Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2, 2009 115
Abstract: This paper describes a case study about the major issues and
challenges in the development of the electronic banking (e-banking) industry
of a relatively underdeveloped nation. This research shows that even in many
less developed nations, the application of e-banking can help their local banks
reduce operating costs and provide a better and fast service to their customers.
The research objectives are to investigate the current trends and developments
in e-banking and provide managerial insights for the banking industry in those
underdeveloped nations. The collected data are examined through statistical
analysis tools. Managerial implications are discussed with suggestions for
future research.
1 Introduction
E-business has been continuously growing as a new industry during the last decade
(Van Hoeck, 2001). The banking industry has been leading this trend in recent years,
and now all banking transactions completing through internet applications is sometimes
called e-banking. Some key issues addressed in the recent literature about the e-banking
include: customer acceptance and satisfaction, privacy concerns, profitability, operational
risks, and competition from nonbanking institutions (Boss et al., 2000; Smith, 2006;
Hwang et al., 2007; Shin, 2008). E-banking has revolutionised the way business is
transacted by globalising the business enterprise.
E-banking technologies have proliferated in recent years, and the availability of
a wide range of products has led to increasing adoption among consumers. These
technologies include direct deposit, computer banking, stored value cards, and debit cards
(Servon and Kaestner, 2008). Consumers are attracted to these technologies because of
convenience, increasing ease of use, and in some instances cost savings (Anguelov et al.,
2004). E-banking, in particular, has grown at impressive rates. Between 1995 and 2003,
e-banking increased eightfold (Hogarth and Anguelov, 2004). Between late 2002 and
early 2005, use of online banking increased 47%, a clear evidence that e-banking is
associated with better household financial management (Smith, 2006).
All businesses, including small and medium scale industries, no matter their
geographical locations, are all beneficiaries of e-banking. It encompasses all kinds of
commercial transaction that is conducted on an electronic medium, mostly through the
internet. E-banking links business to customers no matter their geographical location.
It allows companies to make new business contacts from different global business
alliances, test new products and services, and make market research and other enquiries
all at a minimal cost both financial and otherwise (Shin, 2008).
Smaller community banks, among others, are more interested in the application of
e-banking to gain certain competitive edges over their larger counterparts (Yang et al.,
2007). In addition to previous e-banking delivery systems, Automated Teller Machines
(ATMs) and telephone transaction processing centres, online banking provides banks a
new and more efficient electronic delivery tool (Costanzo, 2000). While ATMs were first
introduced in early 1980s and initially an attempt to reduce operating costs, telephone call
centres were developed in the 1990s to handle simple transactions and provide added
customer services from a remote location. E-banking has been viewed as an upgrading
from previous electronic delivery systems to open new business opportunities for the
banking industry (Ebling, 2001).
This paper describes an empirical study of investigating recent trend and
development of the application of e-banking (banking though internet) in a typical
developing country – Bangladesh, and its economic impact on local financial institutions.
Currently, Bangladesh is far behind in terms of e-banking development and applications.
More specifically, while it is a fact that currently many banks in Bangladesh have
implemented e-banking services, however, comparing with most developed countries,
the e-banking application in Bangladesh is only in its infancy stage and there is a
huge gap to be fulfilled with new research and development effort. As such, addressing
the current issues and challenges in the development of e-banking in Bangladesh is the
primary motivation of this research.
Recent trends and developments in e-banking in an underdeveloped nation 117
2 Literature review
For the past two decades, the banking sector has chosen a new service channel based on
the progress of information technology – internet to respond to the changes in customer
preferences and needs, increasing competition from non-banks, changes in demographic
and social trends, and government deregulations of the financial service sector (Byers and
Lederer, 2001). In the search for sustainable competitive advantages in the technological
financial service industry, banks have acknowledged the value to differentiate themselves
from other financial institutions through new service distribution channels (Daniel, 1999).
