Professional Documents
Culture Documents
- A wealthy Paduan lawyer and Portia͛s standard than Shylock himself, agreeing that his contract damnation by converting, we are less likely to be
cousin. Doctor Bellario never appears in the play, but he very much entitles him to his pound of flesh, but adding convinced. Not only does Antonio͛s reputation as an anti-
gives Portia͛s servant the letters of introduction needed that it does not allow for any loss of blood. Anybody can Semite precede him, but the only instance in the play
for her to make her appearance in court. break the rules, but Portia͛s effectiveness comes from her when he breaks out of his doldrums is his ͞storm͟ against
- Portia͛s servant, whom she dispatches to get ability to make the law work for her. Shylock (I.iii.132). In this context, Antonio proves that the
the appropriate materials from Doctor Bellario. Portia rejects the stuffiness that rigid adherence to the law dominant threads of his character are melancholy and
[ might otherwise suggest. In her courtroom appearance, cruelty.
she vigorously applies the law, but still flouts convention
Although critics tend to agree that Shylock is |he Merchant by appearing disguised as a man. After depriving Bassanio
oa Venice͛s most noteworthy figure, no consensus has of his ring, she stops the prank before it goes to far, but
On the surface, the main difference between the Christian understanding of mercy is based on the way Christians in shall go hard but I will better the instruction͟ (III.i.60ʹ61).
characters and Shylock appears to be that the Christian Shakespeare͛s time understood the difference between Not all of Shylock͛s actions can be blamed on poor
characters value human relationships over business ones, the Old and New Testaments. According to the writings of teachings, and one could argue that Antonio understands
whereas Shylock is only interested in money. The Christian St. Paul in the New Testament, the Old Testament depicts his own culpability in his near execution. With the trial͛s
characters certainly view the matter this way. Merchants God as requiring strict adherence to rules and exacting conclusion, Antonio demands that Shylock convert to
like Antonio lend money free of interest and put harsh punishments for those who stray. The New Christianity, but inflicts no other punishment, despite the
themselves at risk for those they love, whereas Shylock Testament, in contrast, emphasizes adherence to the spirit threats of fellow Christians like Gratiano. Antonio does
agonizes over the loss of his money and is reported to run rather than the letter of the law, portraying a God who not, as he has in the past, kick or spit on Shylock. Antonio,
through the streets crying, ͞O, my ducats! O, my forgives rather than punishes and offers salvation to those as well as the duke, effectively ends the conflict by
daughter!͟ (II.viii.15). With these words, he apparently followers who forgive others. Thus, when Portia warns starving it of the injustices it needs to continue.
values his money at least as much as his daughter, Shylock against pursuing the law without regard for mercy,
suggesting that his greed outweighs his love. However, she is promoting what Elizabethan Christians would have
upon closer inspection, this supposed difference between seen as a pro-Christian, anti-Jewish agenda. |he Merchant oa Venice depends heavily upon laws and
Christian and Jew breaks down. When we see Shylock in The strictures of Renaissance drama demanded that rulesͶthe laws of the state of Venice and the rules
Act III, scene i, he seems more hurt by the fact that his Shylock be a villain, and, as such, patently unable to show stipulated in contracts and wills. Laws and rules can be
daughter sold a ring that was given to him by his dead wife even a drop of compassion for his enemy. A sixteenth- manipulated for cruel or wanton purposes, but they are
before they were married than he is by the loss of the century audience would not expect Shylock to exercise also capable of producing good when executed by the
ring͛s monetary value. Some human relationships do mercyͶtherefore, it is up to the Christians to do so. Once right people. Portia͛s virtual imprisonment by the game of
indeed matter to Shylock more than money. Moreover, his she has turned Shylock͛s greatest weaponͶthe lawͶ caskets seems, at first, like a questionable rule at best, but
insistence that he have a pound of flesh rather than any against him, Portia has the opportunity to give freely of her likening of the game to a lottery system is belied by
amount of money shows that his resentment is much the mercy for which she so beautifully advocates. Instead, the fact that, in the end, it works perfectly. The game
