Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless
you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you
may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use.
Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at .
http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=ucal. .
Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed
page of such transmission.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
University of California Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Film
Quarterly.
http://www.jstor.org
2
k::
see this relationship in its most obvious form in Big Carnival), may well have been the presence
Double Indemnity and The Fortune Cookie, of aggressive rather than sensitive actors in the
both of which revolve around insurance swin- central roles. As a British critic noted, "When
dles, with one partner, an innocent, romantic this singularly dispassionate man makes a film
dupe, exploited to another's advantage (and the without infallible charm stars, like Jack Lem-
innocent in The Fortune Cookie has an innocent mon or Marilyn Monroe, there is an appalled
he exploits). But this perverse partnership is pursing of lips and wrinkling of noses, as though
also present in, for instance, the friendship of he had made a nasty mistake, like a puppy that
Tony Curtis and Lemmon in Some Like It Hot isn't quite house-trained." Wilder's humor, like
-Curtis is constantly bilking and frustrating his all great comedy, springs from threatening sit-
friend. Wilder's is a world of sophisticated uations. "Good taste" is a joke to him, because
pimpery, and in Irma la Douce he goes so far as he plunges the audience into the sordid and the
to present the whore and the pimp as the inno- unbearable.
cent, natural hero and heroine, an idea he had A secondary but pervasive Wilder "touch" is
already toyed with in The Apartment, with the his cynical-romantic use of movie legends. Like
same actor and actress. Lenny Bruce and Terry Southern, Wilder likes
In general, Wilder's point of view is that of to graft show-business argot and mannerisms
an innocent fascinated by the world's corruption onto the outside world. In almost every one of
and attempting, with some success and a great his films, there is a playful recalling of the movie
deal of comic tension, to join in on it. But the past, often re-enacted by one of the original
innocence is his ideal, and he ultimately returns participants. In a way, Wilder is a quintessential
to it (as in the memorably boyish ending scene fan. When he refers to silent movies in Sunset
of The Fortune Cookie, with Lemmon and his Boulevard, it is less the quotation the younger
black buddy tossing a football in the hazy French directors employ than an expose, giving
deserted stadium) or else works out an appro- the audience the voyeuristic pleasure of pene-
priate retribution, frequently death, for his most trating beneath the surface, of seeing demi-gods
absorbingly repellent characters. Wilder's mate- at play. In "exposing" faded glamor even while
rial is almost always serious, and his approach succumbing to its seductiveness, Wilder is again
almost always farcical and ironic. Like his win- supplying the metaphor of the con-game. (This
some hero and heroine Lemmon and MacLaine, probably accounts for what James Agee diag-
he wants to be loved. In Wilder we can see per- nosed as a condescension toward silent movies.)
haps one of the most interesting examples of a Wilder exhibits a sort of saftig Pirandellianism
conflict between box-office values and uncom- when he has Monroe, Marlene Dietrich, and
promising intentions. He works hard to come up Dean Martin play mockeries of themselves in
with genuinely happy endings for most of his several of his films; when he makes up Barbara
films, feeling that the audience deserves "a little Stanwyck to look like Dietrich and has her play
bonus at the end because they sat still for what "Lola Dietrichson" in Double Indemnity; when
we had to tell." He is making exactly the films he has Tony Curtis spoof Gary Grant in Some
he wants to make, but there is a continual ten- Like It Hot and James Cagney recreate the
sion between his darker fascinations and his grapefruit scene from The Public Enemy in
sense of audience communication-which prob- One, Two, Three. Sometimes the worm turns-
ably accounts for his curious charm. When Wil- in Some Like It Hot, Edward G. Robinson Jr.
der "goes too far," as most critics said of Kiss flips a coin a la George Raft in Scarface and
Me, Stupid, it may be because he has misjudged Raft, angered, snatches away the coin.
