Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Strategic
Management
PART two
Planning
CHAPTER 5
Decision Making
What analysis can I use to
make decisions?
1. What is strategic
management?
2. What are the steps in
strategic management?
3. What kinds of strategies can
managers use?
4. How does today s dynamic
environment affect strategic
management?
CHAPTER 6
Foundations of Planning
CHAPTER 7
Strategic Management
CHAPTER 8
Planning Tools and
Techniques
Think About It
How does a media company choose a strategy in the new digital age? Put yourself
in
Leonard Asper s shoes. Do further moves toward convergence make sense? Why would
CanWest benefit, while BCE has determined that convergence is not a good strateg
y
and is considering selling off its print and broadcast businesses? What kinds of
analyses
can Asper use to help make the right decision regarding convergence?
The importance of having good strategies can be seen by the difficulties several
large
Canadian media companies faced after buying into convergence either merging with
other media companies to combine television and print, or merging to own both me
dia and
the way to deliver it (such as AOL and Time Warner.). By choosing effective stra
tegies to
attract customers, organizations can become prosperous and thriving. Improper st
rategies
can lead to huge failures, however. This chapter examines various strategies tha
t organizations
can use to manage more effectively.
The Importance of Strategic Management
Effective managers around the world recognize the role that strategic management
plays 1. What is strategic
management?
in their organizations performance. For instance, using well-designed strategies,
Swedish
180 Part 2 Planning
7.1
Wal-Mart
www.wal-mart.ca
Zellers
www.hbc.com/zellers
strategic management
That set of managerial decisions
and actions that determines the
long-run performance of an
organization.
company Electrolux is the world s number-one producer of household appliances and
vacuum cleaners. It has conquered Europe and is looking to do the same in the US m
arket.
Hindustan Lever is India s largest consumer goods company and makes soaps, deterge
nts,
and food products. As a result of effective strategic management, it has achieve
d an
average three-year total return to stockholders of 120 percent. These companies
illustrate
the value of strategic management. In this section, we want to look at what stra
tegic management
is and why it s considered important to managers.
What Is Strategic Management?
Can the study of strategic
management be used to
plan a successful
life for yourself?
To begin to understand the basics of strategy and strategic
management, you need look no further than at what s happened
in the discount retail industry. The industry s two
largest competitors Wal-Mart and Zellers have battled
for market dominance since Wal-Mart entered Canada in
1992. The two chains have some striking similarities: store
atmosphere, markets served, and organizational purpose.
Yet Wal-Mart s performance (financial and otherwise) has
taken market share from Zellers every single year. Wal-Mart
is the world s largest and most successful retailer and Zellers is the second-larg
est discount
retailer in Canada. Why the difference in performance? Organizations vary in how
well
they perform because of differences in their strategies and differences in compe
titive abilities.
4 Wal-Mart excels at strategic management, while Zellers struggles to find the r
ight
niche.
Strategic management is that set of managerial decisions and actions that determ
ines
the long-run performance of an organization.5 It is an important task of manager
s and
involves all of the basic management functions. We ll discuss in detail how strate
gic management
takes place in an organization at a later point in the chapter.
Why Is Strategic Management Important?
Stellar Blue is the newest colour in H.J. Heinz Company s crazy-coloured ketchup p
alette,
which already includes green, purple, pink, orange, teal, and, of course, the tr
aditional
red. Heinz s managers clearly understand the importance of strategic management be
cause
they know that every time a colour is introduced, the company s market share bumps
up
a little.
Why is strategic management so important? One of the most significant reasons is
that
it can make a difference in how well an organization performs. The most fundamen
tal
questions about strategy address why firms succeed or fail, and why, when faced
with the
same environmental conditions, they have varying levels of performance. Studies
of the factors
that contribute to organizational performance have shown a positive relationship
between strategic planning and performance.6 In other words, it appears that org
anizations
that use strategic management do have higher levels of performance. And that mak
es
strategic management pretty important!
Another reason strategic management is important has to do with the fact that or
ganizations
of all types and sizes face continuously changing situations. These changes may
be minor or significant, but they are still changes with which managers must cop
e. That s
where strategic management comes in. By following the steps in the strategic man
agement
process, managers examine relevant variables in deciding what to do and how to
do it. When managers use the strategic management process, they can better cope
with
uncertain environments. (To understand your ability to deal with the ambiguity t
hat managers
often face, see Self-Assessment How Well Do I Handle Ambiguity?, pages 203 204, at
the end of the chapter.)
Strategic management is also important because of the nature of organizations. T
hey re
composed of diverse divisions, units, functions, and work activities manufacturing
, marketing,
accounting, and so forth that need to be coordinated and focused on achieving the
organization s goals. The strategic management process does this.
Chapter 7 Strategic Management 181
SWOT Analysis
Identify the
organization's
current mission, goals,
and strategies
Internal Analysis
strengths
weaknesses
External Analysis
opportunities
threats
Formulate
Strategies
Implement
Strategies
Evaluate
Results
Chapter 7 Strategic Management 183
Step 1: Identify the Organization s Current Mission,
Objectives, and Strategies
How would you develop a
strategic plan for the next
five or ten years of your
life? What would be your
mission, objectives, and
strategies?
Every organization needs a mission a statement of the
purpose of an organization. The mission answers the question:
What is our reason for being in business? Defining
the organization s mission forces managers to carefully
identify the scope of its products or services. For example,
CanWest s mission statement is to inform, enlighten and
entertain people everywhere so as to improve the quality
of their lives. The mission of the Workers Compensation
Board (WCB) of British Columbia is the safety, protection,
and health of workers. The mission of eBay is to build an online marketplace that
enables
practically anyone to trade practically anything almost anywhere in the world. Th
ese
statements provide clues to what these organizations see as their reason for bei
ng in business.
Exhibit 7 2 on page 184 provides a description of the typical components of a miss
ion
statement.
