Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2
Presentation Outline
Definitions
A Licensed Professional’s Dutyy
Examples of Negligence
Examples
p of Incompetence
p
Lessons Learned
3
Definitions
“Negligence”
Failure by a licensee, in the practice of professional
engineering, to use the care ordinarily exercised in
like cases by duly licensed professional engineers in
good standing.
What is a “like case”?
Does an omission demonstrate negligence?
“Omission” - A failure to do something, especially
something that one has a moral or legal obligation to
do.
do
4
Definitions
“Incompetence”
Lack of knowledge or ability in
discharging professional
obligations.
Does an error demonstrate
incompetence?
“Error” – A mistake; the state
or condition of being wrong in
conduct or judgment.
5
Definitions
“Standard of Care”
In performing professional services for a client, a
professional has the duty to have that degree of
learning and skill ordinarily possessed by reputable
professionals, practicing in the same or similar
locality, and under similar circumstances.
6
A Licensed Professional’s Duty
8
A Licensed Professional’s Duty
“The construction
documents shall be
prepared by a registered
design professional where
required by the statutes of
the jurisdiction in which the
project is to be constructed
constructed.”
(2015 International Building
Code, Section 107.1)
9
A Licensed Professional’s Duty
Professional honesty
To one’s self
To the Law
To Clients
To one’s company
To colleagues and peers
To the general public
10
P ll Q
Poll Question
ti
In your opinion
opinion, can
negligence be intentional?
11
Examples of Negligence
12
Examples of Negligence
14
Examples of Negligence
15
Examples of Negligence
16
Examples of Negligence
17
Examples of Negligence
19
Examples of Incompetence
20
Examples of Incompetence
21
Examples of Incompetence
22
Examples of Incompetence
Example 3: Section
15.5.3.3 of ASCE 7 requires
seismic loads to be
distributed vertically on
steel storage racks in a
specific manner in order to
properly address increased
acceleration at upper levels.
The engineer did not follow
these requirements.
23
Examples of Incompetence
24
Lessons Learned
25
Lessons Learned
26
Lessons Learned
Clear communication is
critical
27
Ethics for Structural Engineers
Lessons in Negligence and Incompetence
(P t 1)
(Part
Dave K. Adams,, S.E.
BWE – San Diego, CA
A. Incompetence
B. Negligence
C. Standard of Care
D. Honesty