You are on page 1of 108

Sometimes it takes just one human being to tip the

scales and change the course of history. At some point UN-HABITAT

in the year 2007, that human being will either move


to a city or be born in one. The event itself will go
unnoticed but demographers watching urban trends STATE OF THE WORLD’S

cities
will mark it as the moment when the world entered a
new urban millennium, a period in which, for the
first time in history, the majority of the world’s people
will live in cities. The year 2007 will also see the
number of slum dwellers in the world cross the one
billion mark – when one in every three city residents
will live in a slum.

Although poverty remains a primarily rural


phenomenon, large sections of the urban population
in developing countries are suffering from extreme
levels of deprivation that are often even more
2006/7
debilitating than those experienced by the rural poor.
The Millennium
UN-HABITAT analyses reflected in this Report
Development Goals and

S TAT E O F T H E WO R L D ’ S C I T I E S 2 0 0 6 / 7
show that the incidence of disease and mortality is
much higher in slums than in non-slum urban areas, Urban Sustainability:
and in some cases, such as HIV prevalence and other 30 Years of Shaping
health indicators, is equal to or even higher than in the Habitat Agenda
rural areas. These disparities are often not reflected in
national statistics, which mask the deprivation
experienced in poor urban neighbourhoods. The
findings in this Report reveal “a tale of two cities
within one city”, where non-slum populations enjoy
good health and education, while slum communities
suffer from both poor health and lack of
opportunities.

This edition of the State of the World’s Cities Report


provides an overview of a range of issues that link
cities, slums and the Millennium Development
Goals. It makes clear that the global fight against
poverty – encapsulated in the Millennium
Development Goals – is heavily dependent on how
well cities perform.

The Report highlights three inter-related issues:


• The Millennium Development Goals provide an
apt framework for linking the opportunities
provided by cities with improved quality of life;
• The achievement of the Goals heavily depends on
governments’ capacity to speed up progress and
reverse current trends on slum formation;
• The achievement of the Goals depends on
governments' capacity to speed up progress in
reducing urban poverty and inequality and in
reversing current trends in slum formation.

www.unhabitat.org

UN-HABITAT
First published by Earthscan in the UK and USA in 2006 for and on behalf of the United Nations Human Settlements Programme (UN-HABITAT)

Copyright © United Nations Human Settlements Programme, 2006

All rights reserved

United Nations Human Settlements Programme (UN-HABITAT)


P.O. Box 30030, Nairobi, Kenya
Tel: +254 20 7621 234
Fax: +254 20 7624 266/7
Website: www.unhabitat.org

DISCLAIMER

The designations employed and the presentation of the material in this report do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the
Secretariat of the United Nations concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area, or of its authorities, or concerning delimitation of its
frontiers or boundaries, or regarding its economic system or degree of development. The analysis, conclusions and recommendations of this report do
not necessarily reflect the views of the United Nations Human Settlements Programme or its Governing Council.

HS/814/06E (paperback)
HS/815/06E (hardback)

ISBN-10: 1-84407-378-5 (Earthscan paperback) 92-1-131811-4 (UN-HABITAT paperback)


ISBN-13: 978-1-84407-378-8 (Earthscan paperback) 978-92-1-131811-1 (UN-HABITAT paperback)
ISBN-10: 1-84407-379-3 (Earthscan hardback) 92-1-131812-2 (UN-HABITAT hardback)
ISBN-13: 978-1-84407-379-5 (Earthscan hardback) 978-92-1-131812-8 (UN-HABITAT hardback)

Design and layout by Michael Jones Software, Nairobi, Kenya


Printed and bound in Malta by Gutenberg Press Ltd

For a full list of Earthscan publications contact:

Earthscan
8–12 Camden High Street
London, NW1 0JH, UK
Tel: +44 (0)20 7387 8558
Fax: +44 (0)20 7387 8998
E-mail: earthinfo@earthscan.co.uk
Website: www.earthscan.co.uk

22883 Quicksilver Drive, Sterling, VA 20166-2012, USA

Earthscan is an imprint of James & James (Science Publishers) Ltd and publishes in association with the International Institute for Environment and
Development

A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data

[to follow]
THE STATE OF THE WORLD’S CITIES REPORT 2006/2007
30 Years of Shaping the Habitat Agenda

United Nations Human Settlements Programme


S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Forword Introduction
The 2006/2007 edition of the State of the World’s Cities marks Istanbul in 1996. With the adoption of the Millennium
two important milestones: the dawn of the urban millennium Declaration by the world’s leaders in 2000, much of this work
in 2007 and the 30th anniversary of the first Habitat is now focused on monitoring progress in attaining
Conference held in Vancouver in June 1976, which placed Millennium Development Goal 7, target 11 on improving the
“urbanisation” on the global development agenda. This publi- lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers by 2020. This task
cation also marks a less triumphal moment in history. Thirty requires the analysis of how well cities are doing and of the
years after the world’s governments first pledged to do more for actual living conditions of the urban poor. Data for this report
cities, almost one-third of the world’s urban population lives in comes primarily from Phase III of UN-HABITAT’s Urban
slums, most of them without access to decent housing or basic Indicators Programme that compiles global, regional, country
services and where disease, illiteracy and crime are rampant. and household-level data of specific relevance to the Habitat
Agenda and the Millennium Development Goals.
Since its establishment in 1979, the United Nations Human
Settlements Programme (UN-HABITAT) has continued to This Report clearly shows how shelter conditions have a direct
highlight the important role and contribution of cities in fos- impact on human development, including child mortality, edu-
tering economic and human development. Understanding the cation and employment. The correlation between a poor living
complex social, cultural and economic dynamics of cities and environment, characterized by one or more shelter depriva-
urbanisation is more important now than ever before as we tions, and poor performance on key indicators of the
strive to attain internationally agreed development goals. In a Millennium Development Goals underscores the assertion that
rapidly urbanizing world attaining these goals will require poli- “where we live matters”. The findings of this report are unfold-
cies and strategies based on clear and accurate data on the ing a new urban reality that needs to be urgently addressed by
human settlements conditions and trends in each country. pro-poor and gender-sensitive urban policies and legislation.

This edition of the State of the World’s Cities advances this Finally, as the international community celebrates Vancouver +
objective by breaking new ground in the area of urban data col- 30, it should also reflect on the important lessons learned in
lection, analysis and dissemination. For the first time in the his- urban development and the need to reduce inequalities within
tory of the United Nations, urban data is reported here at slum cities. Cities present an unparalleled opportunity for the simul-
and non-slum levels, going far beyond the traditional urban- taneous attainment of most if not all of the internationally
rural dichotomy. UN-HABITAT’s intra-urban data analysis – agreed development goals. Interventions in, for example, pro-
involving disaggregated data for more than 200 cities around poor water and sanitation, have immediate positive knock-on
the world – takes this work further and provides detailed evi- effects in terms of improved health, nutrition, disease preven-
dence of urban inequalities in the areas of health, education, tion and the environment. However, unless such concerted
employment and other key indicators. The implications are sig- action is taken to redress urban inequalities cities may well
nificant for the attainment of Millennium Development Goals become the predominant sites of deprivation, social exclusion
as we can no longer assume that the urban poor are better off and instability worldwide.
than their rural counterparts, or that all urban dwellers are able
to benefit from basic services by virtue of proximity.

UN-HABITAT has led the drive for urban indicators since


1991 by working with other United Nations agencies and
external partners to consistently refine methods for data collec-
tion and analysis and to better inform our common quest for
“adequate shelter for all” and “sustainable human settlements Anna K. Tibaijuka
development in an urbanizing world” - the twin goals of the Under-Secretary-General and Executive Director,
Habitat Agenda adopted by the world’s governments in UN-HABITAT

ii iii
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Although poverty remains a primarily rural phenomenon, • Likewise, in some cities, such as Khartoum and Nairobi,
urban poverty is becoming a severe, pervasive - and largely unac- the prevalence of diarrhoea is much higher among slum
knowledged - feature of urban life. Large sections of the popula- children than among rural children. In slums, child deaths
tion in urban areas are suffering from extreme levels of depriva- are attributed not so much to lack of immunization against
tion that are often even more debilitating than those experienced measles, but inadequate living conditions, such as lack of
by the rural poor. UN-HABITAT analyses reflected in this Report access to water and sanitation or indoor air pollution,
show that the incidence of disease and mortality is much higher which lead to water-borne and respiratory illnesses among

Overview in slums than in non-slum urban areas, and in some cases, such
as HIV prevalence and other health indicators, is equal to or even
higher than in rural areas. These disparities are often not reflected
children.
• Malnutrition and hunger in slums is almost the same as in
villages in some countries. In India, for instance, slum

S
ometimes it takes just one human being to tip the growth in many regions, as is reclassification of rural areas into in national statistics, which mask the deprivation experienced in dwellers suffer slightly more from malnutrition than the
scales and change the course of history. At some point urban areas. However, the relative absence of infrastructure, poor urban neighbourhoods. Inequality in access to services, rural population of the country.
in the year 2007, that human being will either move such as roads, water supply and communication facilities, in housing, land, education, health care and employment opportu- • Recent data on HIV/AIDS shows that in various sub-
to a city or be born in one. The event itself will go many small and intermediate-sized cities makes these cities less nities within cities have socio-economic, environmental and polit- Saharan African countries, HIV prevalence is significantly
unnoticed but demographers watching urban trends competitive locally, nationally and regionally, and leads to a ical repercussions, including rising violence, urban unrest, envi- higher in urban areas than in rural areas, and is also high-
will mark it as the moment when the world entered a new lower quality of life for their citizens. ronmental degradation and underemployment, which threaten to er in slums than in non-slum urban areas. Moreover, slum
urban millennium, a period in which, for the first time in his- Thirdly, cities of the developing world will absorb 95 per diminish any gains in income and poverty reduction. women are particularly at risk, with HIV prevalence rates
tory, the majority of the world’s people will live in cities. cent of urban growth in the next two decades, and by 2030, This edition of the State of the World’s Cities Report provides that are higher than that of both men and rural women.
The year 2007 will also see the number of slum dwellers in will be home to almost 4 billion people, or 80 per cent of the an overview of a range of issues that link cities, slums and the • Age pyramids for slum and rural populations in several
the world cross the one billion mark – when one in every three world’s urban population. After 2015, the world’s rural popu- Millennium Development Goals. It makes clear that the glob- countries show similar patterns: both groups tend to be
city residents will live in inadequate housing with no or few lation will begin to shrink as urban growth becomes more al fight against poverty – encapsulated in the Millennium younger and generally die sooner than non-slum urban
basic services. This statistic may be reported in newspaper intense in cities of Asia and Africa, two regions that are set to Development Goals – is heavily dependent on how well cities populations, which tend to have the lowest child mortali-
headlines, but it is still not yet clear how it will influence gov- host the world’s largest urban populations in 2030, 2.66 billion perform. The Report highlights three inter-related issues: ty rates and the highest life expectancy rates.
ernment policies and actions, particularly in relation to and 748 million, respectively. Urban poverty and inequality • The Millennium Development Goals provide an apt frame- The above examples show that slum populations are not
Millennium Development Goal 7, target 11: by 2020, to have will characterize many cities in the developing world, and work for linking the opportunities provided by cities with benefiting from the advantages and opportunities offered by
improved the lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers. urban growth will become virtually synonymous with slum for- improved quality of life; cities. Studies have also shown that children living in a slum
mation in some regions. Asia is already home to more than half • The achievement of the Goals depends on governments' within a city are more likely to die from pneumonia, diar-
of the world’s slum population (581 million) – followed by capacity to speed up progress in reducing urban poverty and rhoea, malaria, measles or HIV/AIDS than those living in a
■ Cities, Slums and the Millennium sub-Saharan Africa (199 million) and Latin America and the inequality and in reversing current trends in slum formation; non-slum area within the same city; many of these diseases are
Development Goals Caribbean (134 million). Sub-Saharan Africa has both the • Improving the living conditions of slum dwellers (housing, the result of poor living conditions prevalent in slums rather
highest annual urban growth rate and the highest slum growth tenure, infrastructure and access to basic services) will auto- than the absence of immunization coverage or lack of health
Three important trends characterize the urbanization process rate in the world, 4.58 per cent and 4.53 per cent, respectively, matically have a positive impact on the attainment of most facilities. In many cases, poverty, poor sanitation and indoor
in this new urban era. Firstly, the biggest cities in the world will more than twice the world average. The continued threat of of the Goals and their related targets. air pollution make children and women living in slums more
be found mainly in the developing world. “Metacities” – mas- conflict in several African countries is a significant contributing vulnerable to respiratory illnesses and other infectious dis-
sive conurbations of more than 20 million people, above and factor in the proliferation of slums in the region’s urban areas. eases than their rural counterparts. For many slum dwellers,
beyond the scale of megacities – are now gaining ground in The prolonged crisis in Southern Sudan, for instance, has led ■ Where We Live Matters: The Social and overcrowding, housing located in hazardous areas and the
Asia, Latin America and Africa. These cities are home to only 4 to the mass exodus of rural communities to the capital Health Costs of Living in a Slum threat of eviction affects other livelihood issues, such as
per cent of the world’s population and most have grown at the Khartoum, which accommodated almost half of the more than employment. Some studies have also found a strong correla-
relatively slow rate of about 1.5 per cent annually. However, the 6 million internally displaced persons in the country in the late For as long as governments have been monitoring the human tion between where people live and their chances of finding a
sheer size of these urban agglomerations points to the growth 1990s. These trends will most likely concern policymakers in development performance of their countries, achievements in job. One such study in France showed that job applicants
of city-regions and “metropolitanization” that call for more the developing world as they confront the reality of growing various sectors have tended to focus on only two geographical residing in poor neighbourhoods were less likely to be called
polycentric forms of urban governance and management and inequality and poverty in their cities. areas: rural and urban. In general, statistics show that urban for interviews than those who lived in middle- or high-
stronger inter-municipal relations. The scale of environmental The good news is that urbanization can also be a positive populations are better off than those living in villages: they income neighbourhoods. Another study in Rio de Janeiro
impact of metacities and megacities on their hinterlands is also force for human development; countries that are highly urban- tend to enjoy more access to services and generally perform well found that living in a favela (slum) was a bigger barrier to
significant and is likely to be a cause for concern in coming ized tend to have higher incomes, more stable economies, on a range of human development indicators, including life gaining employment than being dark skinned or female, a
decades. stronger institutions and are better able to withstand the expectancy and literacy. However, evidence suggests that in finding that confirms that “where we live matters” when it
Secondly, despite the emergence of metacities, the majority volatility of the global economy. In both developed and devel- many developing countries, urban poverty is becoming as comes to health, education and employment.
of urban migrants will be moving to small towns and cities of oping countries, cities generate a disproportionate share of severe and as dehumanizing as rural poverty. This Report pres- These findings reveal “a tale of two cities within one city”.
less than one million inhabitants. Already, more than half of gross domestic product and provide extensive opportunities for ents for the first time data disaggregated at urban, rural, slum Thus, policymakers, governments, development practitioners
the world’s urban population lives in cities of fewer than employment and investment. However, evidence suggests that and non-slum levels. The findings show remarkable similarities and funding agencies should no longer see the city as one
500,000 inhabitants, and almost one-fifth lives in cities of despite the enormous potential of cities to bring about prosper- between slums and rural areas: homogenous entity. Slums are not only a manifestation of
between 1 and 5 million inhabitants. These intermediate cities ity, the wealth generated by cities does not automatically lead • In low-income countries, such as Bangladesh, Ethiopia, poor housing standards, lack of basic services and denial of
are predicted to grow at a faster rate than any other type of city. to poverty reduction; on the contrary, in many cities, inequali- Haiti, India, Nepal and Niger, 4 out of every 10 slum chil- human rights, they are also a symptom of dysfunctional urban
Natural population increase, rather than rural-to-urban migra- ties between the rich and the poor have grown, as have the sizes dren are malnourished, a rate that is comparable to rural societies where inequalities are not only tolerated, but allowed
tion, is becoming a more significant contributor to urban and proportions of slum populations. areas of those countries. to fester.

iv v
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

This Report unfolds a new urban reality that shows how UN-HABITAT presents an analysis of the degrees of shelter Lack of access to improved water Inadequate sanitation is therefore something of a “silent
poor living conditions impact the world’s slum dwellers: slum deprivation in some selected countries and regions. This type Although official statistics reflect better water coverage in tsunami” causing waves of illness and death, especially among
dwellers die earlier, experience more hunger, have less educa- of information helps to connect monitoring information to urban areas than in rural areas, various surveys show that in women and children. As this Report shows, mortality rates
tion, have fewer chances of employment in the formal sector policy, making more rigorous and systematic the development many cities, the quantity, quality and affordability of water in are quite often linked to whether or not children or their
and suffer more from ill-health than the rest of the inhabi- of programmes and interventions that are better attuned to low-income urban settlements falls short of acceptable stan- mothers have access to adequate sanitation facilities; in the
tants of cities. specific locations and situations. dards. Improved water provision in the world’s urban areas was city of Fortaleza in Brazil, for instance, child mortality rates
The international community cannot afford to ignore The State of the World’s Cities Report 2006/7 provides an reported to be as high as 95 per cent in 2002. This statistic, dropped dramatically when sanitation coverage increased.
slum dwellers because, after rural populations, they represent overview of the state of the world’s slums with regards to the however, presents an overly optimistic picture since “improved”
the second largest target group for development interven- five indicators. The following provides a summary of the main provision of water does not always mean that the provision is Lack of secure tenure
tions – and their size is set to grow as the developing world findings. safe, sufficient, affordable or easily accessible. For example, fur- Mass evictions of slum and squatter settlements in various
becomes more urbanized. The Millennium Development ther analysis reveals that getting water from a tap is a luxury cities in recent years suggest that security of tenure is becom-
Goals thus have to target this disadvantaged and vulnerable Lack of durable housing enjoyed by only two-third of the world’s urban population; less ing increasingly precarious, particularly in cities of sub-
group of people; if they are ignored, it is very likely that the It is estimated that 133 million people living in cities of than half of this group (46 per cent) have piped water within Saharan Africa and Asia, where evictions are often carried out
Millennium Development Goals will not be achieved. the developing world lack durable housing. Non-durable or their dwelling; 10 per cent rely on public taps, while 8 per cent to make room for large-scale infrastructure or city “beautifi-
non-permanent housing is more prevalent in some regions have access only to manually pumped water or protected wells. cation” programmes. A global survey in 60 countries found
than in others; over half the urban population living in Inter-regional differences indicate that Africa has the lowest that 6.7 million people had been evicted from their homes
■ The State of the World’s Slums non-permanent houses resides in Asia, while Northern proportion (38.3 per cent) of urban households with access to between 2000 and 2002, compared with 4.2 million in the
Africa has the least numbers of people living in this kind of piped water, while the Latin American and Caribbean region previous two years. Many of these evictions were carried out
The growth of slums in the last 15 years has been unprece- housing. However, UN-HABITAT analysis shows that has the highest (89.3 per cent). Sometimes, even when water is without legal notice or without following due process.
dented. In 1990, there were nearly 715 million slum dwellers global figures on housing durability are highly underesti- available, it may not be affordable or safe to drink. In Addis Improving the tenure of urban households could go a long
in the world. By 2000 – when world leaders set the target of mated due to the fact that durability is based primarily on Ababa, Ethiopia, a UN-HABITAT survey showed that the pro- way in preventing evictions, but operationalizing security of
improving the lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers by permanence of individual structures, not on location or portion of low-income urban residents with access to water tenure for the purpose of global monitoring remains difficult.
2020 – the slum population had increased to 912 million. compliance with building codes. Moreover, estimates are supply dropped to 21 per cent from 89 per cent when the oper- At present, it is neither possible to obtain household-level
Today, there are approximately 998 million slum dwellers in made taking into account only the nature of the floor mate- ational definition of “access” included variables such as cost and data on secure tenure in most countries, nor to produce glob-
the world. UN-HABITAT estimates that, if current trends con- rial, since information on roof and wall materials is collect- quality. Poor access to water in urban areas has a direct bearing al comparative data on various institutional aspects of secure
tinue, the slum population will reach 1.4 billion by 2020. ed in very few countries. For instance, figures indicate that on rates of water-borne or water-related diseases in urban areas, tenure, as data on secure tenure is not regularly collected by
One out of every three city dwellers lives in slum conditions. over 90 per cent of the world’s urban dwellings have perma- a phenomenon that is explored in some depth in the latter part censuses or household surveys . However, non- empirical
Some slums become less visible or more integrated into the nent floors, but when estimates are made combining floor, of the Report. information suggests that between 30 per cent and 50 per
urban fabric as cities develop and as the incomes of slum roof and wall materials, this figure drops dramatically in cent of urban residents in the developing world lack security
dwellers improve. Others become permanent features of urban several countries. In Bolivia, for instance, when only floor Lack of access to improved sanitation of tenure. Although home ownership is regarded as the most
landscapes. Both types of slums have carved their way into material is considered, 83.8 per cent of the urban popula- Over 25 per cent of the developing world’s urban popula- secure form of tenure, evidence from around the world also
modern-day cities, making their mark as a distinct category of tion is counted as having durable housing, but when wall tion – or 560 million city residents – lack adequate sanitation. suggests that ownership is not the norm in both the devel-
human settlement that needs to be looked at over and above and roof materials are taken into account, this figure drops Asia alone accounts for over 70 per cent of this group, main- oped and the developing world, and is not the only means to
the traditional rural-urban dichotomy. to 27.7 per cent. Statistical analysis presented in this ly because of the large populations of China and India; in achieve tenure security. In fact, informal – or illegal – growth
Slum dwellers often live in difficult social and economic Report shows that when more physical structure variables 2000, sanitation coverage in Chinese cities was reported to be has become the most common form of housing production in
conditions that manifest different forms of deprivation – are combined, the results provide a more realistic image of approximately 33 per cent. UN-HABITAT analysis shows the developing world, where gaining access to housing
material, physical, social and political. Throughout this housing durability. that while cities in South-Eastern Asia and Southern Asia through legal channels is the exception rather than the rule
Report, UN-HABITAT uses an operational definition of have made significant progress in recent years to improve san- for the majority of urban poor households. UN-HABITAT
slums – one with measurable indicators at household level. Lack of sufficient living area itation coverage in urban areas, access lags far behind in sub- and its partners are currently working on the preparation of a
Four of the five indicators measure physical expressions of Overcrowding is a manifestation of housing inequality and Saharan Africa and Eastern Asia, where 45 per cent and 31 global monitoring system that could in the future provide a
slum conditions: lack of water; lack of sanitation; overcrowd- is also a hidden form of homelessness. In 2003, approximate- per cent of the urban population still lacks access to improved framework to assist governments at local and national levels
ing; and non-durable housing structures. These indicators – ly 20 per cent of the developing world’s urban population – sanitation, respectively. However, some countries in Southern to produce estimates on how many people have secure tenure,
known also as shelter deprivations – focus attention on the 401 million people – lived in houses that lacked sufficient liv- Asia have extremely low coverage, notably Afghanistan, where using an agreed-upon methodology in terms of definitions,
circumstances that surround slum life, depicting deficiencies ing area (with three or more people sharing a bedroom). Two- only 16 per cent of the urban population has access to a prop- indicators and variables.
and casting poverty as an attribute of the environments in thirds of the developing world’s urban population living in er toilet. Lack of access to an adequate toilet not only violates
which slum dwellers live. The fifth indicator – security of overcrowded conditions resides in Asia; half of this group, or the dignity of the urban poor, but also affects their health.
tenure – has to do with legality, which is not as easy to meas- 156 million people, reside in Southern Asia. This Report Every year, hundreds of thousands of people die as a result of ■ 30 Years of Shaping the “Habitat”Agenda:
ure or monitor, as the status of slum dwellers often depends shows how living conditions, including overcrowding and living conditions made unhealthy by lack of clean water and Policies and Practices That Have Worked
on de facto or de jure rights – or lack of them. By knowing poor ventilation, are related to rates of illness, child mortality sanitation. The number of deaths attributable to poor sanita-
how many slum dwellers there are in cities and what shelter and increase in negative social behaviors. It stresses that the tion and hygiene alone may be as high as 1.6 million per year Since the first UN Conference on Human Settlements
deprivations they suffer most from, it becomes possible to risk of disease transmission and multiple infections becomes – five times as many people who died in the 2004 Indian (Habitat I) took place in Vancouver in 1976, governments
design interventions that target the most vulnerable urban substantially higher as the number of people crowded into Ocean tsunami. A disproportionate share of the labour and and the international community have adopted and imple-
populations. small, poorly ventilated spaces increases. After presenting health burden of inadequate sanitation falls on women, who mented a range of human settlements policies and pro-
Not all slums are homogeneous and not all slum dwellers overcrowding data by region, the Report highlights some of have to wait for long periods to gain access to public toilets or grammes with mixed results. Many programmes were unsuc-
suffer from the same degree of deprivation. In this Report, the local variances of the definition. have to bear the indignity of defecating in the open. cessful; others, while successful at the pilot stages, could not

vi vii
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

be scaled up and remained small “islands of success” that did urban poor by the top leadership were key to the success of
not have a significant impact on urban poverty levels or slum slum upgrading or prevention programmes. These coun-
growth rates. Few interventions had an economic or social tries developed either specific slum upgrading and preven-
impact on urban poor populations. tion policies or have integrated slum upgrading and preven-
Getting urban poverty on the development agenda has been tion as part of broader poverty reduction policies and pro-
a struggle in the last thirty years. Silence or neglect have char- grammes. They have done this not only to respond to social
acterized most policy responses. However, with the adoption imperatives, but also to promote national economic devel-
of the Millennium Declaration in 2000, urban poverty is now
being brought to the centre stage of the global development
agenda. As part of its mandate to assess the performance of
opment. Central governments in these countries, among
others, have played a critical role, not just in the physical
improvement of slums, but also in ensuring that invest-
Acknowledgements
countries on Millennium Development Goal 7, target 11 – to ments are made in other sectors as well, such as education,
improve the lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers by health, sanitation and transport, which have benefited slum Report Team
2020 – UN-HABITAT built a broad architecture for global communities. Overall coordination: Don Okpala
monitoring and reporting. As part of this process, the organ- This perhaps is a prelude to a change in governance para- Director: Nefise Bazoglu
ization has evaluated the performance of more than 100 digms, in which central governments and local authorities Task Manager: Eduardo López Moreno
countries to see if they were “on track”, “stabilizing”, “at risk” would develop a more coordinated approach in the develop- Statistical Adviser: Gora Mboup
Editor: Rasna Warah
or “off track” vis-à-vis the slum target. Three criteria were ment and implementation of policies, with central govern-
used to rate countries: annual slum growth rate; slum per- ments taking the lead in urban poverty reduction programmes
centage; and slum population. as they would have the power and authority to institute pro-
Principal Authors
Analysis of the results revealed some interesting findings: poor reforms and the mandate and ability to allocate resources
Eduardo López Moreno and Rasna Warah
countries that had successfully reduced slum growth rates, to various priority sectors. On the other hand, local authorities
slum proportions and slum populations in the last 15 years would be able to locally coordinate operational actions bring-
shared many attributes: their governments had shown long- ing together different actors. Contributors
term political commitment to slum upgrading and preven- This Report also clearly shows that not all countries strug- Nefise Bazoglu, Tanzib Chowdhury and Gora Mboup
tion; many had undertaken progressive pro-poor land and gling to cope with high slum growth rates have shied away from
housing reforms to improve the tenure status of slum committing to change. Some sub-Saharan African countries,
dwellers or to improve their access to basic services; most namely Burkina Faso, Senegal and Tanzania, have in recent Additional input to individual chapters
used domestic resources to scale up slum improvements and years shown promising signs of growing political support for Cecilia Andersson, Christine Auclair, Francis Dodoo, Alex Ezeh, Anna Alvazzi del Frate,
prevent future slum growth; and a significant number had slum upgrading and prevention that includes reforms in poli- Meg Holden, Asa Jonsson, Sunita Kapila, Wendy Mendes, Jaana Mioch, Luc Mougeot,
put in place policies that emphasized equity in an environ- cies governing land and housing. Shipra Narang, Karen A. Stanecki, Darcy Varney, Ananda Weliwita and Eliya Zulu
ment of economic growth. In many countries, improvements Some low- or middle-income countries that are starting to
in just one sector, such as sanitation, had a significant impact stabilize or reverse slum growth rates, including Colombia, Statistical Annex: Gora Mboup and Philip Mukungu
on slum reduction, particularly in cities where inhabitants El Salvador, Philippines, Indonesia, Myanmar and Sri Graphs: Natsuo Ito
suffered from only one or two shelter deprivations. Lanka, did not wait to achieve important milestones in eco- Maps: Iris Knabe and Martin Raithelhuber
Design and Layout: Mike Jones
Another major finding of this analysis of country per- nomic growth in order to address slums. These countries
Editorial Assistance: Darcy Varney
formance on the slum target showed that those countries have managed to prevent slum formation by anticipating Research Assistance: Martha Mathenge and Raymond Otieno
doing well in managing slum growth had highly centralized and planning for growing urban populations – by expand-
systems and structures of governance; even in cases where ing economic and employment opportunities for the urban
decentralized systems existed, policy actions for slum pre- poor, by investing in low-cost, affordable housing for the UN-HABITAT Advisory and Technical Support
vention and upgrading were implemented through central- most vulnerable groups and by instituting pro-poor reforms Alioune Badiane, Daniel Biau, William Cobbett, Szilard Fricska, Anne Klen, Dinesh Mehta,
ized interventions. This was possible because central gov- and policies that have had a positive impact on low-income Jane Nyakairu, Alberto Paranhos, Roman Rollnick, Sharad Shankardass, Wandia Seaforth,
ernments –having command and control– could put in people’s access to services. These countries give hope and Farouk Tebbal, Raf Tuts, Francisco Vasquez, Satyanarayana Vejella, Chris Williams and
place measures and resources to ensure cohesiveness in the direction to other low-income countries by showing that it Habitat Programme Managers in selected countries.
design and implementation of slum upgrading projects. is possible to prevent slum formation with the right policies
Central governments had the capacity to put forward legis- and practices.
lation and pro-poor policy reforms to tackle basic shelter What comes out clearly in this Report is that slum formation International Advisory Board
deprivations – reforms that require political support at the is neither inevitable nor acceptable. “Running the poor out of Jo Beall, Joep Bijlmer, Andrew Boraine, Edesio Fernandes, Ilona Kickbusch, Susan
national level before being filtered downward to local levels town” – through evictions or discriminatory practices – is not Loughhead, Miloon Kothari, Patricia L. McCarney, Luc Mougeot, Kalpana Sharma and
of government. These central governments have been able the answer: rather, helping the poor to become more integrat- Molly O’Meara Sheehan
to set up the institutional arrangements, allocate important ed into the fabric of urban society is the only long-lasting and
budgets, and execute projects to effectively meet their tar- sustainable solution to the growing urbanization of poverty.
gets and commitments. In countries such as Brazil, Egypt, Ultimately, as the developing world becomes more urban and
Mexico, South Africa, Thailand and Tunisia, implementa- as the locus of poverty shifts to cities, the battle to achieve the
tion of inclusive policies, land reforms, regularization pro- Millennium Development Goals will have to be waged in the
grammes and commitment to improve the lives of the world’s slums.

viii
Contents

Part 1: Cities, Slums and the Millennium Development Goals Part 2: The State of the World’s Slums Part 3: Where We Live Matters Part 4: Policies and Practices That Have Worked
1.1 ‘City-zens’ of the World: Urban Trends in the 21st century ......................6 2.1 Neither Brick nor Mortar: Non-Durable Housing in Cities ......................60 3.1 The Social and Health Costs of Living in a Slum ..................................104 4.1 Milestones in the Evolution of
3.2 Hunger: The Invisible Crisis in Cities......................................................106 Human Settlements Policies 1976-2006 ................................................156
1.2 Putting Slums on the Map: 2.2 Not Enough Room: Overcrowding in Urban Households..........................70
A Global and Regional Overview..............................................................18 3.3 The Urban Poor Die Young......................................................................110 4.2 Countries Taking Slums Seriously ..........................................................162
2.3 Safe Drinking Water in Cities ..................................................................76
1.3 How Well is Your Country Performing on the Slum Target? 3.4 HIV/AIDS and Urban Poverty ..................................................................116 4.3 Pro-poor Reforms on Slum Upgrading and Prevention ..........................166
2.4 The Silent Tsunami:
A Global Scorecard ..................................................................................40 The High Price of Inadequate Sanitation in Urban Areas........................84 3.5 Education and Youth Employment: 4.4 Governing from the Bottom, Governing from the Top,
Debunking Some Myths about the “Urban Advantage” ........................122 Connecting the Two ..............................................................................170
1.4 The Struggle to Achieve the Millennium Development Goals 2.5 Owners without Titles:
will be Won or Lost in Cities ....................................................................48 Security of Tenure in Cities of the Developing World..............................94 3.6 Cities: The Front Lines in the Battle for Sustainability ..........................130 4.5 Time for Bold Action:
3.7 Double Jeopardy: Scaling up Improvements Today, Preventing Slums Tomorrow ............176
The Impact of Conflict and Natural Disaster on Cities ..........................136 4.6 Is the International Community Ready to Keep the Promise? ..............180
Boxes Boxes
Defining “Urban”..................................................................................................................................................................7 Affordability, accessibility and durable houses ................................................................................................................62 3.8 Urban Insecurity: New Threats, Old Fears ............................................144
What is a slum? ................................................................................................................................................................21 Defining durability..............................................................................................................................................................65
Slums: the shelter dimension of urban poverty ................................................................................................................28
Defining and monitoring slums: seeing beyond the stereotypes ....................................................................................29
Beyond culture: defining overcrowding ............................................................................................................................71
“Improved”or “adequate” access to water: definitions and issues of measurement......................................................78
Boxes
Woman-headed households in cities ................................................................................................................................30 Improved sanitation: a basic principle ..............................................................................................................................85
Boxes Costing the slum target ..................................................................................................................................................164
Extreme deprivation in poor urban settings in sub-Saharan Africa................................................................................120 Improving urban planning and monitoring in the city of Aleppo ....................................................................................167
Age pyramids for slum and non-slum populations in Brazil and South Africa ................................................................31 Defining sanitation: to estimate or to underestimate, that is the question ....................................................................86
Renewable energy sources increase urban sustainability..............................................................................................134
Monitoring secure tenure ..................................................................................................................................................96
Urban crime trends ..........................................................................................................................................................150
Tables Figures
4.1.1 Slum population and urban population growth in the world (1976-2006)..........................................................157
1.2.1 Population of slum areas at mid-year, by region; 1990, 2001, 2005 and annual slum growth rate ....................18
1.2.2 Urban and slum growth rates by region ................................................................................................................20
Tables Figures 4.1.2 GDP per capita by income groups 1975-2004 ....................................................................................................158
2.1.1 Housing durability, based on floor, roof and wall materials, in the urban areas of 16
1.2.3 Proportion of slum households in developing regions by number of shelter deprivations, 2001 ........................35 selected countries, 2001 ........................................................................................................................................63 3.2.1 Slum incidence and proportion of underweight children in selected countries ................................................108
2.1.2 Finished floor coverage among urban population by region, 2003 ......................................................................64 3.3.1 Under-five mortality (deaths per 1000 births) by type of residence in selected countries ................................111
2.2.1 Sufficient living area coverage among urban population by region, 2003 ..........................................................72 3.3.2 Under-five mortality (deaths per 1000) births by type of residence in selected cities ......................................111
Figures 2.3.1 Improved drinking water coverage among urban population by region, 2003 ....................................................79 3.3.3 Diarrhoea prevalence among children under five years in selected countries ..................................................113
1.1.1 Proportion of urban population by region, 1950-2030 ............................................................................................7 2.3.2 Cities making rapid progress in drinking water coverage, 1999-2003 ................................................................81 3.3.4 Proportion of underweight children under age five in selected African cities ..................................................114
1.1.2 Rural and urban population by region in 2005 and 2030 ........................................................................................8 2.4.1 Improved sanitation coverage among urban population by region, 2003 ............................................................88 3.3.5 Proportion of children under age five with Acute Respiratory Infections
1.1.3 Population by city size..............................................................................................................................................9 in selected Latin American and Asian cities ......................................................................................................115
1.1.4 Urban growth in the world’s largest cities, 1950-2020 ........................................................................................10 3.4.1 HIV prevalence among men and women aged 15-49 in urban and rural areas
1.2.1 Slum populations, 1990-2020 ................................................................................................................................21 Figures 3.5.1
in selected sub-Saharan African countries 2000-2004 ......................................................................................116
Net enrolment rate (primary) by type of residence in selected countries ..........................................................124
1.2.2 Proportion of woman-headed households in selected countries..........................................................................30 2.1.1 Distribution of the urban population lacking finished floor materials in developing regions, 2003....................64
2.1.2 Proportion of urban households with finished main floor materials, by region, 1990 and 2003 ........................67 3.5.2 Proportion of women aged 15-24 who stopped going to school because of
1.2.3 Proportion of slum households in developing regions by number of shelter deprivations, 2001 ........................35 inability to pay school fees ..................................................................................................................................126
1.2.4 Magnitude of slums in 2020 under three scenarios..............................................................................................36 2.2.1 Distribution of urban population lacking sufficient living area, 2003 ..................................................................72
3.5.3 Percentage of young women and men working in the informal sector in selected African countries ..............128
1.2.5 The rise and rise of slums, 1990-2020 ..................................................................................................................37 2.2.2 Proportion of urban households with sufficient living area ..................................................................................74
3.5.4 Percentage of young women and men who have family responsibilities in selected countries ......................128
1.3.1 A global scorecard on slums..................................................................................................................................43 2.2.3 Proportion of urban population with access to sufficient living area in selected cities, 2003............................74
3.5.5 Percentage of young women and men working in the informal sector in selected Asian countries ................129
1.4.1 Human development is closely related to levels of urbanization ........................................................................48 2.3.1 Water expense as a fraction of household income in Addis Ababa, 2003 ..........................................................77
1.4.2 The annual growth rate of cities and slums..........................................................................................................51 2.3.2 Distribution of urban population lacking improved drinking water by region, 2003 ............................................79
2.3.3 Access to piped water in selected cities in sub-Saharan Africa, 2003................................................................80
2.3.4 Access to water decreases dramatically when cost and quality are considered: the case of Addis Ababa ......83
Maps 2.4.1 Distribution of urban population lacking improved sanitation by region, 2003....................................................88 City Stories Statements
1 Urban population and slum proportion in African countries, 2001 ......................................................................23 2.4.2 Proportion of urban households with access to improved sanitation ..................................................................90 China’s rising cities......................................................................................................................................................16 Peter Hall: Why some cities flourish while others languish ......................................................................................15
2 Urban population and slum proportion in Asian countries, 2001 ........................................................................25 2.4.3 Cities with low sanitation coverage: Mumbai’s quest for ‘world city’ status ......................................................................................................................26 Scott Leckie: The slum target is not in line with housing rights................................................................................38
3 Urban population and slum proportion in countries of Latin America and the Caribbean, 2001 ........................33 proportion of urban population with access to improved sanitation, 2003..........................................................90 Europe’s forgotten Roma community ..........................................................................................................................68
Miloon Kothari: Water and sanitation: only a human rights approach will do..........................................................82
4-6 A look a country performance in developing regions............................................................................................42 2.5.1 Percentage of urban households with adequate housing in Brazil, 1992-2003 ..................................................95 Sanitation: A women’s issue ......................................................................................................................................92
Evictions fail to address the root cause of urban poverty in Zimbabwe..................................................................100 Lena Sommestad: Stronger action is needed to achieve the sanitation target ........................................................93
Agrocities: combating hunger in urban areas ..........................................................................................................109 Luis Felipe Cabrales Barajos: Gated communities are not the solution to urban security......................................148
Maps Slum conditions increase risk of HIV infection in Nairobi........................................................................................119 Stephen Graham: The urbanization of political violence..........................................................................................152
7 Proportion of households without finished main floor material, 2003 ................................................................63 Immigrants in Paris: dreams go up in flames ..........................................................................................................125
Cities + + = 8
9
Proportion of households lacking sufficient living area, 2003 ..............................................................................73
Proportion of households without access to improved water, 2003 ....................................................................79
Surviving anarchy: Somalia’s experience..................................................................................................................139
New Orleans: poor residents suffer deepest impact of Hurricane Katrina..............................................................142
Elisabeth Gateau: Localizing the Millennium Development Goals ..........................................................................161
Tony Hill: Civil society and the urban agenda ..........................................................................................................172
10 Proportion of households without access to improved sanitation, 2003..............................................................89 Vancouver: The world’s most liveable city combines multiculturalism with environmental sustainability ............160 Antoine Heuty and Sanjay Reddy: Technical fixes are not always the solution......................................................175
Shelter People
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

1
Part One

Cities, Slums and the


Millennium Development Goals

This Part highlights the major urbanization trends


in the world and portrays a global and regional
overview of slums. It also presents the first
findings of country performance on the Millennium
Development Goals’ slum target using a new global
scorecard developed by UN-HABITAT. The Part
concludes by emphasizing the importance of
implementing the Millennium Development Goals
at the city level, and more importantly, in slums. A
table linking cities and slums to the Millennium
Development Goals is also presented.
Bangkok, Thailand JEARANAIKUL/UNEP/STILL PICTURES
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

1.1 ‘City-zens’ of the World: Urban Trends in the 21st Century Defining “Urban”
The United Nations defines an urban agglom- However, an analysis of countries shows that • 25 countries specify economic character-
eration as the built-up or densely populated different criteria and methods are currently istics as significant, though not exclusive,
area containing the city proper, suburbs and con- being used by governments to define “urban”: in defining cities – typically, the proportion
of urban dwellers will keep rising, reaching almost 5 billion by tinuously settled commuter areas. It may be of the labour force employed in non-agri-
2030. Between 2005 and 2030, the world’s urban population is smaller or larger than a metropolitan area; it • 105 countries base their urban data on cultural activities.
expected to grow at an average annual rate of 1.78 per cent, may also comprise the city proper and its subur- administrative criteria, limiting it to the • 18 countries count the availability of
almost twice the growth rate of the world’s total population. As ban fringe or thickly settled adjoining territory. boundaries of state or provincial capitals, urban infrastructure in their definitions,
more and more people occupy cities, the population of rural set- municipalities or other local jurisdictions; 83 including the presence of paved streets,
tlements around the globe will begin to contract after 2015, A metropolitan area is the set of formal local use this as their sole method of distinguishing water supply systems, sewerage systems,
decreasing at an average annual rate of -0.32 through 2030 – a government areas that normally comprise the urban from rural. or electric lighting.
decrease of more than 155 million people over 15 years.1 urban area as a whole and its primary com- • 100 countries define cities by population • 25 countries provide no definition of
muter areas. size or population density, with minimum “urban” at all.
concentrations ranging broadly, from 200 to • 6 countries regard their entire popula-
■ Asia and Africa will host the largest urban A city proper is the single political jurisdiction 50,000 inhabitants; 57 use this as their sole tions as urban.
populations that contains the historical city centre. urban criterion.