It s also important for managers to identify goals and strategies consistent with
the mission
being pursued. For instance, based on its mission statement, the WCB established
the following goals:10
¦ Creation of workplaces that are safe and secure from injury and disease
¦ Successful rehabilitation and return-to-work of injured workers
¦ Fair compensation for workers suffering injury or illness on the job
¦ Sound financial management to ensure a viable WCB system
¦ Protection of the public interest
As we explained in Chapter 6, goals are the foundation of planning. A company s go
als
provide the measurable performance targets that employees strive to reach. Knowi
ng the company s
current goals gives managers a basis for assessing whether those goals need to b
e
changed. For the same reasons, it s important for managers to identify the organiz
ation s
current strategies.
Step 2: External Analysis
What changes in the world
are happening that might
affect how your career
might unfold over time?
How might this affect your
strategic plan?
In Chapter 2, we described the external environment as an
important constraint on a manager s actions. Analyzing
that environment is a critical step in the strategy process.
Managers in every organization need to do an external
analysis. They need to know, for instance, what the competition
is doing, what pending legislation might affect the
organization, or what the labour supply is like in locations
where it operates. In analyzing the external environment,
managers should examine both the specific and general
environments to see what trends and changes are occurring. At CanWest, managers
noted
that individuals were reading newspapers less, and using the Internet more. This
observation
required CanWest to rethink how to encourage more people to rely on CanWest for
news services. (To learn more about analyzing the environment, see Building Your
Skills
Scanning the Environment, pages 205 206, at the end of the chapter.)
After analyzing the environment, managers need to assess what they have learned
in
terms of opportunities that the organization can exploit, and threats that it mu
st counteract.
Opportunities are positive trends in external environmental factors; threats are
negative trends. For CanWest managers, one opportunity is the increased use of t
he Internet,
and managers have looked for ways to get more revenue from this medium. Threats
to
CanWest include the decrease in newspaper readership, and increasing competition
by
alternative sources of radio and television programs.
7.2
CanWest Global
www.canwestglobal.com
7.3
opportunities
Positive trends in external
environmental factors.
threats
Negative trends in external
environmental factors.
184 Part 2 Planning
Exhibit 7 2
Components of a Mission Statement
Customers: Who are the organization s customers?
We believe our first responsibility is to the doctors, nurses, and patients, to
mothers and all others who use our products and
services. (Johnson & Johnson)
Products or services: What are the organization s major products or services?
To enrich the lives of everyone in WestJet s world by providing safe, friendly, af
fordable air travel. (WestJet Airlines)
Markets: Where does the organization compete geographically?
As individuals, we are united by one overriding goal: to entertain, uplift, and
enlighten audiences the world over. (Cirque du Soleil)
Technology: How technologically current is the organization?
While our oil is already a very high quality product, we re working to make it eve
n better and fully in step with society s
expectations for cleaner burning fuels. By installing new technologies and proce
sses, we re reducing the sulphur content of our
oil to create a product whose environmental attributes will be among the highest
in industry. (Syncrude)
Concern for survival, growth, and profitability: Is the organization committed t
o growth and financial stability?
In this respect, the company will conduct its operations prudently, and will pro
vide the profits and growth which will assure
Hoover s ultimate success. (Hoover s Universal)
Philosophy: What are the organization s basic beliefs, values, aspirations, and et
hical priorities?
At Hbc, we have a tremendous sense of responsibility, not only to the continued
growth and success of our company, but also to
the nation that we have been instrumental in building. Our culture is grounded i
n a commitment to take into account the social
needs and issues impacting communities where we do business. (Hudson s Bay Company
)
Self-concept: What is the organization s major competitive advantage and core comp
etencies?
The CBC tells Canadian stories reflecting the reality and the diversity of our c
ountry; informs Canadians about news and issues
of relevance and interest; supports Canadian arts and culture; and builds bridge
s among Canadians, between regions, and the
two linguistic communities. (CBC)
Concern for public image: How responsive is the organization to societal and env
ironmental concerns?
To share the world s obligation for the protection of the environment. (Dow Chemic
al)
Concern for employees: Does the organization consider employees a valuable asset
?
At IBM, we recognize individual differences and appreciate how these differences
provide a powerful competitive advantage and
a source of great pride and opportunity in the workplace and marketplace. (IBM C
anada)
Source: Based on company websites and F. David, Strategic Management, 8th ed. (U
pper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 2001), pp. 65 66.
One last thing to understand about external analysis is that the same environmen
t can
present opportunities to one organization and pose threats to another in the sam
e industry
because of their different resources and capabilities. For example, WestJet Airl
ines has
prospered in a turbulent industry, while Air Canada has struggled.
Step 3: Internal Analysis
Now we move from looking outside the organization to
looking inside. The internal analysis should lead to a clear
assessment of the organization s resources (such as financial
What are your strengths
and weaknesses for capital, technical expertise, skilled employees, experienced
developing a successful managers, and so forth) and capabilities in performing t
he
career? different functional activities (such as marketing, manufacturing,
information systems, human resource manage-
strengths ment, and so forth). Any activities the organization does
Any activities the organization
well or any unique resources that it has are called strengths.
does well or any unique resources
Weaknesses are activities the organization does not do well or resources it need
s but does
that it has.
not possess. This step forces managers to recognize that every organization, no
matter how
weaknesses
large or successful, is constrained by the resources and capabilities it has ava
ilable.
Activities the organization does
The internal analysis provides important information about an organization s speci
fic
not do well or resources it needs
but does not possess. resources and capabilities. If any of these organizational
capabilities or resources are excep
Chapter 7 Strategic Management 185
tional or unique, they re called the organization s core competencies. The core comp
etencies
are the organization s major value-creating skills, capabilities, and resources th
at determine
its competitive weapons.11 Toronto-based Sears Canada decided that being in the
automotive business was not one of its core competencies, and decided to get out
of the automotive
repair business in spring 2004.
An understanding of the organization s culture is a crucial part of Step 3 that s of
ten
overlooked.12 Managers should be aware that strong and weak cultures have differ
ent
effects on strategy and that the content of a culture has a major effect on stra
tegies pursued.