In addition, customer’s transaction and communication abilities have been improved by
the developments of information technology. Information technology enabled electronic
channels to perform many banking functions that would traditionally be carried out
over the counter (Giannakoudi, 1999). The rise of electronic payments media such as
debit and credit cards has caused the value of cheques paid in the USA to fall to – from
about $49 billion in 1995 to about $42 billion in 2002 (Gerdes and Walton, 2002).
Furthermore, the use of paper cheques has been supplemented step-by-step with
e-cheques (i.e., electronic images) allowing banks to have more storage capacity, reduce
costs, and improve customer services (Rose and Hudgins, 2005).
Banks have traditionally been in the forefront of harnessing technology to
improve their products and services. They have over the time been using electronic and
telecommunication networks for delivering a wide range of value added products and
services. The range of services and products offered by different banks vary widely both
in their contents and sophistication. E-banking provides enormous benefits to consumers
in terms of the ease and cost of transactions (Liu, 2008). However, it can be thought of as
a service that allows customers to use some types of computers to access account-specific
information and possibly conduct transactions from a remote location – such as at home
or at the workplace (Saleh and Andrea, 2002).
The growth in e-banking with the increase in the range of interface options available
to access online banking solutions has resulted in a steady increase in the number of
customers interacting through remote channels to a greater extent than before. In a
climate of increasing online competition, banks that have chosen to retain extensive
branch networks are re-aligning the roles of staff in these branches and moving towards a
relationship-driven sales culture (Durkin, 2007). E-banking has been around for some
time in the form of automated teller machine and telephone transactions. More recently,
it has been transformed by the internet – a new delivery channel that is fast, convenient,
available round the clock, and from whatever the customer’s location (Saleh and
Andrea, 2002). E-banking also can increase competition among banks, and allows banks
to penetrate new markets and thus expand their geographical reach. Some even see
e-banking as an opportunity for countries with underdeveloped financial systems to
leapfrog into advanced stages (Gao and Owolabi, 2008). Customer in such countries can
access services more easily from banks outside one’s own country through wireless
communication systems, which are developing more rapidly than traditional ‘wired’
communication networks (Gao and Owolabi, 2008).
A more recent e-banking development is wireless internet applications of banking
sometimes called m-banking (mobile banking) (Choi et al., 2006; Scornavacca and
Hoehle, 2007). With the combination of two most recent technological advancements
– internet and mobile phone, a new service (mobile data service) is thus enabled and
118 J. Yang and K.T. Ahmed
the first such wireless internet commercial transaction is performed by the banking
industry (Barnes and Corbitt, 2003). It is believed that m-banking will provide
another new channel for banking services, especially for certain remote areas where
online internet is still unavailable. Strategic implications and customer perception of
m-banking services are explored (Laukkanen and Lauronen, 2005) with a focus on the
consumer value creation and a better understanding about the customer-perceived value
of m-banking services. For instance, mobile internet service has been quite popular
in Japan (over 60 millions users in 2003) especially for those young and single
(i.e., unmarried) consumers (Scornavacca and Barnes, 2004). A summarised literature
review is described below.
3 Research methodology
The original data for this research are collected through a comprehensive web-based
questionnaire survey (see Appendix), as well as some interviews with several
bankers from selected banks in Bangladesh. As shown in Appendix, the questionnaire
items are designed to capture bankers’ perceptions regarding e-banking, demographic
features, strategic considerations, operating issues, its effects on banks, customer-bank
relationships, technology considerations, and services offered through e-banking system.
This study focuses on the effect of e-banking on banks’ strategic and operational
dimensions. Strategic issues include such factors as threats posed by e-banks and the need
to offer internet banking; operational issues include providing better customer service,
lowering transaction costs, and providing additional financial services to customers. A set
of items was generated to gauge banks’ perceptions on the strategic and operational
impact of internet banking. Moreover, the questionnaire also focused on some related
demographic features which describe the size of the banks in terms of assets and their
customers. Similarly items are crafted to assess the benefits and services the customers
are getting by using the e-banking, as well as the technological considerations.