Sources: United Nations: Principles and Recommendations for Population and Housing Censuses (1998) and World Urbanization Prospects: The 2003 Revision
Whereas Europe, North America and Latin America experi-
enced intense urbanization – the increased concentration of
people in cities rather than in rural areas – and rapid urban ■ Small and intermediate cities will absorb most cities are significant sites of social and economic activity,
growth through the mid-20th century, the trend has now urban growth often serving as centres of trade and destinations for rural
shifted to the developing regions of Asia and Africa. In-migra- migrants.3 They are often the first places where the social
tion, reclassification and natural population increase are con- Small cities with less than 500,000 inhabitants and inter- urban transformation of families and individuals occurs; by
tributing to a rapid urban transformation of these regions. mediate cities with between 1 and 5 million inhabitants, not offering economic linkages between rural and urban environ-
Annual urban growth rates are highest in sub-Saharan Africa megacities (defined as cities with 10 million or more people), ments, they can provide a “first step” out of poverty for
(4.58 per cent), followed by South-Eastern Asia (3.82 per will continue to absorb most of the urban population around impoverished rural populations and a gateway to opportuni-
cent), Eastern Asia (3.39 per cent), Western Asia (2.96 per the world well into the future. More than 53 per cent of the ties in larger cities. In Eastern Africa, South-Eastern Asia, the
cent), Southern Asia (2.89 per cent) and Northern Africa world’s urban population lives in cities of fewer than 500,000 Caribbean and Europe, cities of fewer than 500,000 are par-
(2.48 per cent). The developed world’s cities are growing at a inhabitants, and another 22 per cent of the global urban pop- ticularly prevalent, hosting approximately two-thirds of those
slower pace, averaging 0.75 per cent a year. ulation lives in cities of 1 to 5 million inhabitants. These regions’ urban residents.
Havana, Cuba RASNA WARAH

Latin America is the most urbanized region in the developing


world, with 77 per cent of its population – 433 million people
– living in cities.2 The urbanization of Latin America has yet to
FIGURE 1.1.1 PROPORTION OF URBAN POPULATION BY REGION, 1950-2030
reach its peak; by 2015, it is predicted that 81 per cent of its
population will reside in urban areas. In terms of sheer numbers, 100

however, Asia has the largest urban population (with more than
■ 2007: The dawn of the urban millennium 1.5 billion people inhabiting its cities) even though slightly less
80
than 40 per cent of its population is urbanized. The total popu-

T
he year 2007 will mark a turning point in lation of cities in the developing regions of the world already
human history: the world’s urban population exceeds that of cities in all of the developed regions (by 1.3 bil- Percentage of urban population 60
will for the first time equal the world’s rural lion people). If predictions prove accurate, by 2030, nearly 4 bil-
population. Although it is difficult to predict on lion people – 80 per cent of the world’s urban dwellers – will live 50

which day or month this radical transformation in cities of the developing world. 40
will occur, what is certain is that this milestone will herald the Asia and Africa will continue to dominate global urban
advent of a new urban millennium: a time when one out of growth through 2030. Currently the least urbanized regions in
every two people on the planet will be a “city-zen”. the world, with 39.9 per cent and 39.7 per cent of their pop- 20
Cities, whether small municipalities of 2,000 inhabitants or ulations living in cities in 2005, respectively, by 2030, both
massive agglomerations of 10 million people or more, are regions will become predominantly urban, Asia with 54.5 per
becoming a widespread phenomenon. The global urban pop- cent of its population living in cities, and Africa with 53.5 per 0

ulation has quadrupled since 1950, and cities of the develop- cent of its population urban. Asia alone will account for more 1950 1955 1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030

ing world now account for over 90 per cent of the world’s than half the world’s urban population (2.66 billion out of a Africa Asia Latin America and the Caribbean Oceania
urban growth. global urban population of 4.94 billion); and the urban pop- North America Europe World
In 2005, the world’s urban population was 3.17 billion out of ulation of Africa (748 million) will by 2030 be larger than the
world total of 6.45 billion. Current trends predict the number total population of Europe at that time (685 million). Source: United Nations, World Urbanization Prospects: The 2003 Revision.

6 7
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Most of the world’s urban population will continue to live tion, and most have grown at the relatively slow rate of about
in small cities over the next decade, but intermediate cities are 1.5 per cent annually. Although new research techniques that
predicted to grow at a faster rate: between 2000 and 2015, combine population statistics with satellite imagery reveal that
cities of fewer than 500,000 will likely increase their popula- these huge urban agglomerations may already be home to 7 per
tions by 23 per cent, while cities of 1 to 5 million are predict- cent of the world’s population, they still represent just a small
ed to increase their populations by 27 per cent. By 2015, Asia minority of cities worldwide.6
will have gained 37 cities of 1 to 5 million people, rising to a The first metacity came into being in the mid-1960s when
total of 253; Africa will have gained 20, totaling 59; and Latin Tokyo’s population crossed the 20 million inhabitant threshold.
America and the Caribbean will have gained 16, rising to a Tokyo continues to be the only metacity in the world today,
total of 65. with a population in excess of 35 million people – more than
the total population of Canada. In less than a decade, however,
Mumbai, Delhi and Mexico City will have joined the league of
■ The emergence of the “metacity” metacities, closely followed by São Paulo, New York, Dhaka,
Jakarta and Lagos, each with more than 17 million inhabitants.
Although “megacities” of more than 10 million inhabitants By 2020, all of these cities are expected to attain metacity sta-
have been around since the 1950s, when New York and Tokyo tus.7 Lagos is experiencing an exceptional growth rate – more
were the largest cities in the world, “metacities”4 – massive than 5 per cent per year through 2005 – and is expected to con-

Street Scene, Morocco NATSUO ITO


conurbations of more than 20 million people – are now gaining tinue growing faster than the other largest cities of the world
ground in Asia, Latin America and Africa. through 2020.
Called “hypercities” by some,5 cities of more than 20 million On average, the largest cities grow more slowly than cities
inhabitants represent a new type of settlement above and of 5 to 10 million people, and they account for only about 9
beyond the scale of megacities. Spurred by economic develop- per cent of the world’s urban population. The impact of the
ment and increased population, they gradually swallow up rural largest cities on their regions, however, is great. Between 1950
areas, cities and towns, becoming multi-nuclear entities count- and 2020, the New York-Newark metropolitan area is expect-
ed as one. The world has never before known so many cities as ed to have increased its population by only 40 per cent,
large as these metacity agglomerations. Many of these cities have whereas Mumbai will have grown by 88 per cent, and Dhaka
populations larger than entire countries; the population of will have grown to more than 50 times its size in 1950. ■ City-regions will require new forms of
Greater Mumbai (which will soon achieve metacity status), for Throughout the past half-century, the largest cities of the More than 53 per cent of the world’s coordinated management for sustainability
instance, is already larger than the total population of Norway developing world have had to absorb astounding increases in urban population lives in cities of
and Sweden combined. their urban populations while many cities in the developed fewer than 500,000 inhabitants By 2020, all but 4 of the world’s largest cities will be in
Contrary to common perception, however, the world’s largest regions have grown considerably less, or, as in the case of developing regions, 12 of them in Asia alone. While still few
cities are home to only 4 per cent of the world’s total popula- London, decreased in population. in number, these metacities point to new forms of urban
planning and management, leading to the growth of city-
regions and “metropolitanization”.
FIGURE 1.1.2 RURAL AND URBAN POPULATION BY REGION IN 2005 AND 2030 FIGURE 1.1.3 POPULATION BY CITY SIZE As cities increase in size, metropolitanization is becoming a
progressively more dominant mode of urbanization, particu-
5,000
larly in megacities and newly emerging metacities.
4,000
Metropolitanization can take various forms: it may involve
Africa is the least urbanized continent but by 3,500 densely settled regions in which villagers or people living in
4,000 2030 its urban population will exceed the total suburbs commute to work in the nearby cities but where many
3,000
of the production and service activities are located in rural
population of Europe. Population (millions)
2,500 areas and suburbs; it may mean that a stagnating and declin-
Population (millions)

3,000 ing population and economic base in the core of a city shifts
2,000
to nearby secondary cities; or it may refer to the development
Rural population 2005 (millions)
1,500 of inter-connected systems of cities that create city-regions
2,000 Urban population 2005 (millions) linked by manufacturing and other activities, such as the
1,000
Rural population 2030 (millions)
Hong Kong/Pearl River Delta region of China.8
500 Metropolitanization calls for new, innovative and more
1,000 Urban population 2030 (millions)
decentralized forms of governance. Already, many large cities
0
2000 2005 2010 2015 are decentralizing governance to the appropriate levels with
0 more municipalities and boroughs managing different parts of
Europe North Africa Asia Latin Oceania 10 million or more 1 to 5 million Fewer than 500,000 the city. This calls for better inter-municipal coordination,
America America and 5 to 10 million 500,000 to 1 million
the Caribbean more intermediate metropolitan levels of governance, more
civil society participation and more autonomy for various
Source: United Nations, World Urbanization Prospects: The 2003 Revision. Source: United Nations, World Urbanization Prospects: The 2003 Revision. parts of this new organism called the metacity.

8 9
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

The scale of environmental impact of metacities and megaci- institutions, but also generating related economic and civil
ties on their hinterlands is also significant and is likely to be a society activity in other cities. These “world cities” provide
cause for concern in coming decades. For instance, in China, economies of scale and access to resources of local and global
rapid economic growth and urbanization, combined with significance. Connectivity, economic production and cultural
inconsistent implementation of industrial emissions standards innovation have long kept London, New York, Paris, and

Simit Seller, Turkey DARCY VARNEY


and increased use of motor vehicles, have had a negative impact Tokyo at the top of the world-city scale, closely followed by
on the urban environment; the country is the largest producer cities such as Frankfurt, Hong Kong, Amsterdam, Singapore,
of greenhouse gases, after the United States, and hosts 16 of the São Paulo and Shanghai, which are emerging as trend-setters
20 most polluted cities in the world. Managing environmental on the global financial scene. Other cities, such as Dubai and
sustainability, economic sustainability and socio-political sus- Rotterdam, are becoming global transport hubs, while
tainability – the three pillars of sustainable urbanization – will Bangalore, Seattle and Silicon Valley have emerged as world
require more polycentric forms of governance, more environ- leaders in the area of information technology.
mentally-friendly legislation and a regional approach to plan- In the new urban millennium, world city status is beginning
ning and management of human settlements. to extend to several key cities in developing regions as well,
based on their new roles in the global economy and their capac- In developing countries, informal
ity for linking resources with populations in need. Cities such employment comprises one-half to
■ Competition between “world cities” will as Istanbul and Mumbai are already establishing the cultural three-quarters of non-agricultural
intensify trends in their countries and regions, and this influence could employment. In many of these
cross international borders through films, literature and satel-
countries, the informal sector provides
Cities are more than simply concentrations of people and lite television networks and entertainment. Large cities in the
resources. As hubs of trade, culture, information and industry, developing world, including Nairobi, Addis Ababa and more employment opportunities than
cities also articulate and mediate major functions of the global Bangkok, among others, are increasingly bringing together the formal sector.
economy. In developed countries, cities generate over 80 per major national and international partners by hosting interna-
cent of national economic output, while in developing coun- tional agencies and development partners, and offering avenues
tries, urban economic activity contributes significantly to for constructive peer exchange, mediation and diplomacy.
national revenue, generating up to 40 per cent of gross domes- At the same time, cities are becoming more competitive with
tic product.9 Wealthy world cities are also increasingly operat- each other. No longer are only the world’s most highly recog-
ing like city-states and city-regions, independent of regional or nized cities jockeying for the honour of hosting major interna- ■ The urban economy in the developing world and Northern Africa, it is 51 and 48 per cent, respectively. If
national mediation.10 tional events and corporate headquarters; growing cities of the will be largely informal informal employment in the agricultural sector is also includ-
Global urban economies are increasingly reliant on advanced developing regions are also competing with each other to ed, the proportion of informal employment in the total labour
producer services for their income: advertising, finance, bank- become important regional, corporate and development cen- In the developing world, there has been a trend toward force is even larger. It is common to attribute the high propor-
ing, insurance, law, management consultancy, and other serv- tres. The primary economic rival of India’s financial capital of “informalization” of the urban economy, with increasing shares tion of informal sector workers in these regions to migration of
ice-based businesses. Mumbai, for example, is Shanghai in neighbouring China, of incomes earned in unregulated employment.11 In many unskilled workers from rural areas to urban areas. However, in
Today, several major cities play pivotal roles in global net- which has similar global aspirations, but has a much smaller developing countries, particularly in Africa and Asia, the formal many regions, informal sector employment is the only option
works, not only producing goods and services and hosting proportion of its population living in poverty. sector has not been able to provide adequate jobs for rapidly available to skilled and educated people who are not absorbed
growing urban populations, leading to the proliferation of the by the formal labour market. In addition to its contribution to
FIGURE 1.1.4 URBAN GROWTH IN THE WORLD’S LARGEST CITIES, 1950-2020
urban informal sector. In Latin America and the Caribbean, 7 employment, the sector also contributes significantly to nation-
out of 10 new jobs in urban areas are created in the informal al economies in terms of income. The sector’s share of gross
40,000 sector.12 Two main processes have significantly contributed to domestic product (GDP) is approximately 41 per cent in sub-
35,000
the rise in urban informal activities. One is the failure of the Saharan Africa, 31 per cent in Asia, 29 per cent in Latin
formal sector to provide adequate jobs and income-generating America and 27 per cent in North Africa.15
30,000 opportunities for a rapidly growing urban population; the Women account for a disproportionately larger share of the
other is the growing tendency of the formal sector to contract informal labour force than men, particularly in sub-Saharan
Population ('thousands)

25,000
services out to secondary labour markets, which are mainly in Africa and Asia. In developing countries as a whole, more than 60
20,000 the informal sector. per cent of women are engaged in informal employment in the
In developing countries, informal employment comprises non-agricultural sector. In sub-Saharan Africa, about 84 per cent
15,000 1950
one-half to three-quarters of non-agricultural employment. In of women are employed in non-agricultural informal activities
2005
10,000 many of these countries, the informal sector provides more compared with 63 per cent of men. In Latin America, 58 per cent
2015
employment opportunities than the formal sector. In sub- of women are engaged in non-agricultural informal sector activi-
5,000 2020 Saharan Africa, for instance, the informal sector accounts for ties compared with 48 per cent of men. Women’s participation in
0 about 78 per cent of all non-agricultural employment.13 In both the informal and formal sectors of the urban economy has
Kenya alone, there are an estimated 5.5 million informal sector had a positive impact on their social mobility and political
w rk-

on

ris

Ci co

Pa Sao

s
ba

lh

go
ky

ak
De
nd

Pa

i
Ne Yo
k

ty

o
um

ex
To

Dh

La
ar

ul
Lo

M
w

workers compared with only about 1.7 million wage-earners in involvement in urban affairs. A study in Dhaka, Bangladesh, for
M
Ne

Source: United Nations, World Urbanization Prospects: The 2003 Revision. formal establishments.14 In Asia, 65 per cent of all the non-agri- instance, found a positive correlation between women’s employ-
Note: Population in 2020 was estimated from population in 2010 and 2015 assuming that trends for these years remain the same. cultural employment is in the informal sector. In Latin America ment in factories and their level of political participation.16

10 11
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

■ Insecurity will be a growing concern in cities of ing with other forms of insecurity that threaten their lives and
the developed world livelihoods. The security of the urban poor, in particular, is One out every three city dwellers – nearly ■ Slums are emerging as a dominant and distinct
affected by their health status, which influences both their abil- one billion people – lives in a slum. type of settlement in cities of the developing
Since the attacks on New York and Washington on 11 ity to work and their ability to escape poverty. The HIV/AIDS world
September 2001, cities of the developed world have become pandemic has particular implications for urban security as it
increasingly concerned about their vulnerability to acts of ter- leads to loss of household income, growth in the phenomenon The highest levels of income inequality exist in Africa and One out every three city dwellers – nearly one billion peo-
rorism. These concerns have been magnified by recent attacks of orphaned street children and disintegration of the family Latin America, the least and most urbanized developing regions, ple – lives in a slum. The vast majority of slums – more than
on cities such as London, Madrid, Bali, New Delhi, Nairobi unit. Many urban poor families also face the constant threat of respectively. This inequality is most stark in urban areas, and par- 90 per cent – are located in cities of the developing world,
and Dar es Salaam. Because of their dense populations and eviction. Insecurity is exacerbated by insecure tenure with ticularly in large cities. Although the proportion of poor people which are also absorbing most of the world’s urban growth.22
intricate infrastructure, cities are deeply affected by attacks, respect to both housing and land. in rural areas is larger than the proportion in urban areas, there Urbanization has become virtually synonymous with slum
which exact heavy physical, psychological and financial costs. It are more poor people living in Latin America’s cities than its rural growth, especially in sub-Saharan Africa, Western Asia and
is estimated that the city of New York lost $110 billion in infra- areas. In 1999, for example, only 77 million of the region’s 211 Southern Asia, where annual slum and urban growth rates
structure, buildings and jobs as a result of the 11 September ■ Divided cities: Cities are, and will continue to million poor lived in rural areas, while the remaining 134 million are almost identical. Annual slum and urban growth rates are
attacks.17 be, sites of extreme inequality lived in urban areas, although the proportion of rural poor was highest in sub-Saharan Africa, 4.53 per cent and 4.58 per
Although terrorism affects both developed and developing much greater than that of the urban poor – at 64 per cent and cent respectively, nearly twice those of Southern Asia, where
countries, the former have in recent years put in place measures In recent years, an increasing number of countries have 34 per cent, respectively. In Africa, the proportion of people liv- slum and urban growth rates are 2.2 per cent and 2.89 per
to respond to the crisis by increasing their budgets for security opened up markets and expanded political freedoms. Others ing in poverty in rural areas is 59 per cent, compared with 43 per cent, respectively. In Western Asia, slums and cities are grow-
and surveillance apparatus and tightening immigration poli- have made impressive gains in economic growth. But democra- cent in cities, a gap that is likely to shrink in an environment of ing at a similar pace, 2.71 per cent and 2.96 per cent respec-
cies. In some cities, such as New York and London, this has cy and economic growth have not helped reduce inequalities in economic decline.20 Sub-Saharan African countries have some of tively. Northern Africa is the only sub-region where slum
meant visible changes in urban form: loss of use of public much of the world; the wealthiest 20 per cent of the world’s the world’s highest levels of urban poverty, extending to more growth rates are declining, largely due to positive measures
space, restriction of movement within the city, weakening of people account for 86 per cent of private consumption, while than 50 per cent of the urban populations in Chad, Niger and taken by individual countries to address the plight of slum
popular participation and increased use of security and surveil- the poorest account for just 1 per cent. In the past six years, 23 Sierra Leone. Countries of Northern Africa and Western Asia dwellers. Eastern Asia, South-Eastern Asia and Latin
lance equipment in strategic locations. Terrorism and insecuri- million more Latin Americans slipped into poverty, and most have urban poverty levels near or below 20 per cent. In Asia, America and the Caribbean are also regions where annual
ty create fear and change perceptions in cities, leading to situa- African countries – with the exception of Botswana and Egypt India has the highest urban poverty levels, at 30 per cent. slum growth rates have not kept pace with annual urban
tions in which “a bag is no longer a bag, but a bomb”. A 2003 – are poorer today than they were in the 1970s. Despite In Latin America and the Caribbean, levels of urban poverty growth rates. Nonetheless, these regions continue to have
report by the City of London Police found that almost one in impressive economic growth rates in both China and India in vary widely, from 8 per cent of the urban population in large numbers of their urban populations residing in slums.
ten Londoners worried about the threat of terrorism on a daily the last decade, these two countries have not been able to join Colombia to 57 per cent in Honduras. In some countries Sub-Saharan Africa has the highest prevalence of slums in
basis. London authorities are said to have increased police the ranks of “high-income” countries, and have been unable to around the world – notably Nigeria, Egypt and Trinidad and the world – 71.8 per cent of its urban population lives in
patrols and installed more surveillance cameras in strategic bridge the income gap between rural and urban populations Tobago – urban and rural poverty percentages are almost slums – and in the last 15 years, the number of slum dwellers
locations, making the city one of the most closely surveilled and between the urban rich and the urban poor.19 equal.21 However, income-based statistics should be viewed with in the region has almost doubled, from 101 million in 1990
spaces in the United Kingdom, and perhaps the world.18 Some These inequalities manifest themselves most starkly in cities. caution as the true extent of urban poverty is likely higher than to 199 million, in 2005. Given the high slum growth rate in
are concerned that the implementation of these measures could In many cities of both the developed and the developing world, they suggest. The high cost of non-food items, such as transport, the sub-region, the number of slum dwellers is projected to
mean that less money will be available for social services, such economic growth has not resulted in prosperity for all. On the health, education, and water in cities – and poor living condi- double by 2020, reaching nearly 400 million, and overtaking
as health and education, which could become a source of fric- contrary, intra-city inequalities have risen as the gap between the tions, including inadequate housing and poor access to water the slum populations of both Southern Asia and Eastern
tion and conflict in the future. rich and the poor has widened. Although poverty remains a pri- and sanitation – impact the ability of the urban poor to rise out Asia, where slum populations are projected to rise to 385
While terrorism dominates the concerns of cities of the marily rural phenomenon, large sections of the population in of poverty. When these items are included to measure poverty, million and 299 million, respectively. In terms of absolute
developed world, most developing country cities are contend- urban areas are suffering from extreme levels of deprivation. poverty estimates for urban areas are likely to rise significantly. numbers, Asia still has the largest share of the world’s slum
Cairo ©ALESSANDRO BOLIS. IMAGE FROM BIGSTOCKPHOTO.COM

12 13
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

PETER HALL
WHY SOME CITIES FLOURISH WHILE OTHERS LANGUISH
Endnotes
Charcoal vendor, Kibera, Nairobi HIROSHI SATO

There is a vital question for cities, but Very well, policymakers may say; what
1 All urban population statistics are drawn from the United Nations
the answer eludes urbanists: at a time are the lessons for the places now
Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division, World
when the knowledge economy is competing to become the 21st century
Urbanization Prospects: The 2003 Revision, unless otherwise noted.
2 Of the more-developed regions, Australia and New Zealand have the
becoming all-pervasive, what makes equivalents? One point is clear: the
highest proportion of their populations living in cities: 91.6 per cent in cities innovative? Why do cities flour- candidates are no longer individual
2005. ish creatively, but then languish? Why cities but the megacity-regions of
3 Satterthwaite & Tacoli 2003. are Athens or Florence no longer lead- Southeast England, the Northeastern
4 Term coined by UN-HABITAT for cities with populations of more than 20 ing creative cities? Why have seaboard of the United States and the
million. Guangzhou and Shanghai taken the Yangtze River Delta in China, clustered
5 Davis, 2004. places of Manchester and Detroit? around global cities such as London,
6 The Center for International Earth Science Information Network 2005. How do a few cities, including London New York and Hong Kong. Here we
7 This prediction is based on a linear trend model, using the population and New York, manage to retain their find the 21st century equivalents of
growth between 2010 and 2015 as the baseline to extend the population edge? 18th century Manchester or 19th cen-
to 2020. tury Berlin. Centres of concentrated
8 UN-HABITAT/DFID 2002. Economists approach this question innovative power, now diffusing into
9 UN-HABITAT 2002c.
through regression equations to try to neighbouring cities and towns through
10 Taylor 2005.
identify the critically important ingre- networks of information exchange:
11 Cohen 2004.
dient in successful cities. But this may London to Reading and Milton Keynes,
12 Inter-American Development Bank 2004.
not provide a robust explanation for all Shanghai to Suzhou.

London MJS
13 International Labour Organization 2002.
14 Bindra 2005.
or most cities over time. There is
15 International Labour Organization 2002. another way, through economic and The key is information. Knowledge is
16 Sachs 2005. social history: carefully dissecting the the new production factor, and the
17 Cohen 2004. sequence and combination of causes that facilitated the emergence of truly vital information is exchanged face-to-face, brain-to-brain,
18 Coaffee 2004. creative cities. The danger with this approach, too, is that it may fail through local networks in quite concentrated downtown areas, such
Sub-Saharan African countries 19 United Nations 2005a. to generate good general explanations. as the City of London or Downtown Manhattan. So the critical ques-
have some of the world’s highest 20 Ibid. tion now concerns the pattern of diffusion and reconcentration, and
21 World Bank 2002 estimates. Yet it need not. In my own work on creative cities, common themes the limits to that process, within these multi-centred city-regions, set
levels of urban poverty.
22 All slum data drawn from UN-HABITAT Global Urban Observatory. emerge. All were leading cities of their age economically; invariably by some critical time limit from the central city.
For a definition of “slum”, see Chapter 1.2. they were the centres of trading empires. They were at the economic
forefront, or near it. Thus, they became magnets for people with abil- Information, the raw material of the knowledge economy, is manipu-
ity, who migrated from far corners of their far-flung empires. It is no lated by workers in the advanced producer services, who generate
population; in 2005, the region housed more than half the accident that key roles were played by outsiders: non-citizen Metics in incomes that trigger a dazzling array of consumer services. Megacity-
world’s slum dwellers, or 581 million people. Periclean Athens, Jews in the Vienna of the early 1900s, artists like regions compete in a winner-takes-all contest. The most successful
Slums in many cities are no longer just marginalized neigh- Pablo Picasso in Paris shortly after. The immigrants considered them- city-regions grow faster, reinforced by advantages in communications,
bourhoods housing a relatively small proportion of the urban selves half inside, half outside the established societies in which they such as a major international airport or train hub. It is also no accident
population; in many cities, they are the dominant type of lived. They became creative lightning rods of a sort, illuminating the that London and New York, the great English-speaking cities, repre-
human settlement, carving their way into the fabric of mod- underlying tensions inside these societies. Occasionally, as in Berlin in sent the twin peaks of this global information economy.
ern-day cities, and making their mark as a distinct category the 1920s, such tensions tore those societies apart. Generally, the
of human settlement that now characterizes so many cities in results were happier. Yet in the coming century, this may change. The 21st century will
the developing world. Although slums do not directly denote clearly be the Asian century. China and India are already racing ahead,
levels of urban poverty, their prevalence in a city can be an Technological innovation shows similar features – but also interesting aiming to regain the leading positions they occupied in past centuries.
indicator of urban inequality. UN-HABITAT projections differences. Manchester in 1780, Detroit in 1910 and Silicon Valley in Their resurgence will come through their great cities – Shanghai,
indicate that the number of slum dwellers in the world will 1960 were upstart cities or city-regions, egalitarian places that wel- Beijing, Mumbai – and their surrounding megacity-regions. This will
rise to 1.4 billion by 2020 if no remedial action is taken. comed new talent, stressing individual self-improvement and mutual be an ongoing East-West economic Olympic Games – but the stadi-
education. Their people engaged in extraordinary chains of innovation, ums, where the prizes will be won, will be urban.
through networks that – paradoxically – were simultaneously compet-
itive and cooperative. There are amazing parallels between Lancashire
during the period between 1760 and 1830 and Silicon Valley since Sir Peter Hall is Professor of Planning at the Bartlett School of
1960: one innovation stimulated another, in long and complex chains. Architecture and Planning, University College London. He is the author
Regions like these became creative because of an extraordinary and editor of over 30 books, including Cities of Tomorrow (1988) and
process of mutual learning and mutual stimulation. Cities in Civilization (1998).

14
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

China’s Rising Cities


tions in the world – Shanghai, Beijing, Tianjin and Hong time equity grants based on the market value of their
Kong – since the mid-1980s, the country has been pursuing existing housing, which enables them to access mortgage
an aggressive urbanization policy as a means of stimulating instruments. Developers, on the other hand, are provided
both rural and urban economic development. The policy incentives in the form of tax reductions or exemptions.
aims to absorb the hundreds of millions of farmers who are
flocking to cities as a result of economic reforms and easing The use of equity grants, combined with incentives for
of previously strictly enforced “urban residency permits”. housing developers to provide affordable housing, led to
The residency control system is likely to be completely the production of more than 20 million housing units in
eradicated in coming years as capital investments are made the last five years. Chinese cities are hoping to avert the
to improve the infrastructure and economy of urban areas. proliferation of urban ghettos and slums by providing
The aim of China’s pro-urban policies is to focus on the more affordable housing. In large housing estate develop-
development of towns and secondary cities to ease conges- ments, many of which attract foreign direct investment, a
tion in the larger cities. new level of self-governance has also emerged, with resi-
dents electing committees to oversee and manage urban
Equity Grants safety and security, environmental conservation and the
needs of youth and the elderly.
Economic growth has also led to growing urban dispari-
ties. Prior to the economic reforms, the system made it dif- Prosperity and Pollution
ficult for villagers to migrate to cities, with the result that
slum formation was controlled, whenever possible. But China’s recent gains in economic growth and industrial-
economic reforms saw a significant increase in migration ization have in many cases exacerbated environmental
of unemployed workers and farmers to cities, with the problems in its cities. Economic growth has increased
result that some inner-city and peri-urban areas have consumer purchasing power, with the result that Chinese
been suffering from a gradual deterioration of living con- cities, such as Beijing – once the bicycle capital of the
ditions. In 2000, for instance, an estimated one-third of the world – are now teeming with motor vehicles, a leading
urban population in the country lacked adequate sanita- cause of air pollution. There are 1.3 million private cars in
tion. While the economic boom experienced by Chinese Beijing alone, an increase of 140 per cent since 1997.
China PHOTOS.COM

cities induced investment in high and middle segments of Experts believe that China’s skyrocketing private car own-
the housing market, it posed problems of affordability and ership and lax implementation of industrial emission reg-
accessibility for families with limited income and savings. ulations could threaten the recent gains it has achieved
on the economic front. China’s manufacturing-based
Until the early 1980s, China’s urban housing market was economy has made it one of the world’s largest con-
Recent economic reforms coupled with modernization Some coastal cities, such as Shanghai, have skewed these
almost entirely the purview of state-owned enterprises sumers: in 2005, the country used 26 per cent of the
policies have improved the living conditions of millions of figures even further. In 2001, China’s largest city with a pop-
that were responsible for investing in and allocating hous- world’s crude steel, 32 per cent of its rice and 47 per cent
people in China. In the last two decades, the world’s most ulation of 12.7 million had a gross domestic product (GDP)
ing within a strict command-and-control economy. High of its cement.
populous country has witnessed annual economic growth of $4,510 per capita, almost five times the national average.
rates of urbanization and economic growth in the last two
rates of more than 9 per cent while the proportion of peo- The opening up of the Chinese economy has made
decades led to major macroeconomic reforms geared According to the World Bank, China is home to 16 of the 20
ple living on less than $1 a day dropped dramatically from Shanghai China’s most modern city and a favourite for for-
towards a “socialist economy based on market principles” most polluted cities on the planet. China is also the second
634 million in 1981 to 212 million in 2001. eign investment: in the 1990s, foreign investment in the city
and to the liberalization of the urban housing market in largest producer of greenhouse gases, after the United
totalled $45.6 billion. The city, which had only one sky-
the late 1990s. States. Environmental degradation robs the nation of up
The impact of economic growth is most evident in urban scraper in 1988, today has more than 300. A mass transit sys-
to 12 per cent of its GDP, and every year some 400,000
areas. China’s cities are not only doing better than its rural tem, first-rate sea and river ports, well-developed railway
To facilitate low-income people’s access to the housing Chinese die prematurely of respiratory illnesses and some
areas but are largely responsible for the country’s economic and road networks and two international airports have
market, Chinese cities have been practising a policy of 30,000 children die from diarrhoea caused by drinking
boom, the effects of which are concentrated in the larger increased the investment potential of the city and made it a
stimulating supply and demand through the use of equity unclean water. Towns and villages along China’s most pol-
cities. In 2001, per capita disposable income for urban resi- leading centre of international commerce and finance.
grants for people living in sub-standard housing. While luted rivers are also reporting more cases of cancer and
dents was $829 compared to $278 for rural residents. In
land remains the property of the state, leases are auc- miscarriages. According to the Yellow River Conservancy
1987, the income of the average urban household was The prosperity of China’s cities is largely a result of econom-
tioned to developers to supply housing on a home owner- Commission, river pollution costs the country $.1.9 million
almost twice that of the average rural household; today it is ic reform policies that have a pro-urban focus. Although
ship basis. Low-income families living in slums or sub- annually. If China is to sustain its remarkable economic
almost three times higher. China already hosts 4 of the 30 largest urban agglomera-
standard housing are thus provided with once-in-a-life- growth, it must also ensure that its cities are sustainable.
Sources: Linch & Zhi 2003; UN-HABITAT 2005a; TIME 2005; United Nations 2005a; Economy 2005; Worldwatch Institute 2006b; WHO/UNICEF 2000.

16 17
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

1.2 Putting Slums on the Map: A Global and Regional Overview

Global trends

I
n the last decade, an increasing number of governments Inequality has a direct bearing on patterns of urbanization.
around the world have enlarged democratic space with- The rich in most countries live a world apart from the poor, with
in their countries and opened up their markets in homes in protected urban enclaves and access to the latest tech-
response to the demands of a globalizing world. But nology, the best services and the most comfort. The rest, especial-
democracy and market economies have not had the ly slum dwellers, live in the most deprived neighbourhoods,
desired effect of reducing inequalities within and among the struggling to gain access to adequate shelter and basic services,
world’s regions. On the contrary, from 1960 to 1999, the such as water and sanitation. Many slum dwellers also live under
incomes of the richest countries grew to exceed those of the the constant threat of eviction. Such stark differences and divi-
poorest by 35 times.1 Economic growth, it turns out, does not sions can be found among regions and countries, but also with-
automatically result in prosperity for all. In many countries, in countries and cities. Especially in the developing world, urban
national gross domestic product (GDP) rates have risen much zones of poverty and despair commonly skirt modern cosmopol-
more quickly than national poverty rates have fallen; the effect itan zones of plenty. If current trends are not reversed, cities will
has been a growing gap between the rich and the poor, a gap become more and more spatially divided, with high- and middle-
that is most evident in cities of the developing world. income residents living in the better-serviced parts of the city,

TABLE 1.2.1 POPULATION OF SLUM AREAS AT MID-YEAR, BY REGION; 1990, 2001, 2005 AND ANNUAL SLUM GROWTH RATE

% Slum % Slum % Slum Slum


slum Population slum Population slum Population annual
(thousand) (thousand) (thousand) growth rate
1990 1990 2001 2001 2005 2005 (%)

Region

WORLD 31.3 714,972 31.2 912,918 31.2 997,767 2.22

Developed regions 6.0 41,750 6.0 45,191 6.0 46,511 0.72


EURASIA (Countries in CIS) 10.3 18,929 10.3 18,714 10.3 18,637 -0.10
European countries in CIS 6.0 9,208 6.0 8,878 6.0 8,761 -0.33
Asian countries in CIS 30.3 9,721 29.4 9,836 29.0 9,879 0.11
Slum overlooking Mumbai, India R. A. ACHARYA/UNEP/STILL PICTURES

Developing regions 46.5 654,294 42.7 849,013 41.4 933,376 2.37


Northern Africa 37.7 21,719 28.2 21,355 25.4 21,224 -0.15
Sub-Saharan Africa 72.3 100,973 71.9 166,208 71.8 199,231 4.53
Latin America and the Caribbean 35.4 110,837 31.9 127,566 30.8 134,257 1.28
Eastern Asia 41.1 150,761 36.4 193,824 34.8 212,368 2.28
Eastern Asia excluding China 25.3 12,831 25.4 15,568 25.4 16,702 1.76
Southern Asia 63.7 198,663 59.0 253,122 57.4 276,432 2.20
South-Eastern Asia 36.8 48,986 28.0 56,781 25.3 59,913 1.34
Western Asia 26.4 22,006 25.7 29,658 25.5 33,057 2.71
Oceania 24.5 350 24.1 499 24.0 568 3.24

Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Global Urban Observatory, Urban Indicators Programme, Phase III.

18 19
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

What is a slum?
At an Expert Group Meeting in A slum household is a group of individuals living Access to sanitation: A household is considered to
November 2002, UN-HABITAT and its under the same roof in an urban area who lack have adequate access to sanitation if an excreta dis-
partners came up with a provisional one or more of the following five conditions: posal system, either in the form of a private toilet or
definition of “slum”: a settlement in Durable housing: A house is considered “durable” if a public toilet shared with a reasonable number of
an urban area in which more than it is built on a non-hazardous location and has a struc- people, is available to household members.
half of the inhabitants live in ture permanent and adequate enough to protect its Secure tenure: Secure tenure is the right of all
inadequate housing and lack basic inhabitants from the extremes of climatic conditions, individuals and groups to effective protection
services. Developing an operational such as rain, heat, cold and humidity. against forced evictions. People have secure tenure
definition – one with measurable Sufficient living area: A house is considered to when there is evidence of documentation that can
indicators – required further provide a sufficient living area for the household be used as proof of secure tenure status or when
refinement, recognizing that slums members if not more than three people share the there is either de facto or perceived protection
can be geographically contiguous or same room. against forced evictions.
isolated units. UN-HABITAT Access to improved water: A household is consid-
Low-income housing in Mexico City, Mexico RON GILING/STILL PICTURES

therefore focuses on the household ered to have access to improved water supply if it * This definition may be amended according to the situa-
as the basic unit of analysis. A has a sufficient amount of water for family use, at an tion in a specific city. For example, in Rio de Janeiro, living
area is insufficient for both the middle classes and the
single operational definition of slums affordable price, available to household members
slum population and is not a good indicator. It could either
is used throughout this Report.* without being subject to extreme effort, especially be omitted, or it could be combined with another indicator
on the part of women and children. to denote two or more shelter deprivations.