stronger than his greed. she backs Shylock into a corner, where she strips him of keeps a host of suitors at bay, and of the three who try to
Just as Shylock͛s character seems hard to pin down, the his bond, his estate, and his dignity, forcing him to kneel choose the correct casket to win Portia͛s hand, only the
Christian characters also present an inconsistent picture. and beg for mercy. Given that Antonio decides not to seize man of Portia͛s desires succeeds. By the time Bassanio
Though Portia and Bassanio come to love one another, Shylock͛s goods as punishment for conspiring against him, picks the correct chest, the choice seems like a more
Bassanio seeks her hand in the first place because he is we might consider Antonio to be merciful. But we may efficient indicator of human nature than any person could
monstrously in debt and needs her money. Bassanio even also question whether it is merciful to return to Shylock ever provide. A similar phenomenon occurs with Venetian
asks Antonio to look at the money he lends Bassanio as an half of his goods, only to take away his religion and his law. Until Portia͛s arrival, Shylock is the law͛s strictest
investment, though Antonio insists that he lends him the profession. By forcing Shylock to convert, Antonio disables adherent, and it seems as if the city͛s adherence to
money solely out of love. In other words, Bassanio is him from practicing usury, which, according to Shylock͛s contracts will result in tragedy. However, when Portia
anxious to view his relationship with Antonio as a matter reports, was Antonio͛s primary reason for berating and arrives and manipulates the law most skillfully of all, the
of business rather than of love. Finally, Shylock eloquently spitting on him in public. Antonio͛s compassion, then, outcome is the happiest ending of all, at least to an
argues that Jews are human beings just as Christians are, seems to stem as much from self-interest as from concern Elizabethan audience: Antonio is rescued and Shylock
but Christians such as Antonio hate Jews simply because for his fellow man. Mercy, as delivered in |he Merchant oa forced to abandon his religion. The fact that the trial is
they are Jews. Thus, while the Christian characters may Venice, never manages to be as sweet, selfless, or full of such a close call does, however, raise the fearful specter of
talk more about mercy, love, and charity, they are not grace as Portia presents it. how the law can be misused. Without the proper
always consistent in how they display these qualities. c [
ÿ guidance, the law can be wielded to do horrible things.
Throughout the play, Shylock claims that he is simply [
The conflict between Shylock and the Christian characters applying the lessons taught to him by his Christian Twice in the play, daring escapes are executed with the
comes to a head over the issue of mercy. The other neighbors; this claim becomes an integral part of both his help of cross-dressing. Jessica escapes the tedium of
characters acknowledge that the law is on Shylock͛s side, character and his argument in court. In Shylock͛s very first Shylock͛s house by dressing as a page, while Portia and
but they all expect him to show mercy, which he refuses to appearance, as he conspires to harm Antonio, his entire Nerissa rescue Antonio by posing as officers of the
do. When, during the trial, Shylock asks Portia what could plan seems to be born of the insults and injuries Antonio Venetian court. This device was not only familiar to
possibly compel him to be merciful, Portia͛s long reply, has inflicted upon him in the past. As the play continues, Renaissance drama, but essential to its performance:
beginning with the words, ͞The quality of mercy is not and Shylock unveils more of his reasoning, the same idea women were banned from the stage and their parts were
strained,͟ clarifies what is at stake in the argument rears its head over and overͶhe is simply applying what performed by prepubescent boys. Shakespeare was a
(IV.i.179). Human beings should be merciful because God years of abuse have taught him. Responding to Salarino͛s great fan of the potentials of cross-dressing and used the
is merciful: mercy is an attribute of God himself and query of what good the pound of flesh will do him, Shylock device often, especially in his comedies. But Portia reveals
therefore greater than power, majesty, or law. Portia͛s responds, ͞The villainy you teach me I will execute, and it that the donning of men͛s clothes is more than mere
comedy. She says that she has studied a ͞thousand raw Christian teachings, such as the idea that desire is an TAMING OF THE SHREW
tricks of these bragging Jacks,͟ implying that male unreliable guide and should be resisted, and the idea that |he |aming oa the Shrew is one of Shakespeare͛s earliest