how much fooling with depravity and horror his Wilder's conception of life as a game, with
audience will sit still for. A partial reason for the swifties on one side and the law on the
that film's failure, and for the utter disaster of other, may also account for his fondness for
Ace in the Hole (which had to be retitled The sports. He often names his characters after ath-
WILDER 5
letes, especially after college football players. A For a notorious cynic, he has a remarkably mor-
football game is the perfect stylization of the alistic attitude, rather like Fellini's.
con-game; it is played out in the open, enforced
rigorously by uniformed officials, it is action
II.
through grace and strategy-but the underbelly
is gambling and commercialism. Wilder would "Some joke!"
probably enjoy reducing life to the rules of -George Raft's dying words
sports (or of card playing, another of his ob- in Some Like It Hot
sessions).* His twin ideals seem to be the inno-
cent whore and the innocent athlete, livers of a Some Like It Hot opens in one of those lurid
life at once instinctual and encircled with cor- vintage Warner Brothers nights, saturated with
ruption, an irony which he, the clever pimp, can death and hip cynicism. This gayest of Wilder's
enjoy. Shirley MacLaine in Irma and Ron Rich, comedies, his most highpowered piece of gag
the black football player in The Fortune Cookie, creation, hovers constantly on the edge of the
are variants of the same character. macabre. The first things we see are a hearse,
Pimp and whore work out their balancing act a gun battle, and a raid on a speakeasy fronting
between innocence and evil with two other typ- as a funeral parlor. Before long we have edged
ical characters in attendance-the policeman, into the St. Valentine's Day Massacre, a scene
instrument of society, and the morally vacuous of straight-faced brio and cold carnage capped
"observer." The pattern varies considerably by the immaculately shod "Spats" Colombo
from film to film, however; sometimes both are (Raft) kicking a toothpick from the mouth of
present, sometimes they are combined into one a well-ventilated corpse. The psychotic intensity
unnerving character. The observer usually func- of the backdrop throws the boisterous vulgarity
tions as both a refuge and a goad for the hero-- of the blue humor into a kind of limbo between
witness the bartenders in The Lost Weekend innocence and depravity. The movie's ostenta-
and Irma, Erich von Stroheim's butler in Sunset tious artificiality-the outrageous coincidences
Boulevard, the spineless editor in Ace in the that keep the plot moving, the filthy stream of
Hole, the tongue-clucking Jewish couple in The double-entendre, the many obvious grabs from
Apartment. The observer is the voice of con- old movies-all this seals us off from the desola-
science, a more wrenching but less urgent char- tion lurking in the wings. Seesawing between
acter than the voice of authority-a gallery of nightmare and farce, Wilder keeps a heady
types that includes Edward G. Robinson's jump or two ahead of any kind of reality.
paternalistic boss in Double Indemnity, Frank You have to go back to Stalag 17-also rife
Faylen's creepy orderly in The Lost Weekend, with transvestite jokes-to find a similar con-
Charles Laughton's driving barrister in Witness, trapuntal use of gags and backdrop, or a more
and Cliff Osmond's snide detective in The For- extreme justification for the characters' irre-
tune Cookie. This figure is often emotionally sponsibility. Joe and Jerry (Curtis and Lem-
involved with the pimp, either by protecting mon), the accidental witnesses to the massacre,
him or by reproving him. And in rejecting the are dead ducks unless they flee to Miami dis-
representative of normality (who can often be guised as women, an act which calls up curious
seen as a father-figure), the pimp is risking total resonances of Midnight Cowboy. Their only op-
alienation; to return from the abyss, he must tions are death or transvestism. They choose the
domesticate his whore, or abandon her. Vice is fate worse than death. Joe exploits women's
fun, says Wilder, but you'll always get caught. dress to heterosexual advantage, but Jerry
camps up his role, giggling and shrieking like a
*This may explain the most incongruousof Wilder's slapstick drag queen. Their sexual dissonance
projects, The Spiritof St. Louis. CharlesLindbergh may have been suggested to Wilder by the ten-
probably appealed to his latent hero-worship. sions in the Martin and Lewis comedy act; there
WILDER
III.