As we discussed in Chapter 2, an organization s culture is its personality. It ref
lects the
shared values, beliefs, and valued behaviours that embody the way things are done
around
here. In a strong culture, almost all employees have a clear understanding of wha
t the
organization is about. This clarity should make it easy for managers to convey t
o new
employees the organization s core competencies and strengths. At WestJet Airlines,
which
has a very strong culture of customer service and satisfaction, managers can ins
till cultural
values in new employees in a much shorter time than could a competitor with a we
ak culture.
The negative side of a strong culture, of course, is that it s more difficult to c
hange. A
strong culture may act as a significant barrier to accepting any changes in the
organization s
strategies. Successful organizations with strong cultures may become prisoners o
f
their own successes.
Organizational culture also can promote or hinder an organization s strategic acti
ons.
One study showed that firms with strategically appropriate cultures outperformed o
ther
corporations with less appropriate cultures.13 What is a strategically appropria
te culture?
It s one that supports the firm s chosen strategy. For instance, Starbucks ranks hig
h on
brand loyalty. By creating a culture where employees obsess over every step of t
he coffee experience,
Starbucks has built an excellent record of customer loyalty.
The combined external and internal analyses are called the SWOT analysis because
it s an
analysis of the organization s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats.
Based on the
SWOT analysis, managers can identify a strategic niche that the organization mig
ht exploit.
(See Exhibit 7 3 on page 186.) For CanWest, one thing managers realized was that i
t would
make sense for them to expand into film and television production and distributi
on. This
would provide additional product for their own television stations, and be a sou
rce of revenue
when sold to other competitors stations. Owner Leonard Lee started Ottawa-based L
ee Valley
Tools in 1982 to help individual woodworkers, and later gardeners, find just the
right tools
for their tasks. This niche strategy enabled Lee to grow Lee Valley into one of
North America s
leading garden and woodworking catalogue companies over more than 25 years.
Managers of the New Horizon
seniors residence at Bloor and
Dufferin streets in Toronto know
how to recognize a good opportunity.
The not-for-profit home was
losing a lot of money, and half of
its rooms were empty. The double-
cohort was about to hit Toronto
post-secondary schools, and New
Horizons had rooms and rents
that would appeal to student budgets.
So New Horizons decided to
open the residence to college and
university students. Both seniors
and students feel they benefit
from the situation, and New
Horizons is on a better financial
footing these days.
7.4
7.5
core competencies
The organization s major value-
creating skills, capabilities, and
resources that determine its
competitive weapons.
SWOT analysis
An analysis of the organization s
strengths, weaknesses,
opportunities, and threats.
Opportunities in
the Environment
Organization s
Opportunities
Organization s
Resources/Capabilities
SWOT analysis was very effective in keeping jobs at Proctor & Gamble Canada s Broc
kville,
Ontario, plant, as the following Management Reflection shows.
MANAGEMENT REFLECTION
Loss of Detergent Production Turns into Victory
How does a Canadian CEO convince his American bosses that there is advantage to
staying in Canada? SWOT analysis saved the jobs of employees at Proctor & Gamble
Canada s Brockville, Ontario, plant.14 Tim Penner, CEO of the Toronto-based compan
y,
knew that the parent company (based in Cincinnati, Ohio) planned to consolidate
the production of laundry detergent in the United States, which would eliminate
the jobs of the Brockville employees. Penner, in search of a new opportunity, su
ggested
to head office that P&G move manufacture of fabric softener sheets and electrost
atic
cleaning sheets for the Swiffer sweeper to Brockville. Penner outlined the stren
gths of
the Ontario plant, including a highly educated workforce known for its commitmen
t
and productivity. With Penner s strategic thinking, Brockville s loss of laundry det
ergent
production turned into a victory for Canadian jobs. Penner says his job includes
aggressively selling Canada [to US head office] as a possible site for new produc
ts
and reorganized operations. Penner s strategy has paid off. When he became CEO in
1999, P&G Canada was the seventh-largest revenue generator in the world for the
US
multinational. Three years later, he d taken the Canadian subsidiary to third plac
e,
and increased revenues from $1.5 billion to $2 billion. Penner s goal is to have $
3
billion in sales by 2007. ¦
Step 4: Formulate Strategies
Once the SWOT analysis is complete, managers need to develop and evaluate strate
gic alternatives
and then select strategies that capitalize on the organization s strengths and exp
loit
environmental opportunities or that correct the organization s weaknesses and buff
er against
threats. Strategies need to be established for the corporate, business, and func
tional levels of
the organization, which we ll describe shortly. This step is complete when manager
s have
developed a set of strategies that give the organization a relative advantage ov
er its rivals.
Step 5: Implement Strategies
After strategies are formulated, they must be implemented. No matter how effecti
vely an
organization has planned its strategies, it can t succeed if the strategies aren t i
mplemented
properly. Involving all members of the organization in strategic planning can be
effective,
as the following Management Reflection shows.
7.6
7.7
Chapter 7 Strategic Management 187
Focus on InnovationFocus on Innovation
MANAGEMENT REFLECTION
Co-operative Trust Involves All Employees in Decision Making
Would involving all employees in a strategic plan make a company more successful
or less successful? Myrna Bentley, president and CEO of Saskatoon,
Saskatchewan-based Co-operative Trust understands the importance of employee
involvement in implementing the results of SWOT analysis. Her company provides
financial intermediary and trusteeship services to credit unions, corporate clie
nts,
mortgage brokers, and deposit agents across Canada. When we did our SWOT analysis
,
we involved all the staff and sent that information through to the management
team, which spent time working through it. As a result we have business plan del
iverables
in 2004 that are directly fed through the organization from the frontline
level, Bentley says.15
Bentley s inclusion of employees pays off in other ways as well. In 2003, the comp
any
was recognized for being one of Canada s Top 50 Best Managed Companies and
was a repeat winner for Canada s Top 100 Employers.16 ¦
The rest of the chapters in this book address a number of issues related to stra
tegy
implementation. For instance, in Chapter 9, we discuss the strategy-structure re
lationship.