The findings presented in the following chapters represent a ■ Slums: The emerging human settlements of the
new approach to measuring and understanding slums, developed 21st century?
by UN-HABITAT in response to the international community’s
recognition in 2000 that slums cannot be considered an unfortu- The word “slum” first appeared in 19th century London,
nate by-product of urbanization, but instead need to be addressed when the burgeoning urban working classes moved into over-
comprehensively as a major development issue. Approaching crowded and poorly serviced tenements, living close to the fac-
slums as a specific type of human settlement with discernable tories and industrial plants that employed them. The term
characteristics and impacts on the people who live in them pro- referred to what was initially designated “a room of low repute”,
vides a framework for moving toward Millennium Development but over time took on the generic definition, “a squalid and
TABLE 1.2.2 URBAN AND SLUM GROWTH RATES BY REGION Goal 7, target 11: by 2020, to have achieved a significant improve- overcrowded urban area inhabited by very poor people”.2
In 2005, there were 998 million slum ment in the lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers Although slums continued to grow over the course of the last
Urban Slum dwellers in the world; if current
growth two centuries, their evolution was particularly swift in the latter
growth
Regions rate rate trends continue, the slum population half of the 20th century as the developing world became more
will reach 1.4 billion by 2020. FIGURE 1.2.1 SLUM POPULATIONS, 1990-2020 urbanized. Today’s slums are much larger and have many more
residents than the slums prevalent in 19th century Europe and
North America. The slum population of Rio de Janeiro, for
5,000,000 example, is almost the same size as the total population of
Urban growth significantly Latin America and 2.21 1.28 Helsinki. Mumbai’s more than 5 million slum dwellers exceed
higher than slum growth the Caribbean and the poor living in spatially or socially segregated slums the total population of Nairobi. Slum dwellers now live prima-
4,000,000
Northern Africa 2.48 -0.15 with few services or none at all. rily in the cities of Africa, Asia and Latin America, although a
Eastern Asia 3.39 2.28 Not all of the world’s urban poor live in slums; poverty in smaller number also live in cities of the developed world.
South-Eastern Asia 3.82 1.34
Population ('000)

cities has various social and economic dimensions that have 3,000,000 Slum housing ranges from crowded tenement buildings in
little to do with the physical structure of the houses or the Hong Kong to mud-and-tin shacks in Cape Town. Slums can
Urban and slum environments in which people live. Conversely, not all be inner-city tenements in cities of the developed world, shan-
2,000,000
growth similar Western Asia 2.96 2.71 those who live in slums are poor – many people who have ty towns on the periphery of large cities or densely packed
Southern Asia 2.89 2.20 risen out of income poverty choose to continue living in neighbourhoods bordering high-income areas. Individual
Sub-Saharan Africa 4.58 4.53 1,000,000
slums for various reasons ranging from lack of affordable households located in high- or middle-income neighbour-
housing in better parts of the city to proximity to family hoods may also fit the definition of slums. In some parts of the
Developed world 0.75 0.72 and social networks. However, if the quality of housing and 0 developing world, gradations of slums are common, with each
the existence of basic services are used as criteria to deter- 1990 2001 2005 2010 2015 2020 variation having a different name. For instance, in India, a
World 2.24 2.22 mine poverty levels, then slums represent a physical dimen- Year
chawl (a densely packed block of one-room “apartments” with
World Developing Developed & Eurasia
sion of poverty. This aspect of urban poverty is the focus of shared toilets and bathrooms) is quite different from a zopad-
Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Global Urban Observatory. this Report. Source: UN-HABITAT, Global Urban Observatory 2005. patti (a shack made of non-durable materials, often located in

20 21
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

a crowded slum settlement within or on the outskirts of a tation of policies aimed at reducing the number of slum million in 1990 to 199 million in 2005. Urban growth in the
city). Yet, both types of housing could fall under UN- dwellers within countries. Countries such as Morocco and region is almost identical to slum growth – a trend that is also
HABITAT’s definition of slum households if they lack one or Tunisia have been very successful in improving the lives of prevalent to a lesser extent in other regions. Given the high
more of the five conditions that are necessary to deem a house slum dwellers, while Egypt, where slums exist on a much larg- slum growth rate in the region, the number of slum dwellers
“adequate” (see box). er scale, was able to address the problem with pro-poor poli- will likely double by 2020, reaching nearly 400 million, and
One out of every three city dwellers – nearly one billion peo- cies and substantial investments in improving the shelter con- overtake the slum populations of both Southern Asia and
ple – lives in a slum today. For many years, governments and ditions of people living in cities. Eastern Asia, which are estimated to rise to 385 million and
local authorities viewed slums as transient settlements that Sub-Saharan Africa, on the other hand, has been unable to 299 million, respectively.
would disappear as cities developed and as the incomes of slum manage or reduce slum growth. This is partly attributed to the In many of the region’s countries, notably Angola, Ethiopia,
dwellers improved. However, evidence shows that slums are declining economies of some countries in the region, coupled Mali, Mauritania, Sudan, and Tanzania, slum populations are
growing and becoming permanent features of urban land- with its disproportionate share of HIV prevalence and con- expected to double within the next 15 years. Slum households
scapes. Slums have carved their way into the fabric of modern- flicts, both of which have exacerbated slum formation and are the norm rather than the exception in many cities. For
day cities, making their mark as a distinct category of human worsened living conditions in cities. Slums in cities such as instance, UN-HABITAT’s Urban Inequities Survey,5 con-
settlement that constitutes a space between “rural” and Khartoum, for instance, have grown remarkably in the last ducted in the capital of Ethiopia, Addis Ababa, has shown
“urban”. Given the proliferation of slums around the world decade, largely due to an influx of internally displaced persons that less than 10 per cent of that city’s inhabitants live in non-
and the growth of city-regions, in which larger cities act as (IDPs) from Southern Sudan, which has been suffering from a slum areas.
centres for smaller cities and towns and a large rural hinter- protracted civil war. When slums constitute the largest proportion of a city, dif-

Kibera, Nairobi HIROSHI SATO


land, the simple duality that exists in the traditional framing Sub-Saharan Africa has the highest proportion of slum ferentials between, even within, slums also become apparent.6
of human settlement patterns no longer suffices to describe the dwellers in the world: 71.8 per cent. In terms of absolute num- As in Ethiopia, several other primarily rural sub-Saharan
reality of people’s lives. Slums in many cities are no longer just bers, it is home to the third most populous slum population African countries in the first stages of their urban transition –
marginalized neighbourhoods housing a relatively small pro- among the regions of the developing world, after Southern including Chad, and the Central African Republic – have very
portion of the urban population: in some cities, particularly in Asia and Eastern Asia. In the last 15 years, the number of slum high proportions of slums in their cities. Not surprisingly, the
Southern Asia and sub-Saharan Africa, slums host significant- dwellers in sub-Saharan Africa has almost doubled, from 101 living conditions in slums within these countries are also
ly large proportions of the urban population and slum growth
is virtually synonymous with urbanization; this calls for new At the global level, 31.2 per cent of all urban dwellers lived
ways of looking at cities and the slums within them. in slums in 2005, a proportion that has not changed signifi- MAP 1 URBAN POPULATION AND SLUM PROPORTION IN AFRICAN COUNTRIES, 2001
Will slums become a predominant type of settlement in the cantly since 1990. However, in the last 15 years, the magni-
21st century? If no preventive or remedial action is taken, they tude of the problem has increased substantially: 283 million
may indeed come to characterize cities in many parts of the more slum dwellers have joined the global urban population.
developing world. In 1990, there were nearly 715 million slum dwellers in the
The vast majority of slums, more than 90 per cent, are locat- world.3 By 2000 – when world leaders set the target of
ed in cities of the developing world, where urbanization has improving the lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers by
become virtually synonymous with slum formation. This is 2020 – the slum population had increased to 912 million. In
especially so in sub-Saharan Africa, Southern Asia and Western 2005, there were almost 1 billion (998 million) slum dwellers
Asia, where urban growth over the last 15 years has been in the world; if current trends continue, UN-HABITAT esti-
accompanied by a commensurate growth in slums. mates that the slum population will reach 1.4 billion by 2020.
Slum and urban growth rates are highest in sub-Saharan
Africa, 4.53 per cent and 4.58 per cent per year, respectively –
nearly twice those of Southern Asia, where slum and urban Trends in developing regions Urban Population
growth rates are 2.2 per cent and 2.89 per cent per year, respec- <= 4 Mio
tively. In Western Asia, annual slum and urban growth rates are ■ Slum trends in Africa >4-10 Mio
quite similar, at 2.71 per cent and 2.96 per cent respectively, >10-30 Mio
while in Eastern Asia and Latin America, slum growth rates are An interesting disparity exists between Northern Africa and >30-75 Mio
significantly lower than urban growth rates, although slum sub-Saharan Africa in terms of slum growth and slum preva- >75-150 Mio
lence: while the former is experiencing negative slum growth, >150 Mio
growth rates are relatively high in both regions: 2.28 per cent
and 1.28 per cent per year, respectively. South-Eastern Asia and the latter is experiencing the opposite trend, with extremely
Percentage of
Northern Africa are two regions where slum growth has not high slum growth rates of 4.53 per cent per year – the highest Urban Slum Population
kept pace with urbanization; in both regions the proportion of in the world.4 <=10%
slum dwellers has actually declined in recent years from over 36 Northern Africa achieved a reduction in both the number
and proportion of slum dwellers between 1990 and 2005. The >10-30%
per cent of the urban population in 1990 to approximately 25
per cent in 2005. Eastern Asia and Latin America and the share of slum dwellers in the region fell from 37.7 per cent to >30-60%
Caribbean also have urban growth rates that are higher than 25.4 per cent, with the absolute number of people living in >60%
slum growth rates. This suggests that countries within these slums decreasing by half a million, to just over 21 million. The
regions have in recent years taken active steps to reduce the reduction may be attributed to the relatively low levels of slum
number of slum dwellers or prevent slum formation. prevalence in the region in general, as well as to the implemen- Source: UN-HABITAT, Global Urban Observatory 2005.

22 23
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

extremely severe, as 70 per cent to 90 per cent of households Ninety per cent – or 195.7 million people – of Eastern impact on both the magnitude and the proportion of slums.
are deprived of more than two basic shelter needs, such as Asia’s slum dwellers live in China. Chinese slum dwellers The main reasons behind Thailand’s ability to reduce slum
water or sufficient living space. This trend applies to much of account for 20 per cent of the world’s total. It is important to growth are a strong political commitment by its leadership,
sub-Saharan Africa, where slum households are likely to lack note that since 1990, China has been held up as a success in accompanied by a tradition of strategic planning and monitor- Most of the slum dwellers in Southern
water, sanitation, durable housing, sufficient living space, and increasing the scale of low-cost housing schemes, thus prevent- ing development efforts, which have been an integral part of Asia – 63 per cent, or almost 170 million
secure tenure altogether, or a combination of at least three of ing slums before they even form.8 Despite such measures, the the development tradition for the last 30 years. Many of the people – reside in India.
these indicators of adequate housing. country suffers from high levels of slum prevalence. There sub-region’s countries also have an active civil society.
could be two reasons for this, other than the fact that the total Although the high slum growth rates in Cambodia and Lao
population of China constitutes one fifth of the world’s popu- People’s Democratic Republic suggest a less optimistic future,
■ Slum trends in Asia lation. One is the need for a lapse in time for slum prevention there is evidence that they might be able to curb slum growth,
policies to have an impact on the ground. The other could be as they have recently initiated slum prevention policies.
In absolute numbers, Asia has the largest share of the world’s the mismatch between UN-HABITAT and national defini- Western Asia, on the other hand, lags far behind the other an increase in its slum population. Both countries have relative-
slum population – in 2005, the region was home to more than tions of what constitutes a slum. While UN-HABITAT con- sub-regions in terms of slum prevention. Slum and urban ly small populations, so the reduction or increase in slums there
half the world’s total slum population, or about 581 million siders the de facto status of dwellings in the cities of China, growth rates in the sub-region are almost the same, reaching might not make a dent in the overall slum figures by 2020, but
people. Some sub-regions within Asia are faring worse than irrespective of their legal status, national authorities do not nearly 3 per cent per year. The countries of Western Asia have progress is still important, as it would indicate greater stability
others. Eastern and Southern Asia harbour 80 per cent of the consider people who live outside the de jure residential area or made little progress on any of the Millennium Development in the sub-region, accompanied by better social indicators.
slum dwellers in the region, with Southern Asia hosting near- those who do not possess residency permits as bona fide resi- Goal indicators and have not been able to sustain the momen- Slum growth in the largest country of the sub-region, Turkey,
ly half the region’s slum population. These figures are largely dents of a city.9 tum of development they gained between 1980 and 1990, as declined radically between 1990 and 2001, from 23.3 per cent
attributable to China and India, which are the most populous It is interesting to note that real success stories in the region, the region has in recent years been engulfed in political turmoil to 17.9 per cent, primarily because of an effective policy of
countries in the world and have significant proportions of in terms of decreasing slum growth significantly, have occurred that has exacerbated the refugee crisis and worsened conditions decentralization, which empowered the municipal govern-
their urban populations living in slum conditions. Although in South-Eastern Asia, in countries such as Thailand, where in cities. In countries such as Jordan, slums have grown at the ments to borrow directly from international financial institu-
China hosts the world’s largest slum population – almost 196 policies implemented even before the 1990s have had a strong rate of 4.3 per cent per year, and Lebanon has also experienced tions to build or upgrade water and sanitation networks.
million people – its slum prevalence in 2001 was lower than
that of India; UN-HABITAT estimates that 38 per cent of
China’s urban residents lived in slum conditions that year,
MAP 2 URBAN POPULATION AND SLUM PROPORTION IN ASIAN COUNTRIES, 2001
compared with India’s 56 per cent.
Most of the slum dwellers in Southern Asia – 63 per cent,
or almost 170 million people – reside in India. The share of
Southern Asia’s slum dwellers constitutes 27 per cent of the
global total; India alone accounts for 17 per cent of the world’s
slum dwellers. India has pioneered many best practices and
good policies in recent years that are having some impact on
the lives of slum dwellers, but they have not reached a suffi- Mumbai RASNA WARAH
cient scale to ameliorate the proliferation of slums. Although
the country has seen remarkable economic growth rates in
recent years and has managed to reduce extreme poverty by 10
per cent in the last decade, the impact of poverty reduction is
still not being felt in cities. Unless more radical policies are
pursued in India, the global target for improving the lives of
slum dwellers will not be reached.
Other countries that need to address this challenge urgently are
Bangladesh and Pakistan which, along with India, have among
the highest urban poverty rates and the largest urban populations
in the sub-region. UN-HABITAT data shows that Bangladesh
was home to 30 million slum dwellers in 2001, and 85 per cent
of its urban population lived in poverty that year; 74 per cent of
Pakistan’s urban population lived in poverty in 2001 – more than Urban Population Percentage of
Urban Slum Population
35 million people. Through successful initiatives such as the <= 4 Mio
<=10%
Orangi project,7 Pakistan has demonstrated how the lives of slum >4-10 Mio
dwellers can be improved at the local level. Three decades on, >10-30 Mio >10-30%
however, the project has not been able to scale up its interventions >30-75 Mio >30-60%
to have a national impact. Bangladesh’s development campaigns >75-150 Mio
>150-472 Mio >60%
through the Bangladesh Rural Advancement Corporation and its
Grameen Bank initiative have focused on alleviating rural pover-
ty, so have had negligible impact in urban areas. Source: UN-HABITAT, Global Urban Observatory 2005.

24 25
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Mumbai’s Quest for ‘World City’ Status


Mumbai, the capital city of the state of Maharashtra and their names were on the electoral roll on 1 January 1995
India’s most important financial capital, has a population of were protected, to the extent that their homes could not be
18.3 million people, making it the fourth largest urban demolished without rehabilitation.)
agglomeration in the world, after Tokyo, Mexico City and New
York-Newark. The city hosts one of the world’s largest slum Amid public outcry and pressure from the ruling Congress
populations: more than 5 million of the city’s residents are party, the demolitions were halted in February 2005, but
slum dwellers. More people live in Mumbai’s slums than in the many believe that the plan to make Mumbai a world-class
entire country of Norway. city is still very much on the cards. “The reality of course is
that a new Mumbai cannot be built on the corpses of its
Despite its large slum population – or, as some would argue, poor, the very people who hold up this city,” argued journal-
because of it – Mumbai has emerged as one of India’s leading ist Kalpana Sharma of The Hindu newspaper.
commercial and cultural centres, home to the country’s huge-
ly successful film industry and a booming stock exchange.The Jockin Arputham, founder of India’s National Slum Dwellers
city alone pays almost 40 per cent of the nation’s taxes. Federation, has consistently argued that it is Mumbai’s poor,
who allow the city to flourish by providing cheap labour and
There is a perception among many of the country’s policy- services. “The poor work as refuse collectors, construction
makers, however, that Mumbai’s progress is being hampered labourers, handcart pullers, vegetable vendors, factory work-
by its image as a city of slum dwellers, which severely erodes ers, domestic workers and so on.They provide goods and serv-
its ambitions to become the “Shanghai of India” with clean ices at rates that most of the city’s people can afford. But when
streets, gleaming skyscrapers and a modern and efficient it comes to their housing, the city turns its back on them.”
transport and communications network. This perception was
Dire slum conditions

Slum children, Mumbai MARK EDWARDS/STILL PICTURES


reinforced in late 2004 when the Indian government
embarked on a campaign to make Mumbai a “world-class
city” in response to a call by the Indian Prime Minister in Despite the active role played by non-governmental organiza-
October 2004 to transform Mumbai into an international hub tions (NGOs) and slum federations in the city, the situation of
for trade and commerce. The call was supported by slum dwellers in Mumbai remains dire. A recent survey for the
Maharashtra’s chief minister, who submitted an ambitious Mumbai Sewerage Disposal Project found that 42 per cent of
four-year, $8 billion proposal for modernizing Mumbai, which slum dwellings in the city had an area of less than 10 square
included the building of new roads, a subway system and a metres and only 9 per cent had an area of more than 20 square
large-scale public housing project. The modernization pro- metres. Almost half of the households in slums got their water
posal followed an earlier Slum Rehabilitation Scheme in the from shared standpipes and only 5 per cent had direct access
mid-1990s that aimed to improve the lives of 4 million slum to water through individual taps.The city’s sanitation situation
dwellers through public-private partnerships that involved was even more alarming: 73 per cent of the city’s slum house-
builders in the private sector and the authorities. holds – housing 3.86 million residents – depended exclusively
on public toilets. Moreover, overuse and poor maintenance and future generations of slum dwellers and migrants. People are still starving to death in other parts of India. In
Demolition drive had made public toilets a health hazard, especially in areas (Currently, only 58,000 new low-cost housing units are avail- Bombay, there are several hundred slimming clinics.”
where the user group was undefined.Less than one per cent of able for pre-1995 slum dwellers.) The report provides the (Bombay was officially renamed Mumbai in 1996, but like
In late 2004, despite progressive slum improvement and the slum population had access to individual toilets or to pay- framework for the city’s urban renewal scheme,which,if imple- many diehard Bombayites, Mehta prefers to call it by its
tenure regularization policies and programmes, the govern- per-use toilets constructed by private agencies or NGOs. mented, will cost upwards of $40 billion over the next decade. old name.)
ment of Maharashtra began a slum demolition drive aimed City authorities are already looking into how the funds can
at removing slums and shanty towns in the city. Between be raised from federal and local governments and from Others are cynical about Mumbai’s attempts to reach
Despite the daunting conditions in its slums,Mumbai is a mag-
December 2004 and March 2005, more than 90,000 shanties international lending institutions. world-class status. “One hardly needs to emphasize that
net for Indians, not only from neighbouring cities and villages,
were torn down, in violation of poll promises, international the world over, cities with good and affordable public
but also from the rest of the country. According to “Vision
covenants to which India is a signatory and a 2001 Slum Author Suketu Mehta feels that Mumbai cannot escape transport are also the most liveable … . The best cities in
Mumbai”, a 2003 report by the private consultancy firm
Areas Act, which protected all slums built prior to 1995. (The the demands of globalization, including the pressures to the world are also the ones that have affordable housing
McKinsey & Co, the city urgently needs to build at least 1.1 mil-
Act stipulates that all slum dwellers who could establish that become “world class”. In many ways, he writes, the city has for all classes,” writes Sharma, who is the author of a book
lion affordable housing units in the next decade for current
already parted with the rest of India as the gap between on Dharavi, Mumbai’s largest slum. “We need to put aside
the haves and the have-nots widens: “In the Bayview Bar of our obsession with becoming ‘world class’. Let us make our
Sources: Moreau and Mazumdar 2005; Risbud, 2003; YUVA and Montgomery Watson Consultants 2001; Sharma 2005a and 2005b; Burra 2005; Arputham 2001; the Oberoi Hotel you can order a bottle of Dom Pérignon cities liveable for all the people. That itself is a big agenda
Mehta 2004; Kothari 2005; United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division 2004. for one and a half times the average annual income … . for the future.”

26 27
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Slums: The shelter dimension of urban poverty Defining and Monitoring Slums: Seeing Beyond the Stereotypes
Current debates over the multidimensional aspects poverty. These include: human assets (such as skills poverty, with some experts claiming that it has been Until recently, empirical evidence regarding liv- Shelter deprivation indicators Using the first four slum definition indicators,
of poverty recognize that income-based poverty and good health), natural assets (such as land), grossly underestimated. For instance, official fig- ing conditions in the world’s slums was not it has been possible to estimate the preva-
measurements do not capture the scale or range of physical assets (such as access to roads and other ures show that only 9.7 per cent (or 14.6 per cent, available in a universally comparable format. Slum dwellers often live in difficult social and lence and magnitude of slums and to calcu-
poor living conditions experienced by people around infrastructure), financial assets (such as access to depending on the survey used) of Phnom Penh’s Slums were the “invisible” parts of cities – nei- economic conditions that manifest different late projections in most countries of the world
the world. The link between income and levels of savings and credit) and social assets (such as net- population lived below the poverty line in 1999, yet ther reflected in official data or maps, nor recog- forms of deprivation – physical, social, eco- using existing household surveys and census-
deprivation is weak and misleading, as many who works of family and other contacts that can be 2001 data shows that an estimated 40 per cent of nized by authorities. Speculative analysis sug- nomic and political. Four out of five of the es, including Demographic and Health Surveys
live above the poverty line may suffer from serious called upon in times of need). Capturing the depth the Cambodian capital’s population lived in informal gested that people living in slums were experi- slum definition indicators measure physical and UNICEF Multiple Indicator Cluster
deprivations in other areas, while those below the and magnitude of urban poverty is particularly settlements, or slums. Similar gaps between official encing a continuous deterioration of their living expressions of slum conditions: lack of water, Surveys, conducted between 1990 and 2001.
poverty line may suffer from income poverty, but important when monitoring the achievement of figures for urban poverty levels and slum estimates environments, yet figures were often inaccurate lack of sanitation, overcrowding, and non- These indicators are considered “shelter dep-
may not be “poor” in other aspects. Millennium Development Goal 7, target 11. in other cities suggest that poverty in cities is still or contradictory within and among countries. durable housing structures. These indicators rivation indicators” by UN-HABITAT and its
being viewed through the income lens that does not Sometimes, figures overestimated or underesti- focus attention on the circumstances that sur- partners.
These debates are highly applicable to measure- Urban poverty and slums take into account the living conditions of city mated the reality of the situation, based on sub- round slum life, depicting deficiencies and
ments of urban poverty. UN-HABITAT and others dwellers and their needs for goods and services jective concepts about the nature of slums or the casting poverty as an attribute of the environ- The physical and visible manifestations of
have consistently argued that understanding the In this Report, UN-HABITAT attempts to analyse a that are specific to urban areas. While not all peo- motivation of researchers or political entities ments in which slum dwellers live. housing that lacks basic services, space and
various dimensions and degrees of urban poverty is particular dimension of urban poverty that has not ple who live in slums necessarily live below the involved in estimation. The production of data security take many forms, resulting in diverse
important in order to construct pro-poor policies been adequately captured in either national statis- poverty line, the huge discrepancy between these was thus not the result of a reliable monitoring The fifth indicator – security of tenure – has to types of slums. Not all are as easily distin-
that have a tangible impact on the living conditions tics or in United Nations data – that of shelter depri- two figures suggests that the poverty line used in process. do with legality, which is not as easy to meas- guishable or visible as the shanty towns
of the urban poor. UN-HABITAT is convinced that vation. This shelter dimension of urban poverty is cities is not realistic. ure or monitor, as the status of slum dwellers cramped together on the periphery of cities
neither the food basket nor the one-dollar-a-day measured using five key indicators: access to water; Global monitoring has also faced a political often depends on de facto or de jure rights – such as Mumbai, Nairobi or Cape Town. In
indicator can accurately reflect the diverse experi- access to sanitation; durability of housing; sufficient Until a universal knowledge base is developed to obstacle over the term “slum”, which has often or lack of them. This indicator has special rele- some places, slums are less visible to the eye:
ences of people living in poverty in both rural and living area; and secure tenure. produce information on other forms of urban pover- been deemed derogatory by urban planners, city vance for measuring the denial and violation dwellings may look durable or permanent
urban areas. ty, the thrust of UN-HABITAT’s discussion remains authorities and slum dwellers themselves. The of housing rights, as well as the progressive from the outside, but living conditions inside
In cities, poverty is quite often physically and spa- focused on the knowledge and data it has gathered preferred terms, including “informal settlement”, fulfillment of these rights. There currently the dwelling may portray another picture. For
The problem with current measurements of urban tially visible in slums, which suffer from poor quality, and generated on shelter deprivations, which tend “squatter settlement” and “unplanned neigh- exists no mechanism to monitor secure tenure instance, many multi-storey public housing
poverty, and consequent policy discussions, is the insecure, hazardous and overcrowded housing and to be concentrated in slums. This is being done bourhood”, have been used interchangeably with as part of Millennium Development Goal 7, projects at the periphery of urban cores or old,
division of urban populations into the “poor” and the lack infrastructure and basic services. While shelter bearing in mind that “slum dwellers” neither repre- “slum”, but have not heretofore been linked to target 11, as household-level data on property dilapidated buildings in inner cities could
“non-poor” with little recognition of the diversity deprivations are most apparent in slums, they do sent all individuals who live in poverty in cities, nor specific indicators regularly reported on by gov- entitlement, evictions, ownership, and other qualify as slums if they have been neglected
within the “poor” and the “almost poor” with regard not necessarily denote levels of urban poverty and are all slum dwellers, as a heterogeneous group, ernments and stakeholder organizations. The dif- indicators of secure tenure is not uniformly or ill-serviced for significant periods of time,
to their deprivations, vulnerabilities and needs. This are only a subset of a wider range of urban poverty “living below the poverty line”. Nonetheless, slums ficulty in developing a workable measurement available through mainstream systems of data as would many workers’ hostels or dormito-
measurement also fails to recognize that people experiences. However, the huge gap between offi- are a good starting point – but not the ultimate or strategy and the lack of reporting on slums illus- collection, such as censuses and household ries. Such places typically do not look like
have a variety of assets, which may or may not cial urban poverty figures and the proportion of peo- definitive point – for describing urban poverty and trates that they are conceptually complex and surveys. In this Report, UN-HABITAT points to slums, but if their residents experience some
translate into income or cash, but which nonethe- ple living in slums does raise questions about the capturing the scale and depth of shelter depriva- methodologically elusive. trends that suggest levels and severity of inse- form of shelter deprivation or insecure tenure,
less play an important role in determining levels of validity of the methodologies used to measure urban tions in cities. cure tenure around the world, but these fig- then, according to the UN-HABITAT definition
Different cultures and countries define the physi- ures are based on secondary sources that may of a slum household, these residents qualify
Sources: World Bank 2000/2001; Jonsson & Satterthwaite 2000, Asian Coalition for Housing Rights 2001. cal and social attributes of slums differently. UN- or may not reflect the reality on the ground. as slum dwellers.
HABITAT acknowledges this diversity and the
fact that slums take many different forms and
names. Bearing this in mind, in 2002, UN-HABI-
Various dimensions of urban poverty TAT, the United Nations Statistical Division and Shelter deprivations Visible and non-visible types of slums
the joint UN-HABITAT/World Bank Cities and security of tenure
Inadequate and often unstable Inadequate, unstable or risky which can be easily accessed when Voicelessness and powerlessness
Alliance gathered together a group of experts to Slum stereotypes Atypical slum households
income, which impacts people’s asset base (non-material and basic necessities are no longer within non-responsive political
define slums and propose a way to measure
ability to pay for non-food items, material) including lack of assets affordable, such as public housing systems and bureaucratic Shanty towns Dilapidated Multi-family Multi-story Multi-story
them. The resulting definition and methodology at urban houses flats in public dormitories
such as transport, housing and that can help low-income groups and free medical services. structures, leading to little or no
represent a compromise between theoretical and periphery within cities buildings housing
school fees. cope with fluctuating prices or possibility of receiving entitlements to
methodological considerations. The agreed-upon (single units, (single units, within city projects
incomes, such as lack of access to Inadequate protection of rights goods and services; of organizing,
definition is simple, operational and pragmatic: one story) one story) centers
Poor quality, hazardous, land or credit facilities. through the operation of the law, making demands and getting a fair
it can be easily understood and adapted by gov-
overcrowded, and often insecure including regulations and response; and of receiving support for Lack of access to water x x
ernments and other partners; it offers clear,
housing Inadequate public procedures regarding civil and developing initiatives. Also, no means
measurable indicators, provided as a proxy to Lack of access to sanitation x x x x
infrastructure, such as schools political rights, occupational health of ensuring accountability from aid
capture some of the essential attributes of
Inadequate provision of basic and hospitals. and safety, pollution control, agencies, NGOs, public agencies and Non-durable housing x x x
slums; and it uses household-level data that is
services (piped water, sanitation, environmental health, protection private utilities, and of being able to
collected on a regular basis by governments, Insufficient living space x x x x
drainage, roads, footpaths, etc.) which Limited or no safety nets to from violence and forced evictions participate in the definition and
development agencies and non-governmental
increases the health burden and often ensure basic consumption can be and, protection from discrimination implementation of urban poverty Insecure tenure x x x
organizations, which is accessible and available
the work burden. maintained when incomes fall and and exploitation. programmes.
in most parts of the world.

Adapted from Satterthwaite 2004.

28 29
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Woman-headed households in cities Age pyramids for slum and non-slum populations in Brazil and South Africa
Although “the proportion of woman-headed In Latin America, most women heading house-
households” is not among the indicators used to holds live in cities. With the exception of Haiti, a 80+
75-79
80+
75-79 males as more men migrate to cities than
monitor progress on Millennium Development majority of these households are located in non- 70-74 70-74
65-69
60-64
65-69
60-64 women, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa. Yet,
Goal 3 on promoting gender equality and empow- slum areas of cities. The overall share of urban
55-59
50-54
Male Female 55-59
50-54
Male Female
45-49 45-49 when the pyramids of these two countries are
ering women, there is a general belief that households headed by women in Haiti is quite
40-44
35-39
40-44
35-39
30-34 30-34 compared with the age group of the slum popu-
woman-headed households deserve special atten- 25-29 25-29
high (50 per cent), compared with 38 per cent in 20-24
15-19
20-24
15-19 lation, the findings are noteworthy: instead of
tion as they fall under the category of the poorest 10-14
5-9
10-14
5-9
rural areas. 0-4 0-4
shrinking, similar age brackets (20 to 54) start to
households. This belief usually translates into 10 8 6 4 2 0 2 4 6 8 10 10 8 6 4 2 0 2 4 6 8 10

misconceptions about women living in slums, as SLUM SLUM


grow, which probably reflects immigration from
it is assumed that low incomes and single moth- In Asia, an overview of selected countries reveals rural areas. This is particularly clear in the age
erhood go together. two findings: firstly, with the exception of Yemen, pyramid for South Africa. The age distribution of
women heading households tend to settle in urban Brazil and South Africa for the urban slum and
80+ 80+

However, UN-HABITAT data and analyses have areas as opposed to rural areas; and secondly, 75-79
70-74
65-69
75-79
70-74
65-69
non-slum population shows a significant demo-
60-64 60-64
shown that no clear pattern emerges on the mari- with the exception of Indonesia, the proportion of 55-59 Male Female 55-59 Male Female graphic shift: the age bracket from 0 to 14 years

Woman and child in Luanda, Angola EDUARDO LÓPEZ MORENO


50-54 50-54
45-49 45-49
tal status of women living in slums or about their women heading households in urban areas is larg- 40-44
35-39
40-44
35-39
for slum dwellers is as much as 20 per cent larg-
30-34 30-34
household responsibilities. The situation varies er in non-slum areas than in slum areas. Among 25-29
20-24
25-29
20-24
er than the same age distribution of the non-
15-19 15-19
from country to country. In some African coun- countries of the Commonwealth of Independent 10-14
5-9
10-14
5-9 slum population. Brazil exhibits a disproportion-
0-4 0-4
tries, such as Kenya, Malawi and Rwanda, States (CIS), such as Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan, 10 8 6 4 2 0 2 4 6 8 10 10 8 6 4 2 0 2 4 6 8 10 ately large prevalence of females under the age
woman-headed households are mostly found in NON-SLUM NON-SLUM of 19 years. This youth bulge is increasingly seen
the proportion of women heading households in
rural areas, whereas in Burkina Faso, Chad, as a major development challenge, since in the
cities is exceptionally high, 50 per cent.
Central African Republic, Egypt and Tanzania, the coming 5 years this group will enter young adult-
majority of woman-headed households are found hood and will be demanding housing and other
in slums, as opposed to non-slum and rural areas. What these statistics indicate is that the preva- 80+
75-79
80+
75-79

lence of woman-headed households, whether in


70-74
65-69
70-74
65-69 basic services as they marry, have children and
In a significant number of countries, including 60-64
Male Female
60-64
Male Female
55-59
50-54
55-59
50-54 form new households.
Cameroon, Côte d’Ivoire, Ethiopia, Ghana and rural, slum or non-slum areas is quite high. With 45-49
40-44
45-49
40-44
35-39 35-39
Morocco, the majority of woman-headed house- the exception of Africa, the share of such house- 30-34
25-29
30-34
25-29
20-24 20-24 When data is disaggregated between urban slum
holds are found within non-slum areas of cities. holds is also much greater in cities. 15-19
10-14
15-19
10-14
5-9
0-4
5-9
0-4 and urban non-slum, interpreting age pyramids
10 8 6 4 2 0 2 4 6 8 10 10 8 6 4 2 0 2 4 6 8 10 at simple glance becomes more complicated.
RURAL RURAL While comparing the above graphs of the urban
FIGURE 1.2.2 PROPORTION OF WOMAN-HEADED HOUSEHOLDS IN SELECTED COUNTRIES
slum and non-slum population, the most striking
BRAZIL SOUTH AFRICA finding is that the age pyramid of the slum popu-
60 lation has a clear expansive pattern, similar to a
conventional pyramid of a developing country. On
the other hand, the pyramid of the urban non-
50 The average slum dweller is younger and dies sooner than the slum population, while still maintaining a gener-
average non-slum dweller ally expansive pattern, tends to be relatively
40 constricted. This shows a trend toward reduction
Percentage (%)

in the younger age categories, which is typical of


Non-Slum UN-HABITAT urban indicators provide an 14), relative to the population as a whole is more developed countries.
30
All Slum overview of the distribution of the 0-4, 5-14 and higher. This is typical of an expansive pyramid
15-24 age groups in some of the countries that that has a wider base indicating that a large pro- Intra-city inequalities are clearly reflected in the
All Rural
20 are part of the organization’s global sample of portion of the population is young, which is also age-sex distribution of the slum and non-slum
cities. This distribution goes beyond the tradition- an indicator of high fertility rates. The rural pyra- populations in Brazil and South Africa. The two
al dichotomy of urban-rural, and presents a new mids of the two countries show that the propor- age pyramids serve to identify two clear trends:
10 breakdown into four categories: urban, rural, tion of people of the most productive age group an expansive broad base in the slum population
urban slum and urban non-slum. (20 to 54) shrinks. This may be attributed to structure, indicating a high proportion of chil-
0
rural-to-urban migration because of the greater dren, a rapid rate of population growth, and a
The above graphs of two middle-income coun- existence of employment opportunities in cities, low proportion of older people; and stable
co

so

da

ia

il

ti

ia

an

y
ga

az

ne

ke
an

bi

gu
an

Ha

d
Fa
oc

an

st
ne

In
Br

tries – Brazil and South Africa – show very con- which attract people in this age bracket. In coun-
r

growth in the non-slum population structure that


pi
Gh

ra
nz

kh

Tu
lo
or

Rw
a

ilip
Se

ca
in

Ta

Co

za
M

rk

Ni

Ph
Ka

ventional age pyramids for their respective urban tries with lower incomes, the proportion of rural
Bu

suggests a reduction of fertility rates and higher


and rural populations. The number of children (0- people in this age bracket shrinks further among life expectancy, respectively.
Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Urban Indicators Programme, Phase III.
Note: Computed from Demographic and Health Surveys (DHS) data (1996-2004).
Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Urban Indicators Programme, Phase III.

30 31
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

La Paz MARK EDWARDS/STILL PICTURES


Throughout Asia, slums are primarily the consequence of
only one shelter deprivation, reflecting fewer problems with
infrastructure and housing policy than in sub-Saharan Africa.
Therefore, governments or regional entities could tackle the
slum problem with simple sectoral interventions to improve
the living conditions of slum dwellers and their access to
secure tenure. For instance, in many sub-regions, one of the
main shelter deprivations identified is lack of access to ade-
quate sanitation; by addressing this shelter deprivation, coun-
tries can drastically reduce the number of slum dwellings.
Asia’s rapid economic growth over the last decade has not
made a significant impact on the elimination or reduction of
Latin America and the Caribbean
the urban inequalities on several fronts, and there are indica- has almost completed its urban
tions that disadvantaged groups remain disadvantaged, even transition; urbanization rates are
when economies improve.10 In fact, despite the region’s newly stabilizing and slum growth rates
industrializing countries, particularly China and India, which are slowing down.
rank among the world’s fastest-growing economies, gross
domestic product (GDP) rates have risen much more quickly
than national poverty rates have fallen, prompting the presi-
dent of the Asian Development Bank to refer to the scale of
deprivation in the region’s cities as “daunting”.11 It is interest-
ing to note that despite the sheer size of the problem, slum
dwellers in Asia have not received as much attention as they dwellers within urban areas, while in absolute numbers, the
warrant, although a recent Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation increase was minor in both countries. Slum growth rates are
summit did emphasize the need to address urban poverty as a very low in both Brazil and Mexico, at 0.34 per cent and 0.49
priority issue.12 per cent per year, respectively. By 2020, the combined slum
population of Brazil and Mexico will have increased by only
MAP 3 URBAN POPULATION AND SLUM PROPORTION IN COUNTRIES OF LATIN AMERICA AND THE CARIBBEAN, 2001
4 million, totalling 71 million, if declining growth continues.
■ Slum trends in Latin America and the Argentina, however, is experiencing faster rates of slum
Caribbean growth, at 2.21 per cent per year.
Low slum prevalence does not apply to all countries in the
Latin America and the Caribbean has almost completed its region. In both Haiti and Nicaragua, more than 80 per cent
urban transition; urbanization rates are stabilizing and slum of the urban population lives in slums; in Bolivia, Guatemala
growth rates in the region are slowing down. The region’s and Peru, slums host two-thirds of the urban population.
share of slum dwellers is 134 million people, less than the Bolivia, Guatemala, Nicaragua and Peru are all experiencing
total number of slum dwellers in just one country in Southern high urban and slum growth rates, and slums with more than
Asia – India. In the 1960s and 1970s, Latin America’s expe- one shelter deprivation are prevalent.
rience with slum growth and slum prevalence was comparable In the Caribbean country of Haiti, urban poverty levels and Urban Population
to that of the current situation in sub-Saharan Africa. This slum prevalence go hand-in-hand. The slum growth rate in <= 4 Mio
trend was reversed in the late 1980s and early 1990s, when Haiti, 3.63 per cent per year, approximates slum growth pat- >4-10 Mio
the process of “re-democratization” resulted in the adoption terns in sub-Saharan Africa. Only one in four households has >10-30 Mio
of progressive policies aimed at promoting more inclusive a proper kitchen, and only 23 per cent of households have >30-75 Mio
governance and reducing inequalities. Notwithstanding these access to improved water supply. Access to improved sanita- >75-150 Mio
positive developments, there is no room for complacency on tion is low, with only 16 per cent of all households, rich and >150 Mio
the part of policymakers. Extreme urban inequalities persist poor, having toilet facilities within the home. A substantial
throughout the region, and a considerably large share of slum proportion of households in the capital Port-au-Prince, 20 Percentage of
dwellers live on the edge of destitution. Although it is too per cent, have only a pit latrine in the immediate vicinity. A Urban Slum Population
early to associate crime and violence levels with the number large proportion of the city’s garbage – 65 per cent – goes <=5%
of shelter deprivations in slum communities, many uncollected. Many of the city’s families are at risk of being left
>5-10%
researchers are beginning to make a link between inequality behind in an emergency, as 40 per cent of the dwellings do
and violence in the region’s larger cities.13 not have a road leading to them and are not accessible by fire >10-40%
Argentina, Brazil and Mexico – the region’s three largest trucks or ambulances.14 However, the region as a whole >40%
countries – will be influential in reducing the proportion of stands out as one that has in recent years aggressively pursued
slum dwellers in the region by 2020. Brazil and Mexico have and implemented inclusive urban governance and slum
already achieved a remarkable reduction in the share of slum upgrading policies aimed at the most vulnerable populations. Source: UN-HABITAT, Global Urban Observatory 2005.

