Analysis of global efforts

to delay the effects of

climate change
GE5102 Climatic Variations and Change

Climate change is one of the main problems that humans face

today. Every country in the world contributes to, and is affected
by it. Thus, every country in the world has to work together to
delay the effects of climate change. There have been several of
such global initiatives in the history of mankind, some ending in
failure, and others seeing much more success than their
counterparts. In this report, we will be analyzing some of the
more prominent and promising climate change mitigation and
adaptation efforts in the last two decades.

Timothy Tan Xin Zhong

h0610124
M10505
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Table of Contents
Introduction ..................................................................................................... 2
Effects of Climate Change ................................................................................. 2
Analysis of Global Climate Change Efforts ....................................................... 3
Reduction of Greenhouse Gas Emissions ...................................................... 5
United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) ... 6
Kyoto Protocol .............................................................................. 6
Copenhagen Accord ...................................................................... 6
In Pursuit of Green Energy ............................................................................ 5
The Adoption of Greener Sources of Energy ........................................... 5
International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) .................................... 5
Methane to Markets Partnership ............................................................ 5
Non-Governmental Initiatives ....................................................................... 5
Global Campaign for Climate Action (GCCA) ........................................... 5
World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD) ............. 5
Conclusion ........................................................................................................ 4
Bibliography ..................................................................................................... 4

1
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Introduction

“We are living on this planet as if we had another one to go to.”

– Terri Swearingen, 1997 Goldman Environmental Prize Winner

The 3rd Assessment Report authored by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate

Change clearly states that “there has been discernable human influence on global

climate.” This stand was echoed by the US Global Change Research Program in

their June 2008 report, stipulating that climate change is unequivocally and primarily

human-induced. Indeed, the human race has played a fundamental role in the

inception of climate change, with the combustion of fossil fuels, the usage of

nitrogen-based fertilizers and the deforestation of forests to make space for human

settlements. Climate change brings with it a myriad of consequences, mostly

negative and unwanted.

There have been several international initiatives to deal with climate change. In this

report, we will be analyzing some of them and determining their effectiveness in

delaying the effects of climate change.

2
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Effects of Climate Change

All over the world, temperatures are expected to rise due to climate change. In fact,

11 of the dozen warmest years since 1850 have occurred in the past 12 years1.

Increasing temperatures bring increased risks of drought and fire. These can cause

crop yields to decline, leading to the starvation of millions.

Figure 1: Global Warming Temperature Anomaly Projections

Image Courtesy: Robert A. Rohde

1
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC)

3
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Ice has also begun to melt at the polar ice caps, glaciers and the Greenland ice

sheet. The situation has become so dire that the Arctic Ocean is estimated to have

40% less ice by 2030 and could even become ice-free by 20502. These will cause

sea levels to rise, inundating low lying areas and damaging property.

"On the island where I live, it is possible to throw a stone from one side to the other. Our
fears about sea level rise are very real. Our Cabinet has been exploring the possibility of
buying land in a nearby country in case we become refugees of climate change.”
– Teleke Lauti, Minister for the Environment, Tuvalu.

An increase in water temperatures caused by climate change will increase the

frequency and magnitude of storms worldwide and bleach corals, which generate

US$375 billion in goods and services annually and support the livelihoods of 500

million people all over the world.3

There is no debate regarding the severity of climate change and the devastation it

can bring. Something must be done to deal with climate change and its adverse

consequences.

2
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC)
3
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration - United States Department of Commerce

4
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Analysis of Global Climate Change Efforts

“Plans to protect air and water, wilderness and wildlife are in fact plans to protect man.”
– Stewart Udall, United States Secretary of the Interior from 1961 to 1969

Climate change mitigation and adaptation efforts in

the history of mankind can be likened to a long dusty
Texan country road leading to nowhere. The climate
change conferences, treaties and protocols are like the
occasional ramshackle huts dotting the horizon, few
and far in between, each one no more useful than the
one preceding it. Occasionally there are some that
look promising. However, none can house the 7 billion
people in the world. After all, dealing with climate
change is an all or nothing business. You either save the world or you do not. Up to now, we
are still in desperate need of a ramshackle hut that can house the entire human race.

Climate change is theoretically the perfect topic for an international agreement. After

all, all 194 countries in the world4 contribute to, and are affected by climate change

and should therefore be willing to help stop it. However, it is very hard to agree on

exactly what to do and how to do it. Such an international agreement would have to

encompass a mechanism that is stringent, equitable and cost effective. No wonder

the global initiatives in human history can be likened to ramshackle huts along a

Texan country road, few, far in between, and not able to save the world.