In Chapter 11, we show that if new strategies are to succeed, they often require
hiring
new people with different skills, transferring some current employees to new pos
itions,
or laying off some employees. Also, since more organizations are using teams, th
e ability
to build and manage effective teams is an important part of implementing strateg
y. (We cover
teams in Chapter 14.) Finally, top management leadership is a necessary ingredie
nt in a successful
strategy. So, too, is a motivated group of middle- and lower-level managers to c
arry
out the organization s specific strategies. Chapters 12 and 13 discuss ways to imp
rove leadership
effectiveness and offer suggestions on motivating people.
Step 6: Evaluate Results
The final step in the strategic management process is evaluating results. How ef
fective have
the strategies been? What adjustments, if any, are necessary? We discuss this st
ep in our
7.8
coverage of the control process in Chapter 15.
Types of Organizational Strategies
When CanWest Global Communications first started on its convergence strategy in
s. As a result of
bought 11 major
national media holdings.
wn to
related media.
suf-
s and
wspaper
vision listings in
188 Part 2 Planning
3. What kinds of strategies can
managers use?
corporate-level strategy
An organizational strategy that
seeks to determine what
businesses a company should be
in or wants to be in.
PepsiCo
www.pepsico.com
growth strategy
A corporate-level strategy that
seeks to increase the
organization s operations by
expanding the number of products
offered or markets served.
Organizational strategies include strategies at the corporate level, business le
vel, and functional
level. (See Exhibit 7 4.) Managers at the top level of the organization typically
are
responsible for corporate-level strategies, such as CanWest s convergence strategy
. Managers
at the middle level typically are responsible for business-level strategies. And
managers at
the lower levels of the organization typically are responsible for the functiona
l-level strategies.
Let s look at each level of organizational strategy.
Corporate-Level Strategy
A corporate-level strategy seeks to determine what businesses
a company should be in or wants to be in. It reflects
the direction the organization is going and the roles that
If you were to develop your
own company, what
each business unit in the organization will play in pursuing
business would it be in? that direction. For instance, PepsiCo s corporate-level s
trat-
Why? egy integrates the strategies of its various business units
North American Soft Drinks, Pepsi International, Frito Lay,
Quaker Oats, Gatorade/Tropicana North America, and South
Beach (SOBE) Beverage. PepsiCo had a restaurant division
that included Taco Bell, Pizza Hut, and KFC, but because of intense competitive
pressures
in the fast-food industry and the restaurant division s inability to contribute to
corporate
growth PepsiCo chose to concentrate on its soda and food divisions. It spun off
the restaurant
division as a separate and independent business entity now called YUM! Brands.
What types of corporate strategies do organizations such as PepsiCo use?
There are three main corporate strategies: growth, stability, and retrenchment.
To
illustrate, Kellogg, Wal-Mart, and Apple are companies that seem to be going in
different
directions. Kellogg s managers are content to maintain the status quo and focus on
the food industry. Wal-Mart, on the other hand, is rapidly expanding its operati
ons
and developing new business and retailing concepts. It s also pursuing global oppo
rtunities.
Meanwhile, sluggish sales and an uncertain outlook in the computer industry
prompted Apple to try a different direction by launching online music service iT
unes.
Each of these organizations is pursuing a different type of corporate strategy.
Let s take
a closer look at each type.
Growth
The growth strategy is a corporate-level strategy that seeks to increase the org
anization s
business by expanding the number of products offered or markets served. By pursu
ing a
growth strategy, the organization may increase sales revenues, number of employe
es, market
share, or other quantitative measures. How can organizations grow? Through conce
ntration,
vertical integration, horizontal integration, or diversification.
Exhibit 7 4
Levels of Organizational Strategy
Corporate Multibusiness
Level Corporation
Business Strategic
Strategic
Business Unit 2
Strategic
Level Business Unit 1
Business Unit 3
Functional Research and
Human
Manufacturing Marketing
Finance
Level Development
Resources
Chapter 7 Strategic Management 189
When Stewart Gilliland took over as CEO of Labatt
Concentration Growth through concentration is achieved when an organization
concentrates on its primary line of business and increases the number of product
s
offered or markets served in this primary business. No other firms are
acquired or merged with; instead the company chooses to grow by increasing
its own business operations. For instance, Oakville, Ontario-based Tim
Hortons opens about 200 new stores a year, and is currently focusing most
of its new openings on small-town western Canada, Quebec, and the United
States, where it had 184 stores in 2004.17 Montreal-based Jean Coutu Group
recognized that, to grow, the company needed to open stores in the United
States, which has a much larger market than Canada. So it bought 1539 Eckerd
drugstores in the eastern United States.18
Vertical Integration A company also might choose to grow by vertical integration
,
which is an attempt to gain control of inputs (backward vertical integration),
outputs (forward vertical integration), or both. In backward vertical
integration, the organization attempts to gain control of its inputs by becoming
its own supplier. For instance, French hospitality giant Accor, which owns
Motel 6, Red Roof Inns, and numerous other lodging properties, also owns a
majority of Carlson Wagonlit Travel, one of the world s largest travel agencies.
In forward vertical integration, the organization gains control of its outputs
(products or services) by becoming its own distributor. For example, The Body Br
eweries in January 2004, he discovered that
the company had been more of a follower than a
Shop s retail stores are an example of an organization controlling its distributio
n.
leader. He vowed to change that immediately by
putting a fresh emphasis on quality, brewing
Horizontal Integration In horizontal integration, a company grows by combin-proc
ess and taste among his company s many
ing with other organizations in the same industry that is, combining oper-products
, including its flagship Blue brand.
ations with competitors. Interbrew SA of Belgium, which owns Labatt, is now
the number-two brewer in the word, and is a dominant player in Canada,
Britain, and parts of Asia and Africa because of its acquisition of local brewer
ies. Horizontal
integration has been suggested frequently in the banking industry in recent year
s.
Because combining with competitors might decrease the amount of competition in a
n
industry, the Competition Bureau assesses the impact of such proposed growth act
ions
and must approve any proposed horizontal integration strategy. Other countries h
ave similar
restrictions. For instance, the US Federal Trade Commission examines horizontal
integration
in the States. Even though their companies are based in the United States, manag
ers
at AOL and Time Warner had to make certain concessions before the European Commi
ssion,
the watchdog for the European Union, allowed that merger to go through.