32 33
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

■ Degrees of shelter deprivation: have limited access to water and sanitation is that municipal The most common deprivation experienced
A regional analysis authorities often refuse to extend essential services to their by urban households in sub-Saharan Africa
unplanned neighbourhoods. But the burden does not stop
is lack of access to improved sanitation;
Not all slums are homogeneous and not all slum dwellers suf- there. When lack of sanitation is coupled with lack of water, or
fer from the same degree of deprivation. The degree of depriva- temporary or overcrowded housing, the disease and labour bur- 45 per cent of the urban population suffers
tion depends on how many of the five conditions that define den, especially on women and children, is even more intense. from this deprivation, while 27 per cent
slums (poor access to improved water, poor access to sanitation, This means that slum dwellers living under such hardship con- suffers from overcrowding.
non-durable housing, insufficient living area and insecure ditions have to cope with survival issues for a considerable part
tenure) are prevalent within a slum household. UN-HABITAT of each day. Many slum dwellers also lack secure tenure, which
analyses show that sub-Saharan Africa’s slums are the most makes their housing even more precarious. Slum formation and
deprived; over 80 per cent of the region’s slum households have growth is a complex problem to which African governments
one or two shelter deprivations, but almost half suffer from at must commit multiple sectoral interventions and investments Faso, Chad and Mali. In general, if a neighbourhood reflects very few slum households in Southern Asia suffer from three or
least two shelter deprivations. Approximately one-fifth of slum to lift their citizens out of poverty. slum characteristics, so do most of the individual households more shelter deprivations, despite the huge magnitude of slums
households live in extremely poor conditions, lacking more Slum households with the most shelter deprivations are high- within that neighbourhood. This rule of thumb, however, does within the sub-region, lack of sanitation and overcrowding are
than three basic shelter needs. ly visible in most African cities, as many are clustered within not apply to all countries within the region. In Cameroon, the most common deprivations experienced by urban popula-
Generally, the lack of sanitation and water in the region’s geographically contiguous high-density neighbourhoods, either Ghana, Guinea, Namibia, and Zimbabwe, most slum house- tions in the region. These figures may not reflect the reality on
slums is compounded by insufficient living space for families within or on the outskirts of cities. The concentration of slum holds are individual dwellings in different neighbourhoods; the ground, however, as UN-HABITAT and official data
and inadequate, makeshift housing. One major reason families households is highest in Ethiopia, followed closely by Burkina some also exist within serviced, middle- and high-income areas. sources do not capture the shelter deprivations experienced by
While sub-Saharan Africa’s cities suffer from the most pavement dwellers or street families, who are not normally cat-
severe shelter deprivations, cities in Northern Africa have egorized as “households” in censuses and surveys in countries
managed to reduce the severity of slum conditions markedly; such as India.
a vast majority of slum households – 89 per cent – suffer from Western Asian cities are similar to, albeit somewhat worse off
only one shelter deprivation. Simple, low-cost interventions than, Northern African cities. Among slums, nearly one in four
in increasing access to improved sanitation for instance, are all lack more than two indicators of adequate shelter. The problem
that are needed to help the countries in Northern Africa cre- in Western Asia is compounded by a volatile political situation,
ate “cities without slums” – a goal they have been trying to which has contributed to an influx of refugees and internally
reach since long before the Millennium Declaration was displaced persons (IDPs) to cities. In contrast, the majority of
adopted in 2000. slum households in South-Eastern Asia – 74 per cent – suffer
Urban households in Southern Asia suffer from similar levels from only one shelter deprivation.
of deprivation as those in sub-Saharan Africa. Nearly one in In Latin American cities, neither the magnitude of slums nor
five households lack two basic shelter needs. Among slum the degree of severity is as daunting as in other regions.
households, one in three families has to cope with the lack of However, the proportion of slum households that suffer from
two essential services. Nonetheless, unlike sub-Saharan Africa, at least one shelter deprivation is quite high: 66 per cent.

TABLE 1.2.3 & FIGURE 1.2.3 PROPORTION OF SLUM HOUSEHOLDS IN DEVELOPING REGIONS BY NUMBER OF SHELTER DEPRIVATIONS, 2001

Deprivations 100

Region One Two Three Four


80
Percentage

Percentage (%)
60
Northern Africa 89 11 0 0
Sub-Saharan Africa 49 33 15 3 40

Latin America and the Caribbean 66 25 8 1


Favelas in Rio De Janeiro JOHN MAIER

Eastern Asia - - - - 20

Southern Asia 66 29 5 0
0
South-Eastern Asia 74 20 5 1

Su rica n

& La frica n

be ica

So As rn

As rn

As rn
Af her

A ara

he

te
ut ia

ia

ia
rri er

st
an

es
rt

ut
Ca Am

Ea
Western Asia 77 16 6 1

Sa
No

W
So

h-
b-

th tin
e
four deprivations three deprivations

Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Urban Indicators Programme, Phase III. two deprivations one deprivation

34 35
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6
M POPULATIO
D SLU N IN
WORL 202
3: 07
IO 00
AR m

EN

illi
SC

on
■ The prospect of reaching
the slum target
Forecasts reveal that the magnitude of slums will
continue to increase if the trends dominant
between 1990 and 2001 are projected into the
future. In light of recent evidence, even if govern-
ments collectively manage to improve the lives of
100 million slum dwellers by 2020 – as per the 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020
Millennium Development Goals and targets –
this achievement will be insignificant in relation
to creating “cities without slums”,15 a stated
objective of the Millennium Declaration.
Assuming that the leaders who developed the slum
target were aiming to address a major development
issue, policymakers should adjust the benchmark to
reflect the reality of slums of today and tomorrow.
In view of the existing slum situation around the
world, UN-HABITAT constructed three scenarios to 19
aid planners and policymakers who have a stake in 90 ON
improving the lives of slum dwellers. The worst-case sce-
:W
OR I LLI
nario (Scenario 1) assumes that the rate of slum growth
LD S
L U M P O P U L A TI O N 7 15 M
between 1990 and 2001 will remain the same in all five-year
periods between 2000 and 2020 – that is, slums will contin-
ue to grow. The second scenario (Scenario 2) assumes that FIGURE 1.2.4 MAGNITUDE OF SLUMS IN 2020 UNDER
there will be 100 million fewer slum dwellers in 2020 than THREE SCENARIOS
in 1990, which means the target will be met, but in an envi-
ronment in which the annual growth rate of slums exceeds Scenario 1
the rate at which they are being improved. The best-case sce- This assumes present trends of urban and slum growth continue
nario (Scenario 3) assumes that the proportion of slum unabated into the future.
SC
dwellers in 1990 will be reduced by half, in alignment with ENA ON
Scenario 2 RIO ILLI
most of the other Millennium Development Goals and targets.
2: W O .3 B
The result of the projection for Scenario 1 suggests that by Improve the lives of 100 million slum dwellers by 2020 i.e.
RLD SLU 2 020 1
2020, there will be nearly 1.4 billion slum dwellers in the
achieve MIllennium Development Goal 7, target 11. M P O P UL A TIO N IN
world, if present trends of urban and slum growth continue Scenario 3
unabated into the future, and if governments do not upgrade Reduce proportion of slum dwellers from 31 per cent of the global FIGURE 1.2.5
slums or provide positive alternatives to new slum formation. urban population in 1990 to 15 per cent in 2020. This would THE RISE AND RISE OF SLUMS, 1990-2020
Under Scenario 2, if the lives of 100 million slum dwellers are reduce by half the proportion of people living in slums.
improved, 1.3 billion people around the world will continue
400,000
to live in slum conditions. Scenario 2 reveals that slum
growth rates over the next 15 years will be highest in sub- In view of the general lack of international and national 350,000 Northern Africa
Saharan Africa. While the international community would commitment to achieving target 11 in most countries, the Sub-Saharan Africa
have achieved the very modest target set out in the best-case scenario seems quite elusive. If current trends con- 300,000 Eastern Asia
Millennium Development Goals, it would have made no sig- tinue, it is highly likely that in 2020 the slum population will 250,000
Eastern Asia excluding China
Population ('000)

nificant impact on reducing the proportion of people living be 1.4 billion. This has serious implications in terms of poli- Southern Asia
Latin America and the Caribbean
in slum conditions. Scenario 3 is based on the assumption cies for improving lives of slum dwellers, as well as the situ- 200,000
South-Eastern Asia
that in the next 15 years, international and national stake- ation of slum dwellers vis-à-vis the poverty, health, educa- Western Asia
150,000
holders will have adopted and implemented policies to pre- tion, and employment targets stated in the other Millennium Oceania
vent slum formation and reduce by half the number of slum Development Goals. The growth of slums in the world’s 100,000
dwellers. If these policies were effective, the share of slum cities, which will host the majority of the world’s population
50,000
dwellers would decline from 31 per cent of the urban popu- after 2007, should therefore be a cause for concern, as they
lation in 1990 to 15 per cent in 2020. This would amount to may eventually jeopardize the achievement of all the 0
improvement in the lives of at least 700 million people. Millennium Development Goals and targets. 1990 2001 2005 2010 2015 2020

Source: UN-HABITAT, Global Urban Observatory 2005.

36 37
SCOTT LECKIE
THE SLUM TARGET IS NOT IN LINE WITH HOUSING RIGHTS
Endnotes

1 Milanovik 2005.
Children of pavement dwellers, Mumbai RASNA WARAH

2 Definition used in Concise Oxford English Dictionary. Tenth Edition, 2002.


3 UN-HABITAT slum estimations revised in 2005, based on coordination
of definitions with the WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for
Water Supply and Sanitation.
4 Only data for the developing world, collected with household surveys
and censuses, are reported here, as UN-HABITAT’s estimates for the
developed world are based on secondary sources, including reports,
printed censuses and modeling.
5 UN-HABITAT 2004b.
6 Ibid.
7 The Orangi Project, which started as a pilot project within a township
in Karachi in 1965, has been touted as one of the most successful
demonstration projects in the world and has since been replicated in
seven cities in Pakistan.
8 Dialogue at Second World Urban Forum, Barcelona, September 2004.
Reviewing the Millennium Development Goals through a human rights the world, but by focusing on and forcefully discouraging these prac- 9 In China, people’s status as residents is determined by their ability to
prism, one is forced to ponder whether these Goals were designed to tices, the Goals would have improved the lives of many more millions acquire residency permits for a particular city, town or village. An inde-
supplant, integrate or ignore human rights concerns of the world’s poor. of slum dwellers than will possibly see improvements based on Goal 7, pendent study conducted by the Fafo Institute for Applied International
All fair-minded people, of course, would hope for the second of this tril- target 11.
Studies in Beijing in 2000 attests to the fact that the population that
ogy of options. Unfortunately, looking closely at the Goals, particularly
Third, the Goals – as with so many of the agreements emerging from comes either from other cities or villages or from the rural areas of
Goal 7, target 11 on improving the lives of slum dwellers, it appears the
Goals’ flaws, as far as housing rights are concerned, far out-number the various global summits during the past decade, whether by deci- Beijing is not considered part of the total city population. Since they
their benefits. sion or by default – all too often end up taking the wind from the sails are not regarded as dwellers of the city, they are not considered slum
of the human rights movement, slowing human rights progress and dwellers of the city either. However, the study indicates that those
Three shortcomings stand out as particularly worrying. First, the objec- shifting burdens of proof from national governments to the internation- who belong to settlements outside Beijing’s urban areas constituted
tive of improving the lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers by 2020 al community, which can never alone transform the human rights 16 per cent of the de facto population of Beijing at the time. Most of
is almost obscene in its conscious exclusion of a huge majority of the dreams of the poor into reality. the slum characteristics that UN-HABITAT uses as criteria are preva-
world’s urban and rural poor. In a world of almost one billion slum
The Millennium Development Goals are formulated as if to tease those lent among this group of people. The share of people originating from
dwellers, to speak of improving the lives of less than 10 per cent of the
who – in precisely the same manner as international human rights law outside villages could be even higher, as many migrant workers do not
world’s poorest citizens and rights-holders underscores just how far the
Goals stray from the language, sentiments and vision of human rights. – treat issues of poverty not only as development questions, but as live within established housing, as they do not have permits to live in
Which 100 million slum dwellers are we actually talking about? Who rights. By labeling what are, in fact, core human rights principles mere- cities - many live on construction sites. Quite a substantial proportion
will choose those whose lives will be improved? What say will they ly as “goals”, these internationally-agreed targets are effectively sup- of these inhabitants suffer from overcrowding; they often live in dor-
have in the matter? Which 900 million or more slum dwellers and porting a creed which sees only half of the human rights equation as mitories, jerry-built houses or workers’ huts, shared apartment units or
homeless citizens will fall through the cracks? Who will inform them of actual human rights, somehow relegating the other half to “goals”, simple apartment units with shared facilities.
their plight of having been so deliberately barred from the Millennium “aspirations” or “needs” – not enforceable rights held and rightfully 10 Forum on the Global South 2003.
Development Goals? And what of the additional 400 million slum expected by all, especially those currently without the protection these 11 Asian Development Bank President Haruhiko Kuroda quoted in
dwellers that UN-HABITAT projects will be in need of improved hous- rights are meant to provide.
Newsweek, 21 November 2005.
ing by 2030? Does the world truly accept that perhaps some 1.3 billion
As far as housing rights are concerned, it would be difficult not to con- 12 The Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit held in Busan in
people will call slums home some fifteen years from now, and that this
clude that the Millennium Development Goals let governments off the November 2005.
is somehow an acceptable future for the planet’s urban poor?
hook; they almost insinuate that a staggeringly large portion of human- 13 For instance, the 2005 United Nations report entitled The Inequality
Second, the Millennium Development Goals fail to address some of the ity is condemned by circumstance to live in life- and health-threatening Predicament shows a strong correlation between inequality in Latin
most pressing housing rights concerns affecting the world’s slum conditions, without security, as if to say, “Yes, we care, but as far as American cities and levels of homicide.
dwellers, as if these, too, were somehow not part of the poverty trap slums dwellers go, we know and accept that our care will only reach a 14 Fafo Institute for Applied International Studies 2003.
facing growing numbers of people. The global forced evictions epidem- few of you.” Good luck to the 900 or so million slum dwellers that the 15 UN Millennium Declaration 2000, paragraph 19.
ic, decimated budgets and reductions in public expenditure on housing Millennium Development Goals forgot about. They will need it. In the
for the poor, spiraling house, land and property prices reaching bubble- coming years, these neglected millions will, as always, gain ground,
like proportions in many countries, illegal land grabs, entrenched dis- organize, and support themselves. Whatever rights slum dwellers
crimination against women, the disabled and the elderly, ethnic cleans- accrue, or security they can claim, will come from their own energies
ing, the demolition of homes during war and so many other core hous- and sadly, not from a global accord agreed to by governments.
ing rights themes are all remarkably absent from the Goals. Not only
would addressing these poverty-expanding processes have been logi- Scott Leckie is the Executive Director of the Centre on Housing Rights
cal given their impact on hundreds of millions of dwellers throughout and Evictions (COHRE).

39
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

1.3 How Well is Your Country Performing on the Slum Target?


rates over the last 14 years. Yet, these countries still have large
numbers of people lacking adequate housing and basic services –
Millennium Development 52 million in Brazil, 22 million in Indonesia, 15 million in
Goal 7, target 11: Mexico and 8 million in South Africa. These countries are on the
A Global Scorecard By 2020, to have achieved a
significant improvement in the lives
right path but clearly have some way to go in order to make the
kind of reductions registered by the “on track” countries.
of at least 100 million slum dwellers
Warning signals light up in “at risk” and “off track” countries
■ A snapshot of country performance The worrying trend is that most developing countries have
failed to make much headway in reducing slum growth rates. Of

D
eveloping countries have pursued a range of particular concern are those countries that experienced substan-
countries using statistical data and internationally-agreed defini-

Laying new water pipes in Mathare Valley, Nairobi FRIEDRICH STARK/STILL PICTURES
policies and practices to deal with the deficien- tial slum growth rates (ranging between 4 per cent and 6 per cent
tions and methods.
cies in the provision of basic services, housing, annually) and high incidence of slums in the last 15 years. This
But things are changing. The movement that is now challeng-
health, and education for the urban poor and combination has had lethal effects. For instance, the slum popu-
ing countries and the international community to live up to the
slum dwellers over the course of the last thirty lation in Tanzania has more than doubled in the last 15 years,
promise of the Millennium Development Goals is helping to trig-
years. The international community, including United Nations from 5.6 million in 1990 to 14 million in 2005. Likewise in
ger a new way of measuring the performance of countries in
agencies, multilateral funding agencies and bilateral donors, Bangladesh, Nigeria and Sudan, the numbers of slum dwellers
improving slums and meeting the other Goals and targets in
have, through successive strategies, arguably played a pivotal grew from 19 million, 24 million and 5.7 million in 1990 to 36
urban areas. International agencies are indeed seizing the oppor-
role in transforming government attitudes and policy respons- million, 46 million and 12 million in 2005, respectively. This “off
tunity to produce more and better statistics with which to mon-
es to slums. The policy options and interventions by both the track” group needs to take drastic action now to improve existing
itor the Goals.2 UN-HABITAT has devised, through extensive
international community and governments have changed over slum conditions and prevent future slum formation; otherwise
consultation with its partners, a new methodology for measuring
time: neighbourhood-level self-help solutions to housing and the numbers of slum residents will continue to rocket upwards.
slums and has subsequently produced estimates for the numbers
in situ upgrading during the late 1970s and 1980s; getting the Other countries, including Argentina, China, India and Morocco
of slum dwellers at global, regional, national and city levels.3 The
“enabling environment” right and improving urban manage- are doing slightly better than this group in terms of managing
results have been used in this part of the Report to construct a
ment in the 1990s; and scaling-up of slum upgrading through slum growth rates at roughly 2 per cent a year, but they are still
global scorecard showing the varying performance of over 100
national and citywide programmes since the end of 1990s. in the “at risk” category of countries, as the proportion of people
countries in improving the lives of slum dwellers and reducing
During this period, such remedies have brought hope to living in slum conditions is relatively high (over 30 per cent) and
slum growth rates.
many of the world’s urban poor. Initiatives such as the they still need to revisit existing policies and improve perform-
Kampong Improvement Programme in Indonesia, the Favela ance. Over 70 per cent of the countries analysed fell under these
Bairro programme in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, and the Million ■ Results at a glance two bottom-end performance categories.
Houses Programme in Sri Lanka have significantly improved
the lives of the urban poor. For example, the programme in Countries “on track” – those starting to make urban
Indonesia managed to reach 15 million people over its 30- poverty history ■ Track record of regions
year history working with some 300 local governments in the Among all developing countries, Thailand has seen the sharpest
provision of water, sanitation, shelter and roads.1 decline in slum growth rates. In 1990, there were almost 2 mil- Moving from a country to a regional portrait, the scorecard
And yet for much of the rest of the developing world, pol- lion people living in slum conditions; by 2005, this figure had shows countries in sub-Saharan Africa struggled above all to cope
icy reforms or interventions have not been enough or simply been slashed to just 119,000. This dramatic decrease is attributed with the rising numbers of slum dwellers – 34 out of the 50
failed to materialize. Despite their good intentions, some gov- largely to the government’s long-standing commitment to imple- countries in the “off track” group are in this part of the world,
ernments and donors have struggled to cope with overwhelm- menting programmes to improve the housing conditions of the including, Kenya, Lesotho and Mali. These countries not only
ing demographic pressures, massive backlogs in basic services urban poor. Egypt, Georgia, Sri Lanka and Tunisia are also experienced some of the highest slum growth rates, but also tend-
and housing provision, and growing environmental degrada- among the “on track” countries registering falling slum growth ed to have a large proportion of their total urban population liv-
tion and unemployment, while other governments continue rates since 1990, and are seeing significant reductions in the ing in slums. South Africa is the only country in the region that
to ignore the issue of slums in official policy circles. When number of people living in slums. Egypt succeeded in reducing made it into the higher “stabilizing” category, recording an
remedies fail to reach people they are meant to serve, it is the the number of slum dwellers by 3 million from 1990 to 2005. almost negligible annual slum growth rate.
poor who fall back on their own capacity and resilience to Tunisia has succeeded in more than halving the number of slum Southern Asia, as a whole, also demonstrated a poor track
make a home and living for themselves in the city. dwellers in the same period to approximately 190,000. However, record. In particular, Bangladesh, Nepal and Pakistan continued
However, it is still not very clear where actions to upgrade these countries are among a meagre 14 countries out of the over to lag behind, while India performed somewhat better in manag-
slums or prevent their formation have collectively made the 100 analysed that made it to the “on track” category. ing overall slum prevalence, with a slum growth rate of 1.7 per
biggest difference in improving lives of the urban poor or cent. As a notable exception, Sri Lanka, following decades of
where they have failed to address the problem of slums. While Countries in the “stabilizing” category – those starting to put social investment, ranks among the top performers not only in
for the past three decades, researchers and practitioners have the brake on slum growth rates, but need to monitor and the region but also worldwide; with an annual decline of 3.7 per
produced mostly anecdotal or qualitative evidence to evaluate make sure they don’t slip back cent, the total number of slum dwellers stands at half a million,
progress and failure of countries and cities in slum improve- Brazil, Indonesia, Iran, Mexico, South Africa and Turkey appear down from nearly 900,000 in 1990.
ment, what has been missing is a much more systematic, rig- to have made fairly good progress in basic service provision to the Eastern Asia demonstrates even more mixed results, but averages
orous attempt to compare performance among and within urban poor, which is reflected in low to almost stable slum growth a better overall performance than Southern Asia. While Thailand

40 41
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

■ Scorecard Methodology ON TRACK STABILIZING AT RISK OFF TRACK


Slum Slum Slum Slum Slum Slum Slum Slum Slum Slum Slum Slum
The chart presents the first findings of the global scorecard on slums. Annual % % Pop. Pop. Annual % % Pop. Pop. Annual % % Pop. Pop. Annual % % Pop. Pop.
growth slum slum 1990 2005 growth slum slum 1990 2005 growth slum slum 1990 2005 growth slum slum 1990 2005
Countries are judged to be doing well if they have managed to reduce or reverse rate 1990 2005 (000s) (000s) rate 1990 2005 (000s) (000s) rate 1990 2005 (000s) (000s) rate 1990 2005 (000s) (000s)
slum growth rates and if, at the same time, they have succeeded in keeping the
proportion of slum dwellers at relatively low levels.
The cut off points for the annual slum growth rates were: 0%, > 0-2%, > 2-

UPPER MIDDLE INCOME*


4%, > 4%. These growth rate categories were combined with the proportion of Puerto Rico 1.6 2.0 2.0 50 63 Brazil 0.3 45.0 34.0 49,806 52,374 Argentina 2.2 30.5 34.1 8,597 11,978 Gabon 5.9 56.1 70.4 357 872
slums in the discussed regions. As the incidence of slums is very different in Uruguay -10.3 6.9 1.3 191 41 Mexico 0.5 23.1 18.5 13,923 14,983 Botswana 3.7 59.2 61.3 311 540 Oman 5.4 60.5 60.5 671 1,506
Trinidad and Tobago 0.5 34.7 31.0 292 317 Costa Rica 4.3 11.9 13.1 195 372 Venezuela 2.5 40.7 40.7 6,664 9,642
these regions, different categories for the slum proportions were chosen to char- Lebanon 3.1 50.0 50.0 1,142 1,811
acterise these different conditions. For Africa and Asia, where the incidence of Panama 2.2 30.8 30.8 397 552
slums is generally higher than in the other regions, the cut-off points were the Saudi Arabia 3.8 19.8 19.8 2,385 4,196
same (30%, >30-60%, >60%). For Latin America and the Caribbean, the cut
off points were 10, >10-40, 40% and for the Commonwealth of Independent
States the categories are 20, >20-50, >50.
As a result of this procedure the countries could be grouped within the four Cuba 0.7 2.0 2.0 156 174 Colombia 1.1 26.0 20.5 6,239 7,381 Algeria 3.0 11.8 11.8 1,508 2,370 Bolivia 2.3 70.0 58.4 2,555 3,597

LOWER MIDDLE INCOME*


Egypt -1.6 57.5 34.9 14,087 11,015 Dominican Republic -0.9 56.4 32.4 2,327 2,038 China 2.3 43.6 35.9 137,929 195,682 Guatemala 2.5 65.8 60.4 2,192 3,186
performance categories. Covering over 100 countries in the developing world, Sri Lanka -3.7 24.8 10.9 899 515 El Salvador 1.9 44.7 32.3 1,126 1,495 Ecuador 2.5 28.1 24.8 1,588 2,317 Peru 3.4 60.4 71.1 8,979 14,862
the scorecard measures trends in country performance between 1990 and 2005. Thailand -18.8 19.5 0.9 1,998 119 Iran, Islamic Rep. of 1.6 51.9 41.6 17,094 21,763 Honduras 2.4 24.0 16.3 488 703
Countries are grouped into the following four performance categories: Tunisia -5.4 9.0 2.7 425 188 Paraguay 0.5 36.8 21.7 756 812 Iraq 2.5 56.7 56.7 6,825 9,992
Philippines 1.9 54.9 40.7 16,346 21,792 Jamaica 3.5 29.2 38.4 356 604
ON TRACK South Africa 0.2 46.2 29.4 8,207 8,439 Jordan 4.3 16.5 15.4 388 741
Turkey 0.0 23.3 16.3 7,997 8,016 Morocco 2.0 37.4 31.1 4,457 6,054
Countries experiencing rapid, sustained decline in slum growth rates in Kazakhstan -0.6 29.7 29.7 2,835 2,605 Namibia 2.9 42.3 36.4 155 239
urban areas and/or those with low slum prevalence. Syrian Arab Republic 3.2 10.4 10.4 629 1,012

STABILIZING Georgia -7.2 18.4 6.4 558 189 Indonesia 1.4 32.2 20.5 17,964 22,049 Bhutan 1.2 70.0 37.3 61 73 Afghanistan 6.4 98.5 98.5 2,458 6,375
Countries starting to stabilize or reverse slum growth rates but which need Myanmar 1.3 31.1 24.9 3,105 3,794 Congo 3.6 51.9 48.7 5,366 9,227 Angola 5.3 83.1 83.1 2,193 4,839
Republic of Moldova -1.3 31.0 31.0 634 522 India 1.7 60.8 53.6 131,174 169,671 Bangladesh 4.3 87.3 83.8 18,988 36,079
LOW INCOME*

to monitor progress to ensure sustained reductions. Mongolia 0.7 68.5 63.6 866 969 Benin 5.3 80.3 84.8 1,288 2,870
Viet Nam 1.2 60.5 43.4 8,100 9,632 Burkina Faso 4.0 80.9 74.9 987 1,791
AT RISK
Burundi 2.7 83.3 59.8 294 438
Countries experiencing moderate to high slum growth rates but also having Cambodia 6.1 71.7 72.4 870 2,162
moderate incidence of slums that require remedial policies to reverse growth Cameroon 5.0 62.1 68.9 2,906 6,197
Central African Rep. 3.1 94.0 91.8 1,038 1,646
in numbers of slum dwellers. Chad 4.3 99.3 99.1 1,218 2,308
Congo, Dem Rep. of the 5.2 84.5 92.2 1,050 2,276
OFF TRACK
*WORLD BANK INCOME GROUP Côte d’Ivoire 6.0 50.5 75.6 2,532 6,203
Countries with already high slum proportions, facing rapid, sustained slum Eritrea 3.6 69.9 69.9 342 590
growth rates and which require immediate, urgent action to slow down or FIGURE 1.3.1 A GLOBAL SCORECARD ON SLUMS 2006 Ethiopia 4.8 99.0 99.5 5,984 12,315
Gambia 5.4 67.0 67.0 155 348
reverse slum trends. Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Urban Indicators Programme, Phase III. Ghana 1.8 80.4 66.0 4,083 5,372
Guinea 3.4 79.6 69.8 1,145 1,918
Guinea-Bissau 5.2 93.4 93.5 210 456
Haiti 3.6 84.9 86.0 1,728 2,976
MAPS 4, 5, 6 A LOOK AT COUNTRY PERFORMANCE IN DEVELOPING REGIONS, 2006 Kenya 5.9 70.4 70.9 3,985 9,620
Lao People's
Dem Republic 4.7 66.1 66.1 422 850
Lesotho 6.3 49.8 59.8 168 434
Liberia 2.0 70.2 51.2 632 853
Madagascar 5.3 90.9 93.7 2,562 5,696
Malawi 3.9 94.6 89.9 1,033 1,860
Mali 4.9 94.1 92.9 1,968 4,083
Mauritania 5.6 94.3 94.3 827 1,915
Mozambique 6.9 94.5 93.9 2,722 7,710
Nepal 4.8 96.9 90.9 1,574 3,213
Nicaragua 3.4 80.7 81.0 1,638 2,730
ON TRACK Niger 5.9 96.0 96.3 1,191 2,882
Nigeria 5.0 80.0 71.9 24,096 46,272
STABILIZING Pakistan 2.7 78.7 71.8 26,416 39,722
AT RISK Rwanda 3.5 82.2 90.1 296 504
Senegal 4.1 77.6 76.0 2,276 4,181
OFF TRACK Sierra Leone 3.6 90.9 97.6 1,107 1,895
Somalia 3.6 96.3 97.4 1,670 2,867
NO OR NOT RELIABLE DATA Sudan 5.2 86.4 85.5 5,708 12,441
Togo 4.3 80.9 80.5 796 1,510
Tanzania, U. Rep. of 6.2 99.1 89.6 5,601 14,113
Uganda 5.3 93.8 92.7 1,806 4,010
Yemen 5.0 67.5 64.2 1,787 3,803
Zambia 2.9 72.0 74.8 2,284 3,519
Source: UN-HABITAT, Global Urban Observatory 2006.

42 43
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

growth rates. A detailed explanation as to why some countries – that of scaling up improvements that will reach the large

Businesswoman in Tunisia VINCENT KITIO


succeed in reducing slum growth and preventing slum forma- numbers of people who are living in slums today, as well as pre-
tion, while others struggle to deal with growing poverty and venting future slums. This experience is something that other
inequality in their cities is provided in Part Four of this Report. struggling nations and cities could adapt, but they may not find
The analysis draws on recent data compiled and generated by it easy in conditions where economic development, good local
UN-HABITAT to compare country performance and national governance and political leadership are weak.
policy reforms in slum upgrading and prevention.4
Based on the scorecard and policy analyses carried out by
UN-HABITAT, we now have a better understanding of what ■ Using the scorecard:
drives a country’s performance in improving the living con- Measuring, managing and motivating change
ditions of slum dwellers. We know that political commit-
ment and long-term government policies are essential ingre- The scorecard presented in this Report is only the first step
Egypt and Tunisia are the “high-flyers” in dients. The experience of some of the best-performing coun- towards a better understanding of which countries are on track
Northern Africa with a good track record of tries shows that there is nothing like the commitment of top to meet target 11 and why they appear to be more successful
investments in water and sanitation, as well political leadership to give clarity of purpose, direction and than others. It does not pretend to provide definitive answers to
as informal settlements upgrading. a sense of urgency in tackling head-on the growth of slums – many of the questions indicated above. There is still a long way
it has often proven to be the surest way of committing to go to further develop the scorecard approach, especially in
actions and resources to the problem. In Morocco, when the terms of refining the outcome performance measures for slum
King declared slum upgrading as one of his top four priori- growth, producing more complete information about policies
ties, more than 40 per cent of the budget of the national for countries, and setting up a more rigorous way of rating and
development plan went to upgrading. Brazil’s urban pro- comparing policy performance.
poor policies were given a boost when the President set up a The scorecard should be seen as more than just a measuring
housing fund of $1.6 billion for house building and favela yardstick for measuring progress; rather, governments, civil
upgrading. And in Tunisia, scaled-up upgrading has been a
appears to be very much in a league of its own, Indonesia and The best-performing developing region appears to be core business of the government for three decades and is
the Philippines have succeeded in keeping slum growth rates Latin America and the Caribbean. The majority of countries consistently included in its successive five-year national
low. China, despite impressive policy interventions, recorded a mainly fall under the “at risk” and “stabilizing” groups. The development plans.
relatively large slum population. Preliminary UN-HABITAT top performers, according to the scorecard, are Cuba and “On-track” countries have also effectively hit the most crit-
Political commitment to slum
analysis attributes this to high prevalence of poor sanitation in Uruguay. On the other hand, urgent attention is needed to ical policy levers, carrying out reforms and scaling-up of slum prevention and upgrading is essential
cities; a WHO/UNICEF assessment in 2000 showed that 33.8 deal with overwhelming demand for services in countries upgrading programmes that have led directly to improvement to reducing slum growth.
per cent of the urban population lacked access to improved san- such as Bolivia, Guatemala, Haiti, Nicaragua, Peru and in the lives of slum dwellers. We know that some of the most
itation. Cambodia struggled to stay ahead of demographic and Venezuela. However, the majority of countries in the region, progressive sectoral reforms that drive better performance
poverty curves during the 1990s and experienced a high annu- including Brazil, Colombia, Costa Rica, Honduras and focus on: improving secure land tenure; setting up a proper
al slum growth rate of 6.1 per cent, resulting in a more than Mexico, appear to be coping more effectively and have seen land regulation system; providing affordable and accessible
doubling of the slum population from 870,000 in 1990 to over relatively low to moderate increases in the numbers and pro- housing; and improving the efficiency and coverage of water

Cairo VINCENT KITIO


2 million in 2005. portions of slum populations. supply and sanitation services.
In largely Arabic-speaking Northern Africa and Western Asia, Some of the better performing countries also score highly
the results have been mixed: while the former performed well on on local governance, accelerating effective decentralization
reducing slum growth rates, the latter had higher slum growth ■ Understanding the dynamics of improved policies, municipal reforms and broad-based participation in
rates than those of the rest of Asia. Slum growth in many performance planning. With new-found mandates and powers and increas-
Western Asian countries is not necessarily confined to lower- ing pressure to respond to voters’ demands, municipalities are
income countries, but also extends to middle-income and high- Six years after the Millennium Declaration committed gov- paying more attention to improving slums and are getting
income countries in the region, such as Iraq, Jordan and Saudi ernments to strive for “cities without slums”, the results of the more involved in slum upgrading. The analyses also show
Arabia, which experienced a drop in economic performance in global scorecard suggest that only a handful of countries in the that, in many cases, there are no hard-and-fast rules regarding
the 1990s and witnessed sustained growth in the number of slum developing world have made real progress in providing better which policy interventions or governance structures work
dwellers (3 per cent to 4 per cent a year), from 6.8 million, public services and housing to slum dwellers. “On track” coun- best. For instance, some of the best performing countries,
390,000 and 2.4 million in 1990 to 10 million, 740,000 and 4.2 tries, where slum growth rates have actually fallen, include including Egypt, Russia and Tunisia, have succeeded in
million in 2005, respectively. Mauritania and Yemen also per- Egypt, Sri Lanka, Thailand and Tunisia. In these countries, reversing slum growth rates under very centralized systems of
formed poorly, recording annual slum growth rates of 5 per cent governments and other stakeholders have taken on the respon- governance, while others, such as Colombia and India, have
or more. In contrast, Egypt and Tunisia are the “high-flyers” in sibility of providing decent housing, water and sanitation to been unable to reverse slum growth despite highly decentral-
Northern Africa with a good track record of investments in water slum dwellers – and they have shown how to get the job done. ized governance structures.
and sanitation, as well as informal settlements upgrading, during These countries also provide a beacon of hope and inspiration The evidence also points to the high performers improving
the course of the 1990s that resulted in a significant decline in to their neighbours. However, the worrying trend is that most the financial sustainability of local governments, and finding
the number of slum dwellers, from 14 million and 425,000 in developing countries, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, failed innovative ways of raising domestic investment. We also know
1990 to 11 million and 188,000 in 2005, respectively. to make much headway in reducing or reversing the slum that the most successful countries face up to a double challenge

44 45
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

society and the international community have an opportunity The real energy behind this tracking system should come, not
Slum Housing in Manila, Phillipines A. APPELBE/UNEP/STILL PICTURES

to use the results to better manage their performance. By com- from the donors, but from the countries that fall under the
paring the performance outcomes of different slum policies spotlight of the scorecard. It is their policies, their political
among countries, governments and international development leaders and their future prospects that are under scrutiny. The
agencies, stakeholders can use the results to improve policy issue is whether the results will grab the attention of politicians,
and resource allocation decisions, drive performance improve- policymakers and the general public to produce sufficient pres-
ments in service delivery for the urban poor, and communicate sure on governments for change. Arguably, indicators and sta-
to the public how well or otherwise progress is being made tistics make headlines if they are about issues that people really
towards target 11 and the other Millennium Development care about and feel that they, or their leaders, have the power to
Goals and targets in cities. More specifically, the scorecard change for the better. It is too early to say if target 11 can trig-
could be used to: ger such fundamental changes in attitude – but it is clear that
the momentum behind this movement is growing.
• Identify best practices in slum upgrading and prevention
using reliable statistical information. The scorecard may
help point toward success stories in improving the lives of
slum dwellers, and provide a basis for analysing what factors
led to better performance. Other countries could adapt and
implement the most effective practices in order to achieve
similar results. Progressive sectoral reforms, such as
improving land tenure and regularization,
• Motivate countries to improve their performance. One of providing affordable housing and
the most critical barriers to effective service delivery in the
public sector is the lack of competition – comparing and
improving coverage of water and
reporting on performance can help demonstrate how well sanitation, are key to slum prevention.
agencies are doing compared with others.5 The scorecard
could foster a competitive spirit among countries, particu-
larly those at a similar level of development, motivating
progressive countries to make further, continuous
improvements and to alert lagging countries to take
urgent, remedial action.

• Strengthen the accountability of governments.


Ultimately, the performance information contained in
the scorecard, when made publicly available in countries,
could help to make governments more accountable to the
urban poor. While governments do not have the primary
responsibility of providing basic services, a responsibility Endnotes
that is often shared with non-governmental organiza-
tions, the private sector and the urban poor themselves, 1 MIT website, “Upgrading urban communities”:
such a scorecard can lead to wider public debate and cre- http://web.mit.edu/urbanupgrading.
ate pressure for change. 2 Moreno 2005.
3 Refer to UN-HABITAT 2003c.
• Help the international community to target aid more 4 The scorecard simply shows where and by how much there has been
effectively. The scorecard could provide donors, multilater- progress or otherwise in reducing the numbers of people living in slums.
al funding agencies and the United Nations system with a In order to investigate the reasons behind good and bad performance,
tool for comparing how well countries are performing on the results were used to trigger an in-depth analysis of the policy envi-
target 11. Results could be used to identify where problems ronment in 23 of the over 100 countries broadly representative of the
exist and to set priorities for resource allocation according four performance categories. The 23 countries analysed were: Cuba,
to level of need. The scorecard could also provide a baseline Egypt, Sri Lanka, Thailand, and Tunisia in the “on-track” category; Brazil,
against which future changes can be tracked. If there is evi- Colombia, Indonesia, Mexico, Philippines, and South Africa in the “sta-
dence of sustained lack of effective policies to bring down bilizing” category; Chile, Haiti, India, and Morocco in the “at-risk” cate-
slum growth, the international community, including gory; and Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Burkina Faso, Ethiopia, Ghana,
donors, could use the scorecard to decide if making any fur- Liberia, Senegal, and Tanzania in the “off track” category.
ther investments in slum upgrading or prevention to non- 5 Morley, et al. 2001.
performing countries is worthwhile.