4
United States State Department

5
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

We will now be analysing some of the more prominent and promising global

initiatives within the last two decades. The case studies have been segregated into

three different sections based on their objectives. The three sections are as follows:

Reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, In pursuit of green energy and Non-

governmental initiatives.

Reduction of Greenhouse Gas Emissions

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change

In this section, we will be focusing solely on the United Nations

Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) as it is

most prominent global initiative to stop climate change by reducing greenhouse gas

emissions. It is an international treaty drafted and adopted in June 1992. Annual

meetings called the Conferences of the Parties (COP) are held for all the parties that

have ratified the UNFCCC. The objective of these meetings is to formulate policies,

treaties and legislation to combat climate change. The famous Kyoto Protocol was

drafted and adopted in 1997 at COP 3, while the latest COP is in fact the widely

covered Copenhagen Summit. We will discuss them in further detail later in this

section.

6
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

The objective of the UNFCCC is as follows:

“… to achieve, in accordance with the relevant provisions of the Convention, stabilization of

greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that would prevent dangerous
anthropogenic interference with the climate system. Such a level should be achieved within a
time-frame sufficient to allow ecosystems to adapt naturally to climate change, to ensure
that food production is not threatened and to enable economic development to proceed in a
sustainable manner.”
– Full Text of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change

However, there is an inherent problem in the UNFCCC treaty. The treaty does not

set a compulsory limit on the amount of greenhouse gas emissions that countries

can emit. Every pledge is therefore self-decided and self-imposed. There is also an

absence of enforcement mechanisms, meaning that every pledge is self-regulated.

What do you get when you leave several children in an empty room and tell them not

to quarrel? Similarly, without stringent enforcement measures, governments will be

insufficiently pressured to meet their targets.

There are also many conflicts between developing and developed countries

regarding the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. As Stephen Leahy puts it,

“What is abundantly clear is the enormous divide between the rich and poor countries. Poor
countries want deep cuts in emissions by the industrialized world, and the latter continue to
resist significant cuts and legally binding targets.”
— Stephen Leahy, Climate Change: History Was Not Made, 19th December, 2009

7
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Developing countries feel that although they

do need to attempt to become greener,

developed countries should do much more.

This is because the greenhouse gas

emissions per capita in developed countries

are higher as compared to that of developing

countries in the past and present. In Figure 2,

it can be observed that the carbon dioxide

emissions per capita in high income

countries are much more than that of low

income countries. Developing countries

should not be forced to pay for the enjoyment of Figure 2: Carbon Dioxide Emissions in Tonnes per
Capita (2002)
developed countries. This is the Principle of
Image Credits: World Bank
5
Common but Differentiated Responsibilities ,

which even the UNFCCC recognizes. After all, developing countries are usually the

ones heavily burdened with social problems and yet to fulfil the Millennium Goals set

by the United Nations (UN).

However, in the attempt to defend their current living standards,

developed countries, led by the US feel that countries must carry

the same burden, developing or not, stating claims that developing

countries will be experiencing rapid growth in the future, especially

China and India. If they were not bound by such legislation, their

greenhouse gas emissions would go through the roof.

5
UNFCCC COP 3 – Kyoto Protocol

8
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Such conflicts outline international discussions and policy drafting conferences,

making it hard to draft something that pleases everybody. The US is not in

agreement with the Kyoto Protocol, while almost nobody is in agreement with the

Copenhagen Accord.

Kyoto Protocol

The Kyoto Protocol was drafted and adopted at COP 3 in 1997. As of September

2010, 192 countries have signed the protocol6. Its objectives are best summarized

by the following abstract:

“After 10 days of tough negotiations, ministers and other high-level officials from 160
countries reached agreement this morning on a legally binding Protocol under which
industrialized countries will reduce their collective emissions of greenhouse gases by 5.2%.
The agreement aims to lower overall emissions from a group of six greenhouse gases by
2008-12, calculated as an average over these five years. Cuts in the three most important
gases - carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), and nitrous oxide (N20) - will be measured
against a base year of 1990. Cuts in three long-lived industrial gases - hydrofluorocarbons
(HFCs), perfluorocarbons (PFCs), and sulphur hexafluoride (SF6) - can be measured against
either a 1990 or 1995 baseline.”
– Industrialized countries to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 5.2%, Press release from the
United Nations Environment Program, 11th December 1997

Every participating country sets its own target for reducing greenhouse gas

emissions. As mentioned earlier, this type of self-decided and self-regulated targets

are not able to effectively reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Several countries,
6
Official Website of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change

9
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

notably the US, are also yet to set a definite target. The US is the second largest

greenhouse gas emitter and the country with the largest greenhouse gas emissions

per capita. Thus, the failure of the US to comply has already dug the grave for the

Protocol.

The Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) is a flexible structure implemented by

the Protocol that allows countries to meet their targets by carrying out green projects

in developing countries. Although it provides a pathway where developing countries

can develop sustainably under the funding of developed countries (therefore putting

the monetary burden on the developed countries), it is highly controversial, with its

fair share of problems.

The CDM could cause developing countries to become increasingly dependent on

developed countries for green projects and initiatives. Developed countries might

also impose projects on developing countries that are contrary to their development

interests. In some cases, the projects make job promises to the locals in exchange

for cooperation, which are never fulfilled. In general, the CDM allows rich countries to

continue utilizing fossil fuels while paying the poor not to.

“There are significant constraints to the continuing growth of the CDM as a key instrument
to support mitigation efforts in developing countries.”
– World Development Report 2010: Development and Climate Change by the World Bank

In conclusion, the Kyoto Protocol can be deemed a failure. It is highly unlikely that

the self-decided and self-regulated targets will be met. The treaty was adopted in

10
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

1997, but by 2005, emissions had grown by 24%7. This trend can be clearly

observed in Figure 3.

Figure 3: Total Greenhouse Gas Emissions Worldwide (1990 - 2007)8

“Climate policy, as it has been understood and practiced by many governments of the world
under the Kyoto Protocol approach, has failed to produce any discernable real world
reductions in emissions of greenhouse gases in fifteen years. The underlying reason for this is
that the UNFCCC/Kyoto model was structurally flawed and doomed to fail …”
– The Hartwell Paper, London School of Economics, May 2010

7
World Bank, 2010
8
United States Energy Information Administration Report

11
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Copenhagen Accord

The Copenhagen Summit (COP 15), held from the 7th - 18th of

December 2009, was mostly characterized by fierce debates between

developing and developed countries, with the lack of a concrete, binding

treaty, agreement or document.

"The summit as of this morning is a summit in crisis. Only the arrival of heads of state could
bring the summit to a successful conclusion.”
– The Head of the United Nations Environmental Program in an interview with BBC, on the
18th of December, the last day of the Summit

On the very last day of the Summit, in a bid to come up with something, 5 countries,

India, China, Brazil, South Africa and the US, met up without informing the other

member countries, and drew up the Copenhagen Accord, the only substantial

document to ever have come out of the Copenhagen Summit. This document is non-

binding and simply states the intention of countries to limit warming to no more than

2°C above pre-industrial levels. Undoubtedly, many delegations were visibly

offended at being excluded from this backroom meeting. In the words of the Bolivian

delegation, the means at which the Accord was reached was “anti-democratic, anti-

transparent and unacceptable.” Some therefore decided not to support it. In the end,

the Accord had no legal standing under the UNFCCC. Member countries merely

noted its existence and stated whether they were for or against it.

12
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

"While the White House was announcing the agreement, many other – perhaps most other –
delegations had not even seen it.”
– BBC’s Environment Correspondent

The Copenhagen Accord can therefore be concluded to have done nothing

significant with regards to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. John Sauven,

the Executive Director of Greenpeace UK made this bold remark:

"Copenhagen is a crime scene tonight, with the guilty men and women fleeing to the airport.”
– John Sauven, Executive Director of Greenpeace UK

In conclusion, although the UNFCCC has provided us with an international

framework for future climate change negotiations, there are too many problems and

loopholes in the Kyoto Protocol, Copenhagen Accord and other documents.

Developed countries were meant to take the lead in reducing emissions, which they

failed to, due to selfish economic reasons. The numerous emissions reduction

pledges are also unlikely to be realized, as every country does not fulfil because

others are also not intending to fulfil.

"I'm afraid the pledges of Copenhagen will not be realized. It would be a little political
miracle if it happened. I'm fairly pessimistic.”
– Hans Joachim Schellnhuber, Director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research

The IPCC has warned that unless greenhouse gas emissions begin to decline within

the next 10 to 15 years, we are likely to face severe and even catastrophic impacts.

