Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PCR- 2-205
BSc in Criminology
2010/2011
1
Unit Number PCR –2-205
Unit Title Penal Theory, Policy and Practice
Unit Value 1
Courses: Criminology field; BSc in Criminology
Unit Co-ordinator Prof. Roger Matthews
mattherd@lsbu.ac.uk
Extn. 5706.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
2
This unit examines penal theory and practice in a theoretical, comparative and
historical way, and engages critically with the theoretical justifications and policy
proposals for punishment. The first part of this unit examines the philosophical
and historical bases of punishment in general and the prison in particular. The
unit focuses strongly on the growth of the prison population and how the term
‘crisis’ has increasingly come to be associated with the penal system. In
particular the course examines the significance of gender and race in relation to
the use of imprisonment. The course critically evaluates the future promise of the
penal system through an examination of the issues of decarceration and the
privatisation of punishment.
Learning Outcomes
The course curriculum itself considers a broad range of equality and diversity
issues. It encourages students to engage critically with issues of gender, race,
sexuality and mental health. This is further reflected in their assessment tasks.
Students are also encouraged, through seminar sessions to see the potential of
the diversity of experiences within the class for learning on this topic.
3
Recommended Core Textbooks
• Morris, N. & Rothman, D. (1995) The Oxford History of the Prison Oxford
University Press
There is a mass of literature available that examines penal theory, policy and
practice. You will need to be pro-active in searching out these sources, many of
which do not necessarily fall into criminology. Be sure to consult as wide a
4
literature base as possible, including, Criminology, Sociology, Psychology, and
Philosophy. As well as books, ensure that you consult the journals. Below is a
list of journals that you may find useful. Although the Perry Library may not have
all the books and journals you seek you are surrounded by many other sources
of information including; other university libraries, and the internet. Ensure that
you tap into the resources offered by institutions such as the Home Office, the
Centre for Crime & Justice Studies, the Howard League for Penal Reform and
NACRO (National Association for the Care and Resettlement of Offenders). All
of these provide wonderful sources of information, especially in detailing current
issues and many of their publications are free or inexpensive.
Journals include:
5
Assessment
The assessment for this course takes the form of a 3,000 word essay.
Marking Criteria
At all levels, five areas of assessment objective can be recognised:
6
“impose oneself on the subject”
Plagiarism
Plagiarism is the act of taking the words or ideas of others and passing them off
as your own. In many cases plagiarism takes the form of copying from books and
articles without full and accurate acknowledgement of sources. This can happen
unintentionally when you use notes taken from a book/journal article and put
them directly into your essay without properly attributing the source. Whether
intentional or not, plagiarism is not acceptable in any circumstances. It is
regarded as a form of cheating and there are strict University regulations to deal
with it if it is discovered. You will find a summary of the University regulations &
procedures governing plagiarism in your Student Handbook. You must read this
carefully.
(1) Note the FULL reference of the book/article at the top of the first page of
notes.
(2) Keep a precise note of the page numbers of any quoted material (for example
in the margins of your notes)
(3) Use precise double quote marks at the beginning & end of any quotes in your
notes and check that any quotes/material used in your essay in accurately and
carefully attributed.
7
COURSE PROGRAMME
Week One
Week Two
Seminar: Discuss the role of labour discipline, time and space in formation of the
modern prison.
Core reading:
Foucault, M. (1977) Discipline and Punish: the Birth of the Prison, Penguin.
Rusche G and Kirchheimer O. (2003) Punishment and Social Structure.
Transaction.
Rothman D. (1971) The Discovery of the Asylum: Little Brown and Co.
Morris,N & Rothman,D.J (1998) The Oxford History of the Prison, Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
Muncie,J. (2001) ‘Prison Histories: Reform, Repression and Rehabilitation’ in
McLaughlin,E & Muncie,J. Controlling Crime,( 2nd edition) London: Sage & The
Open University..
Cohen,S. (1985) Visions of Social Control: Crime, Punishment and Classification,
Cambridge: Polity Press ( chap 1)
Zedner L (1994) Women, Crime and Custody in Victorian England. Oxford:
Clarendon.
8
Week Three
Seminar
Order and control in prisons is maintained not so much through formal coercion
but through more subtle informal processes. Discuss.
Reading
Week Four
Reading
9
Week Five
Seminar: To what extent has the growth of imprisonment been increased by the
shift towards penal populism?
Reading
Week Six
Seminar: To what extent and in what way should the use of incarceration for
women be significantly different than the way it is used for men?
Core reading:
Carlen, P. (1983) Women’s Imprisonment Routledge
Carlen,P. (1990) Alternatives to Women’s Imprisonment Open University Press.
Carlen, P. (2002) (ed) Women and Punishment. Devon: Willan Publishing
Carlen, P. & Worrall,A. (2004) Analysing Women’s Imprisonment. Devon: Willan
Publishing.
Cavadino,M & Dignan,J. (1992) The Penal System: an Introduction, London:
Sage.