Diversification Finally, an organization can grow through diversification, eithe
r related or
unrelated. In related diversification a company grows by merging with or acquiri
ng firms related diversification
When a company grows by
in different, but related, industries. In unrelated diversification a company gr
ows by
merging with or acquiring firms in
merging with or acquiring firms in different and unrelated industries. Toronto-b
ased
different, but related, industries.
Brascan is one of the few Canadian conglomerates that pursues a diversified stra
tegy. Under
unrelated diversification
CEO Bruce Flatt, Brascan has focused its development in three areas: real estate
(Toronto-
When a company grows by
based Brookfield Properties), financial services (Toronto-based Brascan Financia
l), and
merging with or acquiring firms in
power generation (Masson-Angers, Quebec-based Brascan Power).19 The company also
different and unrelated industries.
owns 43 percent of three other Toronto-based organizations: Noranda, a mining su
bsidiary;
Norbord, a paperboard company; and Fraser Papers, a leading manufacturer of
specialized printing, publishing, and converting papers.
Many companies use a combination of these approaches to grow. For instance,
McDonald s has grown using the concentration strategy by opening more than 30 000
units in 120 countries, of which about 30 percent are company-owned. In addition
, it s used
horizontal integration by purchasing Boston Market, Chipotle Mexican Grill, and
Donato s
Pizza chains. It also has a 33 percent stake in the UK-based sandwich shops Pret
A Manger.
However, unrelated diversification has fallen out of favour in recent years beca
use too
much diversification can cause managers to lose control of their organizations co
re business.
This can reduce value rather than create it.20 For instance, Toronto-based Sears
Canada
announced in March 2004 that it was getting out of the automotive business by cl
osing 13
190 Part 2 Planning
stability strategy
A corporate-level strategy
characterized by an absence of
significant change.
retrenchment strategy
A corporate-level strategy designed
to address organizational
weaknesses that are leading to
performance declines.
McDonald s Canada
www.mcdonalds.ca
BCG matrix
A strategy tool that guides
resource allocation decisions on
the basis of market share and
growth rate of businesses.
of its 49 auto centres, and selling the rest to Vernon, BC-based Kal Tire, Toron
to-based
Active Green & Ross, and Laval, Quebec-based President Tire. In doing this, Sear
s is going
back to its roots. We re a traditional department store and we want to focus our ca
pital
investment on traditional merchandise such as apparel, home fashions, furnishing
s and
appliances, Sears Canada s communication director Vincent Power said.21
Stability
A stability strategy is a corporate-level strategy characterized by an absence o
f significant
change. Examples of this strategy include continuing to serve the same clients b
y offering
the same product or service, maintaining market share, and sustaining the organi
zation s
return-on-investment results.
Although it may seem strange that an organization might not want to grow, there
are times
when its resources, capabilities, and core competencies are stretched to their l
imits, and
expanding operations further might jeopardize its future success. When might man
agers
decide that the stability strategy is the most appropriate choice? One situation
might be that
the industry is in a period of rapid upheaval with external forces drastically c
hanging and
making the future uncertain. At times like these, managers might decide that the
prudent
course of action is to sit tight and wait to see what happens.
Another situation where the stability strategy might be appropriate is if the in
dustry is
facing slow- or no-growth opportunities. In this instance, managers might decide
to keep
the organization operating at its current levels before making any strategic mov
es. This
period of stability would allow them time to analyze their strategic options.
Finally, owners and managers of small businesses, such as small neighbourhood gr
ocers,
often purposefully choose to follow a stability strategy. Why? They may feel tha
t their business
is successful enough just as it is, that it adequately meets their personal goal
s, and
that they don t want the hassles of a growing business.
Retrenchment
The popular business periodicals frequently report stories of organizations that
aren t meeting
their goals or whose performance is declining. When an organization is in troubl
e,
something needs to be done. Managers need to develop strategies that address org
anizational
weaknesses that are leading to performance declines. A retrenchment strategy
reduces the company s activities or operations. Retrenchment strategies include co
st
reductions, layoffs, closing underperforming units, or closing entire product li
nes or
services.22 There s no shortage of companies that have pursued a retrenchment stra
tegy.
A partial list includes some big corporate names: Procter & Gamble, Sears Canada
, Corel,
and Nortel Networks. When an organization is facing minor performance setbacks,
a
retrenchment strategy helps it stabilize operations, revitalize organizational r
esources
and capabilities, and prepare to compete once again. McDonald s is hoping that its
strategy
of retrenchment, by which it will eliminate or restructure operations in seven c
ountries
in the Middle East and Latin America and close about 175 restaurants in 10 other
countries, will be enough to stop the problems of a crowded restaurant market, l
ow
share prices, and complaints about poor service. Toronto-based McDonald s Canada i
s
not concerned about the strategy, however. Bill Johnson, president and CEO of Mc
Donald s
Canada, notes that the company remains on track for continued growth and will con
tinue
to implement our domestic strategy to grow our business into new areas of the
Canadian marketplace.
Corporate Portfolio Analysis
When an organization s corporate strategy involves a number of businesses, manager
s can
manage this collection, or portfolio, of businesses using a corporate portfolio
matrix.23
The first portfolio matrix the BCG matrix developed by the Boston Consulting Group,
introduced the idea that an organization s businesses could be evaluated and plott
ed using
a 2 × 2 matrix (see Exhibit 7 5) to identify which ones offered high potential and w
hich
were a drain on organizational resources.24 The horizontal axis represents marke
t share,
Chapter 7 Strategic Management 191
Exhibit 7 5
The BCG Matrix and Strategic Implications
High Low
HighLow
AnticipatedGrowth Rate
Market Share
Stars
Question
Marks
Heavily invest Sell off or
turn into stars
Cash
Cows
Milk for cash
Dogs
Sell off or
liquidate
which was evaluated as either low or high; and the vertical axis indicates antic
ipated market
growth, which also was evaluated as either low or high. Based on its evaluation,
businesses
can be placed in one of four categories:
¦
Cash cows (low growth, high market share). Businesses in this category
generate large amounts of cash, but their prospects for future
growth are limited.
