Professional Documents
Culture Documents
400 Commonwealth Drive, Warrendale, PA 15096-0001 U.S.A. Tel: (724) 776-4841 Fax: (724) 776-5760 Web: www.sae.org
The Engineering Meetings Board has approved this paper for publication. It has successfully completed
SAE's peer review process under the supervision of the session organizer. This process requires a
minimum of three (3) reviews by industry experts.
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or
transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise,
without the prior written permission of SAE.
SAE Permissions
400 Commonwealth Drive
Warrendale, PA 15096-0001-USA
Email: permissions@sae.org
Tel: 724-772-4028
Fax: 724-776-3036
ISSN 0148-7191
Copyright 2006 SAE International
Positions and opinions advanced in this paper are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of SAE.
The author is solely responsible for the content of the paper. A process is available by which discussions
will be printed with the paper if it is published in SAE Transactions.
Persons wishing to submit papers to be considered for presentation or publication by SAE should send the
manuscript or a 300 word abstract to Secretary, Engineering Meetings Board, SAE.
Printed in USA
2006-01-0694
1
BRAKE THERMAL ANALYSIS MODEL FLUENT: BRAKESYN :
Radiation view factors Normal brake force.
A brake thermal model has been developed to simulate and convection heat
the transient heating and cooling process to predict the transfer coefficients of
rotor temperature rise and thermal deformation under brake surfaces.
cyclic braking and acceleration. The flow chart of the
simulation process is shown in Figure 1. In this model FORTRAN:
the heat flux generated during the braking was FORTRAN: Heat flux generated at
calculated using a FORTRAN subroutine. The Radiation and convection different vehicle
convection and equivalent radiation heat transfer heat transfer coefficients speeds.
coefficients of the surfaces of the brake system at at different vehicle
different vehicle speeds were predicted using a brake-in- speeds.
vehicle CFD model and the other FORTRAN subroutine.
Finally, an ABAQUS thermal model was used to
simulate the transient heat transfer and then predict the ABAQUS:
rotor temperature rise and lateral thermal deformation Transient state -
using the predicted heat flux and convection and coupled temperature
radiation heat transfer coefficients as inputs. The and displacement
modeling of heat flux generation, heat transfer on brake analysis.
surfaces, and heat conduction in the brake system are
outlined in the following subsections.
Post-Processing:
ESTIMATION OF HEAT FLUX GENERATION Thermal deformation
and temperature
The heat flux on the friction surface at each vehicle distribution.
speed was calculated using a FORTRAN subroutine.
The total heat flux generated by friction between the
rotor and pad (on each side of the disk rotor) was given Figure 1: Flow chart of simulation process.
by
q '' = µ PRω rotor were same. Here q”, ρ, C, and k denote heat flux,
, ……………….. (1)
density, specific heat and thermal conductivity,
respectively. The weighting factor of the heat distribution
where µ, P, R, and ω were pad friction coefficient, to the rotor could be finally adjusted by correlating the
contact pressure between the rotor and pad, distance simulated brake equilibrium temperature rise to the
between node and rotor center, and rotor angular physical test data.
velocity, respectively. The contact pressure was
calculated based on the normal brake force that was
ESTIMATION OF SURFACE HEAT TRANSFER
estimated using BrakeSyn, a PC-based software
developed at GM.
Initially the convection heat transfer coefficients and
equivalent radiation view factors of surfaces of rotor,
The distribution of the heat flux between the rotor and
hub, and wheel at vehicle speeds of 24 km/h and 64
pad could be estimated by the ratio of the total thermal
km/h were estimated using a brake-in-vehicle CFD
resistance on pad side and the total thermal resistance
model as shown in Figure 2. In the CFD model the air
on rotor side. However, the transient convection heat
inside the rotor, rotor outside surfaces, hub, half shaft,
transfer, anisotropic thermal property of the pad,
wheel, and tire were set to rotation based on the vehicle
complicated thermal property of insulator, and the
speed. In order to make the solution easy to converge,
thermal conduction among the rotor, wheel, hub and half
the full turbulent region was resolved by using the
shaft made the total thermal resistances on both sides
standard K-ε turbulence model, i.e. the baseline two
difficult to be estimated. In this study, the distribution of
transport equation model solving for turbulence kinetic
the heat flux between the rotor and pad was estimated
using the equation proposed by Rudolf [2], energy k and dissipation rate of turbulence energy ε. In
order to capture the geometric details of the rotor
particularly the geometry of vane or pillar post that
"
q rotor ρ rotor C rotor k rotor played important roles on the brake cooling, the element
=
q "pad ρ pad C pad k pad sizes of the rotor surfaces were 2 ~ 5 mm. The small
, ………. (2) size of the surface element would cause yp to be small.