Chigwada,R. (1997) Black Women’s Experiences of Criminal Justice: a
discourse on disadvantage Waterside Press.
Dobash,R. Et al (1985) The Imprisonment of Women, Blackwell.
10
Week Seven
Reading
Week Eight
Seminar
How useful is the concept ‘crisis’ in explaining the current situation of
imprisonment?
Reading
Fitzgerald M. and Sim J. (1979) British Prisons. Oxford.
Cavadino and Dignan J. (2003) The Penal System: An Introduction: Sage.
Sparks R. (1994) ‘Can Prisons be Legitimate?’ in R. King and M. Maguire (eds)
Prisons in Context . Oxford.
Rusche G. and Kirchheimer Punishment and Social Structure.
Bottoms. A. and Preston R. (1980) The Coming Penal Crisis. Scottish Academic
Press.
Player E. and Jenkins M. (1994) Prisons After Woolf. Routledge.
King R. and McDermott K. (1989) ‘British Prisons 1970- 19887: The Ever-
Deepening Crisis’ British Journal of Criminology. Vol. 29 No. 2 :107-128.
McConville S. and Hall-Williams (1987) ‘The English Response to the Penal
Crisis’ in S. Gottfredson and S. McConville (eds) Americas Correctional Crisis.
Greenwood Press.
Week Nine
Seminar: Discuss the claim that introducing new alternatives to custody will
11
inevitably lead to ‘net widening’.
Core Reading
Week Ten
Seminar: To what extent has prison privatisation reduced the cost and increased
the effectiveness of incarceration?
Reading:
Harding R. (1997) Private Prisons and Public Accountability: Open University
Press.
Erikson,R et al (1987) ‘Punishing for Profit: Reflection on the Revival of
Privatisation in Corrections’ Canadian Journal of Criminology 29/4.
Farrell,M. (ed) (1989) Punishment for Profit? London: Institute for the Study and
Treatment of Delinquency.
Feeley,S & Simon,J. (1992) ‘The New Penology: Notes on the Emerging Strategy
of Corrections and its Implications’ Criminology 30/4: 452-74.
James et al (1997) Privatizing Prisons: Rhetoric and Reality. Sage.
Lilly,J. & Knepper,P. (1992) ‘ An International Perspective on the Privatisation of
Corrections’ The Howard Journal 31,3: 174-91.
Logan,C. (1992) Private Prisons: Cons and Pros Oxford University Press.
Matthews,R. (ed) (1989) Privatizing Criminal Justice Sage.
Newman,J & Clarke,J. (1994) ‘The Managerialisation of Public Services’ in
Clarke,J. Cochrane,A & McLaughlin,E. (eds) Managing Social Policy London:
Sage.
12
Ryan,M & Ward,T. (1989) Privatisation and the Penal System Open University
Press.
Schichor D (1999) ‘Privatising Correctional Institutions; An Organisational
Perspective’ Prison Journal . Vol. 79 No.2. 226- 249.
Week Eleven
Reading
Week twelve
SUPPLEMENTARY READING
There is a mass of literature available that examines penal theory, policy and
practice. You will need to be pro-active in searching out these sources, many of
which do not necessarily fall into criminology. Be sure to consult as wide a
literature base as possible, including, Criminology, Sociology, Psychology, and
Philosophy. As well as books, ensure that you consult the journals. Below is a
list of journals that you may find useful. Although the Perry Library may not have
all the books and journals you seek you are surrounded by many other sources
of information including; other university libraries, and the internet. Ensure that
you tap into the resources offered by institutions such as the Home Office, the
13
Centre for Crime & Justice Studies, the Howard League for Penal Reform and
NACRO (National Association for the Care and Resettlement of Offenders). All
of these provide wonderful sources of information, especially in detailing current
issues and many of their publications are free or inexpensive.
Journals include:
Further References
Bottoms,A and Preston,R. (1980) The Coming Penal Crisis Scottish Academic
Press.
Bottoms,A & Preston,R. (1980) The Coming Penal Crisis Scottish Academic
Press.
Bottoms,A. (1987) ‘ Limiting prison use’ Howard Journal of Criminal Justice vol
26/3: 177-202.
Bottoms,A. (1990) ‘ The aims of Imprisonment’ in Garland,D. (ed) Justice, Guilt &
Forgivingness in the Penal System Edinburgh, University of Edinburgh.
14
Brownlee,I. (1998) ‘ New Labour- New Penology? Punitive rhetoric and the limits
of managerialsm in criminal justice policy’ Journal of Law and Society vol 25, no.
3: 313-35.
Caddle,D. (1998) Research Findings, No. 80 Age Limits for Babies in Prison-
some lessons from abroad, Home Office.
Carlen,P & Cook,D. (1989) Paying for Crime Open University Press.
15
Cullen,E. (1994) ‘Grendon: the therapeutic community that works’ Therapeutic
Communities 15/4.
Downes,D. (1982) ‘ The origins and consequences of Dutch penal policy since
1945’ British Journal of Criminology 22/4: 325-50.
