulk (in ppm) from the simple relationship.
[12], who determined its coverage on mica for pH 7.4 and ionic p 1=2
Mw
strength of 1.5 102, 0.15, and 0.5 M. cb ¼ 1013 sf ð4Þ
Av 2:4D
In Fig. 3, the kinetics is shown as the dependence of the reduced
surface concentration of Fb (number of Fb molecules per lm2 for where cb is expressed in ppm and sf is expressed in lm2 min1/2.
unit bulk concentration of 1 ppm) N/cb on the square root of the Using the value of the diffusion coefficient and molecular
adsorption time t1/2 (I = 103 M, pH 3.5, and 7.4, T = 293 K). As weight pertinent to fibrinogen one can express Eq. (4) in the simple
can be seen, the experimental data in Fig. 3 are agreement with form
theoretic results (depicted by the solid line) stemming from the
C b ¼ 0:014sf : ð5Þ
formula, pertinent to an irreversible, diffusion-controlled adsorp-
tion mechanism [33,34], From Eq. (5) one can directly determine the bulk concentration
1=2 of Fb even below 0.1 ppm, which is rather difficult using other
D methods.
N¼2 t1=2 nb ð3Þ
p Knowledge of the surface concentration of Fb is necessary for a
proper interpretation of results for colloid deposition
where nb = Cb Av 106/Mw is the number concentration of Fb mol- measurements.
ecules in the bulk (Cb is the Fb concentration in ppm, and Av is the Other data needed for this purpose are the zeta potential f of
Avogadro constant). mica covered by Fb monolayers, which were acquired via stream-
This suggests that Fb adsorption on mica for pH 3.5 was irre- ing potential measurements. It is to be emphasized that our
versible and bulk transport controlled with negligible surface streaming potential measurements were carried out under wet,
transport resistance. This seems quite natural considering the in situ, conditions, which excludes any conformation changes of
strong attraction between the Fb molecules and the oppositely fibrinogen monolayers induced by drying.
charged mica substrate. Results are presented in Fig. 4 showing the dependence of f on
However, similar Fb adsorption kinetics was also observed in the coverage of Fb, calculated from the equation
the case of pH 7.4 (see Fig. 3), where a strong electrostatic repul-
sion was expected due to the same sign of zeta potential of Fb H ¼ Sg N; ð6Þ
and mica. Such anomalous fibrinogen deposition under physiologic where Sg is the characteristic cross section of the protein molecule.
conditions (pH 7.4) was also previously observed by Zembala and As demonstrated in Refs. [16,22] the characteristic cross-
Dejardin [21], Malmsten [13], Ortega-Vinuesa et al. [5,6], Toscano sectional Sg for the side-on adsorption of Fb on mica is equal to
and Santore [11] and Kalasin and Santore [15]. 128 nm2. Using the characteristic cross section for the side-on
As suggested in Refs. [9,15], the attractive interactions at this adsorption, the jamming coverage for fibrinogen becomes 0.29
pH may originate from the heterogeneous charge distribution over [16].
the fibrinogen molecule. Hence, besides being negatively charged, It can be seen in Fig. 4a and b that for pH 3.5, where Fb is pos-
the Fb molecule exhibits positively charged patches, which can itively charged, a steep, quasilinear increase in the zeta potential of
form stable electrostatic bonds with the mica surface. This effect mica is observed for Hf < 0.1. Then, for Hf > 0.16, the zeta potential
was confirmed in a recent publication [22]. became positive and approached saturation values, which were
markedly lower than the bulk values of the zeta potential of fibrin-
800
ogen (equal to 28 and 24 mV for 103 and 102 M, NaCl, respec-
tively). It is interesting to note that the f on Hf dependencies
shown in Fig. 4 are quite similar for both ionic strengths, i.e.,
103 and 102 M. They can be adequately reflected in terms of
600 the theoretic model (depicted by solid lines in this figure) postulat-
N/cb [µm ppm ]
-1
formed by only one fibrinogen molecule. If this were the case, HL/ 1.0
1=2
2
Hmx should increase initially as k2 Hf =Hmx (where k ¼ pSag ), i.e.,
proportionally to Hf. Considering that in our case Sg = 1.28 0.8
1012 cm2 and pa2 = 5.03 109 cm2 one obtains k2 = 3.93 103.