Here yp is the distance between the wall and the center
which was given based on the assumptions that the of the first layer of tetra element generated in the TGrid
thicknesses of solid disk rotor and pad were semi-infinite based on the surface element. As a result, the values of
+ +
and the temperatures of friction surfaces of pad and y ( y = uτyp/ν ) on the rotor surfaces would be smaller
2
Rotor hat Steel wheel
Rotor vane
Half shaft
q r" = ε F σ (T surface
4 4
− Tambient )
, …………. (3)
The convection and equivalent radiation heat transfer entire circle of the rotor so that the heat transfer in the
coefficients of the brake surfaces at other different rotor was periodically axisymmetric. As a result, only one
vehicle speeds during the braking and acceleration trimmed sector of the rotor, pad, hub, wheel, and half
cycles were calculated using the other FORTRAN shaft needed to be modeled. The averaged contact
subroutine, where the equivalent radiation heat transfer pressure between the trimmed sectors of pad and rotor
coefficient hr was given by in the model was given by
hr = ε F σ (Tsurface
2
+ Tambient
2
) (Tsurface + Tambient ) Normal brake force
. .....(4) p= . (5)
Pad sweeping area on rotor surface
TRANSIENT HEAT TRANSFER MODELING
The sector angle was chosen as small as possible to
An ABAQUS 3D thermal model shown in Figure 3 was reduce computing cost and guarantee periodically
developed to calculate surface heat transfer based on axisymmetric thermal results. For example, the trimming
the inputs from above two FORTRAN subroutines and to sector angle for an axisymmetric rotor with same vanes
solve the transient heat conduction in the brake system. shown in Figure 4 was given by
Consequentially the brake rotor temperature rise and
thermal deformation could be examined. Considering 180 0
Sector angle = . ..……. (6)
the analytical accuracy and computing cost, it was number of vanes
assumed that each pad was uniformly distributed around
3
o
R o to r T em p eratu re R ise( C ) 500
400
Simulation
Test
300
200
100
0
0 400 800 1200 1600
Time (s)
Figure 5: The brake rotor temperature rise. Figure 6a: A pillar post rotor. Figure 6b: A vane rotor.
Rotor Size
Fig. 8a:Original dust shield. Fig. 8b:Modified dust shield. The effect of the distance between the dust shield and
the rotor on the brake equilibrium temperature rise was
studied by increasing the distance between the modified
dust shield and the rotor from original 5 mm to 7.5 mm. It
was found that the mass flow rate through the vented
area of the rotor was, however, slightly decreased by
approximately 3%. As a result, the convection coefficient
of the rotor was slightly reduced by 1% and the brake
equilibrium temperature rise was increased by 2 °C. This
is because increasing the distance between the modified
dust shield and the rotor by moving the dust shield
towards the knuckle as shown in Figure 9 would reduce
the effective flow area of the flow slots in the modified
dust shield and block the flow entrainment to the rotor.
This again confirmed that the flow slots in the central
area of the modified dust shield played an important role
to the mass flow rate and convection coefficient of the
rotor.
Figure 9: Location of dust shield.
