Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Language Resources:
Specific people, places, and events are named (“On Saturday, our class had a sleepover at
This section describes the key characteristics of “recount” purpose writing.
Kelly Tarlton’s Underwater World in Auckland” or “Today, we raided Lindisfarne Abbey to
gather more gold for our longboat”). Detailed recounting makes extensive use of descriptive
Using the Scoring Rubric verbs, adverbs, adjectives, and idiomatic language to catch and maintain reader interest.
The progress indicators in the scoring rubric have been developed to help teachers understand There is frequent use of prepositional phrases, adverbials, and adjectivals to contextualise
and evaluate their students’ progress and achievement in writing. Teachers are asked to make the events that unfold. Dialogue or direct speech is often used to give the recount a
a “best-fit” judgement as to the level at which their student’s writing most predominantly sits for “realistic” feel, to assist in the reconstruction of the events, or to provide opportunities to
each of the seven content areas: Audience Awareness and Purpose, Content/Ideas, comment on the happenings.
Structure/Organisation, Language Resources, Grammar, Spelling, and Punctuation. Many action verbs tell of happenings and of the behaviours of those involved. Some
relational verbs are used to tell how things are as the writer reflects, observes or comments.
The choice and use of vocabulary often reflects the desire to create particular images or
feelings for the reader. Verbs are commonly in the past tense, though tense can vary in the
Deep Features comments (“On Tuesday, Mary and I went to the shop. We are best friends.”).
Structure/Organisation:
Recounts are organised around a sequenced account of events or happenings. They follow
a time sequence in that they are organised through time (i.e., conjunctions and adverbials
show linkages in setting events in time and ordering the events and the passage of time).
Scoring Rubric, Purpose: RECOUNT
audience content, language, and and writing style. choice of content, language, deliberate choice of
writing style. and writing style. content, language, and
writing style.
Attempts to retell a past Retells a past experience or Attempts to capture the Deliberately tries to inform Deliberately tries to inform Deliberately tries to inform
experience or happening. happening. audience’s interest through and/or entertain audience and/or entertain audience and/or entertain audience
a variety of means e.g., through a variety of means, through a variety of means through a variety of
humour, selected e.g., humour, selected e.g., humour, selected means, e.g., humour,
anecdotes, language anecdotes, language choices. anecdotes, language choices selected anecdotes,
choices. and some relevant reflective language choices, and
comments on the action. relevant reflective
comments on the action.
Assumes shared knowledge Assumes shared knowledge Gives audience most Gives audience information Speaks directly and/or
of the context with the of the context with the information needed to needed to make sense of the indirectly to audience
audience audience. make sense of the past past experience or happening’ making strong
experience or happening. e.g., sufficient description of connections and drawing
e.g. sufficient description of setting and situation. audience into recount.
setting and situation. Adjusts content, details,
and style to effectively
bridge gap between writer
and audience.
May include hook at Uses beginning of text to Beginning of text attracts
beginning of text to engage attract attention and attention and provides
audience’s interest, provide adequate context adequate context for recount.
for the recount.
Writing covers one or more Begins with an orientation Begins with an orientation Uses essential elements of Includes a comprehensive, Writer’s sense of looking
domains appropriate to (background information) (background information) recount. yet succinct orientation. back and analysing
purpose, e.g., happenings, using some of the elements using elements of recount, Focuses on and develops some Focuses on and develops event(s) is fully
Content/Ideas
participants, timeframe, of recount, e.g., happenings, e.g., happenings, specific events and interest specific events and interest integrated through the
place. participants, timeframe, place, participants, timeframe, areas, which may link to a areas with clarity. recount.
etc. place etc. central theme or emotion.
Some attempt to add detail Attempts to add detail. Attempts to add detail in Shows some evidence of Shows evidence of interpretive Enriches recount with
order to comment on, or interpretative reflection, reflection, thoughtful interpretive comments,
evaluate significant points thoughtful observations, and observations, and evaluative evaluations, observations,
of interest. evaluative comments on comments on recounted and sustained appropriate
recounted events, possibly by events, possibly by sharing selection of details linked
sharing thoughts and feelings thoughts and feelings with the to a central theme or
with the audience. audience.
emotion.
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5 Level 6
(Proficient) (Proficient) (Proficient) (Proficient) (Proficient) (Proficient)
May make a simple attempt to Includes a simple Includes a simple appropriate Links ideas and events in the Links conclusion
conclude. conclusion. conclusion. conclusion to content. thematically to content.
Some evidence of time order. Largely sequences events in Sequences events in time Manages sequencing (events Shapes events to achieve a Shapes events and
time order. order. in time order) well. sense of coherence and reflections and/or
wholeness. observations effectively
to achieve a sense of
coherence and
wholeness.