Thus, the slope of the HL/Hmx vs. Hf dependence should be initially
very large initially and independent of pH. 0.6
ΘL/Θmx
It is interesting to note that the data shown in Figs. 5 and 6 are
anomalous in comparison to measurements of colloid particle
deposition on homogeneous surfaces [31,33]. This becomes evi- 0.4
dent if one notes that for pH 3.5 (see Fig. 6) and Hf < 0.15, where
a significant latex deposition was measured, the averaged zeta po-
0.2
tential of the fibrinogen-covered mica substrate remained negative
(see Fig. 4), i.e., of the same sign as the zeta potential of latex. This
should result in a strong electrostatic repulsion preventing particle 0.0
deposition. Qualitatively, this discrepancy could be explained in 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4
terms of a heterogeneous distribution of positive charge due to Θf
natural fluctuations in adsorbed protein density. Consequently,
Fig. 6. Same as in Fig. 5 but for pH 7.4, I = 102 M. The points denote the
the local charge of the substrate could become positive, enabling
experimental results obtained by optical microscopy (d) and AFM (s).
latex particle deposition.
However, the results obtained for pH 7.4 (see Fig. 6) are even
more intriguing, because in this case all components involved in
the adsorption event, i.e., the bare mica substrate, fibrinogen mol-
is observed for negative values of the substrate surface zeta poten-
ecules, and latex particles exhibited negative zeta potentials.
tial, being of the same sign as the latex particle zeta potential.
Hence, paradoxically, the conjuncture of three negative interac-
It is interesting to compare this behavior with predictions
tions produced a positive effect, i.e., irreversible deposition of latex
stemming from the standard DLVO theory, which was previously
particles. This phenomenon can also be explained in terms of the
applied for successfully predicting particle deposition on homoge-
density fluctuation concept if a heterogeneous charge distribution
neous surfaces [31]. The main assumption of this theoretic ap-
over adsorbed fibrinogen molecules is assumed. Therefore, the
proach is that the van der Waals and electric double-layer
simple latex deposition experiments shown in Fig. 6 suggest quite
interactions are additive, which can be expressed for the spherical
unequivocally that at pH 7.4, where the averaged zeta potential of
particle/flat interface by the equation [34].
fibrinogen is negative (19 mV for I = 102 M), there were positive
patches on its surface. This supports the previous conclusion de- A123 a
/ðhÞ ¼ þ /0 eh=Le ; ð7Þ
rived from the streaming potential measurements [22]. 6h
The results shown in Figs. 5 and 6 can be interpreted in a more
where /ðhÞ is the particle / interface interaction energy, A123 is the
quantitative way if the normalized maximum coverage HL/Hmx is
Hamaker constant for the polystyrene/water/mica interactions, h is
plotted against the average zeta potential of fibrinogen-covered
the gap with between the particle and the interface, /0 ¼
mica f, rather than the fibrinogen coverage. The transformation
16aeðkT=eÞ2 tan hðfe=4kTÞ tan hðfp e=4kTÞ is the characteristic energy
from Hf to f was done using the results shown in Fig. 4.
for the linear superposition approximation (LSA) double-layer mod-
As seen in Fig. 7, a quite universal graph was obtained in this
el [39,40].
way, with experimental values of HL/Hmx fairly independent of
Assuming a typical value of A123 = 5 1014 kT, and f = 5 mV,
the ionic strength and pH. However, the results shown in Fig. 7
fp = 82 mV (see Table 1), I = 103 M one obtains from Eq. (7) that
are anomalous because a considerable deposition of latex particles
/ = 278 kT for h = 7 nm (fibrinogen diameter) and / = 0.1 kT for
h = 60 nm. Analogously, for I = 102 M, f = 5 mV, fp = 102 mV,
/ = 59 kT for h = 7 nm and / = 0.5kT for h = 15 nm. These estima-
tions indicate unequivocally that the energy barrier of considerable
1.0 height and extension of db = 15–60 nm is predicted to appear even
for such a low zeta potential of the substrate.