"If you want to tell people the truth,
you'd better make them laugh or they'll
kill you." -Bernard Shaw
The reporter in Ace in the Hole is an unmit- the id but also of the female organ and the
igated son of a bitch. The unusual vehemence womb. Wilder comes right out with the under-
of the film perhaps stems from the fact that tones in the obscene ditty warbled by a cow-
Chuck Tatum (Kirk Douglas) is presented as boy singer to the thousands of spectators out-
cynical and his actions presented as heinous. A side the cave:
man suffers torture and eventually dies-far
different from most of Wilder's other victims, We're coming, we're coming, Leo,
who seem to allow themselves to be used. The Leo, don't despair-
While you're in the cave a-hopin'
actions of the gigolo in Sunset Boulevard are
We are up above you gropin'
certainly cruel, for instance, but he is vindicated And we soon will make an openin'
somewhat by the fact that he is hurting himself
Oh Leo!
more than he is hurting the woman; he at least
adds some excitement to her life. And even Leo, Wilder's exposition of the events is not mere-
the victim of Ace in the Hole, plays along. Ta- ly clever, it is a shrewd commentary on human
tum wins his friendship by leading the "rescue" nature. The way, for example, that the golden
operations, and Leo is naively thrilled by the goose is killed. First Tatum bribes the sheriff
tumult: "My picture in the paper? No kidding?" (by promising to make him the hero of the
But the injustice is monstrous and totally un- "rescue") into drilling from the top of the moun-
provoked. It is in the nature of things for the tain instead of going through the cave opening,
strong to prey on the weak, but for the strong thus delaying the rescue by a week so the story
to prey on the helpless adds a dimension to can be built up. The sheriff forces compliance
Wilder's vision. of the construction foreman, a worried and
The sexual aspect of the story is ferocious. rather gentle man, by threatening to bust him
Leo's sluttish wife is overjoyed when he falls to truck driver. It becomes a matter of his life's
down the hole-she's rid of him at last. The work against Leo's life, a hard choice. Then,
excitement seems to stimulate her sexually, and after several days of drilling, Leo gets pneumo-
she throws herself at Tatum, who uses her to nia. Tatum decides to have him taken out the
seal the bargain. When Tatum kisses her, his easy way, but it's too late-the drilling has dis-
hand in large close-up grasping at her platinum lodged the structure of the cave, making rescue
hair, Wilder dissolves to the big drill "pounding through the entrance impossible. So Leo dies.
and driving towards Leo" (the radio announc- The narrative has the purity of a mathematical
er's words). Even the title has a faintly anal formula, abetted by the almost documentary
ring to it, and the descents into the cave have veracity of the physical details and the char-
implications not only of the underworld and acters' behavior.
8 WILDER
Even more audacious than the sexual satire journalism school who is corrupted by Tatum's
are the connotations of blasphemy. Tatum brash sophistication. The ease in the boy's
builds his story around the angle of a "curse" change from an idealist to Tatum's hanger-on
put on Leo by the Indian spirits inhabiting the implies that he was shallow from the beginning.
mountain, which is known as The Mountain of Which is the point, of course, but it does indi-
the Seven Vultures. Leo believes in the curse, cate a limitation in Wilder's perspective. What
and Tatum encourages him. But later Tatum's would he have done with a strong idealist? The
glibness backfires, and the curse takes on a editor is also a weak idealist, questioning Ta-
strange reality. There is a grim moment when tum's actions while doing nothing about them.