46 47
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

1.4 The Struggle to Achieve the Millennium Development Goals


cities outpace even some countries in economic output. If the Countries that are highly urbanized have
five largest cities in the United States – New York, Los Angeles, higher incomes and more stable
Chicago, Boston and Philadelphia – were treated as a single
economies than those with less urbanized
country, it would rank as the fourth largest economy in the
will be Won or Lost in Cities world.7 This trend is also evident in the developing world: São
Paulo, Brazil’s largest city, and Bangkok, the capital of Thailand,
populations.

both host just over 10 per cent of the total population of their
respective countries, but both account for more than 40 per cent
of their countries’ GDP. Cities also generate a disproportionate cities, particularly national capitals. Attempts to “decentralize”
amount of revenue for governments; the residents of India’s economic activities to secondary cities are unlikely to be success-
commercial capital Mumbai, for instance, pay almost 40 per ful unless the decentralization is supported by pro-poor invest-
cent of the nation’s taxes.8 ment in infrastructure and public services, and by the financial
Goods and services are generally produced more efficiently in and institutional strengthening of local authorities.9
densely populated areas that provide access to supportive servic- Contrary to popular perception, infrastructure investments
Singapore ©PHIL DATE. IMAGE FROM BIGSTOCKPHOTO.COM

es, transport and communication links, a pool of labour with in urban areas are not only cost-effective but also environmen-
appropriate skills, and a critical mass of consumers – all attractive tally sound. The concentration of population and enterprises in
qualities associated with cities. In the new, increasingly knowl- urban areas greatly reduces the unit cost of piped water, sewers,
edge-based global economy, cities are particularly efficient pro- drains, roads, electricity, garbage collection, transport, health
ducers. Improved economic and social infrastructure, together care, and schools. However, the cost-effectiveness of infrastruc-
with economies of scale and agglomeration benefits associated ture investment is greatly reduced when these investments are
with large urban centres, allow businesses and enterprises in cities made too late. For instance, when informal settlements or
to flourish. The concentration of economic activity in cities slums are allowed to proliferate, it becomes more difficult and
makes them prime generators of non-agricultural employment in more expensive to install infrastructure and services because no
both the formal and informal sectors. While the formal sector prior provision was made for the settlement’s development.10
accounts for a much larger share of urban employment in indus- Moreover, population densities and the spatial configuration of
trialized countries, the informal sector employs a significant pro- slums often do not allow for the development of roads, sewer-
portion of the non-agricultural labour force in developing age systems and other facilities that may be easier to install in
THE GOOD NEWS regions (up to 80 per cent in sub-Saharan Africa and more than less dense and better-planned areas.
Cities drive national economies 60 per cent in Asia and Latin America). The Millennium Development Goals provide an apt frame-
Cities are also engines of rural development. They provide work for linking the wealth of cities with increased opportuni-

T
he global fight against poverty1 – encapsulated in many opportunities for investment, which not only support ty and improved quality of life for their poorest residents. In
the Millennium Development Goals2 – is heavi- FIGURE 1.4.1 HUMAN DEVELOPMENT IS CLOSELY RELATED TO urban development but also contribute to rural development in many countries, however, prosperity has not benefited urban
ly dependent on how well cities perform. The LEVELS OF URBANIZATION an environment of strong urban-rural linkages. Improved infra- residents equally. Mounting evidence suggests that economic
link between urbanization and socio-economic 1.000
structure between rural areas and cities increases rural produc- growth in itself cannot reduce poverty or increase opportuni-
development cannot be disputed. Cities make tivity and enhances rural residents’ access to education, health- ties if it is not accompanied by equitable polices that allow
0.900
countries rich. Countries that are highly urbanized have higher care, markets, credit, information and other services. On the low-income or disadvantaged groups to benefit from that
0.800
incomes, more stable economies, stronger institutions and are other hand, enhanced urban-rural linkages benefit cities growth. Recent World Bank reports show that the best policies
better able to withstand the volatility of the global economy 0.700
through increased rural demand for urban goods and services for poverty reduction involve more redistribution of influence,
advantage and subsidies away from wealthier, more powerful
Score of HDI 2003

than those with less urbanized populations.3 The experiences of 0.600 and added value derived from agricultural produce. Increased
developed and developing countries also indicate that urbaniza- 0.500 productivity and competitiveness also fuels the urbanization groups to those that are disadvantaged.11 Countries that have
tion levels are closely related to levels of income and perform- 0.400 process: all over the world there are examples of sleepy fishing attempted to address inequality by investing in the health,
ance on human development indicators. 0.300
villages becoming thriving ports, barren outposts becoming housing and education of their most vulnerable populations
Cities around the world are playing an ever-increasing role in major trading centres and railway depots or harbours becoming tend to perform better on all human development indicators,
0.200
creating wealth, enhancing social development, attracting capital cities. Urban transformations often translate into positive including GDP.12 Countries such as Brazil, Cuba, Egypt,
0.100
investment and harnessing both human and technical resources performance on human development indicators and reduced South Africa, Sri Lanka, Thailand and Tunisia, for instance,
for achieving unprecedented gains in productivity and compet- 0.000 poverty in both rural and urban areas. Put together, all of these have performed relatively well on many human development
0 20 40 60 80 100
itiveness. As countries develop, urban settlements account for a factors provide an apt environment for the attainment of the indicators and have managed to contain or reduce slum
Percentage urban by country 2003
larger share of national income. In both developed and develop- Millennium Development Goals and targets. growth because of a political commitment – backed by
Sources: United Nations, World Urbanization Prospects: The 2003 Revision, UNDP,
ing countries, cities generate a disproportionate share of gross However, the relative absence of infrastructure, such as roads, resources – to invest in the urban poor. Inclusive and vision-
Human Development Report 2005.
domestic product (GDP)4 and provide huge opportunities for Note: Developing countries with populations of more than one million are plotted. water supply, communication facilities, and adequate housing in ary urban planning and governance that includes slum
investment and employment. The human development index (HDI) is a summary measure of human development small- and medium-sized cities – which are currently absorbing upgrading and prevention, combined with pro-poor urban
Urban-based economic activities account for up to 55 per that measures the average achievement in a country in three basic dimensions: a most of the world’s urban population growth – makes these development policies that expand and improve opportunities
long and healthy life, as measured by life expectancy at birth; knowledge, as
cent of gross national product (GNP)5 in low-income countries, cities less competitive at the national, regional and global levels. for employment are, therefore, key ingredients for sustainable
measured by the adult literacy rate and the combined primary, secondary and terti-
73 per cent in middle-income countries and 85 per cent in high- ary gross enrolment ratio; and a decent standard of living, as measured by GDP In many countries, a disproportionate amount of public invest- urban development; these are also key ingredients for the
income countries.6 In the United States, for example, some per capita (PPP US$). ment, especially investment in infrastructure, goes to the larger achievement of the Millennium Development Goals in cities.

48 49
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

THE BAD NEWS poverty, which impedes the sustainability of cities and impacts much faster with the proportion of people living in poverty in ices, making them more vulnerable to natural disasters such as
The locus of poverty is shifting to cities their economic viability. In many parts of the region, high rates rural areas (59 per cent).16 Sub-Saharan African countries have floods, and saddling them with heavy health and social bur-
of urban population growth, high prevalence of unskilled labour some of the world’s highest levels of urban poverty, extending to dens, which ultimately affect their productivity.
and the HIV/AIDS pandemic are further undermining poverty more than 50 per cent of the urban population in the poorest Despite the existence of increasingly large pockets of depri-
reduction efforts in cities. Even in Asia’s economically successful countries, including Chad, Niger and Sierra Leone. In other vation within cities, many governments continue to assume
Despite the enormous potential of cities to reduce poverty and rapidly industrializing countries, such as China and India, countries – notably Nigeria – urban and rural poverty percent- that poverty is mainly a rural phenomenon and that those who
and to achieve the Millennium Development Goals, recent evi- urban poverty remains a persistent problem as national GDP ages are almost equal.17 In Latin America, the most urbanized live in or move to cities escape the worst consequences of this
dence shows that the wealth generated by cities does not auto- rates have risen much more quickly than national poverty rates region in the developing world, there are more poor people liv- scourge, including hunger, illiteracy and disease. A prevalent
matically lead to poverty reduction; on the contrary, intra-city have fallen.14 The economic growth models used by govern- ing in cities than in rural areas. In 1999, only 77 million of the view among governments and the international development
inequalities are on the rise, particularly in the cities of Africa ments and local authorities have widened not only disparities region’s 211 million poor lived in rural areas, while the remain- community is that urban poverty is a transient phenomenon
and Latin America. between rural and urban populations, but also inequalities ing 134 million lived in urban areas. Proportionally, however, of rural-to-urban migration and will disappear as cities devel-
In fact, urbanization in many developing countries, particu- between high- and low-income populations within cities. far more of those living in rural areas than in urban areas were op, thus absorbing the poor into the mainstream of urban
larly in sub-Saharan Africa, has not been accompanied by eco- Poverty is already becoming a severe, pervasive and largely poor: 64 per cent of the rural population lived in poverty, as society. This view is reflected in most national poverty reduc-
nomic growth, industrialization or even by development per unacknowledged feature of urban life. Poverty is shifting to opposed to 34 per cent of the urban population; levels of depri- tion strategies, which remain rural-focused, and in interna-
se.13 On the contrary, the population of some African cities has urban areas and growing in magnitude. World Bank estimates vation are also more extreme in rural areas than in urban areas.18 tional donor assistance to cities, which continues to be modest
grown despite poor economic growth; the region as a whole has indicate that while rural areas are currently home to a majority The picture is quite different in the Caribbean countries, where in scale and impact,20 with the result that both national and
the highest urban growth rate in the world, at 4.58 per cent per of the world’s poor, by 2035, cities will become the predomi- urban poverty levels already exceed rural poverty levels.19 international interventions during the last two decades have
year. This phenomenon, combined with inequitable distribu- nant sites of poverty.15 But in Africa, the proportion of people Relatively low levels of urban poverty exist in countries of had the net effect of increasing poverty, exclusion and inequal-
tion of resources and anti-poor policies, has led to rising urban living in poverty in urban areas (43 per cent) is catching up Northern Africa and Western Asia, where urban poverty levels ity in cities.21
are near or below 20 per cent; the highest prevalence of urban The concept of cities as islands of privilege and opportunity
poverty in Asia is in India, at 30 per cent. is supported by national and international statistics on health,
UN-HABITAT analyses have further shown that people liv- education and income, which generally reflect better outcomes
ing in slums – where a large proportion, but not all, of the in urban areas. What these statistics fail to reveal are the severe
urban poor live – have worse health outcomes and are more inequalities within cities, and the various dimensions of urban
likely to be affected by child mortality and acute respiratory ill- poverty that are not captured by income-based indicators,
nesses than their non-slum counterparts. They are also more including political exclusion and poor quality, hazardous and
likely to live in or near hazardous locations with few basic serv- insecure housing.

FIGURE 1.4.2 THE ANNUAL GROWTH RATE OF CITIES AND SLUMS

Percentage (%)
2
Slums in Port of Spain, Trinidad NOEL P NORTON/UNEP/STILL PICTURES

-1
be ca

As rn

ric n

As rn

As rn

As rn

ric n

w ped
Af her

Af ara
he

te

te
rib eri
an

ia

ia

ia

ia

ld
st

lo
as

es
ut

rt

or
Ca m

Ea

ve
Sa
No

W
E
So
e A

h-

De
b-
th atin

ut

Su
So
an
d L

Urban growth rate Slum growth rate

Source: UN-HABITAT, Global Urban Observatory 2004.

50 51
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

and opportunities generated by the cities in which they live.


Slums are becoming the norm rather than the exception in Endnotes
the poorest cities of the world. In sub-Saharan Africa, where
more than 70 per cent of urban residents live in slums, many 1 The campaign to eradicate poverty began in earnest in 2000 when
Poverty is becoming a severe, world leaders pledged to halve it by 2015 at the UN Millennium
slum dwellers are unable to escape the material deprivation,
pervasive and largely unacknowledged Summit, held in New York in September 2000.
illiteracy and disease that are normally associated with impov-
feature of urban life. erished rural areas. Asia’s cities, which host almost 60 per cent 2 The Millennium Development Goals and targets are derived from the
of the world’s slum population, are becoming sites of severe Millennium Declaration adopted by the world’s governments at the
environmental degradation and pollution, which are impact- Millennium Summit in 2000.
ing recent economic gains. And despite progressive legislation 3 World Bank 2000.
The high cost of non-food items, such as transport, health, and improved governance structures in recent years, Latin 4 GDP refers to the total value of goods and services produced within a

Fruit vendor in Shanghai, China ©AMARK STEPHAN. IMAGE FROM BIGSTOCKPHOTO.COM


education and water in cities, coupled with poor living condi- America’s cities remain the most unequal in the world. country by both nationals of the country and foreigners.
tions, including inadequate housing and poor access to basic The sheer scale of the problem warrants attention. Nearly 5 GNP refers to the total value of goods and services produced by nation-
services, impact the ability of the urban poor to rise out of one billion people around the world are currently living in als of the country.
poverty. If the definition of poverty is broadened to include the urban slums that lack basic services and adequate housing, and 6 World Bank 2000.
social assets available to the poor and their vulnerability to their numbers will increase if no remedial action is taken. 7 U.S. Conference of Mayors 2004.
stress and shocks, including evictions, crime, disease, environ- While the target of improving the lives of at least 100 million 8 Mehta 2004.
mental disasters and unpredictable employment markets, then slum dwellers may be achieved by 2020, particularly in coun- 9 UN-HABITAT/DFID 2002.
it is likely that the proportion of poor people living in cities is tries that have put in place slum upgrading and prevention 10 Hardoy, et al. 2001.
much higher than current estimates. Poverty reduction inter- policies, the scale of the problem may worsen: UN-HABITAT 11 This point has been extensively argued in the World Bank’s World
ventions, including efforts to achieve the Millennium estimates indicate that if governments continue with business Development Report 2006, which shows that the best policies for
Development Goals, therefore, have to be focused on cities of as usual, then an additional 400 million people will be drawn poverty reduction involve more redistribution of influence, advantage or
the developing world, which are absorbing a significant num- into the misery of slum life as the global slum population subsidies away from dominant groups.
ber of the world’s poor and where slums are growing at reaches 1.4 billion in 2020. 12 This finding, for instance, is reflected in UNDP’s Human Development
unprecedented rates.22 However, slums do not simply ensnare impoverished urban Report 2005.
By 2007, half the world’s population will be urban, and in the dwellers; they also act as intermediate urban spaces, situated 13 Davis 2004.
next two decades, more than 95 per cent of the population between destitution and opportunity – key places of transition 14 This fact was highlighted at the 2005 Asia-Pacific Economic
growth in the world’s poorest regions will occur in cities. Urban that can help or hurt individuals, depending on the actions of Cooperation Summit in Busan.
growth rates are particularly high in the least developed countries, governments, the private sector, civil society and slum dwellers 15 Ravallion 2001.
at almost 5 per cent per year. This shift in population implies that themselves. They can also provide upward mobility to urban Development Goals and targets. Improving the living condi- 16 United Nations 2005a.
the major development challenges – and the struggle to achieve dwellers and become sites of immense economic opportunity, tions of slum dwellers, by improving housing, tenure security 17 World Bank 2002 estimates.
the Millennium Development Goals and targets – will have to be culture and innovation – the hallmarks of successful cities. and access to water and sanitation, will automatically have a 18 United Nations 2005a.
focused on cities of the developing world, where an increasingly Despite the substandard living conditions prevalent within positive impact on the attainment of most of the Goals and 19 Inter-American Development Bank 2004.
large proportion of the world’s poor will live. them, slums can also represent a kind of opportunity for the targets. In regions where slum dwellers do not suffer from 20 Cohen 2004. Author estimates that total urban assistance to develop-
urban poor. In most regions, slums are “stepping stones” out multiple shelter deprivations, interventions and investments in ing countries from 1970 to 2000 was just $2 billion a year.
of rural poverty, as slum dwellers have more urban-based just one sector can dramatically reduce the numbers of people 21 UN-HABITAT 2003a.
■ Achieving the slum target employment opportunities than villagers and have better living under slum conditions. 22 For a detailed analysis of this phenomenon, see Chapter 1.2.
access to publicly financed services and infrastructure. Indeed, UN-HABITAT is convinced that the slum target cannot be 23 See Chapter 1.2 for the UN-HABITAT definition of “slums”.
Millennium Development Goal 7, target 11 on improving most slum dwellers choose to remain in cities because of the achieved in isolation. On the contrary, it is becoming increas- 24 Babar Mumtaz makes a case for why “Cities Need Slums” in Habitat
the lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers by 2020 forces perceived and actual social and economic benefits they pro- ingly clear that the failure of the slum target will jeopardize the Debate, Vol 7. No. 3, September 2001. He argues that insisting on a
the international community to address one specific aspect of vide. Slums, some have argued, are an integral and natural part achievement of all the other Goals and targets; conversely, “city without slums”, especially when no alternative housing has been
urban poverty that until now was neither captured in national of economic growth and industrialization and should be con- achieving the other Goals and targets in slums will make the developed, can mean even more hardship for the very group that is
statistics nor reflected in urban data. The slum target is a sidered marks of “success” in urban areas. They reflect a achievement of the slum target more likely.25 essential to urban development: the rural migrant.
recognition by the international community that slums cannot dynamic and diverse labour market and offer affordable hous- The struggle to achieve the Millennium Development Goals 25 Moreno 2005.
be considered an unfortunate by-product of urbanization; ing to those who cannot, or will not, pay more for accommo- has to be waged in slums, not at the expense of rural areas, but
rather, by ignoring the plight of slum dwellers, governments dation in the city.24 alongside them. Ultimately, as the world becomes more urban,
are inadvertently adopting urbanization models that are nei- Cities and the slums within them also offer governments an the battle to achieve the Goals will be won – or lost – in the
ther sustainable nor acceptable. “opportunity” or entry point to tackle some of the world’s zopadpattis of Mumbai, the bidonvilles of Abidjan, the chawls
Slums currently house one out of every three urban dwellers. most pressing challenges, including extreme poverty, under- of Ahmedabad, the villas miseria of Buenos Aires, the favelas of
Although slums23 represent a physical manifestation of urban five mortality, HIV/AIDS, environmental degradation, and Rio de Janeiro, the barrios ilegales of Quito, the shammasas of
poverty and do not capture the myriad facets of urban pover- gender inequality. The sheer concentration of people living in Khartoum, the iskwaters of Manila, the chereka betes of Addis
ty that have little to do with housing or basic services, their cities and slums means that any investment is likely to reap Ababa, the aashwai’is of Cairo, the corticos of São Paulo, the
rapid growth in the last 50 years, particularly in Asia and greater benefits per capita. On the other hand, the economies colonias populares of Mexico City, the vijiji of Nairobi, the
Africa, indicates that they are home to a large number of the of scale offered by high density slums also make them ideal tar- gecekondus of Ankara, the hoods of Los Angeles, the museques
world’s urban poor who are not benefiting from the wealth gets for interventions aimed at achieving the Millennium of Luanda and the katchi abadis of Karachi.

52 53
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6

Cities, Slums and the Millennium Development Goals Goal 4: Reduce under-five mortality
Goal 1: Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger Reduce by two-thirds, between 1990 and 2015, the under-five mortality rate

Halve, between 1990 and 2015, the proportion of people whose income is less than $1 a day  Better access to health facilities in  Under-five mortality rates are higher in slums than in non-slum urban areas.
Halve, between 1990 and 2015, the proportion of people who suffer from hunger. cities means that children born in High child mortality rates in slums are not so much related to whether or not
urban areas have a better chance of children are immunized; rather, they have more to do environmental factors,

 Cities act as catalysts for poverty reduction: they generate the wealth  The locus of poverty is moving to cities. In the surviving than their rural counter-
parts, who may not live near facili-
such as overcrowding, indoor air pollution, poor wastewater treatment and
lack of drainage, sewerage and sanitation facilities. The use of solid fuels,

A victim of eviction in Zimbabwe UN-HABITAT


and the economic opportunities needed to make the achievement of next two decades, more than 95 per cent of the ties that offer services such as combined with overcrowding and poor ventilation, in slum households increas-
the Millennium Development Goals possible. population growth in the world’s poorest regions immunization and post-natal care. es the chances of children contracting acute respiratory illnesses, such as
will occur in urban areas, with the result that
 Urbanization levels are closely related to levels of income and better cities will become the predominant sites of  Empirical evidence suggests that
pneumonia. Many slums are also located in or near hazardous or toxic sites,
which expose children to additional environmental and health hazards.
performance on social indicators, including health and literacy. The poverty in coming years. sectoral interventions in water, san-
achievement of the Millennium Development Goals is, therefore, more  Access to more health care facilities in urban areas does not automatically
likely in cities. Conversely, urban economic growth provides the basis  Malnutrition, hunger and disease are becoming itation and housing have positive
outcomes in the reduction of child lead to reduced mortality rates in slums. Parents struggling to pay for food,
on which cities can contribute to the achievement of the Goals, partic- more prevalent in slums, particularly in develop- mortality rates. school fees and transport costs may be unwilling or unable to pay for the
ularly in the area of poverty reduction. ing countries. Because hunger experienced in health care of their children, which has an impact on child mortality rates.
Somalia UNICEF

cities is directly related to income (rather than


 Cities and slums are often the “first step” out of rural poverty. The agricultural productivity), the urban poor are
rural poor move to cities, where there are more employment opportu- much more vulnerable to income-dependant
nities and better access to services such as health care and education. hunger than their rural counterparts. Goal 5: Improve maternal health
Reduce by three-quarters, between 1990 and 2015, the maternal mortality ratio
Goal 2: Achieve universal primary education
 Mothers are more likely to be  Many women living in slums cannot afford the relatively more expensive
Ensure that, by 2015, children everywhere, boys and girls alike, will be able to complete a full course of primary schooling attended by pre-natal healthcare delivery and post-natal health services in urban areas, and are, therefore,
personnel in cities, as there are less likely to seek these services, especially when a choice has to be made
 Cities are nodes of edu-  Educational facilities are generally more advanced and accessible in cities

Luanda, Angola EDUARDO LÓPEZ MORENO


generally more health care facil- between paying for these services and buying food or meeting other
ities in urban areas than in rural household expenses.
cation and learning, a key but the cost of other items (transport, housing, food) is higher in cities than
areas. Increased awareness in
contributing factor in in rural settings, which impacts the ability of the poorest households to
 Poor urban women who supplement their incomes by engaging in sexually
Education in Africa UNEP/STILL PICTURES

urban areas means that women


rural-to-urban migration. send children to school. Slum children, particularly girls, are more at risk of
are more likely to have a better risky behaviour expose themselves to a variety of sexually transmitted dis-
Urbanization has been dropping out of school than children living in non-slum urban areas.
understanding of the need for eases that have a negative impact on maternal health. Numerous studies
associated with econom-
ic and social progress,  In many slums, overcrowding and inadequate or non-existent toilet facilities ante-natal and post-natal care
than their rural counterparts.
have shown high rates of HIV infection among urban women; in sub-
Saharan Africa, HIV prevalence is highest among women living in urban
the promotion of literacy and other amenities further impact the quality of education that children
areas, and particularly high among women living in slums.
and education. receive. In some countries, adolescent girls drop out of school because of
insufficient toilet facilities in slum schools, or because of family responsi-
bilities, such as taking care of siblings while parents are at work.
Goal 6: Combat diseases including HIV/AIDS, malaria and other diseases
Goal 3: Promote gender equality and empower women Have halted by 2015 and begun to reverse the spread of HIV/AIDS
Have halted by 2015 and begun to reverse the incidence of malaria and other major diseases
Eliminate gender disparity in primary and secondary education, preferably by 2005, and in all levels of education no later than 2015
 Access to information and  Increased awareness about prevention in urban areas has not had the desired effect of reducing HIV prevalence in
 Cities offer women social mobil-  With the exception of Africa, the share of woman-headed households is greater in urban areas than in rural areas. health care facilities in cities is cities. In fact, trends suggest that HIV prevalence is much greater in urban areas than in rural areas, and is also high-
ity, which has a positive impact This trend has socio-economic implications, which can translate into deepening poverty among urban women in higher than in rural areas. er among urban women than among rural women.
on gender equality and has
helped reverse some socially
some countries. Increased awareness has led to
the prevention of malaria and  The HIV-AIDS pandemic may shave off up to 2 per cent of annual economic growth in the worst affected countries. This
prescribed roles. In many coun-  In situations of limited resources and urban impoverishment, women and girls are the first to be sacrificed when other major diseases and has a direct impact on urban economic growth and in some countries severely undermines poverty alleviation efforts.

tries, urban women have more families have to make difficult choices about sending their children to school. widened people’s choices in the  The situation of extreme deprivation in cities, particularly in slums, encourages residents to engage in risky sexual
 Slum life forces many women and girls to engage in sexually risky behaviour, making them more vulnerable to
access to land and property than treatment and prevention of the behaviour for economic survival. Slum residents often start sexual intercourse younger, have more sexual partners,
their rural counterparts as they HIV/AIDS epidemic. and are less likely than other city residents to know of or adopt preventive measures against contracting HIV/AIDS.
HIV/AIDS and other sexually transmitted diseases. HIV prevalence among urban women in sub-Saharan Africa is
 Slum upgrading and prevention  HIV/AIDS has contributed to the growing problems of AIDS orphans; many of these orphans become street children
are not constrained by discrimi-
already is much higher than among rural women.
natory customary laws. In gener-
al, urbanization has had a posi-  Poor access to water and sanitation places an enormous labour and health burden on women living in slums, who are policies that incorporate volun- caught in the poverty trap of hunger, malnutrition, disease and illiteracy.
tive impact on women’s access not only charged with ensuring that their families have water, but who also suffer disproportionately from the health
tary testing and counselling
facilities have helped reduce HIV
 Slums are characterized by overcrowding and poor ventilation, the leading contributors to the rise in tuberculosis
to resources and enlarged their and environmental hazards associated with poor sanitation. In slums, where there are few or no toilets, many women cases worldwide. Studies have shown that HIV-related tuberculosis is becoming an increasingly urban phenomenon,
decision-making roles. prevalence in urban areas.
are forced to defecate in the cover of darkness, which renders them more vulnerable to sexual and physical assault. particularly in slums.

54 55
Goal 7: Ensure Environmental sustainability Goal 8: Develop a global partnership for development
Integrate the principles of sustainable development into country policies and programmes and reverse the loss of environmental resources Address the special needs of the least developed countries and small island developing States
Halve, by 2015, the proportion of people without access to safe drinking water and basic sanitation. Develop further an open, rule-based, predicable, non-discriminatory trading and financial system
By 2020, to have achieved a significant improvement in the lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers (Goal 7, Target 11) Deal comprehensively with developing countries’ debt
In cooperation with developing countries, develop and implement strategies for decent and productive work for youth
In cooperation with pharmaceutical companies, provide access to affordable and essential drug in developing countries
In cooperation with the private sector, make available the benefits of new technologies, especially information and communications

Sustainable urban development


Air Pollution ©ALISTAIR SCOTT. IMAGE FROM BIGSTOCKPHOTO.COM

 Urbanization can bring about irreversible changes in production


and consumption of water, energy and land. Both developed and
developing countries are witnessing rapid urban sprawl with
direct consequences for the surrounding hinterland.

 Air pollution is concentrated in cities. The concentration of


industrial emissions and increased motorized transport in cities
is severely eroding their environmental sustainability and is
affecting the health of urban populations. Acute respiratory ill-
nesses associated with poor air quality and poor housing condi-
tions are impacting the human and economic productivity of
cities, particularly in Asia; it is estimated that the health costs
from pollution reduce gross domestic product (GDP) by some 2
per cent in developing countries.
Sustainable urban development
Slums
 Sustainable urbanization policies have been incorporat-
ed in many city and national plans and are contributing  The rate at which slums are growing exceeds the rate at which
to reversing the impact of environmental degradation they are being improved. This severely impacts the achievement
and pollution. Cities with sound and sustainable land, of Goal 7, target 11: by 2020, to have achieved a significant
air and water management policies have also managed improvement in the lives of at least 100 million slum dwellers.

Tokyo NATSUO ITO


to reduce soil erosion, improve air and water quality Some 200 million more slum dwellers have been added to the
and protect biodiversity within cities and in their hin- world’s urban population since 2000; if current trends continue,
terlands. Some cities in the developed world are uni- by 2020, there will be 400 million more people drawn into the
laterally reducing greenhouse gas emissions and other misery of slum life and the global slum population will reach
pollutants as part of their respective governments’ 1.4 billion.
commitment to adhere to the Kyoto Protocol.
 Slum dwellers are more likely to live in hazardous or toxic loca- Partnerships for development Partnerships for development
 Cities concentrate production and population, which tions, which are more prone to natural disasters, such as
gives them obvious advantages over rural settlements floods, and which pose severe health risks, not just to slum  In the last decade, the international community has become much more aware of the  Increased awareness of the potential and chal-
or dispersed populations. For example, the concentra- dwellers but to city dwellers in general. problems, challenges and opportunities of urbanization. City-to-city cooperation and lenges of cities has not led to a commensurate
tion of populations in urban areas greatly reduces the decentralization policies are becoming more common as governments at the local and increase in international development assistance
unit cost of piped water, sewers, drains and roads. The  Although access to water and sanitation is generally better in national levels cooperate to make cities more liveable. Some national governments are or to greater allocation of national finances to
use of environmentally friendly energy sources and urban areas than in rural areas globally, the consequences of for the first time addressing urban poverty in their national poverty reduction strategies urban poverty reduction. Most development aid is
transport can reduce these costs even further. poor access in cities are more severe. Many slum dwellers have and programmes. Many local governments are also recognizing the need to plan, manage focused on eradicating extreme poverty and
no choice but to use water sources, such as rivers, to bathe and and govern their cities better, which has improved the lives of many urban residents improving the living conditions of rural popula-
Slums wash clothes. Poor sanitation in some cities has also led to worldwide. As part of new structures of governance, where cities are being given more tions. Many governments have not identified
large sections of the population defecating in the open. This authority to manage their affairs, cities are playing a more prominent role in developing “urban poverty” as an area of intervention in their
 Slums provide an important entry point for the achieve- contributes to contamination of water and land resources with- partnerships with central governments, regional organizations and development partners development plans.
ment of all the Millennium Development Goals in in cities, and is a cause of many of the water-borne diseases to promote sustainable urbanization within cities, countries and regions.
cities; the sheer concentration of people living in slums prevalent in slums.  Although investments have been made in various
make them ideal targets for interventions aimed at  Some multilateral agencies and regional development banks are recognizing the need to sectors, such as health and infrastructure develop-
reducing poverty, reducing child mortality and  Indoor air pollution caused by the use of solid fuels is prevalent intervene and invest in urban areas as part of their development assistance programmes. ment, they are often not tagetted specifically at
HIV/AIDS, improving literacy and promoting environ- in slums and is a leading cause of respiratory illnesses in urban In Latin America, for instance, the portfolio of loans for urban development have grown slums.
mental sustainability in urban areas. areas, particularly among women and children. in both volume and complexity.

56 57
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

2
Part Two

The State of the


World’s Slums

Slums are the emerging human settlements of the


21st century. In order to monitor the state of the
world’s slums, this Part presents a detailed
analysis of the five indicators that reflect
conditions that characterize slums. These
indicators, known as “shelter deprivations”, are:
lack of durable housing; lack of sufficient living
area; lack of access to improved water; lack of
access to improved sanitation; and lack of secure
tenure. Information on the five indicators is
analysed at global, regional, national and city
levels. This Part also presents an analysis of the
degrees of shelter deprivation in some selected
countries and regions.
Manila TINA ELAINE RUSTE/UNEP/STILL PICTURES
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

2.1 Neither Brick nor Mortar: Non-Durable Housing in Cities

D
urability is one of the least understood attrib- It is estimated that at least three or four
utes of a nation’s housing stock, and life
in every 10 non-permanent houses in
expectancy of a house is a neglected indica-

Buenos Aires MARK EDWARDS/STILL PICTURES


tor.1 In many parts of the world, housing cities in developing countries are
durability assessments are not systematic, and located in dangerous areas that are
when conducted, they do not generate data that is comparable prone to floods, landslides and other
with data in other areas. Estimates suggest that worldwide, 18 natural disasters.
per cent of all urban housing units (some 125 million units) are
non-permanent structures, and 25 per cent (175 million units)
do not conform to urban building codes or regulations.2 These comprising older construction that has not been upgraded or
figures, however, could be highly underestimated as global data add-on structures that have not been brought up to the stan-
on durability is based primarily on permanence of individual dard of the rest of the dwelling.5 In some European cities, a
structures, not on location or compliance with building codes. small amount of unauthorized construction of dwelling units
Mainstream reporting mechanisms are not designed to capture takes place in absence of building permits and in violation of
data on unsafe or hazardous location of housing, but com- zoning rules. Such houses are illegal in the technical sense, but
pelling reasons exist for collecting such data, as it is estimated in most cases, they respect current building standards. There
that at least three or four in every 10 non-permanent houses in are, however, a small number of houses that do not comply
cities in developing countries are located in dangerous areas with building codes, some of which are regarded as unhealthy
that are prone to floods, landslides and other natural disasters.3 dwellings. In Naples, such buildings are called “bassos”; in
Other unsafe locations include living on garbage dumpsites or Barcelona, “illegal pensions” are a problem; and in Paris, many
in highly polluted areas. Non-durable dwellings located on haz- low-income families live in illegal boarding houses and other
ardous locations are particularly at risk when natural disasters forms of sub-divided apartments.6
strike, as they are least able to withstand the destruction caused In Europe, North America and other developed regions,
by flood, earthquakes or hurricanes. However, people living in housing durability has undergone a fair amount of analysis,
extreme poverty in cities often have little choice but to take particularly with regard to building materials, maintenance and
shelter in ramshackle structures haphazardly constructed in the construction methods and systems. Issues such as affordability,
most polluted, dangerous areas. accessibility, financial costs, and quality of the dwelling are rel-
Informal settlements in the developing world typically do not atively well researched. Studies also include measures to
meet local building codes and other regulations for urban devel- improve housing durability, not only for economic reasons, but
opment. Disregard of building codes has clear implications for also for disaster mitigation and vulnerability reduction.7
the durability and safety of housing. The destruction of residen- The vast majority of housing in developed countries is in
tial buildings wrought by recent earthquakes in cities – such as decent condition. In Canada in 2001, for example, just one in
those in Turkey in 1999, India in 2001 and Iran in 2003 – con- 12 homes (8.2 per cent) were in need of major repairs, and
firmed the importance of enforcing building codes and regula- nearly two-thirds of homes needed only regular maintenance.8
tions, as the structures that collapsed were found to have violat- In the United States, approximately 2 per cent of occupied
ed building norms and technical requirements deemed neces- units had severe physical problems with plumbing, heating,
sary in earthquake-prone regions. Poor enforcement of building electricity, public areas, or maintenance in 1999.9 This ratio is
codes was also the primary reason cited for the collapse of a similar to other developed countries that have a housing stock
multi-storey building under construction in Nairobi, Kenya, in comprised almost entirely of permanent buildings, even in the
January 2006, which claimed 14 lives and injured several oth- lowest-income parts of the city. In some European cities, a few
ers.4 The urban poor suffer the greatest loss when natural disas- unique exceptions exist, such as the Roma encampments built
ters strike, in part because their housing is built to lower stan- with temporary or “non-permanent” materials.
dards than housing for higher-income residents. An interesting pattern emerges from the data about the hous-
In the developed regions, it is estimated that almost all hous- ing stock in developed countries, however, which reveals that
ing is in compliance with codes and regulations. The Canadian the units that are in the worst condition and require the most
government, for instance, reports that just a fraction of the repairs often house members of ethnic minorities or immi-
country’s housing stock – 5 to 10 per cent – is non-compliant, grants.10 Many such houses are overcrowded and dilapidated

60
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

MAP 7 PROPORTION OF HOUSEHOLDS WITHOUT FINISHED MAIN FLOOR MATERIAL, 2003


Affordability, Accessibility and Durable Houses
Durability – the longevity of residential struc- are subject to rapid deterioration and subse- reduce maintenance and replacement costs
tures – is directly associated with housing quent depreciation. Financial institutions, there- remains out of the financial reach of most slum
accessibility and affordability. fore, have adhered to standards and building dwellers. Poor families requiring housing right
codes in a way that limits access to affordability away are more likely to opt for temporary solu-
In the formal housing market in developing schemes for the working poor. tions than wait until they can afford something
countries, mortgage institutions, such as com- more permanent. These solutions increase their
mercial or trading banks, restrict loans to In the informal housing sector, slum dwellers vulnerability, as the units may be structurally
builders who use materials that are “accept- recognize the trade-offs between durability and unstable or located in hazardous areas.
able” in the market because they are considered affordability. They understand that a durable
“durable” (e.g. bricks, stones, concrete, and the house has a clear positive economic benefit, is Lack of affordable land and the absence of
like). The use of durable materials decreases safer and can be healthier for its occupants than affordable self-build housing schemes leave
the bank’s risk over the period of the mortgage one made of temporary materials. However, put- impoverished urban residents susceptible to
loan. This housing policy excludes local building ting up a house that lasts requires a high initial risks and harms that could be alleviated by
materials such as wood, bamboo or other inno- investment, even though it could cost less in the improved urban planning and the development
vations that arise out of the use of indigenous long run. “Building to last” in terms of using of more affordable building materials that are >45%
materials; such materials are inexpensive, but stronger and more durable materials that would durable and easy to use by self-builders. >25-45%
>10-25%
<=10%

dwellings located in low-income neighbourhoods, built in the Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Global Urban Observatory, Urban Indicators Programme, Phase III.
1970s or earlier as part of government housing development
projects, in older parts of central cities and first-ring suburbs.
Many are substandard units that are contaminated and lacking tial problems with other key structural materials of dwellings. fore needed to monitor spatial inequalities within cities where
light, air and open space. Others are poorly built, poorly main- For example, if housing durability estimations include quality segregated urban social structures persist.16 UN-HABITAT’s
tained and isolated, often situated in inaccessible or unhealthy of roof and wall materials, the figure for many countries would urban inequities study conducted in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, for
locations, such as along motorways and industrial wastelands. drop. (See table.) For instance, in Bolivia, when only floor instance, highlights the disparity between slum dwellers and
Even if the number of these housing units is statistically material is considered, 83.8 per cent of the urban population is other urban groups with regard to adequate housing. While
insignificant, they typify some of the exclusion patterns and counted as living in durable housing, but when wall and roof more than half (51.6 per cent) of slum households used natu-
forms of physical and social decay prevalent among impover- materials are considered, this figure drops to 27.7 per cent. In ral, non-permanent, materials for the floors of their dwellings,
ished minorities in the developed world. Government agencies Nicaragua, when floor and roof materials are combined to 58.4 per cent of non-slum households used polished cement, a
have also observed that rental units often have twice as many determine durability, only 9 per cent of the urban population permanent material. Also, a significantly higher percentage of
durability problems as owner-occupied units.11 qualifies as living in a durable home.
A close relationship clearly exists among durability, afford- In order to produce more accurate data on housing durabili-
ability and accessibility in housing markets and building pat- ty, a statistical analysis was conducted in the countries where TABLE 2.1.1 HOUSING DURABILITY, BASED ON FLOOR, ROOF AND
terns around the world. These linkages are very often neglected information is available for the three main physical structure WALL MATERIALS, IN THE URBAN AREAS OF 16 SELECTED
and thus are not properly analyzed for policy purposes. variables – floor, walls and roof – at the urban level. The results COUNTRIES, 2001
provide a more realistic image of housing durability, and three
Country Floor Wall Roof All
examples aptly illustrate this point. In Indonesia, the percent-
■ UN-HABITAT data and analysis of housing age of durable housing in urban areas in 2002 was 69.8 per cent
Benin 80.2 61.6 88.3 60.1
durability in developing countries when the three components of the dwelling were considered,
whereas when only the floor criterion was used, 83.7 per cent Central African
Republic 26.2 9.1 52.5 7.7
To estimate the prevalence of slums around the world using data of houses were deemed durable.12 In Benin, 80 per cent of
Chad 15.3 5.3 52.9 4.7
collected between 1990 and 2001, UN-HABITAT included a houses qualified as permanent and durable in 2001, consider-
Togo 94.4 72.6 88.7 66.2
London MJS

measurement of housing durability as one of its five indicators of ing only the floor criterion; however, when materials for the
Uganda 68.6 58.5 91.8 53.7
slum households. In principle, the estimation procedure consid- three elements of the house were taken into account, housing
durability dropped to 60 per cent.15 UN-HABITAT results are Bolivia 83.8 52.0 41.5 27.7
ered the nature of the roof, wall and floor materials of dwellings.
Data on all three was easily obtainable for developed countries, but consistent with data produced by governmental sources that Brazil 89.2 95.2 98.9 86.1
in the developing world, estimations were made considering only assess quality of housing combining the three variables. India, Dominican Republic 95.7 92.5 98.6 88.6
the nature of the floor material. Roof and wall materials were con- for instance, reported that 73 per cent of urban households Guatemala 77.4 66.3 96.7 60.8
sidered inappropriate variables for the durability indicator, as infor- lived in pucca or permanent houses in 1991,13 and Sri Lanka Nicaragua 65.3 61.2 21.9 9.0
mation on them is collected in few countries. reported that permanent structures with brick walls, tiled roofs, Peru 66.5 58.4 84.8 47.7
The research revealed that in 2003, 94 per cent of the world’s and cement floors constituted 70 per cent of houses in urban Bangladesh 53.2 64.3 27.3 26.4
housing units in urban areas were considered permanent based on areas in the early 1990s.14 Indonesia 83.7 72.6 93.9 69.8
the “floor criterion”, meaning that most of the floor in each This data only presents the national and urban aggregates, 69.2 59.2 72.1 46.8
dwelling was constructed or covered with permanent materials and which are useful for monitoring urban poverty and sustainabil-
was not simply earthen. Using this criterion alone masks poten- ity at city, national and regional levels. Further research is there- Source: UN-HABITAT, Global Urban Observatory, 2005.