It is interesting to note that even for such low zeta potential of
0.8
the interface, the height of the barrier is mainly governed by the
electrostatic interactions.
ΘL/Θ mx
0.6 Knowing the specific energy distribution, one can calculate the
adsorption rate constant from the definite integral [33,34].
"Z #1
0.4 e/ðhÞ=kT
ka ¼ dh ; ð8Þ
db DðhÞ
0.2
where D(h) is the position-dependent diffusion coefficient of the la-
tex particles.
0.0 Knowing Ka, the latex coverage as a function of deposition time
0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 and bulk concentration can be theoretically calculated by solving
Θf the governing diffusion equation using the finite-difference
scheme [33].
Fig. 5. The dependence of the reduced coverage of negative latex particles L800 HL/
Hmx on the fibrinogen coverage Hf. The points denote the experimental results
It is interesting to note that for a barrier height exceeding 10 kT
obtained by optical microscopy (d) and AFM (s) for ionic strength 103 M, (N, 4) (which is the case for f > 2 mV), the kinetics of latex particle
for ionic strength 102 M, pH 3.5, T = 293 K. deposition can be approximated by the expression.
Z. Adamczyk et al. / Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 356 (2011) 454–464 461
a ¼ pa2 Ns ¼ Hs ¼ k2 Hs ; ð10Þ
Sg
0.4
where Ns is the surface concentration of adsorption sites. As calcu-
lated above, in our case, k2 = 3.93 103.
0.2 Knowing the a parameter one can calculate the maximum cov-
erage of latex particles on a heterogeneous surface covered by sites
from the analytical dependence [23,41] modified in this work to
0.0 account for the fact that Hmx is a variable, rather than a constant.
-60 -40 -20 0 20 !
ζ 1 þ 0:314a2 þ 0:45a3
HL ¼ Hmx 1 : ð11Þ
Fig. 7. The dependence of the reduced coverage of negative latex particles L800,
1 þ H1mx a þ 0:66a3 þ a7=2
HL/Hmax on the zeta potential of fibrinogen-covered mica f determined by the
streaming potential method. The points denote the experimental results obtained In the limit of low coverage of sites, where a 1, Eq. (11) simplifies
by optical microscopy and AFM for: (d) I = 103 M, pH 3.5; (N) I = 102 M, pH 3.5; to
(4) I = 102 M, pH 7.4. The dashed line denotes theoretic results calculated from the
DLVO theory for a continuous zeta potential distribution. HL ¼ k2 Hs : ð12Þ
This approach was generalized in Refs. [37,38] assuming that an
D /b /b =kT effective particle immobilization can occur on sites formed by ns
HL ¼ Sg ka nb t ffi e Sg nb t: ð9Þ closely spaced molecules (polyelectrolytes or proteins). It was
a kT
shown in these works, assuming the Poisson statistics that the cov-
The results calculated using Eqs. (7)–(9), referred to as the DLVO erage of adsorption sites composed of ns or more particles is given
theory predictions, are shown by the dashed line in Fig. 7. As can be by the expression.
seen, for f < 0, the DLVO theory predicts negligible latex deposition,
after 24 h. This deviates completely from experimental results, X1
ðSHf Þn ðSHf Þns
Hs ðns Þ ¼ eSHf ffi ; ð13Þ
indicating a significant deposition for substrate zeta potential as n¼ns
n ns !
low as 50 mV.
