Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Home About Moonsighting Islamic Prayer Qibla Questions Articles Eclipses Lectures Links Do NOT
Us Calendar Times Click
Qur'an does not mention eclipses. However, numerous Ahadith mentioned eclipses, e.g.,
Some people, basically Qadianis (Ahmadiyya), mention another Hadith: "Amr bin Shimr narrates from Jabir
who told him that Muhammad bin Ali said that for our Mehdi, two signs are given which never occurred in the
past from the creation of the heavens and the earth. One is that a lunar eclipse will occur on the first night
of Ramadan and the second sign is that a solar eclipse will occur in the middle of Ramadan and these signs
had never happened from the creation of the heavens and the earth (Dar Qutni)."
ATTENTION:
1. The 3rd narration mentioned above is definitely not the saying of the Messenger (SAW), as the narrator
clearly assigns it as the saying of Imam Muhammad Baqir bin Ali which was written in the book of Dar
Qutni. Attributing this to Imam Muhammad Baqir is also wrong as the first narrator mentioned was
Muhammad bin Ali not Imam Baqir. There were several narrators by the name Muhammad bin Ali and there is
no proof or reason to believe that this person is Imam Baqir. Moreover, Imam Baqir was born 47 years after
the death of the Messenger (SAW), and for a narration to be a Hadith, it must have chains of narration going
. .
back to the Messenger (SAW). This narration clearly does not go back to Messenger (SAW).
2. "According to its authenticity, this saying attributed to Imam Baqir is extremely weak, outcast, and
rejected. Looking at the chain of narration, the second narrator is Amr bin Shimr who has been labeled
(in Meezanul-E'tidaal P262) as the big liar, a narrator of weak and fabricated Ahadith, a non-believer of Hadith,
a person who uses abusive words for the companions of the Messenger (SAW), the Sahabah (Razi-Allahu
unhum ajmaeen), and according to Ilm-ul-Hadith, his narration is not written as Hadith." These are the words
of Allamah Shamsuddin Dhahbi (Rahmatullah Alayhe) who was an expert of the Funn-e-Rijaal, art of
Men Narrators. Thus, it is clear that this narrator is absolutely not reliable nor trustworthy. So, to present
this narration as a Hadith of Rasool (SAW) is not only a great false accusation and a lie but according
to Hadith-e-Sahih (agreed upon Hadith, which says, "Whoever lies upon me deliberately and knowingly
should know that he has made his abode in Jahannam"), it is making an abode in the Hell fire.
The third narrator is Jabir. There were several narrators by this name, and which Jabir is mentioned here
is unknown; someone by this name was known to be a person of unknown parentage or lineage. One among
the persons with the name Jabir was Jabir Ja'fi, who was described by Imam Abu-Hanifah (Rahmatullah Alayhe)
as "among the liars that I met, no one was bigger liar than Jabir Ja'fi." Remember, that Imam Abu-Hanifah,
Imam Baqir, Jabir Ja'fai, and Amr bin Shimr were all born after 47 to 80 years after the death of the
Messenger (SAW).
None of the narrators mentioned that they heard this from Sahabah or Rasool (SAW), and the authenticity of
these narrators is extremely questionable. Now you can tell, how can such narration be labelled as Hadith, and
http://moonsighting.com/eclipses.html (2 of 4) [12/5/2010 5:17:02 PM]
Sun & Moon Eclipses
Lunar eclipse only occurs at full Moon, when the earth passes between the Sun and Moon and
the Earth's shadow sweeps across a portion of Moon's surface and an eclipse of the Moon is seen.
Lunar eclipses are less frequent that solar, and at any given location could be zero to three per year.
Total lunar eclipses are visible everywhere that it is night time as the event takes place - essentially over
half the globe.
Thus, the closest time between solar and lunar eclipse is 2 weeks. Solar eclipse always occurs at the end
of an Islamic month. Lunar eclipse always occurs in the middle of an Islamic month.
At solar eclipse the sun is partially or totally blocked by the moon. Some people are confused with
this phenomenon that the moon surface is seen, and the Islamic month has begun. There is a big
difference in seeing this dark circle blocking the sun and the visible Crescent that marks the beginning of
an Islamic month.
Let me emphasize that a solar eclipse is the proof of disappearance of the moon and does not mark
the beginning of a month. Few years ago Sheikh Ali Al-Tantawi, the Mufti of Egypt at that time, also said
the same thing when the eclipse occurred in Saudi Arabia, and he said in a fatwa that this was a proof of
the disappearance of moon and it is not Hilal nor should it be taken as a Hilal.
An interesting story of lunar eclipse is related to Columbus, the sailor when one of his ships was
damaged and he stranded all his ships and crew in Jamaica (caribbeans). In the beginning the crew
traded things for food with the natives, but later, the natives became annoyed with some of the
less respectful sailors, and refused to deal with Columbus. Columbus and his crew faced starvation.
That's when Columbus used his astronomy knowledge of precalculated lunar eclipse on February 29,
1504. He told them that he would remove the moon from the sky if they would not cooperate with him.
The natives at first did not believe him. Then the full moon rose a blood red, then it began to dim.
The natives worried. The moon got very dim; the natives got very worried. Then the moon disappeared.
The natives were in a panic and pleaded with Columbus. Columbus knew precisely when the moon
would reappear. He agreed to bring back the moon in due time, if they agreed to give him food. The
natives agreed, and were awash with relief when the moon reappeared. Columbus saved himself and
his crew from starvation.
Date of death of Ibrahim (son of our beloved prophet, peace be upon him)
Sun Eclipse also occurred at Prophet's time when (his son) Ibrahim died. It was recorded in history that
it was Jan 27, 632 CE (Monday), details of this eclipse. It was the 29th of Shawwal,
while Dhul-Qi'dah 1, 10AH was on Jan 29, 632 CE (Wednesday). Dhul-Qi'dah was of 29 days also
and Dhul-Hijjah 1, 10AH was on Feb 27, 632 CE (Thursday), such that Hajj-e-Nabavi fell on Friday, March
6, 632 CE. This also proves that sun eclipse cannot be taken as the beginning of a month.
All the solar eclipses that could be noticeable in Arabia during the prophethood of Muhammad (peace
be upon him) are listed below (For details of any eclipse, click on it):
Extreme care must be taken when watching the solar eclipse. You should visit a web site
which discusses a number of ways to Safely View the Eclipse.
At solar eclipse, congregational prayers (2 Rak'aat) should be performed as done by the Prophet
Muhammad (peace be upon him). According to Hadith, the Prophet performed 2 long Rak'aat in
congregation (Qir'at loudly) when solar eclipse occured, and individual prayers are encouraged (at least
2 Rak'aat) when lunar eclipse occurred. If congregational prayers are done at lunar eclipse, then
Qir'at should be done silently.