authority is a kind of performance that can be imitated human beings do not deserve God͛s grace but receive it in comedies, and it shares many essential characteristics with
successfully (III.iv.77). She feels confident that she can spite of themselves. Christianity teaches that appearances his other romantic comedies, such as Much Ado About
outwit any male competitor, declaring, ͞I͛ll prove the are often deceiving, and that people should not trust the Nothing and A Midsummer Night͛s Dream. These
prettier fellow of the two, / And wear my dagger with the evidence provided by the sensesͶhence the humble characteristics include lighthearted and slapstick humor,
braver grace͟ (III.iv.64ʹ65). In short, by assuming the appearance of the lead casket. Faith and charity are the disguises and deception, and a happy ending in which
clothes of the opposite sex, Portia enables herself to central values of Christianity, and these values are evoked most of the characters come out satisfied. The
assume the power and position denied to her as a woman. by the lead casket͛s injunction to give all and risk all, as lightheartedness of these romantic comedies contrasts
ÿ
one does in making a leap of faith. Portia͛s father has sharply with the darker humor and deeper
Like Shakespeare͛s other comedies, |he Merchant oa presented marriage as one in which the proper suitor risks characterization of Shakespeare͛s later plays, both comic
Venice seems to endorse the behavior of characters who and gives everything for the spouse, in the hope of a divine and tragic. The youthfulness of the playwright can be seen
treat filial piety lightly, even though the heroine, Portia, recompense he can never truly deserve. The contest in the whimsical spirit of the early plays. Like the other
sets the opposite example by obeying her father͛s will. certainly suits Bassanio, who knows he does not deserve romantic comedies, |he |aming oa the Shrew focuses on
Launcelot greets his blind, long lost father by giving the old his good fortune but is willing to risk everything on a courtship and marriage, but, unlike most of them, it
man confusing directions and telling the old man that his gamble. devotes a great deal of attention to married life after the
beloved son Launcelot is dead. This moment of ÿ wedding. The other comedies usually conclude with the
impertinence can be excused as essential to the comedy of The pound of flesh that Shylock seeks lends itself to wedding ceremony itself.
the play, but it sets the stage for Jessica͛s far more multiple interpretations: it emerges most as a metaphor A play focusing on the concerns of married life would have
complex hatred of her father. Jessica can list no specific for two of the play͛s closest relationships, but also calls seemed particularly relevant to English audiences of the
complaints when she explains her desire to leave Shylock͛s attention to Shylock͛s inflexible adherence to the law. The Renaissance period. Theirs was a society concerned with
house, and in the one scene in which she appears with fact that Bassanio͛s debt is to be paid with Antonio͛s flesh marriage in general, thanks in part to Henry VIII͛s
Shylock, he fusses over her in a way that some might see is significant, showing how their friendship is so binding it separation of England from the Catholic Church in 1534 in
as tender. Jessica͛s desire to leave is made clearer when has made them almost one. Shylock͛s determination is order to secure a divorce that the pope had refused to
the other characters note how separate she has become strengthened by Jessica͛s departure, as if he were seeking grant him. Henry͛s troubles highlight one important aspect
from her father, but her behavior after departing seems recompense for the loss of his own flesh and blood by of Elizabethan marriages among the upper class: they
questionable at best. Most notably, she trades her father͛s collecting it from his enemy. Lastly, the pound of flesh is a were most often arranged for money, land, or power,
ring, given to him by her dead mother, for a monkey. The constant reminder of the rigidity of Shylock͛s world, where rather than for love. Moreover, unless you were the king
frivolity of this exchange, in which an heirloom is tossed numerical calculations are used to evaluate even the most of England, the late sixteenth and early seventeenth
away for the silliest of objects, makes for quite a disturbing serious of situations. Shylock never explicitly demands that centuries offered few ways out of an unhappy marriage.
image of the esteem in which |he Merchant oa Venice͛s Antonio die, but asks instead, in his numerical mind, for a Thus, the resolution of marital disputes became an
children hold their parents, and puts us, at least pound in exchange for his three thousand ducats. Where important topic in the popular literature of the era.