In the survey, those operational and strategic questions and benefit of the
e-banking are measured by the normally used five-point Likert scale (1 = strongly
disagree; 5 = strongly agree). In comparison, to make the questions easy to answer by
survey participants, those technological items are designed with simple ‘Yes’ or ‘No’
choices. For those items which may have multiple selections (like demographic and
current available e-banking services) the questionnaire was designed using ‘Check all
that apply’ option.
After an extensive and persistent selection effort in the city of Dhaka, Bangladesh,
there are 18 banks randomly selected to participate in this research. The survey results are
discussed in the next section.
4 Result analysis
The results of Questions 1–3 of the survey are presented in Figures 1 and 2,
showing the basic demographic information pertaining to the e-banking in Bangladesh.
From Figure 1, it can be seen that the asset size of the commercial banks in Bangladesh
is not very healthy. Most of the banks’ asset fall into the category of less than $20 million
122 J. Yang and K.T. Ahmed
range. Only two banks’ total asset is more than $100 million which represent that most of
the commercial banks in Bangladesh are not very healthy in terms of their asset size.
It may be surprising to see in Figure 2 that a huge majority of customers in Bangladesh
are either not familiar with the e-banking services and not using it at all or using
e-banking rarely – there are 50% of customers with ‘Less than 25%’ e-banking services
usage followed by 44% customers under ‘26% to 50%’ e-banking practice category.
These data clearly indicate that although e-banking service has been offered by most of
the commercial banks in Bangladesh, but a majority of people are either not familiar with
the system or not willing to use the e-banking service.
Figure 1 Total assets of surveyed banks (see online version for colours)
11%
39% Less than $20 million
22%
Between $20 and $30 million
Between $50 and $99 million
More than $100 million
28%
Figure 2 Percentage of current bank customers using e-banking services (see online version
for colours)
6% 0%
The results about the e-banking operational issues are summarised in Table 1. It can be
seen from Table 1 that almost 90% of the banks reported that the benefits of internet
banking outweigh the associated costs. This certainly should be viewed as a positive
sign from the business perspective, that all banks in a underdeveloped nation
(like Bangladesh) have been convinced to believe in the benefit and the potential
from the development of e-banking services – which could be the primary motivation for
those banks in their future e-banking development. In addition, the participating banks
Recent trends and developments in e-banking in an underdeveloped nation 123
reported benefits in the following areas: increases in the customer base (72.22%),
improvements in customer service (88.89%), lower transaction costs (83.33%),
opportunities to offer additional services (e.g., insurance, brokerage services, credit
card applications) (94.44%), secured the customer’s personal information (83.33%),
and increased customer satisfaction (88.89%). All are remarkable improvements from
banks’ operational perspective. Clearly, it is evidenced that even in an underdeveloped
nation (like Bangladesh), the banks offering e-banking services will have much more
competitive advantages compared to their counterpart who do not offer e-banking
services. However, only 27.78% of the respondents believed that customer accounts
would be less costly to maintain through internet banking. The survey also revealed that
more customer training/education is needed (61.11%) in promoting e-banking services.
Table 2 displays the result from the survey pertaining to the strategic considerations.
For example, about half (50%) of surveyed banks believed that developing e-banking
services is essential for a bank’s survival in the marketplace and thus mandatory in order
to compete effectively. In addition, 39% of banks reported that banks not offering
internet banking services would lose customers to other banks and the rest (61%)
responded neutrally about this strategic issue. All surveyed banks (100%) agreed that
internet banking improves bank’s efficiency so that they can offer better services.
Furthermore, a majority (89%) of the respondents said that they have established
e-banking into their banks’ future strategic planning. The same amount of respondents
(89%) also believed that using the e-banking system gives their banks an impression of a
progressive bank in the market. All the above confirm the fact that has been observed in
the development of e-banking industry in the current developed nations.