Downes,D. (1998) ‘ The buckling of the shields: Dutch penal policy 1985-95’ in
Weiss,R.P. & South,N. (eds) Comparing Prison Systems, Amsterdam, Gordon &
Breach.
Dunbar,I & Langdon,A. (1998) Tough Justice: Sentencing and Penal Policies in
the 1990s London, Blackstone Press.
Farrell,M. (ed) (1989) Punishment for Profit? London: Institute for the Study and
Treatment of Delinquency.
Feeley,S & Simon,J. (1992) ‘The new penology: notes on the merging strategy of
corrections and its implications’ Criminology 30/4: 452-74.
Foucault,M. (1977) Discipline and Punish : The Birth of the Prison ,Penguin
Books.
16
Flanagan,T. (1995) Long Term Imprisonment Sage.
Hay,W & Sparks,R. (1990) Control Problems and the Long-term prisoner HMSO.
Hedderman,C. & Sugg,D. (1996) Does Treating sex offenders reduce offending?’
in Research Findings, no. 45 Home Office.
Home Office (1991) Custody, Care and Justice: The Way Ahead for the Prison
Medical Service in England & Wales, Cm 1647,HMSO.
HM Prison Service (1998) Tackling Drugs in Prison: The Prison Service Drug
Strategy, HMSO.
Howard League (1989) Black People and the Criminal Justice System
17
Hudson,B. (1993) Penal Policy & Social Justice London: Macmillan.
King,R. ‘Maximum security custody in Britain and the USA: a study of Gartree
and Oak Park Heights, British Journal of Criminology, 31.
Lloyd,C. (1990) Suicide and self-injury in prison: a review of the literature, Home
Office research study 115.
Logan,C. (1992) Private Prisons: Cons and Pros Oxford University Press.
18
May,T. (1995) Probation, Politics and Practice, Milton Keynes: Open University
Press.
McLaughlin,E & Muncie,J. (2001) Controlling Crime,( 2nd edition) London: Sage
& The Open University.
Morgan,R & Jones,H. (1991) ‘Prison Discipline: the case for implementing Woolf’
British Journal of Criminology 31/3.
Morgan,R. (1997) ‘Imprisonment: current trends and a brief history since 1945’ in
Maguire,M. Morgan,R & Reiner,R. The Oxford Handbook of Criminology, Oxford:
Clarendon Press.
Morgan,R & Evans,M (1994) ‘Inspecting Prisons: the view from Strasbourg ‘ in
King,R. & Maguire,M. (eds) Prisons in Context: Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Morris,N & Rothman,D.J (1998) The Oxford History of the Prison, Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
Player,E & Jenkins,M (eds) (1993) Prisons After Woolf: Reform through Riot
Routledge.
Policy Review Symposium (1996) - The Learmont Report, Context, Content and
Aftermath Howard Journal 35/4.
Reiman,R. (1984) The Rich Get Rich and Poor Get Prison Wiley Press.
Rose N (2000) ‘Government and Control’ British Journal of Criminology Vol. 40.
Ruggiero,V, Ryan, M & Sim,J. (1995) Western European Penal Systems ,Sage.
19
Ryan,M & Ward,T. (1989) Privatisation and the Penal System Open University
Press.
Scraton,P & Sim,J & Skidmore,P. (1991) Prisons Under Protest OUP.
Walker,J, Collier,P & Tarling,R. (1990) ‘Why are prison rates in England & Wales
higher than in Australia’, British Journal of Criminology, 30/1:24-35.
20
Zedner,L (1998) ‘Wayward Sisters: the prison for women’ in Morris,N &
Rothman,D.J (1998) The Oxford History of the Prison, Oxford: Oxford University
Press
21
Are you interested in penal issues ?
Those of you who are particularly interested in penal issues should consider
joining the:
Volunteering possibilities
The Bourne Trust provides support services for prisoners and their families. At
the present time volunteers are involved in work in the following settings- Visitors
Centres at Wormwood Scrubs and Belmarsh; a play area within the prison visits
area at Wormwood Scrubs; visiting isolated prisoners in Holloway, Wakefiled and
Channings Wood.
Contact the Bourne Trust on 020 7582 1313.
22
The New Bridge is an independent voluntary organisation which recruits
volunteers to write and visit prisoners who have o other contact outside of the
prison.
Contact The New Bridge on 020 7976 0779.
Prison Visitors visit and provide support and friendship to lonely and isolated
prisoners. Although officially appointed, prison visitors are independent of the
Prison Service and visit prisoners on an informal and open basis.
Contact the National Association of Prison Visitors on 01234 359763 or write to
the governor of the prison.
NACRO runs a wide range of community based projects which offer practical
services and resources to individuals caught up in the criminal justice process, to
those at risk of offending and to communities suffering the affects of crime.
NACRO does not recruit volunteers centrally for local services, so either look in
the local telephone directory or call the NACRO publications department for and
address list - -20 7582 6500.
23
24