It is interesting to note that such behavior was observed before where S ¼ S =Sg and S is the effective interaction area, whose size is
for heterogeneous surfaces produced by controlled cationic poly- comparable with the cross-sectional area of the site, thus S 1.
electrolyte adsorption [37,38]. As can be noted, the coverage of sites composed of two Fb mol-
As postulated in these works, the deviation from the DLVO the- ecules is proportional to H2f , three molecules H3f , etc. This means
ory is a direct manifestation of a discrete charge distribution that the number of such sites is very low for Fb coverage not
caused by natural fluctuations in the fibrinogen density over the exceeding 0.1.
mica substrate. Because fibrinogen molecules exhibited a net posi- Using Eqs. (13) and (11) one can predict that latex coverage in-
tive zeta potential at pH 3.5, a local increase in their concentration creases initially according to the relationship
at mica could lead to formation of favorable adsorption sites, capa-
Hnf s
ble of immobilizing latex particles. HL ¼ k2 : ð14Þ
Recently, deviations from the classical DLVO theory were theo- ns !
retically analyzed in Ref. [27] using the grid surface integration Thus, in the case of ns = 2, a parabolic dependence of H L on the
(GSI) technique. Both the surface roughness effect and the charge Fb coverage is initially predicted, described by the equation
heterogeity were quantitatively evaluated. The surface heterogene-
ities were assumed to have the form of nanopillars having opposite 1 1
HL ¼ kHs ð2Þ ¼ k2 H2f : ð15Þ
sign of zeta potential as the surface and colloid particles depositing 2 2
on it. A significant decrease in the energy barrier height with the In general, for arbitrary and ns, the latex coverage can be calcu-
size of the nanopillars was predicted for their coverage of 0.25. This lated from Eq. (11) using Eq. (13) to calculate Hs.
seems in a qualitative accordance with our experimental observa- As can be seen in Fig. 8, the experimental data are not properly
tions show in Fig. 7. However, the effect of the nanopillars coverage reflected by theoretic results derived from these equations if ns = 1
has not been studied in Ref. [27], which prohibits a quantitative is assumed, since a much steeper increase of HL/Hmx with the Fb
comparison with our experimental data. Moreover, these theoretic coverage was observed initially. This indicates that adsorption of
results cannot account for the situation arising for pH 7.4, where the latex particles on sites consisting of a single Fb molecule was not
net zeta potential of fibrinogen was negative. Since a significant possible due to too low attractive interaction energy. An analogous
deposition of latex was also observed in this case (see Fig. 6) one phenomenon was previously observed in the case of poly(allyla-
can suspect that there were positive patches on fibrinogen, which mine) hydrochloride and poly(ethylene imine) polyelectrolytes
were used to make permanent contacts with latex particles. [37,38], where latex particle deposition occurred at adsorption
These effects can be properly analyzed in terms of the charge centers composed of two or more closely spaced polyelectrolyte
fluctuation theory previously developed to interpret particle depo- chains.
sition on surfaces covered by polyelectrolytes [36,37] and fibrino- However, a quantitative agreement of theoretic results with the
gen molecules [23]. In a recent work [26], this approach was experimental data shown in Fig. 8 is attained when ns = 2 is as-
exploited to interpret the influence of ionic strength on silica par- sumed (see curve 2). In particular, the parabolic dependence, de-
ticle deposition rates on polyelectrolyte-covered silica surfaces. scribed by Eq. (15) for low Hf coverage, is confirmed. This
462 Z. Adamczyk et al. / Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 356 (2011) 454–464
ΘL/Θ mx
over Fb molecules, bearing patches of positive charge on their
surfaces.