124 J. Yang and K.T. Ahmed
For the questions towards assessing the impact of e-banking on the bank’s customers,
the results are displayed in Table 3. As using e-banking implies to the customers
the potential reduction of physical visits to the banks, easy online payment, viewing the
statement online anytime, and accessing on the account around the clock, positive
responses are expected. Not surprisingly, as seen in Table 3, a majority of surveyed
banks (77.78%) view that e-banking service has significantly benefited their customers.
For instance, over 88.89% indicated that the availability of e-banking reduced the
frequency of customer visits to a physical bank, which in turn saves time and money
for both customers and bankers. Most surveyed banks (72.22%) responded that
customers can access to accounts around the clock is one of the most important features
of e-banking to the customers. Customers can view the monthly statement and make
payment online is viewed another important benefit (77.78%). A majority of bankers
(55.56%) believe that customers enjoy their benefit by using the e-banking, and about
72.22% agree that customers are secured in using e-banking.
Technological issues of e-banking development are also part of interest in this research,
and the results from the survey about those technology related considerations are
displayed in Table 4. Some important implications can be learned from Table 4,
for example, a majority of the banks (78%) reported that they are lack of high quality IT
professionals to design and develop their e-banking systems, a clear signal for the lack
of higher education institutions and training capacity in a least-developed country like
Bangladesh. That is confirmed when over half (57%) indicate that they had difficulties
in finding and recruiting talented high quality IT individuals to run their e-banking
operations. In addition, only half (50%) of the banks believe that government is providing
enough support to train more qualified IT professional in order to meet this demand
for e-banking development (and other high technology industries). And consequently,
only 28% of banks agree that maintaining such an e-banking system is an easy task.
The results above clearly indicate that while the shortage of talented IT professionals
in the information technology and specifically in the e-commerce area may be a major
short-term obstacle in the further development of e-banking in Bangladesh, but to build
more modern up-to-date high quality higher education institutions and the foundation to
improve the educational level of general population by the government and the society as
a whole should be a real long-term solution.
The final two sections of the survey are focused on the current available e-banking
services and the areas to assist potential customers by the banks in promoting
e-banking system. The results about the current available e-banking services (provided by
the surveyed banks) are displayed in Figure 3. It is interesting to see that in this research,
less than half of surveyed banks (39%) currently offer online enquiry and transfers
service – the very basic service of any e-banking systems in the developed nations.
While over 50% of selected banks (61.11%) provide online billing payment service,
may be a positive sign. In contrast, only one-third of banks (33.33%) allow online
deposit account service. As expected, most advanced e-banking services such as: online
small business loans and online trust fund are all very limited (less than 5%), quite
insignificant. The above results confirm the presumption of this research that there
is a huge gap between those well developed and new emerging economic powers
(like the USA, European nations, and China) and those least-developed nations (like
Bangladesh) in terms of the development and application of e-banking services,
as well as other high-tech industries. While an international help from world’s developed
nations certainly will be a big plus, but the policies and appropriate effort of the
governments of those least-developed nations will be the key to reduce this gap in the
foreseeable future.
126 J. Yang and K.T. Ahmed
Figure 3 List of e-banking services currently provided (see online version for colours)
E-banking services
Online inquiry and transfers
Online bill-pay
Figure 4 Available assistance to e-banking customers (see online version for colours)
30%
Brochures
48%
Training
Online banking demo
Others
11%
11%
Recent trends and developments in e-banking in an underdeveloped nation 127
This paper describes an empirical study about the major issues and challenges in
the development of e-banking applications faced in relatively underdeveloped nations
– based on a case study in a typical underdeveloped nation – Bangladesh. The research
objective is to investigate the current trend and development of e-banking industry and
therefore to provide managerial insights for the banking industry in those underdeveloped
nations. The primary data for this study are collected through a carefully designed survey
questionnaire, and in the survey, over 18 commercial banks in this underdeveloped nation
are randomly selected. This research shows that even in a least-developed developing
nation, the application of e-banking can help their local banks to reduce related operating
costs and provide a better and fast service to their customers.