62 63
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

slum dwellers (74.6 per cent) used traditional (non-permanent) increasing housing durability has been registered in the interme-
materials to construct their walls, compared to non-slum diate cities of Assyut, Aswan and Beni Suef in Egypt. These cities Defining durability
dwellers (58.7 per cent). While UN-HABITAT recognizes that have also made progress on other shelter indicators, leading to an
slums are not always geographically contiguous, in most cities, overall decline in the number of slum households. The city of Presently, global data on housing durability is
slum households are clustered to some extent, indicating specif- Porto Novo, Benin – an important political capital and host of not possible to collect and analyze because

Old Town in Fez, Morocco. NATSUO ITO


ic areas of cities in which housing conditions are distinctly an annual international festival – has also shown significant researchers and governments have not agreed
worse than in other areas. It should therefore be emphasized improvements on housing durability and other indicators that upon definitions, specific indicators, classifica-
that an understanding of the spatial patterns of inequality is are attributed to increased government investments in housing. tions, and approaches. What little data has
fundamental to formulating area-based policies to address lack Kigali, the capital city of Rwanda, has experienced a significant been collected has several methodological
of housing durability and other deprivations.17 improvement in housing durability and on all of the slum indi- weaknesses. For instance, wood is considered
cators. Despite the conflict that ravaged the country in 1994, durable in developed regions, but not in most
Rwanda has made steady progress in economic recovery and has developing countries. Other building materials
■ A global and regional overview of housing made impressive sectoral improvements in education and health. are classified as “rudimentary” (e.g. mud or
durability The city of Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, on the other hand, showed palm), but in certain cases, they are recorded as
an improvement in housing durability but did not have similar “permanent”. A material may not be deemed
UN-HABITAT estimates indicate that in 2003, 133 million progress on other shelter indicators. durable in terms of other, more modern building
people living in cities of developing regions lived in housing Urban-level aggregates conceal intra-city disparities. In cities materials, but when combined with skilled con- floors or ceilings, etc.” In Japan, “durable” depending on definitions and measurement cri-
that lacked finished floor materials. In the developing world, such as Luanda, Angola, and Arusha, Tanzania, the population struction and regular repair, it could be coded as housing is any that is not dilapidated, as defined teria. Most of the censuses collected around the
“durable”. Moreover, a problem that arises by the government. According to this definition, world present data on housing quality based on
Asia had the largest proportion (73 per cent) of urban dwellers living in durable houses is approximately 50 per cent.18 It is like-
when measuring the permanency of the struc- housing durability can be captured by three the material used for construction of walls,
living in non-permanent housing. Over 50 per cent of this ly that housing deficits in these countries will increase, as their
ture is that durability manifests itself differently main conditions: permanence of structure, non- roofs and floors separately. The Indian govern-
population lived in Southern Asia, followed by South-Eastern slum growth rate – on average, 5.4 per cent – is higher than the
in different cities. In Nairobi, for instance, non- hazardous location and compliance with local ment, for instance, classifies a house as pucca
Asia (11 per cent). Stark contrasts exist between Northern rest of the sub-region, where the growth of slums is already stag-
durable houses may be made of a patchwork of building codes. when the materials used both for the roof and
Africa and sub-Saharn Africa. Northern Africa hosts only 1 per geringly high, at 4.5 per cent. In other cities such as Port tin, cardboard or plastic sheeting, whereas in wall are regarded as “permanent” (burnt brick,
cent of the developing world’s urban populaton with non- Elizabeth in South Africa, lack of durable housing is surprisingly Mumbai, a temporary house may be made of In developing countries, the nature of the loca- stones, concrete, tiles, and the like). The govern-
durable housing, while sub-Saharan Africa hosts 20 per cent. high if compared with other urban agglomerations in the coun- thatch, bamboo or mud. In Moscow, Tokyo and tion and compliance with building codes are ment classifies houses as kutcha when both
try. Only 58 per cent of Port Elizabeth residents have housing other developed cities, a non-durable unit is rarely used in durability assessments. Whenever materials (roof and wall) correspond to non-per-
Housing durability in Africa considered durable, the lowest in the country. often the equivalent of a dilapidated house a developing country considers the definition of manent (temporary) materials that are replaced
In Northern Africa, housing durability is less of a concern, made of older materials, or an apartment in a durability in a more comprehensive manner, the frequently (grass, bamboo, leaves, mud, and the
Over 10 per cent of the urban population in sub-Saharan since more than 99 per cent of the total urban population lived substandard building. measurement is undertaken by integrating two like). In the cases where there is a mixture of
Africa lives in non-durable housing. Important progress in in durable houses in 2003. variables: “permanence of structure”, under both permanent and temporary materials, the
“Durable housing” is generally defined as a which the state of repair is sometimes also con- dwelling is classified as semi-pucca. (For defini-
“unit that is built on a non-hazardous location sidered; and “hazardous location”, which nor- tions refer to the National Census of India
TABLE 2.1.2 FINISHED FLOOR COVERAGE AMONG URBAN FIGURE 2.1.1 DISTRIBUTION OF THE URBAN POPULATION LACK- and has a structure permanent and adequate mally encompasses compliance with building 2001.) Moreover, very often the settlements’
POPULATION BY REGION, 2003 ING FINISHED FLOOR MATERIALS IN DEVELOPING REGIONS, 2003 enough to protect its inhabitants from the codes. However, no information is provided occupants do not have legal title to their proper-
extreme of climate conditions such as rain, heat, about the description of the area, such as road ty, allowing them to bypass the request for a
cold, and humidity”. conditions and pathways, vehicular access roads building construction permit. Houses built in a
Distribution
Urban of urban pop- and other variables of neighbourhood quality, non-authorized settlement, even if they are per-
population ulation lacking However, the permanence of housing is defined including the type of housing (i.e. detached manent, may be classified as “temporary” until
Access to Urban lacking finished main
Northern Africa by different criteria in different countries. In the houses, multi-storey buildings, and the like). the government grants security of tenure. Since
finished main population finished main floor materials
floor materials, in 2003 floor materials in developing Netherlands, the Department for Housing con- these units are produced by the informal sector,
2003 (%) (thousands) (thousands) world (%) Sub-Saharan Africa siders the number of houses that do not comply People living in poverty in cities endure a com- it is difficult to estimate the number of houses
with the local building codes but are still livable. plex array of housing conditions, the range of built every year and the quality of the structure
Latin America and the Caribbean
In the United States, information about the con- which is difficult to define and capture for sta- and materials in terms of durability.
Northern Africa 98.3 77,910 1,363 1.0 dition of housing, including the need for struc- tistical purposes. Recent migrants may utilize
Eastern Asia
Sub-Saharan Africa 89.1 251,166 27,416 20.6 tural repairs and maintenance, is obtained temporary materials – sometimes scrap – to In developed countries, “compliance with build-
Latin America and Southern Asia through self-reporting in censuses. Similarly, the build their homes and gradually improve them ing codes” is most often used as a separate
the Caribbean 98.2 417,229 7,630 5.7 Canadian government asks its citizens to assess over time. At one stage of this process, the roof variable from the hazardous location of housing.
South-Eastern Asia
Eastern Asia 98.4 564,871 9,271 7.0 the condition of their own dwellings as part of of the house may be made of permanent materi- Thus, all inhabitants of the cities of Amsterdam
Southern Asia 84.8 448,738 68,415 51.4 Western Asia its census every five years. Canadians indicate als, such as galvanized iron sheets or ceramic and Den Haag in the sub-sea level Netherlands
South-Eastern Asia 93.6 228,636 14,650 11.0 whether their dwellings require any major or tiles, while the rest of the unit is made of tem- are classified as living in a disaster-prone area;
Western Asia 96.4 124,370 4,480 3.4 minor repairs, with “major repairs” defined as porary materials. This further complicates classi- yet, their housing units can still be considered
Total 133,226 the need for “repair of defective plumbing or fications, since the same house could be consid- “durable” if the dwellings are in compliance
electrical wiring, structural repairs to walls, ered permanent, semi-permanent or temporary, with the local building codes.

Source: UN-HABITAT (2005), Urban Indicator Programme Phase III and United Nations, World Urbanization Prospects; The 2003 revision. Sources: UN-HABITAT 2003b; Planning Commission of India 2002; Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation 2005.
Note: Access to finished main floor materials was computed from Demographic and Health Surveys (DHS) data.

64 65
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7
AFGHANISTAN RASNA WARAH

Havana ©ALEX BRAMWELL. IMAGE FROM BIGSTOCKPHOTO.COM


Housing durability in Asia Apart from Haiti, no reliable data on durability is available for
the Caribbean sub-region. Haiti is notorious for having the worst
The Asian region is far from homogenous. More than half social and health indicators in the whole region but surprisingly,
inhabitants who lack durable housing in the developing world live lack of durable housing is not the most prevalent shelter depriva-
in Southern Asia, a sub-region that has among the highest preva- tion, as only 10 per cent of the urban population is estimated to
lence of slums, infant mortality and poor performance on other live in non-durable houses. In Haiti, slum dwellers suffer most
social indicators.19 Around one-third of the urban dwellers in from lack of access to improved water and sanitation – less than
Bangladesh, Nepal and Pakistan lack durable housing. One- 50 per cent of the urban population has access to either – and
tenth of the urban population in India, or around 28 million lack of sufficient living area, or overcrowding, which affects 35 had toilets and 38 per cent had access to an improved water source
FIGURE 2.1.2 PROPORTION OF URBAN HOUSEHOLDS WITH
people, are living in non-permanent structures. In Afghanistan, per cent of the urban population. in 2000, whereas in permanent houses, these ratios were 64 per
FINISHED MAIN FLOOR MATERIALS, BY REGION, 1990 AND 2003
despite some advances, housing challenges remain daunting. cent and 75 per cent, respectively.22 In addition to being inade-
Most people in the country live in extreme poverty in cities rav- quate for families’ needs, non-durable housing structures are often
aged by war; housing and physical infrastructure in most ■ Expanding the definition of “durability” situated in urban areas that lack adequate infrastructure, especially
Afghan cities need to be rebuilt.20 access roads and bridges. When emergencies happen, residents of 100

Throughout Asia, advances in housing durability have been less There is no doubt that housing durability figures for Africa, Asia such neighbourhoods may find themselves trapped and unable to
conspicuous than in other developing regions, with some second- and Latin America and the Caribbean are underestimated if the escape or call for help. In cases when help does arrive, poor access 80
ary cities in Indonesia (Bitung and Jaya Pura) experiencing impor- indicator is not widened to include the condition of floor, wall and roads and high densities in the settlement may prevent fire engines
tant improvements. In 2003, one-fifth of the Asian slum popula- roof materials combined. Methods to measure lack of durability or ambulances from reaching victims. Physical accessibility is con-
60
tion lacked durable housing – a proportion that may be higher, require further refinement to include more information regarding sidered an essential part of the durable housing indicator, but data

Percentage (%)
considering that these estimates do not include information about compliance with building codes, the hazardous location of residen- collection systems do not as yet capture this vital information,
other construction variables, such as walls and roofs. tial buildings and the condition of individual dwellings. In Brazil, including data on the surroundings of the household unit. 40

for instance, according to information provided by Munic/IBGE As part of the United Nations Expert Group on the 2010 World
Housing durability in Latin America and the in 2001, all municipalities with more than 500,000 inhabitants Programme on Population and Housing Censuses, UN-HABI- 20
Caribbean had a certain number of favelas (slums), and most of the favelas had TAT has made recommendations that census questionnaires be
houses that were non-permanent. Of the municipalities, 87 per revised and updated to include questions that address three key
0
In Latin America and the Caribbean as a whole, the number cent had non-authorized subdivisions, called loteamentos clandesti- housing durability variables:

ric n

ric n

be nd

ia

ia

As rn

ia
of non-durable houses in urban areas is relatively low. Durability nos, and 65 per cent showed different forms of inadequate hous- 1. houses in hazardous locations;23

Af her

Af ara

As

As

As
e
rib a a
a

an

ia
st
rt

ah

n
Ea
Ca ric
No

er

er

er
S
ing, including non-durable structures.21

h-
is not a determining factor of slums in the region, since more 2. building codes;24

th Ame

st

th

t
b-

es
ut
Ea

u
Su

W
So

So
tin
e
than 99 per cent of the urban population lived in houses that Studies on housing durability should be expanded to take into 3. and hazard mapping.25

La
1990 2003
were considered durable in 2003. Overcrowding remains a much account other shelter deprivation indicators as well, since non-
more significant determinant of slum households in the region. durable houses are very often associated with dwellings that lack The next round of censuses will include relevant questions to
However, serious deficits in housing durability have been report- some basic services, such as water and sanitation. In Indonesia, for obtain data on these variables to further clarify the extent of hous- Source: UN-HABITAT Urban Indicators Programme Phase III.
ed in Guatemala, Nicaragua and Peru. instance, of the non-permanent housing stock, only 28 per cent ing durability. Note: Data for 1990 not available for some regions.

66 67
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Europe’s Forgotten Roma Community


Endnotes
The Roma or Romani (meaning and in France, it is mainly Roma
Roma Settlement in Eastern Europe UN-HABITAT
“man” or “people”) have also asylum seekers from Eastern 1 US Department of Housing and Urban Development 2005. 21 Presidency of the Republic of Brazil 2004.
been called Gypsies, Tsigani, Europe and Asia who end up in 2 UN-HABITAT 2001. 22 Housing Statistics Indonesia 2000.
Tzigane, Cigano, Zigeuner – camps because of official 3 Interviews by Eduardo López Moreno with National Directors of 23 The census will gather additional information on dwellings that are
labels the Roma themselves con- unwillingness to provide proper Housing of various countries as part of the regional workshops on considered hazardous, namely: housing located in areas subject to dis-
sider derogatory. Most Roma housing for refugees. The “Training on Data and Indicators for Monitoring Progress towards the aster more than once every hundred years (disasters include flooding,
identify themselves by their squalor of these camps was Millennium Development Goals.” The countries included, among oth- earthquakes, volcano, storm surge, landslide, or avalanche); housing
tribes or groups, which include revealed in 2004 when two ers, Venezuela, Ethiopia, Indonesia, Angola, and Mexico. not adequately protected against cyclones or bushfires which occur at
the Kalderash, Machavaya, Roma girls from Romania died 4 Ayieko 2006. this frequency; housing settled on garbage mountains or dumps; hous-
Lovari, Churari, Romanichal, in a fire that destroyed the hut 5 In British Columbia, Canada, it is estimated that 20 to 25 per cent of all ing around high industrial-pollution areas; and housing around other
Gitanoes, Kalo, Sinti, Rudari, in which they slept. urban rental housing is in this form, which is 8 to 10 per cent of the total high-risk zones, including railroads, airports and energy transmission
Manush, Boyash, Ungaritza, Luri, housing stock. Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation 2005. lines.
Bashaldé, Romungro, and The European Roma 6 Scaramella 2003. 24 This will include anti-cyclonic and anti-seismic building standards,
Xoraxai. Information Office in Brussels 7 National Institute of Standards and Technology 1999. which should be based on hazard and vulnerability assessment.
has compiled reports showing 8 Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation 2005. 25 Hazard mapping is a simple and effective way of ensuring that hazards
In 1999, the United Nations that the exclusion of the Roma 9 US Census Bureau 2000. Data from the 1999 American Housing Survey. are recorded and updated on a regular basis. The maps shall cover the
Economic and Social Council from mainstream life in Europe In 2003, the American Housing Survey further found that 11 per cent of entire city and its boundaries, be available to the public and as recent
(ECOSOC) reported that the runs contrary to the norms of the total housing stock was considered as having minor technical defi- as possible (less than five years old).
majority of Roma people in European legislation and inter- ciencies.
Europe lived in the “most squalid national human rights conven- 10 In Canada, of the housing stock that needed major repairs, 39.2 per cent
and derelict housing estates” tions. In September 2002, Alvaro were houses on First Nations reserves. In the United States, the share
with sanitary facilities that were Gil-Robles, the Commissioner of households living in houses with severe problems was more than
either extremely poor on non- for Human Rights for the two times higher for blacks and Hispanic populations than white non-
existent. Since 1999, the situation has not changed much. In Council of Europe, stated that the Roma in Greece were living Hispanic populations (3.4 and 3.8 compared to 1.5). US Census Bureau
fact, according to most reports, it is getting worse. The United under conditions “very remote from what is demanded by 2000.
Nations, the World Bank, the European Commission and other respect for human dignity”. And in 2003, a World Bank report 11 In the United States, this ratio is 15.7 per cent of renter houses with
organizations have produced indicators that show that the found that “the Roma inhabit approximately 95 per cent of selected deficiencies versus 7.5 per cent of owner-occupied houses.
standard of living in Roma ghettos in Europe is appallingly the chabolas (makeshift housing and slums) around larger (US Department of Housing and Urban Development 2005.) In Canada,
low, with life expectancy rates sometimes 20 years less than cities in Spain. Approximately 80 per cent of these houses are the ratio is only 9.3 per cent versus 7.4 per cent. (Canada Mortgage and
the majority populations, unemployment rates close to 100 smaller than 50 square meters and house more than 4 people Housing Corporation 2005).
per cent, excessive school drop-out rates, and high incidence … . The lack of sanitation and running water in these areas 12 However, the Housing Statistics of Indonesia published that in 2000
of violence. Despite these indicators, such ghettos are not threatens the health of the inhabitants.” only 14 per cent of the national urban housing stock was considered
only allowed to remain, but more are being created. In fact, non-permanent. Data on floor, roof and walls requires further refine-
the construction of a wall built around one such community In Romania – which has Europe’s largest Roma population of ment. Refer to Housing Statistics Indonesia 2000.
in the Czech town of Usti nad Labem was cited by a recent approximately 2 million people (although the name Roma is 13 Planning Commission of India 2002.
report as “a single but vivid example of such ghettoization in not derived from Romania) – persecution of the Roma has 14 Observers and researchers doubt that the situation has evolved posi-
all its shocking reality”. been occurring since the mid-1800s. During World War II, the tively in recent years due to economic uncertainty and additional expen-
Nazis also slaughtered between 500,000 and 1,500,000 Roma ditures on security matters. US Library of Congress 1998.
Roma settlements in Central and Eastern Europe have during the holocaust. 15 For countries with information on the three components, regression
increased, as have the number of Roma who are forced to live equations using Demographic and Health Survey data show that the
in them. Most affected by the collapse of the Communist According to Valeriu Nicolae of the European Roma percentage of durable housing is strongly correlated with the percent-
economies, evicted because they cannot afford market rents, Information Office in Brussels, although more than 20 years age of houses with durable flooring material in Africa, Asia and Latin
the Roma often have no other choice but to settle in have passed since the European Parliament discovered in its America and the Caribbean. For the three regions the regression equa-
makeshift housing located on land no one else wants: con- 1984 report that the Roma in Europe faced societal and legal tions are statistically similar; that is, one regression equation from
taminated industrial properties or garbage sites isolated from discrimination, the 8 to 12 million Roma living in Europe are these three data sets is sufficient to estimate the durable housing from
the majority population, without public utilities such as clean still considered third-class citizens and there are few, if any, the nature of the floor whatever the region.
drinking water, electricity or waste collection. concrete actions targeting the improvement of their living 16 UN-HABITAT 2004a.
conditions. If the situation continues unabated, it is likely that 17 Martínez-Martín 2005.
In Western Europe, slum-like settlements housing Roma com- the Millennium Development Goals will not be achieved 18 UN-HABITAT 2005c.
munities can be found in Greece, Portugal and Spain. In Italy among this much-neglected community. 19 In countries such as Bangladesh, the prevalence of non-durable hous-
ing is around 50 per cent. UN-HABITAT 2005c.
Source: Nicolae 2005. 20 Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (ESCAP) 2003.

68 69
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Mexico City MARK EDWARDS/STILL PICTURES


2.2 Not Enough Room: Overcrowding in Urban Households
“This one room is my bedroom, my kitchen and my sitting room.”
Jared Odhiambo, a slum dweller in Kibera, Nairobi.1

H
aving only one room for sleeping, eating level, high residential densities can put excessive strains on
and socializing may be perfectly fine for a social services, such as medical clinics, and on schools, natu-
single person on a tight budget, but imag- ral environments and other resources.
ine managing a family of four, five or even Overcrowding is a manifestation of housing inequality that
more in an area fit for just one. Renting a results from a combination of factors. Insufficient housing
squalid, overcrowded one-roomed house or apartment is the stock and lack of affordable housing are perhaps the most
only way many low-income families around the world can prominent factors leading to overcrowding, coupled with
afford shelter at all in urban areas. Family members must market and policy situations unfavorable to low-income res-
adapt small spaces to suit their daily needs, often at the cost idents: inefficient housing markets, inadequate public and
of their privacy and health. private investment in affordable rental units and inappropri-
Recent studies of connections between housing conditions ate design of available units, among others. From a structur-
and rates of illness and child mortality have contributed to al perspective, unemployment, lack of living-wage jobs and
the growing realization that good-quality housing conditions the spatial concentration of ethnic minorities and people liv-
are essential to ensuring a healthy, productive population. ing in poverty are significant factors.
The risk of disease transmission and multiple infections
increases substantially as the number of people crowded into
small, poorly ventilated spaces increases. A study on over- ■ Global trends in overcrowding Beyond Culture: Defining Overcrowding
crowding in low-income settlements conducted by UN- The perception of overcrowding is subject to Many people, especially the poor, have few A common standard is defined by the number
HABITAT in 1995 confirmed that infectious diseases are Scholars have argued that overcrowding is a hidden form cultural definitions and is often a function of options regarding whether or not to live in of people per dwelling, per room or per bed-
likely to thrive in overcrowded and low-income households, of homelessness. People without an adequate place to live are standard dwelling unit sizes, family groupings crowded spaces. Overcrowding, therefore, can room, with some countries separating the num-
owing to lack of ventilation, lack of hygiene and exposure to often forced to search for accommodation with friends or rel- and other cultural norms. In some cultures, and be an important indicator of substandard hous- ber of individuals by age group, in which a gen-
environmental contaminants.2 The prevalence of overcrowd- atives. This can place stress on the hosts, whether tenants or among some ethnic groups, living in close quar- ing, whereas sufficient living area is a key indi- der disaggregation is fundamental.
ing in inadequate dwellings has also been linked to increases owners, making accommodation for visitors and kin even ters is preferable to living in smaller family cator for measuring adequacy of shelter. In this Overcrowding can also be defined in terms of
in negative social behaviours, such as domestic violence and groupings, or it is at least tolerated. sense, overcrowding can be an objective meas- the square meters available per person, in
more tenuous. Consequently, many people occupy dwellings
child abuse, and to negative outcomes of education and child Behavioural studies indicate that certain levels ure that transcends culture and ethnicity. As which values are determined according to the
that exceed local standards of occupancy. In Chile, “los alle-
of crowding are desirable among some groups. one of the shelter deprivation indicators, over- number of individuals.
development. Children’s education may be affected by over- gados” (people living with other families) today represent In the United States, for instance, 8 per cent of crowding expresses a normative judgment
crowding directly, owing to a lack of space to do homework slightly more than one-fourth of the country’s urban popula- high-income Asian and Hispanic groups contin- about the degree of crowding, which applies a UN-HABITAT and its partners developed an
and the disruption of sleep patterns, and indirectly, through tion.4 Chileans are clearly coping with the national housing ue to live in houses considered “overcrowded” criterion that defines a particular density as operational definition of overcrowding as one
absenteeism caused by illness arising in part from overcrowd- deficit through co-habitation instead of creating new slums. by American standards, even though they can acceptable or unacceptable. of the slum-related indicators: the “proportion
ing.3 Research has also suggested that overcrowding may lead In Australia, 58 per cent of the homeless population takes afford to enlarge their living space or move to a of households with more than two persons per
to the eviction of some tenants, since congestion increases shelter with friends or relatives for sometimes six months or larger house. Non-Hispanic and non-Asian peo- There is no basis in scientific literature for room”. This definition was developed consider-
the likelihood of property damage and may violate rental longer, surpassing the “chronic” homelessness threshold in ple with incomes comparable to those groups choosing one standard of unacceptable over- ing that reduced space and high concentration
agreements. that country.5 In Haiti, as in many other parts of the devel- experience overcrowding only half as often. crowding over another. Countries define the of people in the dwelling is often associated
In cities of the developing world, overcrowding in low- Even though it is difficult to place a value judg- crowding indicator in different ways. Some with certain health risks, so may be correlated
oping world, many individuals and families “time share” the
ment on overcrowding, given its cultural speci- developed nations apply the concept of the with slum conditions. After observing the sta-
income areas is often related to other forms of social and same house, occupying it in shifts. ficity, household surveys suggest that if given adult individual’s need for a separate bedroom, tistical distribution of more than two persons
physical deprivation. It is not just a question of parents shar- In developed countries, overcrowding as a physical housing the choice, very few people would be willing to and any value in excess of 1.0 – any bedroom per room throughout the world, UN-HABITAT
ing a bedroom with their grown-up sons and daughters, or problem has substantially decreased over time. According to share a bedroom with four or five people. used by more than one or two adults – repre- revised its definition to three persons per room.
too many people sleeping in the same room; rather, as one the UN-HABITAT definition (see box), which is based on Culture, in terms of tolerable crowding levels, sents a measure of crowding. Other countries As part of the UN-HABITAT monitoring exercise,
inhabitant living in a Nairobi slum put it, overcrowding conditions in developing countries, overcrowding is non- has some limits in that sense. determine the number of bedrooms a dwelling the indicator is described in the positive as
“takes one’s dignity away”. Living in crowded quarters inten- existent or extremely rare in most countries (less than one- should have to provide freedom from crowding. “sufficient living area”.
sifies interpersonal contact and the experience of sights, half of one per cent of the urban population). In Amsterdam,
Sources: Myers & Baer 1996; www.stats.govt.nz; UN-HABITAT 2002b.
sounds and smells – often for the worse. At the community for example, data collected by the Netherlands Department

70 71
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

for Housing indicates that less than 1 per cent of the city’s
MAP 8 PROPORTION OF HOUSEHOLDS LACKING SUFFICIENT LIVING AREA, 2003
households have more than three persons per room.
However, according to the Amsterdam housing standards cri-
teria (one person per room), 26.2 per cent of houses are over-
crowded.6 In Canada, only 0.014 per cent of households
reported having more than three persons per room.
Nonetheless, if a much higher standard is applied as per the
country’s own definition, 6.3 per cent of urban households
were below the standard in 2003.7 In many developed cities,
housing overcrowding (as per national standards) is correlat-
ed with the prevalence of ethnic minorities. In London, the
ward with the highest proportion of households with more
than one person per room is Wembley Central, a ward that
also has the highest proportion of residents of Indian origin.8
In Australia, overcrowding is approximately nine times more

Apartments in Phnom Penh ©ERIK DEGRAAF. IMAGE FROM BIGSTOCKPHOTO.COM


>40%
prevalent among the aboriginal population than it is among
>25-40%
non-indigenous people.9
>15-25%
People living in cities in developing countries, however, still
<=15%
experience high levels of overcrowding. According to UN-
HABITAT urban indicators, approximately 20 per cent of the
world’s urban population was living in inadequate dwellings, in Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Global Urban Observatory, Urban Indicators Programme, Phase III.
terms of sufficient living area, in 2003. However, the extent
and nature of this phenomenon varies among regions. In 2003,
two-thirds of the developing world’s urban population without
■ Overcrowding data by region
sufficient living area resided in Asia, half of this group lived in
Southern Asia (156 million people). Africa ranked second with
75 million people living in overcrowded conditions. Over one- Overcrowding in Africa Overcrowding in Asia
tenth of the developing world’s urban population without suf-
ficient living area (49 million people) resided in Latin America About a quarter of sub-Saharan Africa’s urban population lives In Asia, sufficient living area is poorly reported, so determin-
and the Caribbean. in overcrowded houses. Residential overcrowding is more preva- ing the actual incidence of overcrowding for the region is diffi-
lent in some cities than in others, including Addis Ababa, cult. However, some trends are beginning to emerge. Southern
Kampala and Luanda, where more than 40 per cent of the urban Asia has the highest prevalence of overcrowding in the develop-
population lives in housing that does not have sufficient living ing world, with a third of its urban population residing in hous-
TABLE 2.2.1 SUFFICIENT LIVING AREA COVERAGE AMONG FIGURE 2.2.1 DISTRIBUTION OF URBAN POPULATION LACKING
areas. Similar deficits are found in the Nigerian cities of Lagos es that lack sufficient living area, followed by South-Eastern Asia
URBAN POPULATION BY REGION, 2003 SUFFICIENT LIVING AREA, 2003
and Ibadan. Residents of Ibadan have experienced the sharpest where over a quarter of the urban population lives in overcrowd-
Distribution of decline in sufficient living area in the world: from 95 per cent of ed housing. For Eastern Asia, not enough information was avail-
urban popula-
Population tion lacking the urban population in 1990 to 70 per cent in 2003. It is likely able for analysis, and levels and trends were estimated from those
Access to Urban lacking sufficient that this phenomenon was precipitated by the disproportionate observed in South-Eastern Asia and Western Asia. Differentials
sufficient population sufficient living area in
living area, in 2003 living area developing Northern Africa
increase in the property market value during the 1990s, as a across sub-regions should therefore be examined with caution.
2003 (%) (thousands) (thousands) world (%) result of the construction of the Ibadan-Lagos expressway that An analysis of sufficient living area in this region shows that
Sub-Saharan Africa encouraged many workers in Lagos to move to Ibadan, where most of the cities and countries are facing growing trends toward
accommodation is cheaper. This influx raised the housing overcrowding. The few exceptions include the cities of Manila in
Latin America and the Caribbean
demand and increased prices, simultaneously forcing the urban the Philippines, and the cities of Istanbul, Ankara and Adana in
Northern Africa 90.5 77,910 7,429 1.9 Eastern Asia poor to find rooms in the cheapest areas of Ibadan – the inner Turkey, where urban residents slightly increased their living area.
Sub-Saharan Africa 73.1 251,166 67,629 16.8 city and peripheral slums – and increasing overcrowding rates.11 Overcrowding rates are high in various Asian cities, namely in
Southern Asia In Northern Africa, the incidence of overcrowding is 10 per
Latin America and Yangon, in Myanmar, Dhaka and Rajshahi in Bangladesh,
the Caribbean 88.2 417,229 49,176 12.2 South-Eastern Asia
cent of the urban population. However, some countries, notably Karachi, Faisalabad and Islamabad in Pakistan, and Ulan Bator
Eastern Asia 91.5 564,871 47,813 11.9 Egypt, have dramatically reduced overcrowding in the last two in Mongolia, where around 40 per cent of the urban population
Southern Asia 65.0 448,738 156,849 39.1 Western Asia decades. The cities of Cairo, Alexandria, Port Said and Suez lived in overcrowded dwellings in 2003. With the exception of
South-Eastern Asia 73.1 228,636 61,448 15.3 increased the proportion of their inhabitants with sufficient liv- Myanmar, which has the lowest proportion of slums among the
Western Asia 91.1 124,370 11,111 2.8 ing area from 70 per cent in 1990 to 95 per cent in 2003. In the least developed countries in the world (26 per cent), the other
Total 401,456 Moroccan cities of Casablanca and Rabat, the percentage of peo- nations are characterized by a high prevalence of urban dwellers
ple with sufficient living space rose from 69 per cent and 79 per living in slum conditions: Bangladesh, at 85 per cent; Pakistan,
Source: UN-HABITAT (2006), Urban Indicator Programme Phase III and United Nations, World Urbanization Prospects; The 2003 revision. cent, respectively, in 1998, to 79 per cent and 87 per cent, at 74 per cent; and Mongolia, at 65 per cent. In other countries
Note: Access to sufficient living area was computed from Demographic and Health Surveys (DHS) data. respectively, in 2003. in which the proportion of slum dwellers is high, such as Nepal

72 73
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

(56 per cent) and India (55 per cent), the incidence of over- countries, with more than two-thirds of their urban popula-
crowding is also relatively high – one-third and half of the urban tions living in slum conditions
population, respectively.12
Overcrowding in the developed world
Overcrowding in Latin America and the Caribbean
Studies carried out in developed countries confirm that over-
In Latin America and the Caribbean, information on suffi- crowding affects some specific populations more than others.
cient living area is lacking for most of the Caribbean countries Robust research evidence corroborates the fact that tenants
and many South American nations. Estimations were made are more likely live in overcrowded units than homeowners.13
using data from countries that represent just over 50 per cent In the United States, for instance, overcrowding is approxi-
of the entire region’s population. However, estimates indicate mately twice as prevalent among tenants as among owners.
that whereas the region has made significant progress in Likewise, households made up of young occupants are more
improving slums, overcrowding affects over 10 per cent of the likely to be overcrowded than households comprised of older
urban population. adults, and higher rates of overcrowding are found among
The highest levels of overcrowding in the region are found recent immigrants than other residents. Hispanic and Asian
in Central America, particularly in Guatemala and Nicaragua communities account for 8.3 per cent of all households in the
(30 and 38 per cent, respectively). Both countries had a high United States, but they represent 46.6 per cent of all over-
prevalence of slum households in their cities in 2001, at more crowded households.14
than 60 per cent, and among the highest rates of slum growth In cases in which it has been possible to adjust for con-

Kolkata, India RON GILING/STILL PICTURES


in the region between 1990 and 2001 – 2.4 per cent and 3.4 founding variables, such as tenure status, income and age, the
per cent per year, respectively – more than twice the average conclusions are clear: overcrowding is one of the most signif-
slum growth rate of the rest of the region (1.3 per cent). In icant ways in which urban poverty expresses itself. Statistical
South America, overcrowding rates were higher in Bolivia and analysis conducted by UN-HABITAT shows that overcrowd-
Peru, where around one-third of the urban populations were ing does not appear as an isolated variable, but it is very often
deprived of sufficient living space in 2003. This is not surpris- combined with other slum dimensions, such as lack of safe
ing, considering that slums remain a major challenge in both drinking water and improved sanitation.

FIGURE 2.2.2 PROPORTION OF URBAN HOUSEHOLDS WITH FIGURE 2.2.3 PROPORTION OF URBAN POPULATION WITH
SUFFICIENT LIVING AREA ACCESS TO SUFFICIENT LIVING AREA IN SELECTED CITIES, 2003

100 100

80 80

60 60
Endnotes
Percentage (%)

Percentage (%)

1 Quoted in Phombeah 2005. 10 In sub-Saharan Africa, information was obtained from countries repre-
40 40
2 UN-HABITAT 1995. senting more than 80 per cent of the region. In Latin America and the
3 United Kingdom 2005. Caribbean, data was derived from countries representing slightly more
4 Ministerio de Vivienda y Urbanismo 2004. “Allegados” in Chile may be than 50 per cent of the region. Lack of information was observed on this
20 20
a hidden form of slum-dwellers. If that is the case, national data should indicator in some sub-regions of Asia; for example, in Eastern Asia none
be revised. of the countries reported information on sufficient living area, and in other
5 Australian Bureau of Statistics 2001. sub-regions, this information was obtained from only a few countries.
0 0
6 Netherlands Department for Housing 2005. 11 Fouchard 2003.
n

ba

sa

'a

on

i
ric n

ric n

be nd

ia

ia

As rn

ia

ba

ch
Fe
ja

ol

ak
Af her

Af ara

na
As

As

As
e

ha
ba

ng
rib a a

7 Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation 2005. 12 Other countries that are characterized by having a high prevalence of
id

Pa

um

ra
a

an

ia
st

Dh
Sa
rt

Ab

ns
sA

Ya

Ka
n

rn

rn
Ea
Ca ric
Sa

M
o
No

er

Ki
he

te

Sa
h-

di
th Ame

st
b-

es
ut

slums are Afghanistan (98 per cent) and Cambodia (72 per cent); no infor-
ut

Ad

8 London Research Centre 2005.


Ea
Su

W
So

So
tin
e
La

9 Australian Bureau of Statistics 2004. In some regions, such as mation currently exists on sufficient living area for these countries.
1990 2003 Africa Latin America Asia Warburton, overcrowding stood at 50 per cent for indigenous house- 13 See, for instance, Myers & Baer 1996; and Ellaway & Macintyre 1998.
and the Caribbean holds and 2 per cent for non-indigenous households. 14 Myers & Baer 1996.
Source: UN-HABITAT Urban Indicators Programme Phase III.
Note: Data for 1990 not available for some regions. Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Urban Indicators Programme Phase III.

