Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—Severe voltage distortion, due to power system har- unpredictable and serious in an electric power network with
monic resonance, has been reported in recent years. This issue be- high penetration of photovoltaic (PV) inverters due to a large
comes more significant in high penetration of a photovoltaic (PV) number of household capacitors and inverter output capacitors
network. A conventional voltage detection active filter operates as
similar conductance for all harmonic frequencies to resolve this [4].
problem whether in a fixed conductance command or in an auto- According to IEEE Standard 519-1992 [5], maximum al-
matic gain adjustment control. However, its filtering capability is lowable voltage total harmonic distortion (THD) is 5% and
impeded by the mismatch between the active filter and the radial individual voltage distortion is 3% for distribution network be-
line, and the voltage distortion may still be significant. This paper low 69 kV. In order to comply with the harmonics regulation,
proposes a discrete frequency tuning active filter to suppress power
system harmonics. The active filter operates as variable conduc- various active damping approaches have been presented. Ak-
tance for each individual harmonic frequency. Each harmonic con- agi and coworkers proposed a voltage detection active filter
ductance is dynamically adjusted according to the corresponding installed at the end of a radial line to suppress such harmonic
harmonic voltage distortion of the active filter installation point resonance [6], [7]. The damping performance is subject to the
in response to increase or decrease of nonlinear loads, or varia- matching between the harmonic conductance of the active filter
tion of resonant frequency in the power system. The mismatching
problem between the feeder impedance and the active filter can be and the characteristic impedance of the radial line. Therefore,
avoided effectively. Therefore, harmonic voltage distortion can be the capability of the active filter with fixed conductance de-
maintained at an allowable level throughout the feeder with lower clines due to variation of the characteristic impedance in the real
peak current and lower rms current of the active filter, and loads power system. In order to enhance filtering performance, an au-
installed at various locations of the power system receive more tomatic gain adjustment scheme is added to adjust the operating
uniform voltage waveform.
conductance for reducing the voltage distortion at the installa-
Index Terms—Active power filter, harmonic resonance, har- tion point [8]. The harmonic resonance is frequency-dependent
monic voltage damping. and may vary with the damping harmonic conductance, so the
active filter operating at similar conductance for all harmonic
frequencies may suffer the mismatching problem. This is the
I. INTRODUCTION so-called “whack-a-mole” problem, which illustrates uninten-
ITH the advance of semiconductor devices, power elec- tional induction of another harmonic resonance when supply-
W tronics technologies have been developed extensively
for various applications, such as lighting, adjust speed drivers,
ing damping for a specific harmonic frequency [7]. Therefore,
the filtering performance is limited, and some harmonic volt-
and uninterruptible power supply systems. Due to the nonlinear age components may become worse at certain locations along
nature, most power electronics equipment draws nonsinusoidal the line. Distributed installation active filter systems presented
current, and thus, results in significant harmonic pollution in the previously can address this issue. However, a real-time com-
power system. Harmonic voltage amplification along a power munication system [9] or harmonics-drooped control [10], [11]
feeder resulting from the resonance between power factor cor- should be developed to coordinate the operation of active filters
rection capacitors and system inductances, including transmis- for providing effective damping performances.
sion line inductance and transformer leakage inductances, has This paper proposes a discrete frequency tuning active fil-
been reported [1]–[3]. The harmonic resonance may become ter to suppress power system harmonics. The active filter op-
erates as variable conductance at each harmonic frequency.
The damping conductance for individual harmonic frequency
Manuscript received November 10, 2008; revised January 7, 2009. Current
version published April 17, 2009. This work was supported by the National Sci- is determined by the corresponding harmonic voltage dis-
ence Council of Taiwan under Grant NSC 97-2218-E-110-007. Recommended tortion of the active filter installation point. Based on this
for publication by Associate Editor J. H. R. Enslin. scheme, the active filter can dynamically adjust the filtering
T.-L. Lee is with the Department of Electrical Engineering, National Sun
Yat-sen University, Kaohsiung 80424, Taiwan (e-mail: tzunglin.lee@gmail. capability in response to increase or decrease of nonlinear
com). loads and system resonant frequency variation. The annoy-
J.-C. Li is with the Department of Electrical Engineering, Chang Gung Uni- ing “whack-a-mole” problem due to mismatching between the
versity, Taoyuan 333, Taiwan (e-mail: f22835014@yahoo.com.tw).