Countries all over the world have to get their act together if the human race is to

have a chance at stopping climate change.

13
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

In Pursuit of Green Energy

"Climate change is not just another issue. It is the issue

that, unchecked, will swamp all other issues. The only
hope lies in all the countries of the world coming
together around a common global project to rewire the
world with clean energy. This is a path to peace --- peace
among people, and peace between people and nature.”
– Ross Gelbspan, American activist and author of ‘The
Heat is on’ and ‘Boiling Point’

Energy is a fundamental human need. Without it, everything would come to a

standstill. In today‟s world, mankind faces several monumental challenges:

increasing energy demand, the depletion of fossil fuel stores and climate change.

These contribute to the urgent need to transform the energy sector from one heavily

reliant on fossil fuels to one that utilizes greener sources of energy. In this section,

we would be discussing three case studies: The adoption of greener sources of

energy, the International Renewable Energy Agency, and the Methane to Markets

Partnership.

The Adoption of Greener Sources of Energy

“The spin-off benefits of a renewable powered future are simply too good to ignore. By their
very nature, renewable energies are secure, affordable, easily accessible, and clean. And
because of these traits, it can preserve the environment and protect our climate. It can boost
economic growth and create local jobs that will lead to regional development. It can even
increase social cohesion and make the world’s energy supplies more secure.”
– Hélène Pelosse, Director General of IRENA

14
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Greener sources of energy, such as solar, wind and hydroelectric energy provide

mankind with an answer to many of the current challenges facing the world. They are

renewable and unlimited, unlike fossil fuels. They are currently more expensive than

gas and oil, but prices are expected to be lower than that of fossil fuels in the near

future. They are also much more environmentally friendly, producing negligible

amounts of pollution. Many countries recognize the numerous benefits that

renewable energy provides, causing them to adopt such sources of energy.

Figure 4: World Energy Consumption and their Sources (1973 & 2005)9 10

In Figure 4, it can be observed that although the usage of gas increased from 18.4%

in 1973 to 20.0% in 2008, the usage of coal and oil, two other forms of fossil fuel,

dropped from 10.2% to 3.7% and from 56.2% to 48.7% respectively. This is because

the current stores of coal and oil are much smaller than the current stores of gas,

9
Mtoe = Million Tons of Oil Equivalent
10
Key World Energy Statistics 2010 – International Energy Agency (IEA)

15
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

causing a transition towards gas and other alternatives such as geothermal energy.

This has caused the usage of such alternatives (Other) to increase from 0.7% in

1973 to 1.8% in 2008.

Figure 5: World Energy Consumption and their Sources (1971 - 2005)9 10

In Figure 5, the thin red line representing renewable energy gradually becomes

visible as time progresses, showing the gradual increase in the usage of green

energy, though fossil fuels still provide approximately 75% of the world‟s energy

requirements.

The adoption of green energy is a separate venture by different countries, but under

the same global goal to reduce our dependence on fossil fuels and to stop climate

change. Countries have to start shifting towards greener sources of energy, such as

16
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

solar panels, biofuels and hydroelectric dams if we are to have a chance of stopping

climate change in its tracks. Sooner or later, countries would have to switch to

alternative sources of energy when fossil fuels run out, explaining the trend depicted

in Figures 4 and 5. This switch is steady, but slow. Much more has to be done, by

more countries, to make that thin red line the thick one that our planet deserves.

International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA)

"Promoting renewables must now become a global and universal priority, and IRENA is a
necessary condition for that goal. If we intend to embark on the renewable energy revolution,
we cannot do it without IRENA."

– Bianca Jagger, Chair of the World Future Council

The International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) was founded by the UN on

26th January 2009. It intends to act as the global voice for renewable energy, and will

promote the adoption of all forms of green energy on a global scale. To date, there

are 149 countries that have joined IRENA11. Although there are numerous

campaigns, alliances and agencies actively promoting the switch towards green

energy, IRENA is the largest, most empowered (by the UN) and most prominent

global initiative focusing on the pursuit of green energy.

11 nd
Official Website for the International Renewable Energy Agency, dated 22 September 2010

17
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Various UN organizations work in the field of renewable energy. But IRENA is the only one
dedicated to the promotion of 100% renewable energy worldwide. IRENA and the UN will
join forces to speed up the transformation of the global energy sector

– Hélène Pelosse, Director General of IRENA

A possible reason for the slow uptake of renewables as mentioned earlier is the fact

that the path towards green energy is a hard one. There are numerous obstacles,

such as lengthy paperwork, import tariffs and technical barriers. IRENA intends to

formulate comprehensive solutions to such problems. It will also provide

governments with advice, information and support with regards to policy drafting,

financial mechanisms and best practices.