74 75
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

2.3 Safe Drinking Water in Cities

U
nited Nations statistics on safe drinking water
provision throughout the world indicate a
slight improvement in recent years: between
1990 and 2002, approximately 1.1 billion
people gained access to an improved source of
drinking water, an increase in global coverage from 77 per
cent to 83 per cent.1 Access to safe drinking water is, howev-
er, unevenly distributed around the globe. Significant dispar-
ities exist on several levels. First, safe drinking water is
unevenly distributed between the urban and rural popula-
Indonesia PETRUS IYAY SAPUTRA/UNEP/STILL PICTURES

tions of the world: 95 per cent of the world’s urban dwellers


have access, but only 72 per cent of the world’s rural popula-

Cebu City MARK EDWARDS/STILL PICTURES


tion has access.2 Second, per capita water consumption levels
vary widely between rich and poor nations, with the former
consuming 10 times more drinking water than the latter: 500
to 800 litres per day, compared with 60 to 150 litres per day.3
Third, asymmetries exist in water access and water manage-
ment between high-income countries experiencing low popu-
lation growth and low-income countries facing rapid popula-
tion growth and water scarcity problems. And fourth, there
are extreme differences in the quantity and quality of water
that rich and poor households can obtain within the same city
in different parts of the world. some countries, people suffering from waterborne diseases Drinking water supply is often intermittent even in neigh-
Some of the disparities in drinking water provision are occupy a high proportion of hospital beds – as in India, where FIGURE 2.3.1 WATER EXPENSE AS A FRACTION OF HOUSEHOLD bourhoods where people have water pipes and taps inside their
clear, but others – particularly intra-city differences in access 65 per cent of hospital patients are being treated for water- INCOME IN ADDIS ABABA, 2003 houses. In the coastal city of Mombasa in Kenya, a study found
and consumption – are less evident, as they are often dis- related illnesses at any given time.7 Many people also spend 20
that very few parts of the city had continuous water supply; on
guised by aggregated urban data that averages out quantity large proportions of their incomes on the treatment of water- average, water was available for less than 3 hours per day, and
and quality of water among those having access to safe water related diseases. In sub-Saharan Africa, for instance, people in some parts of the city, pipes had not been functional for sev-
and those who are frequently deprived. This results in a sin- living in poverty spend at least one-third of their incomes on eral years.10 In other instances, such as in Dhaka, Bangladesh,
gle, and misleading, estimate of access to safe drinking water treatment of water-borne and water-related diseases, such as 15
slum dwellers complain that the agency that provides water

Ratio of water expense to income (%)


in a city. diarrhoea and malaria.8 The facts suggest that the drinking supply and sewerage only makes functional water connections
Current United Nations statistics, which use aggregated water available to people living in poverty is frequently inad- available to land owners, not tenants in slums.11
data, confidently report that 95 per cent of the world’s urban equate or contaminated. Water is, therefore, not as safe as it appears according to sta-
population has “improved” water provision (see box). At least Although most statistics reflect better drinking water cover- 10 tistics, nor is it supplied in high enough quantities to all
12 countries with low or middle income levels even report age in urban areas than in rural areas, various surveys show households, thus compelling many families to find more
that they have 100 per cent coverage.4 More than 15 coun- that in many cities, the quantity and quality of water available water from other sources that are less reliable. Differing defi-
tries that perform poorly on a number of health indicators to low-income residents falls short of acceptable standards. nitions, technical measurement problems and political
linked to living conditions also report that their national Hundreds of millions of people who supposedly have access 5 unwillingness to report accurate data prevent the existing
water coverage is above the world’s urban average (95 per to water only have access to communal pipes with intermit- water access issues among people in cities from being cap-
cent)5; and 44 countries (18 in Africa, 12 in Asia and 14 in tent water supply shared by hundreds, or even thousands, of tured for statistical purposes. The need to acknowledge differ-
Latin America and the Caribbean), each with slum popula- people. In the lowest-income areas, people also pay more for ential access and the problems associated with it is urgent:
tions representing at least one-fourth of their total urban pop- water than their wealthier neighbours. UN-HABITAT urban 0 nearly half of the urban populations in Africa, Asia, and Latin
ulations, report that water coverage is almost universal – as indicators show that in 2003 in Jakarta, for example, only 29 First Second Third Fourth Fifth America suffer from one or more of the communicable dis-
high as 90 per cent.6 per cent of the households were connected to piped water in (Poorest) (Richest) eases associated with inadequate water and sanitation provi-
Yet, millions of people living in these countries suffer from their dwellings; 19 per cent used private wells as a second Source: UN-HABITAT, Addis Ababa Urban Inequity Survey 2003.
sion.12 Too often, the myriad issues associated with lack of
waterborne diseases, indicating that they do not have ade- source of water; and 7 per cent purchased water from vendors, Note: Based on wealth of households, households divided equally into five groups, safe drinking water go unrecognized by the development
quate access to safe drinking water as officially reported. In who charged several times more than the official price.9 First (Poorest), Second, Third, Fourth and Fifth (Richest). community. Clearly, however, lack of safe water kills. The

76 77
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

“Improved” or “Adequate” Access to Water: Definitions and Issues of Measurement


As part of its strategy to monitor slum improvement, At least 20 liters per person should be available intermittent supply of water. Definitions of services
UN-HABITAT included inadequate access to safe within an acceptable timespan (defined locally). This and access vary not only among the different types MAP 9 PROPORTION OF HOUSEHOLDS WITHOUT ACCESS TO IMPROVED WATER, 2003
drinking water as one of five shelter deprivation is a variation from the original WHO/UNICEF defini- of surveys undertaken, but also over time. It is
indicators. Lack of access to improved water facili- tion, which indicates that water should be available therefore sometimes difficult to compare surveys
ties and lack of access to improved sanitation are within one kilometer of the residence; the definition undertaken even within the same country. In addi-
coincident with the other indicators of slum house- was changed to accommodate data collection in tion, people often use more than one water source,
holds – housing durability, overcrowding and secure high-density urban areas. Some data collectors and it is difficult to ascertain the quality, accessibili-
tenure – and together account for the identification count all residents with a water source within 200 ty, reliability, and cost of each, and whether its use
of most slum households. meters of their home as having access to water, but, is a problem.
as UN-HABITAT has found in further research, that
To measure access to safe drinking water, UN-HABI- having a tap within 200 meters of a dwelling in a United Nations estimates do not as yet consider the
TAT adopted the definition of “improved” water sup- rural settlement with 200 people using it is not the quality and affordability of water services. UN-
ply developed by the WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring same as having a public tap within 200 meters of a HABITAT is in the process of refining survey ques-
Programme for Water and Sanitation. The definition dwelling in an urban squatter settlement with 5,000 tions on access to improved water through the
is widely accepted and is backed by a long history people using it. application of Urban Inequities Surveys, within the
of data collection in developing countries. framework of the Monitoring Urban Inequities
The WHO/UNICEF definition was designed to meas- Programme. The new questions will appear on
Definition: The water should be affordable and at ure water access in rural contexts and does not nec- household surveys regularly administered by UN-
sufficient quantity that is available without exces- essarily provide a suitable definition for research in HABITAT’s partner agencies.
sive effort and time. urban areas. Urban settlements have particular
needs for water that are distinct from rural areas, Gender issues in safe water access, child access to
Indicator: The proportion of households with yet it is still common to refer to “improved” and facilities and the number of households using the
access to improved water supply with: same facility are other important issues to consider <5%
“adequate” access to water interchangeably in both
>5-12%
• Household connection urban and rural settlements. These terms cannot in urban water research. UN-HABITAT is now work-
>12-50%
• Public standpipe shared by a maximum of two capture the full extent of two different realities: ing with the WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring
households Programme to harmonize and standardize indicators >50%
rural and urban.
• Borehole well and methodologies, in order to match definitions
• Protected spring “Improved” water provision is often no more than a and methods of measurement to produce data com- Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Global Urban Observatory, Urban Indicators Programme, Phase III.
• Rainwater collection public tap shared by several hundred people with an parable across countries and cities.

root of this unrelenting catastrophe is well known13: people cent); in Africa, 7 per cent rely on manual pumps, and in
are not getting sufficient quantity and quality of water that is Latin America and the Caribbean, 5 per cent use them.
affordable and available without having to invest excessive TABLE 2.3.1 IMPROVED DRINKING WATER COVERAGE AMONG FIGURE 2.3.2 DISTRIBUTION OF URBAN POPULATION LACKING
effort and time. URBAN POPULATION BY REGION, 2003 IMPROVED DRINKING WATER BY REGION, 2003
UN-HABITAT data on urban indicators collected in 2003 ■ Global trends
provides the distribution of households by major source of
drinking water at the national, urban agglomeration and The world has made important progress in increasing access to Distribution of
slum/non-slum levels. Analysis of the data at each level reveals safe drinking water. Despite this increase, however, the total num- urban popula-
Urban Population tion lacking
that getting water from a tap is a luxury enjoyed by only two- ber of people who gained access to improved water sources Access to safe Population lacking safe safe water in
third of the world’s urban population. In 2003, 62 per cent of remained stable at approximately 17 per cent, owing to global water source, 2003 water developing Northern Africa
2003 (%) (thousands) (thousands) world (%)
all city dwellers had access to piped water, 46 per cent of population growth.15
Sub-Saharan Africa
whom had water piped into the dwelling and 16 per cent of Data collected by the WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring
whom had a water tap in the yard or plot. Public taps serviced Programme provides additional information on access of the Northern Africa 94.9 77,910 3,960 2.4 Latin America and the Caribbean
10.4 per cent of the urban residents, and 8 per cent had access world’s urban population to safe drinking water. The share of the Sub-Saharan Africa 82.0 251,166 45,210 27.6
to manually pumped water or protected wells.14 urban population with access to improved water sources remained Latin America and Eastern Asia

UN-HABITAT data reveals important inter-regional differ- stable from 1990 to 2002 at 95 per cent. The Joint Monitoring the Caribbean 95.2 417,229 20,166 12.3 Southern Asia
ences in the way urban residents in the developing world gain Programme counts access to all types of improved water sources Eastern Asia 92.5 564,871 42,365 25.9
access to safe water. In 2003, Latin America and the that are protected from external contamination, including piped Southern Asia 94.3 448,738 25,428 15.5 South-Eastern Asia
Caribbean has the highest proportion of urban households household connections, public standpipes, boreholes, hand-dug South-Eastern Asia 91.0 228,636 20,577 12.6
Western Asia
dependent on piped water sources (89.3 per cent) and sub- wells, springs, and rainwater collection.16 However, the number Western Asia 95.1 124,370 6,115 3.7
Saharan Africa has the lowest (38.3 per cent). In Africa, 20 of people without access to improved water will double between Total 163,822
per cent of the urban population cites public water taps as a 1990 and 2010, increasing from 108 million to 215 million.
primary source of drinking water – twice the world’s average Widespread inter-regional differences in water access exist,
– while in Latin America and the Caribbean, only 2 per cent though these asymmetries began to conform around higher cov-
of residents depend on public taps. Asia has the highest pro- erage in the 1990s, particularly in urban areas. An outline of water Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Urban Indicator Programme Phase III and United Nations, World Urbanization Prospects; The 2003 revision.
portion of people using manually pumped water (12 per access trends in the major regions of the world follows. Note: Access to safe water was computed from data of WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and Sanitation.

78 79
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Phnom Penh MIKE KOLLOFFEL/STILL PICTURES


■ Water in Africa Democratic Republic of the Congo, the proportion is 14.4 per
cent.19 Lack of water source improvement is bound to continue
Africa has the lowest safe drinking water coverage, with only affecting health, education, productivity, and income generation
64 per cent of the total population having access to an improved throughout the sub-region.
water supply – that, is water that is affordable and of sufficient In Northern Africa, access to safe water in urban areas was
quantity, and available without the investment of excessive time almost universal in 2002, at 96 per cent. In this sub-region, the
or effort. The situation is much worse in rural areas, where cov- urban population is expected to increase slowly and the number
erage is only 50 per cent, than in urban areas, where coverage is of people living in slums should decline. It is more likely that the
about 85 per cent.17 In global terms, 29 per cent of the world’s reduction in the number of slum dwellers will aid the sub-
urban population without access to improved water supply lives region’s performance on the other slum indicators, particularly
in Africa. overcrowding and sanitation, than on the water indicator, as
In 2003, 82 per cent of sub-Saharan Africa’s urban population other shelter deprivations are more prevalent than access to safe
had access to an improved drinking water supply – a smaller pro- water. Additional government efforts are required to reach the
portion than urban dwellers in any developing region in the remaining 4 per cent of the population that lacks access to an
world. In 2002, only 45 per cent of rural sub-Saharan Africans improved water source. Those who still lack safe drinking water
had access to safe water. The sub-region as a whole did not expe- may be more difficult to reach because their communities are
rience any changes in the coverage levels during the 12 years physically isolated from others and their pervasive poverty limits
between 1990 and 2002, remaining at 82 per cent throughout.18 their ability to improve their own facilities.
In some countries, however, urban populations are grossly under- Data on piped water connections in urban areas reveal con-
served. In Cape Verde, Eritrea, Niger and Rwanda, only one- trasting histories in Africa as a whole. In Northern Africa, piped
third of the urban population had access to an improved water water coverage increased from 83 per cent in 1990 to 96 per cent
source in 2001. in 2003, due in large part to significant improvements in
Lack of access to piped water affects some cities within the sub- Egyptian and Moroccan cities. Despite an acute shortage of
region more than others. Some capital cities have had particular- water in the sub-region, most residents of its cities and rural areas
ly low coverage, including Kampala, Uganda, at 15.1 per cent, enjoy regular, affordable piped water access. The data from
and Kigali, Rwanda, at 35 per cent. Moreover, the proportion of Northern Africa supports the theory that the world’s “water cri- es 79 per cent in urban areas. Impressive growth has taken
households having access to piped water in Central and Western sis” is more of a political and governance crisis than a physical place in several Indian cities, namely in Hyderabad, Amritsar, TABLE 2.3.2 CITIES MAKING RAPID PROGRESS IN DRINKING
scarcity crisis.20 Akola and Hisar, where access to improved water sources WATER COVERAGE, 1999 -2003
African capital cities is much lower than the sub-region’s average,
particularly in Luanda, Angola (13.1 per cent); Yaoundé, increased from 48 per cent to 86 per cent between 1990 and
Cameroon (33.5 per cent); Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso (33.8 2003. The most impressive gains were recorded in the city of Cities that increased coverage by
at least 15% between 1990 and 2003
per cent); and Conakry, Guinea (39.2 per cent). Access to piped ■ Water in Asia Hai Phong, Viet Nam, which provided improved water
water in some secondary African cities is even worse: in Nazret, sources to twice as many people from 46.4 per cent of the
Ethiopia, the proportion is 16 per cent; and in Butembo, Asia accounts for two-thirds of the world’s population that urban population in 1990 to 99.6 percent in 2002. Drinking Water
Coverage (%) % increase
lacks safe water: 670 million people in both rural and urban City/Country 1990 2003 1990-2003
areas.21 In urban areas, coverage is over 90 per cent in most
FIGURE 2.3.3 ACCESS TO PIPED WATER IN SELECTED CITIES IN sub-regions, but poor access to water facilities in urban areas ■ Water in Latin America and the Caribbean
SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA, 2003 Kigali, Rwanda 72.7 84.5 16
is reported in various countries, particularly in Cambodia,
where only 58 per cent of people living in cities have access to Water coverage estimates based on data from the Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso 77.5 94.3 22
40
an improved water source and Lao People’s Democratic WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme suggest that 95
35 Republic, where 66 per cent have access. The most impressive per cent of the urban population and 69 per cent of the rural Fortaleza, Brazil 68.9 93.7 36
30
gains in access to improved water sources were made in population in Latin America and the Caribbean had access to
Goiânia, Brazil 85.7 98.8 15
Access to piped water (%)

Southern Asia’s cities fuelled primarily by increased coverage improved drinking water sources in 2002. Today, around 20
25
in India from 88 per cent in 1990 to 96 per cent in 2002. million people in the region’s urban areas are without access to Tijuana,Mexico 67.8 98.2 45
20 The proportion of the population with access to an improved water supply. While most countries in the region have
improved water source in urban areas in Asia is very high – 93 over 90 per cent coverage in urban areas, some countries have Agartala, India 79.2 99.6 26
15
per cent – as reported by the water utilities and ministries in relatively low coverage: Anguilla (60 per cent), Argentina (85
Bitung, Indonesia 73.6 97.7 33
10 charge of drinking water services. Piped water is more pre- per cent), Belize (83 per cent), Dominican Republic (83 per
cious, since only 70 per cent of the Asian urban population cent), Ecuador (81 per cent), El Salvador (85 per cent), Jamaica Cebu, Philippines 66.5 98.3 48
5
had access to it in 2002, approximately half of whom had (81 per cent), Haiti (49 per cent), Panama (88 per cent), Peru Da Nang, Viet Nam 84.7 96.6 15
0
access to a working tap within the dwelling. The heterogene- (88 per cent) and Venezuela (88 per cent). In Haiti less than half Jaya Pura, Indonesia 47.1 94.1 100
Co . o

ne y

da i

ol a

O iop th

Fa ou

oo é
nd la

an al
ui kr
e ep b

ng nd

er nd
th re

of the urban population has access to an improved water source.


ga pa

w Kig

ity of the region is made clear by the contrasts observed in the


th m.R tem

a ug
ng of

a)

a)

(B uag ia)

n)
(G ona

a)

so
(A ua

am u
(E aza
(U am

kin do
o)
e u

Metro Manilla, Philippines 83.8 96.9 16


C

(C oaY
(D B

ur a
K

level of piped water coverage in the different sub-regions. By Figures on piped water in the region are available only for
(R

far the lowest proportion of people having access to piped major cities in a few countries: Brazil, Colombia and Rajahmundry, India 83.6 99.6 19
Source: UN-HABITAT, Global Urban Observatory, Urban Indicators Programme Phase III. connections in urban areas is found in South-Eastern Asia, Guatemala. On average, urban areas in the three countries had
Note: Data based on Demographic and Health Surveys in various years. with just 45 per cent, whereas coverage in Western Asia reach- some of the highest levels of piped water connections in the Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Urban Indicator Programme Phase III.

80 81
MILOON KOTHARI
WATER AND SANITATION: ONLY A HUMAN RIGHTS APPROACH WILL DO
developing world in 2003, with the Colombian cities of
Economic globalization policies – part of a global structural adjustment assessing the impact of globalization on not only the right to adequate hous- Bogotá, Medellin, Neiva, and Valledupar reporting universal Endnotes
agenda that finds its most boisterous proponents among the wealthy ing in particular, but in a broader sense on the extent of States’ compliance coverage. Slightly less than two-thirds – 71 per cent – of the
nations of the world – have lent momentum to an ongoing movement with their legal obligations under various international and human rights households included in the data had piped connections in their 1 WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and
toward privatization and commodification of basic services, such as water treaties and guidelines. By transforming a basic social service and scarce homes, with the remaining third using a tap in the yard or plot. Sanitation 2004.
and sanitation. This phenomenon, now widely assumed to be irreversible, resource into an economic commodity, the world’s economic and policy plan- 2 Ibid.
coupled with the inability of governments to provide their citizens with ners are operating under the myopic macroeconomic assumption that exist- 3 UNEP 2003.
affordable access to such services, tends to have a disproportionately ing water resources can be managed and consumed efficiently in accordance ■ Understanding access to safe drinking water in 4 These countries are: Andorra, Barbados, Belize, Botswana, Chile,
severe impact on those most vulnerable segments of the population, the with competitive market principles. Let us not be naïve. A consideration of urban areas: The case of Addis Ababa Costa Rica, Dominica, Egypt, Lebanon, Paraguay, Ukraine, and
poor and socially marginalized. the three major criticisms of privatization will readily dispel any notion that Zimbabwe. (WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water
the basis of such an assertion is to be found in reality: private businesses put UN-HABITAT is working on refining the methodology used Supply and Sanitation 2004.)
Water, essential to human life and all life on the planet, is part of the glob- too much emphasis on profits and cost recovery; services to vulnerable to measure access to “improved water supply”. An urban 5 These countries are Albania, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Bolivia, Colombia,
al commons and arguably the most quintessential of all collective groups are inadequate and of poor quality; and private operators are not inequities survey conducted in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, showed Côte d’Ivoire, Dominican Republic, Gabon, Guatemala, Honduras,
resources. It is not a private commodity to be bought, sold or traded for accountable to the public. What’s more, the lack of capacity, or willingness, that if the indicator includes variables for measuring the propor- Kazakhstan, Malawi, Namibia, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, and Uzbekistan.
profit – an exclusive luxury accessible to a few and elusive to the majority. on the part of States to regulate the operations of private providers only mag- tion of people with access to safe water that is affordable, provid- (WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and
This fundamental principle is clearly articulated in the General Comment nifies the above outlined shortcomings of privatization. ed in sufficient quantity and does not require excessive time or Sanitation 2004).
No.15 (2002) of the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, effort to acquire, the number of urban dwellers without sufficient 6 UN-HABITAT 2005c.
which says that: There is an acute need to strengthen participatory monitoring mechanisms, access is much higher than officially acknowledged (see figure). 7 The Virtual Water Forum Final Report, 3rd World Water Forum, March
as processes of privatization are extremely difficult to reverse once imple- Statistics collected by the Government of Ethiopia in Addis 2003: http://www.worldwaterforum.org.
“Water should be treated as a social and cultural good,” and that “invest- mented, and corporations enjoy formidable legal recourse through multilat- Ababa, for instance, report that 88.5 per cent of the urban pop- 8 Hansen & Bathia 2004.
ments should not disproportionately favour expensive water supply servic- eral trade agreements. Consequently, the expansion of any such agree- ulation has improved water provision;24 however, UN- 9 UN-HABITAT 2005c.
es and facilities that are often accessible only to a small, privileged frac- ments, such as the World Trade Organization General Agreement on Trade HABITAT’s study, as part of its Monitoring Urban Inequities 10 Rakodi, et al. 2000.
tion of the population, rather than investing in services and facilities that Services (GATS), which led to the privatization of social services and the Programme (MUIP), demonstrated that the proportion of 11 Civil Society submission to the Government of Bangladesh for the
benefit a far larger part of the population.” entry of corporations into the arena of providing social goods such as water, urban residents with an improved water supply can drop to 21.3 development of the “National Strategy for Economic Growth, Poverty
will only serve to exacerbate an already adverse situation. The right to an per cent if the operational definition that includes ease of access Reduction and Social Development”, Poverty Reduction Strategy
The human rights of people and communities to housing, water and sanita- effective remedy for anyone whose rights have been violated cannot be con- is combined with variables on sufficient quantity, affordability Paper. Bangladesh, 2003.
tion – long recognized as indivisible, and guaranteed under international tracted away by the State nor denied by the operations of intergovernmen- and time required to collect it.25 The same study demonstrated 12 World Health Organization 1999.
law – continue to be eroded as the processes of privatization become more tal institutions. Investment or trade bodies should not adjudicate concerns that when data is disaggregated at intra-city levels, massive dis- 13 Bartram, et al. 2005.
entrenched and quicken in pace. While the promise of economic globaliza- that fall firmly within the ambit of human rights as if they were simply dis- parities are apparent. Official statistics belie the actual condi- 14 The remaining percentage, 18.8 per cent, could not be described with
tion to help alleviate want and reduce poverty may exist in the abstract, its putes between corporations and state actors. Any violation should, and tions under which people in poverty live. In Addis Ababa, the a single variable, owing to differences in definitions and methods of
basis on the Washington Consensus and reliance on a theory of presumed must, be dealt with through the relevant human rights enforcement mecha- survey showed that the proportion of non-slum urban house- computation. UN-HABITAT Urban Indicators Programme Phase III,
trickle-down benefits find little basis in history. The time has come to nisms that seek the integration of human rights obligations into national and holds with access to safe water was almost two times higher than 2005.
rethink current global economic and social policies, and the perverse and international policy making, thereby establishing a clear and positive prece- the proportion of slum households with access to safe water. 15 UNFPA 2003.
brutalized neo-liberal logic that underpins them, and reaffirm our commit- dent for the future. 16 UN-HABITAT 2005c.
ment to the human rights principles and standards that offer the only real FIGURE 2.3.4 ACCESS TO WATER DECREASES DRAMATICALLY WHEN 17 WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and
paradigm for improving the lives of millions of the poor. Of equal or greater importance is the need for sustained vigilance at each COST AND QUALITY ARE CONSIDERED: THE CASE OF ADDIS ABABA Sanitation 2000. The percentage reported by on water supply cover-
stage of this protracted campaign, to actively safeguard against the collater- age in urban areas is 85 per cent, while according to UN-HABITAT’s
100
The consequences of having inadequate or no access to water, while uni- al erosion of other human rights during the ongoing effort to achieve the urban indicators, this percentage is 89 per cent.
versally devastating, tend to be more acutely felt by women and children. Goals. The effort at improving the living conditions of some, by way of slum 18 UN-HABITAT 2005c.
80
When water is not readily available, it is principally women and children upgrading projects, for example, must not lead to the breach of human rights 19 Secretariat of the Third World Water Forum, 2003.
20 Hansen & Bathia 2004.
Percentage (%)
who are charged with the burdensome responsibility of its collection, often of others, such as through forced eviction or the now rampant phenomenon 60

expending inordinate amounts of time and energy in the process. This has of land-grabbing in all of its forms. 21 WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and
a detrimental impact on their health, security and education. While the lack 40 Sanitation 2000.
of sanitation facilities affects both men and women alike, sanitation needs A human rights approach must both inform the normative discussion, as well 22 UN-HABITAT 2005c.
20 23 WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and
and demands tend to differ as a function of gender. Women have particular as guide the processes surrounding efforts to achieve the Millennium
needs and concerns of privacy, dignity and personal safety, and the lack of Development Goals. Such a strategy, coupled with existing international Sanitation 2004.
0
sanitation facilities in the home can force women and girls to use secluded human rights treaties, declarations and guidelines, provides a framework 24 Addis Ababa City Council 2004.
Ke da
a
Ak B ka
Ne i Ka e
fa liti
ilk

et a
a
Ak B ka
e
fa liti
ilk

et a
a
Ak B ka
Ne i Ka e
fa liti
ilk
m

ak ol

s K ad
em

ak ol

s K ad
em

ak ol
sS

sS

sS
Ye

Ye

Ne Ka

Ye
is Ara
te

di Ar 25 UN-HABITAT 2004b.

di Ar
places, often at great distance from the home, thereby exposing them to through which the formulation of responsible economic policies for the ben-

i
d
Ad

Ad

Ad
heightened risk of sexual abuse. Furthermore, lack of accessible basic serv- efit of humankind can become a reality.
ices can often lead to or further exacerbate tense and stressful relations By neighborhood in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
within the home, increasing women’s vulnerability to domestic violence.
Access to improved water
Access to improved water when cost is factored in
Privatization of water and sanitation services warrants close scrutiny when Miloon Kothari is the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Adequate Housing. Access to improved water when cost and quality are factored in

Source: UN-HABITAT, Addis Ababa Urban Inequity Survey 2003.

83
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

2.4 The Silent Tsunami: Improved Sanitation: A Basic Principle


The High Price of Inadequate Sanitation in Urban Areas A household is considered to have access to
“improved” sanitation if it has a human
pit latrines, allowing for acceptable local
technologies.
basic sanitation approach that focuses on
securing sustainable access to safe, hygienic
excreta disposal system, either in the form of and convenient facilities for human excreta
a private toilet or a public toilet shared by a Sanitation is not simply about disposal of disposal. The first, and least expensive, step
maximum of two households. In urban areas, human waste. It is a broad concept that toward a more broadly integrated sanitation
access to improved sanitation is defined by encompasses the safe removal, disposal and system in any community, improved sanitation
direct connection to a public, piped sewer; management of solid household waste, includes the need for privacy, safety, hygiene
direct connection to a septic system; or access wastewater, industrial waste and the like. and convenience.
to pour-flush latrines or ventilated improved “Improved” sanitation, however, refers to a

■ Linking inadequate sanitation and health eases, particularly among the sick and children.4 In 77 per cent
of the 144 cases in the WHO study, positive health benefits in
Globally, an estimated 2.6 billion people lack toilets and the form of reduced incidence of diarrhoea could be definitive-
other forms of improved sanitation. UN-HABITAT analyses ly attributed to improvements in sanitation systems, whereas
reveal that while the world’s cities have made significant only 48 per cent could be attributed to improvements in the
progress in improving people’s access to water, access to water supply. Another multi-country study confirmed that it is
improved sanitation lags far behind, particularly in sub- possible to obtain a reduction of up to 37 per cent in cases of
Saharan Africa, Southern Asia and Eastern Asia, where the pro- diarrhoea when access to improved sanitation facilities is pro-
portion of the urban population having access in 2003 was only vided to unserved populations.5
55 per cent, 67 per cent and 69 per cent respectively. Lack of sanitation is not always a top priority among people
Lack of access to an adequate toilet not only violates the dig- living in poverty, whose needs for drinking water and sufficient
nity of the urban poor, but also affects their health. Urban food often take precedence. Poor sanitation is perceived as
poverty is often related to poor hygiene – the result of inade- “tomorrow’s priority” even if it has life-threatening conse-
quate sanitation facilities combined with an inadequate or quences. Thus, slum dwellers in some African cities resort to
unsafe water supply. Every year, hundreds of thousands of peo- disposal of excreta in plastic bags, which then get discarded
ple die as a result of living conditions made unhealthy by lack carelessly in drainage channels, rubbish bins or in the streets of
of clean water and sanitation options. The number of deaths the neighbourhood itself. These so-called “flying” toilets in
attributable to poor sanitation and hygiene alone may be as Nairobi or “mobile” toilets in Lusaka have negative health con-
high as 1.6 million per year – five times as many people who sequences that are not often apparent to the inhabitants. Low
died in the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami. Inadequate sanitation priority accorded to sanitation is also manifested by the fact
is therefore something of a “silent tsunami” causing waves of ill- that a limited number of households having latrines make
Ecuador T. NEBBIA/UNEP/STILL PICTURES

ness and death, especially among children. Although appropriate use of them, and an even smaller number maintain
Millennium Development Goal 7, target 10, aims to halve the them properly. For instance, a study conducted in Zambia,
proportion of people without access to safe drinking water and Zimbabwe and South Africa showed that only 17 per cent of
basic sanitation by 2020, the relationship between water and the population maintain their latrines properly.6 There is clear-
sanitation is very often ignored when allocating resources; for ly a strong need to link sanitation and hygiene to education,
every dollar invested in water supply, only 20 cents goes toward awareness-raising and cultural attitudes toward waste disposal.
the provision of basic sanitation.1 This explains the huge gap Attributing unhygienic practices only to lack of concern
between water and sanitation coverage in the world: 83 per about inadequate sanitation, however, can misguide analysis
cent of the world’s residents have access to safe drinking water, and conclusions. Poverty and deprivation also play key roles.

S
ince 350 B.C., when the Greek philosopher Aristotle intrusion and observation around their most private affairs and but only 58 per cent have access to improved sanitation.2 For instance, residents of the neighbourhood of Mbare in
posited a distinction between the public sphere of habits; they are much less likely than their wealthier neighbours Research has made it clear that those without access to ade- Harare, Zimbabwe, prefer to defecate wherever possible in the
political activity and the private sphere associated to have access to safe sanitation facilities behind closed doors. quate sanitation are more exposed to diseases than other groups open because their pour-flush toilets are overused and poorly
with family and domestic life, debates about the The absence of decent toilets in impoverished neighbourhoods experiencing lack of safe water and other shelter deprivations. maintained. In that community, up to 1,300 people share one
right to privacy have dominated popular discourse. violates residents’ right to privacy and is an affront to their dig- They are 1.6 times more likely to experience diarrhoea, and communal toilet with only six squatting holes, most of which
In today’s world, privacy is increasingly determined by individ- nity. Being deprived of adequate sanitation facilities is the most they have consistently higher rates of morbidity and mortality.3 are no longer flushable.7 In Nepal, two-thirds (67 per cent) of
uals’ power and social status: the rich can withdraw from soci- direct and most dehumanizing – but least often acknowledged This has been amply demonstrated by several studies, includ- the country’s population defecates in the open despite the fact
ety whenever they wish, but those living in poverty cannot so – consequence of poverty. ing a 1996 study by the World Health Organization (WHO) that half of them have access to latrines; they consider the exist-
easily escape their neighbours’ gaze. This is particularly true More than 25 per cent of the developing world’s urban pop- in Asia, which concluded that sanitation and hygiene are ing latrines unsanitary and unsafe.8 In many countries, children
with regard to sanitation. People living in poverty are subject to ulation lacks adequate sanitation. among the most influential factors in reducing diarrhoeal dis- are afraid or reluctant to use latrines because they are perceived

84 85
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Defining Sanitation: To estimate or to underestimate, that is the question.


Getting a clear picture of the global sanitation sit- ces and can be used by all family members, includ- that fall into disrepair. This explains why some of
uation is complicated by the variety of terminolo- ing children over the age of 5 years. the data from individual countries shows rapid and
gies used for data collection. An individual or a implausible changes in coverage from one assess-
household can have access to “adequate” or Differences in definitions and data reporting meth- ment to the next.
“improved” sanitation depending on the definition ods make direct comparisons difficult. Some coun-
used. Studies indicate that between 850 and 1.13 tries have higher standards for defining adequate UN-HABITAT is working with the WHO/UNICEF
billion people worldwide lacked “adequate” sani- sanitation services, excluding ordinary pit latrines, Joint Monitoring Programme to standardize defini-
tation, whereas about 400 million people lacked or counting only ventilated improved pit latrines or tions to allow for more accurate global compar-
“improved” sanitation in 2004. These figures refer flush toilets connected to a septic tank or sewer- isons. Based on UN-HABITAT suggestions that
to the sanitation hardware, or technologies, used, age system. In Uganda, for example, pit latrines are most of the simple pit latrines and traditional
including sewerage systems, toilets and hygienic counted as sanitary, and the latest Demographic latrines in use in cities are in fact unsanitary, the
latrines. More accurate estimations should also and Health Survey shows 80 per cent of house-
data has been revised for 2004. Figures for people
consider the software, or the hygiene conditions, holds with access. But, if pit latrines are not count-
without adequate sanitation have thus changed
as well, such as maintenance of latrines and provi- ed, the population with access shrinks to a mere 3
from 2.4 to 2.6 million worldwide. The
sion of hand-washing facilities. per cent. These variations in standards make the
WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme agreed
quality of the data questionable in some countries.
to reduce by half the share of the population with
Monitoring adequate or improved sanitation is fur- For instance, in Zambia, one of the least developed

Manila HARTMUT SCHWARZBACH/UNEP/STILL PICTURES


adequate access who use traditional, pit or simple
ther complicated by the fact that “access” assumes countries, more than 87 per cent of the population
the use of the facilities; yet, in many locations, has access to adequate sanitation, while Brazil, a latrines. For instance, the Government of Burkina
facilities are not being used. A family may have middle-income country that is far wealthier and Faso reported that 54 per cent of the urban popu-
access as defined for purposes of the indicator, but much more developed than Zambia, reports access lation had access to improved sanitation. However,
may fail to use the facility for practical, cultural, or of only 83 per cent. Furthermore, data from surveys out of this percentage 84 per cent, had access to
social reasons. Defining “use” of the facilities, and routine reports can also have significant dis- pit latrines, only half of which (42 per cent) were
therefore, can be nuanced to “convenient use”. In crepancies, because some government reports rely counted as improved sanitation. These changes
Nepal, for instance, the government considers a on outdated data that fails to take into account were made in order to facilitate inter-regional
“functioning latrine” as one that is kept free of fae- new informal settlements and sanitation facilities comparisons across time.

Sources: Hansen & Bathia 2004; UK Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology; Bendohmme & Swindde 1999; UNICEF 1997; UN-HABITAT 2005c.

as dark, dirty, unsafe, or smelly. In many places, latrines are not cent (1.98 billion) lived in Asia; 18 per cent (470 million) lived accounts for the largest numbers of people without sanitation Sanitation, hygiene and
available at all. Today, one out of every three children in the in Africa; and 5 per cent (130 million) lived in Latin America nearly 400 million people. Afghanistan has by far the lowest pro- health are interconnected
developing world do not have access to a toilet of any kind in and the Caribbean (see box on definition).10 portion of the urban population with access to improved sanita-
the vicinity of their dwellings.9 As with most other shelter provisions, sanitation coverage is tion (16 per cent) in the region.12
Sanitation, hygiene and health are interconnected, linked by significantly higher in urban areas than in rural areas. Data col- Latin America and the Caribbean has a relatively high sanita-
three main factors in low-income communities: lack of access lected by the WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for tion coverage of 84 per cent; the region is performing better on world region as a whole: 100 per cent. Reporting mechanisms
to a safe, decent toilet; lack of awareness about the connections Water Supply and Sanitation indicates that in 2002, 81 per cent sanitation than Asia and Africa, and it hosts only 12 per cent of for Europe are extremely poor – contrary to what might be
between defecating in the open and contamination of food and of the world’s urban residents had access to improved sanitation, the world’s population without access to improved sanitation. assumed – so available data for that region is not statistically rep-
water sources; and cultural indifference to using the public compared to 37 per cent in rural areas. As expected, these values More than 75 per cent of the urban populations in virtually all resentative.14 Available data indicates that 99 per cent of the
environment for the disposal of human waste. The combined are lower for the developing regions, where the proportion of countries in the region have improved sanitation, with the excep- European population has access to improved sanitation, but in
issues of extreme deprivation, lack of education and poor qual- the population with adequate sanitation in urban areas is 73 per tion of Haiti and Belize – two countries in which less than 50 per many of the region’s new economies, the infrastructure for san-
ity and maintenance of sanitation facilities are compounded by cent, and in rural areas is 31 per cent.11 Estimations of the cent of the urban population has improved sanitation facilities. itation still needs to be developed or improved. Consequently,
the fact that interventions, if any, are typically neither sustained deficit depend heavily on the data sources and definitions used. In contrast, people in the developed world enjoy more or more than 80 million people in the region, or 10 per cent of the
nor systematic, owing to inadequate economic and financial While 73 per cent of the urban population in the develop- less universal provision of advanced sanitation facilities. total population, do not have improved sanitation.15
sector policies, poor urban management, and lack of political ing world has access to adequate sanitation facilities, more than Virtually all households have access to improved sanitation, as
will to respond to the needs of people living in poverty. Non- 560 million city dwellers are still deprived of a basic, decent more than 98 per cent of homes are connected to piped,
recognition of informal settlements by the authorities in charge toilet facility. The region with the lowest coverage of improved municipal sewage treatment systems. Those not connected to ■ Urban sanitation data for regions of the develop-
of provision is also an issue in some cities. sanitation in urban areas is Africa (63 per cent), with a sub- municipal sewage systems use septic tanks and similar solu- ing world
regional variance of 55 per cent coverage in sub-Saharan Africa tions that are regulated, inspected during construction and
at one end, and 89 per cent in Northern Africa at the other end. regularly tested for performance. In Japan, for instance, 100 Based on the definition of improved sanitation, and taking into
■ Global trends in sanitation provision At the continental level, Africa accounts for around one-fifth per cent of the population has improved sanitation: 81 per consideration the limitations of measurement, it is possible to
(21 per cent) of the world’s population lacking improved sani- cent of the population is connected to municipal sewerage sys- claim a modest improvement in the proportion of the world’s
In 2002, nearly half of the population of the developing tation. Asia has the second-lowest coverage in urban areas in the tems, and 19 per cent have household septic tanks (johkasoh) urban residents with access to sanitation: from 68 per cent in
world – about 2.5 billion people – did not have access to ade- world (66 per cent). Because of the population sizes of China and or use other improved facilities in agricultural communities.13 1990 to 73 per cent in 2003.16 A significant proportion of the
quate sanitation. Of those lacking adequate sanitation, 76 per India, along with other large nations in the region, Asia also North America has the highest reported coverage for any urban population in the developing world consequently does not

86 87
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

use or have access to any type of sanitation facility; an estimated cities in sub-Saharan Africa, where performance on sanitation
MAP 10 PROPORTION OF HOUSEHOLDS WITHOUT ACCESS TO IMPROVED SANITATION, 2003
10 per cent of the world’s urban population, or 300 million peo- indicators is as poor as on other development indicators.
ple, defecate in the open or use unsanitary bucket latrines.17 Centralized sewerage systems are the most appropriate solution,
The problem with these estimates is that different countries in terms of expense, infrastructure and health returns. In
use different types and categories of latrines, making it difficult Northern Africa, increased sewerage provision is the most com-
to code them for monitoring purposes. Apparently, not all of the mon solution in large, primary cities – national capitals and eco-
reported facilities are improved; where they are, a large propor- nomic centres. In the sub-region’s secondary cities, however,
tion of them are overcrowded, unsafe, lack provisions for clean- piped sewerage technology is not as common; in Assyut, Egypt,
ing hands and body, and are poorly maintained. In many urban fewer than 20 per cent of the households are connected to piped,
settings, especially in densely populated areas, pit latrines do not waterborne sewer systems.
significantly reduce the risk of faecal-oral diseases because of In 2003, slightly more than half of the urban population in sub-
their unhealthy conditions. Studies have shown that latrines Saharan Africa enjoyed adequate sanitation facilities (55 per cent)
alone do not have a clear health impact unless the behavioural – roughly the same proportion that was recorded in 1990. The rate
patterns associated with sound hygiene practices are also of urbanization in this sub-region has been the highest in the
ensured. In Pakistan, for instance, the fact that only a negligible world: it experienced an 80 per cent increase in the number of
difference exists in the frequency of diarrhoeal episodes between urban residents between 1990 and 2003. Subsequently, the num- >50%
households having latrines and those without latrines indicates ber of people lacking improved sanitation has drastically increased >25-75%
>10-25%
that hygiene is inadequate.18 – from 77 million in 1990, to 132 million in 2001, to 160 million
<=10%
in 2005.19 If no remedial action is taken, poor sanitation will con-
tinue to have a significant – and dismal – impact on the lives of
Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Global Urban Observatory, Urban Indicators Programme, Phase III.
Sanitation in African cities people living in poverty in the cities of sub-Saharan Africa.
Evidence of success exists in a few cities that have managed to
In Africa, the increase in the proportion of people with expand coverage between 1990 and 2003 significantly, including Sanitation in Asian cities Southern Asia’s coverage is also among the highest, with an
improved sanitation varies greatly, depending on the sub-region. Kigali, Rwanda, and Ibadan, Nigeria which increased coverage increase of 12 percentage points, although it started with the
A positive trend has been observed in Northern Africa, whereas from 47.8 per cent and 26.8 per cent in 1990 to 79.4 per cent and Time series analysis based on UN-HABITAT urban indica- lowest baseline in Asia – 54 per cent in 1990. Several Indian
signs of stagnation are clear in sub-Saharan Africa. In the former 67.3 per cent in 2003, respectively. Some countries, such as tors shows that Asia has made major progress on the provision cities – namely Akola, Kanpur and Kharagpur – made rapid
sub-region, the population enjoying improved sanitation services South Africa and Zimbabwe also have extensive sewerage net- of improved sanitation in cities. The region is diverse and het- progress, increasing coverage by at least 25 per cent between
grew from 84 per cent in 1990 to 89 per cent in 2002, due pri- works. This example gives hope and direction to the achievement erogeneous, however, with both advanced and poor economies. 1990 and 2002. However, Southern Asia also has countries with
marily to an increase registered in the Egyptian cities of Cairo, of sanitation target of the Millennium Development Goals. In South-Eastern Asia experienced the highest growth in low proportions of urban dwellers with access to improved san-
Alexandria, Port Said and Beni Suef, and the Moroccan cities of contrast, sanitation facilities in some cities such as Addis Ababa in improved sanitation coverage since 1990, increasing from 67 itation: Nepal (68 per cent); and Afghanistan (16 per cent).20
Casablanca and Rabat. Yet, small cities did not experience the Ethiopia and Porto Novo in Benin have less than half of their per cent that year to 79 per cent in 2002, particularly in mid- Growth in access to improved sanitation in Eastern Asia
same growth in provision; some still have access comparable to population served with improved sanitation. sized cities such as Bogor and Kediri in Indonesia, Cagayan de was rather moderate, increasing from 64 per cent in 1990 to
Oro in Philippines, and Hai Phong in Viet Nam. About 29 69 per cent in 2003, owing in large part to the increase in
million people still lacked access to improved sanitation in China and Mongolia’s largest cities.21 Deficits in sanitation
TABLE 2.4.1 IMPROVED SANITATION COVERAGE AMONG URBAN FIGURE 2.4.1 DISTRIBUTION OF URBAN POPULATION LACKING 2005; by 2020, the deficit is expected to decrease to 25 million. facilities in the two countries remain high: in China, 33 per
POPULATION BY REGION, 2003 IMPROVED SANITATION BY REGION, 2003
cent of the urban population still lacks improved sanitation,
Distribution of as does 54 per cent of the urban population of Mongolia.
urban popula- In Western Asia, coverage was quasi-universal in 1990, at
Population tion lacking
96 per cent, but since then, it has been difficult for countries