temporarily, in Shylock͛s corner. the other characters measure their emotions with long Of particular worry to this society were ͞shrews͟ or
metaphors and words, Shylock measures everything in far ͞scolds͟Ͷthat is, cantankerous or gossipy wives, who
[ more prosaic and numerical quantities. resisted or undermined the assumed authority of the
The contest for Portia͛s hand, in which suitors from various
husband within a marriage. A large number of sermons,
countries choose among a gold, a silver, and a lead casket, The ring given to Shylock in his bachelor days by a woman plays, and pamphlets of the time address related topics:
resembles the cultural and legal system of Venice in some named Leah, who is most likely Shylock͛s wife and Jessica͛s the taming of shrews by their husbands or the public
respects. Like the Venice of the play, the casket contest mother, gets only a brief mention in the play, but is still an punishment of scolds by, for example, repeatedly dunking
presents the same opportunities and the same rules to object of great importance. When told that Jessica has them in a river. Part of this body of literature took a very
men of various nations, ethnicities, and religions. Also like stolen it and traded it for a monkey, Shylock very diplomatic attitude toward women, although much of it
Venice, the hidden bias of the casket test is fundamentally poignantly laments its loss: ͞I would not have given it for a was extremely misogynistic. In some of this literature, it is
Christian. To win Portia, Bassanio must ignore the gold wilderness of monkeys͟ (III.i.101ʹ102). The lost ring allows difficult to distinguish between behavior that is being
casket, which bears the inscription, ͞Who chooseth me us to see Shylock in an uncharacteristically vulnerable parodied and behavior that is presented as an ideal. This
shall gain what many men desire͟ (II.vii.5), and the silver position and to view him as a human being capable of ambiguity may also be found in |he |aming oa the Shrew,
casket, which says, ͞Who chooseth me shall get as much feeling something more than anger. Although Shylock and which manages to lampoon chauvinistic behavior while
as he deserves͟ (II.vii.7). The correct casket is lead and Tubal discuss the ring for no more than five lines, the ring simultaneously reaffirming its social validity. The play
warns that the person who chooses it must give and risk stands as an important symbol of Shylock͛s humanity, his celebrates the quick wit and fiery spirit of its heroine even
everything he has. The contest combines a number of ability to love, and his ability to grieve. while reveling in her humiliation.
ÿ
Petruchio forces Katherine to leave for his country house prone to violence, particularly against anyone who tries to
I N THE ENGLISH COUNTRYSIDE, a poor tinker named Christopher before the feast, telling all in earshot that she is now his marry her. Her hostility toward suitors particularly
Sly becomes the target of a prank by a local lord. Finding property and that he may do with her as he pleases. Once distresses her father. But her anger and rudeness disguise
Sly drunk out of his wits in front of an alehouse, the lord they reach his country house, Petruchio continues the her deep-seated sense of insecurity and her jealousy
has his men take Sly to his manor, dress him in his finery, process of ͞taming͟ Katherine by keeping her from eating toward her sister, Bianca. She does not resist her suitor
and treat him as a lord. When Sly recovers, the men tell or sleeping for several daysͶhe pretends that he loves her Petruchio forever, though, and she eventually subjugates
him that he is a lord and that he only believes himself to so much he cannot allow her to eat his inferior food or to herself to him, despite her previous repudiation of
be a tinker because he has been insane for the past several sleep in his poorly made bed. marriage.
years. Waking in the lord͛s bed, Sly at first refuses to In Padua, Lucentio wins Bianca͛s heart by wooing her with ÿ
- Petruchio is a gentleman from Verona. Loud,
accept the men͛s story, but when he hears of his ͞wife,͟ a a Latin translation that declares his love. Hortensio makes boisterous, eccentric, quick-witted, and frequently drunk,
pageboy dressed in women͛s clothing, he readily agrees the same attempt with a music lesson, but Bianca loves he has come to Padua ͞to wive and thrive.͟ He wishes for
that he is the lord they purport him to be. Sly wants to be Lucentio, and Hortensio resolves to marry a wealthy nothing more than a woman with an enormous dowry,
left alone with his wife, but the servants tell him that a widow. Tranio secures Baptista͛s approval for Lucentio to and he finds Kate to be the perfect fit. Disregarding
troupe of actors has arrived to present a play for him. The marry Bianca by proposing a huge sum of money to lavish everyone who warns him of her shrewishness, he
play that Sly watches makes up the main story of |he on her. Baptista agrees but says that he must have this eventually succeeds not only in wooing Katherine, but in
|aming oa the Shrew. sum confirmed by Lucentio͛s father before the marriage silencing her tongue and temper with his own.