EFFECT OF WHEEL AND WHEEL COVER
Table 3: Effect of dust shield on brake cooling performance. The small flow passage at the exit of the steel wheel and
its cover significantly reduced the amount of air flowing
Original dust Modified dust over the rotor cheeks and vanes causing the averaged
shield shield
convection heat transfer coefficient to decrease and
24 km/h 64 km/h 24 km/h 64 km/h
brake equilibrium temperature rise of the rotor to
Mass flow rate
through rotor 0.0041 0.0103 0.0068 0.0179 increase. In order to estimate the improvement of the
vented area (kg/s) brake cooling performance by using the aluminum wheel
Mass flow rate - - with relatively large flow passage area, the brake
through two 0.0036 0.0083 thermal analyses were performed on the vehicles with
central slots (kg/s) two different wheels, i.e. a standard 16” steel wheel and
Convection heat its cover shown in Figure 10a and a standard 16”
transfer coefficient 16.02 32.96 18.61 38.27 aluminum wheel shown in Figure 10b. Simulations
2
(W/m ⋅k) indicated that the averaged convection heat transfer
Reduction of coefficients of the rotor installed in the aluminum wheel
brake equilibrium 0 -29 were approximately 36% larger than those of the rotor
temperature rise
o installed in the steel wheel at the vehicle speeds from 24
( C)
km/h to 64 km/h. Consequentially the brake equilibrium
temperature rise of the rotor could be reduced by
shields are summarized in table 3. It can be seen that approximately 70 °C by replacing the standard steel
the mass flow rate through the vented area of the rotor wheel and its cover with the aluminum wheel.
with the modified dust shield was approximately 70%
larger than that of the rotor with the original dist shield. Simulations also indicated that the wheel cover also had
This is because the rotation of the rotor caused the an effect on the brake cooling performance. The
pressure at its central area to be lower than that in the convection heat transfer coefficients and the brake
area outside the dust shield. This pressure difference led equilibrium temperature rise of the rotor could be
to the strong flow entrainment to the vented area of the
increased by approximately 4% and decreased by 11 °C,
rotor through the two central flow slots. For example, the
respectively, by deleting the wheel cover.
6
the air deflector shown in Figure 11 could be about 1.5%
smaller than that of the rotor without the air deflector at
the vehicle speed from 24 km/h to 64 km/h. As a result,
the brake equilibrium temperature rise could be reduced
by 4 °C by deleting the air deflectors. This is because in
the case without air deflectors there would be more air
impinging upon front rotating tires so that the pressures
in front of the rotating tires would be increased. The
large pressure in front of the tires would intensify the air
flowing into the front rotors causing the rotor temperature
to decrease. On the other hand, the large pressure in
front of the rotating tires caused the drag force to
increase. For example, the drag force could be
increased by 0.2% at the vehicle speed of 64 km/h in the
Fig.10a: Steel wheel and cover. Fig. 10b: Aluminum wheel. case without two air deflectors.
7
REFERENCES 8. Thomas Valvano and Kwanggjin Lee, “An Analytical
Method to Predict Thermal Distortion of a Brake Rotor,”
1. Masahiro Kubota, Tomihiro Suenaga, and Kazuhiro SAE 2000-01-0445.
Doi, “A Study of the Mechanism Causing High-Speed 9. David A. Johnson, Bryan A. Sperandei and Ross
Brake Judder,” SAE 980594. Gilbert, “Analysis of the Flow Through a Vented
2. Rudolf Limpert, Brake Design and Safety, 1992. Automotive Brake Rotor”, Journal of Fluids Engineering,
Vol. 125, 2003.
3. Fluent 6.1.22 User Mannual, Fluent Inc..
4. ABAQUS/Standard User’s Mannual, Version 6.3,
Hibbitt, Karlsson & Sorensen, Inc.. CONTACT
5. Example Problems Manual, Version 6.3, Hibbitt,
Hongguang Sun, Ph.D.
Karlsson & Sorensen, Inc..
Canadian Regional Engineering Center,
6. Cheng Qian, “Aerodynamic Shape Optimization using
General Motors of Canada Limited,
CFD Parametric Model with Brake Cooling Application,”
SAE 2002-01-0599. 1908 Colonel Sam Drive, Oshawa, Ontrio, L1H 8P7
Tel. (905) 644-5282
7. Akira Fukano and Hiromichi Matsi, “Development of
Email: hongguang.sun@gm.com
Disc-Brake Design Method Using Computer Simulation
of Heat Phenomena,” SAE 860634.