Sometimes links events by Links events by using simple May links events by using Links events in ways that Uses a range of connectives Organises and
Structure
simple words that indicate the connectives that indicate the connectives (words indicate cause and effect and within and between interweaves detailed
passage of time, e.g., “then”, passage of time e.g., “first”, and/or phrases), e.g., “later /or passage of time, e.g., “such paragraphs. events with interpretive
“next” etc. “then”, next. that evening”, “because” as”, “as a result”, “beforehand”,
reflection and/or
etc. etc.
observations.
Attempts paragraphing. Uses paragraphing linking main Uses paragraphs with main
ideas and supporting details. ideas and supporting details. May experiment with
Links sentences thematically conventional structures for
to topic of paragraph or particular effect or
section. purpose, e.g., repetition,
flashback.
Uses some key content and Attempts to add detail by Adds detail using a range Uses some language devices Selects language devices to Deliberately chooses
high-frequency words using a variety of verbs, of language devices, e.g., selectively to add detail for add detail for impact. descriptive and /or
adverbs, adjectives, and other figurative language impact. figurative language to
language devices, e.g., simile. show physical, emotional,
Language Resources
Attempts to use basic Uses most basic Uses most grammatical Uses most grammatical Uses almost all grammatical Sustained control of
grammatical conventions grammatical conventions conventions correctly conventions correctly when conventions correctly when sentence grammar
when writing simple and correctly when writing simple when writing simple, writing simple, compound, and writing simple, compound, evident throughout piece.
compound sentences, e.g., and compound sentences compound, and some complex sentences. and complex sentences.
Grammar
Shows some simple Uses most simple sentence Uses simple correct Uses consistent correct Uses the conventions of punctuation with few intrusive
sentence indication, e.g. indication i.e., caps, full stops, sentence indication i.e., sentence indication i.e., caps, errors.
capital letters, full stops. question marks. caps, full stops, question full stops, question mark,
marks. exclamation.
Punctuation
Errors may interfere with comprehension. Errors do not interfere with comprehension.
Attempts some other basic Uses some other basic Mostly uses accurate Uses complex punctuation accurately e.g.,
punctuation e.g., caps for punctuation correctly complex punctuation e.g., apostrophes, colons, hyphens
proper nouns, commas in e.g., caps for proper commas, colons, hyphen, Some success with using commas, semicolons for
lists, speech marks, nouns, commas in lists, ellipsis, apostrophe of embedded, parenthetical, and conditional phrases or
apostrophes for contraction. speech marks, possession, and the
clauses.
apostrophes for punctuation for dialogue
contraction
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 Level 5 Level 6
(Proficient) (Proficient) (Proficient) (Proficient) (Proficient) (Proficient)
Spells some high frequency Spells most high frequency Spells most high frequency Few errors within high
words (Lists 1-3) correctly words (Lists 1-4) correctly. words (Lists 1-6) correctly. frequency words (Lists 1-7).
Begins to use come common Understands frequently used Understands most spelling Understands most spelling Demonstrates a good understanding of spelling patterns
Spelling
spelling patterns, e.g., “and”, spelling patterns (e.g., patterns including some patterns including most with few intrusive errors.
“band”, “hand” changing y to ies, double complex patterns (e.g., complex patterns e.g., soft ‘g’
consonant when adding ing). plurals using ch,sh,x,o). or ‘c’, keep the ‘e’ manageable.
Attempts to spell words by Approximate spellings show Has some success with Uses complex multi-syllabic Sustains control of complex Sustains control of
recording dominant sounds in knowledge of consonant multi-syllabic (hygienic), irregular or technical words. multisyllabic, irregular, or complex multisyllabic,
order. sounds, blends, and vowel irregular (yacht), or technical words. irregular, or technical
sounds. technical words. words.
Annotated Examples for Recount Purpose
Content/Ideas 2B
This writer simply recounts events.
The orientation is limited. Content is
relevant but limited and no
foregrounding of specific/important
events is apparent. There is no
attempt to conclude (“it is finished”
appears to refer to the race). This is a
“blow-by-blow” account of swimming
sports – often feels repetitive.
To score higher than 2B S/he needs
to include more background info to
orient the reader. More information
Grammar <2B Spelling <2B about the success of “coming first” in
Control of tense is lacking. Irregular verb Many errors in HFW. Little the races. The writer should be
forms are not understood. Subject verb evidence of common spelling encouraged to reflect on/report
agreement often confused. Most sentences patterns. observations of particular incidents for
incorrect (many run-ons) and meaning is lost. the reader.