“The creation of IRENA can be seen as the most important decision ever taken on the global
level in favour of renewable energy. The founding of IRENA sent out a very strong signal to
the world community that renewable energy will have to play and will play a key role in the
future energy supply all over the world.”

– The World Wind Energy Association after giving their 2010 World Wind Energy Award to
the founding member states of IRENA

The formation of IRENA was a huge step in the pursuit of green energy. With the

legislative power of the UN, it intends to blast through the financial, technological and

political barriers that block the road to a future powered by green energy. It is by far

the most prominent global initiative, with the backing of numerous countries,

alliances and associations. As it is still fairly young, it is still hard to tell if it will do any

18
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

good. However, with a substantial host of accolades and awards so far, expectations

are extremely high.

Methane to Markets Partnership

The Methane to Markets Partnership is an international initiative between countries

to recover methane from sources such as coal mines and landfills for usage as an

alternative source of energy. This initiative comprises of two thrusts. Firstly, it

removes methane from the atmosphere, which made up 10.5% of global greenhouse

gas emissions in 200812. Although methane levels are lower than that of carbon

dioxide, it is 25 times better at trapping atmospheric heat. Next, the captured

methane is combusted to produce energy. This energy source does not produce as

much carbon dioxide as other fossil fuels, with the emission of 30% less carbon

dioxide than oil, and 45% less carbon dioxide than coal13.

“The Methane to Markets Partnership is a true success story in the fight against climate
change and the transition to a clean energy economy. Methane to Markets is helping
countries mitigate climate change, develop new sources of clean energy, and protect their
local environments.”

– Gina McCarthy, Assistant Administrator for EPA’s Office of Air and current chair of the
Methane to Markets steering committee

12
United States Energy Information Administration, 2008
13
Natural Gas Supply Association, 2010

19
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

There are many initiatives with regards to alternative sources of energy. However,

what is interesting about this global partnership is the fact that it reduces greenhouse

gas emissions, promotes a shift towards green energy and generates huge amounts

of wealth all at the same time. The typical global initiative shows the economy being

pitted against the environment. However, in this instance, we get to eat the cake and

keep it too. Equipped with this particular unique characteristic, it is bound to be very

effective, propelled forward by the greed of countries, which usually barricades the

way for other global initiatives against climate change. This explains why the US is

playing such an active role in this particular venture, being the country steering and

leading the partnership. Due to the sheer importance of the US and it being one of

the major polluters, any agreement actively backed by her is likely to be successful.

In this section, we have analyzed the effectiveness of the adoption of green energy,

IRENA and the Methane to Markets Partnership against climate change. In summary,

although countries are indeed adopting green energy, the level of uptake is very slow.

IRENA intends to change that. Being empowered by the UN, it has done wonders

despite only being founded in 2009. The Methane to Markets Partnership has by far

the most ingenious idea yet, reducing greenhouse gases, providing green energy

and generating funds all at the same time. It has also managed to get the US

actively promoting it, which is no easy feat. If we compare these initiatives with the

earlier section on the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, the adoption of green

energy has seen much more achievements and progress.

20
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Non-Governmental Initiatives

People all over the world are watching. They watch the Copenhagen Summit

disintegrate and fall to pieces. They watch movies such as „The Age of Stupid‟ and

read books such as „Earth in the Balance‟. And many are unhappy. Some decide to

take matters into their own hands, but to do that, they would have to become

empowered. They would have to unite together under one banner and attempt to win

with numbers. This is how many non-governmental organizations and campaigns

begin. In this section on non-governmental initiatives, we will be discussing two such

examples: the Global Campaign for Climate Action and the World Business Council

for Sustainable Development.

Global Campaign for Climate Action

There are countless non-governmental organizations (NGOs) that campaign for

action against climate change. The Global Campaign for Climate Action (GCCA) is

one of the few ventures that unite all these non-governmental alliances, trade unions

and faith groups under a single name, making it a global initiative. Organizations

participating in the GCCA include the World Wildlife Fund, Avaaz and Greenpeace.

The GCCA attempts to galvanize governments and the masses to support rapid

action against climate change. As the GCCA is non-governmental, it has to resort to

petitions, protests and demonstrations to bring its message across.