In the Italian city of Padua, a rich young man named can take place. Tranio and Lucentio, still in their respective
- The younger daughter of Baptista. The lovely
Lucentio arrives with his servants, Tranio and Biondello, to disguises, feel there is nothing left to do but find an old Bianca proves herself the opposite of her sister, Kate, at
attend the local university. Lucentio is excited to begin his man to play the role of Lucentio͛s father. Tranio enlists the the beginning of the play: she is soft-spoken, sweet, and
studies, but his priorities change when he sees Bianca, a help of an old pedant, or schoolmaster, but as the pedant unassuming. Thus, she operates as Kate͛s principal female
beautiful, mild young woman with whom Lucentio speaks to Baptista, Lucentio and Bianca decide to foil. Because of her large dowry and her mild behavior,
instantly falls in love. There are two problems: first, Bianca circumvent the complex situation by eloping. several men vie for her hand. Baptista, however, will not
already has two suitors, Gremio and Hortensio; second, Katherine and Petruchio soon return to Padua to visit let her marry until Kate is wed.
Bianca͛s father, a wealthy old man named Baptista Minola, Baptista. On the way, Petruchio forces Katherine to say
- Minola Baptista is one of the wealthiest men in
has declared that no one may court Bianca until first her that the sun is the moon and that an old man is really a Padua, and his daughters become the prey of many suitors
older sister, the vicious, ill-tempered Katherine, is married. beautiful young maiden. Since Katherine͛s willfulness is due to the substantial dowries he can offer. He is good-
Lucentio decides to overcome this problem by disguising dissipating, she agrees that all is as her husband says. On natured, if a bit superficial. His absentmindedness
himself as Bianca͛s Latin tutor to gain an excuse to be in the road, the couple meets Lucentio͛s father, Vincentio, increases when Kate shows her obstinate nature. Thus, at
her company. Hortensio disguises himself as her music who is on his way to Padua to see his son. In Padua, the opening of the play, he is already desperate to find her
teacher for the same reason. While Lucentio pretends to Vincentio is shocked to find Tranio masquerading as a suitor, having decided that she must marry before Bianca
be Bianca͛s tutor, Tranio dresses up as Lucentio and begins Lucentio. At last, Bianca and Lucentio arrive to spread the does.
to confer with Baptista about the possibility of marrying news of their marriage. Both Vincentio and Baptista finally
- A young student from Pisa, the good-natured
his daughter. agree to the marriage. and intrepid Lucentio comes to Padua to study at the city͛s
The Katherine problem is solved for Bianca͛s suitors when At the banquet following Hortensio͛s wedding to the renowned university, but he is immediately sidetracked
Hortensio͛s friend Petruchio, a brash young man from widow, the other characters are shocked to see that when he falls in love with Bianca at first sight. By disguising
Verona, arrives in Padua to find a wife. He intends to Katherine seems to have been ͞tamed͟Ͷshe obeys himself as a classics instructor named Cambio, he
marry a rich woman, and does not care what she is like as everything that Petruchio says and gives a long speech convinces Gremio to offer him to Baptista as a tutor for
long as she will bring him a fortune. He agrees to marry advocating the loyalty of wives to their husbands. When Bianca. He wins her love, but his impersonation gets him
Katherine sight unseen. The next day, he goes to Baptista͛s the three new husbands stage a contest to see which of into trouble when his father, Vincentio, visits Padua.
house to meet her, and they have a tremendous duel of their wives will obey first when summoned, everyone
- Lucentio͛s servant. Tranio accompanies Lucentio
words. As Katherine insults Petruchio repeatedly, expects Lucentio to win. Bianca, however, sends a from Pisa. Wry and comical, he plays an important part in
Petruchio tells her that he will marry her whether she message back refusing to obey, while Katherine comes his master͛s charadeͶhe assumes Lucentio͛s identity and
agrees or not. He tells Baptista, falsely, that Katherine has immediately. The others acknowledge that Petruchio has bargains with Baptista for Bianca͛s hand.