Content/Ideas 3P
Some points are selected for attention
but remain underdeveloped (coaches
and calling names). Comments and
evaluations are attempted (“I was
actually feeling nervous”, “I felt great”).
Observation is basic, sequence of events
is related, and an attempt to conclude is
made (“I felt great”).
To score higher than 3P The writer
needs to focus her writing on the
success she achieved in the game. Add
detail and description that will help
readers relate to the recount. Improve
the orientation and conclusion to help
readers focus.
Structure/Organisation 2A
Events are in time order and can be
followed, but seem repetitive
(conjunction use is limited – “as”, “then”,
“and”). No paragraphing evident but
ideas are grouped.
Punctuation 3A Grammar 4P
To score higher than 2A This writer
Sentence punctuation is correct and Most sentences correct. Control of
needs to demonstrate more effective
other basic punctuation is mostly complex sentences though range is
ways of linking ideas across the text and
correct. Some examples of incorrect limited.
to begin using paragraphs to manage the
use of possessive apostrophe To score higher than 4P The writer
structure.
(“friend’s name’s”). needs to demonstrate control of a
To score higher than 3A The writer greater variety of complex sentences.
needs to demonstrate use of Language Resources 3B
complex punctuation. Attempts to add detail but variety of
adjectives and adverbs is limited and is
not maintained throughout the piece.
Some varieties in sentences, but
sentences seem repetitive (“and then”, “I
Spelling 3A then”) at times.
To score higher than 3B The writer
Most HFW spelt correctly. Inconsistent spelling of ‘then’. Evidence of some
needs to learn to vary sentences to keep
understanding of more complex spelling patterns (trial, trialling, repeatedly,
reader interest. Demonstrate evidence of
coaches).
image enhancing
To score higher than 3A This writer needs to demonstrate control of her ability
verbs/adjectives/adverbs.
to spell technical, multi-syllabic and irregular words.
Audience Awareness and
Purpose 6P
Writer interests the audience by
both the content and the mood of
excitement and anticipation.
Comments recalling previous
pleasures, linked to the arrogance of
the skier, hold anticipation high.
Details are kept to the relevant
minimum. The ending is abrupt and
leaves gaps but is just acceptable.
Content/Ideas 6B
Emotional states are used to lead
the audience through the
predictable facts, with sufficient
information being given to set the
scene. The personalised nature of
the writing – opinion, emotion,
expectation, criticism – allows the
audience to identify with the writer.
Structure/Organisation 6B
Good opening sentence – the
“hook” is based on the writer’s
excitement. Background is then
established. The “body” deals
concisely with the decision-making.
The “climax” almost happens off-
stage. The resolution is almost too
economical. Variation of sentence
form and the inclusion of some
dialogue sustain reader interest.
Language Resources 6P
Technical language well used –
naturally included. Emotive
language used throughout,
including colloquial language
(pussy). Stylistic use of repetition.
Occasional imagery adds to
descriptive strengths. Several
impressive expressions – smothers
everything / roasted alive / blank
nothingness Good selection of
vocabulary, especially verbs.
Grammar 6B
No issues. Well controlled.
Punctuation 5P
Punctuation of speech is wrong –
“—wrong?”, I asked / “—pussy”,
he bleated. Several misused or
missing commas.
Spelling 6B
Minor error proof reading rather than
To achieve higher than Level 6B/P The writer would need to attend to the language use (though instead of
conventions for punctuating dialogue. thought).
Audience Awareness and
Purpose 4A
Storyline lurches along without the
audience being prepared for the
movement. “Pet Day” becomes
“Amelia’s disaster”, becomes “Dog
phobia”, becomes “Pet Day”,
becomes “I want to be a vet”. The
event does not seem to be the focus
of the writing. Visual details do
attract and hold the reader’s
attention. The narrator’s decision
seems completely unjustified – only
the word cute suggests an
attraction to animals.
Content/Ideas 4B
School attitude to Pet Day leads to
a vivid account of a girl savaged by
a dog. Description of a phobia
leads very rapidly to a vocational
decision. No facts or practices or
changed emotions are introduced to
justify the decision, or really to
link it to the unfortunate dead girl.
Structure/Organisation 4P
Clearly sectioned into paragraphs
but poorly linked. The logic of the
structure is unclear. Variety of
sentence structures is well used.
Language Resources 4P
Stylistic use of sentence fragments.
Rhetorical questions used to hook
the reader, and to interact with the
reader. Odd expression legumes in
a husk – peas in a pod!
Grammar 4P
Generally reasonable control of the
syntax but stylistic use challenges
that control.
Punctuation 4P
Several missed commas. Several
missed apostrophes. Well-
controlled capitals.
Spelling 4P
Accurate spelling of the basic and
straightforward words selected.