The problem with such NGOs is that they usually lack legislative and political power.

They are only attempting to influence government decisions, which are often made

21
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

without considering the actions of these NGOs, as the government takes into

consideration other factors that are considered of higher priority, such as economic

growth and business interests.

However, they do help to increase community awareness and act as a constant

reminder to the human race that the problem called climate change still exists, just

like an alarm clock programmed with a snooze function. We should therefore give

them some credit for that.

22
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

World Business Council for Sustainable Development

“Respondents identified the World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD)
and the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) to be the most influential forums.”
– Race to the Top: Attracting and Enabling Global Sustainable Business, a 2003 World Bank
and International Finance Corporation (IFC) commissioned study.

The World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD) is a NGO

comprising of 189 international companies, including well-known companies such as

Coca-Cola, Sony and General Motors. These companies feel that it is possible to

merge business with sustainable development, two seemingly opposing elements.

The purpose of the WBCSD is to provide a platform where companies can come

together to conceptualize ideas and to share expertise, knowledge and resources in

the common goal to achieve sustainable growth and development.

“Business is good for sustainable development and

sustainable development is good for business.”
– Adapted from WBCSD’s 10 messages by which to operate

Many governments are fearful of backlash by companies if they were to promise to

cut down on greenhouse gas emissions, or if they were to crack down on illegal

waste dumping or the unsustainable usage of resources. However, the formation of

the WBCSD proves to the world that such fears are unsupported. It makes a

powerful statement, as these international companies are intent on going green even

though they will probably lose out financially by doing so. Although the WBCSD is

simply a NGO, it is still extremely powerful, due to the fact that many large

international companies and businesses, such as Rio Tinto and IBM are its active

23
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

members. This effectively puts sustainable development on the political agenda. A

2006 GlobeScan survey surveyed experts on the importance of various

organizations in the advancement of sustainable development. The WBCSD took

second place, with approval rates of 54%, losing only to the EU14.

Figure 6: Results of the GlobeScan Survey 2006

In conclusion, although NGOs typically lack political and legislative power and

influence, they still attempt to get their message across by bringing many companies,

organizations and people under a single banner, causing the whole to be greater

than the sum of its parts. They also help to act as a constant reminder to the human

race that the problem called climate change still exists, and is yet to be solved.

14 th
GlobeScan Survey of Sustainability Experts, by GlobeScan Incorporated, 20 July 2006

24
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Conclusion
Global efforts to delay the effects of climate change have varying levels of

effectiveness. Some are hindered by factors such as the lack of legislative power

and general apathy. Others are more successful as they possess the essential

elements such as stringent enforcement measures, high cost effectiveness and the

strong support of governments.

The general consensus is that the current progress is still not enough. There may be

ramshackle huts that may be able to house thousands. Some have a carrying

capacity of millions. However, these huts combined are still unable to contain the 7

billion people in the world. Mary Robinson, the President of Ireland from 1990 – 1997

referred to climate change and commented that “we are not showing the intelligent

capability of leadership to deal with it.” Something redemptory and revolutionary

needs to be done, and fast. If not in the near future, we may find that there is no

longer a need for us to do so.