¦
Stars (high growth, high market share). These businesses are in a
fast-growing market, and hold a dominant share of that market.
Their contribution to cash flow depends on their need for
resources.
¦
Question marks (high growth, low market share). These businesses
are in an attractive market, but hold a small share of that market.
Therefore, they have the promise of performance, but need to be
developed more for that to happen.
¦
Dogs (low growth, low market share). Businesses in this category
do not produce, or consume, much cash. However, they hold no
promise for improved performance.
What are the strategic implications of the BCG matrix? Managers should
milk cash cows for as much as they can, limit any new investment in
them, and use the large amounts of cash generated to invest in stars and
question marks with strong potential to improve market share. Heavy
investment in stars will help take advantage of the market s growth and
New
Entrants
Threat of
New Entrants
Substitutes
Buyers
Bargaining
Power of
Buyers
Threat of
Substitutes
Suppliers
Bargaining
Power of
Suppliers
Intensity of
Rivalry Among
Current
Competitors
Source: Based on M. E. Porter, Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyzing In
dustries and Competitors
(New York: Free Press, 1980).
Porter proposes that some industries are inherently more
profitable (and, therefore, more attractive to enter and remain
in) than others. For example, the pharmaceutical industry is
one with historically high profit margins, and the airline industry
has notoriously low ones. But a company can still make a
lot of money in a dull industry and lose money in a glamorous
industry. The key is to exploit a competitive advantage.
In any industry, five competitive forces dictate the rules
of competition. Together, these five forces (see Exhibit 7 6)
determine industry attractiveness and profitability. Managers
assess an industry s attractiveness using these forces:
1. Threat of new entrants. Factors such as economies of
scale, brand loyalty, and capital requirements determine
how easy or hard it is for new competitors to
enter an industry.
2. Threat of substitutes. Factors such as switching costs and
buyer loyalty determine the degree to which customers
are likely to buy a substitute product.
3. Bargaining power of buyers. Factors such as number of
customers in the market, customer information, and
the availability of substitutes determine the amount of
influence that buyers have in an industry.
4. Bargaining power of suppliers. Factors such as the degree
of supplier concentration and availability of substitute
inputs determine the amount of power that suppliers
have over firms in the industry.
Royal Caribbean International, which operates a fleet of 25 cruise
ships, has chosen quality as its competitive advantage. As Maria
Sastre, vice-president of total guest satisfaction, says, The Latin client
... likes the latest and the greatest, and that means brand-new
ships; multiple cabins to accommodate families that might include children,
grandparents, or both; carefully selected menus and wine lists;
and late-evening dining and entertainment featuring groups like the popular
Gipsy Kings.
194 Part 2 Planning
cost leadership strategy
A business-level strategy in which
the organization sets out to be the
lowest-cost producer in its
industry.
5. Current rivalry. Factors such as industry growth rate, increasing or falling
demand,
and product differences determine how intense the competitive rivalry will be am
ong
firms currently in the industry.
Once managers have assessed the five forces and determined what threats and oppo
rtunities
exist, they re ready to select an appropriate competitive strategy. According to
Porter, no firm can be successful by trying to be all things to all people. He p
roposes that
managers select a strategy that will give the organization a competitive advanta
ge, which
he says arises out of either having lower costs than all other industry competit
ors or by
being significantly different from competitors. On that basis, managers can choo
se one
of three strategies: cost leadership, differentiation, or focus. Which one manag
ers select
depends on the organization s strengths and core competencies and its competitors w
eaknesses.
(See Exhibit 7 7.)
Cost Leadership Strategy When an organization sets out to be the lowest-cost pro
ducer
in its industry, it s following a cost leadership strategy. A low-cost leader aggr
essively
searches out efficiencies in production, marketing, and other areas of operation
.
Overhead is kept to a minimum, and the firm does everything it can to cut costs.
You
won t find expensive art or interior décor at offices of low-cost leaders. For examp
le,
at Wal-Mart s headquarters in Bentonville, Arkansas, office furnishings are sparse
and drab
but functional.
Exhibit 7 7
Requirements for Successfully Pursuing Porter s
Competitive Strategies
Generic Commonly Required Common Organizational
Strategy Skills and Resources Requirements
Cost
Leadership
Differentiation
Sustained capital investment
and access to capital
Process engineering skills
Intense supervision of labor
Products designed for ease
in manufacture
Low-cost distribution system
Strong marketing abilities
Product engineering
Creative flair
Strong capability in basic research
Corporate reputation for quality
or technological leadership
Long tradition in the industry or
unique combination of skills
drawn from other businesses
Strong cooperation from channels
Combination of the foregoing
skills and resources directed at
the particular strategic target
Tight cost control
Frequent, detailed control reports
Structured organization and
responsibilities
Incentives based on meeting strict
quantitative targets
Strong coordination among functions
in R&D, product development, and
marketing
Subjective measurement and
incentives instead of quantitative
measures
Amenities to attract highly skilled
labour, scientists, or creative people
Combination of the foregoing
organizational requirements directed
at the particular strategic target
Focus
Source: Reprinted from M. E. Porter, Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analyz
ing Industries and
Competitors (New York: Free Press, 1980), pp. 40 41.
Chapter 7 Strategic Management 195
Although low-cost leaders don t place a lot of emphasis on frills, the product or se
rvice
being sold must be perceived as comparable in quality to that offered by rivals
or at least
be acceptable to buyers. Examples of companies that have used the low-cost leade
r strategy
include Wal-Mart, Hyundai, and WestJet Airlines.
Differentiation Strategy The company that seeks to offer unique products that ar
e widely
valued by customers is following a differentiation strategy. Sources of differen
tiation
might be exceptionally high quality, extraordinary service, innovative design, t
echnological
capability, or an unusually positive brand image. The key to this competitive st
rategy is
that whatever product or service attribute is chosen for differentiating must se
t the firm
apart from its competitors and be significant enough to justify a price premium
that exceeds
the cost of differentiating. For instance, St. Stephen, New Brunswick-based Gano
ng Bros.,
a small chocolate maker, differentiates itself from bigger boxed-chocolate maker
s by focusing
on the assorted chocolates market. This allows it to rank second in Canada in th
at
market. Its Fruitfull brand, made with real fruit puree and packaged like chocol
ates, has a
43 percent share of fruit jelly sales.29 Vancouver-based Vancouver City Savings
Credit Union
differentiates through its focus on the community and the customer, as the follo
wing
Management Reflection shows.