consented to marry him on Sunday. Hearing this claim, won an astonishing victory, and the happy Katherine and
c
- Two gentlemen of Padua. Gremio
Katherine is strangely silent, and the wedding is set. Petruchio leave the banquet to go to bed. and Hortensio are Bianca͛s suitors at the beginning of the
On Sunday, Petruchio is late to his own wedding, leaving [
play. Though they are rivals, these older men also become
Katherine to fear she will become an old maid. When
- The ͞shrew͟ of the play͛s title, Katherine, or friends during their mutual frustration with and rejection
Petruchio arrives, he is dressed in a ridiculous outfit and Kate, is the daughter of Baptista Minola, with whom she by Bianca. Hortensio directs Petruchio to Kate and then
rides on a broken-down horse. After the wedding, lives in Padua. She is sharp-tongued, quick-tempered, and dresses up as a music instructor to court Bianca. He and
Gremio are both thwarted in their efforts by Lucentio. level, since even if she dislikes the role of wife, playing it at subsequently puts into motion a romantic and fanciful
Hortensio ends up marrying a widow. least means she can command respect and consideration plan to do so. Whereas love in the play is often mitigated
- Petruchio͛s servant and the fool of the playͶa from others rather than suffer the universal revulsion she by economic and social concerns, Lucentio is swept up in a
source of much comic relief. receives as a shrew. Having a social role, even if it is not vision of courtly love that does not include the practical
- Lucentio͛s second servant, who assists his ideal, must be less painful than continually rejecting any considerations of men like Petruchio. Throughout much of
master and Tranio in carrying out their plot. social role at all. Thus, Katherine͛s eventual compliance the play, then, Lucentio and Bianca͛s relationship appears
[
- The principal character in the play͛s brief with Petruchio͛s self-serving ͞training͟ appears more to be refreshing and pure in comparison to the
Induction, Sly is a drunken tinker, tricked by a mischievous rational than it might have seemed at first: by the end of relationship between Petruchio and Katherine. Petruchio͛s
nobleman into thinking that he is really a lord. the play, she has gained a position and even an decision to marry is based on his self-proclaimed desire to
[ authoritative voice that she previously had been denied. win a fortune, while Lucentio͛s is based on romantic love.
ÿ
Moreover, while Petruchio devotes himself to taming his
Widely reputed throughout Padua to be a shrew, The boastful, selfish, mercurial Petruchio is one of the bride, Lucentio devotes himself to submitting to and
Katherine is foul-tempered and sharp-tongued at the start most difficult characters in |he |aming oa the Shrew: his ingratiating himself with his. While Petruchio stages his
of the play. She constantly insults and degrades the men behavior is extremely difficult to decipher, and our wedding as a public spectacle, Lucentio elopes with
around her, and she is prone to wild displays of anger, interpretation of the play as a whole changes dramatically Bianca.
during which she may physically attack whomever enrages depending on how we interpret Petruchio͛s actions. If he is The contrast between Lucentio and Petruchio
her. Though most of the play͛s characters simply believe nothing more than a vain, uncaring, greedy chauvinist who distinguishes |he |aming oa the Shrew from other
Katherine to be inherently ill-tempered, it is certainly treats marriage as an act of domination, then the play Elizabethan plays. Through Lucentio and Bianca, the play
plausible to think that her unpleasant behavior stems from becomes a dark comedy about the materialism and hunger looks beyond the moment when the romantic lovers are
unhappiness. She may act like a shrew because she is for power that dictate marriages under the guise of courtly wed and depicts the consequences of the disguises and
miserable and desperate. There are many possible sources love. If, on the other hand, Petruchio is actually capable of subterfuges they have charmingly employed to facilitate
of Katherine͛s unhappiness: she expresses jealousy about loving Kate and conceives of taming her merely as a means their romance. Once the practical business of being
her father͛s treatment of her sister, but her anxiety may to realize a happy marriage, then the play becomes an married begins, Lucentio͛s preoccupation with courtly love
also stem from feelings about her own undesirability, the examination of the psychology of relationships. seems somewhat outmoded and ridiculous. In the end, it is
fear that she may never win a husband, her loathing of the A case can be made for either interpretation, but the truth Petruchio͛s disturbing, flamboyant pragmatism that
way men treat her, and so on. In short, Katherine feels out about Petruchio probably lies somewhere in between: he produces a happy and functioning marriage, and
of place in her society. Due to her intelligence and is unabashedly selfish, materialistic, and determined to be Lucentio͛s poeticized instincts leave him humiliated when
independence, she is unwilling to play the role of the his wife͛s lord and master, but he also loves her and Bianca refuses to answer his summons. Love certainly
maiden daughter. She clearly abhors society͛s realizes on some level that domestic harmony (on his exists in the world of |he |aming oa the Shrew, but
expectations that she obey her father and show grace and terms, of course) would be better for her than her current Lucentio͛s theatrical love, attractive though it is, appears
courtesy toward her suitors. At the same time, however, life as a shrew in Padua. To this extent, Petruchio goes to unable to cope with the full range of problems and
Katherine must see that given the rigidity of her social alarming lengths to impose his mastery on Kate, keeping considerations facing married couples in adult life.