25
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

Bibliography
Adaptation Fund. (2009). How to apply. Retrieved from http://www.adaptation-fund.org/howtoapply
Andersen, M. (2010, January 15). Copenhagen was more than the accord. Retrieved from
http://www.denmark.dk/en/menu/Climate-Energy/COP15-Copenhagen-2009/Selected-COP15-
news/Copenhagen-was-more-than-the-accord.htm
Asia-Pacific Partnership on Clean Development and Climate. (n.d.). Asia-Pacific partnership on clean
development and climate. Retrieved from http://www.asiapacificpartnership.org/english/default.aspx
BBC News. (2005, November 24). Q&A: Blair's climate strategy. Retrieved from
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/4466842.stm
BBC News. (2005, February 16). Q&A: the Kyoto protocol. Retrieved from
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/4269921.stm
Birgfeld, E. (2010, September 07). Thirty-six governments to meet in Mexico on greenhouse gas
reductions, clean energy. Retrieved from
http://www.epa.gov/methanetomarkets/pdf/press_announcement090710.pdf
Bodansky, D., & Chou, S. (2004). International climate: efforts beyond 2012: a survey of approaches.
Braasch, G. (n.d.). World view of global warming: the photographic documentation of climate change.
Retrieved from http://www.worldviewofglobalwarming.org/pages/temperate-zone.html
Climatic Research Unit, School of Environmental Sciences, University of East Anglia, (2005). Global
temperature for 2005: second warmest year on record.
Doyle, A. (2009, October 27). Backers of UN climate treaty look to 2010 for deal. Retrieved from
http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE59Q2TG20091027
Doyle, A. (2010, August 28). Climate aid reaches $30 bln goal, but is it new?. Retrieved from
http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2010/8/29/worldupdates/2010-08-
28T213306Z_01_NOOTR_RTRMDNC_0_-510913-2&sec=Worldupdates
Eindiguer, D. (2009, June 22). Greens welcome global campaign for climate action . Retrieved from
http://greenparty.ca/media-release/2009-06-22/greens-welcome-global-campaign-climate-action
Gelbspan, R. (2008, December). The heat is online. Retrieved from
http://www.heatisonline.org/contentserver/objecthandlers/index.cfm?ID=7203&method=full
Global Campaign for Climate Action. (n.d.). Global campaign for climate action. Retrieved from
http://gc-ca.org/
Global Movement for Children. (n.d.). Global campaign for climate action. Retrieved from
http://www.gmfc.org/en/action-within-the-movement/gmc-actions/actions-by-imperatives/9-
protect-the-earth-for-children/current-actions/18-global-campaign-for-climate-action
GlobeScan Incorporated. (2006). Omnibus research findings from the 2006-1 survey of sustainability
experts. Retrieved from http://www.wbcsd.org/DocRoot/hOpD0UYvnIfAtTFhJovm/sose06-
1_wbcsd_omni.pdf
Harrabin, R. (2010, September 05). BBC news - Tony Blair: 'heavy price' for climate inaction. Retrieved
from http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-11181330
Ian, S. (2010, September 08). Rich countries may pay $10 bn this year: UN climate chief. Retrieved
from http://sify.com/finance/rich-countries-may-pay-10-bn-this-year-un-climate-chief-news-default-
kjisOcghega.html
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. (2010). IPCC - intergovernmental panel on climate
change. Retrieved from http://www.ipcc.ch/
International Energy Agency. (2010). Key world energy statistics. Retrieved from
http://www.iea.org/textbase/nppdf/free/2010/key_stats_2010.pdf
International Renewable Energy Agency. (2010). IRENA - international renewable energy agency.
Retrieved from http://www.irena.org/

26
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

International Renewable Energy Agency. (2008). The role of IRENA in the context of other
international organizations and initiatives. Retrieved from
http://www.irena.org/downloads/Role_IRENA_IO.pdf
Kete, N., & Baumert, K. (Producer). Developing countries and the climate treaty. [Web]. Retrieved
from http://powerpoints.wri.org/devcountries/sld001.htm
Kinver, M. (2010, September 06). BBC news - climate shifts 'not to blame' for African civil wars.
Retrieved from http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-11204686
Liverman, D. M. (2008). Conventions of climate change: constructions of danger and the dispossession
of the atmosphere. Journal of Historical Geography, Retrieved from
http://www.eci.ox.ac.uk/~dliverma/CV/JHGE07-17.pdf
Methane to Markets. (n.d.). Methane to markets. Retrieved from
http://www.methanetomarkets.org/
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Denmark. (n.d.). Denmark: the official website of Denmark. Retrieved
from http://www.denmark.dk/en
National Geographic. (2007, June 14). Global warming fast facts. Retrieved from
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2004/12/1206_041206_global_warming.html
Nowatzki, R. (2010, February 24). World environment news - hard to agree on UN climate treaty in
2010: De Boer - planet ark. Retrieved from http://http://planetark.org/enviro-news/item/56859
Pelosse, H. (2009, December 03). A climate for renewables. Retrieved from
http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/rea/news/article/2009/12/a-climate-for-renewables
Retallack, S. (n.d.). The Kyoto loopholes. Retrieved from
http://www.twnside.org.sg/title/twr125d.htm
Riahi, L. (2008, April 23). Time for an international renewable energy agency?. Retrieved from
http://www.renewableenergyworld.com/rea/news/article/2008/04/time-for-an-international-
renewable-energy-agency-52254
Rosenberg, M. (2010, June 14). The number of countries in the world - number of countries
worldwide. Retrieved from http://geography.about.com/cs/countries/a/numbercountries.htm
Ryan, D. (2009, March 12). Global methane partnership marks five years of progress. Retrieved from
http://yosemite.epa.gov/opa/admpress.nsf/d985312f6895893b852574ac005f1e40/b2156af5131493
2585257681005edb62!OpenDocument
Shah, A. (2009, October 04). Climate change flexibility mechanisms - global issues. Retrieved from
http://www.globalissues.org/article/232/flexibility-mechanisms
Shah, A. (2002, February 15). COP 3 — Kyoto protocol climate conference - global issues. Retrieved
from http://www.globalissues.org/article/183/cop3-kyoto-protocol-climate-conference
Shah, A. (2009, December 30). COP15 — Copenhagen climate conference - global issues. Retrieved
from http://www.globalissues.org/article/784/cop15-copenhagen-climate-conference
Shah, A. (2009, October 04). Reactions to climate change negotiations and action - global issues.
Retrieved from http://www.globalissues.org/article/179/reactions-to-climate-change-negotiations-
and-action
Shah, A. (2004, December 25). UN framework convention on climate change - global issues. Retrieved
from http://www.globalissues.org/article/521/un-framework-convention-on-climate-change
StatCrunch. (2009). Trends of emissions of greenhouse gases since 1990. Retrieved from
http://www.statcrunch.com/5.0/viewreport.php?reportid=6958
The Bureau of Public Affairs, US Department of State. (n.d.). App home page. Retrieved from
http://www.app.gov/
The Bureau of Public Affairs, US Department of State. (n.d.). US led projects. Retrieved from
http://www.app.gov/usled/index.htm