MANAGEMENT REFLECTION
Focus on Customer ServiceFocus on Customer Service
VanCity Champions the Underdog
How does a small bank compete against the larger ones? Vancouver City Savings
Credit Union (VanCity) does not hope to be like the country s Big Five banks.30 It
is
much smaller, for one thing. Profit is not the bank s only goal. Even so, the bank
made
record profits last year, but returned 30 percent of the profits to its members
and the community.
Says CEO Dave Mowat, What we completely understand is that if we ever just
focus on the profit end, maybe a $9-billion organization isn t big enough to be a
financial
institution. And you just lost your differential. That s where all the community
service and advocacy comes in.
VanCity is sometimes mocked for its left coast ways, but it is not afraid to be
clear about its mission: The bank is committed to the community, social responsi
bility,
and the environment. This is also what makes the bank unique. Every day of our li
ves
we re trading on our differentiation, Mowat says. We have to do it a little bit diff
erent,
a little bit better to give value-added to draw people to our organization. Ther
e isn t an
end point where we can win on scale. What they can win on is customer service. As
Mowat explains, We re always looking to provide that extra bit of customization.
While VanCity has many wealthy clients, it likes to work with the less fortunate
.
Currently it is setting up a branch in Canada s poorest neighbourhood, East Vancou
ver.
Mowat believes these clients can be just as trustworthy when you take the time t
o get to
know them. VanCity is so dedicated to customer service that its customer satisfa
ction rating
is at 85 percent, compared with 60 percent for the big banks. ¦
Practically any successful consumer product or service can be identified as an e
xample
of the differentiation strategy: Calgary-based WestJet Airlines (customer servic
e); Ottawa-
based Research In Motion, the maker of the BlackBerry (quality and innovative de
sign);
Vancouver-based Martha Sturdy (furniture design and brand image); and Ottawa-bas
ed
Lee Valley Tools (product design).
Focus Strategy The first two of Porter s competitive strategies seek a competitive
advantage
in the broad marketplace. However, the focus strategy involves a cost advantage
(cost
focus) or a differentiation advantage (differentiation focus) in a narrow indust
ry segment.
That is, managers select a market segment in an industry and attempt to exploit
it rather than
differentiation strategy
A business-level strategy in which
a company seeks to offer unique
products that are widely valued by
customers.
1. Perform a SWOT analysis on a local business you think you know well. What, if
any, competitive
advantage does this organization have?
2. Should ethical considerations be included in analyses of an organization s exte
rnal and
internal environments? Why or why not?
3. How might the process of strategy formulation, implementation, and evaluation
differ for
(a) large businesses, (b) small businesses, (c) not-for-profit organizations, an
d (d) global
businesses?
4. How could the Internet be helpful to managers as they follow the steps in the
strategic
management process?
5. The concept of competitive advantage is as important for not-for-profit organi
zations as it
is for for-profit organizations. Do you agree or disagree with this statement? Ex
plain,
using examples to make your case.
6. Find examples of five different organizational mission statements. Using the
mission
statements, describe what types of corporate-level and business-level strategies
each
organization might use to fulfill that mission statement. Explain your rationale
for choosing
each strategy.
Working Together: Team-Based Exercise
Examples of organizational strategies are found everywhere in business and gener
al news periodicals.
You should be able to recognize the different types of strategies from these new
s stories.
Form groups of three or four individuals. Using news stories in the business and
popular press,
find examples of five different organizational strategies. Determine whether the
examples are corporate
level, business level, or functional level, and explain why your group made that
choice. Be
prepared to share your examples with the class.
Ethical Dilemma Exercise
What happens when a new entrant shakes up an entire industry and changes the com
petitive situation?
Book retailing is a good example. In Japan, the Bookoff chain stirred up controv
ersy by
manoeuvering around the country s law forbidding discounts on new books. Instead,
Bookoff
buys used books from customers, cleans them up, and sells them for half the orig
inal price.
Even as Bookoff has expanded to 700 stores, competitors are upset because they c
annot legally
cut their prices to compete. Moreover, the Japan Booksellers Federation complain
s that teenagers
could be shoplifting books from other stores to sell to Bookoff.
In the United States, Amazon.com has used the Internet to successfully compete a
gainst longestablished
store chains such as Barnes & Noble. Amazon.com also allows dealers and individu
als
to sell used books alongside the new books posted on its online system.
Even though people buy and sell used books (and other items) through auctions on
eBay
sales from which authors receive no royalties Amazon.com is primarily a retailer c
ompeting
with other retailers on and off the web.40 Amazon.com s practice has drawn some pr
otests. The
Authors Guild in the United States wants its members to boycott Amazon.com becau
se authors
receive no royalties from sales of used books, only sales of new books.
Imagine you re an Indigo.ca manager with responsibility for expanding revenues by
broadening
the range of products offered on Indigo s website. You are trying to develop new s
trategies
because Amazon now retails in Canada through its Amazon.ca website. Although exp
anding into
the used book market might increase Indigo s sales, you are somewhat concerned abo
ut the
Chapter 7 Strategic Management 201
202 Part 2 Planning
MANAGEMENT AT WORK
Joe Boxer
Case Application
Nicholas Graham is the king of underwear and the self-pro-
claimed Chief Underpants Officer of Joe Boxer. Originally from
Calgary, Graham loves to create a spectacle. From the time he
put up the world s largest email-message centre for Joe Boxer
on a billboard in New York s Times Square to the time he dressed
up as the Queen of England, suspended himself by a crane 30
metres above Times Square, and tossed boxer shorts attached
to bagels down to the gathered crowd, Graham believes in pro-
moting his company whenever, wherever, and however he can.