P.-T. Cheng is with the Center for Advanced Power Technologies, Depart- feeder and the active filter can be avoided effectively. There-
ment of Electrical Engineering, National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu 30013, fore, harmonic voltage distortion throughout the feeder would
Taiwan (e-mail: ptcheng@ee.nthu.edu.tw). be definitely maintained at an allowable level with lower peak
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org. current and lower rms current consumption in the proposed
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPEL.2009.2013863 approach.
Fig. 1. Proposed discrete frequency tuning active filter in a radial line. (a) One-line circuit diagram of the proposed active filter and the associated control.
(b) Conductance tuning control for individual harmonic frequency.
II. OPERATION PRINCIPLES associated harmonic voltage component Ẽabc h of the AFU in-
A simplified one-line diagram of the proposed discrete fre- stallation point. Harmonic voltage components can be derived
quency tuning active filter is shown in Fig. 1(a). The active filter according to the synchronous reference frame (SRF) transfor-
unit (AFU) is installed at the end of a radial line to terminate mation [12]–[14]. The specific harmonic voltage component
harmonic voltage propagation. The AFU operates as variable Ẽabc h becomes a dc value in the SRF at ωh , so it can be derived
conductance at each harmonic frequency as given, by using a low-pass filter (LPF), as shown in Fig. 1(a). Note that
ωh should be set to extract the corresponding negative-sequence
i∗abc = G∗h · Ẽabc h (1) (i.e., fifth) or positive-sequence (i.e., seventh) harmonic voltage
h component. The current command is then generated by multi-
plying the voltage harmonics and its corresponding conductance
where h represents the harmonic frequency order. The individ-
command. Based on the current command i∗abc , the measured
ual conductance command G∗h is a control gain to suppress the
LEE et al.: DISCRETE FREQUENCY TUNING ACTIVE FILTER FOR POWER SYSTEM HARMONICS 1211
current iabc , and the measured voltage Eabc , the current regula- 3) The reference harmonic voltage distortion is 3% (VD∗h =
∗
tor calculates the voltage command vabc as follows: 3.0%).
4) ωf is set as 62.8 rad to filter out 120 Hz ripple components
∗ Li ∗
vabc = Eabc − (i − iabc ). (2) in the calculation of harmonic voltage distortion.
∆T abc 5) PI controller: kp = 100, ki = 2000.
Here, Li is the output inductor of the AFU, and ∆T is the 6) The AFU is implemented by a conventional three-phase
sampling period [15]. The current regulator operates the inverter voltage source inverter. The PWM frequency is 10 kHz
to synthesize the current as in (1) to accomplish the damping and the sampling frequency is 20 kHz.
functionality. In the simulation, power system parameters are arranged to
Fig. 1(b) shows the proposed discrete frequency tuning illustrate the harmonic amplification issue along the feeder [2],
scheme for harmonic order h. The conductance command of [7], where L is the line inductor and C represents the power
each harmonic frequency G∗h is determined according to the factor correction capacitor installed on the feeder. If the feeder
harmonic voltage distortion VDh at the AFU installation point length is closed to odd multiple of quarter wavelength of specific
Eabc . The harmonic voltage distortion VDh is defined as the harmonic frequency, harmonic voltage resonance occurs and
harmonic voltage component rms value at ωh divided by the then harmonic voltage is severely amplified [7], [17].
voltage rms value as given
Fig. 2. Simulation circuit and steady-state simulation results. (a) Simulation circuit configuration. (b) AFU is OFF. (c) Discrete frequency tuning AFU.
(d) Automatic gain-adjusted AFU. (e) Fifth harmonic voltage distortion on all buses. (f) Seventh harmonic voltage distortion on all buses.
TABLE I
AVERAGE AND VARIANCE VALUES OF VOLTAGE THD, VD5 , AND VD7
LEE et al.: DISCRETE FREQUENCY TUNING ACTIVE FILTER FOR POWER SYSTEM HARMONICS 1213
B. Transient Operation
Fig. 6 shows the conductance commands G∗5 , G∗7 and the har-
monic voltage distortion VD5 , VD7 , THD of the AFU instal-
lation location under nonlinear load variation. NLA increases
to 6.6 kVA at t = 2.0 s and subsequently NLB increases to
6.6 kVA at t = 3.0 s. Fig. 6(a) shows that the increase of non-
linear loads causes higher voltage distortion, thus the PI regu-
lator raises both G∗5 and G∗7 commands to draw more harmonic
current for reducing voltage distortion. VD5 , VD7 would be
maintained at 3%, and voltage THD would be smaller than 5%
as indicated in Fig. 6(b).