27
 Analysis of global efforts to delay the effects of climate change
GE5102

The New York Times. (2009, December 18). Copenhagen climate talks (UNFCCC). Retrieved from
http://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/subjects/u/united_nations_framework_conven
tion_on_climate_change/index.html
The World Bank. (2010). World development report 2010: development and climate change.
Retrieved from http://tinyurl.com/worlddevelopmentreport2010
The World Bank & International Finance Corporation. (2003). Race to the top: attracting and enabling
global sustainable business. Retrieved from
http://www.resourcesaver.org/file/toolmanager/CustomO16C45F49313.pdf
Timberlake, L. (2006, July 20). WBCSD tops GlobeScan sustainable development survey. Retrieved
from http://www.wbcsd.org/plugins/DocSearch/details.asp?type=DocDet&ObjectId=MTk2OTg
Tully, M. (2010, September 10). Methane-to-electricity plant draws raves. Retrieved from
http://www.istockanalyst.com/article/viewiStockNews/articleid/4486656
United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. (2010). United Nations framework
convention on climate change. Retrieved from http://unfccc.int/2860.php
US Climate Change Technology Program. (2005). Vision and framework for strategy and planning. US
Climate Change Technology Program, Retrieved from
http://www.climatetechnology.gov/vision2005/cctp-vision2005.pdf
US Department of Energy. (n.d.). Department of energy - climate change. Retrieved from
http://www.energy.gov/environment/climatechange.htm
US Environmental Protection Agency. (2009, September 09). Climate change technology program |
climate change - US climate policy. Retrieved from
http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/policy/cctp.html
US Environmental Protection Agency. (2010, September 15). Press releases | methane to markets
partnership. Retrieved from http://www.epa.gov/methanetomarkets/pressreleases.htm#sept0710
Vidal, J., Stratton, A., & Goldenberg, S. (2009, December 19). Low targets, goals dropped: Copenhagen
ends in failure. Retrieved from http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2009/dec/18/copenhagen-
deal
Williams, L. (2005). Environmental science demystified. US: McGraw-Hill.
World Business Council for Sustainable Development, . (2010). World business council for sustainable
development. Retrieved from
http://www.wbcsd.org/templates/TemplateWBCSD5/layout.asp?MenuID=1
World Wildlife Fund. (2010). WWF - climate - businesses call for action on climate change. Retrieved
from http://www.worldwildlife.org/climate/businesses-call-for-action.html
World Wildlife Fund. (2010). WWF - climate - WWF and climate change: influencing policy. Retrieved
from http://www.worldwildlife.org/climate/policy/index.html
World Wildlife Fund. (2010). WWF - government relations and policy - climate change. Retrieved from
http://www.worldwildlife.org/what/howwedoit/policy/climatechangeissues.html
World Wind Energy Association. (2009, September 16). Press release: IRENA and REN-Alliance have
agreed to work together. Retrieved from
http://www.wwindea.org/home/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=252&Itemid=40

28