There s no doubt that Graham s strength is branding. He says,
The brand is the amusement park. The product is the sou-
venir. And Graham s odd, and sometimes wacky, strategies
reflect his philosophy. What he really loves is creating experi-
ences for customers that provide a respite from the hubbub of
the modern world a single moment that makes them stop,
do a double-take, and laugh. But things at Joe Boxer haven t
always been so laughable.
From the company s beginning in 1985, Joe Boxer enjoyed
phenomenal growth. Today it has one of the most recognized
fashion brands. Among target customers aged 15 to 30, Joe
Boxer has 87 percent brand awareness. However, over the years
as the company grew, Graham found himself having to deal with
the managerial complexities of running a major fashion com-
pany. Although he brought in executives to help with the details,
the company rapidly lost cash and racked up $18 million in
debt. Many of the financial problems stemmed from Graham s
publicity stunts and cost overruns such as paying too much for
manufacturing products. By 2001, the company was in such
bad shape that a lawsuit filed by a licensee in which Joe Boxer
was ordered to pay $3.15 million had Graham filling out bank-
ruptcy papers.
Bill Sweedler, CEO of Windsong Allegiance Group, is consid-
ering acquiring the resources of Joe Boxer in exchange for
assuming all its debt. Windsong licenses designer labels and dis-
tributes branded underwear, so the Joe Boxer brand had sig-
nificant appeal.
Sweedler is meeting with Graham to discuss the possibil-
ity of buying Joe Boxer from him. Graham has indicated some
interest in this arrangement, but wants to remain as the com-
pany s brand adviser and chief promoter.
Should Sweedler buy the Joe Boxer assets? How can he
best position Joe Boxer to move forward?
Sources: Information from company website, http://www.joeboxer.com (accessed
November 8, 2004); and Windsong Allegiance website,
http://www.windsongallegiance.com (accessed November 8, 2004); and
P. Keegan, The Rise and Fall (and Rise Again) of Joe Boxer, Business 2.0,
December 2002/January 2003, pp. 76 82.
impact this might have on author royalties. You are also worried that the Canadi
an Authors
Association might decide to start a boycott if you sell used books. This could h
arm your instore
sales. What should you do? (Review Exhibit 7 6 as you think about this challenge.)
202 Part 2 Planning
MANAGEMENT AT WORK
Joe Boxer
Case Application
Nicholas Graham is the king of underwear and the self-pro-
claimed Chief Underpants Officer of Joe Boxer. Originally from
Calgary, Graham loves to create a spectacle. From the time he
put up the world s largest email-message centre for Joe Boxer
on a billboard in New York s Times Square to the time he dressed
up as the Queen of England, suspended himself by a crane 30
metres above Times Square, and tossed boxer shorts attached
to bagels down to the gathered crowd, Graham believes in pro-
moting his company whenever, wherever, and however he can.
There s no doubt that Graham s strength is branding. He says,
The brand is the amusement park. The product is the sou-
venir. And Graham s odd, and sometimes wacky, strategies
reflect his philosophy. What he really loves is creating experi-
ences for customers that provide a respite from the hubbub of
the modern world a single moment that makes them stop,
do a double-take, and laugh. But things at Joe Boxer haven t
always been so laughable.
From the company s beginning in 1985, Joe Boxer enjoyed
phenomenal growth. Today it has one of the most recognized
fashion brands. Among target customers aged 15 to 30, Joe
Boxer has 87 percent brand awareness. However, over the years
as the company grew, Graham found himself having to deal with
the managerial complexities of running a major fashion com-
pany. Although he brought in executives to help with the details,
the company rapidly lost cash and racked up $18 million in
debt. Many of the financial problems stemmed from Graham s
publicity stunts and cost overruns such as paying too much for
manufacturing products. By 2001, the company was in such
bad shape that a lawsuit filed by a licensee in which Joe Boxer
was ordered to pay $3.15 million had Graham filling out bank-
ruptcy papers.
Bill Sweedler, CEO of Windsong Allegiance Group, is consid-
ering acquiring the resources of Joe Boxer in exchange for
assuming all its debt. Windsong licenses designer labels and dis-
tributes branded underwear, so the Joe Boxer brand had sig-
nificant appeal.
Sweedler is meeting with Graham to discuss the possibil-
ity of buying Joe Boxer from him. Graham has indicated some
interest in this arrangement, but wants to remain as the com-
pany s brand adviser and chief promoter.
Should Sweedler buy the Joe Boxer assets? How can he
best position Joe Boxer to move forward?
Sources: Information from company website, http://www.joeboxer.com (accessed
November 8, 2004); and Windsong Allegiance website,
http://www.windsongallegiance.com (accessed November 8, 2004); and
P. Keegan, The Rise and Fall (and Rise Again) of Joe Boxer, Business 2.0,
December 2002/January 2003, pp. 76 82.
impact this might have on author royalties. You are also worried that the Canadi
an Authors
Association might decide to start a boycott if you sell used books. This could h
arm your instore
sales. What should you do? (Review Exhibit 7 6 as you think about this challenge.)
MANAGEMENTFOR YOU
MANAGEMENTFOR YOU
Learning Checklist
After reading and studying this chapter, evaluate your understanding by placing
a . next to those things
in the list that you can do successfully. Be sure to reread the chapter for any
topics that you haven t
checked.
1. _____ Explain why strategic management is important.
2. _____ Discuss what studies of the effectiveness of
strategic management have shown.
3. _____ List the six steps in the strategic management
process.
4. _____ Describe what managers do when they do external
and internal analyses.
5. _____ Explain the role of resources, capabilities, and
core competencies in the internal analysis.
6. _____ Explain the three growth strategies.
7. _____ Discuss the BCG matrix and how it s used.
8. _____ Define strategic business units and business-level
strategies.
9. _____ Describe the role of competitive advantage in
business-level strategies.
10. _____ Describe Porter s five competitive forces.
11. _____ Describe the three competitive strategies.
12. _____ Discuss the implications of dynamic and uncertain
environments on organizational strategy.
13. _____ Describe strategies for applying e-business
techniques.
14. _____ Explain what strategies organizations might use to
become more customer service oriented and
more innovative.
Self-Assessment