situation, her only hope to find a secure and happy place her tired and hungry for some time after their marriage,
in the world lies in finding a husband. These inherently but he also insists on framing this treatment in a language
conflicting impulses may lead to her misery and poor of love, indicating his eagerness for Kate to adapt to her As a romantic comedy, the play focuses principally on the
temper. A vicious circle ensues: the angrier she becomes, rightful, socially appointed place and his willingness to romantic relationships between men and women as they
the less likely it seems she will be able to adapt to her make their marriage a happy one. Above all, Petruchio is a develop from initial interest into marriage. In this respect,
prescribed social role; the more alienated she becomes comic figure, an exaggerated persona who continually the play is a typical romantic comedy. However, unlike
socially, the more her anger grows. makes the audience laugh. And though we laugh with other Shakespearean comedies, |he |aming oa the Shrew
Despite the humiliations and deprivations that Petruchio Petruchio as he ͞tames͟ Kate, we also laugh at him, as we does not conclude its examination of love and marriage
adds to her life, it is easy to understand why Katherine see him satirize the very gender inequalities that the plot with the wedding. Rather, it offers a significant glimpse
might succumb to marry a man like him. In their first of |he |aming oa the Shrew ultimately upholds. into the future lives of married couples, one that serves to
conversation, Petruchio establishes that he is Katherine͛s
round out its exploration of the social dimension of love.
intellectual and verbal equal, making him, on some level, Just as Bianca is Katherine͛s foilͶher oppositeͶthe Unlike in £omeo and Juliet, inner emotional desire plays
an exciting change from the easily dominated men who intrepid, lovesick Lucentio serves as a foil for Petruchio only a secondary role in |he |aming oa the Shrew͛s
normally surround her. Petruchio͛s forcible treatment of throughout the play. Lucentio reflects the sort of idyllic, exploration of love. Instead, |he |aming oa the Shrew
Katherine is in every way designed to show her that she poetical view of love that Petruchio͛s pragmatism emphasizes the economic aspects of marriageͶ
has no real choice but to adapt to her social role as a wife. dismisses: Lucentio is struck by love for Bianca at first specifically, how economic considerations determine who
This adaptation must be attractive to Katherine on some sight, says that he will die if he cannot win her heart, and marries whom. The play tends to explore romantic
relationships from a social perspective, addressing the put on the clothes of a lord, but he remains a servant, one her like a ͞falcon͟ and plans to ͞kill a wife with kindness.͟
institutions of courtship and marriage rather than the who must return to his place, as we see with Tranio. Hortensio even conceives of Petruchio͛s house as a place
inner passions of lovers. Moreover, the play focuses on Likewise, Lucentio must reveal his subterfuge to his father where other men may learn how to domesticate women,
how courtship affects not just the lovers themselves, but and to Baptista before moving forward with Bianca. Kate͛s calling it a ͞taming-school.͟
also their parents, their servants, and their friends. In development over the course of the play is basically
[
general, while the husband and the wife conduct the determined by her gradual adaptation to her new social The several father/child relationships in the playͶ
marriage relationship after the wedding, the courtship role as wife. She complies with Petruchio͛s humiliating Baptista/Bianca, Baptista/Katherine, Vincentio/LucentioͶ
relationship is negotiated between the future husband and regimen of taming because she knows on some level that, focus on parents dealing with children of marriageable age
the father of the future wife. As such, marriage becomes a whether she likes the role of wife or not, she will be and concerned with making good matches for them. Even
transaction involving the transfer of money. Lucentio wins happier accepting her social obligations than living as she the sham father/son relationship between the disguised
Bianca͛s heart, but he is given permission to marry her has been at odds with everyone connected to her. In fact, pedant and the disguised Tranio portrays a father
only after he is able to convince Baptista that he is the primary excitement in |he |aming oa the Shrew stems attempting to make a match for his son, as the pedant
fabulously rich. Had Hortensio offered more money, he from its permeable social boundaries, crisscrossed attempts to negotiate Tranio͛s marriage to Bianca.