Using the fluctuation theory, one can analyze this effect in more 0.4
detail by determining the number of Fb molecules necessary for
the immobilization of latex particles. As seen in Fig. 9, the experi- 0.2
mental data for pH 7.4 are in accordance with the theoretic predic-
tions derived from Eq. (13) assuming that adsorption sites were
formed by three Fb molecules (solid line in Fig. 10). It is interesting 0.0
to observe that for Hf < 0.1, the experimental data were well de- 0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30
Θf
scribed by the limiting analytical formula derived from Eq. (14)
for ns = 3, Fig. 8. The dependence of the reduced coverage of negative latex particles L800,
HL/Hmx on the fibrinogen coverage Hf. The points denote the averaged exper-
1
HL ¼ k2 H3f : ð16Þ imental results obtained by optical microscopy and AFM (s) for ionic strength
6 103 M, (N) for ionic strength 102 M, pH 3.5, T = 293 K. The solid lines 1–2 denote
theoretic prediction derived from the fluctuation theory, Eqs. (11) and (13) for the
Thus, in this case the latex coverage HL is expected to increase
adsorption site composed of one and two fibrinogen molecules, respectively. The
proportionally to the third power of the Fb coverage for the low dashed line denotes the limiting analytical solution, i.e., HL ¼ 12 k2 H2f =Hmx .
coverage range.
Immobilization of latex particles on sites composed of three Fb
molecules is understandable because at pH 7.4 (I = 102 M) the
partial positive charge on fibrinogen equals 12e [22] being consid-
1.0
erably smaller than the positive charge pH 3.5 (I = 102 M), esti-
mated to be 24e. However, one should remember that the partial 3
1 1
1.0 1.0
2
0.8 2 0.8
0.6 0.6
ΘL/Θ mx
ΘL/Θmx
0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2
0.0 0.0
0.00 0.05 0.10 0.15 0.20 0.25 0.30 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4
Θf Θf
Fig. 10. The dependence of the reduced coverage of latex particles HL/Hmx on the Fig. 11. Same as in Fig. 10 but for pH 7.4, 102 M. The points denote the averaged
fibrinogen coverage Hf for pH 3.5, T = 293 K. The points denote the averaged experimental results obtained by optical microscopy and AFM for (d) the L800
experimental results obtained by optical microscopy and AFM for (d) the L800 latex, and (O) the A800 latex. The solid line 2 denotes theoretic predictions derived
latex, I = 103 M and (N) 102 M; (}) the A800 latex, I = 103 M and (O) 102 M. The from the fluctuation theory, Eqs. (11) and (13), and the dashed line 1 denotes the
solid line 2 denotes theoretic predictions derived from the fluctuation theory, Eqs. results predicted from the DLVO theory for the A800 latex.
(11) and (13), and the dashed line 1 denotes the results predicted from the DLVO
theory for the A800 latex.
[32] M. Wasilewska, Z. Adamczyk, B. Jachimska, Langmuir 25 (2009) 3698. [37] Z. Adamczyk, M. Zembala, A. Michna, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 303 (2006) 353.
[33] Z. Adamczyk, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 229 (2000) 477. [38] Z. Adamczyk, A. Michna, M. Szaraniec, A. Bratek, J. Barbasz, J. Colloid Interface
[34] Z. Adamczyk, Particles at Interfaces: Interactions, Depositions, Structure, Sci. 313 (2007) 86.
Elsevier/Academic Press, Amsterdam, 2006, pp. 214–219. [39] Z. Adamczyk, P. Warszyński, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 63 (1996) 41.
[35] Z. Adamczyk, M. Zembala, P. Warszyński, Bull. Pol. Acad. Chem. 47 (1999) 239. [40] Z. Adamczyk, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci. 100 (2003) 267.
_
[36] K. Sadlej, E. Wajnryb, J. Bławzdziewicz, M. Ekiel-Jezewska, Z. Adamczyk, J. [41] X. Jin, N.H.L. Wang, G. Tarjus, J. Talbot, J. Phys. Chem. 97 (1993) 4256.
Chem. Phys. 30 (2009) 144706.