Fig. 7 illustrates the transient when the capacitors on bus 4 and
bus 7 are disconnected at t = 2.0 s and t = 3.0 s, respectively. Fig. 4. Magnifying factors of both fifth and seventh harmonics with variation
Due to uneven distribution of the feeder capacitors, the resonant of resonant capacitors. (a) Fifth harmonics. (b) Seventh harmonics.
pattern of the circuit cannot be predicted easily. However, G∗5
and G∗7 can still be tuned effectively according to VD5 , VD7 Fig. 7(b). In addition, voltage THD is always maintained below
in the proposed approach. As shown in Fig. 7(a), G∗5 and G∗7 5% as variation of resonant capacitors.
are decreased because the capacitor on bus 4 getting offline
causes lower voltage distortion. Particularly, G∗7 is reduced sig-
IV. LABORATORY TEST RESULTS
nificantly. On the other hand, the capacitor on bus 7 switching
offline would cause both VD5 and VD7 increased. Therefore, G∗5 Fig. 8 shows a test circuit in the laboratory. System parameters
and G∗7 are raised to maintain VD5 and VD7 at 3%, as shown in are given as follows:
1214 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER ELECTRONICS, VOL. 24, NO. 5, MAY 2009
Fig. 9. Bus voltage waveforms. (a) Bus voltages before the AFU is started.
Fig. 7. Conductance commands and harmonic voltage distortion of the AFU
(b) Bus voltages after the AFU is in operation.
when the capacitors on bus 4 and bus 7 are switched offline at t = 2.0 s and
t = 3.0 s, respectively. (a) Active filter conductance commands. (b) Harmonic
voltage distortion. TABLE II
HARMONIC VOLTAGE DISTORTION WITHOUT ANY FILTERING
TABLE III
HARMONIC VOLTAGE DISTORTION AFTER THE ACTIVE FILTER IS ENGAGED
TABLE IV
HARMONIC VOLTAGE DISTORTION IN THE AUTOMATIC GAIN
ADJUSTMENT CONTROL
Fig. 12. Active filter currents in the automatic gain adjustment control.
Y axis(i∗a f , ia f : 2.8 A/V).
Fig. 10. Active filter currents in the proposed discrete frequency tuning
method. Y axis(i∗a f , ia f : 2.8 A/V).
Fig. 13. Harmonic current components of the AFU in the discrete frequency
tuning method and the automatic gain adjustment control. Y-axis (ia f , h : A).
filters,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 22, no. 5, pp. 1826–1835, Sep.
2007.
[15] T. G. Habetler, “A space vector-based rectifier regulator for AC/DC/AC
converters,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 30–36, Jan.
1993.
[16] P. Jintakosonwit, H. Fujita, and H. Akagi, “Control and performance
of a full-digital-controlled shunt active filter for installation on a power
distribution system,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 17, no. 1, pp. 132–
140, Jan. 2002.
[17] P.-T. Cheng and T.-L. Lee, “Analysis of harmonic damping effect of the
distributed active filter system,” IEEJ Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 126, no. 5,
pp. 605–614, May 2006.
[18] R. Godbole and S. Bhattacharya, “Design and development of a flexible
multi-purpose controller hardware system for power electronics and other
industrial applications,” in Proc. IEEE Ind. Appl. Conf. 43th IAS Annu.
Meet., 2008.
[19] W. R. Ryckaert, K. De Gusseme, D. M. Van de Sype, L. Vandevelde, and
J. A. Melkebeek, “Damping potential of a single-phase bidirectional rec-
tifier with resistive harmonic behavior,” in Proc. IEE Proc.-Elect. Power
Appl., Jan. 2006, vol. 153, no. 1, pp. 68–74.
[20] E. Wu and P. W. Lehn, “Digital current control of a voltage source converter
with active damping of LCL resonance,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron.,
vol. 21, no. 5, pp. 1364–1373, Sep. 2006.
Fig. 14. AFU current to nonlinear loads in various control methods. (p.u.). [21] H. Fujita and H. Akagi, “Voltage-regulation performance of a shunt active
filter intended for installation on a power distribution system,” IEEE
Trans. Power Electron., vol. 22, no. 3, pp. 1046–1053, May 2007.
Therefore, switching devices with lower current rating may be [22] T.-L. Lee and P.-T. Cheng, “Design of a new cooperative harmonic filtering
strategy for distributed generation interface converters in an islanding
used and lower operating current can be accomplished in the network,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 42, no. 5, pp. 1301–1309,
proposed AFU. Sep. 2007.