would have married Bianca, regardless of whether she continually by those who employ a disguise or a clever lie. Through the recurrence of this motif, Shakespeare shows
loved Lucentio. In the end, however, the conventional order reestablishes the broader social ramifications of the institution of
c
itself, and those characters who harmonize with that order marriage. Marriage does not merely concern the future
Each person in the play occupies a specific social position achieve personal happiness. bride and groom, but many other people as well,
that carries with it certain expectations about how that
especially parents, who, in a sense, transfer their
person should behave. A character͛s social position is
responsibility for their children onto the new spouses.
defined by such things as his or her wealth, age, gender, Disguise figures prominently in |he |aming oa the Shrew:
profession, parentage, and education; the rules governing Sly dresses as a lord, Lucentio dresses as a Latin tutor, ÿ
[
how each of them should behave are harshly enforced by Tranio dresses as Lucentio, Hortensio dresses as a music The ridiculous outfit Petruchio wears to his wedding with
family, friends, and society as a whole. For instance, tutor, and the pedant dresses as Vincentio. These disguises Kate symbolizes his control over her. Simply by wearing
Lucentio occupies the social role of a wealthy young enable the characters to transgress barriers in social the costume, he is able to humiliate her. It may be
student, Tranio that of a servant, and Bianca and Katherine position and class, and, for a time, each of them is shameful for Kate to be matched to someone in such
the roles of upper-class young maidens-in-waiting. At the successful. The play thus poses the question of whether attire, but she knows she has no choice if she does not
very least, they are supposed to occupy these rolesͶbut, clothes make the manͶthat is, whether a person can wish to become an old maid. She consents to let the
as the play shows, in reality, Kate wants nothing to do with change his or her role by putting on new clothes. The ceremony proceed, even with Petruchio dressed like a
her social role, and her shrewishness results directly from ultimate answer is no, of course. In |he |aming oa the clown, and thus yields to his authority before the wedding
her frustration concerning her position. Because she does Shrew, society involves a web of antecedents that are even begins.
not live up to the behavioral expectations of her society, always able to uncover one͛s true nature, no matter how The outfit also symbolizes the transient nature of clothing.
she faces the cold disapproval of that society, and, due to differently one wishes to portray oneself. Tranio, disguised Petruchio declares that Kate is marrying him, not his
her alienation, she becomes miserably unhappy. Kate is as Lucentio, needs only to bump into Vincentio, and his clothes, indicating that the man beneath the attire is not
only one of the many characters in |he |aming oa the true identity surfaces. As Petruchio implies on his wedding the same as the attire itself. Thus, Lucentio, dressed as a
Shrew who attempt to circumvent or deny their socially day, a garment is simply a garment, and the person tutor, cannot escape the fact that he must return to his
defined roles, however: Lucentio transforms himself into a beneath remains the same no matter what disguise is true identity. By the same token, when Kate plays the role
working-class Latin tutor, Tranio transforms himself into a worn. of a dutiful wife, she remains, essentially, Kate.
wealthy young aristocrat, Christopher Sly is transformed
c [
from a tinker into a lord, and so forth. The motif of domestication is broadcasted in the play͛s The cap and gown that Petruchio denies Katherine, despite
Compared with Katherine͛s more serious anguish about title by the word ͞taming.͟ A great part of the action the fact that she finds them truly appealing, symbolizes yet
her role, the other characters͛ attempts to circumvent consists of Petruchio͛s attempts to cure Katherine of her again his power over her. The outfit functions as a kind of
social expectations seem like harmless fun. However, the antisocial hostility. Katherine is thus frequently referred to bait used to help convince Kate to recognize and comply
play illustrates that each transformation must be undone as a wild animal that must be domesticated. Petruchio with Petruchio͛s wishes. Only he has the power to satisfy
before conventional life can resume at the end of the play. considers himself, and the other men consider him, to be a her needs and desires, and this lesson encourages her to
Ultimately, society͛s happiness depends upon everyone tamer who must train his wife, and most of the men satisfy him in return.
playing his or her prescribed roles. Through the motif of secretly suspect at first that her wild nature will prove too
disguise, the play entertains the idea that a person͛s much for him. After the wedding, Petruchio and
apparel determines his or her social position, but it Katherine͛s relationship becomes increasingly defined by
ultimately affirms that this is not the case. A servant may the rhetoric of domestication. Petruchio speaks of training