Leo, maddened by the constant pounding of the One dismisses as jejune the complaint that met
drill, tells Tatum, "It's enough to wake the Ace in the Hole at the time of its release ("an
dead." And when Leo is being given the last unfair portrait of journalism"), but it is true
rites, Wilder cuts to an extreme close-up of that the film's case tends to be loaded. For
Tatum on the words, "Bless me, father, for I Tatum's scheme to work, everybody involved
have sinned." Finally, when Leo dies, Tatum had to be a push-over, either corrupt or naive.
mounts a crane platform and rises high into the Though Wilder shows an admirable tenacity
air, overlooking the crowd like a god as he in pursuing his premise, he builds his case in a
ascends to the top of the mountain. His sermon way that Stroheim or Lubitsch, true cynics,
is brief: "The circus is over . . . " Wilder is would not. There is little sense in Wilder of
not implying a dormant religious sense awak- human potentiality-as there is in Stroheim's
ened in Tatum. He is invoking instead the viola- McTeague and Trina in Greed-only a sense of
tion of taboo. more or less acquiescence to the rottenness of
Cynic that Tatum is, there is something that life. A true cynic (to be distinguished from a
affects him, some remnant of fear in his nature mere skeptic) has a conviction of the useless-
that surfaces when his actions get out of control. ness of life, a feeling in no way incompatible
Wilder is usually tolerant of almost anything with grace, grandeur of spirit, and sympathy.
his characters do, and there is only the merest The destruction of McTeague and Trina does
iota of religious satire in his other work. But the not cancel out the value of their brief period of
religious aspects of Ace in the Hole are the humanity. It indicates that such happiness can
vehicle for his deep revulsion at Tatum's ac- never last, not that it cannot exist. Ace in the
tions. This, perhaps, and not Stalag 17, is Wil- Hole appalls but fails to move-Greed is pro-
der's concentration-camp film. The arrogance foundly moving-and remains a moral "demon-
which is so captivating in Wilder's other heroes stration." On that level it can be faulted for not
is chilling in Tatum, but what is more chilling opening itself to all the possibilities of human
is that everyone lies down and plays dead be-
response.
fore him. Wilder has more in common with that Perhaps this analysis of Wilder gives the im-
other Jewish humorist, Franz Kafka, than he pression that he is pretentious. God forbid. As
would care to admit. he once said, "If there's anything I dislike more
Perhaps the difficulty with some of Wilder's than not being taken seriously, it's being taken
films is not "sentimentality" but a moralism too seriously." He would be the first to admit
which tends to overstate its case. The self- that Ace in the Hole should not be praised
disgust exhibited by the gigolo in Sunset Boule- merely because it was a failure with the public;
vard is essentially a moral waste action, and the
perhaps they were right in objecting to the in-
"pastel" flavor of the prostitution in Irma la sult. But if Wilder does not reach greatness with
Douce was no doubt intended as a reaction Ace in the Hole, he comes close enough to justi-
against heavily emotional treatments of the sub- fy the comparison with Greed. His vision is per-
ject. Wilder skimps seriously on the "innocent" haps too limited to permit its extension to an
in Ace in the Hole, a young reporter fresh out of entire society; when he restricts himself to an
WILDER 9
enclosed group (gangsters and entertainers) in the appallingly ridiculous. But what gives his
Some Like It Hot, there is no friction between comedy the urgency of a judgment on life is the
attempt and achievement. Ace in the Hole, for blackness at the core of his heart. On with The
all its power, suggests that Wilder's talents are Private Life of Sherlock Holmes .
better attuned to the purely ridiculous than to . .
ALAN ROSENTHAL
The Fiction Documentary
INTERVIEWSWITH THE MAKERSOF A MARRIEDCOUPLE
THE PRODUCER-DIRECTOR:
ALLAN KING did then, and finally got a job in television in
Vancouver as a production assistant. I did live
television for two years, but in fact after six
I was born in Vancouver, B.C. in 1930. I went months switched primarily into film. The first
to the University of British Columbia and took film was Skid Row, then three or four more in
Honors Philosophy. Then I drove a taxi for nine Vancouver. Then I left Vancouver.
months, went to Europe for a year and a half, What were your jobs in these films, director,
traveling, hitchhiking, the sort of thing that one producer, production-assistant?