However, this research also reveals that there is a huge gap between those
well developed and new emerging economic powers (like the USA, European nations,
and China) and those least-developed nations (like Bangladesh) in terms of development
and application of e-banking services. For example, there is still a huge population in
these least-developed nations are either not familiar with the e-banking services and not
using it at all, although e-banking service has been offered by local commercial banks.
In addition, there is a large shortage in those least-developed nations in terms of
high quality IT professionals to design, develop, and operate their e-banking systems.
A learned implication is that reducing such a shortage of talented IT professionals in the
information technology through high quality training may be a short-term answer to this
challenge in the further development of e-banking application, but to develop up-to-date
high quality higher education institutions and the foundation to improve the educational
level of general population by the government and the society (as a whole) should be a
real long-term solution. To realise the above objective, while an international help
(especially from those developed nations) will be a big plus, but the policies and
commitments of the governments of those least-developed nations will be the key to the
expected success.
This research has some limitations. First, due to the time constraint, a larger sample
size was not obtained. Furthermore, the sample did not include those working in the
government-owned banks in Bangladesh. In addition, in order to avoid a very lengthy
survey questionnaire, some important and related e-banking issues (i.e., specific
technological obstacle) are not covered in the designed questionnaire.
References
Anguelov, C.E., Marianne, A.H. and Hogarth, J.M. (2004) ‘U.S. consumers and electronic banking:
1995–2003’, Federal Reserve Bulletin, Vol. 90, Winter, pp.1–18.
Barnes, S.J. and Corbitt, B. (2003) Int. J. of Mobile Communications, Vol. 1, No. 3, pp.273–288.
Boss, S., McGranahan, D. and Mehta, A. (2000) ‘Will the banks control online banking?’,
McKinsey Quarterly, pp.70–77.
Byers, R.E. and Lederer, P.L. (2001) ‘Retail banking service strategy: a model of traditional,
electronic, and mixed distribution choices’, Journal of Management Information Systems,
Vol. 18, No. 2, pp.133–156.
128 J. Yang and K.T. Ahmed
Carlson, J., Furst, K., Lang, W.W. and Nolle, D.E. (2000) ‘Internet banking: market developments
and regulatory issues’, in The New Economy: What Has Changed, and the Challenges for
Economic Policy, Society of Government Economists Conference, Washington, DC, pp.1–33.
Choi, Y.B., Crowgey, R.L., Price, J.M. and VanPelt, J.S. (2006) ‘The state-of-the-art of
mobile payment architecture and emerging issues’, Int. J. Electronic Finance, Vol. 1, No. 1,
pp.94–103.
Costanzo, C. (2000) ‘Pioneer internet-only bank has a new strategy’, American Banker, Vol. 165,
No. 19, pp.1–2.
Daniel, E. (1999) ‘Provision of electronic banking in the UK and Ireland’, International Journal of
Bank Marketing, Vol. 17, No. 2, pp.72–82.
Durkin, M. (2007) ‘On the role of bank staff in online customer purchase’, Marketing Intelligence
& Planning Journal, Vol. 25, No. 1, pp.82–97.
Ebling, T. (2001) ‘The economics of online banking’, Target Marketing, Philadelphia, Vol. 24,
No. 2, pp.67–78.
Feinman, T., Goldman, D., Wong, R. and Cooper, N. (1999) ‘Security basics: a whitepaper’,
http://islab.oregonstate.edu/koc/ece478/notes/security101.pdf.
Furst, K., Lang, W.W. and Nolle, D. (2000) ‘Internet banking: developments and prospects’,
Working Paper 2000–9, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, Economic and
Policy Analysis.
Gao, P. and Owolabi, O. (2008) ‘Consumer adoption of internet banking in Nigeria’, Int. J.
Electronic Finance, Vol. 2, No. 3, pp.284–299.
Gerdes, G.R. and Walton, J.K. (2002) ‘The use of checks and other noncash payment instruments
in the United States’, Federal Reserve Bulletin, pp.360–370.