Guanabara Bay, Rio de Janeiro ©ELDER SALLES. IMAGE FROM BIGSTOCKPHOTO.COM


Access to Urban lacking improved
improved Population improved sanitation in Northern Africa to reach the poorest of the poor. In some of the middle-
sanitation, 2003 2003 sanitation developing
(%) (thousands) (thousands) world (%) Sub-Saharan Africa
income countries of the sub-region, a great deal of the infra-
structure is in place, but much of it is in poor condition and
Latin America and the Caribbean does not function reliably.22
Northern Africa 89.4 77,910 8,245 1.5
Eastern Asia
The sanitary situation of the countries of the
Sub-Saharan Africa 55.1 251,166 112,815 20.1
Commonwealth of Independent States in Asia is not well
Latin America and
Southern Asia documented. According to data from the WHO/UNICEF
the Caribbean 84.2 417,229 66,061 11.8
Eastern Asia 69.4 564,871 172,756 30.8 South-Eastern Asia
Joint Monitoring Programme, there are significant disparities
Southern Asia 67.0 448,738 148,084 26.4 in access to improved sanitation between urban and rural
South-Eastern Asia 80.0 228,636 45,727 8.2
Western Asia areas: 81 per cent and 45 per cent, respectively. Multiple
Western Asia 94.9 124,370 6,322 1.1 Indicator Cluster Surveys conducted by UNICEF in the
Total 560,011 region reveal that the only available government statistics are
limited to the proportion of the population served by cen-
Source: UN-HABITAT (2006), Urban Indicator Programme Phase III and United Nations, World Urbanization Prospects; The 2003 revision. tralized sewerage systems.23 Since such systems are generally
Note: Access to safe water was computed from data of WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme for Water Supply and Sanitation. limited to central districts of the region’s large cities, smaller

88 89
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

cities are not normally covered, and only 10 per cent of Despite improvements in the overall quality of life in some been recorded in cities such as Guatemala City, from 33 to 85
FIGURE 2.4.3 THE UNEQUAL DISTRIBUTION OF IMPROVED
households in rural areas are covered.24 Almost all the popu- developing countries, many cities, such as Rondonopolis in per cent between 1990 and 2003. The city of Fortaleza in Brazil
SANITATION IN ROSARIO, ARGENTINA
lation not served by centralized sewerage systems uses individual Brazil and Guayaquil in Ecuador, have been largely unsuccess- offers a valuable lesson in how development of sanitation infra-
sanitation facilities, such as pit latrines and pumped latrines. ful in creating reliable and adequate sanitation services. Studies structure can have a positive health outcome. The city experi-
Observations made in various parts of the region suggest that suggest that in most smaller urban centres, the proportion enced significant reduction in infant mortality rates from 74
most pit latrines, for individual household use and in public without adequate sanitation provision is even higher; most per 1,000 births to 28 per 1,000 births in 2001 - the same peri-
institutions such as schools and hospitals, are in poor condi- urban centers in low- and middle-income nations have no sew- od in which sanitation coverage increased from one-third to
tion, especially in economically disadvantaged areas. ers at all and have little or no other public support for good- more than half the urban population.
quality sanitation.26 However, significant improvements have

Sanitation in Latin America and the Caribbean

Latin America and the Caribbean has relatively high sani-


tation coverage but with vast internal variations between Endnotes
rural and urban environments, and among individual coun-
1 From 1990 to 2000, sanitation received only 20 per cent of the $16 bil- 20 UN-HABITAT 2005c.
tries and cities. According to data compiled by the
lion invested in water by national governments and external support 21 WHO/UNICEF 2004.
WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Programme, the propor-
agencies. (United Kingdom Parliamentary Office of Science and 22 Ibid.
tion of the rural population lacking improved sanitation was
Technology 2002.) 23 According to UNICEF, 54 per cent of the population in five of the
almost half of the urban proportion: 44 per cent versus 84
2 WHO/UNICEF 2004. Commonwealth of Independent States countries has access to central-
per cent, respectively. In various countries of the Caribbean, 0% - 22% 3 Evans 2005. ized sewerage systems.
improved sanitation coverage is universal, particularly in 23% - 50% 4 South-East Asia Regional Office of WHO, quoted in Evans 2005. 24 Cherp 1999.
Antigua, Bahamas, Barbados, Cuba, Surinam, and Trinidad 51% - 71% 5 Esray 1996. 25 WHO/UNICEF 2004.
and Tobago.25 UN-HABITAT urban indicators data reveals 72% - 90% 6 Manase, et al. 2001. 26 Satterthwaite, et al. 2005.
high coverage in various cities, namely in Bogotá and 91% - 100%
7 Ibid.
Medellin in Colombia; Caracas in Venezuela; Chillan in 0 0.9 1.8 Kilometers 8 Conference Proceedings for the South Asian Conference on Sanitation,
Chile; and Guadalajara in Mexico. Source: Javier Alberto Martinez-Martin, 2005. Dhaka, Bangladesh, 2004.
9 UNICEF 2004.
10 WHO/UNICEF 2000 assessment.
FIGURE 2.4.2 PROPORTION OF URBAN HOUSEHOLDS WITH FIGURE 2.4.3 CITIES WITH LOW SANITATION COVERAGE: 11 WHO/UNICEF 2004.
ACCESS TO IMPROVED SANITATION PROPORTION OF URBAN POPULATION WITH ACCESS TO 12 WHO/UNICEF 2000 assessment.
IMPROVED SANITATION, 2003 13 Report on Urban Indicators submitted by the Japanese Government to
100
UN-HABITAT, May 2005. Refer as well to the Report on Urban Indicators
60
prepared by the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation 2005.
14 In the WHO/UNICEF 2000 assessment, the coverage data represented
50 15 per cent for 1990 and 44 per cent of the region’s total population. For
80
the UN-HABITAT urban indicators, no reporting mechanism was devel-
40
oped, with the exception of that by the Dutch Government.
60 15 WHO 2005.
Percentage (%)

16 Data is based on Urban Indicators Programme, Phase III. The percent-


30 age in 1990 is the average of 29 cities in Africa, 54 cities in Asia and
40 25 cities in Latin America and the Caribbean. The percentage in 2003 is
20
the average of 55 cities in Africa, 78 cities in Asia and 31cities in Latin
America and the Caribbean.
20 17 As mentioned earlier, a large proportion of people with latrines prefer
10
to defecate in the open. A study conducted by the World Bank in
Mumbai concludes that toilets for slum dwellers, even when available
0 0 are in such poor condition that people refuse to use them. (Nitti &
Sarkar 2003).
ric n

ric n

be nd

ia

ia

As rn

ia

ba

da

Og seru

ag sho

em s
ab
ui
kr

i
Af her

Af ara

ak

go

ut

go

ol
As

As

As
e

aq
rib a a

ba

an

Re
a

an

ia

na

ap
st

óp
m

o
ou

ou
a
rt

ay
n

rn

rn

sA

Lu
Ea

18 Conference Proceedings, South Asian Conference in Sanitation,


Ba
Ca ric

Co

M
Sa

on
No

er

Dj

ad
bo
he

te

Gu
h-
th Ame

di
st
b-

nd

Si
es
ut

ut

Ad
Ea
Su

Ro
W

Ou
So

So

Pakistan, 2004.
tin
e
La

19 Estimations based on the UN-HABITAT Urban Indicators Data 2005 and


1990 2003 Africa Latin America and the Caribbean
the United Nations Urbanization Prospects 2004.
and Asia
Source: UN-HABITAT Urban Indicators Programme Phase III.
Note: Data for 1990 not available for some regions. Source: UN-HABITAT 2005, Urban Indicators Programme Phase III.

90 91
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

LENA SOMMESTAD
Sanitation: A women’s issue STRONGER ACTION IS NEEDED TO ACHIEVE THE SANITATION TARGET
No issue touches the lives of A sanitation target was set at the World Summit on Sustainable

Communal water tap in Soweto, Johannesburg RASNA WARAH


women – particularly poor urban Development, held in Johannesburg in 2002. Sanitation was also discussed
women – as intimately as that of during the 2005 UN-HABITAT Governing Council and during the 30th session
access to sanitation. In low- of the Commission on Sustainable Development in New York in April 2005. I
income settlements where there am pleased that sanitation has finally attracted the attention of policymakers
are no individual toilets, women worldwide. However, to achieve the sanitation target, we need stronger
have to queue for long periods to action and more innovative approaches. In particular, women’s role and inter-
gain access to public toilets; ests must be fully taken into account.
some have to bear the indignity
of having to defecate in the The present growth of the world population is almost entirely in the urban
open, which exposes them to the centres of the developing world. Solutions for improved urban sanitation
possibility of sexual harassment therefore require urgent innovation in urban areas. However, sanitation infra-
or assault. structure planning rarely takes into account a gender perspective. Women
and children are hardly ever considered priority target groups for sanitation
Although men also suffer from provision. This needs to be improved. The social context of sanitation and the
the burden of poor sanitation, needs of families must be built into solutions if they are to be sustainable.
they are more likely to resort to
other means to relieve them- Women, along with children, are the ones who suffer most from lack of water
selves. In many slums, men uri- and sanitation. Girls face lack of sanitation in schools. This is a significant
nate and defecate along railway barrier to education that must be identified and removed. Women normally
tracks and in open spaces. But have the main responsibility for work tasks associated with health and sani-
women – whose anatomy, modesty and susceptibility to national bodies tend to confine women’s issues to reproduc- tation, such as water collection, washing and cleaning of the house and the
attack does not allow them to discreetly relieve themselves in tive health and education. Few, if any, governments focus on latrines. Women, children and elderly people are disproportionately affected
public – have no choice but to wait until dark, usually early in the impact of inadequate sanitation on women. This could by illness caused by polluted water.
the morning when there is less risk of being accosted. “Going also be partially explained by the fact that improving access
to the toilet” for these women often means squatting in a pri- to sanitation was only recently recognized as a pressing The challenge surrounding equity and access to sanitation is closely linked to
vate spot or waking up before dawn to queue at public toilets. internationally agreed target – in 2002 at the World Summit the fact that sanitation systems are seldom planned using the elements of
on Sustainable Development – so the issue has not been on sustainability and ecological principles. This is why sustainable sanitation
One woman interviewed in a Mumbai slum explained what it the public agenda for long. Although women’s lack of access approaches have been developed.
means to have no toilet: “We use the toilet outside our settle- to water in both rural and urban areas and its health impli-
ment, five minutes away. We have to stand in a queue for half cations – including severe back pain caused by carrying The essential features of sustainable sanitation are proper containment
an hour. That is why the men all go under the bridge and only heavy vessels of water over long distances – has been the allowing for sanitation and recycling, closing of the nutrient and water loops,
the women use the toilets. Children also go out in the open.” subject of several studies, women’s lack of access to sanita- protection of downstream health and environment, local management and

Kibera, Nairobi THIERRY GEENEN, FOR NAIROBI RIVER BASIN PROJECT, UNEP.
tion has not received the same attention. Preliminary UN- financing, affordability, and equitable services for rich and poor, women and
A disproportionate share of the labour and health burden of HABITAT analyses indicate the need for further study of the men, old and young. Sustainable sanitation is pursued in very close coopera-
inadequate sanitation falls on women. For women living in issue, as they show that lack of sanitation in slums increases tion with the people who will use these systems. Advanced solutions are
slums, a long wait at the public toilet can mean that children health risks among all slum residents, women and children coupled with local knowledge.
are left unattended, or that a household chore is delayed. in particular.
Unhygienic public toilets and latrines threaten the health of The Government of Sweden contributes to the development of an ecological
women, who are prone to reproductive tract infections caused Because rural women – no matter how poor – do not have to sanitation approach. We are working through SIDA – the Swedish
by poor sanitation. For women who are menstruating, the face the same dilemma as their urban counterparts when it International Development Cooperation Agency – to support the develop-
need for adequate sanitation becomes even more acute. comes to sanitation, poverty reduction efforts, which are ment of ecological sanitation in several developing countries. The Swedish
Moreover, because it is generally women who are responsible currently focused on rural areas, particularly in sub-Saharan support aims to create a global confidence in ecological sanitation as a reli-
for the disposal of human waste when provision of sanitation Africa and Asia, do not factor in women’s access to sanitation able, cost-effective and sustainable alternative to conventional systems.
is inadequate, they are more susceptible to diseases associat- in urban areas. Most rural households have access to at least
ed with contact with human excreta. one toilet – even if it is a crude pit latrine – which means that For decades, sanitation has been neglected in many parts of the world. This
women in rural areas rarely queue to go to the toilet and are has had severe consequences, in particular for the poor, and in particular for
Despite all this, the sanitation crisis affecting women has not less likely to share toilets with dozens of other people. They Today millions of poor people suffer from diseases and parasites women. Now, we have a great challenge ahead. Sanitation should be a
been given a high priority on the agendas of human rights are also more likely to keep the toilets clean, as their family’s because sanitation has not received enough political attention. human right. Sustainable solutions are key. By empowering women and chil-
and women’s organizations. United Nations and other inter- health often depends on it. Young children die of diarrhoea and women are denied security, dren, we can make a difference.
privacy and dignity. Approximately 2.6 billion people in the world
Sources: Warah 2005a; UN-HABITAT 2003a; Hardoy, et al. 2001; Mukherjee 2001. are lacking sanitation services. Lena Sommestad is the Swedish Minister for Sustainable Development.

92
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Family being evicted during slum clearance, Minas Gerias, Belo Horizonte, Brazil DYLAN GARCIA/STILL PICTURES
2.5 Owners without Titles:
Security of Tenure in Cities of the Developing World

■ Evictions: The most severe consequence of integrated and complex networks of the informal economy.5
insecure tenure Media and other reports suggest that the magnitude of urban
evictions is currently highest in sub-Saharan African cities,
Mass evictions of slum dwellers in various parts of the devel- although rural evictions are also quite common. This could be
oping world in recent years have raised fears that security of partly because urban populations in African cities have so far not
tenure and housing rights are becoming increasingly precarious been able to organize themselves politically in large enough num-
in the world’s cities. A global survey1 in 60 countries found that bers to be able to resist evictions or demand rights from their
6.7 million people had been forcibly evicted from their homes governments. In addition, many African governments inherited
between 2000 and 2002, compared with 4.2 million people outdated, elitist laws from colonial powers that discriminate
between 1998 and 2000.2 Some experts have described the against the urban poor; these policies have led to the creation of
unprecedented rise in the number of evictions in the last five “apartheid-type” cities, with the neighbourhoods of the rich and
years as a global “epidemic”.3 the poor clearly demarcated.6
Although forced evictions are an extreme consequence of inse- Strong civil society action in Asia and better legislation has had
cure tenure, their increasing prevalence in recent years point to a significant impact on improving the tenure status of slum
trends that suggest that attitudes of local and national govern- dwellers, but with pressures to “globalize” mounting, particular- holds.8 In many cases the majority of inhabitants live with “owners without titles” conceals the real number of people living
ments towards the urban poor are becoming increasingly intoler- ly in the region’s more economically successful industrializing tenure systems that are “informal”, which means that their in informal settlements and significantly distorts figures and esti-
ant. This can be attributed to to a variety of factors, including cities, this trend could be reversed in the near future. Moreover, occupation of land and/or housing is either illegal, quasi-legal, mates reflecting the magnitude of urban dwellers who live with-
globalization, which is putting pressure on national and local escalating land and house prices in Asian cities could lead to eco- tolerated or legitimized by customary or traditional laws, which out secure tenure in cities.
governments to “beautify” or “clean up” their cities in order to nomic evictions as lower-income groups are pushed out of the can either be recognized or simply ignored by the authorities. Security of tenure is critical to the livelihood of slum dwellers
become more competitive in a global economy that has seen the city simply because they can no longer afford to live there. Slums – the generic term used to classify informal, illegal or and should encompass a minimum package of rights, which
gap between the rich and poor widen and dramatically increased In Latin America, progressive slum upgrading and regulariza- unplanned settlements – are the invisible “zones of silence” on could progressively evolve towards a higher order of rights. This
the price of urban land, pushing lower-income groups to the tion programmes have increased tenure security among the tenure security. Little is known about the formal or informal formalization process can be accomplished through an incremen-
edge of cities to unplanned and poorly serviced areas. urban poor, but evidence suggests that tenure security is not tenure systems slum dwellers enjoy – or don’t enjoy – as official
Evictions are particularly prevalent in sub-Saharan Africa and reaching the most vulnerable groups. For instance, a study in censuses and households surveys do not at present measure
Asia; most are carried out to make room for large-scale develop- Brazil shows that poor blacks and mulattos are least likely to live tenure security as a development indicator, even though infor- FIGURE 2.5.1 PERCENTAGE OF URBAN HOUSEHOLDS WITH
ment projects and infrastructure, such as dams or roads, or to in adequate housing with secure tenure, and are most likely to mality – or “illegality” is perhaps the most significant factor in ADEQUATE HOUSING IN BRAZIL, 1992-2003
accommodate city “beautification” programmes. Cities that have live in slums (see figure). the physical and demographic growth of cities in the developing
experienced mass forced evictions in recent years include Beijing, However, improving the tenure of existing urban populations world and is the main mechanism through which poor people in 80

Lagos, Abuja and Nairobi. Even when evictions are “justified” – is not enough; measures must also be undertaken to prevent the cities gain access to land and housing.9
as when they are carried out in the public interest, to build roads growth of new slums and informal settlements where tenure The status of slum dwellers in developing countries is made
70
or other infrastructure necessary for urban development or when security is at risk. This requires a parallel approach to increase the more ambiguous by the fact that they are often not included in
they are carried out in order to “protect” slum dwellers from haz- supply of planned, legal and affordable land on a scale equal to national censuses and household surveys, which means that their
ards – they not do not take place in conformity with the rules of present and future demand. tenure is neither recorded nor guaranteed. Often, new informal 60
international law.4 Most evictions are carried out without legal settlements are not enumerated, and even when their inhabitants

Percentage (%)
notice and without following due process. Evicted people not are included in censuses, they normally appear as “owners” of the
50
only lose their homes (in which they have invested a considerable ■ Tenure security: The thin line between legality dwelling they occupy, even though surveys and studies have
portion of their savings), they are often forced to relinquish their and illegality shown that large proportions of slum dwellers are actually ten-
personal belongings as well. ants or are “owners without titles”. In 2003, the Inter-American 40
It is not uncommon for evicted families to sleep out in the Non-emperical evidence suggests that between 30 per cent Development Bank estimated that around 60 per cent of the
open around the demolished site without food or basic ameni- and 50 per cent of urban residents in the developing world lack urban poor in Latin America were home owners even though
30
ties. Children and women are particularly vulnerable in such sit- any kind of legal document to show they have tenure security.7 very few had land or housing titles.10 In 2005, the Central
1992 1993 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2001 2002 2003
uations. Incidents of rape and killing of victims during and after Development agencies, academics and practitioners in urban Statistical Bureau in Indonesia reported that “out of those that
eviction exercises have been reported in many places. issues concur that informal growth has become the most signif- own their home, only 32 per cent can show legitimate proof in White Brazil Total Blacks and Mulattos
When evictions take place, they not only destroy homes, but icant mode of housing production in cities of the developing the form of a certificate from the national land agency”.11 In
also entire communities, which can lead to urban unrest and world. In fact, gaining access to housing through legal channels Nicaragua, one-third of the urban population was recorded as Source: Morais, Maria da Piedade, rapporteur Target 11, MDGs, IPEA based on
insecurity. Evictions result in loss of income and disrupt highly is the exception rather than the rule for most urban poor house- being “owners with no deed” in 2001.12 The high prevalence of PNAD microdata, IBGE, 1992 to 2003.

94 95
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Monitoring Secure Tenure invest in enterprise.16 Land and housing are perceived as owners (both public and private) and tenants play a more
market assets that have the potential of generating bottom- important role in securing tenure than titling. In most cases,
UN-HABITAT defines secure tenure as the Component Indicator 1: Proof of Documentation. up economic and social rewards, thereby reducing poverty. land in both rural and urban areas is neither registered, not is
right of all individuals and groups to effective This component indicator assumes that documentation may be considered as proof of occupancy Diametrically opposed to this way of thinking is the percep- there an official title for it. UN-HABITAT estimates indicate
protection from the State against forced evic- and therefore could provide certain levels of security. In most developing countries, tenure security
tion that access to land is a fundamental human right neces- that less than one-third of land in developing countries is
tions. Under international law, “forced evic- in informal settlements is achieved incrementally over time through the accretion of various docu-
sary for a secure livelihood. accounted for in official land records and registries23 and ques-
tion” is defined as “the permanent or tempo- ments, such as utility bills, voter registration forms, ration cards and municipal tax receipts.
rary removal against their will of individuals,
Most governments and development agencies consider ten- tions regarding ownership are tackled through customary, com-
families and/or communities from the homes Component Indicator 2: Perception of security/insecurity of tenure. ants living in informal settlements as having “insecure tenure”, munal or religious laws governing land. According to World
and/or land which they occupy, without the This indicator measures the individual’s or household’s perception of their own tenure situation. It whereas “owners” are automatically classified as “secure”. Bank estimates, in Africa formal tenure extends to only
provision of, and access to appropriate forms is based on the experience and perceptions of those who are most directly confronted with the Countries from various regions, such as Bosnia and between 2 per cent and 10 per cent of all residential land.24
of legal or other protection”. reality of evictions in a country or city. Herzegovina, Cambodia, Cameroon, Côte d’Ivoire and Gabon Unfortunately, in some parts of the world, particularly in sub-
have used indicators such as “the percentage of land parcels Saharan Africa, customary law actually works against the inter-
For global monitoring purposes, UN-HABITAT The two component indicators are complemented by a diagnostic of the policy environment that having titles”, the “percentage of the population with access to ests of women, who are prevented from inheriting land or
proposes to adopt two more component indi- helps to determine the factual status of tenure security in a specific context. This is done through a property”, or the “number of households owning their lodging” property. While an increasing number of sub-Saharan African
cators to measure secure tenure at the indi- qualitative measurement of the legal, institutional, administrative and policy environment govern- to measure tenure security.17 The Economic Commission for countries have recognized women’s equal rights to land and
vidual/household level: ing security of tenure.
Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC) also associates property, thus complying with international human rights stan-
insecure tenure among the urban poor with lack of owner- dards and obligations, there are still some countries, such as
ship.18 This mode of coding seems to respond to ideologies and Kenya, Lesotho, Zambia and Zimbabwe, where discrimination
tal process of tenure upgrading that evolves from de facto tenure security, multiplying the opportunities to obtain capital. As the belief systems that view rights to land and property as being in customary and personal law matters (such as inheritance) is
(taking into account a variety of socially accepted norms in land land systems and markets become more stable, more complex dependant on market forces and affordability, rather than as still permitted in these countries’ constitutions.25
and housing tenure) to de jure tenure. This approach also allows products appear, such as land and credit being placed in second- fundamental rights guaranteed by governments.
governments to build technical and administrative procedures ary markets and stocks. Yet many examples from around the world show that whilst
over time and within their own resource capacity. titling has benefited many slum communities, and deserves a ■ The Challenge of Measuring Tenure in
The precarious status of land and housing tenure among slum place in tenure policies, it has not necessarily increased access Informal Urban Settlements
dwellers can also be progressively strengthened through an institu- ■ Ownership is not always the solution to credit or prevented growth of new informal settlements.
tional and social construct in which the accretion of various docu- Empirical evidence does not support the view that full titling Since many local authorities are reluctant to recognize the
ments plays a key role in the process. The process can start initial- Although ownership is typically regarded as the most secure lifts the poor out of poverty; in many cases, an incremental existence of informal growth in their cities, or are not predis-
ly with the occupant providing simple proof of occupancy, such as form of tenure, evidence from around the world suggests that approach – based on the right to a secure livelihood – has posed to address it in a systematic manner, they do not devel-
utility bills, voter registration forms, ration cards and municipal tax ownership is not the norm in both the developed and develop- proved to be more effective in the long term. In some cases, op appropriate means to measure and monitor the level of
receipts. Gradually, documentation could evolve towards more ing world, and is not the only means through which tenure large scale titling programmes can actually contribute to legit- informality in urban areas. In fact, in 2005, UN-HABITAT’s
consolidated forms of occupancy rights, and eventually to formal security can be achieved. Home owners are a minority in most imizing and exacerbating unequal systems of land and proper- Urban Indicators Programme found that around 100 cities in
tenure regularization and the provision of legal rights, such as free- countries of the developing and developed world. In Central ty distribution.19 For example, in Buenos Aires, Argentina, a Africa, Asia and Latin America, representing more than 70 per
hold or long-term leases, if these are possible and desirable. Europe, for instance, more than half the inhabitants rent the study found that the allocation of property rights across slum cent of a global sample of cities, acknowledged that they did
In formal, advanced systems, tenure rights are reflected in laws houses in which they live. Yet, their tenure is extremely secure. households is usually not random, but based on wealth, family not know to which extent urban growth could be attributed to
and regulations governing housing and property rights. In devel- And despite a significant increase in ownership in North characteristics, political patronage and other mechanisms that informal settlements; 40 cities, or 20 per cent of the sample,
oped countries, security of tenure is in most cases guaranteed, America that saw home ownership rise - from 64 per cent to 69 mark differences between those who have property rights and provided some general data as a percentage of the total urban
and people enjoy a higher order of rights that enables them to per cent from 1993 to 2003 - a third of the region’s inhabitants those who do not.20 Slum upgrading projects in other countries growth; less than 20 cities, or 10 per cent of the sample, made
sell, rent, improve, develop, sub-let or inherit land or property. In still do not own their own home.14 Even in the developing have also been known to play into the hands of illegal structure available accurate information in square kilometers, as request-
virtually all developed countries, these rights are further embed- world, studies have shown that ownership is neither necessary owners and negligent landlords, who lay claim on upgraded ed by the Programme.26
ded in infrastructure, land administration and land recording nor sufficient to generate tenure security. A Demographic and dwellings in order to extract more rent from tenants or to sell Consequently, the number of people lacking secure tenure is
mechanisms. Rights derived from land and property are defined Heath Survey conducted in Senegal in 2005 shows that 45 per them off to higher-income groups.21 Upgrading policies based not known in most cities and countries of the developing
in a way that makes them easy to identify in terms of boundaries, cent of the inhabitants owned their homes, while 42 per cent on ownership and large scale granting of individual titles are world. The lack of official data on informal growth is sympto-
demarcations, registration and transactions. Individuals (owners were tenants. Only 40 per cent of the so-called owners claimed also extremely expensive and cumbersome, especially in coun- matic of the poor capacity of local authorities to plan the
and tenants) have a clear understanding of the potential that land to have title deeds, while 25 per cent had a certificate of occu- tries where titling systems are slow, laborious, inflexible and urbanization process. Instead of learning to accept inevitable
and housing offers in terms of use, appropriation and trade. UN- pation or a receipt of purchase. A significant proportion – 13 generally unaffordable – not to mention prone to corrupt prac- urban growth in informal settlements and slums, governments,
HABITAT uses the concept of “tenure advantage” to describe per cent – had no formal or informal authorization to occupy tices that harm rather than benefit the urban poor. In the like the proverbial ostrich, have chosen to bury their heads in
these more advanced rights of individuals and households.13 the dwelling. Of the tenants, only 14 per cent had a formal Philippines, for instance, establishing legal ownership takes 168 the sand, hoping the problem will go away. That is why meth-
However, it is understood that slum dwellers can also sell, rent or contract and a staggering 68 per cent did not have any kind of procedures and between 13 and 15 years.22 All these problems ods to capture and measure informal settlement growth are not
improve the land or property they occupy, but in a less secure document to prove tenancy. Yet 76 per cent of both owners and are compounded by the fact that little is known about the perceived as necessary. It is also the reason why the extent and
environment. Tenure advantage rights are also known as “trans- tenants said they enjoyed security of tenure.15 severity or range of insecure tenure within cities of the develop- scope of tenure insecurity is not known in most cities and
ferability rights” that have a direct bearing on the livelihoods of The view that ownership is the only path to security has ing world, which makes it difficult to make appropriate inter- countries of the developing world.
people, as they are extensively used as security from which capi- gained credence among development agencies and practi- ventions at the policy level or in the implementation of upgrad- There have, however, been exceptions to this rule. Some gov-
tal can be derived. As property markets become more active, tioners who argue that urban poverty can be drastically ing and regularization programmes. ernments have addressed urban tenure security in their plans,
transferability operations increase because public and private reduced if slum dwellers acquire ownership rights that can In developing countries, customary ownership, religious sys- providing land to urban dwellers before occupation. Others
infrastructure supports the activities. Land is extensively used as enable them to secure loans to improve their housing and to tems governing land issues and informal agreements between have integrated tenure security in their housing programmes

96 97
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

ing to establish monitoring systems on issues such as evictions


and other housing rights abuses, even they admit that a com- Endnotes
prehensive eviction-monitoring system remains elusive as many
gaps in coverage remain because for every reported eviction, 1 Much of the data on evictions in this chapter is drawn from various 31 UN-HABITAT currently undertakes this monitoring strategy in collabora-
there is an unknown number of unreported cases.28 In the reports by the Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions (COHRE). tion with several partners, namely DFID, the World Bank, and the gov-
absence of a monitoring framework that provides a reference 2 COHRE 2003. ernments of Canada, USA and Belgium.
point and guidance, it is statistically difficult to prove whether 3 COHRE 2004.
tenure has improved or deteriorated, as evidence remains most- 4 The most comprehensive interpretation of the scope of protection
ly anecdotal or based on media reports. against forced evictions was made by the UN Committee on Economic,
As long as mainstream systems of data collection and analy- Social and Cultural Rights in its general comment No 7, adopted in
sis (censuses and surveys) do not recognize secure tenure as a 1997, while the right to adequate housing is enshrined in many interna-
unit of analysis, data will not be periodically produced. tional human rights instruments, most notably the Universal
El Alto, Bolivia ©RUSSELL PEARCE. IMAGE FROM BIGSTOCKPHOTO.COM

ECLAC, for instance, recognizes the difficulties in determining Declaration of Human Rights and the International Covenant on
secure tenure in Latin America and the Caribbean and can only Economic, Social and Cultural Rights.
estimate the level of informality in the region’s the cities, which 5 United Nations 2005c.
it places at between 10 and 15 per cent of the urban population 6 These “apartheid cities” appear to be more prevalent in former British
in Argentina and Uruguay, between 20 and 40 per cent in colonies, such Kenya and Zimbabwe, where the migration of the indige-
Mexico and Peru and between 50 and 70 per cent in Ecuador nous population to cities was highly regulated and often prohibited dur-
and Honduras.29 The World Bank estimates that more than 50 ing the colonial period.
per cent of the peri-urban population in Africa and more than 7 World Bank 2003.
50 per cent in Asia has some form of informal tenure. But these 8 De Soto 2000.
are at best estimates as few countries produce data on secure 9 Fernandes, et al. 1998.
tenure, which can be used as basis for global and regional mon- 10 Inter-American Development Bank 2004.
itoring or to assess progress or setbacks. 11 Government of Indonesia 2005.
12 Demographic and Health Survey, Nicaragua, 2001.
13 Bazoglu & Moreno 2005.
■ Toward a Global Monitoring Strategy on 14 US Census Bureau, American Housing Survey (1993 and 2003).
Secure Tenure 15 UN-HABITAT 2005c.
16 De Soto makes a strong argument for ownership in The Mystery of
Informal growth has become the most In the last thirty years, security of tenure has been part of the Capital (2000).
significant mode of housing production in conceptual, institutional and technical discussions about land 17 Lee & Ghanime 2004.
and housing policies. In some moments of this saga, tenure 18 Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean 2005.
cities of the developing world.
security has received a great deal of attention, particularly dur- 19 Quan, et al. 2005.
ing international conferences, political declarations and the 20 Goytia 2005.
preparation of technical reports. These discussions, however, 21 Huchzermeyer 2006.
and projects, but in a very sporadic way. Many governments have not resulted in greater efforts to integrate tenure security 22 UN-HABITAT 2004c.
have responded to informal occupations through remedial in policy reforms and urban interventions. In fact, no mecha- 23 Augustinas 2003.
actions of regularization; however, their interventions have nei- nism currently exists to monitor secure tenure as part of 24 World Bank 2003.
ther been systematic nor politically disinterested. The majority Millennium Development Goal 7, target 11 on improving the 25 UN-HABITAT 2004d.
of the governments have opted to ignore informal settlements lives of slum dwellers.30 26 UN-HABITAT training workshops in five regions of the developing
altogether, either because of their unwillingness to accept in- UN-HABITAT and its partners are working on the prepara- world. Urban Indicators Programme, Cluster B Urban Data, Nairobi,
migration and urban growth, or their incapacity to cope with tion of a global monitoring system31 that could in the future 2005.
the accelerated process of urbanization. provide a framework to assist governments at local and nation- 27 Bazoglu & Moreno 2005.
The problem is compounded by the fact that while United al levels to produce estimates at the household levels on how 28 COHRE 2004.
Nations and other agencies have been testing and developing many people have secure tenure, using a consistent methodol- 29 Clichevsky 2003.
systems of monitoring global poverty, disease, illiteracy, unem- ogy in terms of definitions, indicators and variables. The mon- 30 A list of 18 targets and more than 40 indicators corresponding to these
ployment, and other indicators over the past five decades, the itoring system would serve to track changes in land and resi- goals ensure a common assessment and appreciation of the status of
operationalization of the secure tenure concept, as part of a dential secure tenure to measure how the right to adequate the Millennium Development Goals at the global, national and local lev-
global monitoring system, remains challenging. Indeed, at the housing is progressively realized and how slum dwellers are els. Among the indicators for monitoring progress on the Goals, secure
present time, it is neither possible to obtain household-level improving their living conditions. It would also be an advoca- tenure was given a prominent place (indicator 32, “the proportion of
data on secure tenure, nor to produce global comparative data cy and policy instrument to bring together policy formulation, households with access to secure tenure”), as part of Target 11 “by
on various institutional aspects of secure tenure.27 Although a action and monitoring activities; otherwise, policy actions will 2020, to have achieved a significant improvement in the lives of at
growing global network of organizations, such as the Centre on continue to be formulated independently of results, without least 100 million slum dwellers” of Goal 7 “Ensure Environmental
Housing Rights and Evictions (COHRE), Amnesty clearly indicating if there is efficient, equitable and sustainable Sustainability”.
International and Human Rights Watch, among others, are try- progress in attaining target 11.

98 99
S TAT E O F T H E W O R L D ’ S C I T I E S R E P O R T 2 0 0 6 / 7

Evictions Fail to Address the Root Cause of Urban Poverty in Zimbabwe


In May 2005, with little or no warning, the Government of Like many former British colonies in sub-Saharan Africa, urban
Zimbabwe embarked on an operation to “clean up” its cities. planning in the country formerly known as Rhodesia typically
“Operation Murambatsvina”, or Operation Restore Order, started in reserved the city core for whites, while leaving an undeveloped
the capital Harare, and rapidly evolved into a nationwide demoli- buffer space around the central business district.Towns were often
tion and eviction campaign carried out by the police and the army. pre-planned and imposed on localities, without much attention
Popularly known as “Operation Tsunami” because of its speed and being given to existing constraints.The indigenous population was
ferocity, it resulted in the destruction of homes, business premises either relocated to black townships on the outskirts of the city or to
and vending sites in several parts of the country. A July 2005 report rural “reserves” to make room for European settlers.
by the UN Special Envoy on Human Settlements Issues in
Zimbabwe, Mrs. Anna Tibaijuka, estimated that some 700,000 peo- The indigenous African population moved to towns and cities in
ple in cities across the country had either lost their homes, their large numbers only after attaining independence when policies
source of livelihood or both as a result of the Operation and a fur- prohibiting their movement to cities were abolished or discarded.
ther 2.4 million were indirectly affected in varying degrees. This resulted in a major shift of populations from rural to urban
areas. Within a decade of independence, Zimbabwe’s urban popu-
Operation Restore Order took place at a time of persistent budget lation rose from 23 per cent in the 1980s to 30 per cent by the early
deficits, triple-digit inflation, critical food and fuel shortages and 1990s. However, stringent by-laws and standards adopted from the
chronic shortages of foreign currency. It was implemented in a colonial administration ensured that Zimbabwe’s cities remained
highly polarized climate characterized by mistrust, fear and a lack largely immune to the explosive growth of slums and squatter set-
of dialogue between the government and local authorities, and tlements that are characteristic of other African cities.Official statis-
between the government and civil society. Although the econom- tics compiled by UN-HABITAT show that in 2001 only 3.4 per cent
ic crisis was precipitated by a variety of factors,including increasing of the urban population in the country lived in slums,a figure much
isolation by Western powers, many of Zimbabwe’s problems pre- lower than that of even industrialized countries that had about 6.2
cede the country’s independence. per cent of their population living in slum-like conditions, and dra-
matically lower than that of other African cities, where between 30
Zimbabwe achieved independence in 1980 amid promises of peace per cent to 70 per cent of the urban population lives in slums.
and prosperity. While the government successfully provided social
services,such as education and health care,and increased wages for The acquisition of peri-urban farms during the fast-track reform
the black majority during the early years of independence, underly- programme in 2000 provided one of the first opportunities for the
ing socio-political and economic problems were left unresolved urban poor to occupy land in the vicinity of the city, many of which
and eventually produced a national crisis. Of these, the land ques- were in the form of “backyard extensions” of legal dwellings.These
tion was the most problematic.While the liberation war was fought extensions provided affordable rental housing to the city’s poor
over land, historical inequity was embedded in the constitutional and were a source of much-needed income for the owners. Most of
settlement agreed upon at independence that preserved colonial these extensions within the cities have now been demolished,
patterns of land ownership.To make matters worse, a failed attempt affecting hundreds of thousands of women, men and children who
One of the affected areas in Harare prior to the May 2005 evictions. The same area after the May 2005 evictions. at structural adjustment in the 1990s led to massive retrenchment are sinking deeper into poverty and rendered more vulnerable. A
of civil servants, closure of manufacturing industries, inflation and follow-up report by the UN Office for the Coordination of
Source: IKONOS: Copyright INTA Space Turk 2005; QUICK BIRD: Copyright Digital Globe 2005; Image processing and analysis: UNOSAT.
deterioration of basic services. In February 1998, peasants took mat- Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), for instance, found that some of the