Gerrard, P. and Cunningham, J.B. (2003) ‘The diffusion of internet banking among Singapore
consumers’, International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 21, No. 1, pp.16–28.
Giannakoudi, S. (1999) ‘Internet banking: the digital voyage of banking and money in cyberspace’,
Information and Communications Technology Law, Vol. 8, No. 3, pp.205–243.
Hackett, J. (2000) ‘Gauging prospects of net mortgages: the health of the online banking sector
may be the canary in the mineshaft’, Mortgage Technology, Vol. 28, March, pp.12–20.
Hogarth, J.M. and Anguelov, C.E. (2004) ‘Are families who use e-banking better financial
managers?’, Financial Counseling and Planning, Vol. 15, No. 2, pp.61–78.
Howcroft, B., Hamilton, R. and Hewer, P. (2002) ‘Consumer attitude and the usage and adoption of
home-based banking in the United Kingdom’, The International Journal of Bank Marketing,
Vol. 20, No. 3, pp.111–121.
Hughes, T. (2003) ‘Marketing challenges in e-banking standalone or integrated?’, Journal of
Marketing Management, Vol. 19, pp.1067–1085.
Hwang, H., Chen, R. and Lee, J. (2007) ‘Measuring customer satisfaction with internet banking:
an exploratory study’, Int. J. Electronic Finance, Vol. 1, No. 3, pp.321–335.
Kaleem, A. and Ahmad, S. (2008) ‘Bankers’ perceptions of electronic banking in Pakistan’,
Journal of Internet Banking and Commerce, Vol. 13, No. 1, pp.23–36.
Kolodinsky, J.M., Hogarth, J.M. and Hilgert, M.A. (2004) ‘The adoption of electronic banking
technologies by US consumers’, International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 22, No. 4,
pp.233–241.
Laukkanen, T. and Lauronen, J. (2005) ‘Consumer value creation in mobile banking services’,
Int. J. Mobile Communications, Vol. 3, No. 4, pp.325–338.
Leow, H. and Bee, H. (1999) ‘New distribution channels in banking services’, Bankers Journal
Malaysia, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp.45–56.
Liu, C.C. (2008) ‘The relationship between digital capital of internet banking and business
performance’, Int. J. Electronic Finance, Vol. 2, No. 1, pp.18–30.
Recent trends and developments in e-banking in an underdeveloped nation 129
Appendix
Questionnaire about e-banking in Bangladesh
E-banking Please refer to all banking activities/transactions through internet for this research
Responses
Demographic issues (Please select only one for each question below)
Internet banking
1. What are the total assets of your bank? [ ] Less than $20 million
[ ] Between $20 and $30 million
(Small vs. Large) [ ] Between $50 and $99 million
[ ] More than $100 million
2. Based on your estimate, how many of your customers [ ] Less than 25%
have been using the e-banking services from [ ] 26% to 50%
your branch?
[ ] 51% to 75%
[ ] Over 75%
3. Based on your estimate how many total numbers of [ ] Less than 500
customers you have in your branch? [ ] 501 to 2000
[ ] 2001 to 5000
[ ] 5001 to 8000
[ ] 8001 to 10 000
[ ] Over 10 000
Strongly Strongly
Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Disagree
Operational issues (5) (4) (3) (2) (1)
Please rank the following statement with
5-Strongly Agree; 4-Agree; 3-Neutral; 2-Disagree;
1-Strongly Disagree.
Internet banking
4. Benefit outweigh the cost
5. Allows banks to increase customer base
6. Improves customer service
7. Lowers transaction costs
8. Offers opportunities to provide
additional services
9. Accounts are less costly to maintain
10. More customer training/customer education is
needed in promoting e-banking services.
11. E-banking services will enhance your
competitive position in the market.
12. Your e-banking services increased the degree of
customer satisfaction.
13. Your bank believes that the customer’s personal
information security is better now than it
was before.
Recent trends and developments in e-banking in an underdeveloped nation 131